Magnum Magnetics Corp. v. United States

2023 CIT 140
United States Court of International Trade·Decided September 26, 2023·No. 22-00254·Published

Opinion

/s33  



"! !! "!!!!   "!  !   /%s16s**  8  "! !!  )*24))11s*)4,2)428)57(+)    )*)1(%16 27462    %1(   ! ! (&%    )*)1(%1616)48)124  



,'CAB/7<7<5B63)'3>/@B;3<B=4=;;3@13NA47</:A1=>3@C:7<5B6/B13@B/7< >:/AB71A63:427D723@A/@33F1:C2324@=;B63/<B72C;>7<5/<21=C<B3@D/7:7<52CBG =@23@A=<@/E4:3F70:3;/5<3BA4@=;B63$3=>:3NA&3>C0:71=467</s   /B32'3>B3;03@  

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

=@K!/5<C;!/5<3B71AL16/::3<53AB63)'3>/@B;3<B=4=;;3@13NA K=;;3@13L47</:A1=>3@C:7<5B6/BB63>:/AB71A63:427D723@A=4343<2/<B <B3@D3<=@/AB3<3@A4=@&3B/7:<120/'744@=<K343<2/<B<B3@D3<=@L=@ K'744@=<L/@33F1:C2324@=;B63/<B72C;>7<5/<21=C<B3@D/7:7<52CBG=@23@A=< @/E4:3F70:3;/5<3BA4@=;B63$3=>:3NA&3>C0:71=467</K67</L <B72C;>7<5CBG/<2=C<B3@D/7:7<5CBG#@23@A=<&/E:3F70:3!/5<3BA 4@=;B63$3=>:3NA&3>C0:71=467</7</:&C:7<5=<'744@=<$:/AB71'63:4

7D723@A    C5 K7</:'1=>3&C:7<5L$&   & A33&/E:3F70:3!/5<3BA4@=;B63$3=>:3NA&3>C0:71=467</ 32

&35  '3>B  /<B72C;>7<52CBG=@23@&/E:3F70:3!/5<3BA 4@=;B63$3=>:3NA&3>C0:71=467</ 32&35  '3>B   1=C<B3@D/7:7<52CBG=@23@1=::31B7D3:GK#@23@AL 34=@3B63=C@B7A$:/7<B744NA&C:3 !=B7=<4=@C25;3<B)>=<B63



 7B/B7=<AB=B63/2;7<7AB@/B7D3@31=@2@34:31BB63>C0:71@31=@2K$&L/<2 1=<4723<B7/:@31=@2K&L2=1C;3<B<C;03@A47:327<B67A1/A3"=A   =C@B"=    $/53    53<1G&31=@2K$:/7<B744NA!=B7=<L$:NA& !=B53<1G&K$:NA

!=BL"= $:NA!3;$=7<BACB6=@7B73A'C>>$:NA!=B53<1G& K$:NA@L"= 343<2/<B)<7B32'B/B3AKB63=D3@<;3<BL=@ K343<2/<BL/<2343<2/<B<B3@D3<=@=>>=A3$:/7<B744NA!=B7=<&3A>@34 <B3@DK34<B3@DNA&3A>L"=A  34NA&3A>$:NA!=B 53<1G&K34NA&3A>L"= $:/7<B74447:327BA@3>:G$:NA&3>:G@ C@B63@'C>>&C:3 !=B53<1G&K$:NA&3>:GL"=  =@B63@3/A=<A27A1CAA3203:=EB63=C@BACAB/7<A=;;3@13NA7</: '1=>3&C:7<5/AAC>>=@B320GAC0AB/<B7/:3D723<13/<27</11=@2/<13E7B6:/E "

