McCrory v. JEFFERSON PARISH HOSP. SERV.

686 So. 2d 1060, 1996 WL 744553
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedDecember 30, 1996
Docket96-CA-624
StatusPublished
Cited by6 cases

This text of 686 So. 2d 1060 (McCrory v. JEFFERSON PARISH HOSP. SERV.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
McCrory v. JEFFERSON PARISH HOSP. SERV., 686 So. 2d 1060, 1996 WL 744553 (La. Ct. App. 1996).

Opinion

686 So.2d 1060 (1996)

Flory McCRORY and Leslie McCrory,
v.
JEFFERSON PARISH HOSPITAL SERVICE DISTRICT NO. 2 d/b/a East Jefferson General Hospital.

No. 96-CA-624.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Fifth Circuit.

December 30, 1996.

*1061 Rene' A. Curry, Jr., New Orleans, for The Louisiana Patients' Compensation Fund Oversight Board.

George P. Hebbler, Jr., New Orleans, Kurt P. Forshag, Metairie, for Plaintiffs/Appellees.

Before GRISBAUM, WICKER and CANNELLA, JJ.

WICKER, Judge.

The issue on this medical malpractice appeal is whether the Louisiana Patient's Compensation Fund may assert the victim's contributory/comparative negligence to reduce the amount of damages it must pay under the Medical Malpractice Act. The trial court rejected the Patient Compensation Fund's attempt to apply comparative fault. We affirm.

Bert McCrory was injured in an automobile accident on May 15, 1992, in which he sustained a closed fracture of the left hip and an abrasion of his forehead. His injuries were not life-threatening and his physician expected him to recover. On the evening of his admission to the hospital, however, he was discovered dead in his hospital bed.

McCrory's widow and daughter, Flora and Leslie McCrory, filed a medical malpractice suit against Jefferson Parish Hospital Service District No. 2 d/b/a East Jefferson General Hospital, asserting Bert's death resulted from an overdose of medication while he was a patient in the hospital ("multi-drug toxicity with drug-drug interaction"). The hospital settled with plaintiffs for $114,020, comprising its $100,000-plus-interest maximum liability under the Medical Malpractice Law. See La. R.S. 40:1299.42(B)(2). Thereafter plaintiffs substituted the Louisiana Patient's Compensation Fund (PCF) as defendant in place of the hospital.

The Medical Malpractice Act limits the total amount recoverable for all malpractice claims for injuries to or death of a patient, exclusive of future medical care and related benefits, to a maximum of $500,000 plus interest and cost. La. R.S. 40:1299.42(B)(1). A health care provider's maximum individual liability under the Act is $100,000 plus interest. La. R.S. 40:1299.42(B)(2). Any amount due from a judgment or settlement or from a final arbitration award which is in excess of the total liability of all liable health care providers shall be paid from the patient's compensation fund, but the total amounts paid shall not exceed the $500,000 limitation. La. R.S. 40:1299.42(B)(3)(a)-(b).

The matter was set for trial as to the amount of damages due by the PCF. In a supplemental and amended answer the PCF asserted that Bert McCrory's contributory negligence and/or comparative negligence in causing the automobile accident should be considered by the court in limitation or reduction *1062 of the wrongful death damages claimed by his wife and daughter. Plaintiffs filed a motion to strike and/or motion in limine as to the PCF's attempt to assert the defense of contributory/comparative negligence.

