Martin v. Schwing Lumber & Shingle Co.

76 So. 2d 328, 1954 La. App. LEXIS 945
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedNovember 18, 1954
DocketNo. 3886
StatusPublished
Cited by2 cases

This text of 76 So. 2d 328 (Martin v. Schwing Lumber & Shingle Co.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Martin v. Schwing Lumber & Shingle Co., 76 So. 2d 328, 1954 La. App. LEXIS 945 (La. Ct. App. 1954).

Opinion

CAVANAUGH, Judge.

Plaintiff sued the defendant for a partition of North half of Northwest quarter and West half of Northeast quarter, Sec[329]*329tion 13, Township 3 South, Range 4 West, alleging that he and defendant were co-owners in division and in the portion of one-half interest each and that the property-should he partitioned in kind. Defendant answered the suit, denying plaintiff’s ownership in the land and affirmatively alleged that it owned the whole of the property. It averred that Schwing Lumber & Shingle Company, Ltd., on August 19, 1924, purchased a large tract of land from the West Feliciana Lumber Company, including the land described in plaintiff’s petition; that the land acquired- wa!s open swamp, or wild land and was subject to no other possession than cutting and' removing the timber therefrom; that after the purchase of the land by the Schwing Lumber & Shingle Company, Ltd. it went into possession of said land, had the lines established and cut and removed timber therefrom. That it is the successor of and vendee of Schwing Lumber & Shingle Company, Ltd. and that since its acquisition from the Schwing Lumber & Shingle Company, Ltd. it has had possession of said land, removed timber therefrom, has policed said land to prevent depredation thereon, leased the same for mineral development, paid the taxes, and that having acquired title to said land by a just title and having been in possession thereof for more than ten years it pled ten years ’ prescription acquirendi causa against any claim plaintiff had. Defendant prayed that it be decreed the owner of said land by virtue of its title and alternatively that the ten year plea of prescription be sustained.

After trial, the lower court sustained defendant’s plea of ten years prescription ac-quirendi causa and dismissed plaintiff’s suit.

The record shows that Thomas W. Rayn-ham acquired the land by patent from the State of Louisiana on December 23, 1876. He sold the property to Charles W. Leet and Edwin H. Leet on October- 13, 1883. Edwin H. Leet sold his undivided one-half interest to J. Hereford Percy on November 19, 1902. J. H. Percy sold his undivided one-half interest to Cat Island & Industrial Company, Ltd. on January 23j 1903. Cat Island & Industrial Company, Ltd. sold its undivided one-half interest in the land to Bayou Sara Lumber Company, Ltd. on March 30, 1912 and Bayou Sara Lumber Company, Ltd. conveyed to West Feliciana Lumber Company as per record in Notarial Book 30, page 330, filed for record May 15, 1918. The West Feliciana Lumber Company conveyed to Schwing Lumber & Shingle Company, Ltd. on August 19, 1924, the whole property. The description in the deed reads as follows:

“Also: The West half of the Northeast quarter Section 13, the Southeast quarter of the Northeast quarter of Section 13, the North half of the Northwest quarter of Section 13, the Southeast quarter of the Northeast quarter of Section 13, the West half of the Southwest quarter of Section 13, the East half of the Southeast quarter of Section 13. That portion of said Section 13 hereby described containing 400 acres; * * * all of the lands in this item described being in Township 3 South, of Range 4 West, in said Greenburg Land District, and Parish of West Feliciana,- State of Louisiana.”

The Schwing Lumber & Shingle Company, Inc. acquired all of the outstanding capital stóck of Schwing Lumber & Shingle Company, Ltd. on January 28, 1929, and subsequent to that date exercised all control and possession of the property of the Schwing Lumber & Shingle Company, Ltd., and on November 16, 1938, proceedings were initiated to technically liquidate the Schwing Lumber & Shingle Company, Ltd. and E. N. Taylor, Calvin K. Schwing and E. B. Schwing, Jr. were appointed liquidators of the corporation and said liquidators on December 28, 1938 conveyed' to the defendant the’ 400 acres of land situated in Section 13, Township 3 South, Range 4 West, that Schwing Lumber & Shingle Company, Ltd. had acquired from West Feliciana Lumber Company.

On July 11, 1941, defendant conveyed to Natalbany Lumber Company, Ltd. all cypress, ash, willow-, ¡túpelo gum and cottonwood timber, trees, wood and growth [330]*330twelve inches and above at the stump at the time of the cutting,, measured twelve inches above the ground and fallen timber and logs of said species no smaller in size and all red gum, sap gum, elm, sycamore, oak of all varieties, locust, hackberry, maple and pecan timber, trees, logs, wood and growth of above species, whether growing, standing or lying upon the following described lands:

“* * * West half Northeast quarter, Southeast quarter Northeast quarter, North half Northwest quarter, West half Southwest quarter, East half Southeast quarter, Section 13, Township 3 South, Range 4 West, (with other lands)”

for a consideration of $11,150.03. According to this timber deed, the timber on the entire acreage described in the deed had been estimated by Lemieux Brothers on September 15, 1929, and by H. M. Spain & Co., January 22, 1938. On September 5, 1941, Natalbany Lumber Company, Ltd. conveyed to King Edward Fuller Company, a partnership composed of G. H. King, J. B. Edwards and Parrish Fuller, the timber on the 360 acres of land which it had acquired from the defendant along with the timber on other lands adjacent, adjoining and neighboring to the land involved in this lawsuit. On February 10, 1947, the partnership of King Edward Fuller Company conveyed to King Lumber Industries, a Mississippi corporation domiciled in Madison County, Mississippi, the timber on the 360 acres of land which the partnership had acquired from the Natalbany Lumber Company along with the timber on other lands described- in that deed. On March 1, 1948, King Lumber Industries conveyed to King Lumber Industries, Inc. the timber rights which King Lumber Industries had acquired from King Edward Fuller Company to the timber on the above described lands.

The plaintiff’s record title is predicated on the tax sale made by the Sheriff of West Feliciana Parish to C. E. Thibodeaux dated July 28, 1917, under an assessment in the name of C. W. Leet, for the unpaid taxes of 1916.. The description in the tax deed reads as follows:

“97.80 acres of swamp land, being the undivided one-half of North half of Northwest quarter, and one-half Northeast quarter, Section 13, Township 3 South, Range 4 West, in the Sixth Ward of the Parish of West Feliciana, State of Louisiana.”

Deed from C. E. Thibodeaux to Leslie Smith dated April 29, 1920, deed from L. G. Smith to G. T. Barrow dated October 7, 1920, deed from G. T. Barrow to C. E. Thibodeaux dated April 25, 1923, deed from L. G. Smith to Charles E. Thibodeaux dated September 11, 1950, deed from Charles E. Thibodeaux to the plaintiff undated but filed for record January 22, 1951; and a correction deed dated October 30, 1952, between the same parties.

We will now discuss the possession exercised by the plaintiff and his authors in title to sustain his ownership of an undivided one-half interest in and to the land by virtue of the tax sale made to his vendor Charles E. Thibodeaux by J. H. Clack, Jr., Sheriff and Ex-Officio Tax Collector of West Feliciana Parish on July 28, 1917. The evidence of Charles E.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Allen v. Paggi Brothers Oil Company
244 So. 2d 116 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1971)
Martin v. Schwing Lumber & Shingle Co.
81 So. 2d 852 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1955)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
76 So. 2d 328, 1954 La. App. LEXIS 945, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/martin-v-schwing-lumber-shingle-co-lactapp-1954.