Macclenny Prods. v. United States
This text of 2014 CIT 5 (Macclenny Prods. v. United States) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering United States Court of International Trade primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.
Opinion
S pO. 4 5 l p1- i
U I E S A E C U TO I T R AI N LT A E NT D T T S O R F N E N T O A R D ________________________ ________________________ MA C E N P O U T , C L N Y R D CS :
Pii , l nf a tf :
v . : Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t .
UI E S A E , NT D T T S :
D edn. e na f t : ________________________________________ ________________________________________
[ rn n D ednsP tlM in t D m sfr ako Jr dt nG n n e na ’ G t g e na ’ ai o o oi i oLc f us c o r t gD edns ai f t ra t s s i ii ; a i f t P tl o o o s i oFlr tSt al m(r l ra v yM infrug e o te ai M intD m sfra u o a Ci o aenie , o o oJd mn n h ra t i s i e te a ,t t l t t P a ns r oS m ay ug e )G n n e na ’ o o oP tl u m y ug e l d g ofru m Jd mn;r t gD ednsM infrai S m a Jd mn ei r t ai f t t ra r t a t C t nE r sE g b frD yF eL u a o Prunt US C iba Bs T d s oe a ni l i e o u -r i i t n u a o .. a ben a n r e ri t e i l t e q di s t - r i a P te h A; n Dn n D edns n Pi i’ M infr ai S m ay ug e a n s p c ad ey g e na ’ ad l nf s o os o P tl u m Jd mn r ri t i f t a tf t ra r t at M hd fAp ie e ] so e o o pr s mn t a t D e Jnay , 04 a d au 2 21 t: r2
J r P S k , i os& ik, f o hA by N w e e age fr l nf W h e y . i i S mn S i o Su r sn sn t mo e J sy rud o Pi i. i , r , a tf t h m nh b e w eB n d.Bb ad aikC Re Ocus oter fws hi Y e i oter f e e a J ab n P r . ed f one nh b e a P l a i r rr tc . l i ip l S mn. i os
A y M Rb , Sn r T a Cus,I enin T d Fl Oie C m e i m . u n e o rl one n ra oa r e i d f c o m cl i i i l t t l a e f , ra Lia o B nh C i D i o US Dp t e oJsc o N wYr N wYr age fr i gin r c i l i s n .. ea mn f uie f e ok e ok rud o t t a , v vi , r t t , , , D edn W h eoter fw eta F D ey A i a A onyGn a C i D i o e na . i h nh b e e S r . e r , s s n t re ee l i l i s n f t t r i r ut l st t t r, v vi , adB b a . Wl m,A onynCag I enin T d Fl Oie Ocus ote n a a S ii s t rei h e n ra oa r e i d f c f one nh rr la t r, t t l a e f . l b e ws M he Hyr h Oie fh A i a C e Cus, n ra oa T d Lia o r f a i a ed c, f c ote s s n h f one I enin r e i gin i c l i f st t i l t t l a t t , Bra o Cs m adBre Po c o US Dp t e o H m ad eut o N wYr u u f u o s n od r ein .. ea mn f o e n Scr y f e ok e t r tt , r t l i, , N wYr e ok .
OI I N PN O
R D A, ug I GW YJde:
I t s c o pi i Mc en Pou s hlnetedcinote U tdSts n h ain l nf ac ny rdc caegs h e s f h ne t e i t , a tf l t l io i a
u o s e i 1 ey g ac ny r e s o eig h aec’ i i t n f ni o Cs m S v e dn n Mc en’ po s cn s n te gny l u a o o e r s f t rc i l s tt tt s q di te
1 TeUS Cs m S v e fr e y a o h US Dp t e o T auy i n w a h .. u o s e i –o m l p tf e .. ea mn f r sr –s o p t t rc r r t r t e r o h US Dp t e o H m ad eut ads o mn ko nsUS Cs madBre f e .. ea mn f o e n Scr y nic m o y n w a .. u o s n od t r t l i, l t r Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae
“ e’s t yeak si pr dr mN a gan 00 n 20 Se eeayitA edd mn u- pjce ” mo efo i r ui 20 ad 01 e gnr l Fs mne s it t t ca . l r
C m a t ¶,,. o pi ¶ 3682 ln
Mc en r ss w ci s Mc en fscn ns h Cs m e e b ap i n ac ny a et ol m ac nyit o edta u o s r d y pr s g l i a . l r t t t r ai
te m cad eai u friu a o bsdo “ asc o v u ”bcue–acr n t h e hn s t s e ol i t n ae n t nain a e eas r i s q di r t l, cod g o i
Mc en –h p c ote od wsn une bteet nh b wete mo e by ac ny te r e fh gos aif ecd yhr a os p e enhi pr r ue l i l li i t t- r
ad h fr g mnfc r -ee Mc en a es h te m cad e n ed hu hv n te o in au t e sl . ac ny s r ta h e hn sis a so d ae e a u r lr l st t r i t l
be ap ie ote a s f ddc v v u ”Fs A eddC m a t ¶ 12 I adin en pr sd nh bs o“euie a e it mne o pi ¶ 1-4 n d t , a i t l. r ln . io
Mc en aeetatte x n h te u e m cad ews mo e o oa e O oe ac nyl gsh,oh e e ta hsb c e hn s ai pr d nrf r c b l l t tt t jt r i t t t r
220 tem cad es nt do u - et a mnud teU tdt e C iba Bs , 00 h e hn sie iet d yrer t e ne h ne Sts a ben a n , r i tl tf e t r i a - r i
T d P te h A ( C T A , w c e ed t d bn i t c t ncu r s n h r e a n s p c “ B P ” h h x ns r e eet o e a oni i te a r ri t ) i t a fs ri te
C ibarg n d¶ 2-91 USC§ 73b(003i p mn dnUS N e()) C a bene o r i .I. ¶ 52 9 ... 20()20) m e e ei .. o 7bi h ; , l t t (, .
9 SbhI H mn e T i Shd e fh U tdSts“ T U”(00 4 8 uc I a o zd af ceu ote ne t e( H S S 20) , ., r i rf l i a ) .
A oa i u i t sain s h Gv n e ’ cu e l mfradin d is l t s e n h c o i te oe mns on r a o d t a ue s s i t r t t ci io l t .
Se f a yte Gv n e cn ns h, su ig h Cs m ueot nainv u i pci l , h oe mn o edta a m ta u o s s fr sc o a es i cl r t t t s n t t ’ a t l
ssie c t n o s h w e oic dd nCs m l u a o ote m cad e hu u a d e a cs ta e n n ue i u o s i i t n f h e hn s so d t n , ri t t r t l t ’ q di r i l
Po c o SeB l .U tdSts 49F d 35 16 n (e C. 07 Te gnys r ein e u v ne t e 7 . 16 38 . Fd i 20) h aec i tt . l i a , 3 , 1 . r . r e et a “ u o s h e. e r do s Cs m” e i fr t rn 2 Mc en fe b hpbc n cn dna v s n oi Fs A eddC m a t ac ny i d o u i ad of e i ei s ft it mne o pi . l l t l i tl r o s r ln H wv, n te u i v s nsi d e i o ee o y h pbc ei i ce h e . r l l ro t rn 3 A ca os oee lt u srt te 00 din f h U tdStsCd l it nt fd ast e a o h 20 e t ote ne t e oe l ti r at e io i a . 4 A ca osoh H S S e i a tte 00 dina mdidi r ea p t b l it ntte T U h e r oh 20 e t , s o f ( e vn a) y l ti rn e io ie n l t r i p mnt n f h C T A Te 01 dins dnc t te 00 dina mdid n m e e a o ote B P. h 20 e t iie ia o h 20 e t , s o f , l ti io t l io ie i a r ea rse s l e vn epc. ll t t Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae
b addoht nain a eadCs mso d e w dd d t n d is ae otoe e detter sc o v u n u o s hu b a a e adi a ue bsd nhs a t l, t l r io l t
adin s m As eadCu e l m ¶ 03 d t a u s n w n on r a ¶ 3-3 io l . r t ci .
N w ed g eo teCu a te ais d psiers m in 5 W hepct o pn n b r h or r h p t ’i ot co - o os i fe t e re s i v s t . i rse o t t
Mc en’ C T Al m h Gv n e sesi m s frak f u e mt jr dt n ac ny B P ci, e oe mn ek d i a olc osb c ae us c o l s a t r t s sl j t t r i ii
at a e r stsu o etatoe oe d y r e N 10-4105 e D edns sol ni a set rhnhs cv e b Po s o 830-006 e e na ’ l te i h r tt . .S f t
M mrnu i Spo o M in o S m ay ug e ( D. B e )t,, 11 6 W h e o d mn upr f o o fr u m Jd mn “ e’ r f a291-3 a t t r t fs i ” . it
rse t Mc en’ C T Al mo hs e r s oe d y r e N 10-4105 te epc o ac ny B P ci fr oe ni cv e b Po s o 830-006 h t l s a t te r tt . ,
Gv n e ses i m s fra u t st aci uo w c ri cn e rn d s o h oe mn ek d i a oflr ot e l m pn h h ee a b g t at te r t s sl i e a a i lf ae
fu e r s h w e md p ot O oe 2 20 te f c v d e f h C T A o gos or ni ta e ae r r o c b , 00 h e eie a ote B P fr od te t r i t r , ft t
fo N a ga i. E r Ns WP00399 WP00461 WP00494ad WP r m i r u –., n y o J-029- J-021- J-022- n J- ca e t . , , ,
00401 ei.t &. 91-3 At te h e nis oe d yPo s N 10-4 024-.Se d a 2 n,, 11 s o htr e r cv e b r e o 830- 3 . e te r tt .
105 ta w ee e do o a e O oe 2 20 ( e E r Ns WP00408 WP 006 h e n r n r f r c b , 00 i. n y o J-027- J- t r te t t r ., t . ,
00422ad WP00577 teGv n e ses u m yug e l u a nte nis 029- n J-020-) h oe mn eks m a jd mni i t gh e r , , r t r t q di te
d yre Se d a 2 &n,1 2 D ednsRp t Pi i’ Rsos t D edns u - e e i. t tf . . 3 9 e na ’ e y o l nf s epne o e na ’ 3 , ; f t l a tf f t
M in o S m ay ug e adRsost Pi i’ Co -M in o S m ay ug e o o fr u m Jd mn n epneo l nf s rs o o fr u m Jd mn t r t a tf s t r t
( D. Rp B e )a 3n,2 [ e na ’ Sp e e a M mrnu i Spo o “ e’ e y r f t . 0 D edns up mnl e o d m n upr f fs l i ” 4 ; f t] l t a t
D edns M in o S m ay ug e ( D. Sp B e )t 0 e na ’ o o fr u m Jd mn “ e’ up r f a1 f t t r t fs . i” .
Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI
S pO. 4 5 l p1- i
U I E S A E C U TO I T R AI N LT A E NT D T T S O R F N E N T O A R D ________________________ ________________________ MA C E N P O U T , C L N Y R D CS :
Pii , l nf a tf :
v . : Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t .
UI E S A E , NT D T T S :
D edn. e na f t : ________________________________________ ________________________________________
[ rn n D ednsP tlM in t D m sfr ako Jr dt nG n n e na ’ G t g e na ’ ai o o oi i oLc f us c o r t gD edns ai f t ra t s s i ii ; a i f t P tl o o o s i oFlr tSt al m(r l ra v yM infrug e o te ai M intD m sfra u o a Ci o aenie , o o oJd mn n h ra t i s i e te a ,t t l t t P a ns r oS m ay ug e )G n n e na ’ o o oP tl u m y ug e l d g ofru m Jd mn;r t gD ednsM infrai S m a Jd mn ei r t ai f t t ra r t a t C t nE r sE g b frD yF eL u a o Prunt US C iba Bs T d s oe a ni l i e o u -r i i t n u a o .. a ben a n r e ri t e i l t e q di s t - r i a P te h A; n Dn n D edns n Pi i’ M infr ai S m ay ug e a n s p c ad ey g e na ’ ad l nf s o os o P tl u m Jd mn r ri t i f t a tf t ra r t at M hd fAp ie e ] so e o o pr s mn t a t D e Jnay , 04 a d au 2 21 t: r2
J r P S k , i os& ik, f o hA by N w e e age fr l nf W h e y . i i S mn S i o Su r sn sn t mo e J sy rud o Pi i. i , r , a tf t h m nh b e w eB n d.Bb ad aikC Re Ocus oter fws hi Y e i oter f e e a J ab n P r . ed f one nh b e a P l a i r rr tc . l i ip l S mn. i os
A y M Rb , Sn r T a Cus,I enin T d Fl Oie C m e i m . u n e o rl one n ra oa r e i d f c o m cl i i i l t t l a e f , ra Lia o B nh C i D i o US Dp t e oJsc o N wYr N wYr age fr i gin r c i l i s n .. ea mn f uie f e ok e ok rud o t t a , v vi , r t t , , , D edn W h eoter fw eta F D ey A i a A onyGn a C i D i o e na . i h nh b e e S r . e r , s s n t re ee l i l i s n f t t r i r ut l st t t r, v vi , adB b a . Wl m,A onynCag I enin T d Fl Oie Ocus ote n a a S ii s t rei h e n ra oa r e i d f c f one nh rr la t r, t t l a e f . l b e ws M he Hyr h Oie fh A i a C e Cus, n ra oa T d Lia o r f a i a ed c, f c ote s s n h f one I enin r e i gin i c l i f st t i l t t l a t t , Bra o Cs m adBre Po c o US Dp t e o H m ad eut o N wYr u u f u o s n od r ein .. ea mn f o e n Scr y f e ok e t r tt , r t l i, , N wYr e ok .
OI I N PN O
R D A, ug I GW YJde:
I t s c o pi i Mc en Pou s hlnetedcinote U tdSts n h ain l nf ac ny rdc caegs h e s f h ne t e i t , a tf l t l io i a
u o s e i 1 ey g ac ny r e s o eig h aec’ i i t n f ni o Cs m S v e dn n Mc en’ po s cn s n te gny l u a o o e r s f t rc i l s tt tt s q di te
1 TeUS Cs m S v e fr e y a o h US Dp t e o T auy i n w a h .. u o s e i –o m l p tf e .. ea mn f r sr –s o p t t rc r r t r t e r o h US Dp t e o H m ad eut ads o mn ko nsUS Cs madBre f e .. ea mn f o e n Scr y nic m o y n w a .. u o s n od t r t l i, l t r Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae
“ e’s t yeak si pr dr mN a gan 00 n 20 Se eeayitA edd mn u- pjce ” mo efo i r ui 20 ad 01 e gnr l Fs mne s it t t ca . l r
C m a t ¶,,. o pi ¶ 3682 ln
Mc en r ss w ci s Mc en fscn ns h Cs m e e b ap i n ac ny a et ol m ac nyit o edta u o s r d y pr s g l i a . l r t t t r ai
te m cad eai u friu a o bsdo “ asc o v u ”bcue–acr n t h e hn s t s e ol i t n ae n t nain a e eas r i s q di r t l, cod g o i
Mc en –h p c ote od wsn une bteet nh b wete mo e by ac ny te r e fh gos aif ecd yhr a os p e enhi pr r ue l i l li i t t- r
ad h fr g mnfc r -ee Mc en a es h te m cad e n ed hu hv n te o in au t e sl . ac ny s r ta h e hn sis a so d ae e a u r lr l st t r i t l
be ap ie ote a s f ddc v v u ”Fs A eddC m a t ¶ 12 I adin en pr sd nh bs o“euie a e it mne o pi ¶ 1-4 n d t , a i t l. r ln . io
Mc en aeetatte x n h te u e m cad ews mo e o oa e O oe ac nyl gsh,oh e e ta hsb c e hn s ai pr d nrf r c b l l t tt t jt r i t t t r
220 tem cad es nt do u - et a mnud teU tdt e C iba Bs , 00 h e hn sie iet d yrer t e ne h ne Sts a ben a n , r i tl tf e t r i a - r i
T d P te h A ( C T A , w c e ed t d bn i t c t ncu r s n h r e a n s p c “ B P ” h h x ns r e eet o e a oni i te a r ri t ) i t a fs ri te
C ibarg n d¶ 2-91 USC§ 73b(003i p mn dnUS N e()) C a bene o r i .I. ¶ 52 9 ... 20()20) m e e ei .. o 7bi h ; , l t t (, .
9 SbhI H mn e T i Shd e fh U tdSts“ T U”(00 4 8 uc I a o zd af ceu ote ne t e( H S S 20) , ., r i rf l i a ) .
A oa i u i t sain s h Gv n e ’ cu e l mfradin d is l t s e n h c o i te oe mns on r a o d t a ue s s i t r t t ci io l t .
Se f a yte Gv n e cn ns h, su ig h Cs m ueot nainv u i pci l , h oe mn o edta a m ta u o s s fr sc o a es i cl r t t t s n t t ’ a t l
ssie c t n o s h w e oic dd nCs m l u a o ote m cad e hu u a d e a cs ta e n n ue i u o s i i t n f h e hn s so d t n , ri t t r t l t ’ q di r i l
Po c o SeB l .U tdSts 49F d 35 16 n (e C. 07 Te gnys r ein e u v ne t e 7 . 16 38 . Fd i 20) h aec i tt . l i a , 3 , 1 . r . r e et a “ u o s h e. e r do s Cs m” e i fr t rn 2 Mc en fe b hpbc n cn dna v s n oi Fs A eddC m a t ac ny i d o u i ad of e i ei s ft it mne o pi . l l t l i tl r o s r ln H wv, n te u i v s nsi d e i o ee o y h pbc ei i ce h e . r l l ro t rn 3 A ca os oee lt u srt te 00 din f h U tdStsCd l it nt fd ast e a o h 20 e t ote ne t e oe l ti r at e io i a . 4 A ca osoh H S S e i a tte 00 dina mdidi r ea p t b l it ntte T U h e r oh 20 e t , s o f ( e vn a) y l ti rn e io ie n l t r i p mnt n f h C T A Te 01 dins dnc t te 00 dina mdid n m e e a o ote B P. h 20 e t iie ia o h 20 e t , s o f , l ti io t l io ie i a r ea rse s l e vn epc. ll t t Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae
b addoht nain a eadCs mso d e w dd d t n d is ae otoe e detter sc o v u n u o s hu b a a e adi a ue bsd nhs a t l, t l r io l t
adin s m As eadCu e l m ¶ 03 d t a u s n w n on r a ¶ 3-3 io l . r t ci .
N w ed g eo teCu a te ais d psiers m in 5 W hepct o pn n b r h or r h p t ’i ot co - o os i fe t e re s i v s t . i rse o t t
Mc en’ C T Al m h Gv n e sesi m s frak f u e mt jr dt n ac ny B P ci, e oe mn ek d i a olc osb c ae us c o l s a t r t s sl j t t r i ii
at a e r stsu o etatoe oe d y r e N 10-4105 e D edns sol ni a set rhnhs cv e b Po s o 830-006 e e na ’ l te i h r tt . .S f t
M mrnu i Spo o M in o S m ay ug e ( D. B e )t,, 11 6 W h e o d mn upr f o o fr u m Jd mn “ e’ r f a291-3 a t t r t fs i ” . it
rse t Mc en’ C T Al mo hs e r s oe d y r e N 10-4105 te epc o ac ny B P ci fr oe ni cv e b Po s o 830-006 h t l s a t te r tt . ,
Gv n e ses i m s fra u t st aci uo w c ri cn e rn d s o h oe mn ek d i a oflr ot e l m pn h h ee a b g t at te r t s sl i e a a i lf ae
fu e r s h w e md p ot O oe 2 20 te f c v d e f h C T A o gos or ni ta e ae r r o c b , 00 h e eie a ote B P fr od te t r i t r , ft t
fo N a ga i. E r Ns WP00399 WP00461 WP00494ad WP r m i r u –., n y o J-029- J-021- J-022- n J- ca e t . , , ,
00401 ei.t &. 91-3 At te h e nis oe d yPo s N 10-4 024-.Se d a 2 n,, 11 s o htr e r cv e b r e o 830- 3 . e te r tt .
105 ta w ee e do o a e O oe 2 20 ( e E r Ns WP00408 WP 006 h e n r n r f r c b , 00 i. n y o J-027- J- t r te t t r ., t . ,
00422ad WP00577 teGv n e ses u m yug e l u a nte nis 029- n J-020-) h oe mn eks m a jd mni i t gh e r , , r t r t q di te
d yre Se d a 2 &n,1 2 D ednsRp t Pi i’ Rsos t D edns u - e e i. t tf . . 3 9 e na ’ e y o l nf s epne o e na ’ 3 , ; f t l a tf f t
M in o S m ay ug e adRsost Pi i’ Co -M in o S m ay ug e o o fr u m Jd mn n epneo l nf s rs o o fr u m Jd mn t r t a tf s t r t
( D. Rp B e )a 3n,2 [ e na ’ Sp e e a M mrnu i Spo o “ e’ e y r f t . 0 D edns up mnl e o d m n upr f fs l i ” 4 ; f t] l t a t
D edns M in o S m ay ug e ( D. Sp B e )t 0 e na ’ o o fr u m Jd mn “ e’ up r f a1 f t t r t fs . i” .
5 A hu h Mc en ad h Gv n e fe b h u i ad of e i v s n o l o g ac ny n te oe mn i d o pbc n cn dna ei s f t l r tl t l i tl r o te p n p b e,lca os e i a t te u i v s n h r r c a r f a i t n h e r o h pb c e i s i i i l i s l ti rn e l ro. 6 A d cse b o,l ogteGv n e ’sb i ins a ind ol aa M in si u d e wa huhh oe mns u m s icp oe s e s o o s s l t r t so t ly t frS m ay ug e , h Gv n e ’ b e a o ek i m s o c t nl mfrak f o u m Jd mn te oe mns r f l se d i a f e a ci s olc o r t r t is s s sl ri a sb c mt jr dt n n d m s o o e fra u t st al m pnw c ri cn u e ae us c o adi i a ft r oflr ot e ci uo h hee a j t t r i ii s sl hs i e a a i lf bg nd er t . ae Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae
W h epct a o e e r ste Gv n e rqe se r o s m ay ug e i rse o l t r ni , h oe mn eus n y f u m jd mn t t l h te r t t t r t
ssi n Cs m ue o t nain v u t ap iete m cad e bsd o te u a ig u o s s f r sc o a e o pr s h e hn s ae n h tn t ’ a t l a r i,
“ ru s ne ote a ” e s fr i tev uint u. Se f a yte Gv n e c c m acs f h s e ts e o h n h a a o st e pci l , h oe mn i t l t t t lt at i cl r t
agetaue frnain a ews prp a bcue acr ntteGv n e –h rush s ot sc o v u a aport eas – cod goh oe mn te t a t l ie i r t
p c ote m cad ews st d n mne cn s n w h h nr a p c g rccs f r e f h e hn s a “el i a an ost t i te o m ri p t e o i r i te r ie t l i n ai
tenur ” ntu ws o n une bteet nh b wete mo e by adh hids y adhs a n if ecd yhr a os p e enhi pr r ue nte t, t l li i t t- r
fr g mnfc r -ee 1 USC § 41 b 2 B 1 CFR § 5 13)1;e D. o in au t e sl . 9 ... 10a ) ) ) 9 ... 12 0(() se e’ e a u r lr ((( ; . l 7 fs
B ea91-02 2 2 D. Rp B ea11 1 2 D. Sp B ea 89ps m r ft, 32 6 8 9 e’ e y r ft -2 6 0 e’ up r ft - a i ; i , , , ; fs l i , , ; fs . i , s
D ednsRp t Pi i’ Sp e e a B e( D. Sp Rp B e )t - e na ’ e yo l nf s up mnl r f“ e’ up e y r f a18 f t l a tf l t i fs . l i” .