#<'3>B3;03@  =;;3@137AAC32/<B72C;>7<5/<21=C<B3@D/7:7<5 2CBG=@23@A4=@@/E4:3F70:3;/5<3BA4@=;B63$3=>:3NA&3>C0:71=467</'33 &/E:3F70:3!/5<3BA4@=;B63$3=>:3NA&3>C0:71=467</ 32&35/B   &/E:3F70:3!/5<3BA4@=;B63$3=>:3NA&3>C0:71=467</ 32&35 /B   #<!/@16  '744@=<47:32/A1=>3@C:7<5@3?C3ABB=23B3@;7<3 E63B63@13@B/7<>:/AB71A63:427D723@AE67161=<A7AB=4/@/E4:3F70:3;/5<3BB6/B7A 0=<232E7B6/</263A7D3B=B630/A3=4/>:/AB71A633BB6/B7A53<3@/::G(=@  A6/>32/@31=D3@320GB63A1=>3=4B63#@23@A 3BB3@4@=;'/<2:3@(@/D7A &=A3<03@5$B==;;3@13@3&/E:3F70:3!/5<3BA4@=;B63$3=>:3NA =C@B"=    $/53    &3>C0:71=467<//<2(/7E/<'1=>3&C:7<5&3?C3AB4=@/AB3<3@A4=@&3B/7:<1

,20/s'744@=<!/@  K'744@=<NA'1=>3&C:7<5&3?C3ABL$& & J  #<>@7: !/5<C;!/5<3B71A47:321=;;3<BA=<'744@=<NA'1=>3 &C:7<5&3?C3AB/<2=;;3@137AAC32/AC>>:3;3<B/:?C3AB7=<</7@3B='744@=< 3BB3@4@=;'?C7@3$/BB=<=55A)' $B==;;3@13@3&/E:3F70:3 !/5<3BA4@=;B63$3=>:3NA&3>C0:714@=;67<//<2(/7E/<=;;3<BA0G !/5<C;!/5<3B71A=@>=@/B7=<=<'1=>3&C:7<5>>:71/B7=<4@=;/AB3<3@A4=@ &3B/7:<1,20/s'744@=<>@ $&  3BB3@4@=;=;;3@13@3&/E :3F70:3!/5<3BA4@=;B63$3=>:3NA&3>C0:71=467</'1=>3&C:7<5&3?C3AB /AB3<3@A4=@&3B/7:<1,20/s'744@=<>@ $& A33/:A= 3BB3@4@=; '/<2:3@(@/D7A&=A3<03@5$B==;;3@13@3&/E:3F70:3!/5<3BA4@=; B63$3=>:3NA&3>C0:71=467</'744@=<NA&3A>=<A3B='1=>3<?C7@G'C>>:3;3<B/: %C3AB7=<</7@3>@ $& &  #<>@7:  =;;3@137<7B7/B32B63A1=>37<?C7@G!3;@3 <7B7/B7=<=4/AB3<3@A4=@&3B/7:<1,20/s'744@=<'744@=<'1=>3<?C7@G>@  $& (63$/@B73A47:32B637@@3A>31B7D31=;;3<BA 3BB3@4@=;'?C7@3 $/BB=<=55A)' $B==;;3@13@3&/E:3F70:3!/5<3BA4@=;B63 $3=>:3NA&3>C0:71=467</=;;3<BA/<2/1BC/:<4=@;/B7=<'C0;7BB320G !/5<C;!/5<3B71A=@>=@/B7=<B=&30CBAA3@B7=<A=<B/7<327<B63'1=>3 &C:7<5>>:71/B7=<4@=;/AB3<3@A4=@&3B/7:<1,20/s'744@=<!/G   =C@B"=    $/53   K!/5<C;!/5<3B71AN&30CBB/:=;;3<BAL$& & 3BB3@4@=;'/<2:3@

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s63B63@B63C</;075C=CAB3@;A=4/A1=>31=<B@=:B637<?C7@G=@ E63B63@A=;3/;075C7BG3F7ABA7A/?C3AB7=<=4:/EB6/B,B63=C@B@3D73EAs23 <=D=L!3@727/<$@=2A D)<7B32'B/B3AK!3@727/<$@=2C1BAL  2   327@ K,*s63B63@/>@=2C1B;33BAB63C</;075C=CAA1=>3 B3@;A>@3A3<BA/?C3AB7=<=44/1B@3D73E324=@AC0AB/<B7/:3D723<13L2 =C@B"=    $/53    " 

  200)4');5 '23))6)40s1%6s21 

(63A1=>3:/<5C/53=4B63#@23@AAB/B3A7<@3:3D/<B>/@B

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Magnum Magnetics Corp. v. United States, 2023 CIT 140 (cit 2023).

2023 CIT 140 (Magnum Magnetics Corp. v. United States) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.