Macclenny Prods. v. United States
Opinion
S pO. 4 5 l p1-
i
U I E S A E C U TO I T R AI N LT A E NT D T T S O R F N E N T O A R D
________________________
________________________
MA C E N P O U T , C L N Y R D CS :
Pii , l nf a tf :
v
. : Cu N 0-08 or o 5044
t .
UI E S A E , NT D T T S :
D edn. e na f t :
________________________________________
________________________________________
[ rn n D ednsP tlM in t D m sfr ako Jr dt nG n n e na ’ G t g e na ’ ai o o oi i oLc f us c o r t gD edns ai f t ra t s s i ii ; a i f t P tl o o o s i oFlr tSt al m(r l ra v yM infrug e o te ai M intD m sfra u o a Ci o aenie , o o oJd mn n h ra t i s i e te a ,t t l t t P a ns r oS m ay ug e )G n n e na ’ o o oP tl u m y ug e l d g ofru m Jd mn;r t gD ednsM infrai S m a Jd mn ei r t ai f t t ra r t a t C t nE r sE g b frD yF eL u a o Prunt US C iba Bs T d s oe a ni l i e o u -r i i t n u a o .. a ben a n r e ri t e i l t e q di s t - r i a P te h A; n Dn n D edns n Pi i’ M infr ai S m ay ug e a n s p c ad ey g e na ’ ad l nf s o os o P tl u m Jd mn r ri t i f t a tf t ra r t at M hd fAp ie e ] so e o o pr s mn t a t D e Jnay , 04 a d au 2 21 t: r2
J r P S k , i os& ik, f o hA by N w e e age fr l nf W h e y . i i S mn S i o Su r sn sn t mo e J sy rud o Pi i. i , r , a tf t
h m nh b e w eB n d.Bb ad aikC Re Ocus oter fws hi Y e i oter f e e a J ab n P r . ed f one nh b e a P l a i r rr tc . l i ip l S mn. i os
A y M Rb , Sn r T a Cus,I enin T d Fl Oie C m e i m . u n e o rl one n ra oa r e i d f c o m cl i i i l t t l a e f , ra Lia o B nh C i D i o US Dp t e oJsc o N wYr N wYr age fr i gin r c i l i s n .. ea mn f uie f e ok e ok rud o t t a , v vi , r t t , , , D edn W h eoter fw eta F D ey A i a A onyGn a C i D i o e na . i h nh b e e S r . e r , s s n t re ee l i l i s n f t t r i r ut l st t t r, v vi , adB b a . Wl m,A onynCag I enin T d Fl Oie Ocus ote n a a S ii s t rei h e n ra oa r e i d f c f one nh rr la t r, t t l a e f . l b e ws M he Hyr h Oie fh A i a C e Cus, n ra oa T d Lia o r f a i a ed c, f c ote s s n h f one I enin r e i gin i c l i f st t i l t t l a t t , Bra o Cs m adBre Po c o US Dp t e o H m ad eut o N wYr u u f u o s n od r ein .. ea mn f o e n Scr y f e ok e t r tt , r t l i, , N wYr e ok .
OI I N PN O
R D A, ug I GW YJde:
I t s c o pi i Mc en Pou s hlnetedcinote U tdSts n h ain l nf ac ny rdc caegs h e s f h ne t e i t , a tf l t l io i a
u o s e i 1 ey g ac ny r e s o eig h aec’ i i t n f ni o Cs m S v e dn n Mc en’ po s cn s n te gny l u a o o e r s f t rc i l s tt tt s q di te
1 TeUS Cs m S v e fr e y a o h US Dp t e o T auy i n w a h .. u o s e i –o m l p tf e .. ea mn f r sr –s o p t t rc r r t r t e r o h US Dp t e o H m ad eut ads o mn ko nsUS Cs madBre f e .. ea mn f o e n Scr y nic m o y n w a .. u o s n od t r t l i, l t r or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae
“ e’s t yeak si pr dr mN a gan 00 n 20 Se eeayitA edd mn u- pjce ” mo efo i r ui 20 ad 01 e gnr l Fs mne s it t t ca . l r
C m a t ¶,,. o pi ¶ 3682 ln
Mc en r ss w ci s Mc en fscn ns h Cs m e e b ap i n ac ny a et ol m ac nyit o edta u o s r d y pr s g l i a . l r t t t r ai
te m cad eai u friu a o bsdo “ asc o v u ”bcue–acr n t h e hn s t s e ol i t n ae n t nain a e eas r i s q di r t l, cod g o
i
Mc en –h p c ote od wsn une bteet nh b wete mo e by ac ny te r e fh gos aif ecd yhr a os p e enhi pr r ue l i l li i t t- r
ad h fr g mnfc r -ee Mc en a es h te m cad e n ed hu hv n te o in au t e sl . ac ny s r ta h e hn sis a so d ae e a u r lr l st t r i t l
be ap ie ote a s f ddc v v u ”Fs A eddC m a t ¶ 12 I adin en pr sd nh bs o“euie a e it mne o pi ¶ 1-4 n d t , a i t l. r ln . io
Mc en aeetatte x n h te u e m cad ews mo e o oa e O oe ac nyl gsh,oh e e ta hsb c e hn s ai pr d nrf r c b l l t tt t jt r i t t t r
220 tem cad es nt do u - et a mnud teU tdt e C iba Bs , 00 h e hn sie iet d yrer t e ne h ne Sts a ben a n , r i tl tf e t r i a - r i
T d P te h A ( C T A , w c e ed t d bn i t c t ncu r s n h r e a n s p c “ B P ” h h x ns r e eet o e a oni i te a r ri t ) i t a fs ri te
C ibarg n d¶ 2-91 USC§ 73b(003i p mn dnUS N e()) C a bene o r i .I. ¶ 52 9 ... 20()20) m e e ei .. o 7bi h ; , l t t (, .
9 SbhI H mn e T i Shd e fh U tdSts“ T U”(00 4 8 uc I a o zd af ceu ote ne t e( H S S 20) , ., r i rf l i a ) .
A oa i u i t sain s h Gv n e ’ cu e l mfradin d is l t s e n h c o i te oe mns on r a o d t a ue s s i t r t t ci io l t .
Se f a yte Gv n e cn ns h, su ig h Cs m ueot nainv u i pci l , h oe mn o edta a m ta u o s s fr sc o a es i cl r t t t s n t t ’ a t l
ssie c t n o s h w e oic dd nCs m l u a o ote m cad e hu u a d e a cs ta e n n ue i u o s i i t n f h e hn s so d t n , ri t t r t l t ’ q di r i l
Po c o SeB l .U tdSts 49F d 35 16 n (e C. 07 Te gnys r ein e u v ne t e 7 . 16 38 . Fd i 20) h aec i tt . l i a , 3 , 1 . r . r e et a “ u o s h e. e r do s Cs m” e i fr t rn 2 Mc en fe b hpbc n cn dna v s n oi Fs A eddC m a t ac ny i d o u i ad of e i ei s ft it mne o pi . l l t l i tl r o s r ln H wv, n te u i v s nsi d e i o ee o y h pbc ei i ce h e .
r l l ro t rn 3 A ca os oee lt u srt te 00 din f h U tdStsCd l it nt fd ast e a o h 20 e t ote ne t e oe l ti r at e io i a . 4 A ca osoh H S S e i a tte 00 dina mdidi r ea p t b l it ntte T U h e r oh 20 e t , s o f ( e vn a) y l ti rn e io ie n l t r i p mnt n f h C T A Te 01 dins dnc t te 00 dina mdid n m e e a o ote B P. h 20 e t iie ia o h 20 e t , s o f , l ti io t l io ie i a r ea rse s l e vn epc. ll t t or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae
b addoht nain a eadCs mso d e w dd d t n d is ae otoe e detter sc o v u n u o s hu b a a e adi a ue bsd nhs a t l, t l r io l t
adin s m As eadCu e l m ¶ 03 d t a u s n w n on r a ¶ 3-3 io l . r t ci .
N w ed g eo teCu a te ais d psiers m in 5 W hepct o pn n b r h or r h p t ’i ot co - o os i fe t e re s i v s t . i rse o t t
Mc en’ C T Al m h Gv n e sesi m s frak f u e mt jr dt n ac ny B P ci, e oe mn ek d i a olc osb c ae us c o l s a t r t s sl j t t r i ii
at a e r stsu o etatoe oe d y r e N 10-4105 e D edns sol ni a set rhnhs cv e b Po s o 830-006 e e na ’
l te i h r tt . .S f t
M mrnu i Spo o M in o S m ay ug e ( D. B e )t,, 11 6 W h e o d mn upr f o o fr u m Jd mn “ e’ r f a291-3 a t t r t fs i ” . it
rse t Mc en’ C T Al mo hs e r s oe d y r e N 10-4105 te epc o ac ny B P ci fr oe ni cv e b Po s o 830-006 h t l s a t te r tt . ,
Gv n e ses i m s fra u t st aci uo w c ri cn e rn d s o h oe mn ek d i a oflr ot e l m pn h h ee a b g t at te r t s sl i e a a i lf ae
fu e r s h w e md p ot O oe 2 20 te f c v d e f h C T A o gos or ni ta e ae r r o c b , 00 h e eie a ote B P fr od te t r i t r , ft t
fo N a ga i. E r Ns WP00399 WP00461 WP00494ad WP r m i r u –., n y o J-029- J-021- J-022- n J-
ca e t . , , ,
00401 ei.t &. 91-3 At te h e nis oe d yPo s N 10-4 024-.Se d a 2 n,, 11 s o htr e r cv e b r e o 830-
3 . e te r tt .
105 ta w ee e do o a e O oe 2 20 ( e E r Ns WP00408 WP 006 h e n r n r f r c b , 00 i. n y o J-027- J-
t r te t t r ., t . ,
00422ad WP00577 teGv n e ses u m yug e l u a nte nis 029- n J-020-) h oe mn eks m a jd mni i t gh e r , , r t r t q di te
d yre Se d a 2 &n,1 2 D ednsRp t Pi i’ Rsos t D edns u - e e i. t tf . . 3 9 e na ’ e y o l nf s epne o e na ’
3 , ; f t l a tf f t
M in o S m ay ug e adRsost Pi i’ Co -M in o S m ay ug e o o fr u m Jd mn n epneo l nf s rs o o fr u m Jd mn t r t a tf s t r t
( D. Rp B e )a 3n,2 [ e na ’ Sp e e a M mrnu i Spo o “ e’ e y r f t . 0 D edns up mnl e o d m n upr f fs l i ” 4 ; f t] l t a t
D edns M in o S m ay ug e ( D. Sp B e )t 0 e na ’ o o fr u m Jd mn “ e’ up r f a1 f t t r t fs . i” .
5 A hu h Mc en ad h Gv n e fe b h u i ad of e i v s n o l o g ac ny n te oe mn i d o pbc n cn dna ei s f t l r tl t l i tl r o te p n p b e,lca os e i a t te u i v s n h r r c a r f a i t n h e r o h pb c e i s i i i l i s l ti rn e l ro.
Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI
S pO. 4 5 l p1-
i
U I E S A E C U TO I T R AI N LT A E NT D T T S O R F N E N T O A R D
________________________
________________________
MA C E N P O U T , C L N Y R D CS :
Pii , l nf a tf :
v
. : Cu N 0-08 or o 5044
t .
UI E S A E , NT D T T S :
D edn. e na f t :
________________________________________
________________________________________
[ rn n D ednsP tlM in t D m sfr ako Jr dt nG n n e na ’ G t g e na ’ ai o o oi i oLc f us c o r t gD edns ai f t ra t s s i ii ; a i f t P tl o o o s i oFlr tSt al m(r l ra v yM infrug e o te ai M intD m sfra u o a Ci o aenie , o o oJd mn n h ra t i s i e te a ,t t l t t P a ns r oS m ay ug e )G n n e na ’ o o oP tl u m y ug e l d g ofru m Jd mn;r t gD ednsM infrai S m a Jd mn ei r t ai f t t ra r t a t C t nE r sE g b frD yF eL u a o Prunt US C iba Bs T d s oe a ni l i e o u -r i i t n u a o .. a ben a n r e ri t e i l t e q di s t - r i a P te h A; n Dn n D edns n Pi i’ M infr ai S m ay ug e a n s p c ad ey g e na ’ ad l nf s o os o P tl u m Jd mn r ri t i f t a tf t ra r t at M hd fAp ie e ] so e o o pr s mn t a t D e Jnay , 04 a d au 2 21 t: r2
J r P S k , i os& ik, f o hA by N w e e age fr l nf W h e y . i i S mn S i o Su r sn sn t mo e J sy rud o Pi i. i , r , a tf t
h m nh b e w eB n d.Bb ad aikC Re Ocus oter fws hi Y e i oter f e e a J ab n P r . ed f one nh b e a P l a i r rr tc . l i ip l S mn. i os
A y M Rb , Sn r T a Cus,I enin T d Fl Oie C m e i m . u n e o rl one n ra oa r e i d f c o m cl i i i l t t l a e f , ra Lia o B nh C i D i o US Dp t e oJsc o N wYr N wYr age fr i gin r c i l i s n .. ea mn f uie f e ok e ok rud o t t a , v vi , r t t , , , D edn W h eoter fw eta F D ey A i a A onyGn a C i D i o e na . i h nh b e e S r . e r , s s n t re ee l i l i s n f t t r i r ut l st t t r, v vi , adB b a . Wl m,A onynCag I enin T d Fl Oie Ocus ote n a a S ii s t rei h e n ra oa r e i d f c f one nh rr la t r, t t l a e f . l b e ws M he Hyr h Oie fh A i a C e Cus, n ra oa T d Lia o r f a i a ed c, f c ote s s n h f one I enin r e i gin i c l i f st t i l t t l a t t , Bra o Cs m adBre Po c o US Dp t e o H m ad eut o N wYr u u f u o s n od r ein .. ea mn f o e n Scr y f e ok e t r tt , r t l i, , N wYr e ok .
OI I N PN O
R D A, ug I GW YJde:
I t s c o pi i Mc en Pou s hlnetedcinote U tdSts n h ain l nf ac ny rdc caegs h e s f h ne t e i t , a tf l t l io i a
u o s e i 1 ey g ac ny r e s o eig h aec’ i i t n f ni o Cs m S v e dn n Mc en’ po s cn s n te gny l u a o o e r s f t rc i l s tt tt s q di te
1 TeUS Cs m S v e fr e y a o h US Dp t e o T auy i n w a h .. u o s e i –o m l p tf e .. ea mn f r sr –s o p t t rc r r t r t e r o h US Dp t e o H m ad eut ads o mn ko nsUS Cs madBre f e .. ea mn f o e n Scr y nic m o y n w a .. u o s n od t r t l i, l t r or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae
“ e’s t yeak si pr dr mN a gan 00 n 20 Se eeayitA edd mn u- pjce ” mo efo i r ui 20 ad 01 e gnr l Fs mne s it t t ca . l r
C m a t ¶,,. o pi ¶ 3682 ln
Mc en r ss w ci s Mc en fscn ns h Cs m e e b ap i n ac ny a et ol m ac nyit o edta u o s r d y pr s g l i a . l r t t t r ai
te m cad eai u friu a o bsdo “ asc o v u ”bcue–acr n t h e hn s t s e ol i t n ae n t nain a e eas r i s q di r t l, cod g o
i
Mc en –h p c ote od wsn une bteet nh b wete mo e by ac ny te r e fh gos aif ecd yhr a os p e enhi pr r ue l i l li i t t- r
ad h fr g mnfc r -ee Mc en a es h te m cad e n ed hu hv n te o in au t e sl . ac ny s r ta h e hn sis a so d ae e a u r lr l st t r i t l
be ap ie ote a s f ddc v v u ”Fs A eddC m a t ¶ 12 I adin en pr sd nh bs o“euie a e it mne o pi ¶ 1-4 n d t , a i t l. r ln . io
Mc en aeetatte x n h te u e m cad ews mo e o oa e O oe ac nyl gsh,oh e e ta hsb c e hn s ai pr d nrf r c b l l t tt t jt r i t t t r
220 tem cad es nt do u - et a mnud teU tdt e C iba Bs , 00 h e hn sie iet d yrer t e ne h ne Sts a ben a n , r i tl tf e t r i a - r i
T d P te h A ( C T A , w c e ed t d bn i t c t ncu r s n h r e a n s p c “ B P ” h h x ns r e eet o e a oni i te a r ri t ) i t a fs ri te
C ibarg n d¶ 2-91 USC§ 73b(003i p mn dnUS N e()) C a bene o r i .I. ¶ 52 9 ... 20()20) m e e ei .. o 7bi h ; , l t t (, .
9 SbhI H mn e T i Shd e fh U tdSts“ T U”(00 4 8 uc I a o zd af ceu ote ne t e( H S S 20) , ., r i rf l i a ) .
A oa i u i t sain s h Gv n e ’ cu e l mfradin d is l t s e n h c o i te oe mns on r a o d t a ue s s i t r t t ci io l t .
Se f a yte Gv n e cn ns h, su ig h Cs m ueot nainv u i pci l , h oe mn o edta a m ta u o s s fr sc o a es i cl r t t t s n t t ’ a t l
ssie c t n o s h w e oic dd nCs m l u a o ote m cad e hu u a d e a cs ta e n n ue i u o s i i t n f h e hn s so d t n , ri t t r t l t ’ q di r i l
Po c o SeB l .U tdSts 49F d 35 16 n (e C. 07 Te gnys r ein e u v ne t e 7 . 16 38 . Fd i 20) h aec i tt . l i a , 3 , 1 . r . r e et a “ u o s h e. e r do s Cs m” e i fr t rn 2 Mc en fe b hpbc n cn dna v s n oi Fs A eddC m a t ac ny i d o u i ad of e i ei s ft it mne o pi . l l t l i tl r o s r ln H wv, n te u i v s nsi d e i o ee o y h pbc ei i ce h e .
r l l ro t rn 3 A ca os oee lt u srt te 00 din f h U tdStsCd l it nt fd ast e a o h 20 e t ote ne t e oe l ti r at e io i a . 4 A ca osoh H S S e i a tte 00 dina mdidi r ea p t b l it ntte T U h e r oh 20 e t , s o f ( e vn a) y l ti rn e io ie n l t r i p mnt n f h C T A Te 01 dins dnc t te 00 dina mdid n m e e a o ote B P. h 20 e t iie ia o h 20 e t , s o f , l ti io t l io ie i a r ea rse s l e vn epc. ll t t or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae
b addoht nain a eadCs mso d e w dd d t n d is ae otoe e detter sc o v u n u o s hu b a a e adi a ue bsd nhs a t l, t l r io l t
adin s m As eadCu e l m ¶ 03 d t a u s n w n on r a ¶ 3-3 io l . r t ci .
N w ed g eo teCu a te ais d psiers m in 5 W hepct o pn n b r h or r h p t ’i ot co - o os i fe t e re s i v s t . i rse o t t
Mc en’ C T Al m h Gv n e sesi m s frak f u e mt jr dt n ac ny B P ci, e oe mn ek d i a olc osb c ae us c o l s a t r t s sl j t t r i ii
at a e r stsu o etatoe oe d y r e N 10-4105 e D edns sol ni a set rhnhs cv e b Po s o 830-006 e e na ’
l te i h r tt . .S f t
M mrnu i Spo o M in o S m ay ug e ( D. B e )t,, 11 6 W h e o d mn upr f o o fr u m Jd mn “ e’ r f a291-3 a t t r t fs i ” . it
rse t Mc en’ C T Al mo hs e r s oe d y r e N 10-4105 te epc o ac ny B P ci fr oe ni cv e b Po s o 830-006 h t l s a t te r tt . ,
Gv n e ses i m s fra u t st aci uo w c ri cn e rn d s o h oe mn ek d i a oflr ot e l m pn h h ee a b g t at te r t s sl i e a a i lf ae
fu e r s h w e md p ot O oe 2 20 te f c v d e f h C T A o gos or ni ta e ae r r o c b , 00 h e eie a ote B P fr od te t r i t r , ft t
fo N a ga i. E r Ns WP00399 WP00461 WP00494ad WP r m i r u –., n y o J-029- J-021- J-022- n J-
ca e t . , , ,
00401 ei.t &. 91-3 At te h e nis oe d yPo s N 10-4 024-.Se d a 2 n,, 11 s o htr e r cv e b r e o 830-
3 . e te r tt .
105 ta w ee e do o a e O oe 2 20 ( e E r Ns WP00408 WP 006 h e n r n r f r c b , 00 i. n y o J-027- J-
t r te t t r ., t . ,
00422ad WP00577 teGv n e ses u m yug e l u a nte nis 029- n J-020-) h oe mn eks m a jd mni i t gh e r , , r t r t q di te
d yre Se d a 2 &n,1 2 D ednsRp t Pi i’ Rsos t D edns u - e e i. t tf . . 3 9 e na ’ e y o l nf s epne o e na ’
3 , ; f t l a tf f t
M in o S m ay ug e adRsost Pi i’ Co -M in o S m ay ug e o o fr u m Jd mn n epneo l nf s rs o o fr u m Jd mn t r t a tf s t r t
( D. Rp B e )a 3n,2 [ e na ’ Sp e e a M mrnu i Spo o “ e’ e y r f t . 0 D edns up mnl e o d m n upr f fs l i ” 4 ; f t] l t a t
D edns M in o S m ay ug e ( D. Sp B e )t 0 e na ’ o o fr u m Jd mn “ e’ up r f a1 f t t r t fs . i” .
5 A hu h Mc en ad h Gv n e fe b h u i ad of e i v s n o l o g ac ny n te oe mn i d o pbc n cn dna ei s f t l r tl t l i tl r o te p n p b e,lca os e i a t te u i v s n h r r c a r f a i t n h e r o h pb c e i s i i i l i s l ti rn e l ro.
6 A d cse b o,l ogteGv n e ’sb i ins a ind ol aa M in si u d e wa huhh oe mns u m s icp oe s e s o o s s l t r t so t ly t frS m ay ug e , h Gv n e ’ b e a o ek i m s o c t nl mfrak f o u m Jd mn te oe mns r f l se d i a f e a ci s olc o r t r t is s s sl ri a sb c mt jr dt n n d m s o o e fra u t st al m pnw c ri cn u e ae us c o adi i a ft r oflr ot e ci uo h hee a j t t r i ii s sl hs i e a a i lf bg nd er t .
ae or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae
W h epct a o e e r ste Gv n e rqe se r o s m ay ug e i rse o l t r ni , h oe mn eus n y f u m jd mn t t l h te r t t t r t
ssi n Cs m ue o t nain v u t ap iete m cad e bsd o te u a ig u o s s f r sc o a e o pr s h e hn s ae n h tn t ’ a t l a r i,
“ ru s ne ote a ” e s fr i tev uint u. Se f a yte Gv n e c c m acs f h s e ts e o h n h a a o st e pci l , h oe mn i t l t t t lt at i cl r t
agetaue frnain a ews prp a bcue acr ntteGv n e –h rush s ot sc o v u a aport eas – cod goh oe mn te t a t l ie i r t
p c ote m cad ews st d n mne cn s n w h h nr a p c g rccs f r e f h e hn s a “el i a an ost t i te o m ri p t e o i r i te r ie t l i n ai
tenur ” ntu ws o n une bteet nh b wete mo e by adh hids y adhs a n if ecd yhr a os p e enhi pr r ue nte t, t l li i t t- r
fr g mnfc r -ee 1 USC § 41 b 2 B 1 CFR § 5 13)1;e D. o in au t e sl . 9 ... 10a ) ) ) 9 ... 12 0(() se e’ e a u r lr ((( ; . l 7 fs
B ea91-02 2 2 D. Rp B ea11 1 2 D. Sp B ea 89ps m r ft, 32 6 8 9 e’ e y r ft -2 6 0 e’ up r ft - a i ; i , , , ; fs l i , , ; fs . i , s
D ednsRp t Pi i’ Sp e e a B e( D. Sp Rp B e )t - e na ’ e yo l nf s up mnl r f“ e’ up e y r f a18 f t l a tf l t i fs . l i” .
TeGv n e a o ek e r os m ayug e oi cu e l m oadin h oe mn l ses n y f u m jd mn nt on r a fr d t a r ts t r t s t ci io l
d is A u ig h s m ay ug e e e ssi n Cs m dcin oap ie h ue s m ta u m jd mn n r u a ig u o s e s t pr s te t. s n t r t ts t n t ’ io a
m cad eo tebs ot nainv u te Gv n e rqe s h te Cu od e hn s n h a s fr sc o a e h oe mn eus ta h or re r i i a t l, r t t t t r
riu a o ote nis tsu t ic d i te pr sdv u a pci s mp u t o e q din f h e r ai e o n ue n h ap ie a e se f u e n fr l it te s l a l ic r i
e r smdi 20t r lc“ e r d rdc o Cs, ad n d t n“l mu s a b ni aen 00oe e D e e Pouin o s n i adi , a a on p d y te f t fr t t” , io l t i
B G o r n ea o K i 20 ad 01 h w e o o s b py e s yK t B G r C t o o bh f f B n 00 n 20 ta e n f e y a mn b B o C o l t r t ft t
gos h pd yK t Mc en B Gnhs ya. D. B ea2 seloda92-6 ods pe b Bo ac ny C itoe e s e’ r ft 9 e a i.t, 02 i l / r ” fs i ; s ;
D. Rp B ea1-52-1 D. Sp B ea1 e’ e y r ft 21 02 e’ up r ft 0 fs l i , ; fs . i .
Ii co - o ofr u m yug e , Mc en cnu iteGv n e ’rqe n srs m inos m a jd mn ac ny ocr nh oe mnseus t s t r t l s r t t
ta E r Ns WP00408 WP00422 ad WP00577b l u a dd yre h n y o J-027- J-029- n J-020- ei i t u - e t t . , , q de tf
7 A ca os ofd a rg a osa t te19 e t no te Cd o Fd a l it n t ee l eut n r o h 99 di f h oe f ee l l ti r li e io r Rg a os w c iie iat te 00 n 20 e t ni a r ea rse s eut n h hs dnc o h 20 ad 01 di s nl e vn epc.
li , i t l io ll t t or o 5044 t . Pg 5 ae
prunt teC T A SePi i’ M mrnu i Opsin oD edns M in o u a o h B P. e l nf s e o d m n pot t e na ’ o o fr s t a tf a io f t t
S m ay ug e ad nSpo o Pi i’ Co -M in o S m ay ug e (P’ u m Jd mn n i upr f l nf s rs o o fr u m Jd mn “ls r t t a tf s t r t .
B e )t, n, 21 1 1-73-3 I adin Mc en ses u m y ug e o r f a 23. 1-3 4 61 23 n d t , ac ny ek s m a jd mn n i” 1 , , , . io l r t
i ci ta h b ac ote nistsu so d ae en pr sd ol u a o bsd n t l mh te a ne fh e r a se hu hv be ap ie fr q din ae o sa t l te i l a iit
ddc v v u ei.t, 31 1-52-13 Pi i’ Rp t D ednsRsos euie a e e d a 21-5 72 83 2 l nf s e y o e na ’ epne t l .S , , , ; a tf l f t
t Pi i’ Co -M in o S m ay ug e (P’ Rp B e )t -11-8 Pi i’ o l nf s rs o o fr u m Jd mn “ls e y r f a11 71 l nf s a tf s t r t . l i” , ; a tf
Sp e e a B e(P’ Sp B e )t11 Pi i’ Rp t D ednsSp e e a up mnl r f “ls up r f a -0 l nf s e y o e na ’ up mnl l t i . . i” ; a tf l f t l t
B e(P’ Sp Rp B e )t - r f“ls up e y r f a14 i . . l i” .
W h hl ma os icse h e , us c o oe Mc en’ ci sis ne 2 i tei it n d u d e i jr dt n v ac ny l ml ud 8 t ti s s r n i ii r l s a e r
USC§ 51 )adus c o oe h Gv n e ’cu e l m e ud 2 USC§ 53 ... 18( ; njr dt n v te oe mns on r a l s ne 8 ... 18 a i ii r r t t ci i r .
A d cse i g a r ei b o,t Gv n e ’ o o oi m s olc o jr dt n s i u d n r t d a e w h oe mnsm int d i fr akf us c o s s e e tl l e r t t s s i ii
Mc en’ B P l ms ol nistetatoeoe d yr e N 830-006 ac ny l sC T Aci ata e r o r hnhscv e b Po s o 0-4105 a l te h r t t .1
m s b g n d TeGv n e ’ m in ek g i m s o dnl f Mc en’ C T A u t e r t . h oe mns o o se n d i a r e a o ac ny B P ae r t t i s sl i l s
ca mi epct te or nis oe d y r e o 830-006 h hw r md l w hrse o hfue r cv e b Po s .10-4105 w c e ae i t t te r t tN i e
b o O oe , 00lo u e rn d Atteh e pcid nish a sb c oh er c b f e t r220 a ms g t . sohtr se f e r ta r u e tte s tb a e e ie te t e j t
C T A( n y o J-027- WP00422 ad J-020-)teGv n e ’ B P E r Ns P00408 J-029- n WP00577 h oe mns t .W , , , r t
m in o s m ay ug e ms b g n d H wv,b h h Gv n e ’ m in o o o fr u m jd mn u e r t . o ee o te oe mns o o fr t r t t ae r t r t t
s m ay ug e cnen g h poe m hdo ap ie e o a r m n g nis n u m jd mn oc i te rp e o f pr s mn f l e a i e r ad r t rn r t a t l i n te
Mc en’ co - o o fr u m y ug e o te a esu ms b dn d ac ny rs m in os m a jd mn n h s mi e u e e e l s s t r t s t i.
or o 5044 t . Pg 6 ae
I akr u d .Bc go n
T saincnen 4 e r so mn s t ye ak s mo e fo N a ga n h c o oc s 6 ni f e’ u- p jce i pr d r m i r u i i t r te s it t t ca
20 20 ad rsn t o a csus ()we e ateGv n e cn nstws rp 00 01 n p e s w bs i e 1 h h, sh oe mn o ed i a poe / e t i s : tr r t t , r
frCs mt ap ie h m cad ebsdo i “ asc o v u ”n w h ad g h o u o s o pr s te e hn s ae nt t nain a e o i s n n te t a r i s r t l, t tt i
r a os p ewe Mc en Pou ste mo e by ) n K Mnfc r gC may et nh b en ac ny rdc ( i pr r ue ad B au t i o pn li i t l t h t- r a un
( eo inmnfc r -ee; n()we eayfh m cad ewsl i eod yre t fr g au t e sl )ad2 h h n o e e hn s ae g lfr u - e h e a u r lr tr t r i ib tf
t a mnud tene StsC iba Bs T d P te h A,s Mc en m nis8 r t e ne hU tdt e a ben a n r e a n s p c a ac ny a t n e t r i a - r i a r ri t l ia .
AteCu o Apa hs x a e “] pr dm cad emsb ap ie sta sh or f pe s a epi d [ mo e e hn s u e pr sd oh t l ln, i t r i t a t
teiaa ono d yo e a otem cad e a bf e ad nis fh m cad e hf l mu f u t b p d nh e hn s cn ei d n e r ote e hn s n t t i r i x te r i
cn eiu a d VW o A e c Icv U tdSts15F d 3713 (e C. 99 a bl i t .
q de” P f m ia n . ne t e,7 . 12 30 Fd i 19)
r , . i a 3 , . r
(t g 9USC § 50 Cs mirq rd o pr si pr d m cad e n h mne ci 1 ... 10) u o ss eu e t ap ie mo e e hn si te an in . t i a t r i r
se f d n h v uin t u,1 USC §10a Se1 USC §10( . Te t u pci i te a a o st e 9 ... 41 e 9 ... 50 ) h st e ie lt at . a at
e a ihst nain a e ater m ym hdf a a o 1 USC§ 41 a 1 A se s bse“ asc o v u”sh p a e o ov uin 9 ... 10a ) ) ) e tl r t l i r t lt . (( ( ;
a o P fA e c , 7 F dt 30139 l VW o m ia 15 . a13 35 s r 3 , .
8 Tea sefr it seinr d w gn a yr mh p t s St mn o Fc, hfc s o hnh sc o a r n ee l fo te ai ’ t e e sf a s t t t i t e a rl re a t t a wl s h r r f ad etd x bs n u n i p t u r h dpsin n aia t f s e ate b e n r a eh i, c d g n ai l, e eot ad f dv o l i is l e it i l i , rc a t io f i P l Loyte C e Oe t g Oie o By C t n GopIc( B G,o w c hi ob h h f p a n f c f ae l h g ru n “ C ” f h h ip , i ri f r r oi , . ) i Mc en ws d i o ac ny a a i s n l vi . 9 I adino asc o v u( er m ym hdf a a o) hst eloe fr n d t tt nain a e h p a e o ov uin tet u a s so h io r t l t i r t lt , at s t t f e eod ym hd w c msb cn d ei od (i te rv oh ai pr rmy i scna e os h h u e os e dn re w hh po sta n mo e a v r t , i t ir r t i t t rqe teee ao ddc v v u ad o p e v u a ht mte n y u m ysi d eus hrv s f euie a e n c mu d a et e eh e r s m a ife)
t rl t l t l t i t r l .
Te vscnaym hd ov uinr ()ht nain a efdnc m cad e 2 hf eeod i r e osf a a o a : 1 e asc o v u o e ia e hn s ()
t lt e t r t l i t l r i, ternain a e fi i rm cad e() euie a e() o p e v u ad 5te ht sc o v u os ma e hn s 3 ddc v v u 4c mu d a e n ()h a t l l r i, t l, t l, “ v lef te v us an b d e m e o ue” a se f d n 9USC§ 41 f 1. [] ui o r a e cno e e r i d r sd (s pci i 1 ... 10a) )
a h l t t n ie (( ) Se 9USC§ 41 a e 1 ... 10a )(.