TeGv n e a o ek e r os m ayug e oi cu e l m oadin h oe mn l ses n y f u m jd mn nt on r a fr d t a r ts t r t s t ci io l
d is A u ig h s m ay ug e e e ssi n Cs m dcin oap ie h ue s m ta u m jd mn n r u a ig u o s e s t pr s te t. s n t r t ts t n t ’ io a
m cad eo tebs ot nainv u te Gv n e rqe s h te Cu od e hn s n h a s fr sc o a e h oe mn eus ta h or re r i i a t l, r t t t t r
riu a o ote nis tsu t ic d i te pr sdv u a pci s mp u t o e q din f h e r ai e o n ue n h ap ie a e se f u e n fr l it te s l a l ic r i
e r smdi 20t r lc“ e r d rdc o Cs, ad n d t n“l mu s a b ni aen 00oe e D e e Pouin o s n i adi , a a on p d y te f t fr t t” , io l t i
B G o r n ea o K i 20 ad 01 h w e o o s b py e s yK t B G r C t o o bh f f B n 00 n 20 ta e n f e y a mn b B o C o l t r t ft t
gos h pd yK t Mc en B Gnhs ya. D. B ea2 seloda92-6 ods pe b Bo ac ny C itoe e s e’ r ft 9 e a i.t, 02 i l / r ” fs i ; s ;
D. Rp B ea1-52-1 D. Sp B ea1 e’ e y r ft 21 02 e’ up r ft 0 fs l i , ; fs . i .
Ii co - o ofr u m yug e , Mc en cnu iteGv n e ’rqe n srs m inos m a jd mn ac ny ocr nh oe mnseus t s t r t l s r t t
ta E r Ns WP00408 WP00422 ad WP00577b l u a dd yre h n y o J-027- J-029- n J-020- ei i t u - e t t . , , q de tf
7 A ca os ofd a rg a osa t te19 e t no te Cd o Fd a l it n t ee l eut n r o h 99 di f h oe f ee l l ti r li e io r Rg a os w c iie iat te 00 n 20 e t ni a r ea rse s eut n h hs dnc o h 20 ad 01 di s nl e vn epc. li , i t l io ll t t Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 5 ae
prunt teC T A SePi i’ M mrnu i Opsin oD edns M in o u a o h B P. e l nf s e o d m n pot t e na ’ o o fr s t a tf a io f t t
S m ay ug e ad nSpo o Pi i’ Co -M in o S m ay ug e (P’ u m Jd mn n i upr f l nf s rs o o fr u m Jd mn “ls r t t a tf s t r t .
B e )t, n, 21 1 1-73-3 I adin Mc en ses u m y ug e o r f a 23. 1-3 4 61 23 n d t , ac ny ek s m a jd mn n i” 1 , , , . io l r t
i ci ta h b ac ote nistsu so d ae en pr sd ol u a o bsd n t l mh te a ne fh e r a se hu hv be ap ie fr q din ae o sa t l te i l a iit
ddc v v u ei.t, 31 1-52-13 Pi i’ Rp t D ednsRsos euie a e e d a 21-5 72 83 2 l nf s e y o e na ’ epne t l .S , , , ; a tf l f t
t Pi i’ Co -M in o S m ay ug e (P’ Rp B e )t -11-8 Pi i’ o l nf s rs o o fr u m Jd mn “ls e y r f a11 71 l nf s a tf s t r t . l i” , ; a tf
Sp e e a B e(P’ Sp B e )t11 Pi i’ Rp t D ednsSp e e a up mnl r f “ls up r f a -0 l nf s e y o e na ’ up mnl l t i . . i” ; a tf l f t l t
B e(P’ Sp Rp B e )t - r f“ls up e y r f a14 i . . l i” .
W h hl ma os icse h e , us c o oe Mc en’ ci sis ne 2 i tei it n d u d e i jr dt n v ac ny l ml ud 8 t ti s s r n i ii r l s a e r
USC§ 51 )adus c o oe h Gv n e ’cu e l m e ud 2 USC§ 53 ... 18( ; njr dt n v te oe mns on r a l s ne 8 ... 18 a i ii r r t t ci i r .
A d cse i g a r ei b o,t Gv n e ’ o o oi m s olc o jr dt n s i u d n r t d a e w h oe mnsm int d i fr akf us c o s s e e tl l e r t t s s i ii
Mc en’ B P l ms ol nistetatoeoe d yr e N 830-006 ac ny l sC T Aci ata e r o r hnhscv e b Po s o 0-4105 a l te h r t t .1
m s b g n d TeGv n e ’ m in ek g i m s o dnl f Mc en’ C T A u t e r t . h oe mns o o se n d i a r e a o ac ny B P ae r t t i s sl i l s
ca mi epct te or nis oe d y r e o 830-006 h hw r md l w hrse o hfue r cv e b Po s .10-4105 w c e ae i t t te r t tN i e
b o O oe , 00lo u e rn d Atteh e pcid nish a sb c oh er c b f e t r220 a ms g t . sohtr se f e r ta r u e tte s tb a e e ie te t e j t
C T A( n y o J-027- WP00422 ad J-020-)teGv n e ’ B P E r Ns P00408 J-029- n WP00577 h oe mns t .W , , , r t
m in o s m ay ug e ms b g n d H wv,b h h Gv n e ’ m in o o o fr u m jd mn u e r t . o ee o te oe mns o o fr t r t t ae r t r t t
s m ay ug e cnen g h poe m hdo ap ie e o a r m n g nis n u m jd mn oc i te rp e o f pr s mn f l e a i e r ad r t rn r t a t l i n te
Mc en’ co - o o fr u m y ug e o te a esu ms b dn d ac ny rs m in os m a jd mn n h s mi e u e e e l s s t r t s t i. Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 6 ae
I akr u d .Bc go n
T saincnen 4 e r so mn s t ye ak s mo e fo N a ga n h c o oc s 6 ni f e’ u- p jce i pr d r m i r u i i t r te s it t t ca
20 20 ad rsn t o a csus ()we e ateGv n e cn nstws rp 00 01 n p e s w bs i e 1 h h, sh oe mn o ed i a poe / e t i s : tr r t t , r
frCs mt ap ie h m cad ebsdo i “ asc o v u ”n w h ad g h o u o s o pr s te e hn s ae nt t nain a e o i s n n te t a r i s r t l, t tt i
r a os p ewe Mc en Pou ste mo e by ) n K Mnfc r gC may et nh b en ac ny rdc ( i pr r ue ad B au t i o pn li i t l t h t- r a un
( eo inmnfc r -ee; n()we eayfh m cad ewsl i eod yre t fr g au t e sl )ad2 h h n o e e hn s ae g lfr u - e h e a u r lr tr t r i ib tf
t a mnud tene StsC iba Bs T d P te h A,s Mc en m nis8 r t e ne hU tdt e a ben a n r e a n s p c a ac ny a t n e t r i a - r i a r ri t l ia .
AteCu o Apa hs x a e “] pr dm cad emsb ap ie sta sh or f pe s a epi d [ mo e e hn s u e pr sd oh t l ln, i t r i t a t
teiaa ono d yo e a otem cad e a bf e ad nis fh m cad e hf l mu f u t b p d nh e hn s cn ei d n e r ote e hn s n t t i r i x te r i
cn eiu a d VW o A e c Icv U tdSts15F d 3713 (e C. 99 a bl i t . q de” P f m ia n . ne t e,7 . 12 30 Fd i 19) r , . i a 3 , . r
(t g 9USC § 50 Cs mirq rd o pr si pr d m cad e n h mne ci 1 ... 10) u o ss eu e t ap ie mo e e hn si te an in . t i a t r i r
se f d n h v uin t u,1 USC §10a Se1 USC §10( . Te t u pci i te a a o st e 9 ... 41 e 9 ... 50 ) h st e ie lt at . a at
e a ihst nain a e ater m ym hdf a a o 1 USC§ 41 a 1 A se s bse“ asc o v u”sh p a e o ov uin 9 ... 10a ) ) ) e tl r t l i r t lt . (( ( ;
a o P fA e c , 7 F dt 30139 l VW o m ia 15 . a13 35 s r 3 , .
8 Tea sefr it seinr d w gn a yr mh p t s St mn o Fc, hfc s o hnh sc o a r n ee l fo te ai ’ t e e sf a s t t t i t e a rl re a t t a wl s h r r f ad etd x bs n u n i p t u r h dpsin n aia t f s e ate b e n r a eh i, c d g n ai l, e eot ad f dv o l i is l e it i l i , rc a t io f i P l Loyte C e Oe t g Oie o By C t n GopIc( B G,o w c hi ob h h f p a n f c f ae l h g ru n “ C ” f h h ip , i ri f r r oi , . ) i Mc en ws d i o ac ny a a i s n l vi . 9 I adino asc o v u( er m ym hdf a a o) hst eloe fr n d t tt nain a e h p a e o ov uin tet u a s so h io r t l t i r t lt , at s t t f e eod ym hd w c msb cn d ei od (i te rv oh ai pr rmy i scna e os h h u e os e dn re w hh po sta n mo e a v r t , i t ir r t i t t rqe teee ao ddc v v u ad o p e v u a ht mte n y u m ysi d eus hrv s f euie a e n c mu d a et e eh e r s m a ife) t rl t l t l t i t r l . Te vscnaym hd ov uinr ()ht nain a efdnc m cad e 2 hf eeod i r e osf a a o a : 1 e asc o v u o e ia e hn s () t lt e t r t l i t l r i, ternain a e fi i rm cad e() euie a e() o p e v u ad 5te ht sc o v u os ma e hn s 3 ddc v v u 4c mu d a e n ()h a t l l r i, t l, t l, “ v lef te v us an b d e m e o ue” a se f d n 9USC§ 41 f 1. [] ui o r a e cno e e r i d r sd (s pci i 1 ... 10a) ) a h l t t n ie (( ) Se 9USC§ 41 a e 1 ... 10a )(.
A d csei g a r eib o, Mc en cn nsh tem cad etsu h e si u dnr t d a e w ac ny o edta h e hn s a se e s s e e tl l l t t r i i r Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 7 ae
“rnainv u” sd ie i r ea p ta “ ep c a ul p d . fr h T sc o a e i e nd n e vn a s t r e c a y a . . ote a t l f l t r h i tl i
m cad ewe s d o eprt n o h U tdSts p s e a st oy d t n 1 e hn s hn o fr xo a o t te ne t e ” l c t nt u r adi s 9 r i l ti i a , u ri a t io .
USC§ 41 b 1 selo 9USC§ 41 b 4 A(e n g p c a ul p d a “ e ... 10a ) ) e a 1 ... 10a ) ) ) d i n “r e c a y a ” st ( (; s ((( fi i tl i h
t a py e . . md. . oi pr d m cad e y h by t . . h sl, ec d g ol a mn . ae . fr mo e e hn s b te ue o . te ee” x u n t t t r i r lr li
i enin f ihisrneadte C.. h gs Te p c a ul p ditp a yh n ra oa r g ,nu c n o r . Fca e. h “r e c a y a ”sy clte t t le t a , h I r ) i tl i il
p ctair lc d n hiv c fr h m cad e w c iic ddw h h e r pp s r e h s e e e o te no e ote e hn s h hs n ue i te n y ae i t f t i r i, i l t t r
taai pr ri sw hCs m h n mo efe i u o s t t l t t .
A huhrnainv u itep m y m hdo v u g mo e gosud te l og t sc o a es h r a e o f a i i pr d od ne h t a t l i r t ln t r
st eteueot nainv u myb cn a d a dwe – sh e– h by ad h t u, h s fr sc o a e a e o r n c e h e a e te ue n te at a t l ti i t r r r
sl a “ l e ”Se P fA e c , 7 F dt 303 1 USC§ 41 b 2 B se ee r r a d e VW o m ia 15 . a 13-1 9 ... 10a ) ) ) e l r e et . r 3 ; ((( ;
a o 9CFR§ 5 13)1i)I sc c c m acs h p t st nainmsb “ oe l 1 ... 12 0(() v n uhi u s ne te ai ’r sc o u e c s y s . j (. r t , re a t t l l
s u n ed t esr tatep t shv n c ldd o o ete no ep c i od t c t i [] o nu h h ai ae o o ue t l w h iv c r e n re o ri z ” e t re t l r i i r
m i ie mo d is Se eeay aP l Fs osIcv U tdSts 2 CT 9 35 i m i pr ue e gnr l L e a ah n n . ne t e, 2 I 33 9 n z t t. l r i , . i a , ,
9. up2 68700 (98 a’ pr u a , 8 F d 2 (e C. 99(x a igh FSp d 9 0-1 19) f d e cr m 15. 85 Fd i 19)epi nta . , ,f i 3 . r ln t
p e i fretd aisomn utiv c p ci od t eae mo d is m ia d o na or a p t t a p a no e r en re o vdi pr ue “ o v e t tl l e re i le i i r t t t t
Cnrst ea po c vlglin n t d e Cs mt c s y cu n e etd a y og s o nc r eiee st ad o i c u o s ol e s t i r a p t e t tt i ao rt t o l ri z l e r
so d e pr sd ae o “euie a e e 1 USC§ 41 d(e n g ddc v hu b ap ie bsd n ddc v v u ”Se 9 ... 10a ) d i n “euie l a t l. ( fi t v u” Cs m hs x a e “ a cl ddc v v uiteea p citeU tdt e a e. u o s aepi d Bs a y euie a eshrs er enh ne Sts l ) t ln: i l, t l l i i a a ei prt n fh gos w h euinfr e a i m Gn a y h ddc v v ui f r mo a o ote od i ddc os oc t n e s ee l , e euie a es t ti , t t ri t . rl t t l c c a d yt t gw h u t r e n mk g e a adint ad euinfo ta a ut b s r n i a n p c ad a n c t n d t s o n ddc osr m h l le ai t i i i ri io t t p c ”Se eeay h Eey M meo h T d C m u t So dKo Ao :Cs m r e e gnr l Wa v i. l t r e b f e r e o mn y hu n w bu u o s r t a i l t t V u (.. Dp o H m ad Scr yJ y20)a 1-5 sea oD. B e a 2 a e US e’ f o e n eut u 06 t 41 e l e’ r f t l t l i l ; s fs i (u m i n d i t no “euiev u”a “ s ep cs o US by s e st oy s m a z g e ni f ddc v a e s r a r e t .. ue ls t u r ri fio t l el i r s at ddc os. euin” t ) Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 8 ae
t n e p c g. r s r ri ”1 a f i n )0
De o uh oc n tev uint u p c ds pr s mn bsdo t nain u t sc cne s h a a o st e r l e ap ie e ae nr sc o r, lt at e u a t a t
v u we te ue ad ee a “ l e ” xe i c t ni u s ne Se f a yte a e h e h by n sl r r a d ecp n e a c c m acs pci l , h l r r l r e et , t ri r t . i cl
st e u o zs h ueot nainv u ee we teby ad ee a r a di a t u a hr ete s fr sc o a e vn h e h ue n sl r et “ n at t i a t l r r lr e l e f
ea ia o oteic m acsfh s e .n c eta hr a os p ewe sc by x m t n f h c u s ne o e a. id a sh teet nh b en uh ue ni r t t l. it t li i t r
adeed n i lecte r ec a y a . 1 USC§ 41 b 2 B( mhss de) n sl i o n uneh p ca ul p d 9 ... 10a ) ) )e paeadd lr d t f i tl i” ((( ;
se lo 9CFR § 5 13)2i Aenie , h st e u o zs h ue frnain e a 1 ... 12 0(()) l ra v ytet u a hr ete s ot sc o s . j (. t t l at t i a t
v u n w h ad g r a os p ewete ueadhsl “ te asc o v u o h a e o i s n n aet nh b enh by nteee i ht nain a ef e l t tt i li i t r lr f r t l t
i pr dm cad els y prx m e –iternain a e fdnc m cad eo mo e e hn s c e apo a s ( ht sc o v u oie ia e hn s r t r i ol i t ) a t l t l r i,
os ma m cad e n a so n l e by snh U td t e o()h ddc v v u fi i r e hn s i s et ur a d ue ite ne Sts ri te euie a e l r i, l et r i a; i t l
o c mu d v u frie ia m cad e o s ma m cad e r o p e a e o dnc t l t l e hn s r i i r e hn s ” 1 USC § r i l r i. 9 ...
10ab 2 Bi()1 se lo 9CFR§ 5 13)2i A() 41 ) ) ))i 1;e a 1 ... 12 0(()) ) B ( ( ( (-i s . j (( - .
Cs mrg a osrv e ei d u acfr si ap igh “ ru s ne o h u o seut n po d d ae g dneouen p y te c c m acsf e t li i tl i ln i t t
s ets o e r iewe e o n aet nh if ecd r en r a d a yrnain a ”e t d e m l t t n h h r o r a os pn une p ci aet p tt sc o tr t li i l i le r a t .
10 We a o in a ysc a K h esl m cad eo r a d a ynh U td hn fr g p t (uh s B e ) es e hn st aet p tite ne e r r l r i le r i Stssc a Mc en B G Cs madhI en Rvne ev e“R”sa –tes t e(uhs ac ny C ) u o s nten ra eeu S i ( S h e a a a l / , t t l rc I ) r l t i ter – h s m ga ac t n g h cr c p ctateUS mo eso d a t te n hoy te a e o: se a i te o e r e h h .. pr r hu py o h l ri n rt i t i t l r a do in ntfrh m cad e H wv,Cs madhI S aei e ncnen et fr g e i o a e hn s o ee u o s nte R hv df e oc s le e ty t t r i. r t fr t r. Cs m gn a ys oc nd h tet e p c myb ai cl l ws at m i ie u o s ee l i cne e ta h std r e a e rfil o, o s o i m t rl r t a i ti a y n z cs m d is u o te mo e m cad e I cn a, h I S y cl i cnend h u o s ue de n hi pr d e hn s n o rs te R tp a ys oc e ta t t t r i. t t il r t tet e p c my e rfil h hs taa o e pr o ote rf gn a d y h s e h std r e a b ai cl i , o h l w oin f h pot ee t b te a a i ti a y g t r t i re l oteiapou wl eaa e n h U tdSts fhf l rdc i btxb i te ne t e n t l l i a. 11 Test e eu e ta “ahv u r e e t i c uei o () h i ue fr h t u rq rs h ec a e e r d o n l s ( ri ta s sd o at i t l fr a ) i t c masn ms r a [t m cad e h ws xo e t teU tdStst r bute o p io [ u] et ] o e hn sta a epr d o h ne t e a o ao h r t le r i t t i a t s m t m a te mo e m cad e 1 USC §10ab 2 B sea o 9 CFR § a ei e s h i pr d e hn s ” 9 ... 41 ) ) ) e l 1 ... t r i. ((( ; s 12 0(())C 5 13)2i ) . j (( . Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 9 ae
Te n rr a v N et 1 CFR§ 5 13)1 po d i r ea p t hI ep tie o s o 9 ... 12 0(() rv e ne vn a: t et t . l i, l t r
( I ep tien e1. . h eCs m hsdu s buteueo i n rr a v o . . [We u o s a ob ao h s f ) t et t r t t t p c “n i ua e o ce ternain a ew hufr eiq r ”. . r e ads nb t acp ht sc o v u i o u h nu y] . i l t a t l t t t r i, Cs m wl x m ee vnapc o ht nain n u ntewynw c u o s i ea i r ea se sf e asc o ic d gh ai h h t l n l t t t r t , li i te ue ad ee ogn e h r o m cl et n ad h wy nw c te h by n sl ra zte c m e i r a os n te ai h h h r lr i i r a li i p c i qein wsa ie a i od t d e m e we ete et nh r e n us o a r vd t n re o e r i i t r r t n h h h r a os p tr li i if ecd h p c n une te r e l i.
() n rr a v n e .Iii so n h te ue ad ee a huh i I ep tie o 2 fts h w ta h by n sl,l og i t et t t r lr t r a d by r madsl oec o e a i te w en r a dt s wl et , u fo n e t ah t r s f hy e o et , h i le l h r t le i l d mnr e h tep c hsn be if ecdb te et nh ,ad h e os a ta h r e a o en n une y h r a os p n te tt t i t l li i t nainv u wlb acp d Itep c hsbe st d na mne r sc o a e i e ce e f h r e a en el i a t l l t. i te anr cn s n w hh nr ap c g rccsfhids yn us o, rw hh ost t i te o m ri paie o enu ri qein o i te ie t l in t t t t t wyh sl st s r efr a so ue wor n r a doi,t swl ate ee el p cs os et by s h a o et t h m h i l r te i l r e t le i l e os a ta h p c hs o en n une bte e t nh . d mn r e h te r e a n be i lecd y h r a os p tt t i t f li i
(iI ep tie o 3 Iii so n h te r es dqa t esr i) n rr a v n e. fts h w ta h p ci aeu e o nu i t et t t i t e rcv yo a cs p s pot w c i eu a nt tei m oe l pot eoe f l o s l a rf h hs q v e o h f ’ v a rf r l t u i i ilt r s rl i razd v a ersnt e e o ot m ( g o a ana bs)i s e o eie oe rp e a v p id fi ee. n n nu a s n a s f l r e ti r ., l i, l m cad e fh s m c s o k d h wu d mnr eh te r e a n e hn s ote a el s ri , i o d e os a ta h p c hs o r i a n ts l tt t i t be if ecd en n une l .
1 CFR§ 5 13)1i(i( mhss de) 9 ... 12 0(())i)e pae add . l (-i .
A ht m ote vn a su Mc en ws d i o o By C t n GopIc t e e fh ee st se ac ny a ai s n f ae l h g ru n t i t i , l vi r oi , .
( B G,w hepn bi frB G i preprai t s2 K wss bsei N a ga “ C ” i rsos it o C ’ mo/xo c vi . B ae a ihdn i r u ) t ily s t t t ie1 tl ca
i 19 a ai s n fB G ote pci proe f rdc g cep a ewo mn wa n 97 s d i o o C, rh se f ups o pou n “ha v u o ” es e . vi f ic i l l r
A b h Mc en adK w ei s n o B G w c wswo y we b Rb t By ) s o ac ny n B e d i os f C ( h h a h l o nd y oe I ae, t l r vi i l r. r
i s n su dh Mc en adK a r a d nt soproe o h v uint u. e t ud p eta ac ny n Br et e iefr upssf e a a o st eSe i i t t l e l e ti t lt at
1 USC§ 41 g 1 9 ... 10a ) ) ( (.
K wsh o ymnfc r o mn s t yeak snN a ga we e o n fr B ate n au t e f e’ u- pjce i i r u( h h r o o l a ur s it t ca tr t
12 N ig h “Mc en d n m ni sp a acu ig eod fo B Gad o n ta ac ny i o a t n ea t con n rcrs r m C n t t l d t ia re t awy a e o B G bh f teGv n e ’ b e gn a y e r o Mc en adB G l as c d n C ’ ea, h oe mns r f ee l r et ac ny n C t s l” r t i s rl f l j n ya “Mc en B G Se e’ B ea4. Te a e ovn oif l wd e. o t , s ac ny C. e D. r ft n. h s m cne ins o o e h e il l / ” fs i 5 t l r Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 0
epr oh U tdt e; n K hd o u o e o e hn Mc en B G K tue s d xo tte ne Sts ad B a n cs m st r a ac ny C. Bhs xt t i a ) t r ht l / ie
s e t s v Mc en B G Mc en B G h pd ur wm e a t K i N a ga ol o e e ac ny C. ac ny C s pe c a a rl o Bn i r u ly r l / l / i t ti s ca ,
we K a e b d h m n ray o wa s t ye ak s K r und h a e b d h e B s m e te i o ed- - e u- p jce. B e re te s m e r s l t t r it t t s l
g mn d el bc t Mc en B G n h U tdSts Mc en B G hn o te a e s i c y ak o ac ny C i te ne t e r t rt l / i a . ac ny C te s d h l / l
jce t i UScs m s n u n r ae sc a Sa ad Ceny ak sot .. u o e, c d gei r uh s e s n J Pne t s t r i l i tl s r .
