Mississippi Insurance Guaranty Ass'n v. Gandy

289 So. 2d 677, 1973 Miss. LEXIS 1210
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedDecember 3, 1973
Docket47358
StatusPublished
Cited by34 cases

This text of 289 So. 2d 677 (Mississippi Insurance Guaranty Ass'n v. Gandy) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Mississippi Insurance Guaranty Ass'n v. Gandy, 289 So. 2d 677, 1973 Miss. LEXIS 1210 (Mich. 1973).

Opinion

289 So.2d 677 (1973)

MISSISSIPPI INSURANCE GUARANTY ASSOCIATION
v.
Evelyn Gandy, Commissioner of Insurance.

No. 47358.

Supreme Court of Mississippi.

December 3, 1973.
Rehearing Denied February 25, 1974.

Wells, Gerald, Brand, Watters & Cox, Frank T. Moore, Jr., Eugene A. Simmons, Jackson, for appellant.

A.F. Summer, Atty. Gen. by Maurice R. Black, Asst. Atty. Gen., Jackson, for appellee.

INZER, Justice:

The principal question to be determined in this case is whether the Mississippi Insurance Guaranty Association Act, Chapter 446, Laws of 1970, effective April 6, 1970, now Mississippi Code Annotated, Section 83-23-101 through Section 83-23-135 (1972), applies to claims against an insolvent insurer where such claims existed prior to the effective date of the act and where the insurance company was adjudicated to be insolvent on August 28, 1970, after the effective date of the act. We hold that it does.

*678 On September 10, 1971, Walter Dell Davis, Insurance Commissioner, brought this suit on behalf of certain claimants in the Chancery Court of the First Judicial District of Hinds County against the Mississippi Insurance Guaranty Association seeking to require the association to pay the claims under the provisions of Mississippi Insurance Guaranty Association Act.

The bill of complaint alleged that the Liberty Universal Insurance Company was declared to be insolvent by a Texas court and placed in receivership in that state on August 28, 1970. The bill of complaint also alleged that at the time it became insolvent the claimants on whose behalf the suit was brought were all residents of the State of Mississippi and held valid existing claims against the Liberty Universal Insurance Company, and under the terms of the Mississippi Insurance Guaranty Act, the association was obligated to pay said claims.

It was alleged that Marie M. Moran was a policyholder of the Liberty Universal Insurance Company, and while the policy was in full force and effect, she suffered a loss due to Hurricane Camille on August 17, 1969. Thereafter, the insurance company adjusted the loss and issued its check in the amount of $2,116.15 to cover the said loss, but due to the insolvency of the insurance company, the check was not paid.

On August 17, 1969, claimant Charles T. Pace likewise suffered a loss in the amount of $905.92, covered by a policy issued by said insurance company and that at the time of the loss the policy was in full force and effect. The insurance company issued its check to cover this loss, but due to its insolvency, the check was not paid.

On April 1, 1967, the company issued a policy to T.V. Garroway, and while this policy was in full force and effect, the holder suffered a loss due to Hurricane Camille in the amount of $386.16. The insurance company acknowledged the claim and adjusted the loss but before the loss was paid, the insurance company was determined to be insolvent.

On January 2, 1970, Juanita Camp was injured in an automobile accident with Woodrow Cooper who had a liability policy with Liberty Universal Insurance Company which had been issued on August 1, 1969, and was in full force and effect. After said injury, it was agreed between Juanita Camp and Liberty Universal Insurance Company that the insurance company would pay her $2,000 as damages in settlement of her claim. However, before the claim was paid, the insurance company was determined to be insolvent.

The bill of complaint alleged that all of these claims were "covered claims" under the provisions of the Mississippi Insurance Guaranty Association Act, that Liberty Universal Insurance Company became insolvent and was so adjudicated, and that the association was obligated to pay said claims under the terms of the act.

The association answered the bill of complaint and admitted that the claimants had valid claims against Liberty Universal Insurance Company at the time it became insolvent but denied it was liable for said claims. The association alleged that all the claims arose prior to the effective date of the act, and any payment thereunder would cause the act to operate retroactively where there is no declaration in the act that it so operate. It also alleged that it was not liable for the payment of any claims which arose out of a policy issued by the insolvent insurer after the last day of February 1969, because after that date Liberty Universal Insurance Company was not licensed to transact insurance in the State of Mississippi. The association also alleged that the act relied upon was unconstitutional for several reasons, not necessary to set out here.