A d csei g a r eib o, Mc en cn nsh tem cad etsu h e si u dnr t d a e w ac ny o edta h e hn s a se e s s e e tl l l t t r i i r or o 5044 t . Pg 7 ae
“rnainv u” sd ie i r ea p ta “ ep c a ul p d . fr h T sc o a e i e nd n e vn a s t r e c a y a . . ote a t l f l t r h i tl i
m cad ewe s d o eprt n o h U tdSts p s e a st oy d t n 1 e hn s hn o fr xo a o t te ne t e ” l c t nt u r adi s 9 r i l ti i a , u ri a t io .
USC§ 41 b 1 selo 9USC§ 41 b 4 A(e n g p c a ul p d a “ e ... 10a ) ) e a 1 ... 10a ) ) ) d i n “r e c a y a ” st ( (; s ((( fi i tl i h
t a py e . . md. . oi pr d m cad e y h by t . . h sl, ec d g ol a mn . ae . fr mo e e hn s b te ue o . te ee” x u n t t t r i r lr li
i enin f ihisrneadte C.. h gs Te p c a ul p ditp a yh n ra oa r g ,nu c n o r . Fca e. h “r e c a y a ”sy clte t t le t a , h I r ) i tl i il
p ctair lc d n hiv c fr h m cad e w c iic ddw h h e r pp s r e h s e e e o te no e ote e hn s h hs n ue i te n y ae i t f t i r i, i l t t r
taai pr ri sw hCs m h n mo efe i u o s t t l t t .
A huhrnainv u itep m y m hdo v u g mo e gosud te l og t sc o a es h r a e o f a i i pr d od ne h t a t l i r t ln t r
st eteueot nainv u myb cn a d a dwe – sh e– h by ad h t u, h s fr sc o a e a e o r n c e h e a e te ue n te at a t l ti i t r r r
sl a “ l e ”Se P fA e c , 7 F dt 303 1 USC§ 41 b 2 B se ee r r a d e VW o m ia 15 . a 13-1 9 ... 10a ) ) ) e l r e et . r 3 ; ((( ;
a o 9CFR§ 5 13)1i)I sc c c m acs h p t st nainmsb “ oe l 1 ... 12 0(() v n uhi u s ne te ai ’r sc o u e c s y s . j (. r t , re a t t l l
s u n ed t esr tatep t shv n c ldd o o ete no ep c i od t c t i [] o nu h h ai ae o o ue t l w h iv c r e n re o ri z ” e t re t l r i i r
m i ie mo d is Se eeay aP l Fs osIcv U tdSts 2 CT 9 35 i m i pr ue e gnr l L e a ah n n . ne t e, 2 I 33 9 n z t t. l r i , . i a , ,
9. up2 68700 (98 a’ pr u a , 8 F d 2 (e C. 99(x a igh FSp d 9 0-1 19) f d e cr m 15. 85 Fd i 19)epi nta . , ,f i 3 . r ln t
p e i fretd aisomn utiv c p ci od t eae mo d is m ia d o na or a p t t a p a no e r en re o vdi pr ue “ o v e t tl l e re i le i i r t t t t
Cnrst ea po c vlglin n t d e Cs mt c s y cu n e etd a y og s o nc r eiee st ad o i c u o s ol e s t i r a p t e t tt i ao rt t o l ri z l e r
so d e pr sd ae o “euie a e e 1 USC§ 41 d(e n g ddc v hu b ap ie bsd n ddc v v u ”Se 9 ... 10a ) d i n “euie l a t l. ( fi t v u” Cs m hs x a e “ a cl ddc v v uiteea p citeU tdt e a e. u o s aepi d Bs a y euie a eshrs er enh ne Sts l ) t ln: i l, t l l i i a a ei prt n fh gos w h euinfr e a i m Gn a y h ddc v v ui f r mo a o ote od i ddc os oc t n e s ee l , e euie a es t ti , t t ri t . rl t t l c c a d yt t gw h u t r e n mk g e a adint ad euinfo ta a ut b s r n i a n p c ad a n c t n d t s o n ddc osr m h l le ai t i i i ri io t t p c ”Se eeay h Eey M meo h T d C m u t So dKo Ao :Cs m r e e gnr l Wa v i. l t r e b f e r e o mn y hu n w bu u o s r t a i l t t V u (.. Dp o H m ad Scr yJ y20)a 1-5 sea oD. B e a 2 a e US e’ f o e n eut u 06 t 41 e l e’ r f t l t l i l ; s fs i (u m i n d i t no “euiev u”a “ s ep cs o US by s e st oy s m a z g e ni f ddc v a e s r a r e t .. ue ls t u r ri fio t l el i r s at ddc os. euin”
t )
or o 5044 t . Pg 8 ae
t n e p c g. r s r ri ”1 a f i n )0
De o uh oc n tev uint u p c ds pr s mn bsdo t nain u t sc cne s h a a o st e r l e ap ie e ae nr sc o r, lt at e u a t a t
v u we te ue ad ee a “ l e ” xe i c t ni u s ne Se f a yte a e h e h by n sl r r a d ecp n e a c c m acs pci l , h l r r l r e et , t ri r t . i cl
st e u o zs h ueot nainv u ee we teby ad ee a r a di a t u a hr ete s fr sc o a e vn h e h ue n sl r et “ n at t i a t l r r lr e l e f
ea ia o oteic m acsfh s e .n c eta hr a os p ewe sc by x m t n f h c u s ne o e a. id a sh teet nh b en uh ue ni r t t l. it t li i t r
adeed n i lecte r ec a y a . 1 USC§ 41 b 2 B( mhss de) n sl i o n uneh p ca ul p d 9 ... 10a ) ) )e paeadd lr d t f i tl i” ((( ;
se lo 9CFR § 5 13)2i Aenie , h st e u o zs h ue frnain e a 1 ... 12 0(()) l ra v ytet u a hr ete s ot sc o s . j (. t t l at t i a t
v u n w h ad g r a os p ewete ueadhsl “ te asc o v u o h a e o i s n n aet nh b enh by nteee i ht nain a ef e l t tt i li i t r lr f r t l t
i pr dm cad els y prx m e –iternain a e fdnc m cad eo mo e e hn s c e apo a s ( ht sc o v u oie ia e hn s r t r i ol i t ) a t l t l r i,
os ma m cad e n a so n l e by snh U td t e o()h ddc v v u fi i r e hn s i s et ur a d ue ite ne Sts ri te euie a e l r i, l et r i a; i t l
o c mu d v u frie ia m cad e o s ma m cad e r o p e a e o dnc t l t l e hn s r i i r e hn s ” 1 USC § r i l r i. 9 ...
10ab 2 Bi()1 se lo 9CFR§ 5 13)2i A() 41 ) ) ))i 1;e a 1 ... 12 0(()) ) B ( ( ( (-i s . j (( - .
Cs mrg a osrv e ei d u acfr si ap igh “ ru s ne o h u o seut n po d d ae g dneouen p y te c c m acsf e t li i tl i ln i t t
s ets o e r iewe e o n aet nh if ecd r en r a d a yrnain a ”e t d e m l t t n h h r o r a os pn une p ci aet p tt sc o tr t li i l i le r a t .
10 We a o in a ysc a K h esl m cad eo r a d a ynh U td hn fr g p t (uh s B e ) es e hn st aet p tite ne e r r l r i le r i Stssc a Mc en B G Cs madhI en Rvne ev e“R”sa –tes t e(uhs ac ny C ) u o s nten ra eeu S i ( S h e a a a l / , t t l rc I ) r l t i ter – h s m ga ac t n g h cr c p ctateUS mo eso d a t te n hoy te a e o: se a i te o e r e h h .. pr r hu py o h l ri n rt i t i t l r a do in ntfrh m cad e H wv,Cs madhI S aei e ncnen et fr g e i o a e hn s o ee u o s nte R hv df e oc s le e ty t t r i. r t fr t r. Cs m gn a ys oc nd h tet e p c myb ai cl l ws at m i ie u o s ee l i cne e ta h std r e a e rfil o, o s o i m t rl r t a i ti a y n z cs m d is u o te mo e m cad e I cn a, h I S y cl i cnend h u o s ue de n hi pr d e hn s n o rs te R tp a ys oc e ta t t t r i. t t il r t tet e p c my e rfil h hs taa o e pr o ote rf gn a d y h s e h std r e a b ai cl i , o h l w oin f h pot ee t b te a a i ti a y g t r t i re l oteiapou wl eaa e n h U tdSts fhf l rdc i btxb i te ne t e n t l l i a. 11 Test e eu e ta “ahv u r e e t i c uei o () h i ue fr h t u rq rs h ec a e e r d o n l s ( ri ta s sd o at i t l fr a ) i t c masn ms r a [t m cad e h ws xo e t teU tdStst r bute o p io [ u] et ] o e hn sta a epr d o h ne t e a o ao h r t le r i t t i a t s m t m a te mo e m cad e 1 USC §10ab 2 B sea o 9 CFR § a ei e s h i pr d e hn s ” 9 ... 41 ) ) ) e l 1 ...
t r i. ((( ; s 12 0(())C 5 13)2i ) . j (( .
or o 5044 t . Pg 9 ae
Te n rr a v N et 1 CFR§ 5 13)1 po d i r ea p t hI ep tie o s o 9 ... 12 0(() rv e ne vn a:
t et t . l i, l t r
( I ep tien e1. . h eCs m hsdu s buteueo i n rr a v o . . [We u o s a ob ao h s f ) t et t r t t t p c “n i ua e o ce ternain a ew hufr eiq r ”. . r e ads nb t acp ht sc o v u i o u h nu y] . i l t a t l t t t r i, Cs m wl x m ee vnapc o ht nain n u ntewynw c u o s i ea i r ea se sf e asc o ic d gh ai h h t l n l t t t r t , li i te ue ad ee ogn e h r o m cl et n ad h wy nw c te h by n sl ra zte c m e i r a os n te ai h h h r lr i i r a li i p c i qein wsa ie a i od t d e m e we ete et nh r e n us o a r vd t n re o e r i i t r r t n h h h r a os p tr li i
if ecd h p c n une te r e l i.
() n rr a v n e .Iii so n h te ue ad ee a huh i I ep tie o 2 fts h w ta h by n sl,l og i t et t t r lr t r a d by r madsl oec o e a i te w en r a dt s wl et , u fo n e t ah t r s f hy e o et , h i le l h r t le i l d mnr e h tep c hsn be if ecdb te et nh ,ad h e os a ta h r e a o en n une y h r a os p n te tt t i t l li i t nainv u wlb acp d Itep c hsbe st d na mne r sc o a e i e ce e f h r e a en el i a t l l t. i te anr cn s n w hh nr ap c g rccsfhids yn us o, rw hh ost t i te o m ri paie o enu ri qein o i te ie t l in t t t t t wyh sl st s r efr a so ue wor n r a doi,t swl ate ee el p cs os et by s h a o et t h m h i l r te i l r e t le i l e os a ta h p c hs o en n une bte e t nh . d mn r e h te r e a n be i lecd y h r a os p tt t i t f li i
(iI ep tie o 3 Iii so n h te r es dqa t esr i) n rr a v n e. fts h w ta h p ci aeu e o nu i t et t t i t e rcv yo a cs p s pot w c i eu a nt tei m oe l pot eoe f l o s l a rf h hs q v e o h f ’ v a rf r l t u i i ilt r s rl i razd v a ersnt e e o ot m ( g o a ana bs)i s e o eie oe rp e a v p id fi ee. n n nu a s n a s f l r e ti r ., l i, l m cad e fh s m c s o k d h wu d mnr eh te r e a n e hn s ote a el s ri , i o d e os a ta h p c hs o r i a n ts l tt t i t be if ecd en n une l .
1 CFR§ 5 13)1i(i( mhss de) 9 ... 12 0(())i)e pae add . l (-i .
A ht m ote vn a su Mc en ws d i o o By C t n GopIc t e e fh ee st se ac ny a ai s n f ae l h g ru n t i t i , l vi r oi , .
( B G,w hepn bi frB G i preprai t s2 K wss bsei N a ga “ C ” i rsos it o C ’ mo/xo c vi . B ae a ihdn i r u ) t ily s t t t ie1 tl ca
i 19 a ai s n fB G ote pci proe f rdc g cep a ewo mn wa n 97 s d i o o C, rh se f ups o pou n “ha v u o ” es e .
vi f ic i l l r
A b h Mc en adK w ei s n o B G w c wswo y we b Rb t By ) s o ac ny n B e d i os f C ( h h a h l o nd y oe I ae, t l r vi i l r. r
i s n su dh Mc en adK a r a d nt soproe o h v uint u. e t ud p eta ac ny n Br et e iefr upssf e a a o st eSe i i t t l e l e ti t lt at
1 USC§ 41 g 1 9 ... 10a ) )
( (.
K wsh o ymnfc r o mn s t yeak snN a ga we e o n fr B ate n au t e f e’ u- pjce i i r u( h h r o o l a ur s it t ca tr t
12 N ig h “Mc en d n m ni sp a acu ig eod fo B Gad o n ta ac ny i o a t n ea t con n rcrs r m C n t t l d t ia re t awy a e o B G bh f teGv n e ’ b e gn a y e r o Mc en adB G l as c d n C ’ ea, h oe mns r f ee l r et ac ny n C t s l” r t i s rl f l j n ya “Mc en B G Se e’ B ea4. Te a e ovn oif l wd e. o t , s ac ny C. e D. r ft n. h s m cne ins o o e h e il l / ” fs i 5 t l r or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 0
epr oh U tdt e; n K hd o u o e o e hn Mc en B G K tue s d xo tte ne Sts ad B a n cs m st r a ac ny C. Bhs xt t i a ) t r ht l / ie
s e t s v Mc en B G Mc en B G h pd ur wm e a t K i N a ga ol o e e ac ny C. ac ny C s pe c a a rl o Bn i r u ly r l / l / i t ti s ca ,
we K a e b d h m n ray o wa s t ye ak s K r und h a e b d h e B s m e te i o ed- - e u- p jce. B e re te s m e r s l t t r it t t s l
g mn d el bc t Mc en B G n h U tdSts Mc en B G hn o te a e s i c y ak o ac ny C i te ne t e r t rt l / i a . ac ny C te s d h l / l
jce t i UScs m s n u n r ae sc a Sa ad Ceny ak sot .. u o e, c d gei r uh s e s n J Pne t s t r i l i tl s r .
Te r efrK’s et Mc en B Gw e os b K. n ed h p csw e h p cs o B a so ac ny C e n e y B Is a te r e e i sl l / r tt t , i r
s b P l Loy B G C e Oe t gOiea ht m wo aete o anabde e y hi ob C ’ h f p a n f c t e e h bsdh m n nu ug s t ip , s i ri f rt i , l t
p p e b sv a n v u sn u n B G V e rs e o Mnfc r g n K’ P n r a d y ee l d i a ic d g C ’ i P i n f au t i ad B l t er riidl li s c ed t a un s a
Mng.1 A huhK ws oepc do an pot u ntet tu paetws xe e aae 3 l og B a n xe et e arf dr ghs r p hs i aepc d r t t t r i i a- , t
–we oe t n bgnn 98 tateK wu tr aesnb potw h ae ya.
hn p a os eai 19 –h h B o dun raoa e rf i i f w e s ri t l l i tn r
Y,r mht m K c m ecd rdc oi 19 u i t esd p a osn 07n pot e fo te e B o mne pouinn 98 nl cae oe t ni 20 o rf t i t ti ri , i
ee m e azd Ide K oe tdt lsfr v y e oi e s ne v a rl e ned B p a aa o oee ya ft xt c r t ii . , re s r r s ie .
M Loy ee h e r sdh p csh Mc en B G a K o y w e v te r ob nv te s a ete r eta ac ny C p d B n ti oe h . r lsi i t l / i l c r
cu e fK’l e m – ne o e m a eJ y 99 u b o te m cad etsu ws or o B i t e oc s mi e f r u 19 b e r h e hn s ai e a s s fi t t l t fe r i s
i pr dn 00 01adhn ne g nn 05 Mroe ds t K’rcr ossie mo ei 20 20 nte oc aa i 20 t / , i . o v, epe B eod f u a d e r i s tn
lse K ws of eo eie n od fo Mc en B G Nrwsr e v oet ay o s B a n r t dc n ayre r m ac ny C. o a p c ee pno n s, te l r l / i r
o e cu e o epoe,r n o efr ong iin ewe K ad Mc en B G K f r on r f rrcs oayt ro mf eoa o b en B n ac ny C. B f/ t - f s h tt t l /
wseu et f fl v y re p cd y Mc en B Gado o oth p cta ws e arq rdo ui ee od l e b ac ny C, nt d s a e r eh as i ll r r a l / t i t t
b M Loy h C e Oe t gOie o B G y r ob te h f p a n f c f C.
. , i ri f r
I t s epc Mc en B G da ns w h K df e fo Mc en B G n h rse, ac ny C ’ eig i i t l / s l t B i e d r m ac ny C ’
fr l / s
13 O ala oeocs n M Loylo os tdw h h C e F aclOie o ntes n ca o r ob a cnue i te h f i n a f c f t i, . s l t i n i f r BG C.
or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 1
da nsw hXCl aD m ia g mna e b cn a o ad tes ma cn a o t eig i - e ( o i cn a e s m y o rc r n o ri i r o rc r o l t l n r t s l t t) h l t ts
w c Mc en B Gws or a d Tu fr x m e we Mc en B Go XClh h h ac ny C a n et . hs oea p, hn ac ny C t d - ete i l / t le , l l / l l
p c ta Mc en B G ws wl g opy o ap t u r t eojce XCldc e r e h ac ny C a ii t a fr ai l s l f ak, - e e dd i t l / ln rc a y t l i
we e o n t are o rdcte od a e d e m igwe eicu epct tr a h h r o o g t poue h gos f r e r i n h h t o d xe o un tr t e t t n tr l t
pot n h bs e . U ieK,XCl n Mc en B G o e cn a o w ere o rf o te u ns n k B - e ad ac ny C ’ t r o rc r e f t i i s l l l / s h t ts r e
r e od sr mh c may ffr x m ea r e f rd y Mc en B Gws o l w e c re fo te o pn i o ea p, p c o e b ac ny C ato o. jt r ,, l i fe l /
F a ys m oteK m cad etsu ws mo e a ee l O oe 20 we i l , o e fh B e hn s a se ai pr df r a y c b 00 hn nl r i i t t r t r ,
K’ o e on y N a ga– a rn d ee c r sts netene t e C iba Bsh m cu r –i r u wsg t bn i ayt uud hU tdSts a ben t ca ae fi a r i a - r
Bs rd P te h A ( C T A.Se 9...§ 72b(s nN a gaae g l fr a nT e a n s p c “ B P ” e 1 USC 20()lt g c au sl i e o i a r ri t ) ii i r ib
ds nin s ee c r on y ne c f c v O.2 00 e r ia o ne te e ga o a bn i aycu r ud t f t e c ,20) t m t nud h i t fi t rA,e ei t ;D e ni r
C iba a nA,6 Fd Rg 0 3 ( c 1 20) g n n N a gabn i ayt u a benBs c 5 e e , 6 O. 0 00 (r t gi r u ee c r sts r i t . .6 2 t , ai c a fi a ,
ad o f n T U,e eie c , 00 Ud teA,l i e odfo “ee c r n md y gH S S f c v O.220) ne h c e g l gosr m bn i ay ii ft t . r t ib fi
cu r s sc a N a gamyb i pr d n te ne t e u - e e gnr l 1 oni ” uh si r u a e mo e i o hU tdStsd yre e eeay 9 te ca t t i a t f .S l
USC § 720 (s nc t n onis n gos sl i e od yrera mn neA ) ...§ 20-3lt ge a cu r ad od ae g l fru - e t t e ud c.
ii ri te ib tf e t rt
I p t u rtee hn s l i e osc d yre ra mn n ue“pa lrc s ta nai l , hm cad ee g l fr uh u - e t t e ic dsap eai e” h rc a r i ib tf e t l r tl t
w ea e b d n C T Abn i ay on yfo fb cwo yfr ead uitene e s m e ia B P ee c r cu r “ m ar sh l o mdn c nhU td r s l fi t r i l t i
Sts ad e hn mo ed el i ohU tdSts ne sbed g 82 0 0 f h t e” n w etei pr d rc y n tene t e ud uha n 90 0 8 o te a r t i t t i a r i ..
H S S4– ht i c sf a o fr h m cad etsu h e w c i n i d p e Se T U 1 teaf l si t n ote e hn s ai e e , h hs o n i u. e rf a i ci r i s r i t st
14 H S S uha n 90 0 8 cv s[ rc s. a e b d bodnwo o n a T U sbed g 82 0 0 oe “ ]i e..s m e arai h er p t i .. r atl s l l i r ofb c e c moe ste rdc oteU tdSts w c ( w e xo e i cn t n f ar a d o pnn, h pou f h ne t e h h a e epr d n odi it t t i a, i ) r t io ray o a e b w hufr efb cin()hv n lste py c ie i i sc ed fr s m y i o u h ar a o b ae o o h r hs a dnt n uh s l t t t r it , t t i i l ty ai e b cagifr, hp oo e w eadchv n be avnei v u o mrvd rc s y hneno msaert ri , n( ae o en dacdn a er poe tl h s ) t l i i cn t n bod xe b b n a e b d n ecpb oe t nic e a oh a e b n odi ara ecp y e g s m e ad xe y p a osn dnl te s m y io t i s l t ri i tt s l poe sc a c a n lb cig n p n n ” Sbed g 82 0 0 H S S rcs uh sl n g ur a n ad a t g uha n 90 0 8 T U.
s e i , it ii . i .., or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 2
1 USC 20()2 AiI; S o ())C 8SbhI H S S ea orc min 9...§ 73b ) )))U .N e7bi h , uc I T U;sel Po a a o ( ( (( . t (, .9 ., s l t
75 o O oe , 00 o m e e te ne t e C iba Bs T d P te h A, 31 f c b t r220 t I p mn hU tdSts a ben a n r e a n s p c l t i a - r i a r ri t
Fd e 9 2 5 33 O., 00( o f n H S S o n ueUS N e ()) C 9 e.Rg , 9 9 3 ( c 420) md y g T U t ic d .. o 7bi h 8 .5 3 , , t ii l t (, . ,
SbhI H S Se eieO., 00 uc I T U,f c v c 220)
., ft t .
Prun o rqe fo Mc en Cs mssedd q din fh m cad e u a t aeus r m ac ny u o s upnel u a o ote e hn s s t t l , t iit r i
ai u pn n te eo t no v iu v uin etd susic d g– np t u r– t s e ed g h rs u o f a os a a o- l e i e n u n i ai l s i li r l t ra s , li rc a
Mc en’ ci ta Cs m ueo “ asc o v u” oap ie h gos wu b ac ny l m h u o s s f t nain a e t pr s te od o d e l s a t t ’ r t l a l
iaport bcueacr nt Mc en)hr a os p ewe K ad Mc en B G nprp a eas(cod go ac ny eet nh b en B n ac ny C ie i l t li i t l /
hdn unete r e Mc en ageta ud tei u s ne tem cad e hu aif ecdh p c ac nyrudh, ne h c c m acs h e hn s so d l i. l t r r t , r i l
b ap ie bsd n ddc v v u ” e pr sd ae o “euie a e 1 a t l.5
Cs mrv wd up mnlno min n wrse s u mtd y Mc en te u o se e e sp e e a fr a o ad okhe sb ie b ac ny hn t i l ti t t t l ,
rqe e i en av er mCs m Haqa e. R y go aSp me 20 lt t eus d n ra d c fo u o s edu t s e i n e e b 01 ee o t t l i t rr ln t r tr
Cs mi w c Mc en’ cus hdt e ta “]r h 19 ya”p cs o K’ u o s n h h ac ny one a std h, [ ote 99 e, r e fr B t i l s l a t f r i s
m cad e hd be e a ihd “ t a m ln h ng iin” w h B G Cs m e hn s a en s bse a e r s eg eoa os i r i tl fr ’ t tt t C, u o s
t
Haqa e cn ue –bsdo te“ ru s ne ote a ” e – h te et nh edu t s oc dd ae n h c c m acs f h s e ts ta h r a os p rr l i t l t t li i
b we K ad Mc en B G a n “ f ec” n r e Cs m Haqa e te fr e en B n ac ny C hd oi l ne o p cs u o s edu t sh eo t l / nu i . t rr r e
15 I adino upn nl u a o o h 20 ad 01 nis Cs ma o upne n d t t ssed g q dinf e 00 n 20 e r , u o sl ssedd io i iit t te t s l u a o o e r s md i 19 ( h h r n ai u i t s c o) Cs m ep se i i t n f ni ae n 99 w c a o ts e n h ain u o s xr sd q di te i e t s i t . t e rs vin ao te dqayo Mc en B G dc mnt n n se ig ro i te ee a os bu h aeuc f ac ny C ’ ou e a o ad e m e r n h rt t l / s ti n rs c may ddc v v u srase s Nn h e , h aec ui al aq ecd o h o pn’ euie a e p dhe. oe e s te gny l m e cu se t te s t l e t tls t ty i c may ci w h epct te19 e r s n ap ie te bsdo ddc v v u o pn’ l m i rse o h 99 ni ad pr sd h m ae n euie a e s a t t te a t l, cig so aefCs m prp sne o odca ef a o H wv,Cs mep s y i n a hr g o u o s o e on t cnu v i cin o ee u o s xr s t t t t r l t ri t . r t el cu oe Mc en B G t h t m ta ci s o sbeun ya wu b rv wd n a ind ac ny C atei e h l m fr usqe e s o d e e e e ad t l / t a t r l i poe e bsd nh r us n v m i.Se eeay e’ B ea2 D. Rp B ea rcs d ae ote sb a ie et e gnr l D. r ft; e’ e y r ft s i tt rs l fs i fs l i 2. n.3 or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 3
av eta h poebs fr pr s mn ws asc o v u p s d t n Se Q 445 d sdh terp a soap ie e at nain a el adi s e H 587 i t r i a t r t l u io .
(M c 2 20) D . B e Eh M Acr n y al u a o Cs m ap ie te a h 5 04 ( e’ r f x ) cod g , ti i t n u o s pr sd h r , fs i , . . il q di , t a
m cad e nh bs ot nain a eth u t a e a e e d n u n a a onfr e hn s ote a s fr sc o v u a e n v us s n r , c d g n mu o r i i a t l t i l teili t
te a e o USc moe s D isw ese e a h v iur e d iefo te p ia e h v usf .. o pnn. ue e a s dt e a osa s e vdr mh apcb l t t r ss t r t r l l
sbed gi H S SCa e 6 e gnr l Sbed g 82 0 0 H S S uha nsn T U hp r 2 e eeay uha n 90 0 8 T U.
i t .S l i ..,
Te a e Mc en fe fu po s, ee t gt ci fr pr s mn bsd n h e t , ac nyi d or r e srt a n i l m o ap ie e ae o r fr l l t t i ri s a a t
ddc v v u adi oeotepo s, seig ci frd yrera mn ud te euie a e n n n f h r e sa r n a l m o u - e t t e ne h t l, , t t st a tf e t r
C T A Cs m dn d Mc en’ po s, n t s c o ese B P. u o s e e ac ny r e sad h ain nud t i l s tt i t .
I t n ad fRv w I a dr o e e .S i
W hepc o Mc en’ci so u - et a mnud teU tdt e C iba i rse t ac ny l mt d yre e e ne h ne Sts a ben t t l sa tf rt t r i a - r
Bs T d P te h A ( C T A ,h Gv n e sesi m s frakf u e mt a n r e a n s p c “ B P ” te oe mn ek d i a o c osb c ae i a r ri t ) r t s sl l j t tr
jr dt n soh m ot ote nistsu Se eeay einI A. i r U CT us c o atte a r y fh e r a se e gnr l sc o I.. a n a SI i ii ji te i . l t I 1, f ;
R1()1 Te xtne f u e mt jr dt ns trso iq r e, g S e C . 2b ) h e s c osb c ae us c oi ah h dnu y ee. t l o (. ie j t t r i ii e l i .S . , e .
v Cies oaBt Ev o mn 53US8 9-5 19) We sb c mt jr dt n . iznfr ee n rn e , 2 .. 3 49 (98 h e u e ae us c o t tr i t , . r j t t r i ii
i caegdtep t ivk g us c o ba tebre o po n i e s ne Tu e s hlne h a y no n jr dt n e s h udn f rv gt xt c rs d l , r i i ii r i s ie . t
I erin n v U tdt e 69.d 1916(e C. 01 seloc u v Gn a n g t , c . ne Sts 5 F 15 13 Fd i 21) e a M N t. ee l t ao I . i a , 3 , . r ; s t r
M o Acp neCr 28US1819 13) NrkHdoCnd Icv U tdSts o r ce ac op 9 .. 7 8 (96 o ts t ., , ; s yr aaa n . ne t e , . i a,
42F d 3715 (e C. 06 7 . 14 35 Fd i 20)
3 , . r .
Mroe i s x mita“th U td t e asv e n s m uer m u sv o v , i a o ach ‘]e ne Sts s oe i , i mnfo s t ae e rt i t t [ i a, rgi i
aicne so e ud., n [ a tee m oi cne t b sei ay ord ieh st osn t b se.. adt t ht s ft osn o e udn n cu e nta t h] r s t t f t
cu’jr dt n o n ri te u. U tdStsv Mce,45 US 55 58 18) ors us c o t e e a h s t ” ne t e . i hl 4 .. 3 3 (90 t i ii tt n i’ i a t l , or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 4
(u igU tdSts .Se wo, 1 US 54 56 14) se loleo C v U td qo n ne t e v h od 32 .. 8 8 (91;e a B pr o . ne t i a r , ) s u t . i
Sts 53F d 3417 (e C. 08 Gog o nS e Cr v U tdSts81F d t e, 3 . 17 38 Fd i 20) ere w t l op . ne t e 0 . a 3 , . r ; t e . i a, 2
10 11 (e C. 96 Tu we – s e – w v osv e n m u t i ai u 38 32 Fd i 18) hs h e a h e a a e f oe i i mn ysts e , . r . , r r ir rg i s,
te agaeotet u ms b sil cnre ad n a b uis eo e i fvro h lnug f h st e u et c y os ud n ay m g t rs vd n ao f at t rt t , i ie l
i mn y F Av Coe __ US __ __ 12S C 14 14 (02(t gU td m ut i. A . op , __ .. __ __ 3 . t 41 48 21) ci r , , . , i n ne
i
Sts. Wl m, 1 US5751 19) Z tkCr v U td t e 62 .d 3911 t e v ii s 54 .. 2 3 (95; oe op . ne Sts 7 F 10 38 a la , ) l . i a, 3 ,
(e C. 02 H tgFos nlIcv U tdSts 21F d 8 71 Fd C. 02 Fd i 21) a o odI ’ n . ne t e 9 . 79 9 (e i 20) . r ; r t, . i a , 3 , . r .
W hepc o Mc en’ C T Al m oc n ghfue r s oe d yPo s i rse t ac ny B P ci cne i te or ni cv e b r e t t l s a rn te r tt
N 10-4105ta w emd p ot O oe 220 ( ef c v d e fh C T A s o 830-006h e ae r ro c b , 00t e eie a ote B P a . t r i t r h ft t
t gosr mN a ga teGv n e mvsoi m soflrt st al m pnw c o odfo i r u ,h oe mn oet d i fra u ot e ci uo h h ca ) r t s s i e a a i
ri cn e rn dSe eeay einI A. i r U CTR1()5 O sc am in ee a b g t . e gnr l sc o I.. b n a SI . 2b ) n uh o o lf ae l t I 1, f ; (. t ,
te mvn hs h bre o d mnrig h n ci hs ent e Se eeay BC h oa ate udn f e os a n ta ol m a be std e gnr l 5 .
t tt t a a . l
W g &A Ml , ee l rcc ad rcdr § 37p 466 (d d20)“W g & rh i t . ie Fd a P t e n Poeu 15 p 5-2 3 e 04( r h lr r ai e , . . it
Ml ” Fr e te or ms“os ute o pi ite g ms ao b ttel nf ie ) u h ,h cu u cnreh c m a tnhl h o fvr l oh pi i, l r. t r t t t ln it t ae a tf
acp t aea os sread r wlraoa en rnei fvr fh pi i. I r Bl ce i l gin atu n d a esnb if ecsnao otel nf” ne i ts l t , a l l e a tf l
o Ld gT n m s n n Poe igSs mP e Lia o, 8 F d 3313 (e C. f a n r s i i ad rcs n y e a n i gin 61 . 12 31 Fd i i a so s t tt t t 3 , . r
21)selosco vIb , 5 US6268 20) A ooO C v U tdSts24 02 e a Ah f . qa 56 .. 6 7 (09 mc i o . ne t e 3 ; s rt l , ; l . i a,
F d 3417 (e C. 00 1 Tu te ups oa m in oi m s oflrt st a . 17 36 Fd i 20) 6 hs h proe f o o t d i fra u ot e 3 , . r . , t s s i e a
ci i n t “ s v ] cn s b we te ais butea s r h sb a ie m i o l ms o o r o [ a o e e en h p t ao h fc ote us n v et f a t el e tt t re t t tt rs
16 Otetehn a o pi ’“]rab eet sfh e mn oa as oain nh o r ad c m a t [ h da rca o el e sf cuef c o h , l ns t e r il t e t t , spo e b m e oc sr st mn, o osf c”o asyhrq r mn ote ee l upr d y e cn uoyt e e sd n uiet si teeu e e s fh Fd a t r l a t t f tf i t r R e Ah o vIb , 5 USa68 Mroe “ eee h a or msacpatu a u s sc f . qa 56 ..t 7 l. rt l . o v,t tn ta cu u ce srel e r h t t t t t l otel gin cnie i a o pi iiapcb t lg cn u os I. fh aea os o a d n c m a ts np ia e oea oc s n ” d l t tn ln l l l li .
or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 5
te nn mvnscs ”5 W g & Ml § 36p34 H wv, des vt “ s h h[o- oa ’ ae B r h t] . i t ie 15 . 5 o ee i os e eot t e lr , . rt r et
fr asf c nyotet e e ote l m ori , caeg g te eater ote o m ui ec f h st mn f h ci fr ee ” hln n “ lg hoy f h l fi a t a lf l i h l
c m a t I. Avne C d vsu rSs m Ic v S mdL eSs m Ic 98F d o pi . d dacd a i ac a y e s n . c e i y e s n, 8 .
l n” ; ro l t , . i f t , . 2
15 16 (e C. 93(x a igh m inoi m s oflrt st ci i ds nd 17 10 Fd i 19)epi nta o ot d i fra u ot el ms e ge , . r ln t t s s i e a a i
“ a o te ort e m a aintaa f a yl wd n h rea p m e ad eie t l wh cu ol i t c os h r al f e i te lg r i s n ds nd ol t i ne t t e tl a i l e s t
t fl. Asc “n a o pi tasts p u b ci freesr vssc] m in oa” s uh o y c m a th t e al s l l mori uv e[uha o o i) , l ln t a ai e a lf i t
t d m s Ah o vIb, 5 USa697 oi i . sc f . qa 56 ..t 71 s s” rt l .
F a y b hp t s ek u m y ug e o c t nci s Segnr l sc o i l , o ai se s m a jd mn n e a l m e eeay ein nl t re r t ri a . l t
I.. c n a ad s n Gv n e ’ m inos m ayug e at c t n nis nt d I A. i r (dr s g oe mns o ofr u m jd mn so e a e r e ie I 1, f ei r t t r t ri t e tl
t d yrera mnud C T A sc o I.. i r(drs n Gv n e ’ m in o o u - et t e ne B P ) einI A,n aad s g oe mns o o fr tf e t r ; t I 2 f ei r t t
s m ay ug e cnen gpoe m hdo ap ie e )sc o I., n a ad s n u m jd mn oc i rp e o f pr s mn; einI Bi r (dr s g r t rn r t a t t I f ei
Mc en’ co - o o cnen g a e;U CTR 5 1 S m ay ug e i a ao d ac ny rs m in oc i s m ) SI . 6 8 u m jd mn s fvr l s s t rn . r t e
17 Te i a p a hr y ote rpsinh am inoi m s oflrt st a h es m e u ot frh poot ta o ot d i fra u ot e r l t i io t t s s i e a ci msbfe b o teev ef rsos ela n o e w etmsbt a dhog l m u e ld e r hs i oaepn v p d g t ri , u e e etruh a t i fe rc i e i ; h si t rt s m o e vhl sc a a m in ojd mn o tep a nso a m in o s m ay o e t r e c, uh s o o fr ug e n h l d g r o o fr u m h ie t t ei t r jd mn Se SI R1()st gh “ m inseig n o h ] e ne[s dnR e ug e . e U CT . 2b( a nta a o o a r n ayf e d ess i ei u t ti t t st t[ f lt l 1() ms b md b o p a n i arsos e p a n i a o e” Avne 2b] u e ae e r l d g f t fe ei epn v l d g s l wd ; dacd i ei l )
C d vsu rSs m , 8 F dt 10 n ig h Fd a R e a hr e e na t fe a i ac a y e s 98 . a 16 (o n ta ee l u s u o z d edn oi ro l t 2 t t r l t i f t l m inoi m s b o fig rsos el a n” 5 W g & Ml § 37p48 Ud o ot d i “e r i n aepn v p ed g ; B r h t s s f el i i ) i t ie 15 . 0 ne lr , . r
tei u s ne ot s aeh wv, mks oi e newe ete pci ci stsu h c c m acs fh cs o ee i ae n df ec h h h se f l m a se r t i , rt fr tr ic a i a aa zd hog te eso a m in od m s oflr t st a l mo a m in o r n ye truh h ln f o o t i i fr a u ot e ci r o o fr e l t s s i e a a t s m ayug e . Te u o es h s m e h wy u m jd mn h o c mite a ei e a r t t tr . 18 Te Gv n e sge s h te“rs m ino cr c e ”aahs o Cs m h oe mn ugs ta h p u p o f o e ns t ce t u o s r t t t e t rt s t t ’
dcin ouernainv u t ap ie h sb c m cad e SeD. B e a 1 e s t s t sc o a e o pr s te u e e hn s e e’ r f t 0 io a t l a jt r i. fs i (u igVW o A e c 15.dt 32 n igh a p s m in f o e ns aahso qo n t P f m ia 7 F a14 (o nta “r u p o ocr c e t cet r , 3 t t e t rt st eey a u d e m a oncsayo upra ap ia )e pa s de) H wv,h v fc a e ri t nee rt spo n pr s ”( mhs add. o ee te r t l t ni s t al i ) r st oy rs m in f o e nsta Cs m dcin e o ud 2 USC§ 69 )1 t u r p u p o o cr c e h u o s e s s n y ne 8 ... 23( () at e t rt s t t ’ io j r a hs o o e rf cate u m yug e s g o poed g bcue u m yug e a n fr oe e th s m a jd mn t e f rce ns eas s m a jd mn c ft r ta i , r t my e n rd n ite i n gn n d p e s o n m e afc– n ite i n sc a b e e o yfh es o eu ei u at ay a rla ad fh es o uh te l r i st ti t , r or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 6
poeu l e c “ scrteu, pey niepn v d e m a o o[nain C o x rcdr dv et eu hjs sed adnxes e e r i t nfa] c o ” e t a i o e t i t ni t . le
Cr v C rt 47US373718)qo n Fd R C..) e a oS e s ah n Ic op . a e , 7 .. 1 2(96(u ig e . i P1 sel . tt , t . v ; s wa Fs os n t i , .
v Pn l K t n C , 3 F d 5016 (e C. 97 Ide teCu o Apa hs . anl nt g o 83 . 16 52 Fd i 18) ned h or f pe s a i ii . 2 , . r . , t l
hld u m yug e a a s u r poeu ..o v d nee ay xestte ais ae s m a jd mn s “a t y rcdr .t ao uncs r epneoh p t i r t la e i s re
ad ws f ul a o o tejr poe adjdi rsu e ” n a eu ti t n f h uy rcs n u cl eor s t l izi s ia c. B mg B m a a a e r r r
Msh efb kA v Mr a Mc n y L ., 3 Fd 3 85 Fd C. 94 ac nn r G. u t ah e , t 71 2 81 3 (e i 18)
i ai a ir d , . r .
Nv te s ud U CTR e 6 u m yug e iaport o yweteeod ee h e , ne SI u 5 s m a jd mn s prp a n hnhrcr r ls r l , r t ie l
e dne–“ c d gdpsin dc mn,e c o cl s rd no min aia t o v ec i i l i eot s ou e s l t n a y t e ifr a o f dvs r nun io , t er i l o t , f i
dc rin s p a os., d s os n roa r as e,ad o e m e a ” e a ihs e a t s t ut n .am s n i e g oy n w s n] t r a rl –s bse l a o , i li . ii , t r t r[ h ti s t l
ta “ e i n gn n d p ea t ay a rl a ”ad h mv gp t “ e ie t h t r s o eu e i u s o n m e afc n te o n a y i nt d o t he i st ti t i r s tl
jd mna amt ol w U CTR5( &c 1 A selo C o x47USa322 ug e s ae fa. SI . 6 ) ( () ) e a t tr ” a ) (; s e t , 7 ..t 2-3 le ;
Ad sn .L e yLbyIc, 7 US 22 274 (96 I adin we a m in o ne o v i r ob n 47 .. 4 4-8 18) n d t , h e o o fr r bt , . , . io r t
s m ayug e ife adrp l spo e a av s p t my o e uo m e e a u m jd mn s ld n poe y upr d n de e a y a n rs pn e dnl r t i r t, r r t t r is
t d e i T te o r y h ops g a yms“t ] o aiu r as fm e a ite o e a t o h cn a , e po n p t u c[ t p t l p t o a rl nh f t. tr t i r t ie rc a r ti s
rcr”o s bste p sne f gn n d p e w rn nt a U CTR5(. Ad f eodt e a ihh “r ec oa eu e i u ” a a igrl SI . 6 ) n i tl e i st r t i. c ,
a a y flt poe y drs ao e p t’ a ein f a,taa ein f a my e p t “ i o rp l ad s n h a y s r o ofc” h s r o ofc a b r as r e t r r s st t t st t
fc a d p ete Cs m de n ne te eet f n p s m in See. U v s a u i u, hn u o s os o ed h bn i o ay r u p o e, g n e a tl st t t f e t . . , i rl E c o c Icv U td t e, 1 F d 8 429 (e C. 97(x a igh st oy l t n s n . ne Sts 12 . 48 9-3 Fd i 19)epi nta t u r er i , . i a 3 , . r ln t at p s m in f o e ns “ais o o e s o us os fa ” R l b d Icv U td r u p o o cr c e c r n fr at qein ol w ; oe l e n . ne e t r t s re c t ) lr a , . i Sts 12.d 8 438(e C. 97( a ntap s m inf o e ns“ i e vn t e, 1 F 41 8-4 Fd i 19)st gh r u p o ocr c e i r l a a 3 , . r ti t e t rt s sre t we te i n fc a d p e ewe te ais ;Go mn Mg LPv U tdSts 6 h e h es o a u i u b en h p t ” od a f, ... ne t e , 9 r r tl st t re ) . i a F d 0 58 Fd C. 95(o nta asn a u d p e ewe p t s“ ers m in . 55 0(e i 19)n igh, be fc a i u b en ai ,t p u p o 3 , . r t t t tl st t re h e t o cr c e i n r ea ” Ide teCu o Apa dcin nw c teGv n e f o e ns s o e vn ) ned h or f pe s e s o h h h oe mn r t s t l t. , t l io i r t ris VW o A e c – i n iv v apl e e e o a e s n n u m y ug e . ee – P f m ia d o no e pea rv w f dci o s m a jd mn l r d t l lt i io r t VW hd oe orlSe P fA e c , 7 F dt 32 n ig h dcin fCu o P a gnt t a e VW o m ia 15 . a 13 (o n ta e s o or f i. r 3 t t io t I enin T d ud rv wwsed e “] l w g t a ) n ra oa r e ne e e arne d[ o oi arl. t t l a r i r fl n i ”
or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 7
de e “n su d o proe otem in U CTR5( ()9 e md ud p e fr upss f h o o ” SI . 6 )2 1 i t t . e .
Ui al teuc o o hjdeths m ayug e s g “ n h me t w g l m e ,hfninf eug a e u m jd mn t ei o i s fo e h t ty t t t r ta s t l i
te v ec ad e r iehtu otemt b t d e m ewe ete i a eu esu h e dne n d e m ter h fh ae u o e r i h h h es gn ni e i t n t tr t t n tr r i s
frrl Ad snv L e yLby 47 USa 29 Teqeinte “ n we e[ ot a” ne o . i r ob, 7 .. t 4 h us o hn i o h h a i. r bt . t , , s t tr
p t’ pofwll m e bfud ov c g r e us e.. R h,h qeins n a y ] ro i ui al e on cn n n o p sa v.. a e te us oi o y r s l t ty ii r i tr t l
we ete ais ae rofrh rl m.. u hh arls edd 1 Mo ’ Fd a h h h p t hv pof ote ci s. s cta t a nee ” 1 or s ee l tr re i a t ii . e r
P cc § 6 21 p5-8 3 e 21)“Mo ’ Fd a P cc” Asc amvn s o r t e 5 0[] . 61 (d d 03( or s ee l r t e. s uh oa i n ai . , . e r ai ) , t t
e iet s m ayug e “ e l bcuehfc te a yf rapa mr p u b ta nt do u m jd mn m e eastea sh p t o e pe o l s l hn tl r t ry t r fs r e ai e
toeed ei opsino bcue apa ta h av s ys n k yo rvltrl hstne dn pot , r easi pe sh te de a i u ie t p a a i.
r io t r t rr l l e i ta
T ssre vnhuh o p t smvfr u m yug e ” ate ais ae oe e . h itu eetog b h ai oe os m a jd mn – sh p t hv dn h e i t re r t re r
1 AC W g ,A Ml , & M K Kn Fd a P cc adPoeu § 75p 423 (d 0 . r h . ie it lr . . ae ee l r t e n rcdr 22 p 3-3 3 , r ai e , .
e 19) “W g , Ml , &Kn” S m ay ug e i poe “n we arlwu b d 98( r h ie . i t lr ae . u m jd mn s rp o y hn t a o d e ) r t r l i l
sp f os 1 Mo ’ Fd a P cc § 6 21 p5-6 uel u ” 1 or s ee l r t e 5 0[] . 61 ru . e r ai . , .
A a ymv g os m ayug e tu “ h do signs nad 1 A W g , p t o n fr u m jd mn hsi e t at ne t d . 0 r h r i r t s l r t a r” it
Ml, &Kn § 77 p 47 I ea a n a u m y ug e m in“n du at te ie lr ae 22 . 5 n v uig s m a jd mn o o ay ob s o h , . lt r t t , t
e s ne f gn ni u o m e afc wl eeo e aa stemvn”I. 22 p xt c oa eu es e f a rla i brs vd g n h oa . d § 77 p ie i s ti t l l it t , .
19 Atei eh Gv n e feteSt mno Fc taac ma ei m in o tht mte oe mn i dh t e e f a sh co pn dt o o fr r tl a t t t i s t s m ayug e , n a ht m Mc en fe i rsostteGv n e ’ m in h u m jd mn adt e e ac nyi dt epneoh oe mns o o te r t t i l l s r t t , apcb r eeu e amvn oi “ sp a, hrad oc et e e .. fh m e a p ia e u rq rd oa t fe a ea t so n cn s st mn . ote a rl l l l i t l re t i a t ti fc at w ctemv g a y o edte i n gn ni ut bt e ” nfr estd a sso h hh o n p t cn nsh es o eu es eo e id adu h t e t i i r t r i s r , tra :
A m e afc s o itet e e [fm e afc]eu et b s vd y l a rla s e u nh st mn o a rla srq rdo e e e b l ti t t t a t ti t i r te mvn wlb de e a mtd u e cn oe e b te[ sos e h oa i e e md die n s o rv td y h r pn v tl t ls t r e i]
st mnrq rd o e evd y h ops g a y t e e eu e t b s e b te po n p t a t i r i r.
U CTR5()1 & 3( fc v Jn120)e pa s de) SI . 6h ) ()e eie a , 09( mhs add ( f t . i .
or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 8
475 I adin“b cueh brei otemvn te v ec..l ass os ud 5-8 n d t ,[] aste udns nh oa ,h e dne. awyi cnre . io e t i t
i fvrotep t ops g h m in n teopnni g e tebn i o a fvrb n ao f h a y po n te o o ad h poe s i n h eet f l ao l r i t t v f l ae
if ecs h cn e r w fo i” d § 77p49 Mroe “ c a e e b te a y n rneta a b d nr mt I. 22 . 5 e t a . , . o v, f t s r d y h p t e r a s st r
ops gh m in f upr d yf dvs rtee dnaym e a a rg dd sre po nte o o ispo e b aia t o o r v e i i t , t f i h i t r a rl r ea e atu ”
t i, e r .
I. 22 p 496 d § 77 p 5-2 , . .
I so, eastef cote n y f u m yug e i “ te d sc s m ay n hr bcueh e e fh e r os m a jd mn sr h r t, u m t ft t r t a r ai ” r
jd mn so e cu os ivkd ad sd w h deead oi proe ”1 A W g , ug e it b “a iu ynoe” n ue “i a urg fr s upss 0 r h t t l t r t . it
Ml, &Kn § 72 p 251 S m ay ug e tui n aport we te a ie lr ae 21 p 1-6 u m jd mn hss o prp a h e h e r , . . r t t ie r r e
“dob at te rd it o a mvns f a s rw nse ”I. 22 p40 S ma y []u s s o h c i l y f oa ’ ain o i e s d § 76 . 4 i i r , t e bi t f t t s. , . ll
s m ay ug e i n aport we “ e v ec p sn d . i sb ct cniig u m jd mn s o prp a h et e dne r e e. .s u e o ofc n r t t ie r h i e t jt lt
i ep tin oraoa e ep m h df at i s niac ”I. 22 p 433 n rr a os r esnb po e i t i e s ot i i cne d § 75 p 3-7 t et , l l g fr s gf . , . .
Ad u m yug e i n aport “ te x tnefm e afc suss ne a . I. n s m a jd mn s o prp a i h e s ec o a rla i ei uc t n d r t t ie f i ti t s ri ”
§ 72p20 Fr e a huh[ hfc h df u qein ol w xt rh te ais 21 . 1 u h ,l og “]ea ta ii l us os fa e sota h p t , . tr t t t t fct t i t re
df oteeacn u oso e r w fo tea ss o n n oi e a rud o dn n i e nhlg oc s nt b d nr mhfc i n i ad f s f gon fr ey g fr l li a t t tl i
s m ay ug e , “] de n f l w . tate iiu y f hlg i uss o pt y u m jd mn” [t os o o o . . h h df l oteea s ei c m el r t i tl t fct ls le
i e vnt teg n o dnlo s m ay ug e . I.§22 p 401 A ap cc r l a o h r t r e a f u m jd mn” d 75 p 1-2 s r t a re t a i r t , . . ai l
mt : ae tr
B o te orcn p yhl w tmshv a aeu ea u bs fr o g e r h cu a ap tea, u ae n dqa fc a a s o d n fe t l i t t tl i i s I s ms uin a ue dv o mnotea smy evt c r yhl w o n o ei a os f l ee p e fhfc a s eol i tea . t t , lr l t t r af o h ph cu d e m e s p ia otte ae A aeu,hrs u o o r e te or e r i i apcinoh cs s rs t eeo t n f l t t nt l t . lt li c m e qein ol wrqe l rq rs mr cn e fc adv o mn o p x us os fa f un yeu e a o oc t a u ee p e l t e t i e re t l l t ta my e bie truh u m y rce ns hn a b o a d hog s m a poed g tn r i .
I. 22 p 421 d § 75 p 1-5 , . .
or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 9
Acr n ya oeed g u ot s m utet e fhl ws m ayug e i a cod g , s nla n a hr y u s ph st otea, u m jd mn s il i t i a r t
dv eh i poe yeevd n frhs ain w c a tu “ e css 1 A W g , e cta s rp l rs e o y otoe c os h hr r y c a ae ” 0 r h i t r r l t i e l lr . it
Ml,&Kn § 75p 482 2 ie lr ae 22 p 2-9 0 , . .
I.A a s I n ys I li
A o l e aoe te p t s hv fe a n me o d psie m in Te s ui d bv h ai ae i d tn , re l u b f i ot r s i v o os
t . h
Gv n e ’ pn n m inic d am inoi m s olc osb c mt jr dt n oe mns ed g o osn ue o ot d i frak f u e ae us c o r t i t l t s s j t t r i ii ,
a m in o i m s oflrt st al m pnw c ri cn e rn dad m in o o o t d i fr a u ot e ci uo h h ee a b g t , n a o o fr t s s i e a a i lf ae t
s m ay ug e a t c t ne r sprunt te U tdStsC iba Bs T d u m jd mn s o e a ni u a o h ne t e a ben a n r e r t ri t e s t i a - r i a
P te h A ( C T A . n d t n h Gv n e ad Mc en hvfe co - o os a n s p c “ B P ” I adi , e oe mn n ac ny ae ldrs m in r ri t ) io t r t l i s t
fr u m y ug e cnen g h poe bs fr pr s mn otem cad etsu os m a jd mn oc i te rp a s oap ie e f h e hn s ai e r t rn r i a t r i s.
Ec ote ais m ini aa zd n un e w ah f h p t ’ o oss n ye i tr b o.
re t l l
A TeGv n e ’ D psie M in . h oe mns i ot
r t s i v o os t
Treo te oen e ’ or ed g o in a ad se t Mc en’ ci fr h f hGv mnsfupn n m t s r dr sd o ac ny l m o e r t i o e e l s a
d yrera mn u untte C T A A d cse b o,l h em ina m i r u u - e t t e pr a oh B P. si u d e wa tr o osr et i s tf e t s t s s l l e t e ro o
ad ms b g n d Se eeay einI A, n a I cn a, ote esn s fr i n u e r t . e gnr l sc o I.. i r n o rs fr h raos e o h n t ae l t I 1 f. t t t t
d a, h Gv n e ’ m in o s m ay ug e ssi n Cs m ueot nain ei te oe mns o o fr u m jd mn u a ig u o s s fr sc o tl r t t r t tn t ’ a t
v u t ap ie Mc en’ m cad e aso b h h fc ad h l w Ta m in a e o pr s ac ny e hn s fl n o te a s n te a. h o o l a l s r i i t t t t
20 We a m in os m ay ug e hs en e e te i n h g h ih e l h e o o fr u m jd mn a be dn d h es o i ta ne n y r t r t i, r tn t rt ad ee al p c dsh mvnfo aa se n s m ayug e ,we e ote a e n ncs r y r l ete oa r m g n ek g u m jd mn h h nh s m si e u t i i r t tr odf e gons e, g 1 Mo ’ Fd aP cc § 6 2 p 5-9-637d cs n ri e n rud ee. 1 or s ee l r t e 5 11 p 6295-0( su ig fr t .S . , e r ai . ,. i s “M t l ad ucs v S m ay ug e M in” 1 A W g , Ml,&Kn § 72p ui e n Sce ie u m Jd mn o os ; 0 r h ie lp s r t t ) i t lr ae 21 p, . 241(o ntarn w os m ayug e m inmy e p t u r aport”we 1-5n igh ee a f u m jd mn o o a b “ai l l prp a t t l r t t rc a y ie h e
r
sbeund cv yee sa s oaaa eti e fitm in usqe i oe rva fc n vlb at m ofs o o)
t s r l t t i l r t .
or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 0
acr n yms b dn d Se eeay einI A, n a cod g u e e e e gnr l sc o I.. i r il t i. l t I 2 f.
1 Mc en’ C T ACi . ac ny B P l m
l s a
TeGv n e hsmvdoi m s olc osb c mt jr dt n Mc en’ h oe mn a oet d i frak f u e ae us c o ac ny r t s s j t t r i ii l s
C T Aci a t a e r so eta toecv e b Po s N 10-4105 A B P l m s o l ni t r hn hs oe d y r e o 830-006 s a l te h r tt . .
d cse b o, htre r e stsu o eta Po s N 10-4105 d n a e i u d e w e h po s ai e t r hn r e o 830-006 i o s r s s l t e tt s h tt . d t st
C T Al m TeGv n e ’ m in o i m s h eo ms b g n d B P ci s h oe mns o o t d i te fr u e r t .
a . r t t s s r e t ae
Fr e te Gv n e hs mvd od m s oflr t st a l m Mc en’ u h , h oe mn a oe t i i fr a u ot e ci ac ny tr r t s s i e a a l s
C T Al mw hepc ohfue r s oe d y r e N 10-4105 w c w e B P ci i rse tte or ni cv e b Po s o 830-006 h h e a t t te r tt . i r
md b o O oe 2 20 te f c v d e f h C T A s o odfo N a ga A ae e r c b , 00 h e eie a ote B P at gosr m i r u s fe t r , ft t ca .
d ae b o,we etemt i aa zd nete ur oam inoi m s oflrt ei d e w h h h ae s n ye ud hrb c f o ot d i fra u o tl l tr tr l r i t s s i e
st al m raenie , s m in ojd mnotela ns r os m ayug e , t e ci o l ra v ya a o o frug e nh p d g ofr u m jd mn a a ,t t l t t ei r t
teGv n e ’rqe free msb g n d n Mc en’ C T Al mmsb dn d h oe mnseus ori u er t ad ac ny B P ci u e e e r t t lf t ae l s a t i
o d m sd s o hsfue r s ri i e at toe or ni .
s s te
Atteh ee a ig nis h Gv n e ses u m yug e ,eus nta sohtr r m n e r , e oe mn eks m a jd mn rqeigh e i n te t r t r t t t
te nis ee q d e d yre w hn rs prun oh C T A As fr b o,h h e r briu a d u - e i i e t u a tte B P. se o h e w a te l i t t f , t t e, s t t t l tt
m ino ms b g n d o o to u e r t . t t ae
a TeGv n e ’ M in oD m s o Lc o Sb c Mt Jr dt n . h oe mns o o t i i fr ak f u e ae us c o r t t s s j t t r i ii
W h epct Mc en’ C T A l mte Gv n e sesd m s fr ako i rse o ac ny B P ci, h oe mn ek i i a olc f t t l s a r t s sl
sb c mt jr dt n u un oU CTR e 2 )1at a e r s oe d yh e fh u e ae us c o pr a t SI u 1( () sol ni cv e btr ote j t t r i ii s t l b l te r e
fu po s ie i eite u mn adC m a t i. Po s Ns10-3107 10- or r e sdnf dnh S m os n o pi – e r e o 830-002 83 tt ti l n ., t t . , or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 1
0-004ad 830-003I o e wrs h Gv n e sesi m s o Mc en’ 4102 n 10-4104 nt r od te oe mn ek d i a f ac ny , . h , r t s sl l s
C T Al molc ojr dt n sole r stetatoe oe d y r e N 10- B P ci frak fus c o at a ni o rhnhs cv e b Po s o 83 a i ii l te h r tt .
0-006 Segnr l D. B e a 2 9 1-3 sea o n w ad Cu e l m¶1 4105 e eeay e’ r f t , , 11 e l As e n on r a . l fs i ; s r t ci
(ey g xtne f u e mt jr dt n ecpfre r scv e b Po s N 10- dn n e s c osb c ae us c o “xe o[ni ] oe d y r e o 83 i ie j t t r i ii t te r tt .
0-006 w h epct Pi i’ ci frd yrera mn ud C T A i ¶3 4105 i rse o l nf s l m o u - e t t e ” ne B P ) d , t t a tf a tf e t r ; . 4
(seig s fr a v d es “ c[[fsb c mt jr dt n v pi i’ ci fr a r n a ai mie e nel k o u e ae us c o oe l nf sl m o st f t f a ] ] j t t r i ii r a tf a
d yre n y ne[ eC T A . arg da e r secp o hs cv e b Po s N u - e e r ud t B P ] .sea sl ni , xe fr oe oe d y r e o tf t rh . r l te t t r tt .
10-4105 bcue oe f h o etre r e s. mks C T Al m. 830-006 eas nn ote t r h po s .. ae a B P ci ” 2 , h e tt a )1
Mc en p d a s us c oh e n 8...§ 51 )w c [] i t m .. ac ny r i t jr dt ne o 2 USC 18(, h h byt e s . l e c e i ii r a i ,“ sr ,
l mshjr dt nf hCu f n ra oaT d ope sr me a o vi po s. i i teus c oo teor I enin r etapa fo dnl f a d r e s t i ii to t t l a l is l t t”
Se o eAosn n vU tdSts15.d 0 98 Fd i 99 2 USC 18( . e K k rno i ,Ic . ne t e,6 F 96 0 (e C.19) 8...§ 51 )
. i a 3 , .r ; a
T b vi po s mss fr – dt c y n se f a y –te a r oec o ein o e a d r e u e o h “ s nl ad pci l ” “ n u f ah b c o l ,a t t t t t ii t i cl h te jt
adhraosh eo ”1 USC§ 54 )1 C selo 9CFR§ 7 1( ()rq r g nteesnte fr 9 ... 11( () ) e a 1 ... 14 3 )6( ui r . c (; s . a e in
ta po s d a “]en u o ad ui ci fr] h o ein efr dt c yad h r e ei [ h a r f n jsf ao o,te b c o s o h ii t n t t t tl t te , ti t n [ jt t t s nl
se f a y. ” Tet u fr e mna sh eey r e ie iy aa , dt c y n pci l ..) h st e u h ad eta v po s dnf – g n“ s nl ad i cl . at t r t t r tt t i ii t
21 Te cp adp cc e e ote Gv n e ’ m in od m sa s m wa h soe n r t a f c f h oe mns o o t i i r o e h ai l f t r t t s s e t uc a Mc en’ Fs A eddC m a t pe so m te o pn’ C T Al mo n e. ac ny it mne o pi apa tl i h c may B P ci t lr l s r ln r it s a o yhs e r s oe d yhfu po s a su w c w e e e d n rf rO oe 2 n toe ni cv e bte or r e st se h h e “n r o oa e c b , l te r tt i i r te t t r 20” h e eie a o h C T Aso odfo N a ga SeitA eddC m a t 00( ef c v d ef e B P at gosr m i r u. e Fs mne o pi t ft t t ca ) r ln ¶ 6 Ifr e apa ta ote h e r e stsu o eta Po s N 10-4105 2 t u h pe s h, f htr po s ai e t r hn r e o 830-006 . tr r t e tt s h tt . , o y n po s– pcia y Po s N 10-3102 – oe e r sh w emd o o n oe r e se f l , r e o 830-007 cv s ni ta e ae n r l tt i cl tt . r te t r a e O oe 220 e Fs A eddC m a ttt ce Shd e f r e slt g n y f r c b , 00 eit mne o pi aaahd ceu o Po s (s n e r t t r .S r ln t l t t ii t n me ad epc v d e o e r) Itu apa tateGv n e ’ m in o i m s u b s n rseie a s f n y t hs pe s h h oe mns o o t d i r t t t . r t r t t s s a ul i pc e o y h e r s oe d yPo s N 10-3102 Nv te s i a c a y m ia s n te ni cv e b r e o 830-007 ee h e , n n tl l t l te r tt . . r ls audne f a in h e r s oe d yltre r e sr ad se h ea p sn d y bnac ocu o te ni cv e b a h po s a dr sd e, s r e e b t , te r l e tt e e r e t teGv n e ’ m in h oe mns o o r t t .
or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 2
se f a y –h p t u rCs m dcin ) e g r e e Se 9USC§ 54 )1 A pci l ” te ai l u o s e s ( b n po s d e 1 ... 11( () ) i cl rc a t io s i tt . c (.
TeCu o Apa hs mhs e te mna r”n u oteet u r ad eutr h or f pe s a e pa zd h “ ad oy a r f hs st oy n rg a y t l i t te at lo
po s n t esrtaa po s aps Cs m ote a r ad h a e ote se e rvi s o nu h l r e s pr e u o s f h n u n ca c r f h a r d io, e t l tt i t te rt st
ci s Se o eAosn 15.dt 0-9 e a oa e v A hr 9 US181117) l m e K k rno , 6 F a980 sel Dv s. r u , 6 .. 4 5(87 a . i 3 ; s i t ,
(o igh eey r e “ u b s dt cad pci a we f r cnre t so ta h d ta v po s ms e oii t n se f, s hnal os ud o h wh l n t r tt t sn ic , iy t , t
te b c o..ws ui e t n iy Cs m oi tu n u ad h a e ) h o ein. a sf c n o of [ u o s ft re a r n ca c r.
jt fi t t t ] s te rt ”
Ote orpo s ai u i t s c o o yPo s N 10-4105 s s o h f h fu r e s ts e n h ain n r e o 830-006 e fr a tt s i t , l tt . t t
C T Aci,a eig h “ e a m cad e spoe yd yrea C T Aqaf d B P l m s r n ta t s d e hn s i rp l u - e s B P -ui e a st t h i r i r tf li
gos e D. B ea1(u ig r e N 10-4105) seloda29 Teh e od ”Se e’ r ft 2qo n Po s o 830-006 e a i.t,. htr . fs i t tt . ; s e
r m n gr e srse atteC T Aae n o yh tee vne r sfm cad e e a i po s a i n soh B P,l g g n ta hr ea ni o e hn s i n tt el t li l t l t te r i
“ e rp l d ib o te a s f euie a e d a 1 (u ig h e te po s a a poe y ua e n h bs o ddc v v u ”I.t 2 qo n tr o r r e st r r t l i t l. t e h tt
i u ;e a o d a 29 Toe h e r e s h eo w e o vi at ayC T Al m s e se l i.t,. hstr po s te fr e n a d s o n B P ci, s) s e tt r e r t l a
bcuehyae t g eCs mteeui n ie easte fld o i u o s hrq se oc i v t it t .
Bcue vi po s(n tednlota po s i ap rq se o u e mt eas a a d r e ad h e a f h r e)s r eui t sb c ae l tt i t tt e it j t tr
jr dt nud 2 ...§18( , Mc en’ C T A l m s oPo s Ns 10-3 us c o ne 8USC i ii r 51 ) ac ny B P ci at r e o 830-
a l s a tt .
107 10-4102 ad10-4104 ms b d m sdfr wn o jr dt n 002 830-004 n 830-003 u e i i e o a f us c o , , t s s t i ii .