Te r efrK’s et Mc en B Gw e os b K. n ed h p csw e h p cs o B a so ac ny C e n e y B Is a te r e e i sl l / r tt t , i r
s b P l Loy B G C e Oe t gOiea ht m wo aete o anabde e y hi ob C ’ h f p a n f c t e e h bsdh m n nu ug s t ip , s i ri f rt i , l t
p p e b sv a n v u sn u n B G V e rs e o Mnfc r g n K’ P n r a d y ee l d i a ic d g C ’ i P i n f au t i ad B l t er riidl li s c ed t a un s a
Mng.1 A huhK ws oepc do an pot u ntet tu paetws xe e aae 3 l og B a n xe et e arf dr ghs r p hs i aepc d r t t t r i i a- , t
–we oe t n bgnn 98 tateK wu tr aesnb potw h ae ya. hn p a os eai 19 –h h B o dun raoa e rf i i f w e s ri t l l i tn r
Y,r mht m K c m ecd rdc oi 19 u i t esd p a osn 07n pot e fo te e B o mne pouinn 98 nl cae oe t ni 20 o rf t i t ti ri , i
ee m e azd Ide K oe tdt lsfr v y e oi e s ne v a rl e ned B p a aa o oee ya ft xt c r t ii . , re s r r s ie .
M Loy ee h e r sdh p csh Mc en B G a K o y w e v te r ob nv te s a ete r eta ac ny C p d B n ti oe h . r lsi i t l / i l c r
cu e fK’l e m – ne o e m a eJ y 99 u b o te m cad etsu ws or o B i t e oc s mi e f r u 19 b e r h e hn s ai e a s s fi t t l t fe r i s
i pr dn 00 01adhn ne g nn 05 Mroe ds t K’rcr ossie mo ei 20 20 nte oc aa i 20 t / , i . o v, epe B eod f u a d e r i s tn
lse K ws of eo eie n od fo Mc en B G Nrwsr e v oet ay o s B a n r t dc n ayre r m ac ny C. o a p c ee pno n s, te l r l / i r
o e cu e o epoe,r n o efr ong iin ewe K ad Mc en B G K f r on r f rrcs oayt ro mf eoa o b en B n ac ny C. B f/ t - f s h tt t l /
wseu et f fl v y re p cd y Mc en B Gado o oth p cta ws e arq rdo ui ee od l e b ac ny C, nt d s a e r eh as i ll r r a l / t i t t
b M Loy h C e Oe t gOie o B G y r ob te h f p a n f c f C. . , i ri f r
I t s epc Mc en B G da ns w h K df e fo Mc en B G n h rse, ac ny C ’ eig i i t l / s l t B i e d r m ac ny C ’ fr l / s
13 O ala oeocs n M Loylo os tdw h h C e F aclOie o ntes n ca o r ob a cnue i te h f i n a f c f t i, . s l t i n i f r BG C. Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 1
da nsw hXCl aD m ia g mna e b cn a o ad tes ma cn a o t eig i - e ( o i cn a e s m y o rc r n o ri i r o rc r o l t l n r t s l t t) h l t ts
w c Mc en B Gws or a d Tu fr x m e we Mc en B Go XClh h h ac ny C a n et . hs oea p, hn ac ny C t d - ete i l / t le , l l / l l
p c ta Mc en B G ws wl g opy o ap t u r t eojce XCldc e r e h ac ny C a ii t a fr ai l s l f ak, - e e dd i t l / ln rc a y t l i
we e o n t are o rdcte od a e d e m igwe eicu epct tr a h h r o o g t poue h gos f r e r i n h h t o d xe o un tr t e t t n tr l t
pot n h bs e . U ieK,XCl n Mc en B G o e cn a o w ere o rf o te u ns n k B - e ad ac ny C ’ t r o rc r e f t i i s l l l / s h t ts r e
r e od sr mh c may ffr x m ea r e f rd y Mc en B Gws o l w e c re fo te o pn i o ea p, p c o e b ac ny C ato o. jt r ,, l i fe l /
F a ys m oteK m cad etsu ws mo e a ee l O oe 20 we i l , o e fh B e hn s a se ai pr df r a y c b 00 hn nl r i i t t r t r ,
K’ o e on y N a ga– a rn d ee c r sts netene t e C iba Bsh m cu r –i r u wsg t bn i ayt uud hU tdSts a ben t ca ae fi a r i a - r
Bs rd P te h A ( C T A.Se 9...§ 72b(s nN a gaae g l fr a nT e a n s p c “ B P ” e 1 USC 20()lt g c au sl i e o i a r ri t ) ii i r ib
ds nin s ee c r on y ne c f c v O.2 00 e r ia o ne te e ga o a bn i aycu r ud t f t e c ,20) t m t nud h i t fi t rA,e ei t ;D e ni r
C iba a nA,6 Fd Rg 0 3 ( c 1 20) g n n N a gabn i ayt u a benBs c 5 e e , 6 O. 0 00 (r t gi r u ee c r sts r i t . .6 2 t , ai c a fi a ,
ad o f n T U,e eie c , 00 Ud teA,l i e odfo “ee c r n md y gH S S f c v O.220) ne h c e g l gosr m bn i ay ii ft t . r t ib fi
cu r s sc a N a gamyb i pr d n te ne t e u - e e gnr l 1 oni ” uh si r u a e mo e i o hU tdStsd yre e eeay 9 te ca t t i a t f .S l
USC § 720 (s nc t n onis n gos sl i e od yrera mn neA ) ...§ 20-3lt ge a cu r ad od ae g l fru - e t t e ud c. ii ri te ib tf e t rt
I p t u rtee hn s l i e osc d yre ra mn n ue“pa lrc s ta nai l , hm cad ee g l fr uh u - e t t e ic dsap eai e” h rc a r i ib tf e t l r tl t
w ea e b d n C T Abn i ay on yfo fb cwo yfr ead uitene e s m e ia B P ee c r cu r “ m ar sh l o mdn c nhU td r s l fi t r i l t i
Sts ad e hn mo ed el i ohU tdSts ne sbed g 82 0 0 f h t e” n w etei pr d rc y n tene t e ud uha n 90 0 8 o te a r t i t t i a r i ..
H S S4– ht i c sf a o fr h m cad etsu h e w c i n i d p e Se T U 1 teaf l si t n ote e hn s ai e e , h hs o n i u. e rf a i ci r i s r i t st
14 H S S uha n 90 0 8 cv s[ rc s. a e b d bodnwo o n a T U sbed g 82 0 0 oe “ ]i e..s m e arai h er p t i .. r atl s l l i r ofb c e c moe ste rdc oteU tdSts w c ( w e xo e i cn t n f ar a d o pnn, h pou f h ne t e h h a e epr d n odi it t t i a, i ) r t io ray o a e b w hufr efb cin()hv n lste py c ie i i sc ed fr s m y i o u h ar a o b ae o o h r hs a dnt n uh s l t t t r it , t t i i l ty ai e b cagifr, hp oo e w eadchv n be avnei v u o mrvd rc s y hneno msaert ri , n( ae o en dacdn a er poe tl h s ) t l i i cn t n bod xe b b n a e b d n ecpb oe t nic e a oh a e b n odi ara ecp y e g s m e ad xe y p a osn dnl te s m y io t i s l t ri i tt s l poe sc a c a n lb cig n p n n ” Sbed g 82 0 0 H S S rcs uh sl n g ur a n ad a t g uha n 90 0 8 T U. s e i , it ii . i .., Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 2
1 USC 20()2 AiI; S o ())C 8SbhI H S S ea orc min 9...§ 73b ) )))U .N e7bi h , uc I T U;sel Po a a o ( ( (( . t (, .9 ., s l t
75 o O oe , 00 o m e e te ne t e C iba Bs T d P te h A, 31 f c b t r220 t I p mn hU tdSts a ben a n r e a n s p c l t i a - r i a r ri t
Fd e 9 2 5 33 O., 00( o f n H S S o n ueUS N e ()) C 9 e.Rg , 9 9 3 ( c 420) md y g T U t ic d .. o 7bi h 8 .5 3 , , t ii l t (, . ,
SbhI H S Se eieO., 00 uc I T U,f c v c 220) ., ft t .
Prun o rqe fo Mc en Cs mssedd q din fh m cad e u a t aeus r m ac ny u o s upnel u a o ote e hn s s t t l , t iit r i
ai u pn n te eo t no v iu v uin etd susic d g– np t u r– t s e ed g h rs u o f a os a a o- l e i e n u n i ai l s i li r l t ra s , li rc a
Mc en’ ci ta Cs m ueo “ asc o v u” oap ie h gos wu b ac ny l m h u o s s f t nain a e t pr s te od o d e l s a t t ’ r t l a l
iaport bcueacr nt Mc en)hr a os p ewe K ad Mc en B G nprp a eas(cod go ac ny eet nh b en B n ac ny C ie i l t li i t l /
hdn unete r e Mc en ageta ud tei u s ne tem cad e hu aif ecdh p c ac nyrudh, ne h c c m acs h e hn s so d l i. l t r r t , r i l
b ap ie bsd n ddc v v u ” e pr sd ae o “euie a e 1 a t l.5
Cs mrv wd up mnlno min n wrse s u mtd y Mc en te u o se e e sp e e a fr a o ad okhe sb ie b ac ny hn t i l ti t t t l ,
rqe e i en av er mCs m Haqa e. R y go aSp me 20 lt t eus d n ra d c fo u o s edu t s e i n e e b 01 ee o t t l i t rr ln t r tr
Cs mi w c Mc en’ cus hdt e ta “]r h 19 ya”p cs o K’ u o s n h h ac ny one a std h, [ ote 99 e, r e fr B t i l s l a t f r i s
m cad e hd be e a ihd “ t a m ln h ng iin” w h B G Cs m e hn s a en s bse a e r s eg eoa os i r i tl fr ’ t tt t C, u o s t
Haqa e cn ue –bsdo te“ ru s ne ote a ” e – h te et nh edu t s oc dd ae n h c c m acs f h s e ts ta h r a os p rr l i t l t t li i
b we K ad Mc en B G a n “ f ec” n r e Cs m Haqa e te fr e en B n ac ny C hd oi l ne o p cs u o s edu t sh eo t l / nu i . t rr r e
15 I adino upn nl u a o o h 20 ad 01 nis Cs ma o upne n d t t ssed g q dinf e 00 n 20 e r , u o sl ssedd io i iit t te t s l u a o o e r s md i 19 ( h h r n ai u i t s c o) Cs m ep se i i t n f ni ae n 99 w c a o ts e n h ain u o s xr sd q di te i e t s i t . t e rs vin ao te dqayo Mc en B G dc mnt n n se ig ro i te ee a os bu h aeuc f ac ny C ’ ou e a o ad e m e r n h rt t l / s ti n rs c may ddc v v u srase s Nn h e , h aec ui al aq ecd o h o pn’ euie a e p dhe. oe e s te gny l m e cu se t te s t l e t tls t ty i c may ci w h epct te19 e r s n ap ie te bsdo ddc v v u o pn’ l m i rse o h 99 ni ad pr sd h m ae n euie a e s a t t te a t l, cig so aefCs m prp sne o odca ef a o H wv,Cs mep s y i n a hr g o u o s o e on t cnu v i cin o ee u o s xr s t t t t r l t ri t . r t el cu oe Mc en B G t h t m ta ci s o sbeun ya wu b rv wd n a ind ac ny C atei e h l m fr usqe e s o d e e e e ad t l / t a t r l i poe e bsd nh r us n v m i.Se eeay e’ B ea2 D. Rp B ea rcs d ae ote sb a ie et e gnr l D. r ft; e’ e y r ft s i tt rs l fs i fs l i 2. n.3 Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 3
av eta h poebs fr pr s mn ws asc o v u p s d t n Se Q 445 d sdh terp a soap ie e at nain a el adi s e H 587 i t r i a t r t l u io .
(M c 2 20) D . B e Eh M Acr n y al u a o Cs m ap ie te a h 5 04 ( e’ r f x ) cod g , ti i t n u o s pr sd h r , fs i , . . il q di , t a
m cad e nh bs ot nain a eth u t a e a e e d n u n a a onfr e hn s ote a s fr sc o v u a e n v us s n r , c d g n mu o r i i a t l t i l teili t
te a e o USc moe s D isw ese e a h v iur e d iefo te p ia e h v usf .. o pnn. ue e a s dt e a osa s e vdr mh apcb l t t r ss t r t r l l
sbed gi H S SCa e 6 e gnr l Sbed g 82 0 0 H S S uha nsn T U hp r 2 e eeay uha n 90 0 8 T U. i t .S l i ..,
Te a e Mc en fe fu po s, ee t gt ci fr pr s mn bsd n h e t , ac nyi d or r e srt a n i l m o ap ie e ae o r fr l l t t i ri s a a t
ddc v v u adi oeotepo s, seig ci frd yrera mn ud te euie a e n n n f h r e sa r n a l m o u - e t t e ne h t l, , t t st a tf e t r
C T A Cs m dn d Mc en’ po s, n t s c o ese B P. u o s e e ac ny r e sad h ain nud t i l s tt i t .
I t n ad fRv w I a dr o e e .S i
W hepc o Mc en’ci so u - et a mnud teU tdt e C iba i rse t ac ny l mt d yre e e ne h ne Sts a ben t t l sa tf rt t r i a - r
Bs T d P te h A ( C T A ,h Gv n e sesi m s frakf u e mt a n r e a n s p c “ B P ” te oe mn ek d i a o c osb c ae i a r ri t ) r t s sl l j t tr
jr dt n soh m ot ote nistsu Se eeay einI A. i r U CT us c o atte a r y fh e r a se e gnr l sc o I.. a n a SI i ii ji te i . l t I 1, f ;
R1()1 Te xtne f u e mt jr dt ns trso iq r e, g S e C . 2b ) h e s c osb c ae us c oi ah h dnu y ee. t l o (. ie j t t r i ii e l i .S . , e .
v Cies oaBt Ev o mn 53US8 9-5 19) We sb c mt jr dt n . iznfr ee n rn e , 2 .. 3 49 (98 h e u e ae us c o t tr i t , . r j t t r i ii
i caegdtep t ivk g us c o ba tebre o po n i e s ne Tu e s hlne h a y no n jr dt n e s h udn f rv gt xt c rs d l , r i i ii r i s ie . t
I erin n v U tdt e 69.d 1916(e C. 01 seloc u v Gn a n g t , c . ne Sts 5 F 15 13 Fd i 21) e a M N t. ee l t ao I . i a , 3 , . r ; s t r
M o Acp neCr 28US1819 13) NrkHdoCnd Icv U tdSts o r ce ac op 9 .. 7 8 (96 o ts t ., , ; s yr aaa n . ne t e , . i a,
42F d 3715 (e C. 06 7 . 14 35 Fd i 20) 3 , . r .
Mroe i s x mita“th U td t e asv e n s m uer m u sv o v , i a o ach ‘]e ne Sts s oe i , i mnfo s t ae e rt i t t [ i a, rgi i
aicne so e ud., n [ a tee m oi cne t b sei ay ord ieh st osn t b se.. adt t ht s ft osn o e udn n cu e nta t h] r s t t f t
cu’jr dt n o n ri te u. U tdStsv Mce,45 US 55 58 18) ors us c o t e e a h s t ” ne t e . i hl 4 .. 3 3 (90 t i ii tt n i’ i a t l , Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 4
(u igU tdSts .Se wo, 1 US 54 56 14) se loleo C v U td qo n ne t e v h od 32 .. 8 8 (91;e a B pr o . ne t i a r , ) s u t . i
Sts 53F d 3417 (e C. 08 Gog o nS e Cr v U tdSts81F d t e, 3 . 17 38 Fd i 20) ere w t l op . ne t e 0 . a 3 , . r ; t e . i a, 2
10 11 (e C. 96 Tu we – s e – w v osv e n m u t i ai u 38 32 Fd i 18) hs h e a h e a a e f oe i i mn ysts e , . r . , r r ir rg i s,
te agaeotet u ms b sil cnre ad n a b uis eo e i fvro h lnug f h st e u et c y os ud n ay m g t rs vd n ao f at t rt t , i ie l
i mn y F Av Coe __ US __ __ 12S C 14 14 (02(t gU td m ut i. A . op , __ .. __ __ 3 . t 41 48 21) ci r , , . , i n ne i
Sts. Wl m, 1 US5751 19) Z tkCr v U td t e 62 .d 3911 t e v ii s 54 .. 2 3 (95; oe op . ne Sts 7 F 10 38 a la , ) l . i a, 3 ,
(e C. 02 H tgFos nlIcv U tdSts 21F d 8 71 Fd C. 02 Fd i 21) a o odI ’ n . ne t e 9 . 79 9 (e i 20) . r ; r t, . i a , 3 , . r .
W hepc o Mc en’ C T Al m oc n ghfue r s oe d yPo s i rse t ac ny B P ci cne i te or ni cv e b r e t t l s a rn te r tt
N 10-4105ta w emd p ot O oe 220 ( ef c v d e fh C T A s o 830-006h e ae r ro c b , 00t e eie a ote B P a . t r i t r h ft t
t gosr mN a ga teGv n e mvsoi m soflrt st al m pnw c o odfo i r u ,h oe mn oet d i fra u ot e ci uo h h ca ) r t s s i e a a i
ri cn e rn dSe eeay einI A. i r U CTR1()5 O sc am in ee a b g t . e gnr l sc o I.. b n a SI . 2b ) n uh o o lf ae l t I 1, f ; (. t ,
te mvn hs h bre o d mnrig h n ci hs ent e Se eeay BC h oa ate udn f e os a n ta ol m a be std e gnr l 5 . t tt t a a . l
W g &A Ml , ee l rcc ad rcdr § 37p 466 (d d20)“W g & rh i t . ie Fd a P t e n Poeu 15 p 5-2 3 e 04( r h lr r ai e , . . it
Ml ” Fr e te or ms“os ute o pi ite g ms ao b ttel nf ie ) u h ,h cu u cnreh c m a tnhl h o fvr l oh pi i, l r. t r t t t ln it t ae a tf
acp t aea os sread r wlraoa en rnei fvr fh pi i. I r Bl ce i l gin atu n d a esnb if ecsnao otel nf” ne i ts l t , a l l e a tf l
o Ld gT n m s n n Poe igSs mP e Lia o, 8 F d 3313 (e C. f a n r s i i ad rcs n y e a n i gin 61 . 12 31 Fd i i a so s t tt t t 3 , . r
21)selosco vIb , 5 US6268 20) A ooO C v U tdSts24 02 e a Ah f . qa 56 .. 6 7 (09 mc i o . ne t e 3 ; s rt l , ; l . i a,
F d 3417 (e C. 00 1 Tu te ups oa m in oi m s oflrt st a . 17 36 Fd i 20) 6 hs h proe f o o t d i fra u ot e 3 , . r . , t s s i e a
ci i n t “ s v ] cn s b we te ais butea s r h sb a ie m i o l ms o o r o [ a o e e en h p t ao h fc ote us n v et f a t el e tt t re t t tt rs
16 Otetehn a o pi ’“]rab eet sfh e mn oa as oain nh o r ad c m a t [ h da rca o el e sf cuef c o h , l ns t e r il t e t t , spo e b m e oc sr st mn, o osf c”o asyhrq r mn ote ee l upr d y e cn uoyt e e sd n uiet si teeu e e s fh Fd a t r l a t t f tf i t r R e Ah o vIb , 5 USa68 Mroe “ eee h a or msacpatu a u s sc f . qa 56 ..t 7 l. rt l . o v,t tn ta cu u ce srel e r h t t t t t l otel gin cnie i a o pi iiapcb t lg cn u os I. fh aea os o a d n c m a ts np ia e oea oc s n ” d l t tn ln l l l li . Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 5
te nn mvnscs ”5 W g & Ml § 36p34 H wv, des vt “ s h h[o- oa ’ ae B r h t] . i t ie 15 . 5 o ee i os e eot t e lr , . rt r et
fr asf c nyotet e e ote l m ori , caeg g te eater ote o m ui ec f h st mn f h ci fr ee ” hln n “ lg hoy f h l fi a t a lf l i h l
c m a t I. Avne C d vsu rSs m Ic v S mdL eSs m Ic 98F d o pi . d dacd a i ac a y e s n . c e i y e s n, 8 . l n” ; ro l t , . i f t , . 2
15 16 (e C. 93(x a igh m inoi m s oflrt st ci i ds nd 17 10 Fd i 19)epi nta o ot d i fra u ot el ms e ge , . r ln t t s s i e a a i
“ a o te ort e m a aintaa f a yl wd n h rea p m e ad eie t l wh cu ol i t c os h r al f e i te lg r i s n ds nd ol t i ne t t e tl a i l e s t
t fl. Asc “n a o pi tasts p u b ci freesr vssc] m in oa” s uh o y c m a th t e al s l l mori uv e[uha o o i) , l ln t a ai e a lf i t
t d m s Ah o vIb, 5 USa697 oi i . sc f . qa 56 ..t 71 s s” rt l .
F a y b hp t s ek u m y ug e o c t nci s Segnr l sc o i l , o ai se s m a jd mn n e a l m e eeay ein nl t re r t ri a . l t
I.. c n a ad s n Gv n e ’ m inos m ayug e at c t n nis nt d I A. i r (dr s g oe mns o ofr u m jd mn so e a e r e ie I 1, f ei r t t r t ri t e tl
t d yrera mnud C T A sc o I.. i r(drs n Gv n e ’ m in o o u - et t e ne B P ) einI A,n aad s g oe mns o o fr tf e t r ; t I 2 f ei r t t
s m ay ug e cnen gpoe m hdo ap ie e )sc o I., n a ad s n u m jd mn oc i rp e o f pr s mn; einI Bi r (dr s g r t rn r t a t t I f ei
Mc en’ co - o o cnen g a e;U CTR 5 1 S m ay ug e i a ao d ac ny rs m in oc i s m ) SI . 6 8 u m jd mn s fvr l s s t rn . r t e
17 Te i a p a hr y ote rpsinh am inoi m s oflrt st a h es m e u ot frh poot ta o ot d i fra u ot e r l t i io t t s s i e a ci msbfe b o teev ef rsos ela n o e w etmsbt a dhog l m u e ld e r hs i oaepn v p d g t ri , u e e etruh a t i fe rc i e i ; h si t rt s m o e vhl sc a a m in ojd mn o tep a nso a m in o s m ay o e t r e c, uh s o o fr ug e n h l d g r o o fr u m h ie t t ei t r jd mn Se SI R1()st gh “ m inseig n o h ] e ne[s dnR e ug e . e U CT . 2b( a nta a o o a r n ayf e d ess i ei u t ti t t st t[ f lt l 1() ms b md b o p a n i arsos e p a n i a o e” Avne 2b] u e ae e r l d g f t fe ei epn v l d g s l wd ; dacd i ei l ) C d vsu rSs m , 8 F dt 10 n ig h Fd a R e a hr e e na t fe a i ac a y e s 98 . a 16 (o n ta ee l u s u o z d edn oi ro l t 2 t t r l t i f t l m inoi m s b o fig rsos el a n” 5 W g & Ml § 37p48 Ud o ot d i “e r i n aepn v p ed g ; B r h t s s f el i i ) i t ie 15 . 0 ne lr , . r tei u s ne ot s aeh wv, mks oi e newe ete pci ci stsu h c c m acs fh cs o ee i ae n df ec h h h se f l m a se r t i , rt fr tr ic a i a aa zd hog te eso a m in od m s oflr t st a l mo a m in o r n ye truh h ln f o o t i i fr a u ot e ci r o o fr e l t s s i e a a t s m ayug e . Te u o es h s m e h wy u m jd mn h o c mite a ei e a r t t tr . 18 Te Gv n e sge s h te“rs m ino cr c e ”aahs o Cs m h oe mn ugs ta h p u p o f o e ns t ce t u o s r t t t e t rt s t t ’ dcin ouernainv u t ap ie h sb c m cad e SeD. B e a 1 e s t s t sc o a e o pr s te u e e hn s e e’ r f t 0 io a t l a jt r i. fs i (u igVW o A e c 15.dt 32 n igh a p s m in f o e ns aahso qo n t P f m ia 7 F a14 (o nta “r u p o ocr c e t cet r , 3 t t e t rt st eey a u d e m a oncsayo upra ap ia )e pa s de) H wv,h v fc a e ri t nee rt spo n pr s ”( mhs add. o ee te r t l t ni s t al i ) r st oy rs m in f o e nsta Cs m dcin e o ud 2 USC§ 69 )1 t u r p u p o o cr c e h u o s e s s n y ne 8 ... 23( () at e t rt s t t ’ io j r a hs o o e rf cate u m yug e s g o poed g bcue u m yug e a n fr oe e th s m a jd mn t e f rce ns eas s m a jd mn c ft r ta i , r t my e n rd n ite i n gn n d p e s o n m e afc– n ite i n sc a b e e o yfh es o eu ei u at ay a rla ad fh es o uh te l r i st ti t , r Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 6
poeu l e c “ scrteu, pey niepn v d e m a o o[nain C o x rcdr dv et eu hjs sed adnxes e e r i t nfa] c o ” e t a i o e t i t ni t . le
Cr v C rt 47US373718)qo n Fd R C..) e a oS e s ah n Ic op . a e , 7 .. 1 2(96(u ig e . i P1 sel . tt , t . v ; s wa Fs os n t i , .
v Pn l K t n C , 3 F d 5016 (e C. 97 Ide teCu o Apa hs . anl nt g o 83 . 16 52 Fd i 18) ned h or f pe s a i ii . 2 , . r . , t l
hld u m yug e a a s u r poeu ..o v d nee ay xestte ais ae s m a jd mn s “a t y rcdr .t ao uncs r epneoh p t i r t la e i s re
ad ws f ul a o o tejr poe adjdi rsu e ” n a eu ti t n f h uy rcs n u cl eor s t l izi s ia c. B mg B m a a a e r r r
Msh efb kA v Mr a Mc n y L ., 3 Fd 3 85 Fd C. 94 ac nn r G. u t ah e , t 71 2 81 3 (e i 18) i ai a ir d , . r .
