Meyers v. Wal-Mart Stores

Opinion

5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21 3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH 

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU )LOH 1DPH DS

81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6 )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

:,//,$0 s 0(<(56 ; 3ODLQWLII$SSHOOHH  &URVV$SSHOODQW   1RV  Y !   :$/0$57 6725(6 ($67  ,1&GED:DO0DUW  'HIHQGDQW$SSHOODQW  &URVV$SSHOOHH   1 $SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW IRUWKH(DVWHUQ'LVWULFWRI0LFKLJDQDW)OLQW 1Rn3DXO9*DGROD'LVWULFWsXGJH $UJXHGsXQH 'HFLGHGDQG)LOHGsXO\ %HIRUH*8<%2**6DQG*,/0$1&LUFXLWsXGJHV BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB &2816(/ $5*8('  sHIIUH\ 6 6XWWRQ s21(6 '$< 5($9,6 32*8(&ROXPEXV2KLRIRU$SSHOODQW/LQGD0*DODQWH 0$=85 025*$1 0(<(56  .,77(/ 'HWURLW 0LFKLJDQ IRU $SSHOOHH  21 %5,()  sHIIUH\ 6 6XWWRQ

  0H\HUVY:DO0DUW6WRUHV 1RV

s21(6'$<5($9,6 32*8(&ROXPEXV2KLR5RQDOG ( :HVWHQ 5REHUW 3DWULFN *HRUJH /832  .2&=.85 'HWURLW 0LFKLJDQ 0HODQLH 3 6DUZDO :$/0$57 6725(6,1&%HQWRQYLOOH$UNDQVDVIRU$SSHOODQW/LQGD 0 *DODQWH sHIIUH\ 7 0H\HUV 0$=85 025*$1 0(<(56 .,77(/'HWURLW0LFKLJDQIRU$SSHOOHH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 23,1,21 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 521$/' /(( *,/0$1 &LUFXLW sXGJH  :LOOLDP s 0H\HUV D \HDUROG FODLPDQW VOLSSHG DQG IHOO RQ ORRVH FDUGERDUGLQWKHHPSW\ER[DUHDDWD6DPjV&OXEVWRUH7KH IDOOIUDFWXUHGKLVKLSFDXVLQJKLPWRXQGHUJRKLSUHSODFHPHQW VXUJHU\0H\HUVjVUHKDELOLWDWLRQSURFHVVJUHDWO\DJJUDYDWHG KLVSUHH[LVWLQJDUWKULWLFFRQGLWLRQ $IWHU D QLQHGD\ MXU\ WULDO GXULQJ ZKLFK WKUHH RI WKH RULJLQDOVHYHQMXURUVZHUHGLVPLVVHGE\WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWZLWK WKH FRQVHQW RI ERWK SDUWLHV WKLV QHJOLJHQFH DFWLRQ ZDV VXEPLWWHG WR WKH UHPDLQLQJ IRXU MXURUV  7KH MXU\ UHWXUQHG ZLWK D YHUGLFW LQ IDYRU RI 0H\HUV LQ WKH DPRXQW RI ZLWKDILQGLQJRIFRPSDUDWLYHQHJOLJHQFHRQ KLVSDUW7KLVUHGXFHGKLVGDPDJHVWRZKLFKWKH GLVWULFWFRXUWIXUWKHUUHGXFHGE\LQUHVSRQVHWRWKH GHIHQGDQWjVPRWLRQIRUDUHPLWWLWXUOHDYLQJDQHWYHUGLFWRI  :DO0DUW DV WKH RZQHU RI WKH 6DPjV &OXE VWRUH QRZ DSSHDOVRQYDULRXVJURXQGVDUJXLQJWKDWWKHGLVWULFWFRXUW HUUHGLQSHUPLWWLQJ0H\HUVjVmDJJUDYDWLRQlFODLPWRJRWRWKH MXU\WKHUHZDVLQVXIILFLHQWHYLGHQFHWRVXSSRUWWKHMXU\jV YHUGLFWWKHIRXUSHUVRQMXU\ZDVXQFRQVWLWXWLRQDODQG WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWVKRXOGKDYHUHPLWWHGWKHYHUGLFWE\PRUH WKDQ   0H\HUV FURVVDSSHDOHG FKDOOHQJLQJ WKH  UHPLWWLWXU  )RU WKH UHDVRQV VHW IRUWK EHORZ ZH $)),50WKHMXGJPHQWRIWKHGLVWULFWFRXUW 1RV 0H\HUVY:DO0DUW6WRUHV 