Mc en de n cn n o e w e Se e. P’ B e a 1 (cn w d n ta C T A ac ny os o o ed t ri . e, g ls r ft 2 akol g g h B P l t t h s ., . i ei t
ci i poe y lmette odcv e b E r Ns WP002408 WP00422 l ms rp l “ i doh gosoe d y n y o J-0[]7- J-029- a r it r t . ,
ad WP00577 n ic dd nPo s N 10-4105 o y ( mhss de)2 n J-020- ad n ue i r e o 830-006 n” e pae add2 l tt . l) .
22 Se lo lsB e a 2 ci ig n tac t n m cad e n ue i E r Ns e a P’ r ft ( a m o y h e a “ e hn sic dd n n y o s . i l n l t ri r i l t .
WP00408 WP00422ad WP00577o Po s N 10-4105 . . J-027- , J-029- n J-020- f r e o 830-006 .
tt .
qaf e fr u - et a mn ud C T A i a1 ( g n o yh Cs mso d e uiis o d yrer t e ” ne B P ) d t 4a u g n ta u o s hu b l[ ] tf e t r ; . ri l t t l od et “ l u a teh e e ga d nish qaf fr u - et a mncv e b re dori i t htr ds n e e r ta uiy o d yrer t e oe d y r eq d e e i t te t l tf e t r or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 3
b TeGv n e ’ M in oD m s o Flrt St aCi . h oe mns o o t i i fr a u o t e l m r t t s s i e a a o Aenie , M in oJd mn o teP a ns rS m ay ug e r l ra v y o o fr ug e n h l d g o u m Jd mn , t t l t t ei r t
Ote orpo s ai u i t s c o o yPo s N 10-4105 s s o h f h fu r e s ts e n h ain n r e o 830-006 e fr a tt s i t , l tt . t t
C T Al m Se e’ B ea1 (u ig r e N 10-4105) Ote ee e r s B P ci. e D . r ft 2 qo n Po s o 830-006 fh svn ni a fs i t tt . . te
cv e b ta po s te Gv n e sesd m s frflr t st aci a t oe d y h r e, h oe mn ek i i a o a u o t e l m s o r t tt r t s sl i e a a
Mc en’ C T A l mw h epct E r Ns WP00399 WP00461 WP ac ny B P ci i rse o n y o J-029- J-021- J- l s a t t t . , ,
00494ad WP00401 i. hfue r sh w emd p ot O oe220 te 022- n J-024- –., eor ni ta e aer ro c b , 00 h , et te t r i t r ,
e eie a oteC T A s o odfo N a ga Se d a 2 &. 91-3 U CTR f c v d e f h B P at gosr m i r u ei.t ft t ca . n,, 11 SI .
3 ;
1()5 2 We eaa zd nete ur oam inoi m s oflrt st al mo 2b ) 3 h h n ye ud hrb c f o ot d i fra u ot e ci, r (. tr l r i t s s i e a a ,
aenie , m inojd mnotela ns U CTR e 2 )oam inos m ay l ra v ya o ofrug e nh p d g( SI u 1( )r o ofr u m t t l t t ei l c t r
jd mn ( SI R e5)te Gv n e ’ ag mni eul sud Sen 7 ur ug e U CT u 6 h oe mns ru e s qa y on e . ,spa t l , r t t l . 1
(x a ig h m in o i m s oflrt st al mi d f rAs eso d era d epi n ta o o t d i fr a u ot e ci fe a e n w hu bt t ln t t s s i e a a l t r l ee
a m in ojd mn o p a ns rm in os m ay ug e ) s o o fr ug e n l d g o o o fr u m jd mn.
t t ei t r t
AteGv n e cr c y bevso yh efhsvn nis oe d y r e N sh oe mn o el os e n tr o eee e r cv e b Po s o r t rt r , l e t te r tt .
Po s N 10-4105i acrac w hteC T A ) i a1-7st gh Pi i r e o 830-006n codne i [ tt . t h B P ] ; d t 61 ( a nta l nf ” . ti t a tf
i eddh i C T Al m o d yrera mn wu ap o yotre nis oe d n neta t B P ci fr u - et t e o d p y n t “ e e r cv e t ts a tf e t l l l h te r b oe r e, ad ocd gh “ eCu lcsus c ot g nsc ri w heado y n Po s” n cne nta t or akjr dt no r t uhee i rg t tt i t h t i ii a lf t r tee a ig nis n h cs” hr m n e r i t s ae .
i n te i ) 23 Aa ,h soe n p cc e e oteGv n e ’ m inr s m wauc a g n e cp ad r t a f c fh oe mns o o a o e h n e . it ai l f t r t t e t lr C maen 1 spa I p t u r Mc en’ Fs A eddC m a t pe s oi ite o pr . , ur. n ai l , ac ny it mne o pi apa t l m h 2 rc a l s r ln r t c may C T Al mo n toe nisw c w e e e d n rf rO oe 220 ” o pn’ B P ci t o yhs e r s a l t e h h e “n r o oa e c b , 00 i r te t t r .
SeitA eddC m a t 2 Itu apa tateGv n e ’ m ins drset e Fs mne o pi ¶ 6 ths pe s h h oe mns o oi ad sdo r ln . r t r t t e e r s h, n a,a n te u e o Mc en’ C T Aci a s fr i teFs ni ta i fc r o h sb c f ac ny B P l m s e o h n h it te t t e t jt l s a t t r A eddC m a t Nv te s fr h sk o c r y n i a ecs o cu o te or mne o pi . ee h e , ote ae f l i ad n n xe f a in h fu ln r ls at s t , e r s oe d y r e N 10-4105 w c p d eO oe 220 a ad se h e ni cv e b Po s o 830-006 h h r a c b , 00r dr sd e , te r tt . i et t r e e r a p sn d y h Gv n e ’ m in s r e e b te oe mns o o e t r t t .
or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 4
10-4105 w emd a e O oe220 tef c v d efh C T Aso odfo 830-006 e aef r c b , 00 h e eie a o e B P at gosr m r t t r , ft t t
N a ga Se e’ B e a 2 & . 9 1 N vi C T Al m a b a e e at ay i r u e D . r ft ca . fs i n, , 3 o a d B P ci cn e s r d s o n 3 . l a st
e r s md b o ta d e Se d a 91 se eeay e r ia o Ud teC iba ni ae e r h a. ei.t, 3 e gnr l D e m t n ne h a ben te fe t t ; l t ni r r
Bs T d P te h A, 5 e Rg6 26 O. 020)st gh C T A p is n a n r e a n s p c 6 Fd e 0 3( c 1 00( a nta B P ape o y i a r ri t . . , t , ti t l l
t e g l gos mo e o oa e O oe 220) ol i e odi pr d n rf r c b , 00 ib t t t r .
Mc en i e akoldetaayC T Al m s oE r Ns WP00399 ac nyt l cn w gs h n B P ci at n y o J-029- l sf e t a t . ,
WP00461 WP00494 ad WP00401 ak m i Se e. P’ B e a 1 J-021- J-022- n J-024- lcs et e,. , ls r f t 2 , , r. g . i
(ocd g h C T Aci i poe y“ me t tegoscv e b E r Ns WP cne n ta B P l m s rp l l i d o h od oe d y n y o J-
i t a r it r t .
002408 WP00422 n WP00577.4 Acr n yat toe or nis h 0[]7- J-029- ad J-020-” 2 cod g , s o hs fu e r , e , ) il te t
Gv n e ’rqe fr ee ms b g n dad Mc en’ C T Al mms b dn d oe mns eus ori u e r t , n ac ny B P ci u e e e r t t lf t ae l s a t i
o d m sd ri i e s s .
c TeGv n e ’ M in o S m ay ug e at C t nE r s . h oe mns o o fr u m Jd mn s o e a ni r t t r t ri t e
A tar m n o Mc en’ C T Al mrteh e nis oe d y r e N l h e a s f ac ny B P ci a htr e r cv e b Po s o l t i l s a e e te r tt .
10-4105ta w e n rd n rf rO oe 220 –.,E r Ns WP00408 830-006h e e e o oa e c b , 00 i. n y o J-027-
t r te t t r e t . ,
WP00422ad WP00577 2 TeGv n e akoldeta hstre nisr J-029- n J-020- 5 h oe mn cn w gsh toeh e r a , . r t e t e te e
24 Se lo lsB e a 2 ci ig n tac t n m cad e n ue i E r Ns e a P’ r ft ( a m o y h e a “ e hn sic dd n n y o s . i l n l t ri r i l t .
WP00408 WP00422ad WP00577o Po s N 10-4105 . . J-027- , J-029- n J-020- f r e o 830-006 .
tt .
qaf e fr u - et a mn ud C T A i a1 ( g n o yh Cs mso d e uiis o d yrer t e ” ne B P ) d t 4a u g n ta u o s hu b l[ ] tf e t r ; . ri l t t l od et “ l u a teh e e ga d nish qaf fr u - et a mncv e b re dori i t htr ds n e e r ta uiy o d yrer t e oe d y r eq d e e i t te t l tf e t r Po s N 10-4105i acrac w hteC T A ) i a1-7st gh Pi i r e o 830-006n codne i [ tt . t h B P ] ; d t 61 ( a nta l nf ” . ti t a tf
i eddh i C T Al m o d yrera mn wu ap o yotre nis oe d n neta t B P ci fr u - et t e o d p y n t “ e e r cv e t ts a tf e t l l l h te r b oe r e, ad ocd gh “ eCu lcsus c ot g nsc ri w heado y n Po s” n cne nta t or akjr dt no r t uhee i rg t tt i t h t i ii a lf t r tee a ig nis n h cs” hr m n e r i t s ae .
i n te i ) 25 E r N WP00408ws n rd nO oe 1 20 E r N WP00422 n y o J-027- a e e o c b 0 00 n y o J-029- t . te t r , ; t .
ws n rd nO oe1 20 ad n yN WP00577ws n rd nO oe1 20 ae e o c b 6 00 n E r o J-020- ae e o c b 9 00 te t r , ; t . te t r , .
or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 5
e iet d yrera mnud teU td t e C iba Bs T d P te h A, n nt do u - et t e ne h ne Sts a ben a n r e a n s p c ad tl tf e t r i a - r i a r ri t
ses u m yug e riu a nte acr n ySe e’ B ea2&. 1 2 D. eks m a jd mn e q digh m cod g . e D. r ft n, 3 9 e’
r tl it il fs i 3 , ; fs
Rp B e a 3n,2 D . Sp B e a 1 N srrig , Mc en cnu i te e y r f t . 0 e’ up r f t 0 o ups l ac ny ocr n h l i 4 ; fs . i . t in y l s
Gv n e ’ m in SelsB ea23. 1-31 1-73-32 oe mns o o e P’ r ft, n, 21 4 61 23 6 r t t . . i 1 , , , .
A d csei sc o I bv e g l gosr m ee c r cu r smy e mo e si u dn ein aoe l i e odfo bn i ay oni a bi pr d s s t ,i b fi te t
i o h U tdSts u - e ud teC T A e gnr l 1 USC § 20-3lt g n te ne t e d yre ne h B P.Se eeay 9 ... § 720 (s n t i a tf r l ii
c t n onis n gos s l i e o d yrera mn ud C T A N a ga ws e a cu r ad od a e g l fr u - e t t e ne B P ) i r u a ri te ib tf e t r . ca
fr a yg n dbn i ayt u ud teC T A so O oe 2 20 Se1 USC § o ml r t ee c r sts ne h B P a f c b , 00 e 9 ...
l ae fi a r t r .
20() lt g N a gaa e g l frds nina bn i aycu r ud C T A 72b (s n i r u s l i e o e ga o s ee c r on y ne B P )
ii ca ib i t fi t r ;
D e m a o Ud teC iba Bs T d P te h A, 5 e Rga6 26 g n n e r i t n ne h a ben a n r e a n s p c 6 Fd e t 0 3 (r t g t ni r r i a r ri t . . , ai
N a ga ee c r stsadmd y gH S Se eieO., 00 i r u bn i ayt u n o f n T U,f c v c 220) ca fi a , ii ft t .
Te ode g lfr u - et a mnud teC T An uem cad elsf d h gosl i eod yre e e ne h B P ic d e hn s c si ib tf rt t r l r i aie
ud H S S uha n 90 0 8 e 1 USC § 73b 2 AiI Se f a ytoe ne T U sbed g 82 0 0 e 9 ... 20() ) ))) pci l , hs r i . . .S ( ( ((. i cl
“pa l rc staa a e b d n C T A ee c r cu r (uh sN a ga “ o ap eai e” h r s m e i a B P bn i ay on ysc a i r u f m r tl t e s l fi t ca ) r
fb c wo y o md n c i teU tdSts ad mo e d el i o h U tdSts ar s h l fr e ad u n h ne t e” n i pr d i c y n te ne t e i l t i a t rt t i a
SeitA eddC m a ttt ce Shd ef r e s iig n y u b s nrseie e Fs mne o pi aaahd ceu o Po s (s n e r n me adepc v r ln t l t t lt t r t d e oe r) D . B ea1(a e A huh o p t st eh E r N WP0057 a sf n y e’ r ft 3s m. l og b h ai stta n y o J-020- t t ; fs i ) t t re a t t . 7wsmd o O oe920 ter iae r pp sn c eh te a oe r ws c a y a ae n c b , 00 h o g l n y ae id a ta h d ef n y aa ul t r , in t r it t t t tl O oe1 20 We ete a wsO oe920 o O oe1 20i n m e a B h c b 9 00 h h h d e a c b , 00r c b 9 00s o a rl o t r , . tr t t r t r , t t i. t d e a a e O oe 220 tef c v d e f h C T A s o odfo N a ga a sr f r c b , 00 h e eie a ote B P at gosr m i r u t et t r , ft t ca .
26 Ide Mc en n w d ss h ii edd o se aC T A l m o d yre ned ac ny o av eta t n ne t a r , l i t t s t B P ci fr u - e a tf
t a mno ysohtre pcid nisSee. P’ B ea1-7st gh Mc en r t e n atteh se f e r . e, g ls r ft 61( a nta ac ny e t l e ie te .,. i ti t l i eddh i C T Al m o d yrera mn wu ap o yotre nis oe d n neta t B P ci fr u - et t e o d p y n t “ e e r cv e t ts a tf e t l l l h te r b oe r e, ad ocd gh “ eCu lcsus c ot g nsc ri w heado y n Po s” n cne nta t or akjr dt no r t uhee i rg t tt i t h t i ii a lf t r tee a ig nis n h cs” hr m n e r i t s ae .
i n te i )
or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 6
ud H S S uha n 90 0 8 a e ie t d yrera mn prunt teC T A ne T U sbed g 82 0 0 r nt d o u - et t e u a o h B P. r i . . e tl tf e t s t
Se..N e ()) C 9 SbhI H S S se lorc min 31 fO oe 220 e US o 7bi h 8 uc I T U; e a Po a a o 75 o c b , 00 t (, . , ., s l t t r
tI p mn h U tdt e C iba Bi T d P te h A, 5 e Rg5 395 33 o m e e te ne Sts a ben a n r e a n s p c 6 Fd e 9 2 9 3 l t i a - r s a r ri t . ., ,,
( c 420) md y gH S Son ueU.N e()) C 9 Sbh I H S Se eie O., 00( o f n T Utic d . o 7bi h 8 uc I T U,f c v t ii l S t (, . , ., ft
O., 00 c 220) t .
H e h es oip eh Mc en’s t yeak sw e rp l c sf d ne e , e i n d u ta ac ny u- pjce e poe yl si ud rt r st t l s it t r r aie r
H S S uha n 90 0 8 SeitA eddC m a t 2 As eadCu e l m T U sbed g 82 0 0 e Fs mne o pi ¶ 5 n w n on r a ¶ i ... r ln ; r t ci
2 Nrsh e n d p eh Mc en’ m cad ews mo e d eli oh U td 5 oite ayi u ta ac ny e hn s ai pr di c yn te ne . r st t l s r i t rt t i
Stsr mN a ga SePi i’ St mn o M e a Fc A T W c Te A N t efo i r u e l nf s t e e f a rl a s s o h h h e r o a ca . a tf a t ti t i r e
Gn n I usT B T e (P’ St mn o Fc ” ¶ ;D ednsRsost Pi i’ eu es e o e r d “ls t e e f a s 3 e na ’ epne o l nf s i s i . a t t) f t a tf
St mn o M e a Fc A T W c Te A N Gn n I usT B T e ( D . t e e f a rl a s s o h h h e r o eu e s e o e r d “ e’ a t ti t i r e i s i fs
Rsost P’ St mno Fc ”¶.tsi i r ud p eta h gosw ese b d epneolst e e f a s 3I s ma y n su dh te od e a m e . a t t) i ll i t t r s l
i N a gaa ee c r cu r ud teC T A fo fb cfr e ad u nh U td n i r u( bn i ay on y ne h B P ) r mar s o md n c ite ne ca fi t r , i t i
Sts e P’ St mn o Fc ¶ ;D. Rsost P’ St mn o Fc ¶. F a y te a .Se ls t e e f a s 3 e’ epne o ls t e e f a s 3 i l , . a t t fs . a t t nl
te i n d p e h E r Ns WP00408 WP00422ad WP00577w e h es o i u ta n y o J-027- J-029- n J-020- e r st t t . , , r
e e d f r O oe 2 20 SeFs A eddC m a t t t ce Shd eo Po s n r a e c b , 00 e it mne o pi a aahd ceu f r e s te t t r . r ln t l tt
(s n d e oe r) D . B ea1 (cn w d nta h e s d nis w emd a e lt g a s f n y e’ r ft 3akol g gh tr lt e r “ e aef r ii t t ; fs i ei t e i e te r t
tef c v d e fh C T A at gosr mN a ga n 5 ur ( e iy g n y a s h e eie a ote B P ” so odfo i r u ;. , pai nf n e r d e ft t ca ) 2s dt i t t
oteh e u e e r s fhtr sb c ni )
e j t t e.
A sc E r Ns WP00408 WP00422ad WP00577 as e te s uh n y o J-027- J-029- n J-020- siid h , t . , , tf
rq r mn frd yrera mn ud te C T A Te Gv n e ’ m ina t te eu e e s o u - e t t e ne h B P. h oe mns o o s o h i t tf e t r r t t or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 7
se f d nis h eo ms b g n d n te nisms briu a dd yre pci e r te fr u e r t ad h e r ie te r e t ae t e u ee q d e u - e t l i t, tf .
2 TeAport M hd fAp ie e . h prp a e o o pr s mn
ie t a t
I adin ose n s m ay ug e a t te h ee r se ie t d yre n d t t ek g u m jd mn s o h tr ni nt d o u - e io i r t e t e tl tf
t a mn ud teC T A d cse aoe te Gv n e a o ek s m ay ug e r t e ne h B P ( su d bv, h oe mn l ses u m jd mn e t r i s ) r t s r t
ssi n Cs m ueot nainv u t ap ie l o e e r s tsu i t s c o u a ig u o s s fr sc o a e o pr s a t r ni ai e n h ain tn t ’ a t l a l h te s i t .
Se f a y h Gv n e cn nsh,l ogte ue( e Mc en B Gadhsl pci l, e oe mn o edta a huhh by i. ac ny C ) nteee i cl t r t t tt r ., l / lr
( e K)w eetd h v uint u nv tlsrq rd pr s mnbsd n asc o i. B e r a , e a a o st e ee he eu e ap ie e ae ot nain ., r let l t at re s i a t r t
v u bcue acr n t teGv n e –tei u s ne ote a .. n c e ta a e eas – cod g o h oe mn “ c c m acs f h s e. id a [ h l, i r t h r t l i t] t
teet nh ..i n if ecte r eta Mc en B G a t K. e gnr l 1 hr a os p. d o n uneh p c”h ac ny C p do BSe eeay 9 li i d t l i t l / i l
USC 10ab()B D. B e a 91 -02 2 2 D. Rp B e a 11 1 2 ...§ 41 )2 ) e’ r ft, 3 2 6 8 9 e’ e y r ft -2 6 0 ( ( ; fs i , , , ; fs l i , , ;
D. up r fa89ps m D. up e yB e a 187 Fr h raos u m ie e’ p i t - a i ;e’ p fsS .B e , s fsS .Rp r ft - 2 ote esn s m a zd l i . r
b o, u m y ug e ms b dn d e ws m a jd mn u e e e l r t t i.
I a e o t d mnr eh te c c m acs fh s ets s as eit s ae n nf r o e os a ta h “ ru s ne ote a ”e isiidnh cs ft tt t i t l t tf i ,
teGv n e ivks n rr a v N e t 1 CFR§ 5 13)1 a eig n sec h oe mn noeI ep tie o 2 o 9 ... 12 0(() s r n i e ne r t t et t . l , st , s ,
ta h p csh M Loy B G C e Oe t gOie s frK w est dn mne h ter eta r ob( C ’ h f p a n f c )e o B e “el i a an t i t . s i ri f r t r te r
27 T ss ntp acsi a esoe e rse: tsCs m – o hi pr r ta h i a a i l aent a n kyepc I i yc l t t i u o s n te mo e –h t t t t
i avcig o ap ie e bsd nrnain a e AteGv n e p n o ,ii s doa n fr pr s mn ae o t sc o v u s h oe mn o t u “ s t a t a t l. r t is t t uuu fra i pr r o o ed h t nainv u so d o e p id Ii f mr nsa o n mo e t cn n ta r sc o a e hu n l t t ta t l l tb ape ts a o l . r e
c m o fr n mo etair a d ot sp i t po difr a o t te pr s i a o mn o a i pr r h s et t i upe o rv e no min o h ap ie n t t le s lr i t a r qe t cnr t nain a esh aport m hd oy D. Sp B ea9. se us o of m asc o v u ate prp a e oo g ” e’ up r ft n ; e t i r t l i e t l . fs . i 5 a o e’ Sp Rp B ea3rt a n “ eat oai pr r ek go ae v uin l D. up e y r ft ( i rigt r i f n mo ese nt hv a a a o s fs . l i ee t h ry t i lt m hd oy o eta t nainv u ape t i gos. Te Gv n e w nta e oo g t r hn r sc o a e p id ot od” h oe mn a s h t l h a t l l s ) r t r t cu ote fr msb ee ie “ ap ig n s uin pci a hr y n u n Cs m a inh eo u e x c di p y ayi a o- e f u ot ic d g u o s t r e t rs n l n t t s i c t i, l i t r ig ojdi dcin”n e d gh cs “n stei a o rv wdnhr e ne u ns ru cl e s si dc i t s ae u e h s uine e eitee r cd l ia io in i , ls tt i fe a hr y no e a i pr rr n t r mvi t nainfo ap ia ud t nain u ot iv vs n mo ety g o e oet r sc osr m pr s ne r sc o t i l t i sa t al ra t v u ”Se d a e ei. l.
or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 8
cn s n w h h nr a p c gpaie ote nu r i qein” Se1 CFR § ost t i te o m ri rccs f h ids y n us o. e 9 ... ie t l in t t t
12 0(()i( mhs add D . B ea1 (u ig n rr a v N e ) D. Rp 5 13)1i e pa s de) e’ r ft 6 qo n I ep tie o 2 e’ e y . l () i ; fs i t t et t ; fs l
B ea1 ( f r go r es “ te nr a mnefr g mna e b r ;D. Rp r ft 0r ei t p cs e i h‘o m ’ an oa a e s m e ) e’ e y i ern i t n l r r t s l ” fs l
B e a 1 ( f r g o“o m p c gp ccsfr h g mn ids y.8 Tu t r f t 2 r ei t nr a ri r t e o te a e nur” 2 i ern l i n ai r t t ) hs o ,
28 Selo e’ r fa1 ( f r g onr amne otenur” D. r fa e a D. i t 6 r ei t“o m an s fsB e ern l rfr hids y ;e’ i t t ) fsB e
1 r eigt nr a nur rccs ;D. Rp B e a 1(t g ie l , 7( f r e r n o“o m lids yp t e” e’ e y r f t 1 i n n ra a t ai ) fs l i ci , t i I ep tieo ad e r nt“o m p c grccsf hids y ;e’ upB e n rr a vN e2 n r eigonr a ri p t e otenur” D. t et t fr l i n ai t ) fsSp r f .i
a6 r eig onr ap c g rccsf hids ynus o ” u ig u o sV uin t ( f r t“o m ri p t e otenuriqein qo n Cs m a a o ern l i n ai t t , t t lt Cd ;i a8 r eig o nr ap c g rccs f hids y;da9 r eigi t o oe d t ( f r t “o m ri p t e o te nur )i t ( f r , n w ) . ern l i n ai t” . ern p cst “o m p c g rccs f hids y ;D. Sp Rp B e a 3r eig o l e o nr a ri p t e ote nur” e’ up e y r ft ( f r t a , l i n ai t ) fs . l i ern “o m rigp c cso te nur i qein cig n rr a v N e2 i a 4 nr a i n r t e f h ids y n us o ” i n I ep tie o ) d t lp c ai t t , t t et t ; .
( f r gi t op cst “o m p c gp ccs ;d a 6 r eig o“o m p c g r ei , n w l e o nr a ri r t e” i t ( f r t nr a ri ern a , l i n ai ) . ern l in p ccsnhids y ; da7r eigo mne[ w c] r e a nr a y e nte r t eitenur” i t ( f r t “ an i h h p csr o ml s i [ ] ai t ) . ern rn i i e l t h ids y ; d ( f r g o nr a p c g rccs. nur” i r ei t “o m ri p t e”
t ) . ern l i n ai )
Av iu p n ii b e,h Gv n e f mse srtnadi o et m Se t a os o t n sr f te oe mn r ets os d snt re s e, r is t is r ta t a r h r .
e. D. B e a 1 (seigi cp o ta “ h E dneE a ihsTateP cs . , e’ r f t 5 a r n n a in h Te v ec s bse h h r e g fs i st , t , t i tl t i B we K ad Mc en W eS i teS m Mne a P csA Nr a yS frS e e en B n ac ny e e n h a e an s r e r o ml e o a s t l r t r i e l t l B we Ur a d ais ;i a2 (seigh p cs w e e nh s m mnea p cs e en n l e P t ” d t 6a r nta r e “ e s ite a e an s r e t et re ) . st ti r t r i a s b we ur a d nt s ;D. Rp B ea4a eigh p cs w e e r ie r e e en n l e e ie” e’ e y r ft (s r nta r e “ e d e m d et t et ti ) fs l i st ti r t n u nte a em hd swu b e p ydnrnain b we ur a d nt s ; da6 s gh s m e o a o d e m oeit sc os e en n l e e ie” i t i t l l a t t et ti ) . (seigh p cs w e e nh s m m n a p csr s b we ur a d ais ; d a r nta r e “ e s ite a e a e s r e a e e en n l e p t ” i st ti r t nr i et t et re ) . a7a eigh p csw e os “ f rn y hnhywu hv beite ueadh t (s r nta r e e n e df e l tate o d ae enfh by nte st ti r t t ie t l r sl w e or a d ;D . Sp B e a 6 d cs n c c m acswe “ e mnei ee e n et ” e’ up r ft ( su igi u s ne h et an n l r r t l e ) fs . i i s r t r h r w cte r ews e vds se ilte a e s wu bfr aish a n r a d ; h hh p c a d iei e na yh s m ai o d e o p t ta r o et ” i i r s tl t l re t e t l e ) i a 8 a eig h p cs we ei te a e mne a ap c wu hv be s fr d t (s r n ta r e “ e s n h s m an s r e o d ae en e o . st t i r t r i l t t nain b we ur a d p t s ) r sc os e en n l e [ai ]. a t t et re ”
Teem clnose rnecn a cne tadagaenn rr a v N e 1 n hs i eaeur e cs oft ocps nlnugiI ep tie o s ad sl fe le t et t 2teta te pci po s n nw c teGv n e h eee – h i te rvin f o rhn h se f rvi o h h h oe mn e ris ta s h po s o h ic i o i r t r l t, io I ep tie N e2 tig h teueot nainv u i aport i a etdp t n rr a v o st ta h s fr sc o a e s prp a n r a t et t an t a t l ie l e ayr t nain[fh p c hs en eldn mnecn s n w hh nr ap c g rccs r sc o “]te r e a be st i a an ost t i te o m ri p t e a t i i te r ie t l i n ai ote nur i qein Se e. D. B e a 1 (u ig cn s n w h h nr a f h ids y n us o ” e,. , e’ r f t 6 qo n “ost t i te o m t t . g fs i t ie t l p c g rccs f hids yts ad mt g n r e ne owe e “ e r e a be ri p t e ote nur”e, n o ii ay e r ct h h t p c hs en i n ai t t tn fe tr h i st dn mnecn s n . w hh wyhsl st sr et[n l e] ue ” D . el i a an ost t . i te ateee el p csour a dby s ; e’ te r ie . t l r te i et r ) fs Rp B ea 9s m. e y r ft (a e l i )
Acr ntteGv n e ,n rr a v N e –w c cnen“ ewynw cte cod goh oe mn I ep tie o 1 h h oc st ai h hh i r t t et t i r h i or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 9
p c i qein ws r vd t –hsn r eac t t s ae bcue h n e apet r e n us o a aie a i t r ” a o e vne o h cs eas ta o “p is o l i , t t l s uin n p snh ei. we Cs m hs rv u y x m eteet nh oa ed i a os o r e e ,., hn u o s a p i s ea i dhr a os p rl ay tt t e t r e t e ol n li i r hs‘ui e d ae ifr a o cnen g h by adsl t b siid h te a sf c n ei d no min oc i te ue n ee o e as e ta h fi t tl t rn r lr tf t r a os pi n if ecte r e c a y a o pyb. Se e’ Sp Rp B ea et nh d o n uneh p c a ul p d r aa e” e D. up e y r ft li i d t l i tl i l’ fs . l i 2n. B se D . Rp B e a 1-1 we Gv n e apa t r yi p t o .1 u e e’ e y r f t 01 ( h e oe mn pe s o e , n a, n t fs l i r r t r l r I ep tie N e1 Tu t te x ntate df m e a yr m h s nado “ e n rr a v o ) hs o h e e h hy i e a rl fo tet d f t t et t . , tt t f r t il a r h nr a p c gp ccso te nur ”ayo teaoei e r e ne ta r a t o m ri r t e f h ids y n f h bv ltd e r cs h et o l i n ai t, -s fe t le cn d a o o “ ewy nw c te r e n us o ws r vdt (rwrs o h e e ) os e t n ft a i h h h p ci qein a aie a o odt ta f c i ri h i i t r ” t ft m sh m k i te a . s r
S ma ys m otee rneltd bv a v iin o po s n oI ep tie i i r , o e fhr e cs s aoer a a os n rvi s f n rr a v ll fe ie e rt io t et N e o etate nr a nur p c grccstso w cteGv n e h eee o 2t rhnh “o m ids y ri p t e”e n h hh oe mn e ris t h l t i n ai t i r t r l. AteGv n e epis hi rdc rtxoI ep tieN e – oc n gwe ea sh oe mn x a , en ou oye f n rr a v o 2 cne i h h r t l nt t t t t et t rn tr r a d ueadee“ufo adet ec o eaite w e or a d – os ote et by n sl byr m n slo aht rsfhy e n et ” de n i l le r lr l h r t le t sf s fr ae frh ue frnain a enetd a y a s e D. Sp Rp B e e o h ts ote s ot sc o v ui r a p t s e e e’ up e y r f t t t a t l l e r l .S fs . l i a34Is a ta n ou oye aiuts n v a s nadw c cn eas e b e h t- n ed h i rdc rtx rc a a oe l t d . t , tt t t t le rl a r h h a bsiid yi e i tf tr
ot o l ra v ts s fr i N e2 [] we e “ ep c hsbe st d n mne f w aenie e s e o h n o : 1 h h t r e a en el i a an t t t t t t tr h i te r cn s n w hh nr ap c g rccs fhids yn us o” w citee tate ost t i te o m ri p t e otenuri qein( h hshts h h ie t l i n ai t t i t t Gv n e ivksnh cs ad2 we e“ er e a be st dn mnecn s n oe mn noeit s ae n[] h h t p c hs enel i a an ost t r t i ) tr h i te r ie ..w hh wyh sl st s r efr a so ue wor n r a doi. Sed Te . i te ate ee el p cs os et by s h a o et t h m ei. h t l r te i l r e t le ”
i rdc r tx oI ep tieN e tu hs oiniacidpne ote pcits n ou oye f n rr a v o 2 hs a n s i cne needn f h se f e t t t t et t gf t ic t o w c te Gv n e h e ee –i. we e “ ep c hsbe st d na mne n h h h oe mn e ris ., h h t r e a en el i i r t r l e tr h i te an r cn s n w h h nr a p c g rccs f hids y n us o ” Ad h scn tss ost t i te o m ri p t e ote nur i qein n te eode e ie t l i n ai t t . tt fr i I ep tieN e (e we e “ e r e a be st d n mne cn s n. . o h n n rr a v o 2i. h h t p c hs en el i a an ost t . t t et t ., t r h i te r ie w h h wy h sl st sp cs o s e t [n l e]by s hsn apcinh e i te a te ee el r e fr a s o ur a d ue ” a o p ia o e , t l r te i l et r) l t r bcuehsl it s ae K)md n s e wa ov t by ste Mc en B G e easteee nh cs( B ae oa s h see o ue o r ac ny C.Se lr i l t r r h l / Wa Eey M meo h T d C m u t So dKo Ao :D e m igh Acp bi h v t r e b f e r e o mn y hu n w bu e r i nte ce a l y r t a i l t t n t it o T nainV ufrR a d a y rnain(..Dp o H m ad eut Ar 20) f r sc o a eo et P t T sc os US e’ f o e n Scr y pl 07 a t l le r a t t l i i ( Cs m G dne nAcp bi o T nainV ui R a dP t T nain”a1 “ u o s u ac o ce a l y f r sc o a en et a y r sc os t 0 t i t it a t l le r a t )
(pedd oP’ Sp Rp B e (x a ig h te eode i I ep tieN e i apne t ls up e y r f epi n ta h scn ts n n rr a v o 2s . . l i) l n t t t et t l me t “ta os we te ee slte a e m cad e ob h etd n ur a d i i d o s uin h e h sl es h s m e hn s t o r a ad n l e t i t r lr l r i t le et p t s. ai ” re )
I su h wr o n taasv ap n ii b e, hGv n e pe s ose t fr e o hn ig h, ee l o t n s i steoe mn pa ta r i tr t t tt r i s t r f r ta r st ta hr ea ts a t o s n c moe s () h h hp cst suw e“eld n h tee vn e hs wdt c o pnn – 1we e er e ai ee st i t l t t ii t t t rt i s r te a an ostnw hteo m p c g rccs f hids ynus o” n () h h mne n s ti hnr a ri p t e o tenuriqein ad 2we e rc i e t l i n ai t t tr ter e r lc d o er e e m g f rf – sf h epct n f rf w e sp a hp cs e e e s m po c d a i i f t j t r no pot a ite xe a o o pot e a ea t i ti i r re ct inaoe n byn cn s nyw hh nr ap c grccsfhids y See. re o bv ad eod ost c i te o m ri p t e o enur e, g ir , ie t l i n ai t t. ., D. B ea1 ( d a nta hts swe e p c “ as i amnetac mosw h e’ r ft 7i i t gh tee i h h r e ws e n an h o pr i fs i n ci t t tri t r t t t nr a nur p ccs n ws xe et rs tn. a esnb pot)e pa s de) o m ids y r t e ad a epc do eu i.. raoa e r i ( mhs add l t ai t l l f” i ;
sea o e’ Rp B e a 1 ( a ig h ts a “o m p c gp ccs oteg mn e l D. e y r f t 2f m te e s nr a ri r t e fr h a e s fs l i r n t l i n ai r t or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 0
p vl n sm in os m ayug e ssi n Cs m ue frnain a e e ,h r a oi o o fr u m jd mn u a ig u o s s ot sc o v u h e e ei t t r t tn t ’ a t l rt
Gv n e mspoeh ud p e rcr e dne s bse b h 1temnei w c oe mn u rvta n su deod v ec e a ihs o ()h an n h h r t t t i t i tl t r i
K’ p csw ee ad2“ e o m p c grccs ote a mna e b ids yad B r e e s, n()t nr a ri p t e”fh g e s m ynur n si r t h l i n ai r t s l t; ,
fr e () h Gv n e ms d mnr e h toe w a “ostn” u h, 3te oe mn u e os a ta hst or cn s t2 tr r t t tt t e i e. 9
TeGv n e fl o a cu s Te v ecta h Gv n e cet poe o h oe mn as nl on. h e dneh te oe mn i so rv h w r ti l t i t r tt
M Loy e K’ p css h , tbs Ad h e dneo nr a p c gp ccs n h r ob s B r eit na e. n te v ec f o m ri r t ei te . t s i i t i l i n ai
g mn a e b ids ysvta ynn xtn Mroe te Gv n e mksn ra a e s m y nur i i ul o- i e . o v, h oe mn ae o e r t s l t r l es t e r r t l
ae pt d mnr e h te mnei w c M Loy e K’ p csws ostn w h t m o e os a ta h an n h h r ob s B r e a cn s t i t t tt t r i . t s i ie t
nr aids y rcc –w c ite ud mnl h w g h teGv n e ms mkt o m nur p t e h hs h fna e asoi ta h oe mn u ae o l t ai i t n t r t t
e a iht e ie e t s m ay ug e h e s bsi nt mn o u m jd mn e. t l s tl t r t r
ids y . ,w h o e mu o pot ut n ne h c mays m u fci ” D . nur. . i s m a on f rf b li octe o pn i a a r al y ; e’
t t t i i t e it ) fs Sp B e a 8id a n tatsi we e p csw e s i a mne cn s n w h h up r ft ( i t g h e s h h r e e “e n an ost t i te . i n ci t t tr i r t r ie t nr ap c grccsfhids yadn mnebivdo e dqa t esrrcv y o m ri p t e o enur ni a an eeet b aeu eo nu eoe l i n ai t t, r l t e r o.. pot neK bc m am u fci ” i a 9ag n ta – o e os a tate f. a rf oc B ea e a r al y ; d t ( u g h t d mnr eh h i t e it ) . ri t tt t r a os p ewe K ad Mc en B Gn une p cs Mc en cu “e os a et nh b en B n ac ny C if ecd r e – ac ny o d d mnr e li i t l / l i l l tt tate r e. ws ei a mneta ws o cn s n w h h nr a p c g rccs f h h p c.. a s n an h an ost t i te o m ri p t e o t i t r t t ie t l i n ai te nur ad r ws o ei a mneta ws xe e t ui al yl apot ;d h ids y n o an t n an h a epc d o l m e i d rf” i t / ts r t t t ty e i) .