Nv te s ud U CTR e 6 u m yug e iaport o yweteeod ee h e , ne SI u 5 s m a jd mn s prp a n hnhrcr r ls r l , r t ie l
e dne–“ c d gdpsin dc mn,e c o cl s rd no min aia t o v ec i i l i eot s ou e s l t n a y t e ifr a o f dvs r nun io , t er i l o t , f i
dc rin s p a os., d s os n roa r as e,ad o e m e a ” e a ihs e a t s t ut n .am s n i e g oy n w s n] t r a rl –s bse l a o , i li . ii , t r t r[ h ti s t l
ta “ e i n gn n d p ea t ay a rl a ”ad h mv gp t “ e ie t h t r s o eu e i u s o n m e afc n te o n a y i nt d o t he i st ti t i r s tl
jd mna amt ol w U CTR5( &c 1 A selo C o x47USa322 ug e s ae fa. SI . 6 ) ( () ) e a t tr ” a ) (; s e t , 7 ..t 2-3 le ;
Ad sn .L e yLbyIc, 7 US 22 274 (96 I adin we a m in o ne o v i r ob n 47 .. 4 4-8 18) n d t , h e o o fr r bt , . , . io r t
s m ayug e ife adrp l spo e a av s p t my o e uo m e e a u m jd mn s ld n poe y upr d n de e a y a n rs pn e dnl r t i r t, r r t t r is
t d e i T te o r y h ops g a yms“t ] o aiu r as fm e a ite o e a t o h cn a , e po n p t u c[ t p t l p t o a rl nh f t. tr t i r t ie rc a r ti s
rcr”o s bste p sne f gn n d p e w rn nt a U CTR5(. Ad f eodt e a ihh “r ec oa eu e i u ” a a igrl SI . 6 ) n i tl e i st r t i. c ,
a a y flt poe y drs ao e p t’ a ein f a,taa ein f a my e p t “ i o rp l ad s n h a y s r o ofc” h s r o ofc a b r as r e t r r s st t t st t
fc a d p ete Cs m de n ne te eet f n p s m in See. U v s a u i u, hn u o s os o ed h bn i o ay r u p o e, g n e a tl st t t f e t . . , i rl E c o c Icv U td t e, 1 F d 8 429 (e C. 97(x a igh st oy l t n s n . ne Sts 12 . 48 9-3 Fd i 19)epi nta t u r er i , . i a 3 , . r ln t at p s m in f o e ns “ais o o e s o us os fa ” R l b d Icv U td r u p o o cr c e c r n fr at qein ol w ; oe l e n . ne e t r t s re c t ) lr a , . i Sts 12.d 8 438(e C. 97( a ntap s m inf o e ns“ i e vn t e, 1 F 41 8-4 Fd i 19)st gh r u p o ocr c e i r l a a 3 , . r ti t e t rt s sre t we te i n fc a d p e ewe te ais ;Go mn Mg LPv U tdSts 6 h e h es o a u i u b en h p t ” od a f, ... ne t e , 9 r r tl st t re ) . i a F d 0 58 Fd C. 95(o nta asn a u d p e ewe p t s“ ers m in . 55 0(e i 19)n igh, be fc a i u b en ai ,t p u p o 3 , . r t t t tl st t re h e t o cr c e i n r ea ” Ide teCu o Apa dcin nw c teGv n e f o e ns s o e vn ) ned h or f pe s e s o h h h oe mn r t s t l t. , t l io i r t ris VW o A e c – i n iv v apl e e e o a e s n n u m y ug e . ee – P f m ia d o no e pea rv w f dci o s m a jd mn l r d t l lt i io r t VW hd oe orlSe P fA e c , 7 F dt 32 n ig h dcin fCu o P a gnt t a e VW o m ia 15 . a 13 (o n ta e s o or f i. r 3 t t io t I enin T d ud rv wwsed e “] l w g t a ) n ra oa r e ne e e arne d[ o oi arl. t t l a r i r fl n i ” Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 7
de e “n su d o proe otem in U CTR5( ()9 e md ud p e fr upss f h o o ” SI . 6 )2 1 i t t . e .
Ui al teuc o o hjdeths m ayug e s g “ n h me t w g l m e ,hfninf eug a e u m jd mn t ei o i s fo e h t ty t t t r ta s t l i
te v ec ad e r iehtu otemt b t d e m ewe ete i a eu esu h e dne n d e m ter h fh ae u o e r i h h h es gn ni e i t n t tr t t n tr r i s
frrl Ad snv L e yLby 47 USa 29 Teqeinte “ n we e[ ot a” ne o . i r ob, 7 .. t 4 h us o hn i o h h a i. r bt . t , , s t tr
p t’ pofwll m e bfud ov c g r e us e.. R h,h qeins n a y ] ro i ui al e on cn n n o p sa v.. a e te us oi o y r s l t ty ii r i tr t l
we ete ais ae rofrh rl m.. u hh arls edd 1 Mo ’ Fd a h h h p t hv pof ote ci s. s cta t a nee ” 1 or s ee l tr re i a t ii . e r
P cc § 6 21 p5-8 3 e 21)“Mo ’ Fd a P cc” Asc amvn s o r t e 5 0[] . 61 (d d 03( or s ee l r t e. s uh oa i n ai . , . e r ai ) , t t
e iet s m ayug e “ e l bcuehfc te a yf rapa mr p u b ta nt do u m jd mn m e eastea sh p t o e pe o l s l hn tl r t ry t r fs r e ai e
toeed ei opsino bcue apa ta h av s ys n k yo rvltrl hstne dn pot , r easi pe sh te de a i u ie t p a a i. r io t r t rr l l e i ta
T ssre vnhuh o p t smvfr u m yug e ” ate ais ae oe e . h itu eetog b h ai oe os m a jd mn – sh p t hv dn h e i t re r t re r
1 AC W g ,A Ml , & M K Kn Fd a P cc adPoeu § 75p 423 (d 0 . r h . ie it lr . . ae ee l r t e n rcdr 22 p 3-3 3 , r ai e , .
e 19) “W g , Ml , &Kn” S m ay ug e i poe “n we arlwu b d 98( r h ie . i t lr ae . u m jd mn s rp o y hn t a o d e ) r t r l i l
sp f os 1 Mo ’ Fd a P cc § 6 21 p5-6 uel u ” 1 or s ee l r t e 5 0[] . 61 ru . e r ai . , .
A a ymv g os m ayug e tu “ h do signs nad 1 A W g , p t o n fr u m jd mn hsi e t at ne t d . 0 r h r i r t s l r t a r” it
Ml, &Kn § 77 p 47 I ea a n a u m y ug e m in“n du at te ie lr ae 22 . 5 n v uig s m a jd mn o o ay ob s o h , . lt r t t , t
e s ne f gn ni u o m e afc wl eeo e aa stemvn”I. 22 p xt c oa eu es e f a rla i brs vd g n h oa . d § 77 p ie i s ti t l l it t , .
19 Atei eh Gv n e feteSt mno Fc taac ma ei m in o tht mte oe mn i dh t e e f a sh co pn dt o o fr r tl a t t t i s t s m ayug e , n a ht m Mc en fe i rsostteGv n e ’ m in h u m jd mn adt e e ac nyi dt epneoh oe mns o o te r t t i l l s r t t , apcb r eeu e amvn oi “ sp a, hrad oc et e e .. fh m e a p ia e u rq rd oa t fe a ea t so n cn s st mn . ote a rl l l l i t l re t i a t ti fc at w ctemv g a y o edte i n gn ni ut bt e ” nfr estd a sso h hh o n p t cn nsh es o eu es eo e id adu h t e t i i r t r i s r , tra :
A m e afc s o itet e e [fm e afc]eu et b s vd y l a rla s e u nh st mn o a rla srq rdo e e e b l ti t t t a t ti t i r te mvn wlb de e a mtd u e cn oe e b te[ sos e h oa i e e md die n s o rv td y h r pn v tl t ls t r e i] st mnrq rd o e evd y h ops g a y t e e eu e t b s e b te po n p t a t i r i r.
U CTR5()1 & 3( fc v Jn120)e pa s de) SI . 6h ) ()e eie a , 09( mhs add ( f t . i . Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 8
475 I adin“b cueh brei otemvn te v ec..l ass os ud 5-8 n d t ,[] aste udns nh oa ,h e dne. awyi cnre . io e t i t
i fvrotep t ops g h m in n teopnni g e tebn i o a fvrb n ao f h a y po n te o o ad h poe s i n h eet f l ao l r i t t v f l ae
if ecs h cn e r w fo i” d § 77p49 Mroe “ c a e e b te a y n rneta a b d nr mt I. 22 . 5 e t a . , . o v, f t s r d y h p t e r a s st r
ops gh m in f upr d yf dvs rtee dnaym e a a rg dd sre po nte o o ispo e b aia t o o r v e i i t , t f i h i t r a rl r ea e atu ” t i, e r .
I. 22 p 496 d § 77 p 5-2 , . .
I so, eastef cote n y f u m yug e i “ te d sc s m ay n hr bcueh e e fh e r os m a jd mn sr h r t, u m t ft t r t a r ai ” r
jd mn so e cu os ivkd ad sd w h deead oi proe ”1 A W g , ug e it b “a iu ynoe” n ue “i a urg fr s upss 0 r h t t l t r t . it
Ml, &Kn § 72 p 251 S m ay ug e tui n aport we te a ie lr ae 21 p 1-6 u m jd mn hss o prp a h e h e r , . . r t t ie r r e
“dob at te rd it o a mvns f a s rw nse ”I. 22 p40 S ma y []u s s o h c i l y f oa ’ ain o i e s d § 76 . 4 i i r , t e bi t f t t s. , . ll
s m ay ug e i n aport we “ e v ec p sn d . i sb ct cniig u m jd mn s o prp a h et e dne r e e. .s u e o ofc n r t t ie r h i e t jt lt
i ep tin oraoa e ep m h df at i s niac ”I. 22 p 433 n rr a os r esnb po e i t i e s ot i i cne d § 75 p 3-7 t et , l l g fr s gf . , . .
Ad u m yug e i n aport “ te x tnefm e afc suss ne a . I. n s m a jd mn s o prp a i h e s ec o a rla i ei uc t n d r t t ie f i ti t s ri ”
§ 72p20 Fr e a huh[ hfc h df u qein ol w xt rh te ais 21 . 1 u h ,l og “]ea ta ii l us os fa e sota h p t , . tr t t t t fct t i t re
df oteeacn u oso e r w fo tea ss o n n oi e a rud o dn n i e nhlg oc s nt b d nr mhfc i n i ad f s f gon fr ey g fr l li a t t tl i
s m ay ug e , “] de n f l w . tate iiu y f hlg i uss o pt y u m jd mn” [t os o o o . . h h df l oteea s ei c m el r t i tl t fct ls le
i e vnt teg n o dnlo s m ay ug e . I.§22 p 401 A ap cc r l a o h r t r e a f u m jd mn” d 75 p 1-2 s r t a re t a i r t , . . ai l
mt : ae tr
B o te orcn p yhl w tmshv a aeu ea u bs fr o g e r h cu a ap tea, u ae n dqa fc a a s o d n fe t l i t t tl i i s I s ms uin a ue dv o mnotea smy evt c r yhl w o n o ei a os f l ee p e fhfc a s eol i tea . t t , lr l t t r af o h ph cu d e m e s p ia otte ae A aeu,hrs u o o r e te or e r i i apcinoh cs s rs t eeo t n f l t t nt l t . lt li c m e qein ol wrqe l rq rs mr cn e fc adv o mn o p x us os fa f un yeu e a o oc t a u ee p e l t e t i e re t l l t ta my e bie truh u m y rce ns hn a b o a d hog s m a poed g tn r i .
I. 22 p 421 d § 75 p 1-5 , . . Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 1 ae 9
Acr n ya oeed g u ot s m utet e fhl ws m ayug e i a cod g , s nla n a hr y u s ph st otea, u m jd mn s il i t i a r t
dv eh i poe yeevd n frhs ain w c a tu “ e css 1 A W g , e cta s rp l rs e o y otoe c os h hr r y c a ae ” 0 r h i t r r l t i e l lr . it
Ml,&Kn § 75p 482 2 ie lr ae 22 p 2-9 0 , . .
I.A a s I n ys I li
A o l e aoe te p t s hv fe a n me o d psie m in Te s ui d bv h ai ae i d tn , re l u b f i ot r s i v o os t . h
Gv n e ’ pn n m inic d am inoi m s olc osb c mt jr dt n oe mns ed g o osn ue o ot d i frak f u e ae us c o r t i t l t s s j t t r i ii ,
a m in o i m s oflrt st al m pnw c ri cn e rn dad m in o o o t d i fr a u ot e ci uo h h ee a b g t , n a o o fr t s s i e a a i lf ae t
s m ay ug e a t c t ne r sprunt te U tdStsC iba Bs T d u m jd mn s o e a ni u a o h ne t e a ben a n r e r t ri t e s t i a - r i a
P te h A ( C T A . n d t n h Gv n e ad Mc en hvfe co - o os a n s p c “ B P ” I adi , e oe mn n ac ny ae ldrs m in r ri t ) io t r t l i s t
fr u m y ug e cnen g h poe bs fr pr s mn otem cad etsu os m a jd mn oc i te rp a s oap ie e f h e hn s ai e r t rn r i a t r i s.
Ec ote ais m ini aa zd n un e w ah f h p t ’ o oss n ye i tr b o. re t l l
A TeGv n e ’ D psie M in . h oe mns i ot r t s i v o os t
Treo te oen e ’ or ed g o in a ad se t Mc en’ ci fr h f hGv mnsfupn n m t s r dr sd o ac ny l m o e r t i o e e l s a
d yrera mn u untte C T A A d cse b o,l h em ina m i r u u - e t t e pr a oh B P. si u d e wa tr o osr et i s tf e t s t s s l l e t e ro o
ad ms b g n d Se eeay einI A, n a I cn a, ote esn s fr i n u e r t . e gnr l sc o I.. i r n o rs fr h raos e o h n t ae l t I 1 f. t t t t
d a, h Gv n e ’ m in o s m ay ug e ssi n Cs m ueot nain ei te oe mns o o fr u m jd mn u a ig u o s s fr sc o tl r t t r t tn t ’ a t
v u t ap ie Mc en’ m cad e aso b h h fc ad h l w Ta m in a e o pr s ac ny e hn s fl n o te a s n te a. h o o l a l s r i i t t t t
20 We a m in os m ay ug e hs en e e te i n h g h ih e l h e o o fr u m jd mn a be dn d h es o i ta ne n y r t r t i, r tn t rt ad ee al p c dsh mvnfo aa se n s m ayug e ,we e ote a e n ncs r y r l ete oa r m g n ek g u m jd mn h h nh s m si e u t i i r t tr odf e gons e, g 1 Mo ’ Fd aP cc § 6 2 p 5-9-637d cs n ri e n rud ee. 1 or s ee l r t e 5 11 p 6295-0( su ig fr t .S . , e r ai . ,. i s “M t l ad ucs v S m ay ug e M in” 1 A W g , Ml,&Kn § 72p ui e n Sce ie u m Jd mn o os ; 0 r h ie lp s r t t ) i t lr ae 21 p, . 241(o ntarn w os m ayug e m inmy e p t u r aport”we 1-5n igh ee a f u m jd mn o o a b “ai l l prp a t t l r t t rc a y ie h e r sbeund cv yee sa s oaaa eti e fitm in usqe i oe rva fc n vlb at m ofs o o) t s r l t t i l r t . Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 0
acr n yms b dn d Se eeay einI A, n a cod g u e e e e gnr l sc o I.. i r il t i. l t I 2 f.
1 Mc en’ C T ACi . ac ny B P l m l s a
TeGv n e hsmvdoi m s olc osb c mt jr dt n Mc en’ h oe mn a oet d i frak f u e ae us c o ac ny r t s s j t t r i ii l s
C T Aci a t a e r so eta toecv e b Po s N 10-4105 A B P l m s o l ni t r hn hs oe d y r e o 830-006 s a l te h r tt . .
d cse b o, htre r e stsu o eta Po s N 10-4105 d n a e i u d e w e h po s ai e t r hn r e o 830-006 i o s r s s l t e tt s h tt . d t st
C T Al m TeGv n e ’ m in o i m s h eo ms b g n d B P ci s h oe mns o o t d i te fr u e r t . a . r t t s s r e t ae
Fr e te Gv n e hs mvd od m s oflr t st a l m Mc en’ u h , h oe mn a oe t i i fr a u ot e ci ac ny tr r t s s i e a a l s
C T Al mw hepc ohfue r s oe d y r e N 10-4105 w c w e B P ci i rse tte or ni cv e b Po s o 830-006 h h e a t t te r tt . i r
md b o O oe 2 20 te f c v d e f h C T A s o odfo N a ga A ae e r c b , 00 h e eie a ote B P at gosr m i r u s fe t r , ft t ca .
d ae b o,we etemt i aa zd nete ur oam inoi m s oflrt ei d e w h h h ae s n ye ud hrb c f o ot d i fra u o tl l tr tr l r i t s s i e
st al m raenie , s m in ojd mnotela ns r os m ayug e , t e ci o l ra v ya a o o frug e nh p d g ofr u m jd mn a a ,t t l t t ei r t
teGv n e ’rqe free msb g n d n Mc en’ C T Al mmsb dn d h oe mnseus ori u er t ad ac ny B P ci u e e e r t t lf t ae l s a t i
o d m sd s o hsfue r s ri i e at toe or ni . s s te
Atteh ee a ig nis h Gv n e ses u m yug e ,eus nta sohtr r m n e r , e oe mn eks m a jd mn rqeigh e i n te t r t r t t t
te nis ee q d e d yre w hn rs prun oh C T A As fr b o,h h e r briu a d u - e i i e t u a tte B P. se o h e w a te l i t t f , t t e, s t t t l tt
m ino ms b g n d o o to u e r t . t t ae
a TeGv n e ’ M in oD m s o Lc o Sb c Mt Jr dt n . h oe mns o o t i i fr ak f u e ae us c o r t t s s j t t r i ii
W h epct Mc en’ C T A l mte Gv n e sesd m s fr ako i rse o ac ny B P ci, h oe mn ek i i a olc f t t l s a r t s sl
sb c mt jr dt n u un oU CTR e 2 )1at a e r s oe d yh e fh u e ae us c o pr a t SI u 1( () sol ni cv e btr ote j t t r i ii s t l b l te r e
fu po s ie i eite u mn adC m a t i. Po s Ns10-3107 10- or r e sdnf dnh S m os n o pi – e r e o 830-002 83 tt ti l n ., t t . , Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 1
0-004ad 830-003I o e wrs h Gv n e sesi m s o Mc en’ 4102 n 10-4104 nt r od te oe mn ek d i a f ac ny , . h , r t s sl l s
C T Al molc ojr dt n sole r stetatoe oe d y r e N 10- B P ci frak fus c o at a ni o rhnhs cv e b Po s o 83 a i ii l te h r tt .
0-006 Segnr l D. B e a 2 9 1-3 sea o n w ad Cu e l m¶1 4105 e eeay e’ r f t , , 11 e l As e n on r a . l fs i ; s r t ci
(ey g xtne f u e mt jr dt n ecpfre r scv e b Po s N 10- dn n e s c osb c ae us c o “xe o[ni ] oe d y r e o 83 i ie j t t r i ii t te r tt .
0-006 w h epct Pi i’ ci frd yrera mn ud C T A i ¶3 4105 i rse o l nf s l m o u - e t t e ” ne B P ) d , t t a tf a tf e t r ; . 4
(seig s fr a v d es “ c[[fsb c mt jr dt n v pi i’ ci fr a r n a ai mie e nel k o u e ae us c o oe l nf sl m o st f t f a ] ] j t t r i ii r a tf a
d yre n y ne[ eC T A . arg da e r secp o hs cv e b Po s N u - e e r ud t B P ] .sea sl ni , xe fr oe oe d y r e o tf t rh . r l te t t r tt .
10-4105 bcue oe f h o etre r e s. mks C T Al m. 830-006 eas nn ote t r h po s .. ae a B P ci ” 2 , h e tt a )1
Mc en p d a s us c oh e n 8...§ 51 )w c [] i t m .. ac ny r i t jr dt ne o 2 USC 18(, h h byt e s . l e c e i ii r a i ,“ sr ,
l mshjr dt nf hCu f n ra oaT d ope sr me a o vi po s. i i teus c oo teor I enin r etapa fo dnl f a d r e s t i ii to t t l a l is l t t”
Se o eAosn n vU tdSts15.d 0 98 Fd i 99 2 USC 18( . e K k rno i ,Ic . ne t e,6 F 96 0 (e C.19) 8...§ 51 ) . i a 3 , .r ; a
T b vi po s mss fr – dt c y n se f a y –te a r oec o ein o e a d r e u e o h “ s nl ad pci l ” “ n u f ah b c o l ,a t t t t t ii t i cl h te jt
adhraosh eo ”1 USC§ 54 )1 C selo 9CFR§ 7 1( ()rq r g nteesnte fr 9 ... 11( () ) e a 1 ... 14 3 )6( ui r . c (; s . a e in
ta po s d a “]en u o ad ui ci fr] h o ein efr dt c yad h r e ei [ h a r f n jsf ao o,te b c o s o h ii t n t t t tl t te , ti t n [ jt t t s nl
se f a y. ” Tet u fr e mna sh eey r e ie iy aa , dt c y n pci l ..) h st e u h ad eta v po s dnf – g n“ s nl ad i cl . at t r t t r tt t i ii t
21 Te cp adp cc e e ote Gv n e ’ m in od m sa s m wa h soe n r t a f c f h oe mns o o t i i r o e h ai l f t r t t s s e t uc a Mc en’ Fs A eddC m a t pe so m te o pn’ C T Al mo n e. ac ny it mne o pi apa tl i h c may B P ci t lr l s r ln r it s a o yhs e r s oe d yhfu po s a su w c w e e e d n rf rO oe 2 n toe ni cv e bte or r e st se h h e “n r o oa e c b , l te r tt i i r te t t r 20” h e eie a o h C T Aso odfo N a ga SeitA eddC m a t 00( ef c v d ef e B P at gosr m i r u. e Fs mne o pi t ft t t ca ) r ln ¶ 6 Ifr e apa ta ote h e r e stsu o eta Po s N 10-4105 2 t u h pe s h, f htr po s ai e t r hn r e o 830-006 . tr r t e tt s h tt . , o y n po s– pcia y Po s N 10-3102 – oe e r sh w emd o o n oe r e se f l , r e o 830-007 cv s ni ta e ae n r l tt i cl tt . r te t r a e O oe 220 e Fs A eddC m a ttt ce Shd e f r e slt g n y f r c b , 00 eit mne o pi aaahd ceu o Po s (s n e r t t r .S r ln t l t t ii t n me ad epc v d e o e r) Itu apa tateGv n e ’ m in o i m s u b s n rseie a s f n y t hs pe s h h oe mns o o t d i r t t t . r t r t t s s a ul i pc e o y h e r s oe d yPo s N 10-3102 Nv te s i a c a y m ia s n te ni cv e b r e o 830-007 ee h e , n n tl l t l te r tt . . r ls audne f a in h e r s oe d yltre r e sr ad se h ea p sn d y bnac ocu o te ni cv e b a h po s a dr sd e, s r e e b t , te r l e tt e e r e t teGv n e ’ m in h oe mns o o r t t . Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 2
se f a y –h p t u rCs m dcin ) e g r e e Se 9USC§ 54 )1 A pci l ” te ai l u o s e s ( b n po s d e 1 ... 11( () ) i cl rc a t io s i tt . c (.
