McCarter, Lethaniel Lee

CourtTexas Supreme Court
DecidedNovember 23, 2015
DocketWR-84,150-01
StatusPublished

This text of McCarter, Lethaniel Lee (McCarter, Lethaniel Lee) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Texas Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
McCarter, Lethaniel Lee, (Tex. 2015).

Opinion

QQ\>:@./\/o. mci zl-o\ . ._ '; \';>< …Tzz %WSD 0

' RECE|VED |N CC)URT OF CR|M|NAL APPEALS

}LET H m\/:ec, LEE /\/\<;QART’E"\°§ NOV 23 2015

,»" '~ »"'

CGO P\T GF C.Rl/\/\:/\/ MlAQQSta,C\erk ¢\QPEAL; w /TF:H\§

RE§P<>/\/§e l/\/ <>PODSITIOI\/ Tf> TH~E >W\TE'§ MGP{>§ED

Fl/\/GI/\/G>g 'L§€ FA<;T§ 6a Cc>)\/c_w&lc))\/ C>F L~A \/U -

APPHCM+ wm &\m>w 1';\\@ H~cr\c>m\&\€, Cc>uf+ +)w<>, F@l\cm)m§ Fc:rcjr£ m §u(>@oc£ 0!\: @\i§ »§€_.J[>\\{ bp`lep'

r_-

j_d A»P(>l(<;&n+ 0105€.<;+& ~EC> ~`rficb\ C_ouv\$€_l/S (€S{)GY\SQ, Fc>r ' (\M c>k;§ec_~¥m% +O §+c\;¥@.'$ /V\{SC\_Q§>|(€,Q..+{N\ 0\? +%C I;LUQ §§ F&c+ieg m C_`\@smg chume.n.+ cum Q§;@H§ wm wm QMSQA alanv ms §@i\c@cx +@ adams b'-\Wliwn+'$ Qlcqm MM +he 5+0&€, “n/\\'s a.,§){>l.'ed +h@

\@Lu,) mg Q@Jl\`a§, +O ~+h@ Q&SQ. EX omle We,l\oorr\/

185 S,W; ad 3@\1~3% S+cw+e§/" Tm@\ Q@@m@,\ mu:+ howe c~; firm Cc>m MY\M& 0€ MW. goue…'m `\C\L@ \Q~Q_ ?C>f€, l: 4')@&\@.\,1) 9

\/€C! C

P(?_>.lc:@n\\mo@§

f 5

Q.PECC_+\\)Q, &§Si&%o\x\ac "’ T\~\'cp\ Cczon§e,\ S%O\J\~Q._-S §\/\ 5\\'3 @,YP\'&cn/i+ +hcdv, "lr\' +ha _$+a}e m€v\“r, 5'5\@ %+cdce; gm ; 5kch ix ms m*cem? 50 '&Q+ 503@<'\/\€.¢' W|/\,\'C\q 1 uNYQ§ Slm>c>c§ 553 vY\eeL_r\. "<'\f\Q, B+CEFQ E€H: H\Q_ \c»,u) 0§ 9&€4`\€_§ umwa '{\05 G\M>mc?-'m`cdre_ m 5\\`\3 CC\S€.‘" §A@?l\'a@w+ O\SSQH£ J<'>wc,dt +hB OW\\`§,§{C>/\ b\/ 555ch 'CC>U\SQ,\ §mc>u\>$ H\Q H~cmo¢&\&\e Q<:>u FJC +h&i"“_ )Ffi&/\ C_c>uw$€,l C<>_\)\OX 5\05 l/\a\'\)€, been ko@$£{bl\/ \ pfdif\g-QH+U\+(@Y\_ +c; MQ S+Od'c€’§ C_\o;&r\j Qr§@m@n+ beacwge. +hQ, 350-dca m amw+ +c>\d H\Q dow +hcdr 15 £\fe(\ "\¥ ~°c\\@,y 'k>€.'\{£u»e& Jv`hadr 1/5_€9\{@&\/\.'+@00~£~_- Chasim§ &€+U H\Q mbh\ev MU\ 5\€_ was S+[l\ Cjui\+j uY\é\ev VY)Q, l&u) 051 par+\'_e§ 50€,&@05@ ha way

m P@;;Q.Ss\`<>(\ §§ /\J\S. /mc\,c+m Pr@\>w/'f Th@ $+cdre>.- w€n'lv M§)…` mm ~Me. Sor\! C?\

iam 65 PCJ+\`€.§ c»v\é\ aj irm end 05 €X©\am"\n £+ `-~ v1`°(>\65 H\Q, Sur\/,€( H\Nd 53\/ 5\'\§ §56¢\(, 159 5\)&+ S€€>_ +')5»\`$ QL)\/ 665 §§ 00 u_)`r\'€€&, mm Oq v him mud 5th

hQ pm¥\`€_lp@jr€£ IV\ ..+5\($ 1051 Ol@?r\`w`@ /\/\S»/l/\cwjv(/\~¢ 05 `Y\QF CQ\\, her M&.K& QJ¢B.»Q.G_SQ, |qgr Q&gh QJ\C\