( d a n tatsi we e p c ws“ei a mne cn s n w h h nr a p c g i i t g h e s h h r e a s n an ost t i te o m ri n ci t t tr i t r ie t l in p ccs f hids y n o w h h epct n h . . potwl e and. H wv , r t e ote nur ad r i te xe a o ta . a rf i b e e” o ee ai t / t ti t i l r ) r n h gnh p t s pp s upr te o o osc a w-a ts(togide n se o i ite ai ’ ae sposh n in f uh t op te a huh os o e m tn re r t t r tl t t f - thd o su e h a m g o pots ne ni tenr a p c gp ccso ay af ce t a m ta re s t a i f rf iih e n h o m ri r t e f n rn i rt l i n ai ids y nur)
t .
I s mfr upss f his n m in os m ay ug e , h s e e vntsi n u, o proe ote n a o o fr u m jd mn te o r ea e s tt t r t l l t t we e M Loy ep cs o K “ amnecn s n w hh nr ap c g rccs o h h r ob s r efr Bi tr . ti n an ost t i te o m ri p t e” f r ie t l i n ai
te a mna e b ids y h g e s m y nu r r t s l t. 29 Se eeay u o sG dne nAcp bi o T nainV ui R a d a y e gnr l Cs m u ac o ce a l y f r sc o a en et P t l t i t it a t l le r T nain a78epi ntat poeh t nain a es ce a e easte r e r sc ost - (x a igh,o rvta r sc o v ui acp b bcueh p c a t ln t ta t l tl i ws eld n codnew h o m ids y rig rccs p t “ u [] ae b c v a st i acrac i nr a nur p c p t e a y ms 1 hv o eie te t l t i n ai , r t jt e dnefh nr ap c grccsfhids yn us o ad2p sne dneh te v ec o e o m ri p t e o enuri qein n[]r e v ecta h i t l i n ai t t t e t i t t n e p c ws eld n codnew h hsids y rccs. r s r r e a st i acrac i tee nur p t e” af i te t t ai )
or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 1
Attemne nw c K’ p csw eeteGv n e rpa d s e eta M soh an i h h B r e e s,h oe mn ee e yt s sh r r i si r t r t tl rs t .
Loy a “eae o p c st g xe eci te mn tlrdl h g u ns ” n ws ob hs dcds f r e ei ep ine n h e’ a o c t n bs e , ad a i - tn r s i e oi i s
– s M Loy u t “u y aa e f se ig raoa e r e e D edns t e e a r ob p i–f l cpb oa s n aesnb p c ”Se e na ’ St mn . t l l ss l i. f t a t
o M e a Fc A T W c Te A N Gn n I usT B T e (D. sSt mn o f a rl a s s o h h h e r o eu es e o e r d “e ’ t e e f ti t i r e i s i f a t
Fc ” 2 (seig h Loy“a ep ine i st g r efr a mn adwsf l as t )¶ 4 a r n ta ob ws xe ecd n ei p cs o g e s n a‘u y st t r tn i r t l
cpb o a e ig raoa er e ) qo n LoyDpsina16 D. up Rp aa ef s s n a esnb p c ” (u ig ob eot l ss l i’ t i o t 4) e’ p e y ; fsS . l
r fa7 0 o ee ii oeh go s bsta r ob hdh a l yo e r e aa B e t. H wv ,ts nt nt e a ihh M Loy ate bi t s p cst n i 3 r i tl t . it ti
aportlv.ts ue df e mt t e a ihh hi fcd s h e1 Te ra s prp a ee I q t ai e n ae o s bsta ena i o e. h g t t ie l i i f r t tr t l t t d r3 ee
cne inh teGv n e cu e rcfo M Loyws se il aa o g –., e ocs ota h oe mn o d x a r m r ob a e na y tu l y i.h s t r t l t t . s tl to e
30 Seloe.D. r fa6 a eig h Loy“ a ep ine ist g a mn e a , g e’ i t (s r n ta ob ws xe ecd nei g e s . , fsB e st t r tn r t p cs n ws‘u yaa ef se ig raoa er e )D. e yB e t (seig r e ad a f l cpb o a s n a esnb p c ” e’ p r fa7 a r n i l l ss l i ’ ; fsR l i st ta ob “o e es nia ep ine nhg mnids yn ..a a iaw hh w h Loy ps s si i cn xe ec itea e nurad .wsf mi i o t s s gf t r r t t lr t p cs r s i ..h ids y adh Loywsf l a a o h w oe r ie a mn r e a e n .ta nur ” nta ob a “u y w e f o t d e m g e i e t t t, t l r t n r t a e b p cs n mne h wu l m e e n ha e b r pot nets r u cs s m yr e ia an s l i rta o dui al a tes m earf oc i t t p o s t l t ty r s l i s a- t w ef l a oie” i a 1 (seig h “ vnh e es e xe ec i teg mn e u y mrzd ; d t 1 a r n ta g e i x n v ep ine n h a e r l t ) . st t i s t i r r t ids y M Loy wu ko h wp csa s i taids y adn ig h Loy nur r ob o d n w o r e r e n h nur ” n o n ta ob t, . l i e t t t, t t “ sf d h h wsf l cpb o a e ig raoa ep c ad g e . . h h i t ti ta e a ‘u y aa e f s s n a esnb r e n ar d . ta es ei e t l l ss l i’ e t ‘xe ecd n eig r efr a mn’ (u igLoyDpsint 4-7 ep ine i st p cs o g e s ) qo n ob eot a 164)
r tn i r t” t io . 31 A d cse i g a rd a b o, h p cs h M Loy efr K nv ee s i u d n r t ei e wte r eta r ob s o B ee vn s s e e tl l i t . t r cv ete o pn’ epne K oe tdt ls ec ad v y e oi e s nefo oe dh c may xess B p a aao ah n ee ya f s xt c r m r s . re s r r t ie , te mte o pn bgn rdc oi 19 u i h c may esd p a osn 07Se ht eh c may ea pouinn 98 nl e o pn cae oe t ni 20 e, i t tt ri . e. D. Rp B ea5i pcl akold nta K “ i e]o an pot e a e . , e’ e y r ft ( m it cn w g gh Bfl dt e a rf ya f r g fs l i li y ei t a[ r i rt ya )P’ B ea1(seigh,oeey e oc may oe t n “ B t aepne e ” ls r ft 8a r ntafr v ya f o pn’ p a os K’ ol xess r; . i st t r r s ri , st eceei t aic m ec ya rs t g n lsfr ah e ” xeddt ol no e ah e ,eui i a o oec ya )
st r ln s r.
A a a d ii wr n ig h – l og te nis nqeinh e w e md i s n s e ts o h o n ta a huh h e r i us o e e ae n i, t t t t te t r r 20 20 – o p t sre r y nno min oc n g M Loy p c g rccs n 00 01 b h ai f l e oifr a o cne i r ob’ ri p t e ad / t re e y l t rn . s i n ai K’ oe t n oete nr l eote o pn ( o 19 t 20) W h u oe a y B p a os v h e i i f h c mayf m 97 o 07 i js n e l s ri r te f r . t t r ecp o nte p thsqeind h r eac o po t o sc ifr a o SeD. xe in e h a a us oe te e vne r rb y f uh no min e e’
t , i r r t l i t . fs Rsos t P’ St mn o Fc ¶2 (s oc t naea os et g o Gv n e ’ epne o ls t e e f a s 1 a t e a l gin r a n t oe mns . a t t ri l t li r t cu e l ma eig h “ ne he r st suw emd n00 n 20 ..ayiu s on r a , s r n ta s c teni ai ee aei20 ad 01 .,n f r t ci s t ti te s r ge fr 99ri e vnt t s c o” o 19 a r l a o h a in .
ere t i t )
or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 2
ca c r ete r etah s frK a “esnb ” eas “ e u eosl mn ite h a e zdh p csh e e o B s raoa e bcuet n m u e e snh r ti i t t l h r e t
oe t gbde w eraoa e”SeD. r fa 8(tn adca c rig Loy p a n ug e esnb . e e’ i t1 cig n h a e z , ob ri t r l fsB e i , r ti n
Dpsina174) e paeadd3 TeGv n e ’e pa s n M Loy kolde eot t 4-8( mhssde)2 h oe mns mhs o r ob’ n w g io . r t i . s e
o p c g rccs osilt avnet cs f ri p t e delt o daci ae i n ai te s .
Te Gv n e ’ p n p ci cnen g K’ p css bod sein h M h oe mns r c a l m oc i r t iil a r n B r ei a ra a r o ta r s i st t .
Loyee o “ei d anabde i d e m igh p csh Mc en B G a t ob rid n d ae” nu ug sn e r i nte r eta ac ny C p do l tl l t t n i t l / i
K – h i ta “r e w e e bsduo bde ta po c d h epr r ic m ad B ta s h p cs e s ae pn ug s h r e e te xo e s no e n t, t i r t t t jt t’
epne adt lv ta ws xe e t ra a rf octe xo e st tu cs w e xess n aaee h a epc d o ep pot ne h epr r s r p o s e l t t i t ’ a- t r
f l a oie ” e D . Rp B ea23ca c righfrg n ateGv n e ’ u y mrzd Se e’ e y r ft - (h a e z te o o g sh oe mns l t . fs l i r ti n ei r t
“ o r ea ag mn ) D. B ea6a eigh “r e w e ae uo d ae bde ms e vn ru e ” e’ r ft (s r nta p cs e bsd pn ei d ug s tl t t ; fs i st t i r tl t
r a nt K’ a i p e poui t ad xess. B ta s osy gmc O s m et go B nc a d rdc v y n epne”3 u h i n a n uh n o e li s ti t ti )3 t t t i .
32 AteGv n e epis s h oe mn x a :
r t ln
Se f a y we akdwa mdter eraoa e M Loyt e “ my pci l , hnse h aeh p c “ snb, r ob std[ ]
i cl t i e l” . a f mi i w h hlbr o e ad m f mi i w h h p ne bde ad a iat i teao cn n n ya iat i te l nd ug s n lry t tt lry t a t biv g h toe h g..w e esnb..” H fr e epie ta i ee n ta hst ns. e raoa e . e u h x a d h, n l i t i r l. tr ln t h ids yar ewu b “n aoa e we “teoeierh o e ws i nur p c o d e ur snb ” h e e h ns o et r a s t, i l e l r i r d t h erg u y ee cls ] r u. g i s bn i a[ c o hr” e ol fi i t
D. B e a 1 (u igLoyDpsint 4-8 Se loe.D. e yB e t 1 e’ r ft 8 qo n ob eot a 174) e a , g e’ p r fa1 fs i t io . s . , fsR l i ( g n ta ob t e ta te Bp cs e ew e‘ aoa e” n ta [ ]e akd o a u g h Loystd h “ K r e h s e r snb, ad h “ whn se t ri t a th i tr e l’ t e br e pn h e eee te ie h s tb ‘ aoa e M ob stdta eas l o t uo wyh bivd hp cs e e oer snb, r oy t e i sbcue a a l r t e l’ .L a w h sd‘ aoa e bde ” qo n adca c rig ob eoi o a 164) i eue r snb ’ ug s e l t )(u ig n h a e z ,LoyDp sin t 4-7 d t , r ti n t ; .
( a n taLoy“ sf d h ter e h s fr Bw ebsd pn i‘ee o wai st g h ob t ti ta hp cs e e oK e ae uo h bi f h t ti t ei e t i t r s lf t og t ed p oig n b raoa e oteaocn no te a mn ”(u ig ob uh o n u cs n ad e esnb fr hlbr o e f h g e ’ qo n Loy t t l tt r t) t Dpsint 4) eot a16 io . 33 Seloe. D . St mno Fc ¶ 2-0a eigh “r e w e ae uo e a , g e’ t e e f a s ¶ 73 (s r nta p cs e bsd pn s . , fs a t t st t i r .. ei d ug s w c w ei eddoe e K’‘ at’ead g nc a d xess . d ae bde ” h h e “ tnetr lc B r l yrg i a i p e epne tl t i r n f t s ei r n ti t ad nc a d rdc o” nic dd mn l p nfr rdc o lbr o s n oeha n a i p e pouin adn ue “ o h l s o pouin aocs ad v ed ti t t l ty a t , t r epne o s adw c w e p p e frK b B G v ep s e o mnfc r ga xes cs, n h h e “r a d o B y C ’ i r i n f au t i , t” i r er s c ed t a un or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 3
lv, v y ee bss s r e o s mfr o bde( bt oncsal a o m,wt n ee ee sl aei p cs n o e o m f ug a e n ee r y fr a rt l r lr t i t li t si l ie
oe adh gao bs a ylc m e i s e ai t it tr a rf. TeGv n e ’ n ; nte o f a cl a o m cl a s c v ys o un pot h oe mns ) l il l r a l ti i r t
a ein h K’ p csw e e vdr m ug s n a i p e pot as m use f d s r o ta B r e e d ie fo bde ad nc a d rfst o e npci st t si r r t ti t i ie
p nite u ritu s gn i ad n e aat bl g yma n e . o tnhf u s hs o ee c n u v s s o ea e en g s i te r i rl rl ils
Te v ecta h Gv n e cet spo i gn azdl msi i r as a h e dneh te oe mn i so uprt ee l e ci is ma y brc i t r tt t s ri a ll t t
ad ak g nsf c n se fi . Cnp uu y ak g se dne h ds ie w h n lc n i ui e pcit i fi t i c y os cos lc n i v ec ta ec bs i i l i i t r t
p t u r y o M Loy sdh “ei d anabde ta h Gv n e tu t d ie ai l i h w r ob uete d ae” nu ug sh te oe mn o so e v rc at . tl l t t r t t r
p cs o K. Fr x m ete v ec o wih h Gv n e ris as o dqal r e fr B o ea p, h e dne n hc te oe mn ee flt aeu e i l i r t l i ty
epi we e we M Loy p c g rccsw en net yl a rf frK 3 (n x a h h / hn r ob’ ri p t e e i eddoi d pot o B ad ln tr . s i n ai r t e i 4 ,
‘ui gy n t ie’ n n ne ad h K p n mng ”(u ig n o cigLoy qat u adr n , a eg e , n te B l t aae ) qo n ad ri n ob ly a r i r a r t / t Dpsint 5 196 166 P’ RsossoD. Fsad h dn roa r s D . eot a17 5-0 6-7 ls epnet e’ it n T rI e g o e; e’
io , , ;. fs r i t r t i ) fs B e a 6 a eig h p csw e ae o “ei d nu bde w c ic dd mn l r ft (s r n ta r e e bsd n d ae ana ug s h h n ue o h i st t i r tl l t i l ty p nfr rdc o lbr o s n oeha epne o s (u igP’ Rsoss oD . l s o pouin ao cs ad v ed xes cs ” qo n ls epnet e’ a t , t r t) t . fs FsI e oa r s i a1 (seigh “r e w e ebsd pn ei d ug s.ta it n r g o e; d t 7a r nta p cs e s ae uo d ae bde ..h r tr ti ) . st t i r t tl t t w e rp e frK b B G v e rs e o mnfc r ga qat gy n t ie’ n e p a d o B y C ’ i p i n f au t i , ‘ui u adr n, a r er s c ed t a un ly a r eg e, n te K p n mng , ad h “ ]c ya spo c dbde ws n ne t n ne ad h B l t aae ” n ta [ ah e ’ r e e ug ai edd o i r a r t e r jt t t r lc K’ ‘ at’rg d ga i p e epne ada i p e pouin ;i a 1 ee f t B r l y ea i nc a d xess n nc a d rdc o” d t 9 s ei r n ti t ti t t ) .
( f r g o ei oy h p cs w e bsduo po c dbde ” i a 2 ( a n ta r ei t ts mn ta r e e “ae pn r e e ug s ; d t 0 st g h ern t t i r jt t) . ti t “ B p csw eebsd pn ei d ug s ;D. Rp B ea23ag nta“r e K’ r e e s ae uo d ae bde ” e’ e y r ft-( u gh p cs si r t tl t ) fs l i ri t i w e e bsduo bde ta po c d h epr r ic m adepne” i a 4n e s ae pn ug s h r e e te xo e s no e n xess ; d t . r t t t jt t’ ) . 9 ( f r g o tebde uo w c M Loybsdh p c gdcin fr K ” i a 6 r ei t “ ern h ug s pn h h r ob ae i ri e s s o B ;d t t i . s i n io ) .
(seigh “r e w eebsd pnr e e bde ” i a1(seigh “ B p cs a r nta p cs e s ae uo po c d ug s ;d t 2a r nta K’ r e st t i r t jt t) . st t si w e e bsduo d ae po c dbde ” D. Sp Rp B e a 7 a eig h e s ae pn ei d r e e ug s ; e’ up e y r f t (s r n ta r t tl jt t ) fs . l i st t “r e w e e . bsd pn ei d ug s. p cs e s .. ae uo d ae bde ” i r t tl t)
34 A oe o t nt b e, h Gv n e stsll ta“ B p csw e e bsd t n p ni i r f te oe mn t eft h K’ r e e s ae i s is r t a ay t si r t uo d ae bde w c iacr ewu hv ere K a r io eey a mns d – pn ei d ug s h h f cu t o d ae and B pot n vr gr e o ”
tl t i, a, l f tl se ig id a nta K’ p cse e e a epct nfrf fo DyOefrdc o e m l n cigh B r er lc d n xe a o opotr m a n opouin n y it t si f t ti i t .
Se e’ B e a 2 ( mhs add se lo da 1 (seig ee l ,w hur e ne e D. r ft 0 e pa s de) e a i t 7 a r n gn a y i o e r c fs i i ; s . st rl t t f e t ay mf m tap cs e w e e“ amneta . ws xe et rs tnh sl o nt er e h r e h e e s i i a , ti r r t n an h .. a epc doeu ite ee r t t l lr
raz g raoa e rf” i a1 (seig w h oe pr l ma o –h “r e w e ei n aesnb pot ; d t 9a r n – i nt mo l it n ta p cs e li l i) . st t a i ti t i r s t poue raoa e rf frK bsd pn r e e bde ” D . Sp B e a 9 e o rdc a esnb pot o B ae uo po c d ug s ; e’ up r ft t l i jt t ) fs . i (seig– w hurs vin– h Loy e p cs w h h epct n h . . pot a rn st i o ee a o ta ob s r e “i te xe a o ta . a rf t t rt t t i t ti t i or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 4
i s te n ne m g o ay uhpot3 Ide te Gv n e i n c a ee at f o h i edd a i f n sc rf)5 ned h oe mn s o l r vn s o , t rn i. , r t t e
[ o db e nd .H wv ,h uqaf dt e e iaod w hh Gv n e ’ psin wu ] e a e” o eeta nui e st mn st ds i te oe mns ot l r ) r t li a t t r t io a aiutdle h e nt b e. Nrs uh n sein upr d y hrcr e dne src a e we i i r f oi sc a a r o spo e b teeod v ec t le s r s is st t i .
Is a teGv n e ’ psin pe s o e h te r eta M Loy e w e n ed h oe mns ot apa t bta h p cs h r ob s e t , r t io r t i t . t r ee u l epc doi d pot o K, un “ ‘ et tu ya. See’ St mn vn ay xe et yl a rf fr Bb o i t s r p e s” eD. t e e tl t e i t t n h a- r’ fs a t o Fc ¶ 1cig ob Dpsint 6 19 seloe.i ¶ 3-2a eigh “ ws f a s 3(t Loy eot a10 6) e a , g d ¶ 13(s r nta i a t in io , ; s .,. st tt epc dh,f rh s r u paete r e h gdwu ..i d raoa e rf, ad xe eta aetet t p hs,h p c ca e o d. yl aesnb pot n t t t a- i r l e l i”
ta “ whn K bgnpouin n19 i ws xe e t bc m a m u adpotb h [ ]e B ea rdc o i 98 t a epc d o eo e a r n rfa e t t , t te i l mnfc r gal yw h ae ya ”(t g ob Dpsint 6 148 P’ Rsoss au t i fci i i f w er )ci Loy eot a11 8-5 ls epne a u n it t n s in io , ;.
t D. T rI e oa r s( mhss de) D. B ea1-8a eigh “]e ws o e’ h dn r g o e e paeadd e’ r ft 71(s r nta [ h e a fs i t r t i ) ; fs i st tt r n a i pin f rf i ‘ et tu ya, ad h “] ws xe e ta a etet tu o nc a o o pot nt s r p e s” n ta [t a epc d h, f r h s r p ti t i h a- r’ ti t t t a- paete r e h gdwu . . i d raoa e rf” i a 1 (seig h, n 98 hs h p c ca e o d . yl a esnb pot ; d t 8 a r n ta i 19 , i r l e l i) . st t , potws xe et “o ew h ae ya ” D. Rp B ea23a eigh Loy rf a epc do c m i i f w e s ; e’ e y r ft - (s r nta ob i t tn r ) fs l i st t s p cs aaee h ws xe et ra a rf octe xo e st tu cs w e u y e r e “ lv ta a epc doep pot neh epr r s r p o s e f l ti t l t t i t ’ a- t r l a oie” i a6a eigh p cse e e “ e xe a ota we K bc m am u mrzd ; d t (s r nta r er lc dt epct nh hn B ea e a r t ) . st ti f t h ti t te mnfc r g al yi wu e n pot ; i a 78 a eig h Loy e p cs i a au t i fci ,t o d a a rf” d t - (s r n ta ob s r e “ a u n it l r i) . st t t i n mneta wu ui al e n K] pot nets r u cs w e u y mrzd ;i an h o dl m e a [ Ba rf oci t t p o s e f l a oie” d r t l t ty r i s a- t r l t ) .
a 1 (seig h “ Bws oepc d o e rfa et h bg n g ; da 1 (seig t 0 a r n ta K a n xe e t b potb ate e n n” i t 2 a r n st t t t i l ii ) . st ta p csw e e w h xe a o ta“ raoa e rf [ o d b e nd y K] f rt h r e e s i epct n h a esnb pot wu ] e a e b [ B a ei ti r t t ti t l i l r t [ea e a m u fci ” D . Sp B e a 8 a eig h p csw e e“ a mne bc m ] a r al y ; e’ up r ft (s r n ta r e e s i t e it ) fs . i st ti r t n an r bivdo e dqa t esrrcv y f. a rf oc K bc m am u fci ” i eeet b aeu eo nu eoe o.. pot ne B ea e a r al y ; d l t e r i t e it ) . a 9 a eig h Loy e p csi a mneta ws xe e t ui al yl a rf” t (s r n ta ob s r e “ st t ti n an h a epc d o l m e i d pot ;
r t t t ty e i)
D. Sp Rp B ea7a eigh p csw e e“i te xe a o oa rf oc e’ up e y r ft (s r nta r e e s w hh epct n f pot ne fs . l i st ti r t t ti i K m u d eod h s r u pae . B a r byn tet t p hs”
te a- )
I adints oc a weteGv n e cn nsK’s r u paews o pt n d t , i n l r hnh oe mn o ed B t t p hs ac m e, io i te r t t s a- le sc taa rf wu hv be epc d Fr x m ete i a ih e a b u y n h uh h pot o d ae en xe e o ea p, h es n ne n m g t i te t i l t. l r rt ii Gv n e ’rp snt n h “ 19 K ws xe e t bc m a m u mnfc r g oe mns er e a o ta i 98 B a epc d o eo e a r au t i r t e ti t n , t te a un fci ad rf wu c m w h ae ya.. Te nistsu w emdw h toe al y n pot o d o e i i f w e s . h e r a se e aei i hs it i l tn r. te i r tn f sf w er”Se e’ B e a 1 ( mhs add se lo e’ St mn o Fc ¶ 3 i te ya . e D . r ft 8 e pa s de) e a D. t e e f a s 3 r s fs i i ; s fs a t t (seigh “]e nistsu w emdw h te r f w er o K s r n pouin) a r nta [ h e r a se e ae t nhf s e ya f Bt t g rdc o ” st tt te i r ii it s ai t ( mhs add Teosr e neotoe r f w e s cn eed n o e )on c e e pa s de) hloee r ct “ sfs e ya ” a bra( cn x tid a i . fe h it r i tt it ta h Gv n e cn nsh K wstln st tu paen 00 01 h d e ote h te oe mn o edta B asl i s r p hsi 20 20 te a s fh t r t t t i i t a- / , t e r sn us o use e.i ¶ 3-2a eigh “ whnK bgnrdc oi 19 ni i qein te , g d ¶ 13(s r nta [ ]e B ea pouinn 98 te t .B .,. st t t , i ws xe e t bc m a m u adpotb mnfc r g al yi i a e ya ” t a epc d o eo e a r n rfa e au t i fci w h f w er )
t te i l a u n it t n s ( mhs add se lo e’ B e a 2 ( f r g o K’ s r u pae we lt o n e pa s de) e a D . r ft 3r ei t “ B t t p hs ‘ hnil r o i ; s fs i ern s a- te pouinws apn g ) Teeodslo o b b rnf v ec ad s n p n sc rdc o a hpe n’ . hrcria n a y a e oe dne dr s g o t uh t i ” s tl r i ei i s ate e nin f “ a-p pae r e o te y c drin ft tu oe t ni te s h d i t o a s r u” hs o p id htp a u t os r p p a os n h fio tt r , i l ao a- ri g mna e b ids y n u n e.te sap ideu et a oiet tu cs)ad a e s m ynur( c d g . ,h uu e orq rdo mrzs r p o s n r ts l t ili, g l r i t a- t, h wog nr a yae g mna e b f mt so a rf. ts n n ee , n su d o lni o mltks a e s m yi so h w potI , ay vn ud p e t l r t s l r i ii t i t ta– v tei ote o pn –K nv tre a rf. h oe hl e f h c may B ee und pot t r f r i or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 5
we e wete r eta M Loy e w e e get cv K’ cs.6 Teog nte h h / hnh p csh r ob s e ds ndo oe B o s3 hln adh tr i t . t r i r s t
35 TeGv n e ce n e dne unf ni aywy n potm g ta ws ut h oe mn i s o v ec qa iy gn n a ayrf a i h a b l r tt i ti i rn t i i oh p csh M Loy eote x note rf tah p csw ete w e xe e n te r eta r ob s rh e e fh poth i r e e o ri epc d t i t . t tt i tsi r h s t t yl Is a teGv n e r e o y au y n gn a yo “ aoa e pot o oi d n ed h oe mn e r n vge ad ee l t ar snb ” rf – r e. t , r t fs l l rl e l i , eels d i t e ,o s mlv o pot e, g D. St mno Fc ¶ 1a eig vne e ni l t “o eee f rf. ee. e’ t e e f a s 3 (s r n s fiv y l i”S . , fs a t t st ta“ ws xe e ta a etet tu pae h p c cagdwu .. i d raoa e h i a epc d h, f r h s r p hs te r e h e o d. yl a esnb tt t t t a- , i r l e l pot (t gLoyDpsint 6 P’ Rsoss oD. T r I e oa r s D . rf” ci ob eot a 11 ls epnet e’ h d n r g o e; e’
i) in io ;. fs i t r t i ) fs B ea2 (seigh p cs eb Loyw e bsd pn n xe a ota[ B wu . r ft 0a r nta r es y ob e “ae uo a epct nh K] o d i st ti t r ti t l . raz s m lv o pot ( mhs add i (seig h lc o Mc en B G . eie o e ee f r i) e pa s de) d a r n ta ak f ac ny C l l f” i ; . st t l / if ec i d mnr e b fcta K’ p cspo c d i p “”pot o use f d n une s e os a d y a h B r e r e e s m y a rf, f npci l tt t t s i jt l i ie a on;sea oi a 1-8 r eig o“ raoa epot ;d a 1 ( f r g o“ mu ) e l d t 71 ( f r t a esnb rf” i t 9 r ei t a t s . ern l i) . ern raoa e rf” D . Rp B ea 1 ( f r g o aesnb pot. esnb pot ; e’ e y r ft 2r ei t “raoa e rf”
l i ) fs l i ern l i)
Aa , s o d bv ii ud p e ta K nv gn a d pot g na n e aoe ts n su d h B ee ee t a rf. i t , i t t r re i 36 Asv a p n i i b e, h Gv n e sts–ueu oa yadw hu ay t ee l o t nt r f te oe mn t e r is s is r t a nq vcl n i o n i l, t t
l ma o atte mf m –h M Loy p c grccsw e e get esrta K i it nsoht er e ta r ob’ ri p t e e ds ndo nu h B ti i a t . s i n ai r i e t wu a es“ra ee” i. eoplo h c may cs)r mDyOefh c may o dt a b k vn(., cu a f e o pn’ o sfo a n o e o pn’ l l t e er l t s t t s oe t n SeD. B e a 1 (t gLoy Dpsina 10 19 sea o d a 2 p a os e e’ r f t 7 ci ri . fs i i n ob eot t 6 6) e l i t 0 io , ; s .