TeCu o Apa hs mhs e te mna r”n u oteet u r ad eutr h or f pe s a e pa zd h “ ad oy a r f hs st oy n rg a y t l i t te at lo
po s n t esrtaa po s aps Cs m ote a r ad h a e ote se e rvi s o nu h l r e s pr e u o s f h n u n ca c r f h a r d io, e t l tt i t te rt st
ci s Se o eAosn 15.dt 0-9 e a oa e v A hr 9 US181117) l m e K k rno , 6 F a980 sel Dv s. r u , 6 .. 4 5(87 a . i 3 ; s i t ,
(o igh eey r e “ u b s dt cad pci a we f r cnre t so ta h d ta v po s ms e oii t n se f, s hnal os ud o h wh l n t r tt t sn ic , iy t , t
te b c o..ws ui e t n iy Cs m oi tu n u ad h a e ) h o ein. a sf c n o of [ u o s ft re a r n ca c r. jt fi t t t ] s te rt ”
Ote orpo s ai u i t s c o o yPo s N 10-4105 s s o h f h fu r e s ts e n h ain n r e o 830-006 e fr a tt s i t , l tt . t t
C T Aci,a eig h “ e a m cad e spoe yd yrea C T Aqaf d B P l m s r n ta t s d e hn s i rp l u - e s B P -ui e a st t h i r i r tf li
gos e D. B ea1(u ig r e N 10-4105) seloda29 Teh e od ”Se e’ r ft 2qo n Po s o 830-006 e a i.t,. htr . fs i t tt . ; s e
r m n gr e srse atteC T Aae n o yh tee vne r sfm cad e e a i po s a i n soh B P,l g g n ta hr ea ni o e hn s i n tt el t li l t l t te r i
“ e rp l d ib o te a s f euie a e d a 1 (u ig h e te po s a a poe y ua e n h bs o ddc v v u ”I.t 2 qo n tr o r r e st r r t l i t l. t e h tt
i u ;e a o d a 29 Toe h e r e s h eo w e o vi at ayC T Al m s e se l i.t,. hstr po s te fr e n a d s o n B P ci, s) s e tt r e r t l a
bcuehyae t g eCs mteeui n ie easte fld o i u o s hrq se oc i v t it t .
Bcue vi po s(n tednlota po s i ap rq se o u e mt eas a a d r e ad h e a f h r e)s r eui t sb c ae l tt i t tt e it j t tr
jr dt nud 2 ...§18( , Mc en’ C T A l m s oPo s Ns 10-3 us c o ne 8USC i ii r 51 ) ac ny B P ci at r e o 830- a l s a tt .
107 10-4102 ad10-4104 ms b d m sdfr wn o jr dt n 002 830-004 n 830-003 u e i i e o a f us c o , , t s s t i ii .
Mc en de n cn n o e w e Se e. P’ B e a 1 (cn w d n ta C T A ac ny os o o ed t ri . e, g ls r ft 2 akol g g h B P l t t h s ., . i ei t
ci i poe y lmette odcv e b E r Ns WP002408 WP00422 l ms rp l “ i doh gosoe d y n y o J-0[]7- J-029- a r it r t . ,
ad WP00577 n ic dd nPo s N 10-4105 o y ( mhss de)2 n J-020- ad n ue i r e o 830-006 n” e pae add2 l tt . l) .
22 Se lo lsB e a 2 ci ig n tac t n m cad e n ue i E r Ns e a P’ r ft ( a m o y h e a “ e hn sic dd n n y o s . i l n l t ri r i l t . WP00408 WP00422ad WP00577o Po s N 10-4105 . . J-027- , J-029- n J-020- f r e o 830-006 . tt . qaf e fr u - et a mn ud C T A i a1 ( g n o yh Cs mso d e uiis o d yrer t e ” ne B P ) d t 4a u g n ta u o s hu b l[ ] tf e t r ; . ri l t t l od et “ l u a teh e e ga d nish qaf fr u - et a mncv e b re dori i t htr ds n e e r ta uiy o d yrer t e oe d y r eq d e e i t te t l tf e t r Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 3
b TeGv n e ’ M in oD m s o Flrt St aCi . h oe mns o o t i i fr a u o t e l m r t t s s i e a a o Aenie , M in oJd mn o teP a ns rS m ay ug e r l ra v y o o fr ug e n h l d g o u m Jd mn , t t l t t ei r t
Ote orpo s ai u i t s c o o yPo s N 10-4105 s s o h f h fu r e s ts e n h ain n r e o 830-006 e fr a tt s i t , l tt . t t
C T Al m Se e’ B ea1 (u ig r e N 10-4105) Ote ee e r s B P ci. e D . r ft 2 qo n Po s o 830-006 fh svn ni a fs i t tt . . te
cv e b ta po s te Gv n e sesd m s frflr t st aci a t oe d y h r e, h oe mn ek i i a o a u o t e l m s o r t tt r t s sl i e a a
Mc en’ C T A l mw h epct E r Ns WP00399 WP00461 WP ac ny B P ci i rse o n y o J-029- J-021- J- l s a t t t . , ,
00494ad WP00401 i. hfue r sh w emd p ot O oe220 te 022- n J-024- –., eor ni ta e aer ro c b , 00 h , et te t r i t r ,
e eie a oteC T A s o odfo N a ga Se d a 2 &. 91-3 U CTR f c v d e f h B P at gosr m i r u ei.t ft t ca . n,, 11 SI . 3 ;
1()5 2 We eaa zd nete ur oam inoi m s oflrt st al mo 2b ) 3 h h n ye ud hrb c f o ot d i fra u ot e ci, r (. tr l r i t s s i e a a ,
aenie , m inojd mnotela ns U CTR e 2 )oam inos m ay l ra v ya o ofrug e nh p d g( SI u 1( )r o ofr u m t t l t t ei l c t r
jd mn ( SI R e5)te Gv n e ’ ag mni eul sud Sen 7 ur ug e U CT u 6 h oe mns ru e s qa y on e . ,spa t l , r t t l . 1
(x a ig h m in o i m s oflrt st al mi d f rAs eso d era d epi n ta o o t d i fr a u ot e ci fe a e n w hu bt t ln t t s s i e a a l t r l ee
a m in ojd mn o p a ns rm in os m ay ug e ) s o o fr ug e n l d g o o o fr u m jd mn. t t ei t r t
AteGv n e cr c y bevso yh efhsvn nis oe d y r e N sh oe mn o el os e n tr o eee e r cv e b Po s o r t rt r , l e t te r tt .
Po s N 10-4105i acrac w hteC T A ) i a1-7st gh Pi i r e o 830-006n codne i [ tt . t h B P ] ; d t 61 ( a nta l nf ” . ti t a tf i eddh i C T Al m o d yrera mn wu ap o yotre nis oe d n neta t B P ci fr u - et t e o d p y n t “ e e r cv e t ts a tf e t l l l h te r b oe r e, ad ocd gh “ eCu lcsus c ot g nsc ri w heado y n Po s” n cne nta t or akjr dt no r t uhee i rg t tt i t h t i ii a lf t r tee a ig nis n h cs” hr m n e r i t s ae . i n te i ) 23 Aa ,h soe n p cc e e oteGv n e ’ m inr s m wauc a g n e cp ad r t a f c fh oe mns o o a o e h n e . it ai l f t r t t e t lr C maen 1 spa I p t u r Mc en’ Fs A eddC m a t pe s oi ite o pr . , ur. n ai l , ac ny it mne o pi apa t l m h 2 rc a l s r ln r t c may C T Al mo n toe nisw c w e e e d n rf rO oe 220 ” o pn’ B P ci t o yhs e r s a l t e h h e “n r o oa e c b , 00 i r te t t r . SeitA eddC m a t 2 Itu apa tateGv n e ’ m ins drset e Fs mne o pi ¶ 6 ths pe s h h oe mns o oi ad sdo r ln . r t r t t e e r s h, n a,a n te u e o Mc en’ C T Aci a s fr i teFs ni ta i fc r o h sb c f ac ny B P l m s e o h n h it te t t e t jt l s a t t r A eddC m a t Nv te s fr h sk o c r y n i a ecs o cu o te or mne o pi . ee h e , ote ae f l i ad n n xe f a in h fu ln r ls at s t , e r s oe d y r e N 10-4105 w c p d eO oe 220 a ad se h e ni cv e b Po s o 830-006 h h r a c b , 00r dr sd e , te r tt . i et t r e e r a p sn d y h Gv n e ’ m in s r e e b te oe mns o o e t r t t . Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 4
10-4105 w emd a e O oe220 tef c v d efh C T Aso odfo 830-006 e aef r c b , 00 h e eie a o e B P at gosr m r t t r , ft t t
N a ga Se e’ B e a 2 & . 9 1 N vi C T Al m a b a e e at ay i r u e D . r ft ca . fs i n, , 3 o a d B P ci cn e s r d s o n 3 . l a st
e r s md b o ta d e Se d a 91 se eeay e r ia o Ud teC iba ni ae e r h a. ei.t, 3 e gnr l D e m t n ne h a ben te fe t t ; l t ni r r
Bs T d P te h A, 5 e Rg6 26 O. 020)st gh C T A p is n a n r e a n s p c 6 Fd e 0 3( c 1 00( a nta B P ape o y i a r ri t . . , t , ti t l l
t e g l gos mo e o oa e O oe 220) ol i e odi pr d n rf r c b , 00 ib t t t r .
Mc en i e akoldetaayC T Al m s oE r Ns WP00399 ac nyt l cn w gs h n B P ci at n y o J-029- l sf e t a t . ,
WP00461 WP00494 ad WP00401 ak m i Se e. P’ B e a 1 J-021- J-022- n J-024- lcs et e,. , ls r f t 2 , , r. g . i
(ocd g h C T Aci i poe y“ me t tegoscv e b E r Ns WP cne n ta B P l m s rp l l i d o h od oe d y n y o J- i t a r it r t .
002408 WP00422 n WP00577.4 Acr n yat toe or nis h 0[]7- J-029- ad J-020-” 2 cod g , s o hs fu e r , e , ) il te t
Gv n e ’rqe fr ee ms b g n dad Mc en’ C T Al mms b dn d oe mns eus ori u e r t , n ac ny B P ci u e e e r t t lf t ae l s a t i
o d m sd ri i e s s .
c TeGv n e ’ M in o S m ay ug e at C t nE r s . h oe mns o o fr u m Jd mn s o e a ni r t t r t ri t e
A tar m n o Mc en’ C T Al mrteh e nis oe d y r e N l h e a s f ac ny B P ci a htr e r cv e b Po s o l t i l s a e e te r tt .
10-4105ta w e n rd n rf rO oe 220 –.,E r Ns WP00408 830-006h e e e o oa e c b , 00 i. n y o J-027- t r te t t r e t . ,
WP00422ad WP00577 2 TeGv n e akoldeta hstre nisr J-029- n J-020- 5 h oe mn cn w gsh toeh e r a , . r t e t e te e
24 Se lo lsB e a 2 ci ig n tac t n m cad e n ue i E r Ns e a P’ r ft ( a m o y h e a “ e hn sic dd n n y o s . i l n l t ri r i l t . WP00408 WP00422ad WP00577o Po s N 10-4105 . . J-027- , J-029- n J-020- f r e o 830-006 . tt . qaf e fr u - et a mn ud C T A i a1 ( g n o yh Cs mso d e uiis o d yrer t e ” ne B P ) d t 4a u g n ta u o s hu b l[ ] tf e t r ; . ri l t t l od et “ l u a teh e e ga d nish qaf fr u - et a mncv e b re dori i t htr ds n e e r ta uiy o d yrer t e oe d y r eq d e e i t te t l tf e t r Po s N 10-4105i acrac w hteC T A ) i a1-7st gh Pi i r e o 830-006n codne i [ tt . t h B P ] ; d t 61 ( a nta l nf ” . ti t a tf i eddh i C T Al m o d yrera mn wu ap o yotre nis oe d n neta t B P ci fr u - et t e o d p y n t “ e e r cv e t ts a tf e t l l l h te r b oe r e, ad ocd gh “ eCu lcsus c ot g nsc ri w heado y n Po s” n cne nta t or akjr dt no r t uhee i rg t tt i t h t i ii a lf t r tee a ig nis n h cs” hr m n e r i t s ae . i n te i ) 25 E r N WP00408ws n rd nO oe 1 20 E r N WP00422 n y o J-027- a e e o c b 0 00 n y o J-029- t . te t r , ; t . ws n rd nO oe1 20 ad n yN WP00577ws n rd nO oe1 20 ae e o c b 6 00 n E r o J-020- ae e o c b 9 00 te t r , ; t . te t r , . Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 5
e iet d yrera mnud teU td t e C iba Bs T d P te h A, n nt do u - et t e ne h ne Sts a ben a n r e a n s p c ad tl tf e t r i a - r i a r ri t
ses u m yug e riu a nte acr n ySe e’ B ea2&. 1 2 D. eks m a jd mn e q digh m cod g . e D. r ft n, 3 9 e’ r tl it il fs i 3 , ; fs
Rp B e a 3n,2 D . Sp B e a 1 N srrig , Mc en cnu i te e y r f t . 0 e’ up r f t 0 o ups l ac ny ocr n h l i 4 ; fs . i . t in y l s
Gv n e ’ m in SelsB ea23. 1-31 1-73-32 oe mns o o e P’ r ft, n, 21 4 61 23 6 r t t . . i 1 , , , .
A d csei sc o I bv e g l gosr m ee c r cu r smy e mo e si u dn ein aoe l i e odfo bn i ay oni a bi pr d s s t ,i b fi te t
i o h U tdSts u - e ud teC T A e gnr l 1 USC § 20-3lt g n te ne t e d yre ne h B P.Se eeay 9 ... § 720 (s n t i a tf r l ii
c t n onis n gos s l i e o d yrera mn ud C T A N a ga ws e a cu r ad od a e g l fr u - e t t e ne B P ) i r u a ri te ib tf e t r . ca
fr a yg n dbn i ayt u ud teC T A so O oe 2 20 Se1 USC § o ml r t ee c r sts ne h B P a f c b , 00 e 9 ... l ae fi a r t r .
20() lt g N a gaa e g l frds nina bn i aycu r ud C T A 72b (s n i r u s l i e o e ga o s ee c r on y ne B P ) ii ca ib i t fi t r ;
D e m a o Ud teC iba Bs T d P te h A, 5 e Rga6 26 g n n e r i t n ne h a ben a n r e a n s p c 6 Fd e t 0 3 (r t g t ni r r i a r ri t . . , ai
N a ga ee c r stsadmd y gH S Se eieO., 00 i r u bn i ayt u n o f n T U,f c v c 220) ca fi a , ii ft t .
Te ode g lfr u - et a mnud teC T An uem cad elsf d h gosl i eod yre e e ne h B P ic d e hn s c si ib tf rt t r l r i aie
ud H S S uha n 90 0 8 e 1 USC § 73b 2 AiI Se f a ytoe ne T U sbed g 82 0 0 e 9 ... 20() ) ))) pci l , hs r i . . .S ( ( ((. i cl
“pa l rc staa a e b d n C T A ee c r cu r (uh sN a ga “ o ap eai e” h r s m e i a B P bn i ay on ysc a i r u f m r tl t e s l fi t ca ) r
fb c wo y o md n c i teU tdSts ad mo e d el i o h U tdSts ar s h l fr e ad u n h ne t e” n i pr d i c y n te ne t e i l t i a t rt t i a
SeitA eddC m a ttt ce Shd ef r e s iig n y u b s nrseie e Fs mne o pi aaahd ceu o Po s (s n e r n me adepc v r ln t l t t lt t r t d e oe r) D . B ea1(a e A huh o p t st eh E r N WP0057 a sf n y e’ r ft 3s m. l og b h ai stta n y o J-020- t t ; fs i ) t t re a t t . 7wsmd o O oe920 ter iae r pp sn c eh te a oe r ws c a y a ae n c b , 00 h o g l n y ae id a ta h d ef n y aa ul t r , in t r it t t t tl O oe1 20 We ete a wsO oe920 o O oe1 20i n m e a B h c b 9 00 h h h d e a c b , 00r c b 9 00s o a rl o t r , . tr t t r t r , t t i. t d e a a e O oe 220 tef c v d e f h C T A s o odfo N a ga a sr f r c b , 00 h e eie a ote B P at gosr m i r u t et t r , ft t ca . 26 Ide Mc en n w d ss h ii edd o se aC T A l m o d yre ned ac ny o av eta t n ne t a r , l i t t s t B P ci fr u - e a tf t a mno ysohtre pcid nisSee. P’ B ea1-7st gh Mc en r t e n atteh se f e r . e, g ls r ft 61( a nta ac ny e t l e ie te .,. i ti t l i eddh i C T Al m o d yrera mn wu ap o yotre nis oe d n neta t B P ci fr u - et t e o d p y n t “ e e r cv e t ts a tf e t l l l h te r b oe r e, ad ocd gh “ eCu lcsus c ot g nsc ri w heado y n Po s” n cne nta t or akjr dt no r t uhee i rg t tt i t h t i ii a lf t r tee a ig nis n h cs” hr m n e r i t s ae . i n te i ) Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 6
ud H S S uha n 90 0 8 a e ie t d yrera mn prunt teC T A ne T U sbed g 82 0 0 r nt d o u - et t e u a o h B P. r i . . e tl tf e t s t
Se..N e ()) C 9 SbhI H S S se lorc min 31 fO oe 220 e US o 7bi h 8 uc I T U; e a Po a a o 75 o c b , 00 t (, . , ., s l t t r
tI p mn h U tdt e C iba Bi T d P te h A, 5 e Rg5 395 33 o m e e te ne Sts a ben a n r e a n s p c 6 Fd e 9 2 9 3 l t i a - r s a r ri t . ., ,,
( c 420) md y gH S Son ueU.N e()) C 9 Sbh I H S Se eie O., 00( o f n T Utic d . o 7bi h 8 uc I T U,f c v t ii l S t (, . , ., ft
O., 00 c 220) t .
H e h es oip eh Mc en’s t yeak sw e rp l c sf d ne e , e i n d u ta ac ny u- pjce e poe yl si ud rt r st t l s it t r r aie r
H S S uha n 90 0 8 SeitA eddC m a t 2 As eadCu e l m T U sbed g 82 0 0 e Fs mne o pi ¶ 5 n w n on r a ¶ i ... r ln ; r t ci
2 Nrsh e n d p eh Mc en’ m cad ews mo e d eli oh U td 5 oite ayi u ta ac ny e hn s ai pr di c yn te ne . r st t l s r i t rt t i
Stsr mN a ga SePi i’ St mn o M e a Fc A T W c Te A N t efo i r u e l nf s t e e f a rl a s s o h h h e r o a ca . a tf a t ti t i r e
Gn n I usT B T e (P’ St mn o Fc ” ¶ ;D ednsRsost Pi i’ eu es e o e r d “ls t e e f a s 3 e na ’ epne o l nf s i s i . a t t) f t a tf
St mn o M e a Fc A T W c Te A N Gn n I usT B T e ( D . t e e f a rl a s s o h h h e r o eu e s e o e r d “ e’ a t ti t i r e i s i fs
Rsost P’ St mno Fc ”¶.tsi i r ud p eta h gosw ese b d epneolst e e f a s 3I s ma y n su dh te od e a m e . a t t) i ll i t t r s l
i N a gaa ee c r cu r ud teC T A fo fb cfr e ad u nh U td n i r u( bn i ay on y ne h B P ) r mar s o md n c ite ne ca fi t r , i t i
Sts e P’ St mn o Fc ¶ ;D. Rsost P’ St mn o Fc ¶. F a y te a .Se ls t e e f a s 3 e’ epne o ls t e e f a s 3 i l , . a t t fs . a t t nl
te i n d p e h E r Ns WP00408 WP00422ad WP00577w e h es o i u ta n y o J-027- J-029- n J-020- e r st t t . , , r
e e d f r O oe 2 20 SeFs A eddC m a t t t ce Shd eo Po s n r a e c b , 00 e it mne o pi a aahd ceu f r e s te t t r . r ln t l tt
(s n d e oe r) D . B ea1 (cn w d nta h e s d nis w emd a e lt g a s f n y e’ r ft 3akol g gh tr lt e r “ e aef r ii t t ; fs i ei t e i e te r t
tef c v d e fh C T A at gosr mN a ga n 5 ur ( e iy g n y a s h e eie a ote B P ” so odfo i r u ;. , pai nf n e r d e ft t ca ) 2s dt i t t
oteh e u e e r s fhtr sb c ni ) e j t t e.
A sc E r Ns WP00408 WP00422ad WP00577 as e te s uh n y o J-027- J-029- n J-020- siid h , t . , , tf
rq r mn frd yrera mn ud te C T A Te Gv n e ’ m ina t te eu e e s o u - e t t e ne h B P. h oe mns o o s o h i t tf e t r r t t Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 7
se f d nis h eo ms b g n d n te nisms briu a dd yre pci e r te fr u e r t ad h e r ie te r e t ae t e u ee q d e u - e t l i t, tf .
2 TeAport M hd fAp ie e . h prp a e o o pr s mn ie t a t
I adin ose n s m ay ug e a t te h ee r se ie t d yre n d t t ek g u m jd mn s o h tr ni nt d o u - e io i r t e t e tl tf
t a mn ud teC T A d cse aoe te Gv n e a o ek s m ay ug e r t e ne h B P ( su d bv, h oe mn l ses u m jd mn e t r i s ) r t s r t
ssi n Cs m ueot nainv u t ap ie l o e e r s tsu i t s c o u a ig u o s s fr sc o a e o pr s a t r ni ai e n h ain tn t ’ a t l a l h te s i t .
Se f a y h Gv n e cn nsh,l ogte ue( e Mc en B Gadhsl pci l, e oe mn o edta a huhh by i. ac ny C ) nteee i cl t r t t tt r ., l / lr
( e K)w eetd h v uint u nv tlsrq rd pr s mnbsd n asc o i. B e r a , e a a o st e ee he eu e ap ie e ae ot nain ., r let l t at re s i a t r t
v u bcue acr n t teGv n e –tei u s ne ote a .. n c e ta a e eas – cod g o h oe mn “ c c m acs f h s e. id a [ h l, i r t h r t l i t] t
teet nh ..i n if ecte r eta Mc en B G a t K. e gnr l 1 hr a os p. d o n uneh p c”h ac ny C p do BSe eeay 9 li i d t l i t l / i l
USC 10ab()B D. B e a 91 -02 2 2 D. Rp B e a 11 1 2 ...§ 41 )2 ) e’ r ft, 3 2 6 8 9 e’ e y r ft -2 6 0 ( ( ; fs i , , , ; fs l i , , ;
D. up r fa89ps m D. up e yB e a 187 Fr h raos u m ie e’ p i t - a i ;e’ p fsS .B e , s fsS .Rp r ft - 2 ote esn s m a zd l i . r
b o, u m y ug e ms b dn d e ws m a jd mn u e e e l r t t i.