The case was submitted to the district court on joint stipulations of fact, which stated in pertinent part:

STIPULATION NO. 21:
Liability for the overdose of medications and the death of Mr. McCrory was admitted by East Jefferson General Hospital and considered as established by virtue of the hereinafter described court approved settlement between plaintiffs and intervenors with East Jefferson General Hospital as well as under the provisions of LSA-R.S. 40:1299.44(C)(5).
STIPULATION NO. 22:
It is stipulated that plaintiffs' decedent, Bert W. McCrory, was 100% negligent or at fault in causing the automobile accident and his automobile accident-related injuries.
STIPULATION NO. 23:
As a result of the negligence of decedent, Bert McCrory, in having caused the automobile accident and accident-related injuries, the PCF, in response to plaintiffs' lawsuit, has answered same, affirmatively pleading the negligence, contributory negligence, and/or comparative negligence of plaintiffs' decedent (Mr. McCrory) under the provisions of LSA-C.C. Arts. 2323 et seq. and C.C. Articles 1803, 1804 and other laws and jurisprudence of the State of Louisiana, in mitigation and/or reduction of the malpractice damages for which plaintiffs seek recovery herein. Plaintiffs deny that the PCF is entitled to any such mitigation or reduction.
* * * * * *
STIPULATION NO. 26:
It is stipulated between the parties that plaintiff's malpractice damages amount to $500,000, plus legal interest and court costs.
* * * * * *
STIPULATION NO. 32:
The parties stipulate, as a matter of fact, that Bert McCrory's death was solely the result of the administration to him of excessive amounts of Demerol and Phenergan by East Jefferson General Hospital personnel while he was a patient at East Jefferson General Hospital ("the hospital's acts"). The parties do not stipulate that Bert McCrory's death and/or plaintiffs' malpractice damages were, as a matter of law, solely caused by the hospital's acts....

On January 31, 1996 the court rendered judgment in favor of plaintiffs in the amount of $500,000, plus legal interest from date of judicial demand, less a credit for amounts paid by the hospital. The judgment granted plaintiffs' motion to strike/motion in limine. It also granted reimbursement to the worker's compensation intervenor for payments of survivors' benefits and medical expenses to plaintiffs and recognized the claim of plaintiffs' former attorney for attorney's fees.

Pursuant to timely motions for new trial by all parties, on March 8, 1996 the trial court rendered an amended judgment which provided for legal interest on the amount awarded against the PCF from October 21, 1992 until paid, reduced by the sum of $100,000 previously paid by the hospital together with legal interest on the reduced sum from October 21, 1992, until paid. The amended judgment granted the plaintiffs' motion to strike and/or motion in limine and ordered the Patient's Compensation Fund to pay all costs incurred by plaintiffs in prosecution of the claim. It also made certain provisions regarding the interventions that are not relevant to this appeal.

On April 19, 1996 the court rendered a second amended judgment which changed the wording of the amended judgment only as to ruling on the motion to strike/motion in limine, stating that "the award to plaintiffs, as set forth hereinabove for malpractice damages shall not be reduced by apportioning or considering the negligence or fault of plaintiffs' decedent, Bert W. McCrory, in causing the automobile accident and his accident-related injuries."

The PCF took a suspensive appeal.

*1063 On appeal the PCF contends the trial court erred in the following respects: (1) disallowing the PCF's attempt to assert the affirmative defenses of contributory and/or comparative negligence in mitigation or reduction of damages; (2) failing to reduce through apportionment the amount of damages for which the PCF is liable to plaintiffs; and (3) failing to apply the doctrine of confusion to partially extinguish the PCF's obligation to plaintiffs.

APPLICABILITY OF VICTIM FAULT

La. R.S. 40:1299.44(C)(5) provides, in pertinent part:

In approving a settlement or determining the amount, if any, to be paid from the patient's compensation fund,

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Willis v. Ochsner Clinic Foundation
140 So. 3d 338 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2014)
Cannatella v. Cougle
119 So. 3d 94 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2013)
Harrison v. Smith
832 So. 2d 1064 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2002)
McGrath v. Excel Home Care, Inc.
810 So. 2d 1283 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2002)
UNITED MEDICAL CORP. OF LOUISIANA v. Johns
798 So. 2d 1161 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2001)
Greer v. Lammico
779 So. 2d 894 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2000)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
686 So. 2d 1060, 1996 WL 744553, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/mccrory-v-jefferson-parish-hosp-serv-lactapp-1996.