MALOUFF, CHARLES ANTHONY Jr.

Texas Supreme Court·Decided November 16, 2015·No. WR-82,475-03·Published

Opinion

-~~~·~)- ,.-~t

.'€32/415-oJ

~--------------------~------~-----~-~~ ll~l20\~~----­ ~0F ~-~--------------------------------~------­ ~~ Gt=='" ~Ml~N P..P~ Ot== ~~-------------------

-~· O. -~ \Z-?::Q._,£5"'--------------------------- RECEIVEDlN'__________ C-.b.J?tTI?L- ~~ON ICOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALS

~u-=:sn.r--.1 ,~? {Jb1ll NOV 16 2015 Abel Acosta, Clerk

l2e. : 'l'l [2.§ c..~~A.., fVl~E:Et<~lZ,________________________ ____,-',-'_k-"-"'-'',@ ~-~~-'0 · ~2s_l-lt0 .~~- \_5 -O:J:Z,~Cl2'~-~--

-~~ -- 1:------------------------------------------- ---~ /J\C(87Y ANQ· ~,.-To~ C!..D\..7tZJ"""" N'\.~---

- I

. • 012ll:::M-.l.t.L Fff..o~t~ ~~-lTIQN_~_ ~~ QE ~~~~-

To.~ ~ ¢..!:::' c.ou~ o_F-~~L_~_.._ _________________ . -

____-----".P.__Le-~ ~~ M":i-~~ mE- ~lCE_., __tv\:_r-..r~.---

~~ ~QT1o-..l'? ~ \~~~ {2gol+\_12tT' ~-S.­

-~ ~-~c::, J:.... --rt2-~ Jl.No CJOrza~ Ooe":(_oE_~'Y._ ....~_

1n+t~~ ~~~====~~==~*--------------~------~--------------­ ____.:;r: e12~~U>-t-~~~ !J_o~-~)..~,~~-t....t'--=---

-~ lf\..lG? ~ ~00~' ~0 ·C.:O_Ut,.l_~€:k,~ lV\..~--­ CQ.-()6~~ ~~-~-~~u? ~-~ v..l\LL- ~'"\ItS.

__ ~~-~--c ~ ~-~ _fM..l .__tt-J J:...I;:>o n:JJ~-;-&~

. .:c ~~ar:· ~1Ze'--'-~-~-~ c.r:teY_i_:s;. ~2e~u~-- _e@"~~r 'b AL£ ?:c~_tZl$0 c:n_~-~ ~'--{ ~wCZ.£2.6 . ____ . ~~'-!~ "LtD.s.J FO~ ~OJtZ. G.Q~~l_a~nVt--l_~o'------'----­

• ~~~l~CE' ,~ ·. n~...;:, ~~·-------:------------.---------- -----------------~~~~~~~~---------~~------- ------~--~--------~---c,-~~~~--=-·------------~--------~ ·------~-~------~----- --~-----~c~,~~~t..~lZ~'~ f::...,·M~ ~-e.

. . ,----=--..::._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

~~ .f'lo ~t~S9t:>

I

________:Lt\-Do w(lJJ._P.Ce. ~L. (2D

--~----~-~~~~--~J~~~--.~~·~·-~~·~·~·-~--~·~~~~~------~~---·

' '

•• I •

•~----~----------~---

..

.. '

···r=~ ',··-

.~·~~ ... ··.,.. ·.

( ----- --~~-~-~------

NG~

...:,

-------------------------

_ _ _ _:IQ__ ~"f\1£ .·

_ _ _ COJ\Zr -~_C£-lMI-~ ~2~---~~---­ ________cx=_~-~~

-----------------

-----'--''N--=.0&~~ ~_:___ ~FF",c:JQ.

--~0-=-ct~LQQ

<D\21G-At---t~~~~ -~il..:.D~ ~\t-J£..t\ l::£: M~P~'-'0

r6 ·Tl-tt T'l-M(2.0c::.DJ(2r ~ ~~~~t-.cJ!:LI.EE ~~LE~~<t:E _cn-f€__ ~~--

_ ___:~,-=

_ .~FF Ql:&:€,___ .~"':2_\D!Nb ·--- ---------~~--------

--------

c... - ------~ A... ~~ _~I"'? .0r:?~-c:=:::

----,~--,-,--t=-~~-

--~--------~·

~----~---~_r~--'~t::7J:bs=l_O

-- ----~-~_.__\'\:._____ __ ----~- --~---

--~-----~------

----·---~-------- -·--------

------·--·--·--------------- --- - --··-······-----··-··· ·-·-------- ----------------·----------·--·----------------·------··----

-- --~---··--------------

----·-----------··-------·-----------~---·---·-·- -----------

.-'-----.