I a e o t d mnr eh te c c m acs fh s ets s as eit s ae n nf r o e os a ta h “ ru s ne ote a ”e isiidnh cs ft tt t i t l t tf i ,
teGv n e ivks n rr a v N e t 1 CFR§ 5 13)1 a eig n sec h oe mn noeI ep tie o 2 o 9 ... 12 0(() s r n i e ne r t t et t . l , st , s ,
ta h p csh M Loy B G C e Oe t gOie s frK w est dn mne h ter eta r ob( C ’ h f p a n f c )e o B e “el i a an t i t . s i ri f r t r te r
27 T ss ntp acsi a esoe e rse: tsCs m – o hi pr r ta h i a a i l aent a n kyepc I i yc l t t i u o s n te mo e –h t t t t i avcig o ap ie e bsd nrnain a e AteGv n e p n o ,ii s doa n fr pr s mn ae o t sc o v u s h oe mn o t u “ s t a t a t l. r t is t t uuu fra i pr r o o ed h t nainv u so d o e p id Ii f mr nsa o n mo e t cn n ta r sc o a e hu n l t t ta t l l tb ape ts a o l . r e c m o fr n mo etair a d ot sp i t po difr a o t te pr s i a o mn o a i pr r h s et t i upe o rv e no min o h ap ie n t t le s lr i t a r qe t cnr t nain a esh aport m hd oy D. Sp B ea9. se us o of m asc o v u ate prp a e oo g ” e’ up r ft n ; e t i r t l i e t l . fs . i 5 a o e’ Sp Rp B ea3rt a n “ eat oai pr r ek go ae v uin l D. up e y r ft ( i rigt r i f n mo ese nt hv a a a o s fs . l i ee t h ry t i lt m hd oy o eta t nainv u ape t i gos. Te Gv n e w nta e oo g t r hn r sc o a e p id ot od” h oe mn a s h t l h a t l l s ) r t r t cu ote fr msb ee ie “ ap ig n s uin pci a hr y n u n Cs m a inh eo u e x c di p y ayi a o- e f u ot ic d g u o s t r e t rs n l n t t s i c t i, l i t r ig ojdi dcin”n e d gh cs “n stei a o rv wdnhr e ne u ns ru cl e s si dc i t s ae u e h s uine e eitee r cd l ia io in i , ls tt i fe a hr y no e a i pr rr n t r mvi t nainfo ap ia ud t nain u ot iv vs n mo ety g o e oet r sc osr m pr s ne r sc o t i l t i sa t al ra t v u ”Se d a e ei. l. Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 8
cn s n w h h nr a p c gpaie ote nu r i qein” Se1 CFR § ost t i te o m ri rccs f h ids y n us o. e 9 ... ie t l in t t t
12 0(()i( mhs add D . B ea1 (u ig n rr a v N e ) D. Rp 5 13)1i e pa s de) e’ r ft 6 qo n I ep tie o 2 e’ e y . l () i ; fs i t t et t ; fs l
B ea1 ( f r go r es “ te nr a mnefr g mna e b r ;D. Rp r ft 0r ei t p cs e i h‘o m ’ an oa a e s m e ) e’ e y i ern i t n l r r t s l ” fs l
B e a 1 ( f r g o“o m p c gp ccsfr h g mn ids y.8 Tu t r f t 2 r ei t nr a ri r t e o te a e nur” 2 i ern l i n ai r t t ) hs o ,
28 Selo e’ r fa1 ( f r g onr amne otenur” D. r fa e a D. i t 6 r ei t“o m an s fsB e ern l rfr hids y ;e’ i t t ) fsB e 1 r eigt nr a nur rccs ;D. Rp B e a 1(t g ie l , 7( f r e r n o“o m lids yp t e” e’ e y r f t 1 i n n ra a t ai ) fs l i ci , t i I ep tieo ad e r nt“o m p c grccsf hids y ;e’ upB e n rr a vN e2 n r eigonr a ri p t e otenur” D. t et t fr l i n ai t ) fsSp r f .i a6 r eig onr ap c g rccsf hids ynus o ” u ig u o sV uin t ( f r t“o m ri p t e otenuriqein qo n Cs m a a o ern l i n ai t t , t t lt Cd ;i a8 r eig o nr ap c g rccs f hids y;da9 r eigi t o oe d t ( f r t “o m ri p t e o te nur )i t ( f r , n w ) . ern l i n ai t” . ern p cst “o m p c g rccs f hids y ;D. Sp Rp B e a 3r eig o l e o nr a ri p t e ote nur” e’ up e y r ft ( f r t a , l i n ai t ) fs . l i ern “o m rigp c cso te nur i qein cig n rr a v N e2 i a 4 nr a i n r t e f h ids y n us o ” i n I ep tie o ) d t lp c ai t t , t t et t ; . ( f r gi t op cst “o m p c gp ccs ;d a 6 r eig o“o m p c g r ei , n w l e o nr a ri r t e” i t ( f r t nr a ri ern a , l i n ai ) . ern l in p ccsnhids y ; da7r eigo mne[ w c] r e a nr a y e nte r t eitenur” i t ( f r t “ an i h h p csr o ml s i [ ] ai t ) . ern rn i i e l t h ids y ; d ( f r g o nr a p c g rccs. nur” i r ei t “o m ri p t e” t ) . ern l i n ai )
Av iu p n ii b e,h Gv n e f mse srtnadi o et m Se t a os o t n sr f te oe mn r ets os d snt re s e, r is t is r ta t a r h r . e. D. B e a 1 (seigi cp o ta “ h E dneE a ihsTateP cs . , e’ r f t 5 a r n n a in h Te v ec s bse h h r e g fs i st , t , t i tl t i B we K ad Mc en W eS i teS m Mne a P csA Nr a yS frS e e en B n ac ny e e n h a e an s r e r o ml e o a s t l r t r i e l t l B we Ur a d ais ;i a2 (seigh p cs w e e nh s m mnea p cs e en n l e P t ” d t 6a r nta r e “ e s ite a e an s r e t et re ) . st ti r t r i a s b we ur a d nt s ;D. Rp B ea4a eigh p cs w e e r ie r e e en n l e e ie” e’ e y r ft (s r nta r e “ e d e m d et t et ti ) fs l i st ti r t n u nte a em hd swu b e p ydnrnain b we ur a d nt s ; da6 s gh s m e o a o d e m oeit sc os e en n l e e ie” i t i t l l a t t et ti ) . (seigh p cs w e e nh s m m n a p csr s b we ur a d ais ; d a r nta r e “ e s ite a e a e s r e a e e en n l e p t ” i st ti r t nr i et t et re ) . a7a eigh p csw e os “ f rn y hnhywu hv beite ueadh t (s r nta r e e n e df e l tate o d ae enfh by nte st ti r t t ie t l r sl w e or a d ;D . Sp B e a 6 d cs n c c m acswe “ e mnei ee e n et ” e’ up r ft ( su igi u s ne h et an n l r r t l e ) fs . i i s r t r h r w cte r ews e vds se ilte a e s wu bfr aish a n r a d ; h hh p c a d iei e na yh s m ai o d e o p t ta r o et ” i i r s tl t l re t e t l e ) i a 8 a eig h p cs we ei te a e mne a ap c wu hv be s fr d t (s r n ta r e “ e s n h s m an s r e o d ae en e o . st t i r t r i l t t nain b we ur a d p t s ) r sc os e en n l e [ai ]. a t t et re ”
Teem clnose rnecn a cne tadagaenn rr a v N e 1 n hs i eaeur e cs oft ocps nlnugiI ep tie o s ad sl fe le t et t 2teta te pci po s n nw c teGv n e h eee – h i te rvin f o rhn h se f rvi o h h h oe mn e ris ta s h po s o h ic i o i r t r l t, io I ep tie N e2 tig h teueot nainv u i aport i a etdp t n rr a v o st ta h s fr sc o a e s prp a n r a t et t an t a t l ie l e ayr t nain[fh p c hs en eldn mnecn s n w hh nr ap c g rccs r sc o “]te r e a be st i a an ost t i te o m ri p t e a t i i te r ie t l i n ai ote nur i qein Se e. D. B e a 1 (u ig cn s n w h h nr a f h ids y n us o ” e,. , e’ r f t 6 qo n “ost t i te o m t t . g fs i t ie t l p c g rccs f hids yts ad mt g n r e ne owe e “ e r e a be ri p t e ote nur”e, n o ii ay e r ct h h t p c hs en i n ai t t tn fe tr h i st dn mnecn s n . w hh wyhsl st sr et[n l e] ue ” D . el i a an ost t . i te ateee el p csour a dby s ; e’ te r ie . t l r te i et r ) fs Rp B ea 9s m. e y r ft (a e l i )
Acr ntteGv n e ,n rr a v N e –w c cnen“ ewynw cte cod goh oe mn I ep tie o 1 h h oc st ai h hh i r t t et t i r h i Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 2 ae 9
p c i qein ws r vd t –hsn r eac t t s ae bcue h n e apet r e n us o a aie a i t r ” a o e vne o h cs eas ta o “p is o l i , t t l s uin n p snh ei. we Cs m hs rv u y x m eteet nh oa ed i a os o r e e ,., hn u o s a p i s ea i dhr a os p rl ay tt t e t r e t e ol n li i r hs‘ui e d ae ifr a o cnen g h by adsl t b siid h te a sf c n ei d no min oc i te ue n ee o e as e ta h fi t tl t rn r lr tf t r a os pi n if ecte r e c a y a o pyb. Se e’ Sp Rp B ea et nh d o n uneh p c a ul p d r aa e” e D. up e y r ft li i d t l i tl i l’ fs . l i 2n. B se D . Rp B e a 1-1 we Gv n e apa t r yi p t o .1 u e e’ e y r f t 01 ( h e oe mn pe s o e , n a, n t fs l i r r t r l r I ep tie N e1 Tu t te x ntate df m e a yr m h s nado “ e n rr a v o ) hs o h e e h hy i e a rl fo tet d f t t et t . , tt t f r t il a r h nr a p c gp ccso te nur ”ayo teaoei e r e ne ta r a t o m ri r t e f h ids y n f h bv ltd e r cs h et o l i n ai t, -s fe t le cn d a o o “ ewy nw c te r e n us o ws r vdt (rwrs o h e e ) os e t n ft a i h h h p ci qein a aie a o odt ta f c i ri h i i t r ” t ft m sh m k i te a . s r
S ma ys m otee rneltd bv a v iin o po s n oI ep tie i i r , o e fhr e cs s aoer a a os n rvi s f n rr a v ll fe ie e rt io t et N e o etate nr a nur p c grccstso w cteGv n e h eee o 2t rhnh “o m ids y ri p t e”e n h hh oe mn e ris t h l t i n ai t i r t r l. AteGv n e epis hi rdc rtxoI ep tieN e – oc n gwe ea sh oe mn x a , en ou oye f n rr a v o 2 cne i h h r t l nt t t t t et t rn tr r a d ueadee“ufo adet ec o eaite w e or a d – os ote et by n sl byr m n slo aht rsfhy e n et ” de n i l le r lr l h r t le t sf s fr ae frh ue frnain a enetd a y a s e D. Sp Rp B e e o h ts ote s ot sc o v ui r a p t s e e e’ up e y r f t t t a t l l e r l .S fs . l i a34Is a ta n ou oye aiuts n v a s nadw c cn eas e b e h t- n ed h i rdc rtx rc a a oe l t d . t , tt t t t le rl a r h h a bsiid yi e i tf tr ot o l ra v ts s fr i N e2 [] we e “ ep c hsbe st d n mne f w aenie e s e o h n o : 1 h h t r e a en el i a an t t t t t t tr h i te r cn s n w hh nr ap c g rccs fhids yn us o” w citee tate ost t i te o m ri p t e otenuri qein( h hshts h h ie t l i n ai t t i t t Gv n e ivksnh cs ad2 we e“ er e a be st dn mnecn s n oe mn noeit s ae n[] h h t p c hs enel i a an ost t r t i ) tr h i te r ie ..w hh wyh sl st s r efr a so ue wor n r a doi. Sed Te . i te ate ee el p cs os et by s h a o et t h m ei. h t l r te i l r e t le ” i rdc r tx oI ep tieN e tu hs oiniacidpne ote pcits n ou oye f n rr a v o 2 hs a n s i cne needn f h se f e t t t t et t gf t ic t o w c te Gv n e h e ee –i. we e “ ep c hsbe st d na mne n h h h oe mn e ris ., h h t r e a en el i i r t r l e tr h i te an r cn s n w h h nr a p c g rccs f hids y n us o ” Ad h scn tss ost t i te o m ri p t e ote nur i qein n te eode e ie t l i n ai t t . tt fr i I ep tieN e (e we e “ e r e a be st d n mne cn s n. . o h n n rr a v o 2i. h h t p c hs en el i a an ost t . t t et t ., t r h i te r ie w h h wy h sl st sp cs o s e t [n l e]by s hsn apcinh e i te a te ee el r e fr a s o ur a d ue ” a o p ia o e , t l r te i l et r) l t r bcuehsl it s ae K)md n s e wa ov t by ste Mc en B G e easteee nh cs( B ae oa s h see o ue o r ac ny C.Se lr i l t r r h l / Wa Eey M meo h T d C m u t So dKo Ao :D e m igh Acp bi h v t r e b f e r e o mn y hu n w bu e r i nte ce a l y r t a i l t t n t it o T nainV ufrR a d a y rnain(..Dp o H m ad eut Ar 20) f r sc o a eo et P t T sc os US e’ f o e n Scr y pl 07 a t l le r a t t l i i ( Cs m G dne nAcp bi o T nainV ui R a dP t T nain”a1 “ u o s u ac o ce a l y f r sc o a en et a y r sc os t 0 t i t it a t l le r a t ) (pedd oP’ Sp Rp B e (x a ig h te eode i I ep tieN e i apne t ls up e y r f epi n ta h scn ts n n rr a v o 2s . . l i) l n t t t et t l me t “ta os we te ee slte a e m cad e ob h etd n ur a d i i d o s uin h e h sl es h s m e hn s t o r a ad n l e t i t r lr l r i t le et p t s. ai ” re )
I su h wr o n taasv ap n ii b e, hGv n e pe s ose t fr e o hn ig h, ee l o t n s i steoe mn pa ta r i tr t t tt r i s t r f r ta r st ta hr ea ts a t o s n c moe s () h h hp cst suw e“eld n h tee vn e hs wdt c o pnn – 1we e er e ai ee st i t l t t ii t t t rt i s r te a an ostnw hteo m p c g rccs f hids ynus o” n () h h mne n s ti hnr a ri p t e o tenuriqein ad 2we e rc i e t l i n ai t t tr ter e r lc d o er e e m g f rf – sf h epct n f rf w e sp a hp cs e e e s m po c d a i i f t j t r no pot a ite xe a o o pot e a ea t i ti i r re ct inaoe n byn cn s nyw hh nr ap c grccsfhids y See. re o bv ad eod ost c i te o m ri p t e o enur e, g ir , ie t l i n ai t t. ., D. B ea1 ( d a nta hts swe e p c “ as i amnetac mosw h e’ r ft 7i i t gh tee i h h r e ws e n an h o pr i fs i n ci t t tri t r t t t nr a nur p ccs n ws xe et rs tn. a esnb pot)e pa s de) o m ids y r t e ad a epc do eu i.. raoa e r i ( mhs add l t ai t l l f” i ; sea o e’ Rp B e a 1 ( a ig h ts a “o m p c gp ccs oteg mn e l D. e y r f t 2f m te e s nr a ri r t e fr h a e s fs l i r n t l i n ai r t Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 0
p vl n sm in os m ayug e ssi n Cs m ue frnain a e e ,h r a oi o o fr u m jd mn u a ig u o s s ot sc o v u h e e ei t t r t tn t ’ a t l rt
Gv n e mspoeh ud p e rcr e dne s bse b h 1temnei w c oe mn u rvta n su deod v ec e a ihs o ()h an n h h r t t t i t i tl t r i
K’ p csw ee ad2“ e o m p c grccs ote a mna e b ids yad B r e e s, n()t nr a ri p t e”fh g e s m ynur n si r t h l i n ai r t s l t; ,
fr e () h Gv n e ms d mnr e h toe w a “ostn” u h, 3te oe mn u e os a ta hst or cn s t2 tr r t t tt t e i e. 9
TeGv n e fl o a cu s Te v ecta h Gv n e cet poe o h oe mn as nl on. h e dneh te oe mn i so rv h w r ti l t i t r tt
M Loy e K’ p css h , tbs Ad h e dneo nr a p c gp ccs n h r ob s B r eit na e. n te v ec f o m ri r t ei te . t s i i t i l i n ai
g mn a e b ids ysvta ynn xtn Mroe te Gv n e mksn ra a e s m y nur i i ul o- i e . o v, h oe mn ae o e r t s l t r l es t e r r t l
ae pt d mnr e h te mnei w c M Loy e K’ p csws ostn w h t m o e os a ta h an n h h r ob s B r e a cn s t i t t tt t r i . t s i ie t
nr aids y rcc –w c ite ud mnl h w g h teGv n e ms mkt o m nur p t e h hs h fna e asoi ta h oe mn u ae o l t ai i t n t r t t
e a iht e ie e t s m ay ug e h e s bsi nt mn o u m jd mn e. t l s tl t r t r
ids y . ,w h o e mu o pot ut n ne h c mays m u fci ” D . nur. . i s m a on f rf b li octe o pn i a a r al y ; e’ t t t i i t e it ) fs Sp B e a 8id a n tatsi we e p csw e s i a mne cn s n w h h up r ft ( i t g h e s h h r e e “e n an ost t i te . i n ci t t tr i r t r ie t nr ap c grccsfhids yadn mnebivdo e dqa t esrrcv y o m ri p t e o enur ni a an eeet b aeu eo nu eoe l i n ai t t, r l t e r o.. pot neK bc m am u fci ” i a 9ag n ta – o e os a tate f. a rf oc B ea e a r al y ; d t ( u g h t d mnr eh h i t e it ) . ri t tt t r a os p ewe K ad Mc en B Gn une p cs Mc en cu “e os a et nh b en B n ac ny C if ecd r e – ac ny o d d mnr e li i t l / l i l l tt tate r e. ws ei a mneta ws o cn s n w h h nr a p c g rccs f h h p c.. a s n an h an ost t i te o m ri p t e o t i t r t t ie t l i n ai te nur ad r ws o ei a mneta ws xe e t ui al yl apot ;d h ids y n o an t n an h a epc d o l m e i d rf” i t / ts r t t t ty e i) . ( d a n tatsi we e p c ws“ei a mne cn s n w h h nr a p c g i i t g h e s h h r e a s n an ost t i te o m ri n ci t t tr i t r ie t l in p ccs f hids y n o w h h epct n h . . potwl e and. H wv , r t e ote nur ad r i te xe a o ta . a rf i b e e” o ee ai t / t ti t i l r ) r n h gnh p t s pp s upr te o o osc a w-a ts(togide n se o i ite ai ’ ae sposh n in f uh t op te a huh os o e m tn re r t t r tl t t f - thd o su e h a m g o pots ne ni tenr a p c gp ccso ay af ce t a m ta re s t a i f rf iih e n h o m ri r t e f n rn i rt l i n ai ids y nur) t .
I s mfr upss f his n m in os m ay ug e , h s e e vntsi n u, o proe ote n a o o fr u m jd mn te o r ea e s tt t r t l l t t we e M Loy ep cs o K “ amnecn s n w hh nr ap c g rccs o h h r ob s r efr Bi tr . ti n an ost t i te o m ri p t e” f r ie t l i n ai te a mna e b ids y h g e s m y nu r r t s l t. 29 Se eeay u o sG dne nAcp bi o T nainV ui R a d a y e gnr l Cs m u ac o ce a l y f r sc o a en et P t l t i t it a t l le r T nain a78epi ntat poeh t nain a es ce a e easte r e r sc ost - (x a igh,o rvta r sc o v ui acp b bcueh p c a t ln t ta t l tl i ws eld n codnew h o m ids y rig rccs p t “ u [] ae b c v a st i acrac i nr a nur p c p t e a y ms 1 hv o eie te t l t i n ai , r t jt e dnefh nr ap c grccsfhids yn us o ad2p sne dneh te v ec o e o m ri p t e o enuri qein n[]r e v ecta h i t l i n ai t t t e t i t t n e p c ws eld n codnew h hsids y rccs. r s r r e a st i acrac i tee nur p t e” af i te t t ai ) Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 1
Attemne nw c K’ p csw eeteGv n e rpa d s e eta M soh an i h h B r e e s,h oe mn ee e yt s sh r r i si r t r t tl rs t .
Loy a “eae o p c st g xe eci te mn tlrdl h g u ns ” n ws ob hs dcds f r e ei ep ine n h e’ a o c t n bs e , ad a i - tn r s i e oi i s
– s M Loy u t “u y aa e f se ig raoa e r e e D edns t e e a r ob p i–f l cpb oa s n aesnb p c ”Se e na ’ St mn . t l l ss l i. f t a t
o M e a Fc A T W c Te A N Gn n I usT B T e (D. sSt mn o f a rl a s s o h h h e r o eu es e o e r d “e ’ t e e f ti t i r e i s i f a t
Fc ” 2 (seig h Loy“a ep ine i st g r efr a mn adwsf l as t )¶ 4 a r n ta ob ws xe ecd n ei p cs o g e s n a‘u y st t r tn i r t l
cpb o a e ig raoa er e ) qo n LoyDpsina16 D. up Rp aa ef s s n a esnb p c ” (u ig ob eot l ss l i’ t i o t 4) e’ p e y ; fsS . l
r fa7 0 o ee ii oeh go s bsta r ob hdh a l yo e r e aa B e t. H wv ,ts nt nt e a ihh M Loy ate bi t s p cst n i 3 r i tl t . it ti
aportlv.ts ue df e mt t e a ihh hi fcd s h e1 Te ra s prp a ee I q t ai e n ae o s bsta ena i o e. h g t t ie l i i f r t tr t l t t d r3 ee
cne inh teGv n e cu e rcfo M Loyws se il aa o g –., e ocs ota h oe mn o d x a r m r ob a e na y tu l y i.h s t r t l t t . s tl to e
30 Seloe.D. r fa6 a eig h Loy“ a ep ine ist g a mn e a , g e’ i t (s r n ta ob ws xe ecd nei g e s . , fsB e st t r tn r t p cs n ws‘u yaa ef se ig raoa er e )D. e yB e t (seig r e ad a f l cpb o a s n a esnb p c ” e’ p r fa7 a r n i l l ss l i ’ ; fsR l i st ta ob “o e es nia ep ine nhg mnids yn ..a a iaw hh w h Loy ps s si i cn xe ec itea e nurad .wsf mi i o t s s gf t r r t t lr t p cs r s i ..h ids y adh Loywsf l a a o h w oe r ie a mn r e a e n .ta nur ” nta ob a “u y w e f o t d e m g e i e t t t, t l r t n r t a e b p cs n mne h wu l m e e n ha e b r pot nets r u cs s m yr e ia an s l i rta o dui al a tes m earf oc i t t p o s t l t ty r s l i s a- t w ef l a oie” i a 1 (seig h “ vnh e es e xe ec i teg mn e u y mrzd ; d t 1 a r n ta g e i x n v ep ine n h a e r l t ) . st t i s t i r r t ids y M Loy wu ko h wp csa s i taids y adn ig h Loy nur r ob o d n w o r e r e n h nur ” n o n ta ob t, . l i e t t t, t t “ sf d h h wsf l cpb o a e ig raoa ep c ad g e . . h h i t ti ta e a ‘u y aa e f s s n a esnb r e n ar d . ta es ei e t l l ss l i’ e t ‘xe ecd n eig r efr a mn’ (u igLoyDpsint 4-7 ep ine i st p cs o g e s ) qo n ob eot a 164) r tn i r t” t io . 31 A d cse i g a rd a b o, h p cs h M Loy efr K nv ee s i u d n r t ei e wte r eta r ob s o B ee vn s s e e tl l i t . t r cv ete o pn’ epne K oe tdt ls ec ad v y e oi e s nefo oe dh c may xess B p a aao ah n ee ya f s xt c r m r s . re s r r t ie , te mte o pn bgn rdc oi 19 u i h c may esd p a osn 07Se ht eh c may ea pouinn 98 nl e o pn cae oe t ni 20 e, i t tt ri . e. D. Rp B ea5i pcl akold nta K “ i e]o an pot e a e . , e’ e y r ft ( m it cn w g gh Bfl dt e a rf ya f r g fs l i li y ei t a[ r i rt ya )P’ B ea1(seigh,oeey e oc may oe t n “ B t aepne e ” ls r ft 8a r ntafr v ya f o pn’ p a os K’ ol xess r; . i st t r r s ri , st eceei t aic m ec ya rs t g n lsfr ah e ” xeddt ol no e ah e ,eui i a o oec ya ) st r ln s r.
