Maurice Salem v. Illinois Attorney Registration and Discipinary Com

Seventh Circuit

Maurice Salem v. Illinois Attorney Registration and Discipinary Com

Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit·Decided September 28, 2023·No. 22-3222·Published

Opinion

In the

United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKP

#@P66M7666P @ AP !#)7%%!!#)AP

+2P

" AP ('P M !"'(&(#&AP"P# P"P"*) P$('AP ##)(7%%!!(@P KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKP

9!9#9#9 ##"9"#!#9$!#9!9#9 !#!9"#!#99"49"#!9%"39 39.,77,10/-989 439 KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKP

65A6467O 6

#&P AP AP"PA9'*)9 *(@P A9'*)9 *@P "P6447P )&P @P !P&M *PP "'P(#P$&(P +P"P +P#&@PP$$ P#&P !''#"P"P "#'P(##P)(P+'P()&"P#+"@P(P(+"P 6448P "P 645=P P !"("P "P (*P $&(P "P "#'AP +&PP&''AP(&#)P$&!''#"P(#P$$&9%'$99+O 6P #@P66M7666P

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

!AP +#P "#+P ''P (P & P )&-P (#P '&P +(P (P '((P #)&(H'P '$#'(#"AP P "#(P #P !' P "-P *#&'P +"PP"#&P(P$((#"P"P #+P &"H'P&)!"('P (#P#P)""'+&P"P(P'((H'P'(P#)&(@PP P#P#$M $#'(#"P!-P,$ "P(P#)&(H'P P((P(PP"#(P"P(#P +&(P"P#$"#"P&'# *"PP#"('(P!3&@P !H'P & P ')(AP 'P #"P 86P @@@P L5=<7AP ''P #&P !#"-P!'P(#P#!$"'(P!P#&P#(P(P')'$"'#"P #&&P E+P &!"'P "P #&FP "P #+P (PP 'P M '&P((P')'$"'#"@P ('P+'(P'(('BP #@P66M7666P 7P

!39 9"9"99 &9!9$#9&"9%!9"997 "399"49&%!49#99&9*999$#(49 "49 !9 "%!9 (!"39 9 $ !9 $!#9 9 "9 "$"7 99!9#(9("99$#9$!#!9!!99#9$!#9 !9""#(99"9$#9#9#9 $9"99"9&7 (!39

!P#"("'P((P(P+#&PI'#"'( -JP"P('P'&$M (#"P'P 'P"P!"("'P((P$&"$ 'P#P%) P$&#((#"P "P')'("(*P)P$&#''P"(( P!P(#P& @PP#'P"#(P $&'"(P"-P !P)"&P'((P(#&(P +AP"#&P'PP'PP'((P #)&(P(#P&(P(PP(#P"P(P+'(H'P ")@P P& P')(PP"#(P#P+ P#&P !@PP)P'M !''P(P#"P(P$ "'AP&) "P((P(P'(&(P#)&(P 'P )&'(#"P(#P&*+P(P'((P)$&!P#)&(H'P'#"P"P ((P(P'((P#)&(H'P'#"P')$$ 'P P(P''P"P#&P (PH'P#P#P ")@P6466P@@P'(@P P65684

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

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

In the

United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKP

#@P66M7666P @ AP !#)7%%!!#)AP

+2P

" AP ('P M !"'(&(#&AP"P# P"P"*) P$('AP ##)(7%%!!(@P KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKP

9!9#9#9 ##"9"#!#9$!#9!9#9 !#!9"#!#99"49"#!9%"39 39.,77,10/-989 439 KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKP

65A6467O 6

#&P AP AP"PA9'*)9 *(@P A9'*)9 *@P "P6447P )&P @P !P&M *PP "'P(#P$&(P +P"P +P#&@PP$$ P#&P !''#"P"P "#'P(##P)(P+'P()&"P#+"@P(P(+"P 6448P "P 645=P P !"("P "P (*P $&(P "P "#'AP +&PP&''AP(&#)P$&!''#"P(#P$$&9%'$99+O 6P #@P66M7666P