(seig w h o ma o tap cs eb Loyw e bsd pn n xe a ota[ B a r n i nl it n h r es y ob e “ae uo a epct nh K] st , t i ti , t i t r ti t wu cv i epne” D . Rp B ea1 (seig w hurs vin h Loy e o d oe t xess ; e’ e y r ft 2a r n i o ee a o ta ob s l rs ) fs l i st , t t r t , t t K’ p csw h xe a o “ aa bde d o s wu b cv e” D. Sp B e a B r e i epct nt tl ug e cs [ o d e oe d ; e’ up r ft si t ti h l t t l ] r ) fs . i 9 a eig w hu qaf a o ta p csw e e“i te xe a o taa cs wl e (s r n i o ui cin h r e e s w h h epct n h l o s i b s t , t t li t , t i r t t ti tl t l rcv e” eoe d.
r )
E e h eh wv ,h Gv n e tks cniig ot nci ign edh te l we , o ee te oe mn ae a ofc n psi ,l m is ata h s r r r t lt io a n t t p cs e b M Loyw e n ne t cv K’ cs o y f r“ a-p oe t n w e r e s y r ob e i edd o oe B o s n ae s r u” p a os e i t . r t r s t l t tt ri r cn ue e, g D . St mno Fc ¶ 1a eigh “ ws xe eta a ete oc dd ee. e’ t e e f a s 3 (s r nta i a epc dh,f rh l .S . , fs a t t st tt t t t s r u paetep c cagdwu cv epne”(t gLoyDpsint11 P’ t t p hs h r e h e o d oe xess ci ob eot a 6 ls a- , i r l r ) in io ;. Rsoss oD . T r I e oa r s D. B e a 1-8 a eig h “ ws xe e epnet e’ h d n r g o e; e’ r ft 71 (s r n ta i a epc d fs i t r t i ) fs i st tt t ta a etet tu pae h p c cagdwu cv epne” Ii uc a we eay h,f rh s r p hs te r e h e o d oe xess. ts n e h h n t t a- , i r l r ) lr tr p t fh cnu oite xt geodeusr mh p t s ue f mrc ee m o g a ote ofs nnh e s n rcr rs tfo te ai ’ s oi p i t i l y r i ii l re es r n o , fl g o iig s a og rdc o cs, p a n cs, n o e c eo e o cs (uh ai t dt u h mn pouin o soe t g o sad t r a gr s f o ssc in sn i t t ri t h t i t as r u cs) st t p o s a- t.
I ay vnte i n d p eh, ote nr y f s e l 1 ya o oe t n K n n ee ,h es oi u ta frh e i t oi na y 0 e s f p a o B t r st t te t r r ri , nv octre a rf, n i fc cn s n y p a dt ls e, g D. Rp B e ee neund potad na, ost t oe t aao .See. e’ e y r f r i , t i el r e s . , fs l i a 5i pcl akold n ta K “ i e] o an pot e a e ya ) P’ St mn t ( m it cn w g g h B fl dt e a rf ya f r e ” ls t e e li y ei t a[ r i rt r; . a t o Fc ¶ 3st gh “ B t aepneeceet a no en ah e rs t gn ls f a s 2( a nta K’ ol xess xeddol c mi ec ya eui i ao t ti t st ti r ln s frec ya ” w hn “rf o ay o ” (t gi e a a Loy Aia t¶ 3-1 ( o ah e , i o pot f n sr ) ci , n r l , ob f dv ¶ 03) a r t i t in t i f i st mn ta te Gv n e “e e fr ako koldeo ifr a o ” huh h t e e h h oe mn dn s o lc f n w g r no min tog te a t t r t i e t , or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 6
Gv n e a o ocdsh tet e e ispo e b LoyAia t 3) P’ B ea oe mn l cneeta h st mn s upr d y ob f dv ¶ 4 ls r ft r ts t a t t f i ;. i 1 (seigh, oeey e oc may oe t n “ B t aepne eceei t a 8a r nta fr v ya f o pn’ p a os K’ ol xess xedd sol st t r r s ri , st t t ic m ec ya rs t gn lsfr ah e ” i a2 (a e P’ Rp B ea2s m ; no e ah e ,eui i ao oec ya ) d t 2s m ; ls e y r ft (a e r ln s r; . ) . l i )
i a3s m ;da91 (a e i a1 (a e P’ Sp B ea1s m ;da4s m ;d d t (a e i t -0s m ;d t 7s m ; ls up r ft (a e i t (a e i . ) . ) . ) . . i ) . ) . a5s m. t (a e)
H h g ig h fc ot s ae Mc en r ss h qeinwy asna ue s i l h n te a s f h cs ac ny a ete us o h – be by ’ gi t t i , l i t t r “ f ec” v teee– n sl ta ee e yaetraz arf oi s e( uhe i l ne oe hsl ayee h rpa d fldoeie pot n sa s mcls nu r lr lr t tl i l i t l s cn ne t pe p c alse)wu n fec mee t tk ainsc a b r s gt o iud o i u a u o s o d o e o pld oae c o (uh s y ai i t l tl s l t l l t in s p cs n ose n o adin cs m s i a e o t aam i u,tnhh b e n r e ad r ek g u d t a u o e ) n nf r o t i m ms ctel d g i / i t i o l t r, ft , n a ei. Se e. P’ Rp B e a 1 ( g n ta w hK cn s n y p a n aa o , [ o c e, g ls e y r ft 0 a u g h, i B ost t oe t gt ls “]g ., . l i ri t t i el ri s l i wu dt e cag..i eaic aen p csn a so ac nyB G oa a p g o di a a hne. e h nn esi r ei s et [Mc en C ] r c ma n l ct tr r i l l / i tf d n sloteby str e mrl e traz arf fr K] ;e a olsB e o n adet o r ue ap cs o i l oeie poto[ B ) el P’ r f i l h r i eky l i ”s s . i a1 ( g nta we by ad eea n r a dsl fcdw hee else wu t 9a u gh, h e ue n sl r o et , ee ae i rpa do s o d ri t r r lr e t l e lr t t s l “ek o e bs e w hh hp oe n g pot ; d( g nta g e cn nelse se[ t r u ns i te oe f a i a rf” i a u gh,i n o iudo s ] h i s t rn i) . r i t v t s, “ K w e or a d oB G . , od u ns snewu dt ei eta K r s ]t i B e n et t C . . go bs e es o d i a e h h B a e i f r t le i s l ct t r t i[ s p csfri s et B G r h K f d ad e[t o e cs m st r e[ e ig a r e[o t a s o C ota Bi [ n sl o t r u o e a p cs yl n] i ]s l t n] l] h t r i id raoa e rf” P’ Sp B ea5ag nta“ ws ocn s n w hnur p cc esnb pot ; ls up r ft ( u gh i a n ost t i ids y r t e l i) . . i ri tt t ie t t ai o Mc en’t nain w h n l e sl s o K t cn ne. t sl o Mc en a r ac ny r sc os i ur a d ee fr B o o iu.. o e t ac nyt l sa t t et l r t l l p csh nv rcv e [ B ] o s w huala ty g oid nl ra v by ” r eta ee eoe d K’ cs, i o tes r n t f a aenie ue ) i t r r s t t t t i n t t r.
TeGv n e mks mc ote a tate i n st oy r te a hr y h h oe mn ae uh f h fc h h es ot u r o o r u ot ta r t t t r at h t i t rsi s h ue frnain a e n etd a y a s o n toe ae we te ee hs ertte s ot sc o v ui r a p t s et o y hs css h e h sl a tc a t l le r l l r lr mrta oe u o ead r ucs u yun a rf. See. D. B ea1-7ag n o hn n cs m n osce f ltrs pot e, g e’ r ft 61 ( u g e t r / sl i . , fs i ri ta“ e i n a hr y otepoot n h t nainv u ape o ywe te ee h t r s o u ot fr h rpsi ta r sc o a e p is n hn h sl t he t i io t a t l l l lr mksapot ad h “n i e [9 CFR §12 0() oi i ep t en e nray ae rf, n ta []t r 1 ... 5 131 rt n rri o s o n i” t eh . ] s t ev t , st oy u otrq rshrazinf poto rnain a eo p yo r a d a y t u r a hr yeu eteeia o oarf fr asc o v ut ap t aet p t at t i i l t i t t l l le r s e ; e a o da 1 ( g n ta a a mt ol wiii e vn “ h h apot ws a ” se l i t 0 a u g h, s ae f a,tsr l a we e rf a l) s . ri t tr re t tr i razd ;D . Rp B e a 6 ag n ta“ e a et u sy n h g bu h w mn eie” e’ e y r ft ( u g h t v u st e as o i ao o ay l ) fs l i ri t h l at tn t cs m s sl my ae nise rg d g sl ’ potbi ” i a1 ( g nta u o e a ee a hv adsi n ea i a ee s rfa l y ; d t 0a u gh t r lr lt rn lr i it ) . ri t “ e i n i ep t en ei i n teapcbi o t nainv u i r a dp t t r s o n rri o l mig h p ia l y f r sc o a e n et a y he t ev t t l it a t l le r t naint s uini w c te ee a ul razs pot ;d a 1 ( g n ta“ r sc os oi a os n h h h sl c a y eie a rf” i t 2 a u g h i a t tt i lr t l l i) . ri tt mksn df ec t arnainv u a e mn we ete ee hsoe u o e o a ae o i e ne o t sc o a e s s e h h h sl a n cs m r fr a t l ss t tr lr t r tosn” se eeay e’ B ea56 D . Rp B ea81 huad ;e gnr l D. r ft - e’ e y r ft -2 ) l fs i ; fs l i .
Y tem e bec oaearq r mnde n ncsal rnei e vntea e h e asne f lg eu e e os o ee r yed r l a hfc t r l i t t si rre t t ta K n o ynv tre apot b oe td ah n eeyya a a o , o a olo h B o n ee und rf, u p a ec ad v t t l r i t re r e t ls fr t a f r s t
ruh n e e s Mroe w li sreh M Loya e p cs ne o e m b we og yi ya. o v , he ituta r obr sdr e ocs mi e e en l n r e r i t t . i i t t l e u 19 adht m ote nistsu h en 00 01 h p cic ae b os a J y 99 ntei e fh e r ai e e i 20 20 ta r en es ov u y t l te s r / , ti r i l ws osf c n o oe K’ cs, eas – ow h ad ghic ae te o pn sl a n ui e t cv B o sbcue n i s n nten es –h c maytl t fi t r s t t tt i r i cn netls mny Se e’ St mno Fc ¶ 4 4 (o nta Loya e p cs o iudooe oe e D . t e e f a s ¶ 1 3 n igh ob r sd r e t . fs a t t , t t i i or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 7
“o e m a eJ y 619” n oc aa “ 20”(t g ob Dpsint 5-520 s mi ef r u 2 99 ad ne g ni 05 ci Loy eot a135 0)
t t l , i n ) in io , ;
selolsB ea2( a nta Loyn esdK’ p cs n tienh c may n e e a P’ r ft 1st gh obic ae B r e o y w ite o pn’ i s . i ti t r si l c s n ya o oe t n fs “ote a sao i 20 ” n te oc aa , nDc me 20) e s f p a o –it fr h fl esn n 00 ad hn ne g ni ee b 05 r ri r, l , i r D. B e a 1 (se il tes m. I l h o K’ ssie rcr o lse te e’ r f t 9 e na y h a e n i t f B u a d eod f o s h fs i s tl ) g s tn s, Gv n e ’ ci tafr e p cic ae w e nee ay bcuei d g. po c d oe mnsl mh u h r en ess e uncs r “eas d i n.. r e e r t a t tri r r s vi jt t a cs b . .po c d q v e u t yls f u q t c s t te no ep c”s ol o s y . r e e eu a n ns i d ai r ue l e o h iv c r e i t t jt ilt i e ge i o i i cr u t syhla.Se e’ Rp B ea1 n 6 I o e wrs fateGv n e u os o atees e D. e y r ft 1. . nt r od i(sh oe mn i , t fs l i 1 h , r t ps l e iv c p ci eu a n o r e et acs d ie b po c d u u te i o uts no e r es q v e t po c dol o si dd y r e e o p ,h es ta ) i i ilt jt t t v jt t t r ov u y o rf aa – n oewu a u eh,n ee la o nap cic aewu b os n pottl ad n o d s mta i gn a p e i r en es o d i l i l l s t r, t tl i r l b oe fh o in o tea e e n ote p os n htb.
t l
Te Gv n e m nis h,a a mt o c m e i rat “rfsa n h oe mn a t n ta s r t ia t ae f o m cl ei , pot r o tr r a ly i e t ga n e eeit nain b we ur a d ais adh “ i n aa uuu fr e u a ed vnnr sc os e en n l e p t ” nta i s o tl nsa o n w rt , a t t et re tt t l l c ma e n t e n pot oeet fll g h –nhfsf w e s f xtne Se o pn s o o a a rf – r vnoa a oe e iteite ya oe s c ” e i t r i i t tr r r ie .
D. B ea2 selo d a eigh, eas “r efr odtahv n be poue e’ r ft 0 e a i (s r nta bcue p csogosh ae o enrdcd fs i ; s . st t i t t a s bsd pn nc a d xess tsl as o i eh te xesswl eih ad r e ae uo a i p e epne ii awy ps b ta h epne i b h e n et ti t , sl t l gr te xe e pot wln m e az ” h “]razdpotde n ,b i e, ed te h epc d rf i o a rl e ta [ n l e rf os o yt l rne h t i l t t ii , t u e i i t sf r c c m acsfa uuu fo a u nss np n” nta“p o c os a b wog n i u s ne os e nsa r m bs e t do t adh [] j t ncn e rn ad r t l l i s a i, t r ei n wbs e e myhv mr ‘r w gp n ta a i p e” D. Rp B e a 91 e u ns s a ae o goi a s hn nc a d ; e’ e y r f t -0 i s e n i’ ti t ) fs l i (seig h “nobs e , vnoe eig our a d u o e,sga n e t e na a r n ta [] u ns ee n sl t n l e cs m si u a ed o a st t i s ln et t r rt r pot ad h “ ] ee sak f rfa l ys o ncsal a osqec o p cs e g rf, n ta [ sl ’lc o potbi i n ee r y cneune f r e b n i” t a lr i it t si i i s too, r f o u o b we by ad ee i myu b a osqec o ua i p e e ol wo oc ls n e en ue n sl ; ajs e cneune f nnc a d t l i t r lrt t ti t fc r sc albr o sh tr o t b h h tatoeh w en ueite r e e a o, uh saocs ta un u o ei e hnhsta e ic ddnh po c d ts t t t gr t r l jt bdeuo w cter e w e ae” a huh i p hptl gh teGv n e de ug pn h hh p cs e bsd –l ogi s e asei ta h oe mn os t i i r t t r ln t r t n ad s we e tsesnb t ac b na y dcd swr ocn s n o e yaa e o dr s h h i raoa eos ie e l a eae o hf ost t s s e f r t e t ri l r r ’ t i e l s, r t ya t fc r sc a ud ei a d xess r v ei a d rdc v y e,oa o uh s ne s m e epne o oe s m e poui t) r ts rt t rt t ti .
D w gab g l eb we po c dpotad h a u raz in fpotte r i a n r h i e en r e e rf n te c a e ia o o rf, h it n t jt i tl l t i Gv n e ’ psin e mt bta – rv e taa ee s r et aetd ueala oe mns ot se s o e h po dd h sl ’ p cs o r a by tes r t io t i t lr i le r t pro t r lcs m a o ac frpot–tso n m mn we e aypot v ra y upr o e e o e l wne o rf ii f o o e h h n rf ee el t f t l i t tr i r l m e azs oee we ete eei o r hh mrhg gmny nuigms vlse a rl e(r vn h h h sl s ui t e o a n oe icr n a ieo s t ii tr lr t g r i , r s s ya a e ya a e ya. Se e. D. B e a 1 ( g n ta ueot nainv u i e f r e f r e ) e,. , e’ r f t 7 a u g h s fr sc o a e n rt rt r g fs i ri t a t l r a d a y a s os orq r sl ’ “ azin f pot ad h ii eog i i e et p t s e de n eu e ee s r l a o o a rf, n ta ts nuhf n r le r l t i l r ei t i” t ,t a ate r e wsxe e t rs tnh sl mk g raoa e rf”( mhs add l ,h p c “ aepc d oeu ite ee a n aesnb pot e pa s de) i i t l lr i l i) i ; D. Rp B ea5 d i n Mc en’ ag mn h “ hn sl ..aso an pot e’ e y r ft (e d g ac ny ru e ta we a ee .flt e a rf fs l i ri l s t t lr i r i yaa e ya ..hr a os p ewete uead ee ms aen unete r e . e f r e ,.teet nh b enh by n sl u rt r li i t r l r thvif ecdh p c”
l i )
TeGv n e cn nsh wa s e r ia vit s aesh “ e oeoarf h oe mn o edta h i d e m t enh csita t hp f pot r t t t t t ni i t h i wsm nie ya ae ya. Se e’ Rp B e a 1 ( mhss de) A Mc en a a t nd er f r er” e D. e y r ft 0 e pae add s ac ny ia t fs l i . l sge sh wv , i aa qeinwe e – be teif ec” f r a d ue – sl ugs, o ee i s f r us o h h asn h “ l ne oaet by a ee t rt i t tr t nu le r lr cn s n y p a n aa o cu o wu ke i do oe id i t y h efr e l a ost t oe t gt ls o d r o d ept or pn ne ne (e , o na y i el ri s l l s s f il r r or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 8
so otemt ita hrcr e dneas o dqal epi h w ug sw e sdo hr fh ae sh teeod v ecfl t aeu e x a o bde e uet t tr t i i ty ln t r
d e m e h p cstsu h e e r i te r e ai e e . t n i s r
TeGv n e p n t c t nei oyh ds iei bodtoete rcsta h oe mn o t o e a ts mnta ec bsn ra s ksh poe h r t i s ri t t r r s t
ws sd o ete r e o K atei e h c mayws one ad x aotsr mh a ue t s h p c fr Bt ht mte o pn afudd n e rp a fo ta t i , t le t
fr usqe ya u t 20 e gnr l D. B e a 1-9 cig i e a a Loy o sbeun e s p o 01 e eeay e’ r f t 81 (t , n r l , ob t r .S l fs i in t i
Dpsint 7-3177 118) se lo e’ Rp B e a 1 n 6 B t s v ec eot a 127 7-8 8-2 e a D. e y r ft 1. . u h e dne io , , ; s fs l i 1 ti i
dcd.See. P’ B ea1( mhsigh Gv n e ’ psinsh, ee] B G eae e, g ls r ft 9e pa z ta oe mns ot ita“ vn f C ) ., . i in t r t io t[ i adK w e or a d K [ee h e ]wu cn net oe t aao ] ote e sh n B e n et , B nv te s o d o iu[ p a t ls frh ya ta r t le r ls l t o re s r t id ” P’ Sp B ea 5a eig h “ ws ocn s n w hnur p cc” o K ti ) ls up r ft (s r n ta i a n ost t i ids y r t efr B d; . . i st tt t ie t t ai t cn ne o e t Mc en B Gt lsfr e s o o iut sl o ac ny C aa o o ya )
t l l / s r.
TeGv n e nv s ks ua ot n s o o ln a ee cn o iu mk g h oe mn ee t e o psi at h w og sl a cn ne a n r t ra t io lr t i pot e (r o n) a s o r a d ue b o te pc r f hr a d ue sif ec” rf- s ols gs et a et by e r h se e oteet by ’ “ l ne il s i l le r fe t le r nu ir sd S ma y h Gv n e nv c ri we e–ouiyh uefrnain a e sa e i i r , e oe mn ee l i e h h tjsfte s ot sc o v u i . ll t r t r afs t r t a t l i a etd a yrnain a ee s r ein( c d g r e e pot a wl si e n r a p t t sc o – sl ’ po c osi l i po c d rfs s e a n r le r a t lr jt n u n jt i, l ,t a a po c d xess n po c os oc n g rdc v y msbraoa e n rasc l , r e e epne ad r ein cne i poui t) u eesnb adeii i jt jt rn ti t l lt. See. D . Rp B ea1( mhsigh “oe ad epct ntap csefrK e, g e’ e y r ft 0e pa z te hp” n “xe a o”h r es o B . , fs l i in ti ti t wu rs tn rf,w h o cu n ote esnb ns osc hps n epct n. ts o deu i pot i n s t y fhr aoa ee f uh oe ad xe a os I l l i t ri l s ti ) i a ouc a h w onacr n t te Gv n e , sl raoa y hu b epc d o l n e o so cod g o h oe mn a ee esnb so d e xe e t s lr , i r t lr l l t r lca r e e m g o pot nt p cse. h w og s r u” p a os a e ed e e po c d a i f rf i i r e( g o ln “ a-p oe t n cn x n) f t jt rn i s i ., tt ri t . C..4 ur ( su igi e a aasne f v ec cnen gy c drin ft tu f n , pa d cs n n rl , bec oe dne oc i tp a u t os r p 3s i s ,t i i r n i l ao a-
p id ng mn a e b ids y n h w ogtnr a y ae g mn a e b f mt e o i a e s m y nur ad o ln i o ml tks a e s m yi s o r r t s l t l r t s l r so pot h w rf)
i.
F a ya d cse aoe h Gv n e flt g p e n n wyw h h ma n i l , s i u d bv te oe mn as o r p i ay a i te en g nl s s , r ti al t i otee mraoa e pot See. D. B ea1 (seigh asne fn unes fht “ snb ” rf. e, g e’ r ft 7a r nta bec oif eci r e l i . , fs i st t l id a dwe ,n rl ,r er lc d xe a ota hywu “ s tnhsl raz g n c e h e t a ap cse e e epct nh te o dr uiteee ei n it ri e i i f t ti t l el l r li a esnb pot ( mhs add Fr e a d cse aoeas m p n teGv n e raoa erf” e pa s de) u h,si u d bv t o e o t h oe mn l i) i . tr s s , is r t se s o o ed h a etdby ’if ec i d mnr e o y we te ee sp cs e mt cn n ta r a t t l e ue s n unes e os a d n h e h sl ’ r e r l tt l r lr i icro tn po c d r i mr nwa ovr See.i a 2 ( d a n tate i n nopr e o r e e pot ag h see. e, g d t 0i i t g h h es o a jt f i t ., . n ci t r if ec i a etdp t t nain fsl ’ p cs e e ee “ m lv o pot n une n r a l l e a y r sc o i ee s r e r lc vn s e ee f rf”
r a t lr i f t o l i)
( mhs add i (seigh lc o Mc en B Gn unes e os a d ya ta e pa s de) d a r nta akf ac ny C if eci d mnr e bfc h i ; . st t l / l tt t t K’ p cs r e e s m y a poto use f d mu ) Ala afs b s h wv , B r e po c di p “” rf, f npci a on. tes tit l h o ee si jt l i ie t t r u, r i wu se taaetd ue sn une v a eelg a y o d e v ecd y pot t o d e mh r a by ’if ec oe sl o cl cu b e dne b a rf l t le r l r lr i l l i i m g tai ee js s g l l w ta wu o e w eb tecs Ii uc a wya a i h s vn u l h y o e hn o d t ri e h ae t s n e h rn t tit r l h s . lr wo s e bec o potm g so d eeu e t poe n une h ea asne f rf a i hu brq rd o rvif ec l l i rn l i l .
or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 9
tosol me v u Isylt mr ta ta p c “ a d e m e b d i n te ol o i fi i d a e t asil o hn h r e ws e r i d y i d g h t a t l. te e t i t n vi t
po c d o s y h bde d u b o u tt b poue ad hn o i y on n u o r e e cs b te ug e n me f ns o e rdcd n te ps b rud g p r jt t t r i sl i
d w 51 cn . Se e’ B ea1 (t gLoyDpsint 7 17( mhs add o n -0 e s” e D . r ft 8ci ob eot a13 7)e pa s de)
t fs i in io , i .
A sc te v ec i n d i t e vn s o we e o n p cs o ayp t u rya s uh h e dnes o e ni ee at h h r o r e fr n ai l e , i t fiv tr t i rc a r
r lc d n a u mntte rdcoteol r e e cs d ie bte u b o u t e e e ay d s e oh pou fht apo c d o si dd yh n me f ns f t jt t t t jt t v r i
( eteiu ws ps b ” d s d mclstei c o (e “p r o n oe e (e i. hf r a “o i y a u e) uhe h d ein., u o d w” r x n i. ., ge sl j t , s r t i. ) t t.,
“-0 e s oay uh d s mn Nr osh Gv n e ce n e dne x a igh 51 cn ” f n sc a u e . o dete oe mn i ay v ec epi nte t) jt t r tt i ln
bs frd e m igwe e o n t mk sc a a u mn(n is te mu ota a s o e r i n h h r o o ae uh n d s e ad f o h a on f h i t n tr t jt t , , t t
a u mn. d s e )7 j t t3
37 A p tf s ae nh mne nw c K’ p csw eeteGv n e a oee s a o tcs ote an i h h B r e e s,h oe mn l ris r i r i si r t r ts l o a e e b 20lt fo Mc en’fr ecus (o dcae)tigh,n 99 n Sp me 01ee r m ac ny o m one n w eesdst tai 19 t r tr l s r l an t , “ B n st tp hs dc e ote n p csote mo e wo ak sf rr sln h K, i s r pae e dd nh u tr efrhi pr d o jce a ea m eg i t au , i i i t l t t ’ t ng iin w h ac nyB G ”Se Lt t Cs mfo Cus fr Mc en (e . eoa os i [Mc en C ] e ee o u o sr m one o ac ny Sp tt t l / . tr t l l t 2 20) D . B e Eh At ) D. B ea1 (seigh “Mc en’ o nt re 7 01( e’ r f x a2 e’ r ft 7a r nta ac ny w a ony , fs i , . ; fs i st t l s t av e Cs mta K’ p cs. hd en eoa daa m ln h” nta“]n e s d sd u o sh B r e.. a be ng i e ‘ r ’ eg , adh [ e ya i t t si tt t s t’ tt r l e t st e e ws of md y h p sn r m i rsos l fr eigK’ p cs a r h st mn a cnr e b te e o p al epn b ost t, i a t i r i ry ie t n B r e”
si )
(t gi e a a LoyDpsint 6-3 D . Rp B e a 67s m ;e a o e’ ci , n r l , ob eot a 126) e’ e y r ft - (a e se l D. in t i io ; fs l i ) s fs B ea9a eigh, a cnr e b [M Loy tern e p c b wete aisws r ft (s r nta “s of md y r ob] ht s r r e e enh p t i st t i . , af i t re a d ie aa m ln h ;D . Sp B ea 4. (a e e vdtr ’ eg ” e’ up r ft n s m. r s t ) fs . i 3 )
Te ais u r ao te o e adma n oteee se rneo a m ln h h p t qa e bu h cn x n en g fhlt ’r e ct “ s eg re r l t tt i tr f e r ’ t ng iin ”SelsSp B ea89 P’ Sp Rp B ea4 D. Sp Rp B e eoa os e P’ up r ft - ls up e y r ft; e’ up e y r f tt . . . i ;. . l i fs . l i a5 B tast mni teeei “oc sr ” n i n croo td i fc i aga y t. u h t e e n hlt s cn uoy ads o o br e – na,srub t ta t tr l , t r a t l cn a c d–b o ercr e dne Ud tee i u s ne tet e e m i lt o rdt t ie y t r eod v ec h i . ne hs c c m acs h st mn et il r r t , a t rs te w g ,p t u r a tes m ay ug e s g Segnr l Cs m G dneo e h ai l l t h u m jd mn t e e eeay u o s u ac n i t rc a y r t a. l t i Acp bi o T nain V u i R a dP t T nain a 1 (d s g h Cs m ce a l y f r sc o a e n et a y r sc os t 0 avi ta u o s t it a t l le r a t in t t “f ne c c c m acsfa ci s eastel gina cn uoy n n spo e o er e si u s ne os el m bcueh aea osr oc sr ad o upr d t jt r t l a l t e l t t b e dne ; d st gh c c m acsfa ci swl ee c dwe p t “lgsh y v ec” i ( a nta i u s ne os el m i br e e hn a y aeeta i ) . ti tr t l a l jt r l t tern e p c [ a ng i e a a m ln h b de n sb i aye dnesc a h t s r r e ws eoa d t r ’ eg , u os o u m n v ec uh s af i ] tt s t t t t i , cr sodne ewe te ais h r lc sc ng iin. o epnec b en h p t , a e e s uh eoa o” r t re t t f t tt )
Ao e m o p n o cn n o b we tep t ss h s niac ote a ta n h a r o t f o e in e en h ai itei i cne f h fc h tr j i tt t re gf t t p csw env oet ng iin ewe K ad Mc en B Gnrw e r e eete r e e ee pno eoa o b en B n ac ny C; o e p cs v h i r r tt t l / r i r or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 0
sb coay f r on ro e poe . e, g D. Sp B ea8cne nta“r e u e f n o e cu e f r rcs See. e’ up r ft (ocd gh p cs jt f/ t - f s . , fs . i i t i w en f e ng i e”b we Mc en B Gad K) D. Sp Rp B e a 7 e o r l eoa d e en ac ny C n B e’ up e y r f t r t ey tt t l / ; fs . l i (d iigh “ e ws o c abc ado h eoa o b we K ad Mc en B G ; a mt ta t r a n a u ak nfr ng iin e en B n ac ny C ”
tn t h e tl t tt t l / )
[ e’ Rsost Cu’ Lt Rqe o Nv me 2 21 a2 akold nta“ e D. ] epneo ors ee eus f oe b 2 03t (cn w g gh t fs t tr t r , ei t h p c ws of e ng i e b we Mc en B G n K ” LoyAia tt ¶ 22 r e a n r l eoa d e en ac ny C ad B ; ob f dv a¶ 2-3 i t e y tt t l / ) f i (ts ntap csw e u e t ng iin ewe Mc en B G n g mna e b aeigh r e e sb c o eoa o b en ac ny C ad a e s m y tt ti r jt tt t l / r t s l cn a o i D m ia Rpbc B g i adPci R m P’ B e a 5 cn aigte o rc r n o i cn eu i u a a n a f i ) ls r ft (o rs n “ t ts n l, l r, ic ;. i t t h o e adcu eo e adng iin”b we Mc en B Gadt cn a o i te f r n on rf r n eoa os e en ac ny C n i o rc r n h fs t fs tt t l / s t ts D m ia Rpbc B g i adh Pci R mw h Mc en B G p cc v-- s K) o i cn eu i u a a nte a f i i ac ny C ’ r t e i a i B n l, l r, ic t l / s ai s v ;
i a2 (a e i a2 (a e i a3 (a e P’ Rp B ea2a eigh K’ p cs d t 1s m ;d t 8s m ;d t 2s m ; ls e y r ft (s r nta B r e . ) . ) . ) . l i st t si “ e n d e m e a a eu o a m ln h eoa o b we te ue ad h sl i a w e o e r i d s rs t f r ’ eg ng iin e en h by n te ee n r t t n l s t tt t r lr mne nr a y odc d n ht d” i a3s m ;da 34ag n ta K p csw e an o ml cnu e i ter e ; d t (a e i t - ( u g h B r e e r l t a ) . ) . ri t i r n “o n r y eoa d n are uo ad ce e b b hh by adh sl ” i a o v u al ng i e ad g d pn n acp d y o te ue nte ee ) d t t l ti tt e , t t r lr; . 7a eigh,nh cs s e d n “ s tr m nr ’ln h g e e b wete ue (s r ntait s ae a si o r u fo a a m eg ar mn e enh by st t i , l d t el s t e tt r ad h sl , ad h K ws of e o acp or e tee m o a o e o cu eo e n te ee ” n ta B a n r t “ce r e c ht s f n f r r on rf r lr t te t jt r f t f .. ot] nae n c vis h r lcte rsu s f h m k p c” i a 9st g h . [r o eggi ai t ta e e h p sr ote a e l e ;d t ( a n ta t ie t f t e e rta ) . ti t “M Loy e dd K’ p cs n i o nw huay eoa osw hK p sne” n r ob dc e [ B ] r e o h w i o n ng iin i B e on, ad . i s i s t t tt t r l ta K’ p csw e e“i n ng iintl ) da1 ( g nta “] a a m ln h h B r e e s w h o eoa o aa” i t 0a u gh,[ n nr ’ eg t si r t t tt l; . ri t i s t t nain w p t sec aigni o h o nn rsad ea, eoa [t aiet n r sc o t o ai , ah c ni h r e wi e t n bh fng i e or v aa a t , re t s r te l tt ] r are uo p c ” u“]a d n hpe h e ; da 1 ( a n i e a ata K p cs g d pn r e b [ h i o apn e ” i t 7st g n r l , h B r e e i, t t t d t r) . ti , t i t i “ e n s b a are e b wete ueadhsl adi n rs tr mr ’ln h w e o e y n g mn e enh by nteee n d o eu fo a m eg r tt e t t r lr d t l s t ng iin b wete uead ee ) P’ Sp B ea4a eigh “ Bi n mk eoa os e enh by n sl ” ls up r ft (s r nta K d o ae tt t r lr; . . i st t d t i o nrig e s n o t o n e s n we e o ce or e ” Mc en B Gre ) t w p c dci sr s w dci s h h t acp re c ac ny C od s s i n io i io tr t jt l / r; i a5ag nta“r e b we K ad Mc en”w eev yi e n yr mr eta d t ( u gh p cs e en B n ac ny e s e df e lfo p csh . ri t i t l r t r fr t i t Mc en p d o“n l e sp i s ;P’ Sp Rp B e a 4 e pa z g h “ e ac ny a t ur a d upe ” ls up e y r f t ( mhsi ta t l i et lr ) . . l i in t h gv n e akoldeta nh cs‘ er e w e o re ng i e b wete ue oe mn cn w gsh it s ae h p cs e n f l eoa d e enh by r t e t i t i r t e y tt t r ad e e ” n sl ’ .