---'--------,-----'---- _________ -----

~~~-------~~G?~#~-----~---------------------~---------

~-------lN \~~ 'A. M~_~F ~-~-~~--------

-----------~--------~----------------------

. '

-------~,~t~.-~IY-~--e~LJ~~~---------------

e~l 0_e._:, CL~ZUS0 ~. · M~ 1_...J~...~------------

,-~ NO. \~..__,10""--s=•'--q_._D~.'-------------------------

• ____2~ D~~=~~\'~--~-------------~--------------~- _ _2_\\Qo. ~ ~eo _______________ N~\1 A.:·'!:K7rb_, -n~)(pob ·:L/_?LidO~---

_ _c:C=-:.~<Z::F_,.j~CJ£ ' OF. ·n--+E c.Dv~ ~€-~'EF Q.D:::E t ~'\2tt-l~----- ---- P.o. eox 'z..s-t.t·l A..\bn N 1

~ -::JJ2/lL-'l_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

c~~~ ~. co~-;-'-~ -a::rz...."?:.__::~~~-

•----------~-----~~-~ I•.

-------------------------,----------------------~---.--------·-

•·~--~·-·- - - - - - - - - - - - - -

H~~ciE ~\'S"'::> ~ --'-~~o_E_~\JTI-4-~na~---------------~-- _bi~L'-a~ n+e ~ S' _S_\_~_eMEt-J~ -QE_~6Dl <..:t"'\D~ ~---- _l~P~~ I EL2 FQC?._~_:_\6'\N~-----------___;"=------ ----'--\o_6Q_~~e _:_ ~ --ro '"r'~"T'\~_o_~. ____ _g __ _

---~Qnor-.1? :n:J~ ~L____:_'L\:\-6_\ QJ tAL ~\QG~ 9-----

. .

_ ______,_~\_._c::..Q~t:J;::··~~ 'LO'"t~ g;noN Qt-.!-=---c___ _ _ g_

· - - - - -~aKJAL- Nm~L&~-~----'-----~----~----

l c;)F.. ~-~-----'----------------'·_Q__ ~~-OF, Q~\.J\E\N i_\ __ _ /M.'bl>M~-r' \~--- ~t~a..."-l ' l9 ___ - RzA~ - ___W __ Q..\JL6 ~.3----W) CJ:S'iL'Tl:F\~cvN ~\: __ _ , -'~""~ ::E);s~a~ ~~~\~~· OE ~-~~~------~--------

-~~Dl~~-----------'-----------------~­ ~A__cn_0LD.F tZ.lS="-E.LQ__~'Eb~\._\_~O.::J,_·- - - - - - , - - - - - - -

• ~.r_o~~~~%-lbl\L-- ~'2,'::\::ts -c'\J-.__.__t-.__ ·-· ------~~------------

. ~~.,. No~~~ • ~~IAL \.J..o'bC2~-·; --------- '-~-- '"7~-i sw ·u cos. q~·L~-\9~'------------------- .~oou~~o1 "'::> ,.., c...ow~ , q.s 9 .~~-z.a '2.'t-J-.L~ ~f"l"_oA.UA.~ \9s:i) __~__ C,.._p.v~N-ek\.~~_9_g_L~W 'Z.J ~1L~_~P.€LP~-,--&=19J t-~

~wNee.v ~r-.Js ~~L,c~Le..... ._ _ _ _ _ _ _--'--~---

1

~0\~~~ ~~~~ '~-------~-------- ~----- l

~-"' A CP~,__:__LQ9 E. zd \0~2..-~~\~,----.---------- __t'] __ _::u.:J. F.~ t~ ~s- =rn~ l9._~_5),_.--,-----

.tt-l' \ \'.!

e.& ~~~,l...._K... ,1 \1~'3d r"J~1 XJ5_l~~·--------'l ~ ~~-~,_L""b~~,_~'5B-~wa:i),______ H _lt-.l ~~' US"'~W3J 3_(o_G~~-~-~~-~~_!.l_tQ~~}____ j_t.. lsJ- ~Mu~,.._5~~\J_? ~~2~J~_(Jss5:.') · \~

t~~ ~Elk__ __ _ el~_w_z.l_at_z.:z_(_n:~~-~P G.O_~ c.~B.9:tlAZ- Mo~-~ B~~_s_Llls:l~_za_s-~~ . _____tz, W'bo.l ~~ y P~VcaP.,_8.2.~~ ·~~:3,'B~' -ll()_{_~_l9~Z.") ___\_\ . I ' ' ' •

w~"' "'-~ u= :~eosv" ,-~.e,~q u~--~-1-,_Co'l...L\~CJ~ _·\'?> ~"2_CO~:r::rn..k:tobl AIZ.T__.__l-_ _ _-,--------'---~---__;____-·· a_, \3 "'11!x.~ C.O~.t~n::C_\Jntnb.!-~_3 ___ q_ T6~-Co~~ ~______,'5'=-----------------'lr\'2...-IJ~ ~.A-? C...O~a.l M'J-:r, \5 ---~q __,J:Z.. - T~ &~~ti\~_.CDQE "S<EC. ~2.'2./L'Z-\ ' __g__ .e-r~~ bc:N~tl\~ ~ ~. (D'2..t05' _9 __ _ :r~~ ~CoO€ ~ ~.oz. _ ~{_1 _(2.-rL~- _ . ~~ fL. c..'"' .. Pwc.... ~ l0o. , 10 b ______ _9 ___ - T~ ~. ~tO~ AcQ.:r. 1l. ~ . '2.£) \ 4I f'2 I t& I

