McElvain, Russell Terry

Court of Appeals of Texas·Decided September 18, 2015·No. WR-81,181-02·Published

Opinion

g\ \O\~<>&

`\

g;a~ o_\o\\c>ca » \'>'.>J_,c)_,_;e E)s__PARTE _ __*____J;N ‘r\»\€ csa r\v\r~m_

”_,.v- ___` .D'I.$I£~;.CI 4__€_»£>*\)_1’>'.\'__-¥.\\_0,__1_

_._”___e`\)_s.s_v=_\,;_`_:\#§_es>~_~c_.,y_\.e£.\,\_re~_;_- M.-___,_____~..W.__,._ __ S\TA_Q,MQI,RE@E:!ME:@¢I . _1€;~,¢.¢>(5_.__

COURT OF CR|!‘.‘I|NAL PPEALS

APPL'£C,ANT`S GB“SEC:\’I<>N 'ro %Y¢>¢\'E'S &€SP§E¢PS]ES ms

w we Ho~oo`m>,\,e :QDQ§_Q_E_$~AC_L.-~.;Q£.\._>;\s:<_:_w__---...“_~-_A@@LAQ@§&&?CB@M_~_» ___ ________,.'..S`~,,,.“@s§$ SS.X\:.\`_QM;\_.‘Y\__¢;E_\»_\¢Q_L¢.\,. _P.~.pg.\_€ m¢<‘c.~p.¢;o_rse,.,*o_\>§ e¢lr~_)ho_g\..\.*\'.)mms w \*':\’ ki.k_'f(?\\e_ -

%‘€<>3\ Q.‘ S W\ Qm_§>.v.`g_w_\.d;u.v.~. , .E\‘.Ad.~\;n%s_.s>§__r:'ad»_w.\d~ .Com.<§_\g_$_\‘_o_v_\s“ ~o£__\..aw.,,»s_u\\>m.\‘ftkm.._-,, _.,_";\>\/\__Bmcéo\_:§.e_.¢_o.\>s.,__&$$_\`.$§q;\'§ C-»"‘m)`;\o..\_.b*\‘.$`.\`,¢;\’..écw A\Xn¢:v>_e.§\_,l.°§_€;.~jr_(bw.\\_z\_, _

____ __e`n..*/_>_\_\)ASM.$:\_~')_-_S.rj,>@.l$,um_o~d.~bp_\`.e.,d_\;>\__`\’\rs§...€@_ud . On____p$‘;~q¢;)us'}.._').~l, §;Q`\.$.,_.. ._.,____ , ___“_»_C§¢%Q\<:d_\\l¢_\§_>,_.J,v_\.\_/._._A._pp_\_\`.=cei§i.oz>;__cg.c,.\ls).€"z`§ _9§._"\1\!0;\0.<0` s_ _.Ca>_c_j>.v.~$ .