,%$&.*5281' $ )DFWXDOEDFNJURXQG 2QsXO\0H\HUVDQGKLVZLIHZHQWVKRSSLQJDWWKH 6DPjV&OXEVWRUHLQ6RXWKJDWH0LFKLJDQ:KLOHKLVZLIHZDV ZDLWLQJ LQ WKH FKHFNRXW OLQH 0H\HUV ZDONHG RYHU WR WKH HPSW\ER[DUHDWRILQGDER[LQZKLFKWRSODFHWKHFRXSOHj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jV QHJOLJHQFH:DO0DUW UHPRYHGWKHDFWLRQWRIHGHUDOFRXUW EDVHGXSRQGLYHUVLW\RIFLWL]HQVKLSXQGHU86&† $WWULDO:DO0DUWVWLSXODWHGWKDW0H\HUVVOLSSHGRUWULSSHG RQFDUGERDUGO\LQJRQWKHIORRULQWKHER[DUHD6HYHUDO:DO 0DUW HPSOR\HHV WHVWLILHG WKDW DW WKH WLPH RI WKH DFFLGHQW WKHUHZHUHER[HVOHIWDOORYHUWKHER[DUHDEHFDXVHWKHUHZDV QRRWKHUSODFHWRSXWWKHPWKDWWKHUHZDVORRVHFDUGERDUG XQGHUWKHER[HVDQGWKDWFOHDQXSZDVGRQHRQO\RQDmFDWFK DVFDWFKFDQlEDVLV7ZRRIWKHHPSOR\HHVHYHQDGPLWWHGWKDW WKHFRQGLWLRQRIWKHER[DUHDZDVGDQJHURXV 7KH XQFRQWUDGLFWHG HYLGHQFH HVWDEOLVKHG WKDW 0H\HUV IUDFWXUHG KLV KLS DV D UHVXOW RI WKH IDOO  +LSUHSODFHPHQW VXUJHU\ZDVUHTXLUHGLQRUGHUWRUHVWRUHKLVDELOLW\WRZDON DQG KH VXIIHUHG D GHJUHH IHYHU IRU IRXU GD\V DIWHU WKH RSHUDWLRQ  $V D UHVXOW RI WKH KLJK WHPSHUDWXUH KLV GRFWRU GLVFRQWLQXHGDOOSDLQPHGLFDWLRQFDXVLQJ0H\HUVWREHmLQ DJRQ\lGXULQJWKLVWLPH0H\HUVFRQWLQXHGWRIHHOSDLQDIWHU KHEHJDQRXWSDWLHQWSK\VLFDOWKHUDS\7KLVWKHUDS\LQYROYHG VWDQGLQJDQGZDONLQJH[HUFLVHVLQFOXGLQJWKHXVHRIFUXWFKHV  0H\HUVY:DO0DUW6WRUHV 1RV 1RV 0H\HUVY:DO0DUW6WRUHV 

DQG ZDONHUV  0H\HUV WHVWLILHG WKDW WKH H[HUFLVHV DQG ( 7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVIDLOXUHWRRIIHU0H\HUVWKHRSWLRQ VXSSRUWLYH GHYLFHV FDXVHG KLP WR IHHO SDLQ LQ KLV KDQGV RIDFFHSWLQJWKHUHPLWWLWXURUUHFHLYLQJDQHZWULDO VKRXOGHUVKLSVZULVWVHOERZVDQGRWKHUMRLQWV7KHSDLQ PDGHLWKDUGIRUKLPWRVOHHSDWQLJKW 3ULRUWRRUDODUJXPHQWRQDSSHDOZHDVNHGERWKSDUWLHVWR VXEPLW D EULHI VWDWLQJ WKHLU SRVLWLRQ UHJDUGLQJ WKH GLVWULFW $OWKRXJKVRPHRIWKHVHV\PSWRPVHYHQWXDOO\DEDWHGRWKHUV FRXUWjV IDLOXUH WR SURYLGH 0H\HUV ZLWK WKH RSWLRQ RI HLWKHU VWLOOUHPDLQ0H\HUVWHVWLILHGWKDWWKHKLSUHSODFHPHQWVXUJHU\ VXEPLWWLQJWRDQHZWULDORUDFFHSWLQJWKHDPRXQWRIGDPDJHV SHUPDQHQWO\ DIIHFWHG KLV JDLW DQG KLV HYHU\GD\ OLYLQJ WKDW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW FRQVLGHUHG MXVWLILHG  6HH )DUEHU Y DFWLYLWLHV+HKDVEHHQXQDEOHIRUH[DPSOHWRVWDQGIRUPRUH 0DVVLOORQ%GRI(GXF)GWK&LU WKDQWRPLQXWHVDWDWLPHRUWRZDONPRUHWKDQDPLOH m>$@IRUFHGUHPLWWLWXUZLWKRXWWKHRIIHURIWKHRSWLRQRID DQGDKDOIZLWKRXWIHHOLQJSDLQLQKLVKLSQRUFDQKHULGHKLV QHZWULDORQWKHLVVXHRIGDPDJHVFRQVWLWXWHVHUURUUHTXLULQJ ELF\FOHDVIDUDVKHZDVRQFHDEOHWRGR WKLVFRXUWWRUHYHUVH DQG UHLQVWDWHWKHYHUGLFWl%UHZHUY 8QLUR\DO ,QF  )G   WK &LU  m>7@KH 3ULRUWRWKHDFFLGHQW0H\HUVKDGVXIIHUHGIURPUKHXPDWRLG 'LVWULFW &RXUW PXVW RIIHU WKH SDUW\ DZDUGHG GDPDJHV WKH DUWKULWLVIRUPDQ\\HDUVEXWKDGQRWQHHGHGVWHURLGWUHDWPHQW FKRLFH RI D QHZ WULDO RU WKH DPRXQW RI WKH &RXUWjV VLQFH+LVWUHDWLQJSK\VLFLDQ'U5D\PRQG:HLW]PDQ UHPLWWLWXUl0H\HUVUHVSRQGHGE\VWDWLQJWKDWLIJLYHQWKH WHVWLILHGWKDW0H\HUV FKRLFHKHZRXOGDFFHSWWKHUHPLWWLWXU ZHQWIRUDORQJSHULRGZLWKRXW>VWHURLGV@EHIRUHKHIHOO :HDOVRDVNHG0H\HUVjVFRXQVHODWWKHRUDODUJXPHQWLWVHOI DQG IUDFWXUHG KLV KLS      +H ZDV QRW UHDOO\ JRLQJ ZKHWKHU0H\HUVZDVZLOOLQJWRIRUHJRKLVULJKWWRDQHZWULDO WKURXJKIODUHXSVIRUWKHIHZ\HDUVSULRUWRWKHIUDFWXUHRI E\ DFFHSWLQJ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV UHPLWWLWXU  &RXQVHO DJDLQ KLVKLS,WDSHUHGWKH3UHGQLVRQHVRWKDWEHWZHHQ FRQILUPHGWKDWWKLVZDVKHUFOLHQWjVFKRLFH$FFRUGLQJO\ZH DQG6HSWHPEHURIKHZDVRIIDOOVWHURLGV UHJDUG WKLV HUURU RQ WKH SDUW RI WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW DV KDYLQJ +LVGLVHDVHRQWKHJROG>DW\SHRIPHGLFDOWUHDWPHQWIRU EHHQZDLYHG6HH7KRUQHY:HON,QY,QF)G UKHXPDWRLG DUWKULWLV LQYROYLQJ JROG VDOWV@ DFWXDOO\ GLG  WK &LU  WUHDWLQJ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV HUURU LQ ZHOODQGKHVHHPHGWRVWDELOL]H IDLOLQJWRRIIHUWKHSODLQWLIIDQHZWULDOUHPLWWLWXUHOHFWLRQDV ZDLYHG ZKHQ WKH m>S@ODLQWLII KDV UHSUHVHQWHG WKURXJK KHU 'U:HLW]PDQDOVRFRQILUPHGWKDW0H\HUVjVDUWKULWLVIODUHG DWWRUQH\VWKDWVKHZLOOZDLYHKHUULJKWWRDQHZWULDOLIJLYHQ XSDIWHUKLVIDOOQRWLQJWKDW0H\HUVjVmGLVHDVHSURFHVVVHHPHG WKHFKRLFHl0H\HUVjVFURVVDSSHDOFKDOOHQJLQJWKH WRFKDQJHDIWHUWKHIUDFWXUHKHEHFDPHIODUHGXSLQDOORIKLV UHPLWWLWXULVWKHUHIRUHGLVPLVVHGDVPRRW MRLQWVQRWMXVWWDONLQJDERXWWKHKLSl+HDOVRSRLQWHGRXW WKDW WKHVH V\PSWRPV DSSHDUHG WR EH WHPSRUDOO\ UHODWHG WR ,,,&21&/86,21 0H\HUVjVKLSLQMXU\m,QRWKHUZRUGVLWVHHPHGSUHWW\FOHDU FXWWKDWWKHDUWKULWLVIODUHGIROORZLQJWKHIUDFWXUHl0RUHRYHU )RU DOO WKH UHDVRQV VHW IRUWK DERYH ZH $)),50 WKH 'U:HLW]PDQWHVWLILHGWKDWWKHJROGVDOWVWUHDWPHQWKHKDG MXGJPHQWRIWKHGLVWULFWFRXUW EHHQ XVLQJ IRU 0H\HUVjV DUWKULWLF FRQGLWLRQ ORVW LWV HIIHFWLYHQHVVDIWHUWKHDFFLGHQWHYHQDIWHUKHLQFUHDVHGWKH GRVDJHDQGIUHTXHQF\RIWKHVKRWV7KLVUHTXLUHGDUHWXUQWR LQMHFWLQJ 0H\HUV ZLWK VWHURLGV VXFK DV 3UHGQLVRQH DQG &RUWLVRQH  0H\HUVY:DO0DUW6WRUHV 1RV 1RV 0H\HUVY:DO0DUW6WRUHV 

