Maurice Salem v. Illinois Attorney Registration and Discipinary Com

Seventh Circuit

Maurice Salem v. Illinois Attorney Registration and Discipinary Com

CourtCourt of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit

DecidedSeptember 28, 2023

Docket22-3222

StatusPublished

This text of Maurice Salem v. Illinois Attorney Registration and Discipinary Com (Maurice Salem v. Illinois Attorney Registration and Discipinary Com) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Maurice Salem v. Illinois Attorney Registration and Discipinary Com, (7th Cir. 2023).

Pincite

Opinion

In the

United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKP

#@P66M7666P @ AP !#)7%%!!#)AP

+2P

" AP ('P M !"'(&(#&AP"P# P"P"*) P$('AP ##)(7%%!!(@P KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKP

9!9#9#9 ##"9"#!#9$!#9!9#9 !#!9"#!#99"49"#!9%"39 39.,77,10/-989 439 KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKP

65A6467O 6

#&P AP AP"PA9'*)9 *(@P A9'*)9 *@P "P6447P )&P @P !P&M *PP "'P(#P$&(P +P"P +P#&@PP$$ P#&P !''#"P"P "#'P(##P)(P+'P()&"P#+"@P(P(+"P 6448P "P 645=P P !"("P "P (*P $&(P "P "#'AP +&PP&''AP(&#)P$&!''#"P(#P$$&9%'$99+O 6P #@P66M7666P

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

!AP +#P "#+P ''P (P & P )&-P (#P '&P +(P (P '((P #)&(H'P '$#'(#"AP P "#(P #P !' P "-P *#&'P +"PP"#&P(P$((#"P"P #+P &"H'P&)!"('P (#P#P)""'+&P"P(P'((H'P'(P#)&(@PP P#P#$M $#'(#"P!-P,$ "P(P#)&(H'P P((P(PP"#(P"P(#P +&(P"P#$"#"P&'# *"PP#"('(P!3&@P !H'P & P ')(AP 'P #"P 86P @@@P L5=<7AP ''P #&P !#"-P!'P(#P#!$"'(P!P#&P#(P(P')'$"'#"P #&&P E+P &!"'P "P #&FP "P #+P (PP 'P M '&P((P')'$"'#"@P ('P+'(P'(('BP #@P66M7666P 7P

!39 9"9"99 &9!9$#9&"9%!9"997 "399"49&%!49#99&9*999$#(49 "49 !9 "%!9 (!"39 9 $ !9 $!#9 9 "9 "$"7 99!9#(9("99$#9$!#!9!!99#9$!#9 !9""#(99"9$#9#9#9 $9"99"9&7 (!39

!P#"("'P((P(P+#&PI'#"'( -JP"P('P'&$M (#"P'P 'P"P!"("'P((P$&"$ 'P#P%) P$&#((#"P "P')'("(*P)P$&#''P"(( P!P(#P& @PP#'P"#(P $&'"(P"-P !P)"&P'((P(#&(P +AP"#&P'PP'PP'((P #)&(P(#P&(P(PP(#P"P(P+'(H'P ")@P P& P')(PP"#(P#P+ P#&P !@PP)P'M !''P(P#"P(P$ "'AP&) "P((P(P'(&(P#)&(P 'P )&'(#"P(#P&*+P(P'((P)$&!P#)&(H'P'#"P"P ((P(P'((P#)&(H'P'#"P')$$ 'P P(P''P"P#&P (PH'P#P#P ")@P6466P@@P'(@P P65684

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

In the

United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKP

#@P66M7666P @ AP !#)7%%!!#)AP

+2P

" AP ('P M !"'(&(#&AP"P# P"P"*) P$('AP ##)(7%%!!(@P KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKP

9!9#9#9 ##"9"#!#9$!#9!9#9 !#!9"#!#99"49"#!9%"39 39.,77,10/-989 439 KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKP

65A6467O 6

#&P AP AP"PA9'*)9 *(@P A9'*)9 *@P "P6447P )&P @P !P&M *PP "'P(#P$&(P +P"P +P#&@PP$$ P#&P !''#"P"P "#'P(##P)(P+'P()&"P#+"@P(P(+"P 6448P "P 645=P P !"("P "P (*P $&(P "P "#'AP +&PP&''AP(&#)P$&!''#"P(#P$$&9%'$99+O 6P #@P66M7666P

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

!AP +#P "#+P ''P (P & P )&-P (#P '&P +(P (P '((P #)&(H'P '$#'(#"AP P "#(P #P !' P "-P *#&'P +"PP"#&P(P$((#"P"P #+P &"H'P&)!"('P (#P#P)""'+&P"P(P'((H'P'(P#)&(@PP P#P#$M $#'(#"P!-P,$ "P(P#)&(H'P P((P(PP"#(P"P(#P +&(P"P#$"#"P&'# *"PP#"('(P!3&@P !H'P & P ')(AP 'P #"P 86P @@@P L5=<7AP ''P #&P !#"-P!'P(#P#!$"'(P!P#&P#(P(P')'$"'#"P #&&P E+P &!"'P "P #&FP "P #+P (PP 'P M '&P((P')'$"'#"@P ('P+'(P'(('BP #@P66M7666P 7P

!39 9"9"99 &9!9$#9&"9%!9"997 "399"49&%!49#99&9*999$#(49 "49 !9 "%!9 (!"39 9 $ !9 $!#9 9 "9 "$"7 99!9#(9("99$#9$!#!9!!99#9$!#9 !9""#(99"9$#9#9#9 $9"99"9&7 (!39