---- -;-----

·--~--~--------------­ "'"'ibT"\:4€_~~ ~~ oF_-n+E ce.~-'~c-~o£- ~~

~e? hl~ t-tZE~az,,_~_A., ~~.U'fF,~~'-r--J)JLA.

~~€ ~~ OJ~,_etzQ ~,-~~t'-J'b \MM.E,Df:iU,C f2B4\SF.;_ b..ND ·' 1'-i ~ lN~. OE ~~Tl~ .,.\\J?TI( &~-----------'---

lZe A"T'Q~ ~-~~---r_u_eo ~___:_eeo ~~lYtaL\~~L.o_ _

o~~'-'~.P"Y T~______c~ ~~_c:x:::,s.,_wt_n*_"S_D_Peoe:qNb___,_~M~ I

A.TIQ"-1_, bl--.JO e.EQJE'~_D_~~C€~~ ::r:HE_tZ£,~~ -

· B='"&S¢:.iDINb ~ui:J6:E.,_wt~- 6\)__e8dg:J:Jb3G D~U~aJJ:Ktl~ TO

~~ -1\\\ ~wAit t<S::t--:s ~ t:i2 ~;;:;.. ~ .ft:t"Af?4rt

• ~-~-~--~u~-~Y-~'-Je ~-. §Z.CPEQ ~ :'JE12_ -~D~ lN ~~-a ~-~~0~~~2-~-~=-----

------""~= =XJeg.,. ~-~-~ M_€\ W ~ ~\J.D.\ UN._ ~-US.~ IP\)e,~N& J::HE ~CE- ~~\MC¥f??0f2't:":-i_,_ ~e> ~ c::::.av\ ~ M\:>~c--e: ifF- ..)y-;mcg.. tae1 ~~-~-

.

W~ ~C§'FI\ -~~-.W-~:t:: \~ ~~ « \""=:> \~-- /.»-lQ_

l>~:2nTUn . ~b. • L '::-.!_~ N€:D \N' tB-~-u~~c>---~

--------------~~-----------------------------------

-\Za..A~_~l>C>-~~-o W t;TI-:i-_~-~ A--D~~~ ·-~-~c..€.JZ:n~., e.e~:ro.g.. ~ NOV bu\L:ty' ~ :,Ibi:E._ _ c~ ~D-~r.~~~ 'T'D_~M. · AL~f::4-.. \Nr=ici.Isr.lC18._,_-__ ·------------------------- ~D ~ ld:S~-~__::y\~U-~-OE f2.er7:.l..J&'T1ot=! ~D -;>El£<2.T-

\~ A.J-..)0 \J'iNt:::?\?TJ\J€ f'r?c:r:-t§¥'1 >TJOt--1·~----'--------------

___e.. . . =~~~ ~\J\Cl"a2 OF_~'Z-JI'J{;;. p:,_ ~­ s.,..._

-~:-:L~o_N · \.~_T::HE . 'l.lZA"} l? CD\.>~IY-~~ th DJ~~:>I\Zl~--- CoJe-T,_~UQb<E ~~t---1 ~e.. ~\Q.\Nb~ 0bl-¥r- ,b...JA;t_€12.

~'~'CXl.~._e_cEJ o~~ ~ ~~· c:S~ ~­

-~~ f::Jd>-1~ IZE~ toe :c.. '~onE:~ Al--P .C.O~W!E?\1\lQ:.b" ~ ~ ue~'"''='. ~~m~... :::s-~~____c_~­ e~:c£;~ ~-~~e~ ~~-Q I\.:tE_~E :rJsHC>}G._

• · ~· AL.IED /::>.. ~'VDQ}..L Ml~ UJM(JL?',\N"r -~ l~ :Jl±.E ~MM.\?~_QbS~~ ~'-.:>D\LJA} ._C..O.~QJ_cr ,_~ NO , _ C..L . . No,. \4---D_a'Zk-D L 1 _~_Z'ZG4- ~ ~-~~---­ ~~~- ~..., 1 _DI-$VV\\~ U0\~ \2~~~-""(b~--

. ' .

~~ ~Ll?SUlS iZ.fSM~ ,-.~L\-~ o-, ~J2t\ o_E___~---

'

~ill~;-~T Q'F_(0~n..... 'l>\ -~A.l..6 ~ ND,_~-e_- 87...,_. ~~ ·::SJ.L,-~~'D_&__Q'Q.Q ~ ~e_.e~M~ ~_eP ,_B~Q_ __ ' '

1t-S ~ -rt+teo CQ,z~ at'" ~~? 0-.1 tv\~ ~~,205_ _ _

1

ALL- ~~N(::, ~\JDL'bl tv\\~~ ~-~'-~--­

L~~~~- · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

----""'"~"'--'--~--=---~~ '~~-z.aY-::,_,~ ~ ~-'-~U~-\A~~~ lf'..t ~ c.oJfl:r, ?~IE..___:~~~-t~___r~~~-

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

MALOUFF, CHARLES ANTHONY Jr., (Tex. 2015).

MALOUFF, CHARLES ANTHONY Jr. (MALOUFF, CHARLES ANTHONY Jr.) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.