Missionary Sisters of the Most Sacred Heart of Jesus Inc. v. Berks County Board of Assessment Appeals

74 Pa. D. & C.4th 424, 2005 Pa. Dist. & Cnty. Dec. LEXIS 119
CourtPennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Berks County
DecidedJune 6, 2005
Docketno. 04-13889
StatusPublished

This text of 74 Pa. D. & C.4th 424 (Missionary Sisters of the Most Sacred Heart of Jesus Inc. v. Berks County Board of Assessment Appeals) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Berks County primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Missionary Sisters of the Most Sacred Heart of Jesus Inc. v. Berks County Board of Assessment Appeals, 74 Pa. D. & C.4th 424, 2005 Pa. Dist. & Cnty. Dec. LEXIS 119 (Pa. Super. Ct. 2005).

Opinion

LASH, J,

The appellant, Missionary Sisters of the Most Sacred Heart of Jesus ínc., has appealed the decision of the Berks County Board of Assessment Appeals granting a partial exemption to real estate owned by Missionary Sisters. The board had assessed the property at $6,186,200, with the taxable portion of the assessment being $1,870,000. Anon-jury trial was held on May 10, 2005. The sole issue raised on appeal is whether the premises is fully exempt from local taxation as an institution of purely public charity.

This court makes the following findings of fact:

I. FINDINGS OF FACT

(1) The appellant, Missionary Sisters of the Most Sacred Heart of Jesus Inc., is a Pennsylvania nonprofit corporation with its principal place of business located at 2811 Moyer Lane, Reading, Berks County, Pennsylvania 19605.
(2) The appellee, Berks County Board of Assessment Appeals, is located at the Berks County Services Center, [426]*426Third Floor, 633 Court Street, Reading, Berks County, Pennsylvania 19601.
(3) The property that is subject to this appeal is located at 51 Seminary Avenue, Muhlenberg Township, Muhlenberg School District, Berks County, Pennsylvania, and consists of approximately 41.93 acres of land, together with a convent building and cemetery site for the sisters.
(4) The Missionary Sisters have always provided for the care of their sick and elderly members by maintaining its own nursing facilities located in the convent building.
(5) The cost of this care is borne by Missionary Sisters, however, sisters receiving Social Security or SSI benefits transfer these benefits to Missionary Sisters to help defray the costs of their care.
(6) Sisters residing in a personal care service facility receive increased Social Security benefits.
(7) In an effort to better care for their elderly and sick members, the Missionary Sisters opened the convent as a licensed personal care service facility, thereby maintaining their ability to care for those sisters in need of assisted and skilled care and entitling those sisters to additional SSI benefits.
(8) The Missionary Sisters created the Sacred Heart Villa, a Pennsylvania nonprofit corporation, which is controlled by the Provincial Superior and the Provincial Councilors of the order, to operate the licensed personal care services facility.
[427]*427(9) The Sacred Heart Villa has been designated as a section 501(c)(3) organization by the Internal Revenue Service.
(10) On or about May 21, 2004, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Department of Public Welfare, issued a personal care services license to Sacred Heart Villa.
(11) The Sacred Heart Villa is certified by DPW to operate personal care services for up to 100 persons.
(12) On or about May 27,2004, the missionary sisters entered into a lease agreement with Sacred Heart Villa for the convent building to operate the personal care services facility (subject property).
(13) The number of sisters requiring personal care services has consistently been substantially less than 100 persons. Currently, 57 sisters reside in the convent and utilize the personal care services.
(14) To fill the remaining available beds, and to help defray the costs, Sacred Heart Villa has accepted qualified members of the public as residents.
(15) Sacred Heart Villa has designated 40 beds for the public, located in the front portion of the convent.
(16) A public applicant qualifies to become a resident if the applicant establishes ownership of sufficient assets to pay the cost for his care from the inception of the residency through his estimated life expectancy.
(17) While ownership of sufficient assets must be established to qualify the applicant, the assets are not immediately transferred to Sacred Heart Villa, but remain in the applicant’s possession, who is responsible for pay[428]*428ing the monthly residency fee from the assets, or from Social Security or pension benefits received.
(18) Sacred Heart Villa does not require that the assets be escrowed, that a lien be placed upon the assets, or that the resident be otherwise legally bound to transfer the assets to Sacred Heart Villa.
(19) If the resident’s assets are used up and the applicant is unable to continue to pay the costs of the personal care, the resident nevertheless may continue to reside at the convent for the duration of his life, without paying any additional costs.
(20) Sacred Heart Villa leases the space from the Missionary Sisters for an annual rental of $173,166.12.
(21) The Missionary Sisters pay to Sacred Heart Villa resident fees for the care of their elderly members.
(22) In 2004, the Missionary Sisters paid approximately $734,183.81 to Sacred Heart Villa in resident fees for those sisters requiring assisted care.
(23) In 2004, the Missionary Sisters paid approximately $189,600 to Sacred Heart Villa in resident fees for those sisters requiring skilled care.
(24) In 2004, Sacred Heart Villa received approximately $87,585 in resident fees from qualified members of the public for non-skilled living care and $12,000 for skilled living care.
(25) In 2004, Sacred Heart Villa had revenues in an approximate amount of $1,070,624.05.
(26) In 2004, Sacred Heart Villa had expenses in an approximate amount of $1,715,994.14.
[429]*429(27) In 2004, the Missionary Sisters subsidized the Sacred Heart Villa in an approximate amount of $862,255.60 in order to maintain its operation.
(28) The Assessment Office changed the assessment from a total exemption of $5,737,800 to a partial exemption of $4,316,200 and taxable $1,870,000, for a total assessment of $6,186,200.
(29) On or about July 14, 2004, the Missionary Sisters filed an appeal on the amount of the assessment and on the issue of exemption.
(30) On or about August 16, 2004, the board upheld the determination of the Assessment Office and sent a final notice of the determination on September 2,2004.
(31) On or about September 24,2004, the Missionary Sisters appealed the board’s determination to the Court of Common Pleas of Berks County.
(32) By order dated February 16,2005, this honorable court bifurcated the proceedings and this issue of exemption is now before the court.

II. DISCUSSION

The authority permitting certain real estate to be declared exempt as a purely public charity appears in Article VIII, Section 2(a) of the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, which provides in part: “The General Assembly may by law exempt from taxation: ... (v)(d) Institutions of purely public charity ....”

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

City of Washington v. Board of Assessment Appeals
704 A.2d 120 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1997)
St. Margaret Seneca Place v. Board of Property Assessment
640 A.2d 380 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1994)
Borough of Homestead v. St. Mary Magdalen Church
798 A.2d 823 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2002)
Grace Center Community Living Corp. v. County of Indiana
796 A.2d 1008 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2002)
Hahn Home v. York County Board of Assessment Appeals
778 A.2d 755 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2001)
Lutheran Home at Topton v. Schuylkill County Board of Assessment Appeals
782 A.2d 1 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2001)
Presbyterian Homes Tax Exemption Case
236 A.2d 776 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1968)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
74 Pa. D. & C.4th 424, 2005 Pa. Dist. & Cnty. Dec. LEXIS 119, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/missionary-sisters-of-the-most-sacred-heart-of-jesus-inc-v-berks-county-pactcomplberks-2005.