McIlease v. James F. Meehan Co.

113 N.Y.S. 489

• Court: Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York
• Decided: December 16, 1908
• Status: Published

Opinion

FORD, J.

Action by employé for damages for alleged negligence. Defendant was employed in repairing a building. Plaintiff was hoisting mortar to the upper story by means of a rope and pulley hung in an air shaft. Plaintiff stood outside the shaft, and, while looking up into it at the pail above him, some mortar fell and hit him in the eye, destroying its sight. He had been doing this kind of work for two hours before his injury, and always filled the pail himself.

Plaintiff claims the defendant was negligent in that it did not furnish a safe place to work, and did not furnish proper appliances. I cannot see that negligence can be predicated here on either ground or any other ground. No defect in the appliance is shown, nor was the method of doing the work inherently dangerous. From the testimony the most reasonable inference is that the accident was caused by some act of the plaintiff either in hoisting the pail too quickly or in allowing it to hit the side of the shaft. The appliance furnished was a most simple one, and it cannot be said that such an unfortunate occurrence was reasonably to be anticipated. Whatever danger there was, was as well known to plaintiff as to defendant.

Judgment and order should be reversed, and new trial ordered, with costs to appellant to abide the event. All concur.