&I+XQGOH\Y0LOQHU+RWHO0JPW&R)6XSS $IWHUDQLQHGD\WULDOWKHMXU\UHWXUQHGZLWKDXQDQLPRXV :'.\KROGLQJWKDWWKHGHIHQGDQWFRXOGQRW YHUGLFWLQIDYRURI0H\HUVLQWKHDPRXQWRIZLWK FRPSODLQ LQ LWV PRWLRQ IRU MXGJPHQW QRWZLWKVWDQGLQJ WKH DILQGLQJRIFRPSDUDWLYHQHJOLJHQFHRQKLVSDUW%HFDXVH YHUGLFW RU LQ WKH DOWHUQDWLYH IRU QHZ WULDO WKDW WKH RIWKHFRPSDUDWLYHQHJOLJHQFHDOORFDWLRQ0H\HUVjVGDPDJHV LQWURGXFWLRQRIFHUWDLQORYHOHWWHUVDVHYLGHQFHFDXVHGWKHMXU\ ZHUHUHGXFHGWR7KHILQDOMXU\ZDVFRPSRVHGRI WRUHQGHULWVGHFLVLRQEDVHGRQSDVVLRQDQGSUHMXGLFHZKHQWKH RQO\IRXUPHPEHUVEHFDXVHWKUHHRIWKHRULJLQDOVHYHQMXURUV GHIHQGDQW GHOLEHUDWHO\ LQWURGXFHG WKH ORYH OHWWHUV LQWR KDG EHHQ H[FXVHG E\ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW ZLWK WKH ZULWWHQ HYLGHQFHLQWKHILUVWSODFH FRQVHQWRIERWKSDUWLHV 6XSSRUWIRUWKHFRPSDUDWLYHQHJOLJHQFHILQGLQJ :DO0DUW ILOHG VHYHUDO SRVWWULDO PRWLRQV  7KH GLVWULFW FRXUWUHMHFWHG:DO0DUWjVPRWLRQIRUMXGJPHQWDVDPDWWHURI )LQDOO\ :DO0DUW DUJXHV WKDW 0H\HUVjV DZDUG ZDV ODZ UHJDUGLQJ 0H\HUVjV FODLP IRU DJJUDYDWLRQ RI KLV H[FHVVLYH EHFDXVH WKH HYLGHQFH GLG QRW VXSSRUW WKH MXU\jV SUHH[LVWLQJDUWKULWLFFRQGLWLRQDVZHOODVLWVPRWLRQIRUDQHZ ILQGLQJ WKDW 0H\HUV ZDV RQO\  DW IDXOW IRU KLV LQMXULHV WULDOEDVHGRQFKDOOHQJHVWRWKHVXIILFLHQF\RIWKHHYLGHQFHLQ ,QVWHDGDUJXHV:DO0DUWmDEXQGDQW HYLGHQFHVXSSRUWHGD VXSSRUW RI WKH DZDUG DQG WKH FRQVWLWXWLRQDOLW\ RI WKH IRXU PXFKKLJKHUQHJOLJHQFHUXOLQJlIRU0H\HUVDQGWKHUHIRUHD SHUVRQMXU\6HH0H\HUVY:DO0DUW6WRUHV(DVW,QF) PXFKORZHUQHJOLJHQFHUXOLQJIRU:DO0DUW:HZLOOQRWVHW 6XSSG('0LFK+RZHYHU DVLGHWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVGHWHUPLQDWLRQWKDW:DO0DUWjVIDXOW WKH FRXUW JUDQWHG :DO0DUWjV PRWLRQ WR UHPLW WKH YHUGLFW DSSRUWLRQPHQW ZDV QRW H[FHVVLYH KRZHYHU DEVHQW D FOHDU EDVHGXSRQDUDQJHRIDOOHJHGO\FRPSDUDEOHFDVHV6HHLGDW DEXVHRIGLVFUHWLRQ6HH3DGJHWWY65\&R)G $FFRUGLQJO\WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWUHPLWWHGWKHYHUGLFWE\ WK&LUVHHDOVR7XOORVY5HVRXUFH'ULOOLQJ,QF WRUHDFKDQDPRXQWDSSUR[LPDWLQJWKDWDZDUGHGLQ  )G   WK &LU  VSHFLILFDOO\ DSSO\LQJ D 6OH]DNY0DULQH0LGODQG%DQNs951R:/ FOHDUO\ HUURQHRXV VWDQGDUG RI UHYLHZ WR WKH MXU\jV DW 1<$SS'LYDZDUGLQJ DSSRUWLRQPHQWRIIDXOW WR D SODLQWLII ZKR UHTXLUHG D KLS UHSODFHPHQW ZKHQ VKH VOLSSHG DQG IHOO DW WKH GHIHQGDQWjV EDQN  7KLV UHPLWWLWXU ,QWKHSUHVHQWFDVHWKHUHZDVVXIILFLHQWHYLGHQFHWRVXSSRUW ZKLFKUHVXOWHGLQDQHWDZDUGWR0H\HUVRIZDV WKH MXU\jV ILQGLQJ WKDW :DO0DUW ZDV  DW IDXOW IRU PDGHZLWKRXWRIIHULQJKLPWKHFKRLFHRIHLWKHUDFFHSWLQJWKH 0H\HUVjV LQMXULHV  6HH WKH GLVFXVVLRQ LQ 3DUW ,,% DERYH UHPLWWLWXURUSURFHHGLQJWRDQHZWULDO UHJDUGLQJ WKH HYLGHQFH VXSSRUWLQJ WKH MXU\jV YHUGLFW HVSHFLDOO\ WKH SURRI DFNQRZOHGJLQJ WKH ODFN RI UHJXODU 7KLVWLPHO\DSSHDODQGFURVVDSSHDOIROORZHG PDLQWHQDQFHLQWKHER[DUHDGHVSLWH:DO0DUWjVDZDUHQHVVRI WKH FDUGERDUG FOXWWHU DQG WKH DGPLVVLRQ E\ WZR RI LWV ,,$1$/<6,6 HPSOR\HHVWKDWWKHDUHDZDVDKD]DUGWRFXVWRPHUV*LYHQDOO RIWKLVWHVWLPRQ\ZHFDQQRWVD\WKDWWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWDEXVHG $ $JJUDYDWLRQ RI 0H\HUVjV SUHH[LVWLQJ FRQGLWLRQ RI LWVGLVFUHWLRQLQXSKROGLQJWKHMXU\jVDSSRUWLRQPHQWRIIDXOW UKHXPDWRLGDUWKULWLV 7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVGHFLVLRQQRWWRUHPLWWKHMXU\jVYHUGLFWE\ DQDGGLWLRQDODPRXQWWRDFFRXQWIRUDJUHDWHUGHJUHHRIIDXOW $ PRWLRQ IRU MXGJPHQW DV D PDWWHU RI ODZ mPD\ QRW EH RQWKHSDUWRI0H\HUVDFFRUGLQJO\LVDIILUPHG JUDQWHG XQOHVV UHDVRQDEOH PLQGV FRXOG QRW GLIIHU DV WR WKH FRQFOXVLRQVWREHGUDZQIURPWKHHYLGHQFHl0FsXQNLQ&RUS Y 0HFKV ,QF  )G   WK &LU   $Q DSSHDOV FRXUW LV QRW WR mZHLJK WKH HYLGHQFH SDVV RQ WKH  0H\HUVY:DO0DUW6WRUHV 1RV 1RV 0H\HUVY:DO0DUW6WRUHV 