_-M_, I- %M.”\>.`.o\§\_m~_\mcsvm_&\a_i.;\\o.__v?.~_.*¢\__c\_e_{>.,\.\`,.¢:oj_t§_o_v.\ _e¢.§_r_v>"_\,`s¢é. .1`;¢\§_ _.1._0_<`_\`_ §J_\asl_, -..~-._ _.___._.\`_¢_\,v:'_~o&_e's_-c§\<`c,\o_\cofh€am ~o\r_\pi og‘.\h.»f\'hz§“'§-.__\'Ae§§_§.v,g._,- Q_~r.\d_er__€.iv.\o_\f€\_¢l~¢o§..?§r_§w¢\-,__. m .~.I\'\r\p~_*v._occ,o¢ch\“n%_-\-o.w\\\_\><,\ {£,S,, ‘\'\P\€._€Q~.c§.$_"$§e¢!$d-..mjj~$ `C>_~L\o.(_.`€&£ces_`\*.. - .M__»____ A.-_____,_1_6\010.).1'.5_»_\_311>__\<>£_§/_\%_`:\'& “`.`.',\>€,_,Ql\j'_€r_\".\*_\'.o_n _0_9_ _“.\'_\r_\l'»s.. §:'\¢_n~or:_¢~@_\o.\.c__(;°?.%_¢:`§., 4_1`_¢_\;`!12._\:1¢_\5_\_. ~ __L@mb\£m§~)_o;\f_\d'_~\?c>§§§0\_§__§_@€¥_»1`>:§‘%~\»3.£‘\1\:\,€.0_:ch_r»qof\__Qv.mi\~)_o~r;eq_?.o_\xbem___ q ,_*___i:{e,ev§¥§§:\~_€,o»&c gd..\o§.`__'\.'§;\g_E¢,<:°.\'_..b_~.\o_r_;\’_\'_\_$§'n<::§`g§g. . cam._\§;\__o§~j_.\`s\gs., m..§\_';¢\_¢. l'b. `., _...7;0..\5_0~1.\¢£ -..'3.\)\1_\¢._.9.-£2.,- 9.0.\5 ... - -T\r.\Lf\o».o_.b_.\ls'.\§'idk-_g_`\"}o_C:\“€,g\_,__ __o_\_\$i;\ao_c»§§;{c,.e*do ,-`___l$.w\%.~.v"__$_\@_\$_: ldnlsg\o se_s_*?_r;o}a¢. .\‘;\~§x>,.q,.mg_s'}_(_;=_v,\ed_p,~,_).\£c£,_`\”£$}_€‘.wx_wl:.;_ _ L__B'.\_m§~ _ __,___. 13__.\1\10~3\\\'1\£-~&°_\0\3.__:F ha , _'SW_\_.\`.r_`\¢b\‘.r.\§. ..i:\t,_bx\j:\.`a>cc:o"_~'%, 0C’¢»>.~»\r_\°,\w\ 0 -P_r_\>_$_e¢.»;`so cz§.) _ du c.\.\.mev\°.\~$.- ,'5;\_»_~=.\¢'.~.`/`___'\.1¢@~\/2.____ m m LAM_MX*41';A~Q-_Gz.`oz\`,'\`.\‘ on :\:v o\oj\.g~.\`.o._o¢\;\. .09 _`\'\Ae,d\w`§_c\.\`_.\S_.o>/.\A..&€9\1m'smrxqv.v.\e$-).M/_\€* _.‘ wl 19*€§6.~§}>€\.\}\1, 09_¢. \(¢ _o§:€.\lcecs:_.\‘ s¢os;we,§\§»‘.o.v:\gd§_\‘_,\ _ F\ _`_c»mmmm"\’_fe s .. ._gus\:o.u\ r_\»k.@§,.\e)_»__ * .__'__¥.>,\a\evm, c;,?r_~,-__@_.-hm11mgB&__C¢.\;¢§._~,.“S_\;M_c§?_e‘s,0,_0_(;5.:@¢._,...:\1¢ _M~$M¢:_. _______J,L\.Ql.\i`$¢,__`l.&&<§guzd_u"_v_\j. »a__w_a`k’.mvs%a ~,o.-Q>E\lge,el$;\`_gs`\`§ w.~on \T,__o\. ..P.¢:<> S&MQ¢,~§¢¢,<-WS evid , ,..,.__

,., __....__

_.0_ d___’J_Z,:_\:\-.\.o.»a`_kk. ,.\.\§, -._.\,_~;Az .*mo.\)$_\y,\o,)_s§:»%§`-.u,(>_<>_<~_~`dmsd,.`w_f¢>%_)“.¢.\%._`\:\: MQ~..;QMFJ&§L_ \

. W,QMB{%L&~-SW.S.,“AMM““Q cc>..$_e_<;_¢_»~_¢¥o.r__w,co'.\:g_ aho_».»&.m.o>_,,E\/.\\AS_S_ `_\Lw`k§;\o.\r.\"§ v

_i§_e)__,gd.e._d_\qgr_\ _1‘_¢.\,<5_¢,\¢¢\.\\`_\a~j':$,_\io5_0`\¢.¢:&§¥.¢¢1_,;\`.<:,\`,e_,xi\_ ao\;\o\_. _¢_~§L\s_\`_¢;\de.d._w_\a.\ac.~__-- () `)