C_Q_,l\ phOnQ_w 80 hQ:S 3(.)\,14’)// (_")`J/`\\] wO\-’\/ \/C)U 3 [t.é€:‘l_ (JQ l QOD+:`Y\U€, Q')/\ `L/)QH 506 ‘ v

550 5 0005'5550@ \5¢

“ ( `5/05 5.5 536 53& \&3> 5555(5 §0§_5 5>€_101@ 551@31>1\( 5151€155 555 50 0055510.1005<; 55\Q, 35005€, 5055`5 55\0 §511~\[ “ WQ__

150555 5\0511. 50 5510\1€, 0\1€1\[/\5551§ 55'5005 55&1@€151@5 551005

155%555 WQ §0§5 55&\1€_ 50 95051& 551€05 55€. C55.C555 051` 550 510003 05_ 9055\/ 50 \5: (_ \10\ .5,. PC;>. 5&8>. 30 515510\

C051553@,5/ 1655>0115@_ 5501155 550 50055`1511€5 5550 &50,5@, 105 5550 50500 055 90155`1,_; 51003 1505 00111"005‘1015€, 555 55\5`§ COM, 53 0050801<5 0055 1,…555@555 155015-5**-" 5001@\55$@ 5550 §50050 050§05 505€.55/ 1055 1505 500 50511' 01 9015505 51000$ 0,5>5>105>150_050 50 555<2, C,QSQ 0000115`0 55501` 0015551\\5@@5 50 §51€€,$ 55 &0€5 5551§1£ 5:)€€,051§€1 55\@5 55155§0011>55@15 510 5000 05 500155€3 50 55510 Co\,&@,~ .`51)555055 50~5155€(5 55\& 0511`\/_§ 5500'58505”5 115005(5159,¢,

15 CC5 1111 311'~5 1510 01 11515@§1 10151€; 1101 000 13 1501 00 1015/ 50 0015 051€11$€_ 005501 5550 00151\15\5385015 01 5551 011€555@_ 500 1111)&5 51155 - 5005\ 05 551 C\51C51115§5c01\c@5 00<;0151555 511101@,/-_,

550~55159 010l 010 1510 001151155'0;5'015 01 5551, 051015§0,

506 5 <;01551051€. fm 15055 95

5>(;>. 5 C0155`515\1€. 5 '

. \5/' l 0 ' 1551155‘10155 0015511\0_% 555005 5551 5000§500§€» 51&@0 515 1051 3500051 §§ 510 0011\5053005 000 05101. 15-~ 055@503 1501 1551 001 5555‘3@0111)55‘@0 5551 50001 _5)0155'15 50 55512. C&SQ, 50110030 51 5551 §-5515 y _ 5 511\5"`1\1115 555005 1555>5>55'001155 wm Qh&&;'ng CLW_`V 1550 10505>11 1510 551111 53 150 5003§5`505&01001 115<;15“-1111155@151” 100555 5\0511 \0€1,5”5 050 53015\1 10 5551/ 10515)-11\/ l:;::j E\/51511510 1150&5 05500) 55100'5 005 551 5515111051 55\1 05505$€. 5501 50555€.5 50€1@ 050+5513 5001.55\11, 1001/5

C®m+F55)O55[53 30515’5@ 15)@(5 »5-0®®§(5$ `55552_ -`Q»X`€.El£)'5`('©nv 05 55115`1 00515155505\ 90150§1 1 300 T>(. 0.0.5.015.?)5’5‘5

701 01€050 <:51'15 1505 010\1€. 5515105 /51)5>55'001155 0011@5 -j 555@, 105053€1 5\0515 0\_ Qc)mmmf\ 53015960@» @@CCW$Q/ ` 511`005 000\0£15 00\50\1010 5551 351/050 50 5Y51‘S5C0055 151 1155 131 555001)115'159 1551 1050 01 15551511 m 551 §'511\/ 1550§531/. 1415>15`1,05155 5000 0310§5'051555/ 55011151;5 50\1 515'005 1000015'3“ 50155`€_5'," 555<11 1551 555:051515@5515 01€1€ 5505 515\0105)01 5501 1550 5511\1 U¢'@|CbeQS ®W`/ 1 §1005515€, 01 000515'5;505@, 15@55) 1@@11 55@15/515 105105511

Q/C,C,L)SS€(§" 55 551`5/050513 &5555 01555501_15»1'55€115 506(.05113@ 93 5 C0155’51151@015 150<5~5'6-5

PC»>.\ Cl>n¥»{\\)@_\

\)/ ‘ .