FUHGLELOLW\RIZLWQHVVHVRUVXEVWLWXWHLWVMXGJPHQWIRUWKDWRI )GG&LU*LYHQWKHKLJKO\GHIHUHQWLDO WKHMXU\l7RWKY

7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWKRZHYHUGLVWLQJXLVKHG5XIIRQWKHEDVLV 0H\HUVGLGQRWUHO\VROHO\XSRQHLWKHUWKHWHVWLPRQ\RIKLV WKDWmWKHUHLVQRLQGLFDWLRQLQSODLQWLIIjVEULHIDVWRWKHVHYHULW\ WUHDWLQJSK\VLFLDQRUXSRQKLVRZQOD\WHVWLPRQ\WRHVWDEOLVK RI WKH LQMXULHV VXIIHUHG E\ WKH SODLQWLII LQ 5XIIl  0H\HUV WKH DJJUDYDWLRQ RI KLV SUHH[LVWLQJ FRQGLWLRQ  ,QVWHDG KH  ) 6XSS G DW   ,W WKHQ GLVWLQJXLVKHG3HUNV RQ WKH SURIIHUHG WKH FRPELQHG WHVWLPRQ\ RI ERWK WR VXSSRUW KLV EDVLVWKDW3HUNVmFRQFHUQHGDWUDIILFDFFLGHQWDQGQRWDVLPSOH FODLP)LUVW'U:HLW]PDQRSLQHGDVDPHGLFDOH[SHUWWKDW VOLSDQGIDOOlDQGLQYROYHGmFRQVLGHUDEO\PRUHLPSDFWLQMXULHV 0H\HUVKDGDSUHH[LVWLQJDUWKULWLFFRQGLWLRQ+HDOVRWHVWLILHG WKDQWKHKLSLQMXU\VXVWDLQHGE\SODLQWLII0H\HUVl,G WKDWDIWHUWKHLQMXU\0H\HUVjVUKHXPDWRLGDUWKULWLVLQFUHDVHG LQVHYHULW\0RUHRYHU'U:HLW]PDQQRWHGWKDWWKHHQWLUH $IWHUGLVWLQJXLVKLQJ5XIIDQG3HUNVWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWFKRVH GLVHDVHSURFHVVVHHPHGWRFKDQJHDIWHU0H\HUVVXIIHUHGKLV WKH1HZ

7KHNH\LVVXHLQ+DVOHUKRZHYHUZDVZKHWKHUWHPSRUDO DSSUDLVDOVl3DGJHWWY65\&R)GWK&LU HYLGHQFHDORQHZDVVXIILFLHQWWRHVWDEOLVKWKDWWKHVZLQHIOX FLWDWLRQVRPLWWHG YDFFLQDWLRQFDXVHGWKHRQVHWRIWKHSODLQWLIIjVQHZGLVHDVH QRWZKHWKHUWKHYDFFLQDWLRQH[DFHUEDWHGDNQRZQSUHH[LVWLQJ &DVHVVXSSRUWLQJWKHVL]HRIWKHMXU\DZDUG FRQGLWLRQ8QOLNHLQ+DVOHUWKHUHLVQRTXHVWLRQWKDW0H\HUV ZDVLQMXUHGDQGUHTXLUHGPHGLFDOWUHDWPHQWDVDUHVXOWRIWKH %RWK:DO0DUWDQG0H\HUVKDYHFKDOOHQJHGRQDSSHDOWKH LQFLGHQWLQTXHVWLRQ7KHUHZDVDOVRQRTXHVWLRQWKDW0H\HUV GLVWULFW FRXUWjV UHPLWWLWXU RI WKH MXU\ DZDUG DUJXLQJ KDGDSUHH[LVWLQJPHGLFDOFRQGLWLRQ0RUHRYHUWKHPHGLFDO UHVSHFWLYHO\WKDWWKHUHPLWWLWXUVKRXOGKDYHEHHQKLJKHURU WHVWLPRQ\HVWDEOLVKHGWKDWWKLVVSHFLILFSUHH[LVWLQJFRQGLWLRQ WKDWWKHDZDUGVKRXOGQRWKDYHEHHQUHPLWWHGDWDOO:DO0DUW LQWXUQFRXOGFDXVHKLPWRH[SHULHQFHVHYHUHFROODWHUDOHIIHFWV DUJXHV WKDW WKH UHPLWWLWXU ZDV RXW RI OLQH ZLWK WKH GDPDJH IURPDKLSLQMXU\ZLWK'U:HL]PDQSRLQWLQJRXWKRZWKH DZDUGVJLYHQLQFRPSDUDEOH0LFKLJDQFDVHVZKLOH0H\HUV HQWLUHSURFHVVRI0H\HUVjVDUWKULWLFGLVHDVHVHHPHGWRFKDQJH KDV SUHVHQWHG DOOHJHGO\ FRPSDUDEOH FDVHV LQ ZKLFK WKH DIWHUWKHLQMXU\6SHFLILFDOO\'U:HLW]PDQWHVWLILHGWKDWWKH SODLQWLIIVUHFHLYHGHYHQJUHDWHUDZDUGV mLQFUHDVHG DFWLYLW\ FDQ FDXVHl D IODUHXS RI 0H\HUVjV