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

!AP +#P "#+P ''P (P & P )&-P (#P '&P +(P (P '((P #)&(H'P '$#'(#"AP P "#(P #P !' P "-P *#&'P +"PP"#&P(P$((#"P"P #+P &"H'P&)!"('P (#P#P)""'+&P"P(P'((H'P'(P#)&(@PP P#P#$M $#'(#"P!-P,$ "P(P#)&(H'P P((P(PP"#(P"P(#P +&(P"P#$"#"P&'# *"PP#"('(P!3&@P !H'P & P ')(AP 'P #"P 86P @@@P L5=<7AP ''P #&P !#"-P!'P(#P#!$"'(P!P#&P#(P(P')'$"'#"P #&&P E+P &!"'P "P #&FP "P #+P (PP 'P M '&P((P')'$"'#"@P ('P+'(P'(('BP #@P66M7666P 7P

!39 9"9"99 &9!9$#9&"9%!9"997 "399"49&%!49#99&9*999$#(49 "49 !9 "%!9 (!"39 9 $ !9 $!#9 9 "9 "$"7 99!9#(9("99$#9$!#!9!!99#9$!#9 !9""#(99"9$#9#9#9 $9"99"9&7 (!39

!P#"("'P((P(P+#&PI'#"'( -JP"P('P'&$M (#"P'P 'P"P!"("'P((P$&"$ 'P#P%) P$&#((#"P "P')'("(*P)P$&#''P"(( P!P(#P& @PP#'P"#(P $&'"(P"-P !P)"&P'((P(#&(P +AP"#&P'PP'PP'((P #)&(P(#P&(P(PP(#P"P(P+'(H'P ")@P P& P')(PP"#(P#P+ P#&P !@PP)P'M !''P(P#"P(P$ "'AP&) "P((P(P'(&(P#)&(P 'P )&'(#"P(#P&*+P(P'((P)$&!P#)&(H'P'#"P"P ((P(P'((P#)&(H'P'#"P')$$ 'P P(P''P"P#&P (PH'P#P#P ")@P6466P@@P'(@P P65684

'((P "P +P I(P !(P *P "P &#)(J@P PP 'P $&(P#P(P'((P#P "#'CP(P#'P"#(P#P)'"''P"P "P "P 'P "*&P P "'P +(P !P (&@P !AP +#P #'P"#(P!"(#"PL5848P"P'P#$""P&PE"P#'P"#(P'M )''P(P& *"(P ")P"P'P&$ -P&FAP 'P"-P P ')$$#&(P#&P(P$&#$#'(#"P((PP'(&(P)P"P#&&P(P P(#P"P(' P"P "@P $$&"( -P !P *'P ((P P '%) /P '(&(P )P"P'"P(P ((#"P"-+&@PP#'P"#(P')$$ -P (&P )(#&(-P #&P &)!"(P #&P ('P "#* P $&#$#'(#"@P P P"#(P#(&P(#P#P(P P&'&P(#P'#*&P#+P& P #)&('P$&#P+"P P#PP'(&(H'P)'P&P'%) /@P "P"#"P#P(P)'P'P* AP(PP )P#P(P #)&(P#P$$ 'P+ P'"(PP)P&#!P"#(&P'(&(P +("P (P &)(P (#P &'# *P (P '@P 6

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

&@P E !P '#P P )(P P "#(P )'P "P #$$#&()"(-P (#P $&'"(P'P&)!"('P(#P(P)$&!P#)&(P#P "#'@FP 'P#&P(P%) M$&#((#"P(#&-BP !P'&'P!M ' P 'P P I ''P #P #"JP +#P 'P "P *(!.P -P (P H'P ! @P 'P $$&'P (#P P )'(P &() P $ "P #P P !(#"P(#&-AP+P'P"#P'#)"&P)"&P(P%) P&#M ((#"P )'P ("P )"&P (P )P &#''P )'@P (P P *"('APP&(#" P''P')2'P#&P$) P('P "P)"M &P(P%) P&#((#"P )'AP'P!!$,'$$ 9+29!AP96

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

" )"P"P#&&P(#P$-P(P""('HP3#&"-'HP'AP)"M &P@P@P$$@P@P7<@P

Maurice Salem v. Illinois Attorney Registration and Discipinary Com, (7th Cir. 2023).

Pincite

Maurice Salem v. Illinois Attorney Registration and Discipinary Com (Maurice Salem v. Illinois Attorney Registration and Discipinary Com) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.