lr )
Mc en p n teakf eoa os ewe K ad Mc en B Gadhasne ac ny a t hlc ong iin b en B n ac ny C, nte bec l is tt t l / oay xhne o o e ad on ro e, s a n g v ec aa s h Gv n e . Te f n ecags f f r n cu e f r a d m n e dne g n te oe mn h fs t- f s i i it r t Gv n e cu e ta h p csh Mc en B G a t o e(n l e) o rc r w e oe mn on r h ter eta ac ny C p dot rur a dcn a o e r t ts t i t l / i h et t ts r n awy sb ct ng iin n ig h Mc en B Gocs nl “ ctd p cs o o l as u e o eoa o o n ta ac ny C ca oa y dt e” r et t jt tt , t t l / i l ia i cn a o o eta K.Se e. D. B e a 5st g h “ ]t ms Mc en B G o rc r t r hn B e, g e’ r ft ( a n ta [ ti e ac ny C t ts h . , fs i ti t a , l / wu tl XClte D m ia g mn a e b cn a o tep c i ws wl g opy o de - e [ l l l h o i cn a e s m y o rc r h r et a ii t a n r t s l t t] i ln , uulfresn i m ” nta Mc en B Gwu “o e msei mnfc r si. sa yosaoat s adh ac ny C o ds mi etl s au t e [ e l le , t l / l t lt a u r ., cn a o ]watwu pyoaie pou ” i a1(a e D. Rp B ea7cig o rc r h i o d afr g nrdc ) d t 6s m ; e’ e y r ft (t t ts t l v t; . ) fs l i in LoyDpsint 1 ad seig h Mc en B G i n ng i e r e w h te ob eot a 15 n a r n ta ac ny C d o eoa p cs i o r io , st t l / d t tt i t h g mna e b cn a o ) se lo e’ B e a 2 (seig h “ i n uuu fr a e s m y o rc r; e a D. r ft 0 a r n ta i s o nsa o a r t s l t ts s fs i st tt t l by t dt e p ct a eefr aiu r e s ;f D. Sp Rp B ea7ag n ue oi a a r eo sl o p t l i m” c e’ up e y r ft ( u g r ct i lr rc a t ) . fs . l i ri, i e a ata –a huh“ e wsn a u bc ad o hng iinb we K ad n r l, h t i t l og t r a o c a ak n fr eoa o e en B n t he tl t tt t Mc en B G – ng iin a n a pcirq r mn oI ep t eN e ” ac ny C ” “eoa osr o se f eu e e f n rri o 2.
l / tt e t ic i t t ev t )
or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 1
Cs mi e hs a ind h apcin f h c c m acs f h s ee rq rs u o st l a cu oe ta p ia o otei u s ne ote a ts eu e t sf t t l t r t l t i
cn d a o o“ h h te i s fine dne o s bstel gdi u s ne ote os e t n f we e h es ui e v ec t e a ihh aee c c m acs fh i ri tr r fc t i tl l r t
s e e Wa Eey M me oteT d C m u t So dKo Ao : D e m ig h a. e h v l ”S t r e b f h r e o mn y hu n w bu e r i n te r a i l t t n
Acp bi o T nain V u fr R a dP t T nain (.. Dp o H m ad ce a l y f r sc o a e o et a y r sc os US e’ f o e n t it a t l le r a t t l
Scr yAr 20)“ u o sG dne nAcp bi o T nainV ui R a d a y eut pl 07( Cs m u ac o ce a l y f r sc o a en et P t i i t i t it a t l le r
T nain” a 9 apne t P’ Sp Rp B e ( mhs add sea o d a 1 r sc os t (pedd o ls up e y r f e pa s de) e l i. t 0 a t ) . . l i) i ; s
( mhsigeu e e o“toog ep n infh c c m acs u on nte a, e pa z rq r mn f a hruh x aa ootei u s nesr ud gh s e in i t l t r t r i l”
ic d gspoig v ec”( mhs add i (x a igh c c m acsfa ci s n u n “upr n e dne e pa s de) d epi nta i u s ne os el m li t i ) i ;. ln tr t l a
a r e e we a ein ofc“ e. n spo e b e dne. S ma y Cs m hs r e c d hn s r os fa a .. o upr d y v ec” i i r , u o s a e jt st t r t t i ) ll t
e pa zdh –we ,s e , p t sesorvta rnain a es ce a e eas mhs eta h ea h ea a yekt poeh t sc o v uiacp b bcue i t r r r ta t l tl
I sh wv , n su dh –we e o n Mc en B G eoa d r e w h s t , o ee ud p eta h h r o ac ny C ng i e p cs i i i r i t t tr t l / tt i tt g mna e b cn a o o eta K – Mc en B G o e cn a o w ere o a e s m y o rc r t r hn B ac ny C ’ t r o rc r e f t r t s l t ts h l / s h t ts r e r e od sr mh c may ffr x m e h p c “ ctd b Mc en B Gws o e c re fo te o pn i o ea p, e r e dt e” y ac ny C ato jt r ,, lt i ia l / l wSee. D . B ea5st gh,we Mc en B G og t “ ct” p ct o. e, g e’ r ft ( a nta hn ac ny C suh o dt e a r e o . , fs i ti t l / t ia i teD m ia g mna e b cn a o XCl“ - e wu dc e. we et poue h o i cn a e s m y o rc r - e, XCl o d e d.. h h o rdc n r t s l t t l l l i tr te od ate i a d r e ; da 2 (seig h “ wh h [ sl aret a i a d h gost h dt e p c” i t 0 a r n ta [ ]e e a ee g s o dt e ct i ) . st t t r ] lr e ct p c o g e u [ s es fnin fwe ei bivs h icn rdcte rdcate r e r i s p a a i a uc o o h h t eeeta t a poue h pou t h i v ]l t tr l t t [ ctd p c adtl xe t mk s m pot ;P’ Sp B e a 5 n ig h “ hn dt e] r e n slepc o ae o e rf” ls up r ft (o n ta we ia i i t i) . . i t t Mc en md o e t ur a d ee,te ee dc e we e “ acp or e te ac ny ae f r o n l e sl s h sl s e dd h h t ce r e c h l fs et l r ” lr i tr o t jt o e ) Ii s ma y n su d h – n kte te cn a o –K hd o o et tr f r. tsi i r ud p e ta u ie h o r o rc r f” ll i t t l h t t s B a n p w o un
r
d w ay refo Mc en B G Q ttte o r y K wseu et f fllod s o n n od r m ac ny C. ueoh cn a , B arq rdo ui a re r l / i tr i ll l r fo Mc en B G n t d s a h p c s b M LoySe D. ]Rsost Cu’ r m ac ny C ad o o ot e r e e y r ob e [ e’ epneo ors l / t i t . . fs t Lt Rqe o Nv me 2 21 (cn w d nta“ eeod v ec..n c eta ee eus f oe b 2 03akol g gh t rcr e dne.id a sh tr t r , ei t h i it t K ws o rei e oet o nr eroeueordc m cad eth p cse f d B a n f e h t s i w p c o r st poue e hn s a er e pci ”
t e t r ts i t f r i t i ie b Mc en B G P’ Sp B ea4st gh K cu n “ ae.i o n e s n y ac ny C ) ls up r ft ( a nta B o d o mk.. s w dci s l / ;. . i ti t l t t io we et acpor e ” Mc en B G od s Lt t Cu fo Cus frPi i h h o ce re c ac ny C ’ re ) ee o or r m one o l nf tr t jt l / s r; t r t l a tf ( o 2 21) st g h “ B wso ia d odiet Mc en B G l m cad e Nv 6 03( a n ta K a b g e t e v o ac ny C a e hn s . , ti t l t l r l / l r i od e atep c se f db Mc en B Gad K wsn f e o eue opoue re d t h r e pci y ac ny C n B a o r t r s t rdc r i ie l / t e f m cad e o Mc en B Gt h p c se f d y Mc en B G. TeGv n e e hn s fr ac ny C ate r e pci b ac ny C ” h oe mn r i l / i ie l / ) r t nv d el ad se we e t sp t u rapc o ter a os pb we K ad ee i c y dr ss h h h ai l se f h et nh e en B n r rt e t r i rc a t li i t Mc en B Gwsi tewrsoI ep tieN e2“ostn w h h nr a p c g ac ny C a n h od f n rr a v o , cn s t i te o m ri l / , t et t ie t l in p ccs ote a mna e b ids y r t e” f h g e s m y nur ai r t s l t.
or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 2
p csw e eld n codnew h o m ids y rig rccs “v ectate . r e e st i acrac i nr a nur p c p t e – e dne h h. . i r te t l t i n ai i t
p c ws eld n codne w h . ids yp ccs i rq rd Se d a 89 O te r e a st i acrac i . . nur r t e”s eu e e i. t - i te t t ai i . . nh
e s n rcr tee dne sn sf c n ysb a i t a o araoa ep sn o xt g eod h v ec i o ui e l us na o l w esnb e o t ii , i t fi t t tl l l r
ud s n aa aportlv o d a te mne i w c M Loy e K’ p cs Nr net dt n prp a ee f ei h anr n h h r ob s B r e o ra ie l tl i . t si .
ite v ec sf c n y us naad ei d o e m c masn f h mnei w c s h e dne ui e l sb a i n d ae t p i o p io ote an n h h i fi t t tl tl rt r r i
K’ p csw ee oh nr ap c grccsfh g mna e b ids y Te v ec B r e e s tte o m ri p t e o e a e s m ynur h e dne si r t l i n ai t r ts l t. i
o K’ p cssi p isf c nt spo s m ay ug e . n B r ei s m y nui e o upr u m jd mn si l fi t t r t
TeGv n e ’ cs otetes e fh euin “ e o m p c g rccs f h oe mns ae nh o ri ote qa o –t nr a ri p t e o r t h d t h l i n ai
te g mna e b ] nur” i ee waeta teGv n e ’ cs o te mnei h [a e s m yids y –s vn ek hn h oe mns ae n h an n r t s l t r r t r
w c K’ p csw e e 3 TeGv n e p n t r a v yil e dne oc n gh h h B r e e s. 8 h oe mn o t oet e lt v ec cne i te i si r t r t i s li l te i rn
p c g rccs f nt steta K. Adh qa u oe dnes y omash o y ri p t e oe ie o rhn B nte un m f v eci b n ente n i n ai ti h t i l
so c m g n h Gv n e ’ cs Te v ec tate Gv n e ce a osoe y hr o i i te oe mns ae h e dne h h oe mn i s l i v l t n r t . i t r tt s r
gn a Mri pr n ynn o h e dnei d yh Gv n e se f a y drsete ee l o mo a l oef e v ec ce bte oe mn pci l ad ssh r. e t t, t i t r t i cl e
g mna e b ids y Msct a y h Gv n e flt d mnr eh M Loy a e s m ynur r t s l t . o ri l , e oe mn aso e os a ta r ob’
t icl t r ti tt t . s
38 N we ii b e deteGv n e d c t y n sc nl o l eh e dne o h en s r f osh oe mn i r e ad uc c y ui te v ec r t is r t s el i t tn i w cicn ns ost e poffh nr ap c grccsfh g mna e b ids y h h o edcni tsroo e o m ri p t e o e a e s m ynur i t t tu t l i n ai t r ts l t. A aeu,h cu ws o et c mteGv n e ’ pp sn nfo tie iy oi e s rs t e or afr do o bh oe mns ae i a e r odnf fr s f lt t c r t r ft t tl ay uhp e i e dne T a o e h lse e e , h cu hd oud tk ai i r n sc o na v ec o s m wa e r x n te or a t ne ae s ma t tl i . t s tt t r l ee ie o dnf ay v ectateGv n e m haga y os et b e dne f x c t ie iy n e dne h h oe mn i t rub cn d o e v ec o rs t i t r t g l ir i K’ p c g rccsIte u r tte x n h te ais o iut fcs nh “o m B ri p t e nhf u ,oh e e ta h p t cn neo ou ote nr a s i n ai . te tt t re t l ids y rig rccsts te wu b wl d sdotu u te p snt ns at nur p c p t e”e,hy o d e e av et s c r h r r e a os o so t i n ai t l l i r t e i e ti c a ydnf ad drs M Loy p c g rccsi a i K, nt sp alie iy l r ie iy n ad s r ob’ ri p t e v-- s Bado ea t ydnf el t e . s i n ai s v re t ad drste o m p c g rccs f h g mna e b ids y adi adint n ad s h nr a ri p t e ote a e s m y nur – n n d t , o e l i n ai r t s l t , io aa z ad x a te x n ow ctoe w p ae(ri efo ) n ao e Fr e t n ye n epi h e e t h hhst o a ll o df r m oe n h. u h ,o l ln tt i rl fr tr tr te x n h e h o b h fh p t slc t aa mvfr u m yug e ,h p t s h e e ta i e r o ote ai e t o g n oe os m a jd mn te ai tt ttr t re e s i r t re so dg ec eu cn d a o t tese f a oa o o tebreso pouinad hu i a f os e t n o h pci l cin f h udn f rdc o n l v r l i ri ic l t t p sa o o sc m in Se eeaye. 1 Mo ’ Fd aP cc § 6 05 4 p 5- e us n n uh o os e gnr l, g 1 or s ee l r t e 5 4-6 2 p 6 r i t . l ., e r ai . ., . 115-1 (n y n “ udn o Pouin n P sa o”t u m y ug e s g. 0-619aa z g Bres f rdc o ad e us n as m a jd mn t e li t r i r t a)
or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 3
p ccsn eig r efrK p ae h p c g rccs fh g mna e b ids y s r t ei st p cs o B a ll e ri p t e ote a e s m ynur a ai tn i rl t i n ai r t s l t
awo.
h e9 l3
A n e aoeteGv n e ’ cn ate s s oK’ p c gs h M Loy e s o d bv h oe mns e r hs at B ri ita r ob s t , r t tl i s in t . t
39 Av iu p n ii b e,h Gv n e ge byn p c grccsnh g mn t a os o t n sr f te oe mn os eodri p t eite a e r is t is r t i n ai r t a e b ids y w cite pciids ytsu h eC maeD. Rp B ea1 s m y nur h hsh se f nur ai e e. o pr e’ e y r ft 0 s l t, i ic t s r fs l i ( f r g or e s “ tenr a mne oa a mna e b r) e pa s de)i a r ei tp cs e i h‘o m ’an ern i tn l rfr gr e s m e”( mhs add d t t s l i ; .
1 ( f r g o nr a p c g rccs ote a mnids y) e pa s de) I s m 2r ei t “o m ri p t efr h gr e nu r”( mhs add n o e ern l i n ai t t i . is ne fr x m e h Gv n e a uet p c g rccsntesc r oteah n n acs oea p, e oe mn l dso ri p t ei o r e o fhfs o t , lt r tl i n ai h ts i ap e bs e , uh s h mnei w c Mc en B G ei p cs os et i o n pa l u ns sc ate an n h h ac ny C s t r efr a s ot w r i s r i l / ts i l s cs m s i. h p cso Mc en B G s e o m cad eoei rsc a Sa ad u o e –., er efr ac ny C ’ a sf e hn str ae uhs e s n t r et i l / sl r i tl s r J Pne Se e. D . B e a 56 st g h “ C ’ cs m si.r ae ] wu Ceny e,. , e’ r f t - ( a n ta B G u o e [e ei r o d . g fs i ti t s t r ., tl s l s mi etlB Gwap cte w ewl go a” i a1 ( a nta“ C cs m s o e mse C h r ehy e ii t py ; d t 6st gh B G u o e t l ti r ln ) . ti t t r s mi e dt e te r ete w ewl g o a” o e ms i a d h p cs hy e ii t py.
t ct i r ln )
A o e p n, h Gv n e mks we n rp snt n ao p c g rccs t t r o t te oe mn ae s ep g er e a os bu ri p t e h is r t i e ti t i n ai w c a n se f t ay nur aa – n w c a n spo e b ca os o eod h h r o pci o n ids ytl ad h h r o upr d yit nt rcr i e t ic t l i e t t ti e dnet bo e,. ,D . B e a 2 (seig n ra ata“ i n uuu fr v ec o o .Se e. e’ r ft 0 a r n i e l , h i s o nsa o a i , t g fs i st , t i tt t l by t dt e p ct a eefr aiu rt m ” n ta“ wh h te ee aret a ue o i a a r e o sl o p t l i s ad h [ ]e e h sl g s o r ct i lr rc a e , t tr lr e dt e p c..s fnin fwe eibivsh icnrdcte rdca h[ ctd i a d r e.i a uc o o h h t eeeta t a poueh pou t e dt e] ct i t tr l t t t ia p c adtl xe t mk s m pot st gh “ ] c p cs o gosh hv n be r e n slepc o ae o e rf” ti ta [i e r efr odta ae o en i i t i; a n t s n i t t poue a s bsd pn nc a d xessii awy ps b tate xesswl e rdcd r e ae uo a i p e epne tsl as o i e h h epne i b et ti t , sl t l h h ad h epc dpot wln m e az” ci ig h “un azdpot i n i e n te xe e rf i o a rl e l m ta []r l e rf” s o gr t i l t t ii ; a n t ei i t “nsa r m bs e s np n;ru gh “p o c os a b wog n n w u nse uuu fo a u ns t do t ag nta [] j t ncn e rn ad e bs e s l i s a i” i t r ei i s myhv mr ‘r w gp n ta a i p e ” n ta “rfs r n ga n e ee i a ae o goi a s hn nc a d ad h pot a o u a ed vn n e n i’ ti t , t i e t rt , t nain b we ur a d ais ;D. Rp B ea91 (seigh “no u ns r sc os e en n l e p t ” e’ e y r ft -0a r nta [] bs e , a t t et re ) fs l i st t i s n ee oeeigo n l e cs m s s urn et e n pot adh “i n uuu o vn nsl t ur a d u o e, gaa edo a arf” nta i s o nsa t ln et t ri t r i tt t l frn wc ma e n t e napot–o ee t fla oe e – n h fsf wya o o e o pn s o o a i t r rfi r vn o a l g h i teit e e s f i t tr r r
e s ne ; da1(seigh “ ]ee sakfrfa l ys oncsal a osqec xt c” i t 0a r nta [ sl ’lc opotbi i n ee r y cneune ie ) . st t a lr i it t si o p cs e g eto o, r f o u o b we by ad ee” uis a “ a js b a f r e b n s o l wo o c ls n e en ue n sl, b n ed my u e i i t l i t r lr t t t cneune f nnc a da o, uh sao cs tatr o t b h h tatoeh osqec o ua i p e fc r sc albr o sh un u o ei e hnhsta ti t ts t t t gr t w e n ue i tepo c dbde uo w c tep cs w ebsd ;i a 1 n (t g e ic dd n h r e e ug pn h h h r e e ae” d t 0 . ci r l jt t i i r ) . 4 in ai enH v dBs e Shopbcin otelnepoot nh “ ea u r e o rc i a a u ns co u ia o frh b k rpsi ta t flr a fr tl rr i s l l t a t io t h i e t n w u ns e i 3-0 e e , w h on cin oc n ghstt soc ma eite e bs e [s s 04 p cn” i nid a o cne i tetii fr o pn snh i s ] r t t it rn asc i se f ids ytsu h e pci nur ai e e )
ic t s r.
A sc e dnewu apat bi e vn Nte p t hsrudh tee vn l uh v ec o d pe o er l a . e h a y a ageta hr ea l i l r re t i r r t l t p c g rccs r o eta toe fK ad h g mna e b ids y fw c K ws ri p t e a t r hn hs o B n te a e s m y nur o h h B a i n ai e h r t s l t i a a. pt r or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 4
p cs ae o “ei d bde “ apo c dh epr r ic m ad xess n aaee r e bsd n d ae” ug st tr e ete xo e sno e n epneadt lv i tl t h jt t’ l
ta ws xe e t ra apotoc te xo e st tu cs w e u y mrzd Se h a epc d o ep rf ne h epr r s r p o s e f l a oie ” e t t i t ’ a- t r l t .
D. B ea6 D. Rp B ea23 A d cse aoeh wv,h Gv n e hs o e’ r ft; e’ e y r ft - s i u d bv o ee te oe mn a n fs i fs l i . s s , r r t t
adcd ui e e dneo upradls o iteeui d a temnei w c M due sf c n v ect spo n f h u nhrq se ei h an n h h r fi t i t e t it tl r i .
Loy e vdK’ p csr mh anabde. Mroe eei h Gv n e hd pld ob d ie B r efo te nu ug s o v, vn te oe mn a see r si l t e r f r t l
o i d a h w M Loy sd ug s o e p csteGv n e p n t n e dne o u n ei o r ob ue bde t s r e h oe mn o t o o v ect t tl . t ti , r t is i
d mnr eh te o m p c g rccs fh g mna e b ids yr cn s n w h e os a ta h nr a ri p t e ote a e s m ynur a ost t i tt t l i n ai r t s l t e ie t
wa M Loyi h e h r ob d e. t . d r
Ii rp b e teGv n e de a e ta M Loyei eta“o m p c g n se y r f h oe mn os s r h r obtsf dh nr a ri t l i, r t st t . ti t l in
p ccs ote a mn nuriv vte rp a o ad os e t n f ug sh po c r t efrh g e ids yno eh p a t n n cn d a o o bde ta r e ai r t t l e ri i ri t t jt
cs ad u ufr g e t m p id w h o e mu o pot ut n ne h c mays o s n o p o a i ni e e o i s m a on f rf b li octe o pn i t tt v r , t t i i
am u fci . D . Rp B ea1 Tte a ef cteGv n e e e h el m a r al y e’ e y r ft 2 oh s m e e,h oe mn l we ci s t e it ” fs l i . ft r ts r a
ta M Loyei etats o m idsyrcct s p cs bsd pn ei d ug s h r obtsf dh i nr a nurp t eoe r e“ae uo d ae bde t . ti ti l t ai ti tl t
. .w h h epct n f pot ne a al y m u [ byn tet tu pae D . . i te xe a o o a rf oc [ fci ] a r s eod h s r p hs ” e’
t ti i it t e] a- . fs
Sp Rp B ea7I seigh wv,h teGv n e po e n ca osohrcr up e y r ft.t tl , o ee ta h oe mn rf r oit ntteeod . l i i ln r t r t f s ti
t spo toe sein S u n o b h M Loy aia t n h dpsinee sh o upr hs a r os c t y f o r ob’ f dv adi eot rva ta t st . ri t . sf i s io l t
h nv md ay uht e e s 0 I ay vn ts mnt sc bodf c–e r n fr e ee ae n sc st mn. n n ee ,ei oyo uh ra e e r eig o r a t4 t t f t fr ,
40 Te n ee aga y upr n e dne h i ce i teGv n e ’ b e i a h o y vn rub spoig v ecta si d n h oe mns r f s l l t i t t r t is r e ne o M Loy ts mn ta “rigb a al y uha XClte D m ia e r c t r ob’ ei oy h p c fe . s t t i n y fci sc s - e [ it l h o i cn
n
g mna e b cn a o i a p fc wr ’wu b bsd pn bde h cn d sh a e s m y o rc r n ‘e e o d o d e ae uo a ug ta os e te r t s l t t] r t l l t t ir fc r’ p e i o p adepne ( g te uprs f nee fr h epc do p , a oy o na u u n xesse. h spo t f edd ote xe e u u t s t tl t t ., t a t tt oeha epne e cit d e lbre.”Se e’ B ea5cig n ca c rig v ed xess l t c y i c ao t) e D. r ft (t ad h a e z r , e ri , r t , c. fs i in r ti n Loy Dpsina 143) H wv,p t u r we ra i cn x tea u ce ob eot t 3-5 io . o ee ai l l hn ed n o e , h c a i d r rc a y tt tl t ts mn de n ee po st ds ie rig rccs n h g mna e b ids y s ei oy os o vn rf s o ec b p c p t ei te a e s m y nur a t t e r i n ai r t s l t a wo. Mroe te ei oys mc tobs ad ak g n pcit t s v ate h e o v , h ts mn i uh o a c n lc n i se fi o e e s h l e r t i i icy r or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 5
ea p, o a r i ot “o e mu o pot a wl s o h (nunf dt m nee x m e “ pot r o s m a on f rf, s e at te uqa i e)i e edd lt f” t i” l ti
t a o aln o eo e aa r fci ” wu b mctoi psc nlc ni d a ol w p t bc m “m ue al y – o d e uho s m ii adak gn ei l at t it l lt i tl
t cni tteeui pof f o m p c g rccs n hids y o ost e hrq se ro o nr a ri p t ei te nur tu it l i n ai t.
A sc js ate Gv n e hs ae t c m l te v ec nee t poe y s uh u s h oe mn a fld o o pe h e dne edd o rp l , t r t i i i r
sb a i e s ot nh M Loye K’ p cs ae o bde tapo c d o em g us na i psi ta r ob s B r e bsd n ug sh r e e s m a i t tt t i o t . t si t t jt rn
o pot h Gv n e hsi i r fldoliteeui e dneo s bstasc f rf, e oe mn as ma yaet ec hrq se v ect e a ihh uh it r t ll i it it i tl t
a rcdri cn s n w h o m p c g rccs n h g mna e b ids y poeu s ost t i nr a ri p t ei te a e s m y nur e ie t l i n ai r t s l t.
TeGv n e ce s m o e e dne h r a s o h p c g rccs f nt s h oe mn i s o e t r v ecta et t te ri p t e o e ie r tt h i t le i n ai ti
o eta K. B tae dneloas o a y h dy t rhn B u h v ec a flt c r te a h t t i s i r .
Frea p, nsv a p cs h Gv n e r e t M Loy ts mn ta o x m ei ee l l e te oe mn e r o r ob’ ei oy h l r a r t fs . s t t
“v yn [e h s ee wre w h hs“se e te ‘o p s nada o e m u ee oe h a ] v okd i ” a a s d h r cs e t d l wd i t r ] [ r t ss i t r a r l ne
[ AM’ n[oea aa s ote aiu rrdc o o e pw h t g p c ” e D. S ] addn n n y s nh p t l pou t c m u i aa e r e Se e’
, ] li rc a t t r t i. fs
B e a 4 cigadqo n Loy Dpsina 121) sea o e’ Rp B e a 1 r f t (t i i n n u ig ob eot t 1-4 e l D. e y r f t 1 t io ; s fs l i
(seigh “M Loyei eta eeyoyh hs v wre w h a bsdh rr e a r nta r obtsf dh ‘v bd’ e aee okd i hs aete p cs st t . ti t r r t i i
rq rd v ec oids y rcc Is a teei oysmrite e oa r m fr eu e e dne fnur p t e n ed hts mni o nh v n f p e oa i i t ai . t , t e i i r lye o –a i rdc o t s m v ye mn r p c gp n p ss fr i s m wa ap sn n n ouin o o e e l e ay ri r c l , e o h n o e h r t t r e t in iie t t t as a ad ho t at m (s e fre b M Loy ueoteqaf r i [ p fc brc n teri l e s a r no d y r ob’ s f h ui e “ a e e t t ec r i c . s li n ] r t wr ” Fr e n w h ad g h Gv n e ’ r e ne o a al y sc a XCl a o d. u h , o i s n n te oe mns e r c t “ fci uh s - e, l) t r t tt i r t fe it l” rv w f ht nc prva tatei dei oy e r d pcia y ad n ) oXCl e e oter s i ee s h h ce ts mn r e e se f l (n o yt - e. i a rt l t t t fr i cl l l Se ob Dpsint 3 (of m gh Loyst k g bu XCli p t u r Ad e Loy eot a13cnr i ta obi “l n ao - e”n ai l ) n io i n t ai t l rc a.
ee at XCl M Loy ad l cneetah hs oi c p sn kolde fh vn so - e, r ob cn d ocddh e a n d e, e oa n w g ota l . iy t rt r l e t c may p c g rccs Se da 14st g h XCl nv t d h m h w hys o pn’ ri p t e e i t 1 ( a n ta - e “ee o [ ] o te [e s i n ai . . ti t l rl i t p cs ) re” i ].
S nia l ite ore fi dpsin h Gv n e suh o rs M Loy s i i cn y nh cu o h eot , e oe mn og t p s r ob a g f t, s s io t r t t e .
t we etep c gp ccs h h ds ie w e tnad n h ids y M Loy o h h h ri r t e ta e ec bd e s d i te nur tr i n ai t r r a r t . r ob .
d mr d “ ma h wwu I n w”Se ob Dpsint 7 e u e I en o o d ko ? e Loy eot a14 r: , l io .
or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 6
o a i p e cs, cigLoyDpsint 1) 1 Oc aa , o ee sc ts mn i n nc a d o s i n ob eot a 14 4 ne g nh wv, uhei oys ti t t” t io . i r t
mc to ee l o ev a pof f o m p c g rccs n h g mna e b ids y uh o gn at s e s ro o nr a ri p t ei te a e s m y nur r r l i n ai r t s l t.
I adin hts mn il me o i fct “v yn [.Loy] a ee wre w h n d t , eei oysi i d nt ae o ee oeM ob hs v okd i .
io t t t s r r r t”
Teei oyhs os oee pro t b a os e dt st n oc n grigrccs hts mntu de n vn upr o e cn d e ae a o cne i p c p t e t t t i r t ti r n i n ai
i teg mna e b ids y s wo. Fr e teei oy e rt st g “ re n h a e s m y nur a a h e2 u h , hts mn r e o ei at g r t s l t l4 tr t fs tn a t
p c”oecid iu “aiu rrdc”B n we deteGv n e epi h wh r efr ahn v a p t l pou. u o h e osh oe mn x a o ta i i d l rc a t t r r t ln t
41 “tnad A o e M u ”(S ” i au to mau mn ue i idsi S d a r l wd i t “ AM s n f esr e sd n nurl l ne ) i e t ta eg e igo unfteaoe o ee ei c m e n a pcits Gn a y pa n n ne nt qa iyhlbrf r x tdn o pt g se f ak ee l sek g i r t ft r li ic . rl i, ten me o s nad l wd m u ss h a on ot m taitks n v ae wre h u b ft d a o e i t ite mu fi e h t ae a ae g ok , r a r l ne t t r r epn n ae g e o ad s g v ae kl t c m e a aiu r p a o (r e , o xed g v ae f r n u n ae g s l, o o pt p t l oe t n o h efr i r ft i r is l e rc a ri r ea p,ose b s m p t u r a mn.Se eeay ob Dpsint 4-0 Loy x m e a m e o e ai l g e ) e gnr l Loy eot a195 ob lt s l rc a r t l io ;
Aia t 3 M he A mrn AHnbo o Mng mn Tcn us 2 (d d20) f dv ¶ 1 i a r s og f i ; c l t , adok f aae e eh qe 75 3 e 01 t i . .
42 Mr gn a y tsafo c ata M Loys o p e ad ui ettsft o ee l , if r ml rh r obi c me n n qaf doeiyo e rl i r e t . tt li t nr a p c gp ccs n h g mn a e b ids y A n e aoe h p snl o m ri r t e i te a e s m y nur l i n ai r t s l t . s o d bv e e oa y t , r l
d ci e te ee ay n w de Se.0spa i l md h ncs r kol g e n , ur. sa s e . 4
A aersnt e f Mc en B G w ci it s o e , by ) M Loys y s rp e a v o ac ny C ( h hs nh cn x a ue, r obi b e ti l / i , i tt r .
n mas ee al p vtte ei oh w n p t u r a mna e b f m( e sl s o en ncs r yr yoh d asf o ay ai l g e s m y r si. ee )
si i tl rc a r t s l i ., l r s te p cs mclste o m p c grccsfh g mna e b ids ys wo. e h rr e uhe h nr a ri p t e o e a e s m ynur aa h e t i i , s l i n ai t r t s l t l See. LoyDpsint 1(cn w d ntahlcs n p sn, r-ad n w de e, g ob eot a14akol g gh eakay e oafs hn kol g ., io ei t r l it e a t h w XCl– h D m ia g mn a e b cn a o – ei p cs Mroe s o o - e te o i cn a e s m y o rc r s t r e. o v , l n r t s l t t ts i ) e r acr nt h dpsin M Loy a “n wretrelcsn h]i,ic d g n cod goi eot , r ob hs o y okdh p ei [ sl e n u n oe i s io . l e a i f” l i f m r roi e p y e a B Gad s rdcso adhf mwe h ws m oe a i p ot h m o mn t C (ni p ee r ntei r i s l t t e s) r h e e a e p ydt r l
tei e f i dpsin Se da 18 LoyAia t ¶ - Te i n id a o i te ht m o h eot . e i t 3 ob f dv ¶ 14 h es o n cin n h s io . ; f i . r it rcr tae h M Loy fse p y o h e p y atei eo h dpsinw e eod h i e r ob’ it m oe r i m oe t ht m f i eot ttr . sr l r s l r s io e r g mna e b c ma e Ide te v ec sge sh te w e o See. Loy a e s m y o pn s ned h e dne ugs ta hy e n . e, g ob r t s l i. , i t t r t ., Dpsint 3 ( a n ta“]e o pn ta[M Loy wsw h o[ sfs 2 ya eot a 16st g h [ h c may h io ti tt t r ob] a i fr h]it 1 e s . t i r r ra ymd eey igh me e” i a1 2(ec b gh bs e e o Loy e p y s el ae v t nte s vs ;d t 6 1ds i nte u ns sf ob’ m oe ) l rh l ) . , ri i s s l r; LoyAia t ¶ , (a e B ee a u igaged ta b hw e a mna e b ob f dv ¶ 2 4s m. u vn s m f i ) t s n runo h o e g e s m y t t r r t s l
c ma e ad su igh M Loy a kolde fh r rig rccs h kolde o pn s n a m ta r ob hd n w g ote p c p t e ta n w g i, s n t . e i i n ai , t e wu e h s nia l p -a o ps d eh d e ote nistsu h eadhs o d o di e i i cn y r d e r o-a te a s fh e r a se e, ntu cu l t r gf t e t t t t te i r l h d b de e cn mo nos Se d¶ 134id a n ta Loywre fr ifs a l e e md o e pr eu e i ¶, - ( i t g h ob okd o h it ry t a . . n ci t sr e p y fo 19-91adh h ps B G m o mnbgnn 07 Ee mrtte m oe r m 9019 nta i o- C e p y e eai 20) vn o oh l r , t s t l t . e p n ii du f tae dne oc n g h p c g rccs f n t o a mna e b o t ts ob u h v ec cne i te ri p t e o o y w g e s m y i, tl t i rn i n ai l r t s l c ma e cu sf ct poe nur-ie rcc o pn s o d uie o rvids y w p t e i l f t d ai .
or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 7
cne r a s o h Gv n e ’ cn ate s– h p csa bsdo ana bde, ocp et t te oe mns e r hs ta r e r ae n nu ug s t le r t tl i t i e l t
d cse aoe 3 i u d bv 4 s s .