The term of office of Walter Dell Davis as Insurance Commissioner expired on January 17, 1972, and Evelyn Gandy succeeded him in that office. Upon proper motion the cause was revived in the name of Evelyn Gandy.

The principal factual issue developed before the trial court concerned the claim of *679 Juanita Camp which arose under a policy issued by Liberty Universal Insurance Company after March 1, 1969. Walter Dell Davis testified that Liberty Universal Insurance Company had been authorized and licensed to do business in the State of Mississippi for many years. When the insurance company applied for the renewal of its license which would expire on March 1, 1969, he held up the renewal for the reason that it was determined that the company held certain securities which did not meet the requirements of Mississippi law. Mr. Davis said he made a trip to Texas where the company was incorporated and learned that the securities were acceptable under Texas law. He then held up the issuance of the license while negotiating with the company to furnish securities which would comply with the Mississippi requirements. After the expiration of its license, the company continued to do business in the State of Mississippi by servicing its policyholders and paying claims. Mr. Davis said he was under the impression that they were not going to write any new business in the state until their license was renewed. He also has testified that he knew that Liberty Universal was continuing to do business in Mississippi and doing so at the time the Mississippi Insurance Guaranty Act became effective. He further stated that he had no proof of insolvency during the period he was negotiating with the company and that no action was taken to stop the company from doing business in this state until it was adjudicated to be insolvent on August 28, 1970.

The chancellor found that the Mississippi Insurance Guaranty Act requires the association to be obligated "to the extent of covered claims existing prior to the determination of insolvency —" and that all the claims here involved were covered claims including the claim of Juanita Camp that arose under a policy issued after March 1, 1969. He found that Liberty Universal Insurance Company was permitted to continue its operation in this state. It was authorized to do business in this state, and such authority was not revoked as required by law. He was of the opinion that the essence of the act is to deal with claims that were unpaid at the time of insolvency, and in order to properly understand or deal with a matter in the present, it is often necessary to take into consideration antecedent facts. It was his opinion that had the legislature intended that only those claims which arose after the effective date of the act would be covered, it would have so provided. A decree was entered finding the association liable for payment of all the claims.

On appeal the association argues two principal propositions.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Marshall Fisher v. Michael Drankus
204 So. 3d 1232 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2016)
Sass Muni-V, LLC v. DeSoto County, Mississippi
170 So. 3d 441 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2015)
Florida Insurance Guaranty Ass'n v. Bernard
140 So. 3d 1023 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 2014)
Brown v. State
102 So. 3d 1087 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2012)
Brown v. State
83 So. 3d 459 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2012)
National Union Fire Ins. v. Miss. Ins. Guar. Ass'n
990 So. 2d 174 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2008)
Miga v. Cole Ex Rel. Dillon
954 So. 2d 407 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2007)
Corning v. Mississippi Ins. Guar. Ass'n
947 So. 2d 944 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2007)
Miss. Ins. Guar. v. Goldin Properties
893 So. 2d 1062 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2004)
SMITH EX REL. SELMON v. Braden
765 So. 2d 546 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2000)
Bank of Miss. v. MISS. LIFE & HEALTH INS.
730 So. 2d 49 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1998)
Sharon Selmon Smith v. David Steven Braden
Mississippi Supreme Court, 1997
Regan v. Citizens Bank
675 So. 2d 1239 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1996)
Marshall v. State
662 So. 2d 566 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1995)
Mississippi State Tax Commission ex rel. Marx v. Veazey
624 So. 2d 997 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1993)
Mississippi Ins. Guar. Ass'n v. Byars
614 So. 2d 959 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1993)
Bobby Regan v. Citizens Bk
Mississippi Supreme Court, 1993

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
289 So. 2d 677, 1973 Miss. LEXIS 1210, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/mississippi-insurance-guaranty-assn-v-gandy-miss-1973.