" ' ” \ \'\ ‘ o I ___.____¢¢O`\_§ '\)`>\‘9\'\ ch O\\Qx&€`v\`-\,Q\g 4\"£'>`\§3~\0 1\:\` D~I\Cl w\w‘ l9f\~\t,c;<;o_%&§(_\§o“w_"\:\l~\is_j_$j§/_Q__ _191\{>_09_’\’\'\9_\‘99\09¢-5 "¥9_500\__ _ ._\'_5_\'5.__\‘.(` m\&_\)gv.\*x_£_v'\~v\__<;as'e'- mg¢l\:_\ge_;jzc.~¢~é __, `\313'___

999\¢\ __\0§__9¢_\_£»_%¢`_9'5_\__‘095_@_0_9_9_\:, 19 '9)_\_90\_ cm_v\_w_~.~_o. \‘o 099\¢¢4~5__\¢\ __‘7_\_99»\_~~\9¢\=__

`\~§9>‘_9$_,__09\\»‘..5 '\~9_59~\_"9\~9¢9_0¢9“.9_»~099 7

Ns€_‘§_o_x>\_ §_~Ac\'-\ &\;90 ¢0§

%'T N\~E‘s Fr~br~€:.s__ o_v~’_ Ee~_¢_\'_k_;_ %_._9_53_¢_\__'9 95_939_'~_'\ __%:ec>`;t__x~_\_@_)_ ___ \3 c>r\\E '

(o. _3.`.1.\_3_9_~9_~ °\.\_,_:9\;9_\1\€9\~.¢03§£§§__9;95\\_9_ _“9\¢_\93_€_\9@_\_\_99'_<\_~\:9_9}\<_ g\_cl§`_u_~x:es_w_\é~_

_' \1\' 99ng 39190_\\0\_00§0\_3_\,_\5 \r\¢r ~

§?. _`\3\9_329999_¢_\92\£5 ,_¢:S’;’v_\zr_;\iv_\¢=\r_\_c,.\`f\d_ no)_¥~¢_°_’t\/_\&_\s_ \ ‘C\i_ ~_\‘5_1995'9`_\ m ._r_\!\ _,_-P\pp\;_€_qv_~_\*_

__9¢\9$9¢<\$_1\0_9\3\ an:\-p_s»~{,pork_\£\<_>_c_ ‘\0»_~_`3\'9\9*.\_*3\>3/_\_9_<>_0;991~_\1__0¢?\ v.\ess__€'-_o_mm.\.;"v».d_

\>K>W_`__B_QAA _\A!s_ivg.s__ ~\¢.>0_0\.,.\¢ _M__me_\_¢_ _m,_\,__\¢ 19 +\\9 mem _'5.¢2\3`$_99_*’5\_'_\\s_o!\\:d__.m£<__9_¥2~{).?.9¢.\.,_i\'§/\_9_CM_'§._SMM.%9\_0.\9_95_'3_'\’_9>9\.\_909_\¢_`~_9:___» ____L\'.».\d$.e_¢\_b»i\_l_x_e.\zo.r_\d_\;;d._\b_r£~§.oc_d_~\9_'\99"_\§3‘_¢:9¢00!5_¢0;1\‘_9:91_.

____C,Ro\)\`\>b$'”i`w° \Zztve N~_m F::\=T€E'N' '

"\"\,\L 95_9_<3_9 `99¢~\$_¢`°~0\$01\0\§\¢;91;\‘n\_s'\`ro?ro.%»\_o\r\ S`\'¢; qj_g;ts;c;_____ Aw§ro___¢\ _p_m _9590[_

\`5_ q_\)z¥)&sr_$w\*.\'_€d v-'>“<‘A'

___j__.'___\ "Y\\_e _5\~9\__~9 ow\oo\¢¢_d"€»\e{>ow\\ '9\¢_\,;5_:_‘9!/_\9_\0\9¢1<_0\¢)\90 ;99{>`@_0->9>_'¢_\9`\_9¢_\;9\'_99_

5°~9¢:_9§_\_939¢:¢~9¢<\_0¢.\(9_ 99_\9$_°_9_¢_\`\/\9$__9_\_~1_\`§_\!_9_ €u.\_ d~.er.\c.+.., _