ThQ_ &lrc~:“ejg m+ `Q\)i§mce, imc/dr " ADP\ i CQ\M A;+@,m@ m mm…'§ way wm \NQ,… pr@,mga£@~l bea&&>§@, ¥mzr@, wm mo -A\)tOM\QO~ Hvu“ Apv\£c&\/H* w€\$ ever m 9033@,&3‘\00 ,@% \r\@.r ws@. TY\-i; …’ver&@Q+-»'ov\ -- gmn@d ¥h.,@ mfva @§ +\/m 5\»4 w b@\ce,@m\§ Ag)p`\i &>W©Y*v iii 606 M\Q, §0{€,30\“3 .FUJSO\\S.

1 0103@@3¢ jre +`Y\f¢ -+~v\‘od Coun§@\/; AH\'¢\@_\)£+.

@C»,., Q 4\0@316\3{ ¢\o<>\\wvf <>m<»_@+g w wm Q<>L><\S@_\i@ MW\SQ~ F@“

"‘ m:>% c>b§ec¥m_<) w Pr\xz,§\)r\[ Q,\m&<%& mW@C€/%L)QSMY\ O;. \e,;sev m<;'\u(§

lmm §&mjra§%"'._ AQ@I.'Q@M 'C;@r\cec§

f$ S+}\\ hi§ d\\&?@v\$eo H@\D mem irm f@Q@cd A@e§~`

Y\(>jr. Q,.@Fr@bmodr@ +f\`@\ 4600¥\£@\:§ Q`.,-l\e§vo;+n`on .j(-'hcdf /in§>l.'war @L)\\\/ `\Mex\c\,m£ m WS 9053@35{0/\ 40 M O@|{Q'€,. -

.. H@,;) C@n¢m\)»@ c>\m.es(+(?€>~

g£>c/).a ;§mm@

1+ was wis m¥\\ c\Mev 4th QH\`Q€F &5\& 6&0\ MQ\@<;KQNS, did.\fm>\f)`\iW@C%S 'Hm H\QOF\/ @E‘ TMH m+ A\o\)@v\/ 16 Vm §\)r\{ -m\.ie\)ed H\..§mg wm irm mbh-er md APPMQM+ P.'QK€(;\ UO H\Q ‘{¥€nq$ HW€ (`@§Jb@(` (M“@QQQ(` L/L)\n_@y\ MP\D\K:O»HWL maj QUFS m§_ Y\WY\. Tr\`a,\ c:c;»on$e\/$ \Pcese\w+€d 00 €,\)\AQU\QQ/H)

jim 5\”\) \3\>"¢ O~ 'S\f\if+ uman w +h€, MQ!\`QM_*Y.IJF m&o\d howe been Jvr\`<@\ SHC\+Q%\(\ J¢<> @\@g@@,+ )F-@

H\.Q, S\)N <;hoq.%€, amd mY\ §er @\_ag.§e,r mclu&ecl

Q>EMV\SQ, 05 +heH am QL_ A~Q, w/)SQ_ irc +h@fA@§. (l@\@be¢\(, "NPI»'QQA»% -Lle@rl\/' wc>u`\& wm &CQQ,P¥@A 1000 ""' §¢~)1')¥§/ §§ /U\€,H FC-\.¥\AQ€ H”)O)\r\ *Hl`&l C.`oul/Ue,l-

{Mrh"n€)' @_,\l hf§d\[é)§ gm Pr\€. +C\BD\Q Q>Y\\\(SL,\)(U-- ibm \\)- ,+m @\s>+r@n +@ @;AA @Q;@@\»;m+ 9@£1+~/@1¢ m>% gm“… 06 543<3‘ QCMJQ(\/, AQP\\'Q@M @35@€+$

jrhodv» § L)_§+ beacx\)sq irr{al CQw/\.SQ.\ SC¢/S H w&$ +rrc\~\ S+r@j€,§\[ 40 nmb @Lz>§ec.+ 40 +M SQM dwij

C\‘Q c@n+moe,@m me)<+@@_

i.m:W-i

GM\' €§'r(ib§@,c_% @PC> +r\`.&l C@ov\£@\/§ AFG\AQ,vLJc._

f

J/

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
McCarter, Lethaniel Lee, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/mccarter-lethaniel-lee-tex-2015.