McCartney v. McCormick

974 So. 2d 854, 2008 WL 239558
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedJanuary 30, 2008
Docket07-0997
StatusPublished
Cited by1 cases

This text of 974 So. 2d 854 (McCartney v. McCormick) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
McCartney v. McCormick, 974 So. 2d 854, 2008 WL 239558 (La. Ct. App. 2008).

Opinion

974 So.2d 854 (2008)

Robert Kevin McCARTNEY, et al.
v.
George McCORMICK, et al.

No. 07-0997.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Third Circuit.

January 30, 2008.

*856 Robert Kevin McCartney, Homer, LA, Pro Se for Plaintiffs/Appellants, Robert Kevin McCartney, Aubrey McCartney, Elaine McCartney.

No Counsel Enrolled for Defendants.

Court composed of ULYSSES G. THIBODEAUX, Chief Judge, SYLVIA R. COOKS and JIMMIE C. PETERS, Judges.

PETERS, J.

The plaintiffs in this matter, Robert Kevin McCartney, Aubrey McCartney, and Elaine McCartney,[1] appeal the trial court's dismissal of their suit against a number of defendants. For the following reasons, we affirm in part, reverse in part, render in part, and remand to the trial court for further proceedings.

DISCUSSION OF THE RECORD

This litigation arises from Robert Kevin McCartney's September 28, 1995 conviction of first degree murder in the death of Dale DeSelle, a violation of La.R.S. 14:30.[2]*857 On July 14, 2006, the plaintiffs filed the instant suit seeking to have that conviction declared a nullity and seeking to recover monetary damages for alleged constitutional rights violations. The original petition named as defendants Detective Clyde Terral of the Rapides Parish Sheriffs Department; Officer Michael Villard of the Rapides Parish Sheriffs Department; Rapides Parish Sheriff William Earl Hilton; Ninth Judicial District Assistant District Attorneys Clifford Strider, III and James Buck; Ninth Judicial District Attorney Charles Wagner; and Dr. George McCormick.

The plaintiffs' basic complaint in their original petition was that Dr. McCormick testified falsely concerning his involvement in the autopsy of Mr. DeSelle's body and in the preparation of the coroner's report. Specifically, the plaintiffs asserted that during Robert Kevin McCartney's trial, Dr. McCormick and James Buck "committed Fraud, Ill-Practice, Misrepresentation, Non-feasance, and Malfeasance in Office, when they deceived the jury into a belief that McCormick had performed the autopsy, examined the body, and prepared the autopsy report and death certificate, when he had not, done any of the above."

On July 27, 2006, the trial court signed an ex parte order that the suit "be re-allotted to the proper criminal division of the Ninth Judicial District Court" and that "any civil claims raised by the petitioners are reserved until after a determination of the criminal matters."[3] On October 30, 2006, the plaintiffs filed a motion seeking to have the July 26, 2007 order stricken and to be granted a judgment on the pleadings. For reasons not made clear from the record before us, the trial court did not respond to this filing until January 11, 2007. On that date, the trial court hand-wrote across the face of the motion "Denied. No hearing will be set unless or until all defendants have been served with the petition. No service has been requested or made." On February 2, 2007, Robert Kevin McCartney filed a written motion for service of both the petition and the initial request for subpoenas.[4] On that same day, the trial court ordered that service of both the petition and the subpoenas be effected.

On February 22, 2007, Robert Kevin McCartney filed a motion seeking to have all evidence in cases involving Dr. McCormick preserved. By a hand-written notation across the face of the pleading, the trial court denied the motion, noting that it did so "for failure to meet C.Cr.P. 718."

In his next pleading, filed March 7, 2007, Robert Kevin McCartney sought an order addressed to the Office of District Attorney of the Ninth Judicial District and the Rapides Parish Sheriffs Office for the production of all evidence in their custody which related to the autopsy of Dale Paul DeSelle; an order addressed to the Rapides Parish Clerk of Court's Office for the production of a transcript of the trial testimony of Dr. McCormick in his trial; and an order addressed to Dr. McCormick's office for the production of all documents or statements which might relate to misconduct on the part of Dr. McCormick in other cases, as well as all notes and documents *858 relating to the autopsy of Dale Paul DeSelle. All of the plaintiffs then filed an additional motion on April 11, 2007, seeking an order compelling the defendants to respond "to their petition and summonses and to have their case set for trial.

The trial court rejected both the March 7 and April 11 Motions on June 20, 2007, by writing "denied" across the front of the orders provided. On that same day, the trial court entered an order dismissing the plaintiffs' suit. The order reads in pertinent part as follows:

Considering the foregoing Petition for Nullification and Civil Rights Complaint with Jury Demand, Motion for Production of Documents Relevant and Material to Guilt or Punishment in Pro-se, and Motion to Compel Answer with Request to Set Matter for Trial, herein;
IT IS ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED that the Defendant [sic, Plaintiffs] fails to state a Cause of Action and fails to state a claim upon which relief can be granted as to nullification of the judgment. This court believes that Defendant's nullification request is actually an attempt to seek a Post Conviction Relief hearing, which should be brought before the Criminal Court.
IT IS ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED that the Defendant [sic, Plaintiffs] fails to state a Cause of Action against all Defendants with the exception of the Estate of Dr. McCormick.
IT IS ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED that the Defendants [sic, Plaintiffs'] Petition as to the Estate of Dr. McCormick is dismissed with out [sic] prejudice as this court does not have jurisdiction of the Estate of Dr. McCormick. Dr. McCormick resided and died in Caddo Parish. The proper jurisdiction for an action against the Estate of Dr. McCormick is the 1st Judicial District Court for Caddo Parish, Louisiana.

This judgment constitutes the basis of the plaintiffs' appeal.

In their appeal, the plaintiffs assert the following assignments of error:

1) Whether the district court has excepted to plaintiff's right and cause of action on the basis of Robert McCartney's felony Conviction for second degree murder of September 30, 1995?
2) Whether the district court refused ALL PLAINTIFFS a review by erroneously believing the Petition for Nullification is actually Robert McCartney attempting to seek post conviction relief when all parties could not seek relief by post conviction?
3) Whether the known use of false testimony and evidence, violation of Due Process, a Public Trust, Oath of Office, Malfeasance and nonfeasance of office, obstruction of justice, filing false public record, injuring public records, clear violation of procedural and Constitutional law, etc., state a Cause of Action?
4) Whether a cause of action is determined where one resided and died or where the crime and violation took place—filing of false public record, injuring public record, committed perjury, obstructed justice, etc.?
5) Whether third parties have grounds to seek redress by Complaint and Petition for Nullification where public trust is violated, oath of office is violated, fraud and ill practice is used, etc., depriving them their loved one in violation of both procedural and Constitutional law?
6) Whether a suit can be dismissed by "DEFENDANT'S FAILURE" to show Cause of Action rather than plaintiff's failure?

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
974 So. 2d 854, 2008 WL 239558, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/mccartney-v-mccormick-lactapp-2008.