SUHH[LVWLQJUKHXPDWRLGDUWKULWLV ,QGHFLGLQJWRJUDQWDUHPLWWLWXURIWKHGLVWULFW FRXUW H[DPLQHG D ZLGH UDQJH RI FDVHV ERWK IURP ZLWKLQ 7KHUHZDVWKXV D mORJLFDOVHTXHQFHRIFDXVHDQGHIIHFWl 0LFKLJDQDQGIURPRXWVLGHWKHVWDWH6HH0H\HUVY:DO0DUW EHWZHHQWKHDFFLGHQWDQGWKHDJJUDYDWLRQRI0H\HUVjVDUWKULWLF 6WRUHV(DVW,QF)6XSSG('0LFK FRQGLWLRQ6HH.DPLQVNLY*UDQG7UXQN:551:G 7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWILUVWHYDOXDWHGWKHDSSOLFDELOLW\RI   0LFK  KROGLQJ WKDW HYLGHQFH DERXW WKH WKHFDVHVFLWHGE\:DO0DUW6HHLGDWGHVFULELQJ SRVLWLRQ RI WKH WUDLQ EHIRUH DQG DIWHU DQ DFFLGHQW WKH VHYHQFDVHVLQZKLFKORZHUDZDUGVZHUHJLYHQIRUSODLQWLIIV FRQVWUXFWLRQ RI D QHDUE\ PHWDO FDUW DQG WKH VRXQG RI WKH ZKRDVDUHVXOWRIWKHLUIDOOVUHTXLUHGKLSUHSODFHPHQWV,W FUDVK ZDV VXIILFLHQW WR FUHDWH D TXHVWLRQ RI IDFW DV WR WKH QH[WH[DPLQHGWKHDSSOLFDELOLW\RIWKHFDVHVFLWHGE\0H\HUV QHJOLJHQFH RI WKH UDLOURDG LQ DQ DFFLGHQW WKDW DOOHJHGO\ 6HH LG DW  OLVWLQJ HOHYHQ FDVHV LQ ZKLFK GDPDJHV RFFXUUHGZKHQWKHWUDLQVWUXFNWKHPHWDOFDUWFDXVLQJWKHFDUW FRPSDUDEOHWRWKHRQHDZDUGHGWR0H\HUVZHUHJLYHQ WRPRYHDQGVWULNHWKHSODLQWLIIHYHQWKRXJKWKHSODLQWLIIZDV XQDEOHWRYLVXDOO\LGHQWLI\WKHFDXVHRIWKHDFWXDOFROOLVLRQ ,QWZRRIWKHFDVHVFLWHGE\0H\HUVWKHSODLQWLIIVUHFHLYHG :H FRQVHTXHQWO\ ILQG +DVOHU GLVWLQJXLVKDEOH IURP WKH HYHQJUHDWHUGDPDJHVWKDQWKDWDZDUGHGLQWKHSUHVHQWFDVH FLUFXPVWDQFHVRIWKHSUHVHQWFDVH 6HH 5XII Y 'RQXW 6\V ,QF &LY &DVH 1R 12 :/DW /53sXU\*HQHVHH&R0LFK *LYHQ WKH FRPELQDWLRQ RI 'U :HLW]PDQjV PHGLFDO DZDUGLQJWRDZRPDQZKRLQMXUHGKHUNQHHDWD WHVWLPRQ\DQG0H\HUVjVOD\WHVWLPRQ\ZHDUHRIWKHRSLQLRQ GRQXWVKRSZKHUHWKHRQO\UHFRXUVHWRUHOLHYHKHUSDLQZDVWR WKDW 0H\HUV SUHVHQWHG VXIILFLHQW HYLGHQFH IRU UHDVRQDEOH XQGHUJR D IXWXUH NQHH UHSODFHPHQW 3HUNV Y =LHJHOKRIIHU PLQGVWRmGLIIHUDVWRWKHFRQFOXVLRQVWREHGUDZQIURPWKH *RUGRQ)RRG6HUY,QF1R1,:/ HYLGHQFHl0FsXQNLQ&RUS)GDW$FFRUGLQJO\ DW  /53 sXU\ :DVKWHQDZ &R 0LFK  DZDUGLQJ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW GLG QRW HUU LQ SHUPLWWLQJ 0H\HUVjV FODLP  WR D SODLQWLII ZKR VXIIHUHG D IUDFWXUHG SDWHOOD UHJDUGLQJ WKH DJJUDYDWLRQ RI KLV SUHH[LVWLQJ UKHXPDWRLG PXOWLSOHHOERZIUDFWXUHVDQGDIUDFWXUHGKLSWKDWUHTXLUHGD DUWKULWLVWREHVXEPLWWHGWRWKHMXU\ IXWXUH KLS UHSODFHPHQW DOO UHVXOWLQJ IURP DQ DFFLGHQW LQ ZKLFK WKH SODLQWLIIjV YHKLFOH VWUXFN WKH GHIHQGDQWjV SDUNHG WDQGHPWUXFN  0H\HUVY:DO0DUW6WRUHV 1RV 1RV 0H\HUVY:DO0DUW6WRUHV 