A a a d ii wr n ig h – l og te nis nqeinh e w e md i s n s e ts o h o n ta a huh h e r i us o e e ae n i, t t t t te t r r 20 20 – o p t sre r y nno min oc n g M Loy p c g rccs n 00 01 b h ai f l e oifr a o cne i r ob’ ri p t e ad / t re e y l t rn . s i n ai K’ oe t n oete nr l eote o pn ( o 19 t 20) W h u oe a y B p a os v h e i i f h c mayf m 97 o 07 i js n e l s ri r te f r . t t r ecp o nte p thsqeind h r eac o po t o sc ifr a o SeD. xe in e h a a us oe te e vne r rb y f uh no min e e’ t , i r r t l i t . fs Rsos t P’ St mn o Fc ¶2 (s oc t naea os et g o Gv n e ’ epne o ls t e e f a s 1 a t e a l gin r a n t oe mns . a t t ri l t li r t cu e l ma eig h “ ne he r st suw emd n00 n 20 ..ayiu s on r a , s r n ta s c teni ai ee aei20 ad 01 .,n f r t ci s t ti te s r ge fr 99ri e vnt t s c o” o 19 a r l a o h a in . ere t i t ) Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 2
ca c r ete r etah s frK a “esnb ” eas “ e u eosl mn ite h a e zdh p csh e e o B s raoa e bcuet n m u e e snh r ti i t t l h r e t
oe t gbde w eraoa e”SeD. r fa 8(tn adca c rig Loy p a n ug e esnb . e e’ i t1 cig n h a e z , ob ri t r l fsB e i , r ti n
Dpsina174) e paeadd3 TeGv n e ’e pa s n M Loy kolde eot t 4-8( mhssde)2 h oe mns mhs o r ob’ n w g io . r t i . s e
o p c g rccs osilt avnet cs f ri p t e delt o daci ae i n ai te s .
Te Gv n e ’ p n p ci cnen g K’ p css bod sein h M h oe mns r c a l m oc i r t iil a r n B r ei a ra a r o ta r s i st t .
Loyee o “ei d anabde i d e m igh p csh Mc en B G a t ob rid n d ae” nu ug sn e r i nte r eta ac ny C p do l tl l t t n i t l / i
K – h i ta “r e w e e bsduo bde ta po c d h epr r ic m ad B ta s h p cs e s ae pn ug s h r e e te xo e s no e n t, t i r t t t jt t’
epne adt lv ta ws xe e t ra a rf octe xo e st tu cs w e xess n aaee h a epc d o ep pot ne h epr r s r p o s e l t t i t ’ a- t r
f l a oie ” e D . Rp B ea23ca c righfrg n ateGv n e ’ u y mrzd Se e’ e y r ft - (h a e z te o o g sh oe mns l t . fs l i r ti n ei r t
“ o r ea ag mn ) D. B ea6a eigh “r e w e ae uo d ae bde ms e vn ru e ” e’ r ft (s r nta p cs e bsd pn ei d ug s tl t t ; fs i st t i r tl t
r a nt K’ a i p e poui t ad xess. B ta s osy gmc O s m et go B nc a d rdc v y n epne”3 u h i n a n uh n o e li s ti t ti )3 t t t i .
32 AteGv n e epis s h oe mn x a : r t ln
Se f a y we akdwa mdter eraoa e M Loyt e “ my pci l , hnse h aeh p c “ snb, r ob std[ ] i cl t i e l” . a f mi i w h hlbr o e ad m f mi i w h h p ne bde ad a iat i teao cn n n ya iat i te l nd ug s n lry t tt lry t a t biv g h toe h g..w e esnb..” H fr e epie ta i ee n ta hst ns. e raoa e . e u h x a d h, n l i t i r l. tr ln t h ids yar ewu b “n aoa e we “teoeierh o e ws i nur p c o d e ur snb ” h e e h ns o et r a s t, i l e l r i r d t h erg u y ee cls ] r u. g i s bn i a[ c o hr” e ol fi i t
D. B e a 1 (u igLoyDpsint 4-8 Se loe.D. e yB e t 1 e’ r ft 8 qo n ob eot a 174) e a , g e’ p r fa1 fs i t io . s . , fsR l i ( g n ta ob t e ta te Bp cs e ew e‘ aoa e” n ta [ ]e akd o a u g h Loystd h “ K r e h s e r snb, ad h “ whn se t ri t a th i tr e l’ t e br e pn h e eee te ie h s tb ‘ aoa e M ob stdta eas l o t uo wyh bivd hp cs e e oer snb, r oy t e i sbcue a a l r t e l’ .L a w h sd‘ aoa e bde ” qo n adca c rig ob eoi o a 164) i eue r snb ’ ug s e l t )(u ig n h a e z ,LoyDp sin t 4-7 d t , r ti n t ; . ( a n taLoy“ sf d h ter e h s fr Bw ebsd pn i‘ee o wai st g h ob t ti ta hp cs e e oK e ae uo h bi f h t ti t ei e t i t r s lf t og t ed p oig n b raoa e oteaocn no te a mn ”(u ig ob uh o n u cs n ad e esnb fr hlbr o e f h g e ’ qo n Loy t t l tt r t) t Dpsint 4) eot a16 io . 33 Seloe. D . St mno Fc ¶ 2-0a eigh “r e w e ae uo e a , g e’ t e e f a s ¶ 73 (s r nta p cs e bsd pn s . , fs a t t st t i r .. ei d ug s w c w ei eddoe e K’‘ at’ead g nc a d xess . d ae bde ” h h e “ tnetr lc B r l yrg i a i p e epne tl t i r n f t s ei r n ti t ad nc a d rdc o” nic dd mn l p nfr rdc o lbr o s n oeha n a i p e pouin adn ue “ o h l s o pouin aocs ad v ed ti t t l ty a t , t r epne o s adw c w e p p e frK b B G v ep s e o mnfc r ga xes cs, n h h e “r a d o B y C ’ i r i n f au t i , t” i r er s c ed t a un Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 3
lv, v y ee bss s r e o s mfr o bde( bt oncsal a o m,wt n ee ee sl aei p cs n o e o m f ug a e n ee r y fr a rt l r lr t i t li t si l ie
oe adh gao bs a ylc m e i s e ai t it tr a rf. TeGv n e ’ n ; nte o f a cl a o m cl a s c v ys o un pot h oe mns ) l il l r a l ti i r t
a ein h K’ p csw e e vdr m ug s n a i p e pot as m use f d s r o ta B r e e d ie fo bde ad nc a d rfst o e npci st t si r r t ti t i ie
p nite u ritu s gn i ad n e aat bl g yma n e . o tnhf u s hs o ee c n u v s s o ea e en g s i te r i rl rl ils
Te v ecta h Gv n e cet spo i gn azdl msi i r as a h e dneh te oe mn i so uprt ee l e ci is ma y brc i t r tt t s ri a ll t t
ad ak g nsf c n se fi . Cnp uu y ak g se dne h ds ie w h n lc n i ui e pcit i fi t i c y os cos lc n i v ec ta ec bs i i l i i t r t
p t u r y o M Loy sdh “ei d anabde ta h Gv n e tu t d ie ai l i h w r ob uete d ae” nu ug sh te oe mn o so e v rc at . tl l t t r t t r
p cs o K. Fr x m ete v ec o wih h Gv n e ris as o dqal r e fr B o ea p, h e dne n hc te oe mn ee flt aeu e i l i r t l i ty
epi we e we M Loy p c g rccsw en net yl a rf frK 3 (n x a h h / hn r ob’ ri p t e e i eddoi d pot o B ad ln tr . s i n ai r t e i 4 ,
‘ui gy n t ie’ n n ne ad h K p n mng ”(u ig n o cigLoy qat u adr n , a eg e , n te B l t aae ) qo n ad ri n ob ly a r i r a r t / t Dpsint 5 196 166 P’ RsossoD. Fsad h dn roa r s D . eot a17 5-0 6-7 ls epnet e’ it n T rI e g o e; e’ io , , ;. fs r i t r t i ) fs B e a 6 a eig h p csw e ae o “ei d nu bde w c ic dd mn l r ft (s r n ta r e e bsd n d ae ana ug s h h n ue o h i st t i r tl l t i l ty p nfr rdc o lbr o s n oeha epne o s (u igP’ Rsoss oD . l s o pouin ao cs ad v ed xes cs ” qo n ls epnet e’ a t , t r t) t . fs FsI e oa r s i a1 (seigh “r e w e ebsd pn ei d ug s.ta it n r g o e; d t 7a r nta p cs e s ae uo d ae bde ..h r tr ti ) . st t i r t tl t t w e rp e frK b B G v e rs e o mnfc r ga qat gy n t ie’ n e p a d o B y C ’ i p i n f au t i , ‘ui u adr n, a r er s c ed t a un ly a r eg e, n te K p n mng , ad h “ ]c ya spo c dbde ws n ne t n ne ad h B l t aae ” n ta [ ah e ’ r e e ug ai edd o i r a r t e r jt t t r lc K’ ‘ at’rg d ga i p e epne ada i p e pouin ;i a 1 ee f t B r l y ea i nc a d xess n nc a d rdc o” d t 9 s ei r n ti t ti t t ) . ( f r g o ei oy h p cs w e bsduo po c dbde ” i a 2 ( a n ta r ei t ts mn ta r e e “ae pn r e e ug s ; d t 0 st g h ern t t i r jt t) . ti t “ B p csw eebsd pn ei d ug s ;D. Rp B ea23ag nta“r e K’ r e e s ae uo d ae bde ” e’ e y r ft-( u gh p cs si r t tl t ) fs l i ri t i w e e bsduo bde ta po c d h epr r ic m adepne” i a 4n e s ae pn ug s h r e e te xo e s no e n xess ; d t . r t t t jt t’ ) . 9 ( f r g o tebde uo w c M Loybsdh p c gdcin fr K ” i a 6 r ei t “ ern h ug s pn h h r ob ae i ri e s s o B ;d t t i . s i n io ) . (seigh “r e w eebsd pnr e e bde ” i a1(seigh “ B p cs a r nta p cs e s ae uo po c d ug s ;d t 2a r nta K’ r e st t i r t jt t) . st t si w e e bsduo d ae po c dbde ” D. Sp Rp B e a 7 a eig h e s ae pn ei d r e e ug s ; e’ up e y r f t (s r n ta r t tl jt t ) fs . l i st t “r e w e e . bsd pn ei d ug s. p cs e s .. ae uo d ae bde ” i r t tl t) 34 A oe o t nt b e, h Gv n e stsll ta“ B p csw e e bsd t n p ni i r f te oe mn t eft h K’ r e e s ae i s is r t a ay t si r t uo d ae bde w c iacr ewu hv ere K a r io eey a mns d – pn ei d ug s h h f cu t o d ae and B pot n vr gr e o ” tl t i, a, l f tl se ig id a nta K’ p cse e e a epct nfrf fo DyOefrdc o e m l n cigh B r er lc d n xe a o opotr m a n opouin n y it t si f t ti i t . Se e’ B e a 2 ( mhs add se lo da 1 (seig ee l ,w hur e ne e D. r ft 0 e pa s de) e a i t 7 a r n gn a y i o e r c fs i i ; s . st rl t t f e t ay mf m tap cs e w e e“ amneta . ws xe et rs tnh sl o nt er e h r e h e e s i i a , ti r r t n an h .. a epc doeu ite ee r t t l lr raz g raoa e rf” i a1 (seig w h oe pr l ma o –h “r e w e ei n aesnb pot ; d t 9a r n – i nt mo l it n ta p cs e li l i) . st t a i ti t i r s t poue raoa e rf frK bsd pn r e e bde ” D . Sp B e a 9 e o rdc a esnb pot o B ae uo po c d ug s ; e’ up r ft t l i jt t ) fs . i (seig– w hurs vin– h Loy e p cs w h h epct n h . . pot a rn st i o ee a o ta ob s r e “i te xe a o ta . a rf t t rt t t i t ti t i Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 4
i s te n ne m g o ay uhpot3 Ide te Gv n e i n c a ee at f o h i edd a i f n sc rf)5 ned h oe mn s o l r vn s o , t rn i. , r t t e
[ o db e nd .H wv ,h uqaf dt e e iaod w hh Gv n e ’ psin wu ] e a e” o eeta nui e st mn st ds i te oe mns ot l r ) r t li a t t r t io a aiutdle h e nt b e. Nrs uh n sein upr d y hrcr e dne src a e we i i r f oi sc a a r o spo e b teeod v ec t le s r s is st t i .
Is a teGv n e ’ psin pe s o e h te r eta M Loy e w e n ed h oe mns ot apa t bta h p cs h r ob s e t , r t io r t i t . t r ee u l epc doi d pot o K, un “ ‘ et tu ya. See’ St mn vn ay xe et yl a rf fr Bb o i t s r p e s” eD. t e e tl t e i t t n h a- r’ fs a t o Fc ¶ 1cig ob Dpsint 6 19 seloe.i ¶ 3-2a eigh “ ws f a s 3(t Loy eot a10 6) e a , g d ¶ 13(s r nta i a t in io , ; s .,. st tt epc dh,f rh s r u paete r e h gdwu ..i d raoa e rf, ad xe eta aetet t p hs,h p c ca e o d. yl aesnb pot n t t t a- i r l e l i” ta “ whn K bgnpouin n19 i ws xe e t bc m a m u adpotb h [ ]e B ea rdc o i 98 t a epc d o eo e a r n rfa e t t , t te i l mnfc r gal yw h ae ya ”(t g ob Dpsint 6 148 P’ Rsoss au t i fci i i f w er )ci Loy eot a11 8-5 ls epne a u n it t n s in io , ;. t D. T rI e oa r s( mhss de) D. B ea1-8a eigh “]e ws o e’ h dn r g o e e paeadd e’ r ft 71(s r nta [ h e a fs i t r t i ) ; fs i st tt r n a i pin f rf i ‘ et tu ya, ad h “] ws xe e ta a etet tu o nc a o o pot nt s r p e s” n ta [t a epc d h, f r h s r p ti t i h a- r’ ti t t t a- paete r e h gdwu . . i d raoa e rf” i a 1 (seig h, n 98 hs h p c ca e o d . yl a esnb pot ; d t 8 a r n ta i 19 , i r l e l i) . st t , potws xe et “o ew h ae ya ” D. Rp B ea23a eigh Loy rf a epc do c m i i f w e s ; e’ e y r ft - (s r nta ob i t tn r ) fs l i st t s p cs aaee h ws xe et ra a rf octe xo e st tu cs w e u y e r e “ lv ta a epc doep pot neh epr r s r p o s e f l ti t l t t i t ’ a- t r l a oie” i a6a eigh p cse e e “ e xe a ota we K bc m am u mrzd ; d t (s r nta r er lc dt epct nh hn B ea e a r t ) . st ti f t h ti t te mnfc r g al yi wu e n pot ; i a 78 a eig h Loy e p cs i a au t i fci ,t o d a a rf” d t - (s r n ta ob s r e “ a u n it l r i) . st t t i n mneta wu ui al e n K] pot nets r u cs w e u y mrzd ;i an h o dl m e a [ Ba rf oci t t p o s e f l a oie” d r t l t ty r i s a- t r l t ) . a 1 (seig h “ Bws oepc d o e rfa et h bg n g ; da 1 (seig t 0 a r n ta K a n xe e t b potb ate e n n” i t 2 a r n st t t t i l ii ) . st ta p csw e e w h xe a o ta“ raoa e rf [ o d b e nd y K] f rt h r e e s i epct n h a esnb pot wu ] e a e b [ B a ei ti r t t ti t l i l r t [ea e a m u fci ” D . Sp B e a 8 a eig h p csw e e“ a mne bc m ] a r al y ; e’ up r ft (s r n ta r e e s i t e it ) fs . i st ti r t n an r bivdo e dqa t esrrcv y f. a rf oc K bc m am u fci ” i eeet b aeu eo nu eoe o.. pot ne B ea e a r al y ; d l t e r i t e it ) . a 9 a eig h Loy e p csi a mneta ws xe e t ui al yl a rf” t (s r n ta ob s r e “ st t ti n an h a epc d o l m e i d pot ; r t t t ty e i) D. Sp Rp B ea7a eigh p csw e e“i te xe a o oa rf oc e’ up e y r ft (s r nta r e e s w hh epct n f pot ne fs . l i st ti r t t ti i K m u d eod h s r u pae . B a r byn tet t p hs” te a- )
I adints oc a weteGv n e cn nsK’s r u paews o pt n d t , i n l r hnh oe mn o ed B t t p hs ac m e, io i te r t t s a- le sc taa rf wu hv be epc d Fr x m ete i a ih e a b u y n h uh h pot o d ae en xe e o ea p, h es n ne n m g t i te t i l t. l r rt ii Gv n e ’rp snt n h “ 19 K ws xe e t bc m a m u mnfc r g oe mns er e a o ta i 98 B a epc d o eo e a r au t i r t e ti t n , t te a un fci ad rf wu c m w h ae ya.. Te nistsu w emdw h toe al y n pot o d o e i i f w e s . h e r a se e aei i hs it i l tn r. te i r tn f sf w er”Se e’ B e a 1 ( mhs add se lo e’ St mn o Fc ¶ 3 i te ya . e D . r ft 8 e pa s de) e a D. t e e f a s 3 r s fs i i ; s fs a t t (seigh “]e nistsu w emdw h te r f w er o K s r n pouin) a r nta [ h e r a se e ae t nhf s e ya f Bt t g rdc o ” st tt te i r ii it s ai t ( mhs add Teosr e neotoe r f w e s cn eed n o e )on c e e pa s de) hloee r ct “ sfs e ya ” a bra( cn x tid a i . fe h it r i tt it ta h Gv n e cn nsh K wstln st tu paen 00 01 h d e ote h te oe mn o edta B asl i s r p hsi 20 20 te a s fh t r t t t i i t a- / , t e r sn us o use e.i ¶ 3-2a eigh “ whnK bgnrdc oi 19 ni i qein te , g d ¶ 13(s r nta [ ]e B ea pouinn 98 te t .B .,. st t t , i ws xe e t bc m a m u adpotb mnfc r g al yi i a e ya ” t a epc d o eo e a r n rfa e au t i fci w h f w er ) t te i l a u n it t n s ( mhs add se lo e’ B e a 2 ( f r g o K’ s r u pae we lt o n e pa s de) e a D . r ft 3r ei t “ B t t p hs ‘ hnil r o i ; s fs i ern s a- te pouinws apn g ) Teeodslo o b b rnf v ec ad s n p n sc rdc o a hpe n’ . hrcria n a y a e oe dne dr s g o t uh t i ” s tl r i ei i s ate e nin f “ a-p pae r e o te y c drin ft tu oe t ni te s h d i t o a s r u” hs o p id htp a u t os r p p a os n h fio tt r , i l ao a- ri g mna e b ids y n u n e.te sap ideu et a oiet tu cs)ad a e s m ynur( c d g . ,h uu e orq rdo mrzs r p o s n r ts l t ili, g l r i t a- t, h wog nr a yae g mna e b f mt so a rf. ts n n ee , n su d o lni o mltks a e s m yi so h w potI , ay vn ud p e t l r t s l r i ii t i t ta– v tei ote o pn –K nv tre a rf. h oe hl e f h c may B ee und pot t r f r i Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 5
we e wete r eta M Loy e w e e get cv K’ cs.6 Teog nte h h / hnh p csh r ob s e ds ndo oe B o s3 hln adh tr i t . t r i r s t
35 TeGv n e ce n e dne unf ni aywy n potm g ta ws ut h oe mn i s o v ec qa iy gn n a ayrf a i h a b l r tt i ti i rn t i i oh p csh M Loy eote x note rf tah p csw ete w e xe e n te r eta r ob s rh e e fh poth i r e e o ri epc d t i t . t tt i tsi r h s t t yl Is a teGv n e r e o y au y n gn a yo “ aoa e pot o oi d n ed h oe mn e r n vge ad ee l t ar snb ” rf – r e. t , r t fs l l rl e l i , eels d i t e ,o s mlv o pot e, g D. St mno Fc ¶ 1a eig vne e ni l t “o eee f rf. ee. e’ t e e f a s 3 (s r n s fiv y l i”S . , fs a t t st ta“ ws xe e ta a etet tu pae h p c cagdwu .. i d raoa e h i a epc d h, f r h s r p hs te r e h e o d. yl a esnb tt t t t a- , i r l e l pot (t gLoyDpsint 6 P’ Rsoss oD. T r I e oa r s D . rf” ci ob eot a 11 ls epnet e’ h d n r g o e; e’ i) in io ;. fs i t r t i ) fs B ea2 (seigh p cs eb Loyw e bsd pn n xe a ota[ B wu . r ft 0a r nta r es y ob e “ae uo a epct nh K] o d i st ti t r ti t l . raz s m lv o pot ( mhs add i (seig h lc o Mc en B G . eie o e ee f r i) e pa s de) d a r n ta ak f ac ny C l l f” i ; . st t l / if ec i d mnr e b fcta K’ p cspo c d i p “”pot o use f d n une s e os a d y a h B r e r e e s m y a rf, f npci l tt t t s i jt l i ie a on;sea oi a 1-8 r eig o“ raoa epot ;d a 1 ( f r g o“ mu ) e l d t 71 ( f r t a esnb rf” i t 9 r ei t a t s . ern l i) . ern raoa e rf” D . Rp B ea 1 ( f r g o aesnb pot. esnb pot ; e’ e y r ft 2r ei t “raoa e rf” l i ) fs l i ern l i)
Aa , s o d bv ii ud p e ta K nv gn a d pot g na n e aoe ts n su d h B ee ee t a rf. i t , i t t r re i 36 Asv a p n i i b e, h Gv n e sts–ueu oa yadw hu ay t ee l o t nt r f te oe mn t e r is s is r t a nq vcl n i o n i l, t t l ma o atte mf m –h M Loy p c grccsw e e get esrta K i it nsoht er e ta r ob’ ri p t e e ds ndo nu h B ti i a t . s i n ai r i e t wu a es“ra ee” i. eoplo h c may cs)r mDyOefh c may o dt a b k vn(., cu a f e o pn’ o sfo a n o e o pn’ l l t e er l t s t t s oe t n SeD. B e a 1 (t gLoy Dpsina 10 19 sea o d a 2 p a os e e’ r f t 7 ci ri . fs i i n ob eot t 6 6) e l i t 0 io , ; s . (seig w h o ma o tap cs eb Loyw e bsd pn n xe a ota[ B a r n i nl it n h r es y ob e “ae uo a epct nh K] st , t i ti , t i t r ti t wu cv i epne” D . Rp B ea1 (seig w hurs vin h Loy e o d oe t xess ; e’ e y r ft 2a r n i o ee a o ta ob s l rs ) fs l i st , t t r t , t t K’ p csw h xe a o “ aa bde d o s wu b cv e” D. Sp B e a B r e i epct nt tl ug e cs [ o d e oe d ; e’ up r ft si t ti h l t t l ] r ) fs . i 9 a eig w hu qaf a o ta p csw e e“i te xe a o taa cs wl e (s r n i o ui cin h r e e s w h h epct n h l o s i b s t , t t li t , t i r t t ti tl t l rcv e” eoe d. r )
E e h eh wv ,h Gv n e tks cniig ot nci ign edh te l we , o ee te oe mn ae a ofc n psi ,l m is ata h s r r r t lt io a n t t p cs e b M Loyw e n ne t cv K’ cs o y f r“ a-p oe t n w e r e s y r ob e i edd o oe B o s n ae s r u” p a os e i t . r t r s t l t tt ri r cn ue e, g D . St mno Fc ¶ 1a eigh “ ws xe eta a ete oc dd ee. e’ t e e f a s 3 (s r nta i a epc dh,f rh l .S . , fs a t t st tt t t t s r u paetep c cagdwu cv epne”(t gLoyDpsint11 P’ t t p hs h r e h e o d oe xess ci ob eot a 6 ls a- , i r l r ) in io ;. Rsoss oD . T r I e oa r s D. B e a 1-8 a eig h “ ws xe e epnet e’ h d n r g o e; e’ r ft 71 (s r n ta i a epc d fs i t r t i ) fs i st tt t ta a etet tu pae h p c cagdwu cv epne” Ii uc a we eay h,f rh s r p hs te r e h e o d oe xess. ts n e h h n t t a- , i r l r ) lr tr p t fh cnu oite xt geodeusr mh p t s ue f mrc ee m o g a ote ofs nnh e s n rcr rs tfo te ai ’ s oi p i t i l y r i ii l re es r n o , fl g o iig s a og rdc o cs, p a n cs, n o e c eo e o cs (uh ai t dt u h mn pouin o soe t g o sad t r a gr s f o ssc in sn i t t ri t h t i t as r u cs) st t p o s a- t.