!P#"("'P((P(P+#&PI'#"'( -JP"P('P'&$M (#"P'P 'P"P!"("'P((P$&"$ 'P#P%) P$&#((#"P "P')'("(*P)P$&#''P"(( P!P(#P& @PP#'P"#(P $&'"(P"-P !P)"&P'((P(#&(P +AP"#&P'PP'PP'((P #)&(P(#P&(P(PP(#P"P(P+'(H'P ")@P P& P')(PP"#(P#P+ P#&P !@PP)P'M !''P(P#"P(P$ "'AP&) "P((P(P'(&(P#)&(P 'P )&'(#"P(#P&*+P(P'((P)$&!P#)&(H'P'#"P"P ((P(P'((P#)&(H'P'#"P')$$ 'P P(P''P"P#&P (PH'P#P#P ")@P6466P@@P'(@P P65684

'((P "P +P I(P !(P *P "P &#)(J@P PP 'P $&(P#P(P'((P#P "#'CP(P#'P"#(P#P)'"''P"P "P "P 'P "*&P P "'P +(P !P (&@P !AP +#P #'P"#(P!"(#"PL5848P"P'P#$""P&PE"P#'P"#(P'M )''P(P& *"(P ")P"P'P&$ -P&FAP 'P"-P P ')$$#&(P#&P(P$&#$#'(#"P((PP'(&(P)P"P#&&P(P P(#P"P(' P"P "@P $$&"( -P !P *'P ((P P '%) /P '(&(P )P"P'"P(P ((#"P"-+&@PP#'P"#(P')$$ -P (&P )(#&(-P #&P &)!"(P #&P ('P "#* P $&#$#'(#"@P P P"#(P#(&P(#P#P(P P&'&P(#P'#*&P#+P& P #)&('P$&#P+"P P#PP'(&(H'P)'P&P'%) /@P "P"#"P#P(P)'P'P* AP(PP )P#P(P #)&(P#P$$ 'P+ P'"(PP)P&#!P"#(&P'(&(P +("P (P &)(P (#P &'# *P (P '@P 6

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

&@P E !P '#P P )(P P "#(P )'P "P #$$#&()"(-P (#P $&'"(P'P&)!"('P(#P(P)$&!P#)&(P#P "#'@FP 'P#&P(P%) M$&#((#"P(#&-BP !P'&'P!M ' P 'P P I ''P #P #"JP +#P 'P "P *(!.P -P (P H'P ! @P 'P $$&'P (#P P )'(P &() P $ "P #P P !(#"P(#&-AP+P'P"#P'#)"&P)"&P(P%) P&#M ((#"P )'P ("P )"&P (P )P &#''P )'@P (P P *"('APP&(#" P''P')2'P#&P$) P('P "P)"M &P(P%) P&#((#"P )'AP'P!!$,'$$ 9+29!AP96

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

!P '&*P '#*&-P &%)'('P #"P #$$#'"P #)"' P "P P $""P'@P(P P(#PP#!$ "(P"P'$ "P#&P)"M )(#&.P $&(P #P +@P E !P ''&(P ((P P "H(P "#+P((P'&*"P'#*&-P&%)'('P#"'(()('P(P$&(P #P +@PP#)&(P"H(P *P!O"#&P+'P(P,)'PM %)(P *"P P !P +'P 'P "#&"(P 'P P $&#''@FP P *P&*#P'P&(P(#P$&(P"P(P*"(P&)(@P"P #2 'P "P +P #&AP *"P &"P +(P +'P $$""AP ')'$"P !H'P&(P(#P$&(P(&@P 0'9$9!"AP5=8P @@7P64PE @@P6465F@P(P')'$"'#"P&!"'P"P#&@P$M '#(BP !P'P"#(P)(#&.P(#P$&(P +P"P +P#&AP"P "#'AP"P(P*"(P&)(AP#&P"P(P #&(&"P'(&(P#P "#'@P)(PP#"(")'P(#P/ P$'(&#)'P')('P#"P'P#+"P AP#P+P('P#"P'P"P,!$ @P !H'P* P#P&*# #)'P')('P!)'(P'(#$@PP'"M (#"'P!$#'P"9())9$90'P"9!!#P+&P'"P(#P '#)&P&*# #)'P ((#"P-P!"P('P#")(P#'( -AP )(P((P#'P"#(P+#&PP !P()!'P'P"#'P(P(P#)&(P "P 'P(#P$-@P ((#"P"P&%)&P(-P#)( -'P&#!PM ""('AP,$"''P((P(-P'#) P"#(PP#&P(#P&P)"M ''PP')(P$&'"('P$ )' P !'@P !P!)'(P,$ "P+-P (#" P'"(#"'O" )"P3#&"-'HP'P"P/"" P $" ('O'#) P"#(PP!$#'P"P('P'@PP!)'(P)"M &'("P((AP)" ''PP$-'P P#)('(""P/"'P"P+&'P #P'AP$ )'P"-P(#" P+&P"P('P'AP+P+ P'')P "P#&&P)"&P*%%$')9.()"(9 #)'#)$#!39 #29+29 AP89P @7P 5<9P E;(P &@P 5==9FAP ((P $&#(('P #(&P $&'#"'P -P $&M *"("P!P&#!P/ "P#&P$)&')"P"-P* P')(P)"( P P#)(M '(""P+&'P*P"P'('/@P P '(&(P #)&(H'P )!"(P 'P 2&!@P !P 'P 58P -'P(#P'#+P)'P+-PP'#) P"#(PP')(P(#P'"(#"'AP #@P66M7666P 55P

" )"P"P#&&P(#P$-P(P""('HP3#&"-'HP'AP)"M &P@P@P$$@P@P7<@P

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

Maurice Salem v. Illinois Attorney Registration and Discipinary Com, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/maurice-salem-v-illinois-attorney-registration-and-discipinary-com-ca7-2023.