]HUR E\ ZDLYLQJ D MXU\ WULDO DOWRJHWKHU DQG KDYLQJ WKHLU % 6XIILFLHQF\ RI WKH HYLGHQFH LQ VXSSRUW RI 0H\HUVjV FRQWURYHUV\GHFLGHGE\WKHFRXUW DZDUG :HDOVRQRWHWKDW:DO0DUWFRXOGKDYHDYHUWHGWKHIRXU $GLVWULFWFRXUWjVGHFLVLRQWRGHQ\DPRWLRQIRUDQHZWULDO SHUVRQMXU\WULDOVLPSO\E\UHIXVLQJWRVWLSXODWHWRWKHUHGXFHG ZLOOQRWEHVHWDVLGHXQOHVVWKHFRXUWDEXVHVLWVGLVFUHWLRQ6HH VL]H7KHUHFRUGUHIOHFWVWKDWWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWH[SUHVVO\JDYH /RJDQY'D\WRQ+XGVRQ&RUS)GWK&LU :DO0DUWWKLVFKRLFH,QVWHDGERWKSDUWLHVYROXQWDULO\ILOHG   6XFK DQ DEXVH ZLOO EH IRXQG RQO\ LI ZH KDYH mD DZULWWHQVWLSXODWLRQWRSURFHHGZLWKRQO\IRXUMXURUV6HH GHILQLWHDQGILUPFRQYLFWLRQWKDWWKHWULDOFRXUWFRPPLWWHGD 0H\HUVY:DO0DUW6WRUHV(DVW,QF)6XSSG FOHDUHUURURIMXGJPHQWl,Gm7KHDPRXQWDOORZHGIRUSDLQ  Q (' 0LFK   :H DFFRUGLQJO\ UHJDUG :DO DQGVXIIHULQJPXVWUHVWLQWKHVRXQGMXGJPHQWRIWKHWULHUVRI 0DUWjVREMHFWLRQDVZDLYHG6HH:HLVVY+RGJH1:G WKHIDFWVl6WHYHQVY(GZDUG&/HY\&R1:G   0LFK &W $SS  m:KHUH DV KHUH SDUWLHV 0LFK VWLSXODWHDQDUUDQJHPHQWWKDWOLPLWVRQHSDUW\jVULJKWVWROHVV WKDQWKDWZKLFKLVRWKHUZLVHUHTXLUHGWKDWSDUW\PD\QRWODWHU ,Q WKH FDVH EHIRUH XV WKHUH ZDV PRUH WKDQ VXIILFLHQW FRPSODLQ RQ DSSHDO DERXW WKLV UHVWULFWLRQl FI %XUQV Y HYLGHQFHWRVXSSRUWWKHMXU\jVYHUGLFW)LUVWWKHMXURUVZHUH /DZWKHU)GWK&LUm7KH6HYHQWK SUHVHQWHGZLWKHYLGHQFHXSRQZKLFKWKH\FRXOGUHDVRQDEO\ $PHQGPHQWULJKWWRDFLYLOMXU\LVQRWDEVROXWHDQGPD\EH FRQFOXGH WKDW :DO0DUW ZDV QHJOLJHQW LQ PDLQWDLQLQJ LWV ZDLYHGLIWKHUHTXHVWIRUDMXU\ZDVQRWWLPHO\l SUHPLVHV:DO0DUWVWLSXODWHGWRWKHIDFWWKDW0H\HUVVOLSSHG RU WULSSHG RQ FDUGERDUG O\LQJ RQ WKH IORRU  6HYHUDO RI LWV ,QOLJKWRI:DO0DUWjVVWLSXODWLRQWKHODQJXDJHRI5XOH HPSOR\HHVWHVWLILHGWKDWWKHER[HVZHUHOHIWDOORYHUWKHER[ DQG WKH DEVHQFH RI FDVH ODZ LQ VXSSRUW RI :DO0DUWjV DUHDEHFDXVHWKHUHZDVQRSODFHHOVHWRSXWWKHPWKDWWKHUH DUJXPHQWZHFRQFOXGHWKDWWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWGLGQRWHUULQ ZDVORRVHFDUGERDUGXQGHUWKHER[HVDQGWKDWFOHDQXSZDV DOORZLQJWKHFDVHWRSURFHHGZLWKDIRXUSHUVRQMXU\:DO GRQHRQO\RQDmFDWFKDVFDWFKFDQlEDVLV,QDGGLWLRQRQHRI 0DUWjV 6HYHQWK $PHQGPHQW DUJXPHQW WR WKH FRQWUDU\ LV :DO0DUWjV HPSOR\HHV FRQFHGHG WKDW OHWWLQJ FXVWRPHUV JR WKHUHIRUHZLWKRXWPHULW LQWR WKH DUHD WR REWDLQ ER[HV ZDV DQ mDFFLGHQW ZDLWLQJ WR KDSSHQlDQGDQRWKHUVDLGWKDWWKHGLVRUJDQL]HGER[HVFRXOG ' $OOHJHGH[FHVVLYHQHVVRIWKHMXU\jVYHUGLFW EHDmWULSDQGIDOOKD]DUGlWRFXVWRPHUV :DO0DUWjV ILQDO FKDOOHQJHV UHODWH WR WKH IDLOXUH RI WKH 7KHUHZDVDOVRVXIILFLHQWHYLGHQFHIRUDUHDVRQDEOHMXURUWR GLVWULFW FRXUW WR UHGXFH WKH MXU\jV YHUGLFW E\ PRUH WKDQ FRQFOXGHWKDW0H\HUVVXIIHUHGH[WHQVLYHSDLQDVDGLUHFWUHVXOW :LWKUHJDUGWRMXU\YHUGLFWVWKLVFRXUWKDVKHOG RIKLVLQMXU\,PPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWKHDFFLGHQWD:DO0DUW WKDW DQ DZDUG ZLOO QRW EH KHOG H[FHVVLYH mLI WKH YHUGLFW LV HPSOR\HHVDZ0H\HUVUROOLQJRQWKHIORRUVFUHDPLQJ7KH ZLWKLQ WKH UDQJH RI SURRI DQG WKH MXU\ ZDV SURSHUO\ HPSOR\HH WHVWLILHG WKDW 0H\HUV DSSHDUHG WR EH LQ D JUHDW LQVWUXFWHGl/HLOD+RVS +HDOWK&WUY;RQLFV0HG6\V DPRXQW RI SDLQ  0H\HUV DOVR KDG WR XQGHUJR D WRWDO KLS ,QF)GWK&LU,QHYDOXDWLQJWKHMXU\ UHSODFHPHQWDVDUHVXOWRIKLVIDOO%HFDXVHRIWKHKLJKIHYHU DZDUG WKH SULPDU\ FRQVLGHUDWLRQ LV ZKHWKHU WKH DZDUG LV KH H[SHULHQFHG LPPHGLDWHO\ DIWHU WKH KLS UHSODFHPHQW ZLWKLQWKHUDQJHRISURRIm>7@KHGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIZKHWKHUD 0H\HUVjV XVH RI PRUSKLQH KDG WR EH GLVFRQWLQXHG  7KLV MXU\jV YHUGLFW LV H[FHVVLYH LV UHVROYHG E\ WKH GLVFUHWLRQDU\ IRUFHGKLPWRUHFXSHUDWHIURPDPDMRURSHUDWLRQZLWKRXWDQ\ FRQVLGHUDWLRQ RI WKH WULDO MXGJH  $EVHQW FOHDU DEXVH RI SDLQ UHOLHI D SURFHVV WKDW FDXVHG KLP WR H[SHULHQFH GLVFUHWLRQ DSSHOODWH FRXUWV ZLOO QRW PDNH WKHLU RZQ mWUHPHQGRXVSDLQlDQGmDJRQ\l  0H\HUVY:DO0DUW6WRUHV 1RV 1RV 0H\HUVY:DO0DUW6WRUHV 