___l'l\» `.995>__"§\'\'_>,9 $Wv`_ms_%\vev\_o\n_ev<'\~¢`omeous_€_v\o\9v\r_9_\\/\S`9fv\ &9\'0\¢\»-\'>~»\'-`-\'_\’>&*`3-__- __\Q_C_\s_v;o_d_\e% mib99_95_:\'9_90\\99_\»95_9>&¢999095_- _9>. _ __u.msn_ `9_ Wv{_\:\osl_ p\r_\:o:\u$_cmd_\: \`A¢_o '\0_9)¢_¢\,0_‘21€_(>_ \_Q\r_\g~`.\\".ov_\_d\\_\)_\‘_ck€ _r_\g)_`\N_\Q/m_,_(b. o\ r_\'.\:\`. r.\¢)_'ové“_\,.>}_\o.l\_ wm\e\_o\v\i_e»\~`\&m§ bg_u>§ecl.. E\L\_o£ej\ce,_g:(`o_w~_{dm_o£_ `90_ `99\_$992\` 995_ ___*l~\m?`.\`.me_v\*r_ms_m§_$gnomod\~¢d _ ` ' _.'.1_3_ _`:9}_\9¢~9_\‘>_1\»_€_999¢:¢:9_ oF~_~‘€v_\L_("t{>o.¢-_‘\_§cow\__ _(3 sv\c\r\q\o§<§\ `\`\'\As_\s_o¢_\r_\e__ 999 _p,p_\_\`_¢_¢\¢.\k\_$e\_wk \)'.>_3.9\9_9_ 69995:¢\23~_0_$_0\\‘¢&_ ._I_\Sr.\nw_\p_\\¢i*__§_\_\mml_c:<:¢_m_l!\s_

_Q._Q\_MP\¢_¢._\_\_ ,_90@9_'\:3'__\)~> §¢>_¢Q_g'_i _§,u_o 60 __\_9_5_°'\’_\'_~_9_‘>$“1_ 99\,¢_\_90)_\'_§\5__ \`_9\99<"\`-__

3%- "“\0. w DBSE " A°°\§gg,g§ peg sg,§&§ 'm; Q\\;'¢gngg j-_\go,i; I!§;, Mgg;k` hgg,g §§ M$

`\"\9\`5'9<' wm B.l‘_Q\SS_Q\_&<`_Q\nfy_c§.\*.¢.949\019:_T_k{$_\'_$_\‘./.\co.c:¢`_o_d'_c\.:>-I_o_\xrd_f>¢.¢;;\'9 99 `\\~2___ 719_p.o_r_\'_<¢:`s_&.e_c».cd_w\_\o_ce__l!_\¢,.§r]§:°§§§\:ec'$_s§-.Q=\-.e;_c¢_§'d99¢_909§_0_\_\)1€9;_»0_¢£_09\.M__sg>sm\:_-» abv\>e_g.,_~d\ \\/\9_9!\9.\".5:94~_5‘_9_99_95._`\‘_9_.99.5_9599599?__09_\>»_9»_9_5 o\ 0_\'_¢_§`_¢0_¢&_9\_/_\$§9_$9)§_99_\ abuse . boaz `\'\¢_\\;5_9_\9;\0.¢>9!'>.\.9_€994~§_'\`9_~\9_\>_~_\3.909_‘*§9:`_»9_9£_9_\_)_\9_93_\9599_?

_§h._T.\_~L_§~§\-A£_ML\»_@;.)_"AW\.€_W?r~_{d.r:e$_e.¢§sS_f_\o_€__.v_\‘.oL¢.¢\c.e,_:\‘-_sw@or§ \'\\`s_c§e.\w_`k'_\>ak_

__v\_~;\_a\\'.\_¢)?_X\/.\e._#a_\ulc.k.u\c_e,_o>d`m§_‘€\s-d_wq.s_cl\»_\.d_?om_\%mph.\..:_°_\\~_\'>_\1&_9.2¢0,1>%3__ 3 1"\ "\\4\ N\`€ w\.c'>c:°_\/.\o\mm`__§`-__P_L'_>§f\" `\'\\ Q¢M°-$ "'\ ‘X\\L_S§\’_¥>

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

McElvain, Russell Terry, (Tex. Ct. App. 2015).

McElvain, Russell Terry (McElvain, Russell Terry) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.