F a yteGv n e a o pns pg os s m a z g e a ts mn b M i l , h oe mn l sed a ae r o u m i n c t nei oy y r nl r t s ri ri t .
Loy oc n gh p c grccsfXCl Mc en B G D m ia g mna e b ob cne i teri p t e o - e, ac ny C ’ o i cn a e s m y rn i n ai l l / s n r ts l
cn a o e gnr l D . B e a 45 a eig i e a ata“ ep csta XCl o rc r e eeay e’ r ft - (s r n n r l , h t r e[ t - e] t t .S l fs i st , t i t h i h l
cagd o Mc en [ e ] e r ie b teao cs ad eedd pn h cnrc o h e t ac ny w e d e m d y hlbr o s n dpne uo te os uin r l r t n t t t
rq r mn, cig n ca c rig ob Dpsint 1-4a oi n LoyDpsin eu e e s i n ad h a e z Loy eot a121 l cig ob eot i t” t r ti n io ;s t io
a162 103)4 B , y e nin h ts mn cnen XCln te a mna e b t 1-3 3-54 u b d i t , a ei oy oc s - e, o h g e s m y , . t fio t t t r l t r t s l
ids yn ee l5 Fr e teei oysmcto ocp aadsak gn pcit ad nuri gn a4 u h ,hts mni uho cne u nilc ni se fi n t r. tr t tl i icy
d a.S nia l a ogted i ec s hts mn o i ayics o opotm g s ei i i cn y mn o r e c n e teei oy ms n d u infrf a i . tl g f t, h fi i , t t s s i rn
Acr n y ie h o e e dne uie aoe M Loy ts mn cnen gXCl cod g , kte t r v ec o l d bv r ob’ ei oy oc i - e’
ill h i tn , . s t rn ls
p c gp ccs o cno cni t tepofotenr a p c gp ccsoteg mn ri r t eto an ost e h ro f h o m ri r t e f h a e i n ai t tu l i n ai r t
a e b ids y h irq rd omkteGv n e ’ cs s m y nur ta seu e t ae h oe mns ae s l t t i r t .
Cs m hs pknla y n h mt : T poe h t nain a es ce a e u o s a soe c r o t s ae o rvta r sc o v ui acp b t el i tr ta t l tl
43 S ma y M Loy ei e tai ws n uc m o” o XClte D m ia i i r , r ob tsf d h t a “o no mn fr - e, h o i cn ll . ti t t l n g mna e b cn a o t b cld pno ea r e oa aiu r e dr gh cu e a e s m y o rc r o e ae uot s p cfr p t l i m u nte or r t s l t t, l t i rc a t i s o a esn e LoyDpsint 3-2 TeGv n e mks ot m t su e h f sao .Se ob eot a 113 h oe mn ae n ae p o qa ta io . r t t t r t ts mn w h s ot nh,nur-ieg mna e b f ms p cs ae o ana ei oy i i psi ta ids y w , a e s m yi s e r e bsd n nu t t t io t t d r t s l r ti l bde. ug s t 44 Seloe. D. B ea1(seigh Mc en B Gs mi e dt e p cs e a , g e’ r ft 6a r nta ac ny C “o e msi a dr e s . , fs i st t l / t ct i t XCl ;da2 (seigh XCl p csw e bsd pn n xe a ota h sl o - e” i t 0a r nta - e’ r e e “ae uo a epct nh te ee l) . st t ls i r ti t lr wu cv i epne ad eie o eee o pot ;i a 2 ( f r g o h mnei o d oe t xess n raz s mlv f rf” d t 6r ei t te an n l rs l l i) . ern r w c “r e[ e ] e . b we XCl n Mc en” D. Rp B e a 7 a eig h h p cs w es .. e en - e ad ac ny ; e’ e y r ft (s r n i i r t t l l ) fs l i st ta“ e r e cagd y. XCl dpne uo cnrc o rq r mn ” h t p cs h e b.. - e[ eedd pn os uineu e e s. t h i r l] t t i t)
45 A n e aoe M Loy ad l akoldetah hs o e oakolde f s o d bv r ob cn d cn w gdh e a n p sn n w g o t , . iy e t r l e XCl p c g rccs See. LoyDpsint 1 - e’ ri p t e e, g ob eot a14 ls i n ai . ., io .
or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 8
bcuep cs w est d nacrac w hnr aids yp c gp ccs “b cv eas r e e el i codne i o m nur ri r t e o eie i r te t l t i n ai , j t
e dne f h nr a p c g rccs f hids y n us o irq rd tg h w h a v ec ote o m ri p t e ote nur i qeins eu e ” oe e i “ i l i n ai t t i , tr t
toog ep n inf h c c m acs u on n te a ” n “n x aa o o wy . hruh x aa o otei u s ne sr ud g h s e ad a ep nin f h. .
l t r t r i l l t
sc c c m acse a ih h te et nh d n if ec tep c ” SeCs m uh i u s ne s bs ta h r a os p i o n une h r e e u o s r t tl t li i d t l i. t
G dne nAcp bi o T nainV ui R a d a y rnaina781( mhss u ac o ce a l yf r sc o a en et P t T sc ost- 0e pae i t it a t l le r a t ,
add sea o d a 1 (x a ig h c c m acso s e l m a r e e we “ e de) e l i. t 0 epi n ta i u s ne f a ci s r e c d hn t ; s ln t r t l a e jt h
aea osr cn uoy n n spo e b e dne. l gin a oc sr ad o upr d y v ec” l t e l t t i )
Mc ateeod e ic dsolt e dne ou e ig o K’ p csw ee uhshrcr h en uetote v ec dc mn n h w B r e e s, r l il i t si r t
stohrcric dsse il n e dne“b c v”rte w e6 adte x aa o ooteeodn uee na y o v ec(o eie oo ri ) nlt ep nin l s tl i jt h s4 il l t
46 Mc en z os n n hlnugi teCs m pbcintig h “o eie ac ny e ei o teagae n h u o s u ia o st ta b cv l r t l t an t j t e dne f h nr a p c gp ccsote nur i qeins eu e”we ap t’ v ec ote o m ri r t e f hids y n us o irq rd h e a y i l i n ai t t i r r s ci tat nainv u i acp b i bsdo cn s ny w hnr aids yp c g l m h r sc o a es ce a es ae n ost c i o m nur ri a ta t l tl ie t l t in p ccs SeCs m G dneo Acp bi o T nain V u i R a d P t rte ai . e u o s u ac n ce a l y f r sc o a e n et a y t i t it a t l le r T naina78e pa s de)P’ Sp Rp B ea23 Cti nteGv n e ’ r sc ost-( mhs add ls up e y r ft- ri z gh oe mns a t i ;. . l i . ici r t e dne e a “u eie Mc en p n d os vs h – [ s h o yl s a o o v ec h e s sb c v ” ac ny o t l be eta “ ]te n i urin f i r jt , l iey r t a l l tt o eie v ec”– h Cs m pbcin i s Haqa e R igLt i w c te b c v e dne te u o s u ia o ce a edu t s u n ee n h h h jt i t l t t rr l tr i aec acp dshrq se o eie v ec”f o m ids yrigrccsro h gny ce e ateeui “b c v e dne onr a nur p c p t e pof a t it j t i l t i n ai tt te r en us o “ a d ie w he rneo r e pbsei ardjun ( e o e h p ci qein ws e nd i r e ct p cs u ihdn t eora t ps d i t f t fe i l a lh t p c adte by s n sl s o mn uete o e p c ate a s f o rcp cs r e n o r ue ad ee c m o y sdh ps d r e sh bs ocn a r e ” i) h r lr l t i i t ti . Se u o sG dne nAcp bi o T nainV ui R a dP t T nain a 8 e Cs m u ac o ce a l y f r sc o a e n et a y r sc ost t i t it a t l le r a t ( su igH 526 (M c 1 18) P’ Sp Rp B ea2selols up B e d cs n Q 421 a h 1 91; ls up e y r ft; e a P’ Sp r f i s r , ) . . l i s . . i a3 d cs n H 526 sgeigh te nr a nur p c g rccsts“o d e t ( su ig Q 421 ugs nta h “o m ids y ri p t e”e cu b i s , t t l t i n ai t l siidfr x m eite i a ids yo c mayp cc o st g o rc p csb as e o ea p,f h es n nur r o pn r t e f ei cn a r e y tf , l r t ai tn t t i r e neo ‘o e p c r lc ntervl gm k p cfr c m o t ac m ld n e r ct aps dr e e eigh p ai a e r eoa o md y s o pe ad fe t i’f t e in r t i i, i pbse b ard [ru] adi n UCC § -0() ) 21)r eig o cn a s n u ihd y t e gop ” n cig ... 2351 c(03( f r t “o rc i l a , t ( ern t t w c ‘ e r es.f eit m os m are m k o o es nad s eorcre b h ht p ci..i dne s f o e g d a e rt rt d as reodd y i h i x r e rt h a r t ah d e o oaec..’ ) t r p sn r gny.. ) i r ”.
Mc en cn ns h teGv n e cno ps b p vl nt “o m ids y ac ny o edta h oe mn an o i y r a o i nr a nur l t t r t t sl e i s l t p c grccster bcueter e ewe K ad Mc en ws os it m oay ri p t e”hoy eas “ p c b en B n ac ny a n e ne sf n i n ai h i t l tt r are m k p c ps d r eo o eidpne s nad h cu o eie so ta g d a e r e o e p c r t r needn t d ta o d b c v y h w h e r t i, t i, h t a r t l jt l t [ er a os p b wete ueadh sl ] [ ] o n uneh p c ” e P’ Sp t ]et nh [e enh by nte ee d d n if ecte r e Sels up h li i t r lr i t l i. . . B ea5 selo e’ Sp Rp B ea7cne ntae dne os oso ta K’ r ft; e a D . up e y r ft (ocd gh v ec de n h wh B i s fs . l i i t i t t s or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 9
( hruh o n ) fh “o m p c g rccs ote a mna e b ids y C t n “ oog” r o ote nr a ri p t e” fh g e s m ynur e a l t t l i n ai r t s l t . ri y
te Gv n e hsn e a ihd h K’ p cs w e ei acrac w h h ids y h oe mn a o s bse ta B r e e s n codne i te nur’
r t t tl t s i r t t t s
nr ap c g rccsaI ep tieN e wu rq r Se 9CFR§ 5 13)1i. o m ri p t e s n rr a v o 2 o deu e e 1 ... 12 0(()i l i n ai , t et t l i. . l ()
Cs m hs ne crd h ap ie e bsd nrnain a es o p mtd n u o s a ud so ta pr s mn ae o t sc o v ui n e ie i t r e t a t a t l t rt
aetd a yrnain be “ui e ifr a o”o e os a si ain fi ete r a p tt sc o asn sf c n no mint d mnr e as c o oe h h le r a t t fi t t t t tf t tr
c c m acsote a ts ote e v us SeCs m G dneo Acp bi o i u s ne f h s e e r h ts a e e u o s u ac n ce a l y f r t l t t l . t i t it
T nain V u i R a dP t T nain a 1 Te v ec tate Gv n e hs r sc o a e n et a y r sc os t 7 h e dne h h oe mn a a t l le r a t . i t r t
m sa do a i dc e ynui e t spo te s ot nain a e e. O b hh a h et d es e dd isf c n o upr h ue fr sc o v u h e n o te r l t i l fi t t a t l r t
fc ad h l wte Gv n e ’ m in o s m ay ug e ssi n Cs m ueo a s n te a, h oe mns o o fr u m jd mn u a ig u o s s f t r t t r t tn t ’
t nain a e h eo ms b dn d7 r sc o v ute fr u e e e4 a t l r e t i.
p csr a do n‘g e m k p c o‘o e p c ” TeGv n e “o sn d p e r e“ l et ayar d a e r e rps dr e ) h oe mn d[ ] o i u i et e rti’ t i ’. r t e tst ta te‘o e’ m k p c ds ie i [ Q526]po dda acp b maso h h ps d a e r e ec bd n H 421 rv e n ce a e en f t t rt i r i tl d e m ig h te r e a ws ostn w h o m p c g rccs n hids y Se e r i n ta h p c p d a cn s t i nr a ri p t ei te nur ” e t n t i i ie t l i n ai t. i a6 B , nh o ehn teGv n e m nish sc “ps dr e a n te n d t. u otet r ad h oe mn a t nta uh‘o e p cs r o h o y . t h , r t ia t t i ’e t l mas yw c [n rr a v N e ’‘o m ids y rig rccsts cn e as e ” en b h hI ep tie o 2 nr a nur p c p t e e] a b siid i t et t s l t i n ai ’ t tf .
I Ad h Gv n e fr e age ta K’ p cs n a w e“e b a idpne d n te oe mn u h rus h B r e i fc e s y n needn . r t tr t s i t r t t s nad i a mne “ostn w h o m p c g rccsi te nur d Te e a t d , n an cn s t i nr a ri p t e” n hids y . h dnl a r” r ie t l i n ai t .I i oteGv n e ’ m in os m ay ug e o te rud s fr aoe b a s n f h oe mns o o fr u m jd mn n h gons e o h bv ovt ay r t t r t t t ie net g e u h cn d a o t te aisag mn o t s o tt h t m edoi fr e os e t n oh p t ’ru e s n h p nat si e v t r i ri re t i i i . 47 Bs e se n s m ay ug e ssi n Cs m ueo t nainv u t e ds ek g u m jd mn u a ig u o s s f r sc o a e o i i r t tn t ’ a t l ap ie h m cad ete Gv n e a o eus te n yo s m ay ug e o i pr s te e hn s h oe mn l rqe s h e r f u m jd mn nt a r i, r t s t t r t s cu e l m o adin d is e eig e a cs ta w en ic dd t h t m te on r a fr d t a ue r lc n c t n o s h e o n ue atei e h t ci io l t f t ri t t r t l e r stsu w e q d e e D. B ea92-62 D . Rp B ea1-52-1 ni a se e l u a d e e’ r ft, 02 9 e’ e y r ft 21 02 te i r i i t .S fs i , ; fs l i , ; D. Sp B ea1 Bcueh Gv n e ’ cu e l ms o igno a e r ia o e’ up r ft 0 easte oe mns on r a i cn ne n d e m t n fs . i . r t t ci t t t ni ssi n teueot nainv u s m ay ug e at te on r a m lo ms b u a ig h s fr sc o a e u m jd mn s o h cu e l a tn a t l, r t t ci s u e t dn d eei.
or o 5044 t . Pg 5 ae 0
B Mc en’ M in o S m ay ug e . ac ny o o fr u m Jd mn
l s t r t
Mc en’ m in os m ayug e is ma yak gnm i Mc en ses ac ny o o fr u m jd mn si i r lc ni et ac ny ek l s t r t ll i r. l
s m ay ug e o i ci ta a e r sai u so dhv be ap ie bsdo u m jd mn nt l m h l ni t s e hu ae en pr sd ae n r t s a t l te s l a
ddc v v u w h h ecp o ote h e nisw c a e ie t d yrera mn euie a e i te xe in f htr e r t l, t t e t e h h r nt d o u - et t e i e tl tf e t
ud teC T A e gnr l P’ B ea21-51-52-13 P’ Rp B ea11 ne h B P.Se eeayls r ft, 31 72 83 2 ls e y r ft-1 r l . i , , , ;. l i ,
1-8 P’ Sp B e a 11 P’ Sp Rp B e a 14sc o I.. cspa g n n 71 ls up r ft -0 ls up e y r ft - einI A. ur (r t g ;. . i ;. . l i ; t I 1, ai
Gv n e ’ m inos m ayug e attre nis nt do u - et a mnud oe mns o ofr u m jd mn soh e r e iet d yre e e ne r t t r t e t e tl tf rt t r
teC T A h B P).
H wv ,h v uint u p msCs mt ap iem cad e ae o ddc v o eete a a o st e e i u o so pr s e hn s bsd n euie r lt at r t t a r i t
v u o yfrnain a e an b ue Se 9USC § 41 a sc o I spa Te a e n it sc o v u cno e sd e 1 ... 10a ) ein, ur. h l l a t l t . (; t
st e hs eu ete s ot nain a e vnwe (s e ) h by ad h sl a t u turq rs h ue fr sc o v u ee h e a h ete ue n te ee r at i a t l r r r lr e
r a dpo ddh “ ei u s ne ote a ..n c e tateet nh ..i n et , rv eta t c c m acs fh s e.id a [ h hr a os p. d o le i t h r t l i t] t li i d t
if ecter e o aenie ,h ternain a e c s y prx m e”i eote n uneh p c”r l ra v y a ht sc o v u “ oe apo a s e h fh l i ,t t ltt a t l l l i t tr
t oe v use o hnhst e ta s h te asc o v u c s y prx m ee h wts a es fr itet u –h i ta ht nain a el e apo a si e t l t t at t, t r t l ol i t tr
( ternain a e fdnc os ma m cad en a so n l e by snh US i ht sc o v u oie ia ri i r e hn si s et ur a d ue ite .. ) a t l t l l r i l et r
o()h ddc v v u o h c mu d a eo dnc os ma m cad e Se 9... r i e euie a er e o p e v ufr e ia ri i r e hn s e 1 USC it t l t t l i t l l r i.
§ 41 b 2 Bi() 8 ( ( ( (-i 4 10a ) ) ))i.
A d ae aoe h Gv n e tuf hsaetjsfte s ot nain a e s ei d bv te oe mn hsa afldouiyh ue fr sc o v u tl , r t r i t a t l
bsd nh “ ru s ne ote a. We e o n i s o i e oteGv n e t d s ae ote c c m acs fh s e i t l ” h h r o t ps b frh oe mn o o o tr t i sl r t
48 Tet u fr erq rsh tee v u uefr o p io “ l e t m cad e hst eu h eu eta hts a e sdoc masnr a [ o e hn s at t r i t tl r et ] r i ta ws xo etteU td t e aoao te a e m” sh m cad etsu Se h a epr doh ne Stst r bu h s mt e ate e hn s a se e t t i a t i r i i . 1 USC§ 41 b 2 B 9 ... 10a ) ) )
((( .
or o 5044 t . Pg 5 ae 1
r m n a oe qein e einI A, ur. B , nayee ,q t aa fo te e a s n pn us o i t .Sesc o I.. spa u i n vn ue p tr m h t I 2 t t i r
“ ru s ne otea ”e, e h p t hs esuh omk a h w gsowe eon c c m acsfhs ets nte a y a y og t ae soi at h h r o i t l t i r r t t n tr t
ternain a els y prx m ete euie a e rh c mu d a e oie ia ht sc o v u c e apo a sh ddc v v u ote o p e v ufrdnc a t l ol i t t l t l t l
os ma m cad e te eod fht otsv us s fr itet u.Se 9... ri i r e hn s –h scn ote w “ t a e” e o hnh st e e 1 USC l r i e l t t at
§ 41 b 2 Bi; e gnr l D . B ea2-7e pa z gh, vnf c c m acs 10a ) ) )i se eeay e’ r ft 62 ( mhsi ta eei“ ru s ne ( ( ( () l fs i in t i t
ote a ”e i n siidst oye v us ms b cn d e b o d e m a o cn f h s ets s o as e t u r ts a e u e os e d e r e r i t n a l t t tf , a t t l t i r f e t ni
b md cnen g pr s mn u n t nain a e D. Rp B ea 1-7s m. e ae oc i ap ie e s gr sc o v u ; e’ e y r ft 61 (a e 4 rn a t i a t l ) fs l i )9
Mc en ae p t age h,b se n s m ay ug e bsds e o te ac ny t m s o ru ta y ek g u m jd mn ae ol n h l t t t i r t ly
c c m acs f h s ee, h Gv n e hsw vd h opr n y o ek o mk a ae i u s ne ote a ts te oe mn a a e te po u t t se t ae cs r t l t r t i ti
frh ue frnain a e ae otet u rtsv usSelsB ea2 (o nta ote s ot sc o v u bsd nh st oye a e e P’ r ft 9 n igh a t l at t l . . i t t
Gv n e “a n o e d n pof o s bs ae v u acp b a ddc v v u o oe mn hs o f r ay rot e a ih ts a e ce a e s euie a e r r t t fe tl t l tl t l
ud c mu d a e ad seigh “]te Gv n e ] ekt so te ce abi ] ne o p e v u ” n a r nta [fh[ oe mn seso h wh acp [ l y r t l, st ti r t t it
oarnain a e easte pr sd a e c s y prx m ee v us.,hn ws f t sc o v u bcueh ap ie v usl e apo a ts a e..tei a a t l a l ol i t t l t
[ eGv n e ’ bret o ee dne cod g ” H wv, Mc en ce n a hr y t oe mns udnof r v ec acr n y. o ee ac nyi s o u ot h r t] f i il) r l t t i
49 A epie aoea hr ea t m K wsh o y eei N a ga fhtp s x a d bv t ee vn i e B ate n sl n i r u oteye ln , t l t , l lr ca o m cad etsu h eadK d n slo n l e by s e sc o Ispa Tu f e hn s ai e e , n B i o e t ur a d ue.Se ein, ur. hs r i s r d tl et r t , te a n s e o “ e ia os ma m cad et “n l e by s n h U tdSts h e r o a s fi nc ri i r e hn s” o ur a d ue i te ne t e” r e l dt l l r i et r i a t s v a a a s oc masn o proe oteite v u s fr itet u. e 1 o e e s bs fr o p io fr upss fhfs s a e e o hnh st eSe 9 r i r r tt l t t at USC 10ab 2 Bi Te aish eo areh te n r ea tsv u h esh ...§ 41 ) ) )) h p t te fr g ta h o ye vn e a e e ite ( ( ( (. re r e e t l l t t l r scn oe–i.we e ht naina ec s y prx m e teeuie a eo h eod n ., h h e t rter sc o v u l e apo a s hddc v v u rte a t l ol i t t l c mu d a e oie iao s mam rhn s e 1 USC 10ab 2 Bi; e’ o p e v u fr dnc r i i r e cad e e 9...§ 41 ) ) )i D.
t l t l l i .S ( ( ( () fs B e t2 epi n ta i l ho a s ft s ae tetss fr i ‘) cno b r fa 7(x a ig h, ni tffc o h cs h e e o h n(’ an e i ln t g t i ,“ tt t i t ape” P’ B ea2 n 1 n igh fsst oye v ui n apcb, bcueh p id ; ls r ft 3. (o nta itt u rts a es o p ia e“easte l ) . i 1 t t r at t l t l l rcr so sh K wsh o yrdc o mn tlrdl h gnN a ga. a o w c eod h wta B ate n poue f e’ a o c t ni i r u..l f h h t l r s i e oi ca l i ws h pd o Mc en” P’ Rp B e a 1-4 epi n ta“ e w e o a s f a s pe t ac ny ; ls e y r ft 31 (x a ig h t r e n s e o i l ) . l i ln t he r l ie iaos ma m cad emdt ur a dUSby s pnw c arnain a e f dnc ri i r e hn s aeo n l e .. ue uo h h t sc o v u o t l l r i et r i a t l ie iaos ma m cad emy e rd a d. dnc ri i r e hn s a b p i t ”
t l l r i e ce )
or o 5044 t . Pg 5 ae 2
t spo t snv apcinotedcieo w v. Nrcn Mc en d s Te o upr h oe p ia o f h o r f a e t i l l t tn i r o a ac ny o o h l .
Gv n e ws ne n o ia ot ad s b hh c c m acs fh s ee adhts oe mn a ud o b gino dr s o tei u s ne ote a ts ntee r t r l t e t r t l t t
v us nt m in o s m ay ug e . Segnr l,. ,1 Mo ’ Fd a P cc § a ei i o o fr u m jd mn e eeay e. 1 or s ee l r t e l s t r t l g e r ai
5 12p 5-0-630 d cs n “ai S m ay ug e s ad x a igi e a a 6 2 p 6375-1 ( su ig P tl u m Jd mn, n epi n n r l , . , . i s ra r t” ln , t i
ta“u m yug e my eeus d oo y s o n nr cs oat a o pt ci h s m a jd mn a brqe e n n at a e i ae r so c m e l m t r t t t l te , le a
o d es b a oa t p t o ci so d ess ;i §5 111 a p 5-9-630 r e ne u l s o as f l m r e ne” d f , t s r a f ) . 6 2[] ] p 6295-0 . [, .
(a ind“M t l [ u m yJd mn M in o Df e Gons So d N B cp oe t ui e S m a ug e ] o os n i e n rud hu lp r t t fr t l o e
t
Dfvrd .0 i ao ” 5 s e)
Te o o l esh – n s ad nl hs en e r ieta h ue frnain h b t m nita u e n u i t a be d e m dh te s ot sc o t i t ls ti t n t a t
v ui n mna d yi etei u s ne ote a ts otet u r ts v us te a es o ad e b e h h c c m acs f h s ee r h st oye a e – h l t t tr r t l t at t l
st ei p de n p m ap ie e bsdo ddc v v u w c ite eu ta t u s m y os o e i pr s mn ae n euie a e h hs h rs t h at l t rt a t t l, i l t
Mc en avc e Mc en’ m in os m ay ug e te fr ms b dn d ac ny doa s ac ny o o fr u m jd mn h eo u e e e l t. l s t r t r e t i.
I. C n u o V oc s n
li
Frhraos efr aoeteoen e ’ o o o s i frakf us c o oteesns o h bv hGv mnsm intd m s olco jr dt n t t , r t t i s i ii
Mc en’ l m ne tene t e C iba Bs rd a n s p c “ B P ”a ac ny l sci ud hU tdSts a ben a nT eP te h A a r i a - r i a r r i t( C T A s)
t a niso e hn hs cv e yPo s o 10-4105 u b rn d Te ol t e t rta toe oe db r e . 830-006ms eg t . h le r h r t tN t ae
Gv n e ’ o o ek gi m s odnlf ac ny B P l mi epc oh oe mnsm inse n d i a r e aoMc en’ r t t i s sl i l sC T Aci w hrse tte a t t
50 Mc en dv e ms oi iko te e v ussu t ag n ta a e ad o ac ny eo s o ft n n h ts a ei e o ru g h r mn t l t t s t l s i t Cs mi n aport See. P’ B ea1-41 1 n, 22 3 P’ Rp B e u o ss o prp a. e, g ls r ft 31 5 8. 2-5 2 ls e y r f t t ie ., . i , , 8 , ;. l i a 1-4 Mc en tufcss n n r w us o o poeu, n t et g s oete t 21 . ac ny hs oue o a a o qein f rcdr adr s o l s v h l r t e i o r ct aud l n p nosb a iea – pcia y Cs m st oy b gino pr s ri l ne y g o tf us n vl w se f l , u o s t u r o ia ot ap ie ic ri i tt i cl t ’ at l t a m cad e ae oi t nain a eee we te ueadhsl a r a d fi e e hn s bsd n sr sc o v u vn h eh by nteee r et , e h r i t a t l, r r lr e l e i t r ote wts s fr i 1 USC§ 41 b 2 Bi siid fht oe s e o hn 9 ... 10a ) ) )s as e t t t ((( tf .
or o 5044 t . Pg 5 ae 3
fue r s oe d yPo s o 830-006w c e ae b o c b ,20 or ni cv e b r e .10-4105 h hw emd e r t e te r t tN i r f eO o r2 00
s ma y u e rn d At te h e pcid nis h a sb ct teC T A E r i i r ms l l tb g t . s o htr se f e r ta r u e o h B P ( n y ae e ie te t e j t t
Ns WP00408 WP00422 adWP-020-) te Gv n e ’ m infr o J-027- . , J-029-, n J 00577 h oe mns o o o , r t t
s m ayug e msb g n d Otetehn b hh Gv n e ’ m inos m ay u m jd mn u er t . nh o r ad o te oe mns o ofr u m r t t ae h , t r t t r
jd mncnen gh poe m hd f pr s mnoa r m n g nis n Mc en’ ug e oc i te rp e o oap ie e fl e a i e r ad ac ny t rn r t a t l i n te l s
co - o o fr u m y ug e o te a esu ms b dn d rs m in os m a jd mn n h s mi e u e e e s t r t s t i.
A od wl n r cod g . n re i e eacr n y r l t il
/ Di aR g a s es i wy / ls d Di aA R g a es . i wy ls d
Jde ug
D e Jnay 204 a d au 221 t: r , N wYr N wYr e ok e ok ,
E RT R AA
Mc en Pou s.U td t e Cu N 0-08 S pO 1- d e Jnay 221 ac ny rdc v ne Sts, or o 5044 l p 45 a d au 2 04 l t i a t . ,i . , t r , .
Pg 6 ae: Ite eui a l efhfsp arp ofo o 9d e te x a pcta nh pn t m e n o e r a g hfo n e, et h e rsae h l t i t it r a tt le t t apa i mdt y eo “v le pe s m e al b r [] u”
r ie f e a .
Pg 9 ae: I teie m e al f l w g h b c qo, e ae 1 CFR§ w h 1 n hl i mdt y o oi te l k u erp c “9 ... ” i “9 n ie l n o t l t CFR§” ... § .
Pg 1 ae 0: I l eie f h fsf l a g p rp c “ ateK wu ”w hta K ni f oteit u p ar h e aet t h B o d i “ t B n v r l r a, l h l t h wu ” od l.
Pg 1 ae 5: I teial e f h m ne , ette pc b we “a e ad).
n hf li ote a tx d e h sae e en s m” n “ ”
n n i t le t ;
Pg 1 ae 6: I l ei rp c “ 2”w h F d ni s ,e ae Fd i “. ”
n x l t 2.
Pg 2 ae 7: I l e ih oteit u p arp rp c “3 2” w h 1-0 (n te ni e t f h fsf l a g h e ae 1 -0 i “32” I o r n g r l r a, l t . h wrsd e te pctaapa i mdt yf r 1” n b o “2” od et h sae h pe s m e al a e“3 ad e r -0)
, le t r ie t fe .
Pg 2 ae 8: I l e w ofo o 2 is t sae ewe “1 ad(t g.
ni t o f o n e 8 ne a pc b en 1” n “ i n ”
n tt , r t ci ,
Pg 3 ae 0: Il e 1t 1 otei h a g p ofo o 2 rp c “o d d mnr e n ns 3o 4 fh s t p ar h f o n e 8 e ae cu “e os a i x r a tt , l l tt tate r e. ”w h cu “e os a etate r e. ” h h p c.. i “o d d mnr [ h h p c... t i t l tt ] t i
Pg 4 ae 2: I tepn t m eieofo oe3 rp c “ 5 4-6 2 w h § 5 4-
n h eui a l f o n t 8 e ae § 6 05 4 ” i “§ 6 0 l t n t , l . ., t .
54” 6 2. .,
Pg 5 ae 0: Itea l e fh scn f l a g p rp c “ 10ab 2 Bi() w h nhls i ote eod u p ar h e ae § 41 ) ) ))i. i tn l r a, l ( ( ( (-i ” t “§ 41 b 2 Bi(). § 10a ) ) ))i.
( ( ( (-i”
Fbu y 121 era 2 04 r ,
S P L E T LE R T U P EM N A R A A
Mc en Pou s.U td t e Cu N 0-08 S pO 1- d e Jnay 221 ac ny rdc v ne Sts, or o 5044 l p 45 a d au 2 04 l t i a t . ,i . , t r , .
Pg 1 ae: I teiigo cus frPi i, e ae J r P S k ,S mn &S k , n h lt f one o l nf rp c “e y . i i i os i i ”
sn l a tf l r sn sn w h J r P W k ,S mn & W k , i “e y . i i i os i i ” t r sn s n.
Fbu y 521 era 2 04 r ,
2014 CIT 5 (Macclenny Prods. v. United States) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.