7KH HYLGHQFH DOVR GHPRQVWUDWHG WKDW 0H\HUV VXIIHUHG D $OORIWKLVHYLGHQFHZKHQFRQVLGHUHGWRJHWKHUSURYLGHV JUHDWDPRXQWRISDLQGXHWRWKHUHKDELOLWDWLYHWKHUDS\UHTXLUHG PRUHWKDQVXIILFLHQWVXSSRUWIRUWKHMXU\jVYHUGLFW%HFDXVH DVDUHVXOWRIKLVLQMXULHVPRUHVRWKDQZRXOGW\SLFDOO\EHWKH ZHDUHQRWmOHIWZLWKWKHGHILQLWHDQGILUPFRQYLFWLRQWKDWD FDVH  0H\HUVjV SK\VLFLDQ WHVWLILHG WKDW m>Z@KDW KDSSHQHG PLVWDNHUHVXOWLQJLQSODLQLQMXVWLFHKDVEHHQFRPPLWWHGRU IROORZLQJWKHIUDFWXUHZDVWKDWKLVMRLQWVEHFDPHPXFKPRUH >WKDW@WKHYHUGLFWLVFRQWUDU\WRDOOUHDVRQZHPXVWDIILUPWKH SDLQIXODQGPXFKPRUHVZROOHQl$VDUHVXOWRIWKLVFKDQJH MXU\jVYHUGLFWl6FKRRQRYHUY&RQVRO)UHLJKWZD\V&RUSRI LQWKHDUWKULWLFGLVHDVHSURFHVV0H\HUVKDGWRUHWXUQWREHLQJ 'HODZDUH /RFDO   )G   WK &LU  WUHDWHG ZLWK VWHURLGV D FRXUVH RI WUHDWPHQW WKDW KDG EHHQ LQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNVRPLWWHG GLVFRQWLQXHGIRUWKUHH\HDUVSULRUWRWKHDFFLGHQW & &RQVWLWXWLRQDOLW\RIWKHIRXUSHUVRQMXU\ 7KLV FDVH LV HVVHQWLDOO\ D SDUDOOHO WR WKH FODVVLF WH[WERRN H[DPSOH RI WKH SODLQWLII ZLWK DQ HJJVKHOO VNXOO ZKHUH WKH :DO0DUW QH[W DUJXHV WKDW WKH XVH RI D IRXUSHUVRQ MXU\ WRUWIHDVRUPXVWWDNHWKHLQMXUHGSDUW\DVLWILQGVKLPDQGLV YLRODWHG LWV 6HYHQWK $PHQGPHQW ULJKW WR D MXU\ WULDO  7KH OLDEOHIRUWKHIXOOH[WHQWRIWKHKDUPFDXVHGE\LWVQHJOLJHQFH 6XSUHPH&RXUWKDVOHIWRSHQWKLVLVVXHVWDWLQJWKDWmZKLOHZH HYHQ LI D PRUH mQRUPDOl SODLQWLII ZRXOG QRW KDYH VXIIHUHG H[SUHVVQRYLHZDVWRZKHWKHUDQ\QXPEHUOHVVWKDQVL[ZRXOG QHDUO\ DV PXFK  6HH : 3DJH .HHWRQ HW DO 3URVVHU DQG VXIILFHZHFRQFOXGHWKDWDMXU\RIVL[VDWLVILHVWKH6HYHQWK .HHWRQRQ7KH/DZRI7RUWV†DWWKHG $PHQGPHQWjV JXDUDQWHH RI WULDO E\ MXU\ LQ FLYLO FDVHVl ,Q WKLV LQVWDQFH 0H\HUVjV SUHH[LVWLQJ DUWKULWLF FRQGLWLRQ &ROJURYHY%DWWLQ86XSKROGLQJ FDXVHG DQ LQIODPPDWLRQ RI KLV MRLQWV GXH WR WKH VWUHVV DGLVWULFWFRXUWjVORFDOUXOHWKDWDXWKRUL]HGWKHXVHRIDVL[ QHFHVVDULO\SODFHGRQWKHPGXULQJWKHUHKDELOLWDWLYHSURFHVV PHPEHUMXU\LQFLYLOFDVHV IROORZLQJ KLV KLSUHSODFHPHQW VXUJHU\  7KH LQIODPPDWLRQ H[SRQHQWLDOO\LQFUHDVHG0H\HUVjVSDLQDQGVXIIHULQJGXULQJ 5XOHRIWKH)HGHUDO5XOHVRI&LYLO3URFHGXUHKRZHYHU WKHSURFHVVEXWWKLVLVDFRQVHTXHQFHIRUZKLFK:DO0DUWLV H[SOLFLWO\DGGUHVVHVWKHVL]HRIMXULHVLQFLYLOFDVHV OLDEOHXQGHU0LFKLJDQODZ6HH:LONLQVRQY/HH1:G   0LFK  KROGLQJ WKDW WKH HYLGHQFH 7KHFRXUWVKDOOVHDWDMXU\RIQRWIHZHUWKDQVL[DQGQRW VXSSRUWHGDMXU\jVILQGLQJWKDWDQDXWRPRELOHDFFLGHQWZDVWKH PRUHWKDQWZHOYHPHPEHUVDQGDOOMXURUVVKDOOSDUWLFLSDWH FDXVHLQIDFWRIV\PSWRPVVXFKDVQDXVHDVHYHUHKHDGDFKHV LQWKHYHUGLFWXQOHVVH[FXVHGIURPVHUYLFHE\WKHFRXUW GL]]LQHVVGRXEOHYLVLRQDQGDFFHOHUDWLQJPHPRU\ORVVIURP SXUVXDQW WR 5XOH F  8QOHVV WKH SDUWLHV RWKHUZLVH DSUHH[LVWLQJEUDLQWXPRUZKHUHWKHUHZDVPHGLFDOWHVWLPRQ\ VWLSXODWHWKHYHUGLFWVKDOOEHXQDQLPRXVDQGQR WKDW WKH WUDXPD FDXVHG E\ WKH DFFLGHQW WULJJHUHG WKH YHUGLFWVKDOOEHWDNHQIURPDMXU\UHGXFHGLQVL]HWRIHZHU V\PSWRPV WKDQVL[PHPEHUV

)LQDOO\ ERWK 0H\HUV DQG KLV ZLIH WHVWLILHG WKDW WKH KLS )HG5&LY3HPSKDVLVDGGHG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