I ay vnte i n d p eh, ote nr y f s e l 1 ya o oe t n K n n ee ,h es oi u ta frh e i t oi na y 0 e s f p a o B t r st t te t r r ri , nv octre a rf, n i fc cn s n y p a dt ls e, g D. Rp B e ee neund potad na, ost t oe t aao .See. e’ e y r f r i , t i el r e s . , fs l i a 5i pcl akold n ta K “ i e] o an pot e a e ya ) P’ St mn t ( m it cn w g g h B fl dt e a rf ya f r e ” ls t e e li y ei t a[ r i rt r; . a t o Fc ¶ 3st gh “ B t aepneeceet a no en ah e rs t gn ls f a s 2( a nta K’ ol xess xeddol c mi ec ya eui i ao t ti t st ti r ln s frec ya ” w hn “rf o ay o ” (t gi e a a Loy Aia t¶ 3-1 ( o ah e , i o pot f n sr ) ci , n r l , ob f dv ¶ 03) a r t i t in t i f i st mn ta te Gv n e “e e fr ako koldeo ifr a o ” huh h t e e h h oe mn dn s o lc f n w g r no min tog te a t t r t i e t , Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 6
Gv n e a o ocdsh tet e e ispo e b LoyAia t 3) P’ B ea oe mn l cneeta h st mn s upr d y ob f dv ¶ 4 ls r ft r ts t a t t f i ;. i 1 (seigh, oeey e oc may oe t n “ B t aepne eceei t a 8a r nta fr v ya f o pn’ p a os K’ ol xess xedd sol st t r r s ri , st t t ic m ec ya rs t gn lsfr ah e ” i a2 (a e P’ Rp B ea2s m ; no e ah e ,eui i ao oec ya ) d t 2s m ; ls e y r ft (a e r ln s r; . ) . l i ) i a3s m ;da91 (a e i a1 (a e P’ Sp B ea1s m ;da4s m ;d d t (a e i t -0s m ;d t 7s m ; ls up r ft (a e i t (a e i . ) . ) . ) . . i ) . ) . a5s m. t (a e)
H h g ig h fc ot s ae Mc en r ss h qeinwy asna ue s i l h n te a s f h cs ac ny a ete us o h – be by ’ gi t t i , l i t t r “ f ec” v teee– n sl ta ee e yaetraz arf oi s e( uhe i l ne oe hsl ayee h rpa d fldoeie pot n sa s mcls nu r lr lr t tl i l i t l s cn ne t pe p c alse)wu n fec mee t tk ainsc a b r s gt o iud o i u a u o s o d o e o pld oae c o (uh s y ai i t l tl s l t l l t in s p cs n ose n o adin cs m s i a e o t aam i u,tnhh b e n r e ad r ek g u d t a u o e ) n nf r o t i m ms ctel d g i / i t i o l t r, ft , n a ei. Se e. P’ Rp B e a 1 ( g n ta w hK cn s n y p a n aa o , [ o c e, g ls e y r ft 0 a u g h, i B ost t oe t gt ls “]g ., . l i ri t t i el ri s l i wu dt e cag..i eaic aen p csn a so ac nyB G oa a p g o di a a hne. e h nn esi r ei s et [Mc en C ] r c ma n l ct tr r i l l / i tf d n sloteby str e mrl e traz arf fr K] ;e a olsB e o n adet o r ue ap cs o i l oeie poto[ B ) el P’ r f i l h r i eky l i ”s s . i a1 ( g nta we by ad eea n r a dsl fcdw hee else wu t 9a u gh, h e ue n sl r o et , ee ae i rpa do s o d ri t r r lr e t l e lr t t s l “ek o e bs e w hh hp oe n g pot ; d( g nta g e cn nelse se[ t r u ns i te oe f a i a rf” i a u gh,i n o iudo s ] h i s t rn i) . r i t v t s, “ K w e or a d oB G . , od u ns snewu dt ei eta K r s ]t i B e n et t C . . go bs e es o d i a e h h B a e i f r t le i s l ct t r t i[ s p csfri s et B G r h K f d ad e[t o e cs m st r e[ e ig a r e[o t a s o C ota Bi [ n sl o t r u o e a p cs yl n] i ]s l t n] l] h t r i id raoa e rf” P’ Sp B ea5ag nta“ ws ocn s n w hnur p cc esnb pot ; ls up r ft ( u gh i a n ost t i ids y r t e l i) . . i ri tt t ie t t ai o Mc en’t nain w h n l e sl s o K t cn ne. t sl o Mc en a r ac ny r sc os i ur a d ee fr B o o iu.. o e t ac nyt l sa t t et l r t l l p csh nv rcv e [ B ] o s w huala ty g oid nl ra v by ” r eta ee eoe d K’ cs, i o tes r n t f a aenie ue ) i t r r s t t t t i n t t r.
TeGv n e mks mc ote a tate i n st oy r te a hr y h h oe mn ae uh f h fc h h es ot u r o o r u ot ta r t t t r at h t i t rsi s h ue frnain a e n etd a y a s o n toe ae we te ee hs ertte s ot sc o v ui r a p t s et o y hs css h e h sl a tc a t l le r l l r lr mrta oe u o ead r ucs u yun a rf. See. D. B ea1-7ag n o hn n cs m n osce f ltrs pot e, g e’ r ft 61 ( u g e t r / sl i . , fs i ri ta“ e i n a hr y otepoot n h t nainv u ape o ywe te ee h t r s o u ot fr h rpsi ta r sc o a e p is n hn h sl t he t i io t a t l l l lr mksapot ad h “n i e [9 CFR §12 0() oi i ep t en e nray ae rf, n ta []t r 1 ... 5 131 rt n rri o s o n i” t eh . ] s t ev t , st oy u otrq rshrazinf poto rnain a eo p yo r a d a y t u r a hr yeu eteeia o oarf fr asc o v ut ap t aet p t at t i i l t i t t l l le r s e ; e a o da 1 ( g n ta a a mt ol wiii e vn “ h h apot ws a ” se l i t 0 a u g h, s ae f a,tsr l a we e rf a l) s . ri t tr re t tr i razd ;D . Rp B e a 6 ag n ta“ e a et u sy n h g bu h w mn eie” e’ e y r ft ( u g h t v u st e as o i ao o ay l ) fs l i ri t h l at tn t cs m s sl my ae nise rg d g sl ’ potbi ” i a1 ( g nta u o e a ee a hv adsi n ea i a ee s rfa l y ; d t 0a u gh t r lr lt rn lr i it ) . ri t “ e i n i ep t en ei i n teapcbi o t nainv u i r a dp t t r s o n rri o l mig h p ia l y f r sc o a e n et a y he t ev t t l it a t l le r t naint s uini w c te ee a ul razs pot ;d a 1 ( g n ta“ r sc os oi a os n h h h sl c a y eie a rf” i t 2 a u g h i a t tt i lr t l l i) . ri tt mksn df ec t arnainv u a e mn we ete ee hsoe u o e o a ae o i e ne o t sc o a e s s e h h h sl a n cs m r fr a t l ss t tr lr t r tosn” se eeay e’ B ea56 D . Rp B ea81 huad ;e gnr l D. r ft - e’ e y r ft -2 ) l fs i ; fs l i .
Y tem e bec oaearq r mnde n ncsal rnei e vntea e h e asne f lg eu e e os o ee r yed r l a hfc t r l i t t si rre t t ta K n o ynv tre apot b oe td ah n eeyya a a o , o a olo h B o n ee und rf, u p a ec ad v t t l r i t re r e t ls fr t a f r s t ruh n e e s Mroe w li sreh M Loya e p cs ne o e m b we og yi ya. o v , he ituta r obr sdr e ocs mi e e en l n r e r i t t . i i t t l e u 19 adht m ote nistsu h en 00 01 h p cic ae b os a J y 99 ntei e fh e r ai e e i 20 20 ta r en es ov u y t l te s r / , ti r i l ws osf c n o oe K’ cs, eas – ow h ad ghic ae te o pn sl a n ui e t cv B o sbcue n i s n nten es –h c maytl t fi t r s t t tt i r i cn netls mny Se e’ St mno Fc ¶ 4 4 (o nta Loya e p cs o iudooe oe e D . t e e f a s ¶ 1 3 n igh ob r sd r e t . fs a t t , t t i i Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 7
“o e m a eJ y 619” n oc aa “ 20”(t g ob Dpsint 5-520 s mi ef r u 2 99 ad ne g ni 05 ci Loy eot a135 0) t t l , i n ) in io , ; selolsB ea2( a nta Loyn esdK’ p cs n tienh c may n e e a P’ r ft 1st gh obic ae B r e o y w ite o pn’ i s . i ti t r si l c s n ya o oe t n fs “ote a sao i 20 ” n te oc aa , nDc me 20) e s f p a o –it fr h fl esn n 00 ad hn ne g ni ee b 05 r ri r, l , i r D. B e a 1 (se il tes m. I l h o K’ ssie rcr o lse te e’ r f t 9 e na y h a e n i t f B u a d eod f o s h fs i s tl ) g s tn s, Gv n e ’ ci tafr e p cic ae w e nee ay bcuei d g. po c d oe mnsl mh u h r en ess e uncs r “eas d i n.. r e e r t a t tri r r s vi jt t a cs b . .po c d q v e u t yls f u q t c s t te no ep c”s ol o s y . r e e eu a n ns i d ai r ue l e o h iv c r e i t t jt ilt i e ge i o i i cr u t syhla.Se e’ Rp B ea1 n 6 I o e wrs fateGv n e u os o atees e D. e y r ft 1. . nt r od i(sh oe mn i , t fs l i 1 h , r t ps l e iv c p ci eu a n o r e et acs d ie b po c d u u te i o uts no e r es q v e t po c dol o si dd y r e e o p ,h es ta ) i i ilt jt t t v jt t t r ov u y o rf aa – n oewu a u eh,n ee la o nap cic aewu b os n pottl ad n o d s mta i gn a p e i r en es o d i l i l l s t r, t tl i r l b oe fh o in o tea e e n ote p os n htb. t l
Te Gv n e m nis h,a a mt o c m e i rat “rfsa n h oe mn a t n ta s r t ia t ae f o m cl ei , pot r o tr r a ly i e t ga n e eeit nain b we ur a d ais adh “ i n aa uuu fr e u a ed vnnr sc os e en n l e p t ” nta i s o tl nsa o n w rt , a t t et re tt t l l c ma e n t e n pot oeet fll g h –nhfsf w e s f xtne Se o pn s o o a a rf – r vnoa a oe e iteite ya oe s c ” e i t r i i t tr r r ie . D. B ea2 selo d a eigh, eas “r efr odtahv n be poue e’ r ft 0 e a i (s r nta bcue p csogosh ae o enrdcd fs i ; s . st t i t t a s bsd pn nc a d xess tsl as o i eh te xesswl eih ad r e ae uo a i p e epne ii awy ps b ta h epne i b h e n et ti t , sl t l gr te xe e pot wln m e az ” h “]razdpotde n ,b i e, ed te h epc d rf i o a rl e ta [ n l e rf os o yt l rne h t i l t t ii , t u e i i t sf r c c m acsfa uuu fo a u nss np n” nta“p o c os a b wog n i u s ne os e nsa r m bs e t do t adh [] j t ncn e rn ad r t l l i s a i, t r ei n wbs e e myhv mr ‘r w gp n ta a i p e” D. Rp B e a 91 e u ns s a ae o goi a s hn nc a d ; e’ e y r f t -0 i s e n i’ ti t ) fs l i (seig h “nobs e , vnoe eig our a d u o e,sga n e t e na a r n ta [] u ns ee n sl t n l e cs m si u a ed o a st t i s ln et t r rt r pot ad h “ ] ee sak f rfa l ys o ncsal a osqec o p cs e g rf, n ta [ sl ’lc o potbi i n ee r y cneune f r e b n i” t a lr i it t si i i s too, r f o u o b we by ad ee i myu b a osqec o ua i p e e ol wo oc ls n e en ue n sl ; ajs e cneune f nnc a d t l i t r lrt t ti t fc r sc albr o sh tr o t b h h tatoeh w en ueite r e e a o, uh saocs ta un u o ei e hnhsta e ic ddnh po c d ts t t t gr t r l jt bdeuo w cter e w e ae” a huh i p hptl gh teGv n e de ug pn h hh p cs e bsd –l ogi s e asei ta h oe mn os t i i r t t r ln t r t n ad s we e tsesnb t ac b na y dcd swr ocn s n o e yaa e o dr s h h i raoa eos ie e l a eae o hf ost t s s e f r t e t ri l r r ’ t i e l s, r t ya t fc r sc a ud ei a d xess r v ei a d rdc v y e,oa o uh s ne s m e epne o oe s m e poui t) r ts rt t rt t ti .
D w gab g l eb we po c dpotad h a u raz in fpotte r i a n r h i e en r e e rf n te c a e ia o o rf, h it n t jt i tl l t i Gv n e ’ psin e mt bta – rv e taa ee s r et aetd ueala oe mns ot se s o e h po dd h sl ’ p cs o r a by tes r t io t i t lr i le r t pro t r lcs m a o ac frpot–tso n m mn we e aypot v ra y upr o e e o e l wne o rf ii f o o e h h n rf ee el t f t l i t tr i r l m e azs oee we ete eei o r hh mrhg gmny nuigms vlse a rl e(r vn h h h sl s ui t e o a n oe icr n a ieo s t ii tr lr t g r i , r s s ya a e ya a e ya. Se e. D. B e a 1 ( g n ta ueot nainv u i e f r e f r e ) e,. , e’ r f t 7 a u g h s fr sc o a e n rt rt r g fs i ri t a t l r a d a y a s os orq r sl ’ “ azin f pot ad h ii eog i i e et p t s e de n eu e ee s r l a o o a rf, n ta ts nuhf n r le r l t i l r ei t i” t ,t a ate r e wsxe e t rs tnh sl mk g raoa e rf”( mhs add l ,h p c “ aepc d oeu ite ee a n aesnb pot e pa s de) i i t l lr i l i) i ; D. Rp B ea5 d i n Mc en’ ag mn h “ hn sl ..aso an pot e’ e y r ft (e d g ac ny ru e ta we a ee .flt e a rf fs l i ri l s t t lr i r i yaa e ya ..hr a os p ewete uead ee ms aen unete r e . e f r e ,.teet nh b enh by n sl u rt r li i t r l r thvif ecdh p c” l i )
TeGv n e cn nsh wa s e r ia vit s aesh “ e oeoarf h oe mn o edta h i d e m t enh csita t hp f pot r t t t t t ni i t h i wsm nie ya ae ya. Se e’ Rp B e a 1 ( mhss de) A Mc en a a t nd er f r er” e D. e y r ft 0 e pae add s ac ny ia t fs l i . l sge sh wv , i aa qeinwe e – be teif ec” f r a d ue – sl ugs, o ee i s f r us o h h asn h “ l ne oaet by a ee t rt i t tr t nu le r lr cn s n y p a n aa o cu o wu ke i do oe id i t y h efr e l a ost t oe t gt ls o d r o d ept or pn ne ne (e , o na y i el ri s l l s s f il r r Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 8
so otemt ita hrcr e dneas o dqal epi h w ug sw e sdo hr fh ae sh teeod v ecfl t aeu e x a o bde e uet t tr t i i ty ln t r
d e m e h p cstsu h e e r i te r e ai e e . t n i s r
TeGv n e p n t c t nei oyh ds iei bodtoete rcsta h oe mn o t o e a ts mnta ec bsn ra s ksh poe h r t i s ri t t r r s t
ws sd o ete r e o K atei e h c mayws one ad x aotsr mh a ue t s h p c fr Bt ht mte o pn afudd n e rp a fo ta t i , t le t
fr usqe ya u t 20 e gnr l D. B e a 1-9 cig i e a a Loy o sbeun e s p o 01 e eeay e’ r f t 81 (t , n r l , ob t r .S l fs i in t i
Dpsint 7-3177 118) se lo e’ Rp B e a 1 n 6 B t s v ec eot a 127 7-8 8-2 e a D. e y r ft 1. . u h e dne io , , ; s fs l i 1 ti i
dcd.See. P’ B ea1( mhsigh Gv n e ’ psinsh, ee] B G eae e, g ls r ft 9e pa z ta oe mns ot ita“ vn f C ) ., . i in t r t io t[ i adK w e or a d K [ee h e ]wu cn net oe t aao ] ote e sh n B e n et , B nv te s o d o iu[ p a t ls frh ya ta r t le r ls l t o re s r t id ” P’ Sp B ea 5a eig h “ ws ocn s n w hnur p cc” o K ti ) ls up r ft (s r n ta i a n ost t i ids y r t efr B d; . . i st tt t ie t t ai t cn ne o e t Mc en B Gt lsfr e s o o iut sl o ac ny C aa o o ya ) t l l / s r.
TeGv n e nv s ks ua ot n s o o ln a ee cn o iu mk g h oe mn ee t e o psi at h w og sl a cn ne a n r t ra t io lr t i pot e (r o n) a s o r a d ue b o te pc r f hr a d ue sif ec” rf- s ols gs et a et by e r h se e oteet by ’ “ l ne il s i l le r fe t le r nu ir sd S ma y h Gv n e nv c ri we e–ouiyh uefrnain a e sa e i i r , e oe mn ee l i e h h tjsfte s ot sc o v u i . ll t r t r afs t r t a t l i a etd a yrnain a ee s r ein( c d g r e e pot a wl si e n r a p t t sc o – sl ’ po c osi l i po c d rfs s e a n r le r a t lr jt n u n jt i, l ,t a a po c d xess n po c os oc n g rdc v y msbraoa e n rasc l , r e e epne ad r ein cne i poui t) u eesnb adeii i jt jt rn ti t l lt. See. D . Rp B ea1( mhsigh “oe ad epct ntap csefrK e, g e’ e y r ft 0e pa z te hp” n “xe a o”h r es o B . , fs l i in ti ti t wu rs tn rf,w h o cu n ote esnb ns osc hps n epct n. ts o deu i pot i n s t y fhr aoa ee f uh oe ad xe a os I l l i t ri l s ti ) i a ouc a h w onacr n t te Gv n e , sl raoa y hu b epc d o l n e o so cod g o h oe mn a ee esnb so d e xe e t s lr , i r t lr l l t r lca r e e m g o pot nt p cse. h w og s r u” p a os a e ed e e po c d a i f rf i i r e( g o ln “ a-p oe t n cn x n) f t jt rn i s i ., tt ri t . C..4 ur ( su igi e a aasne f v ec cnen gy c drin ft tu f n , pa d cs n n rl , bec oe dne oc i tp a u t os r p 3s i s ,t i i r n i l ao a- p id ng mn a e b ids y n h w ogtnr a y ae g mn a e b f mt e o i a e s m y nur ad o ln i o ml tks a e s m yi s o r r t s l t l r t s l r so pot h w rf) i.
F a ya d cse aoe h Gv n e flt g p e n n wyw h h ma n i l , s i u d bv te oe mn as o r p i ay a i te en g nl s s , r ti al t i otee mraoa e pot See. D. B ea1 (seigh asne fn unes fht “ snb ” rf. e, g e’ r ft 7a r nta bec oif eci r e l i . , fs i st t l id a dwe ,n rl ,r er lc d xe a ota hywu “ s tnhsl raz g n c e h e t a ap cse e e epct nh te o dr uiteee ei n it ri e i i f t ti t l el l r li a esnb pot ( mhs add Fr e a d cse aoeas m p n teGv n e raoa erf” e pa s de) u h,si u d bv t o e o t h oe mn l i) i . tr s s , is r t se s o o ed h a etdby ’if ec i d mnr e o y we te ee sp cs e mt cn n ta r a t t l e ue s n unes e os a d n h e h sl ’ r e r l tt l r lr i icro tn po c d r i mr nwa ovr See.i a 2 ( d a n tate i n nopr e o r e e pot ag h see. e, g d t 0i i t g h h es o a jt f i t ., . n ci t r if ec i a etdp t t nain fsl ’ p cs e e ee “ m lv o pot n une n r a l l e a y r sc o i ee s r e r lc vn s e ee f rf” r a t lr i f t o l i) ( mhs add i (seigh lc o Mc en B Gn unes e os a d ya ta e pa s de) d a r nta akf ac ny C if eci d mnr e bfc h i ; . st t l / l tt t t K’ p cs r e e s m y a poto use f d mu ) Ala afs b s h wv , B r e po c di p “” rf, f npci a on. tes tit l h o ee si jt l i ie t t r u, r i wu se taaetd ue sn une v a eelg a y o d e v ecd y pot t o d e mh r a by ’if ec oe sl o cl cu b e dne b a rf l t le r l r lr i l l i i m g tai ee js s g l l w ta wu o e w eb tecs Ii uc a wya a i h s vn u l h y o e hn o d t ri e h ae t s n e h rn t tit r l h s . lr wo s e bec o potm g so d eeu e t poe n une h ea asne f rf a i hu brq rd o rvif ec l l i rn l i l . Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 3 ae 9
tosol me v u Isylt mr ta ta p c “ a d e m e b d i n te ol o i fi i d a e t asil o hn h r e ws e r i d y i d g h t a t l. te e t i t n vi t
po c d o s y h bde d u b o u tt b poue ad hn o i y on n u o r e e cs b te ug e n me f ns o e rdcd n te ps b rud g p r jt t t r i sl i
d w 51 cn . Se e’ B ea1 (t gLoyDpsint 7 17( mhs add o n -0 e s” e D . r ft 8ci ob eot a13 7)e pa s de) t fs i in io , i .
A sc te v ec i n d i t e vn s o we e o n p cs o ayp t u rya s uh h e dnes o e ni ee at h h r o r e fr n ai l e , i t fiv tr t i rc a r
r lc d n a u mntte rdcoteol r e e cs d ie bte u b o u t e e e ay d s e oh pou fht apo c d o si dd yh n me f ns f t jt t t t jt t v r i
( eteiu ws ps b ” d s d mclstei c o (e “p r o n oe e (e i. hf r a “o i y a u e) uhe h d ein., u o d w” r x n i. ., ge sl j t , s r t i. ) t t.,
“-0 e s oay uh d s mn Nr osh Gv n e ce n e dne x a igh 51 cn ” f n sc a u e . o dete oe mn i ay v ec epi nte t) jt t r tt i ln
bs frd e m igwe e o n t mk sc a a u mn(n is te mu ota a s o e r i n h h r o o ae uh n d s e ad f o h a on f h i t n tr t jt t , , t t
a u mn. d s e )7 j t t3
37 A p tf s ae nh mne nw c K’ p csw eeteGv n e a oee s a o tcs ote an i h h B r e e s,h oe mn l ris r i r i si r t r ts l o a e e b 20lt fo Mc en’fr ecus (o dcae)tigh,n 99 n Sp me 01ee r m ac ny o m one n w eesdst tai 19 t r tr l s r l an t , “ B n st tp hs dc e ote n p csote mo e wo ak sf rr sln h K, i s r pae e dd nh u tr efrhi pr d o jce a ea m eg i t au , i i i t l t t ’ t ng iin w h ac nyB G ”Se Lt t Cs mfo Cus fr Mc en (e . eoa os i [Mc en C ] e ee o u o sr m one o ac ny Sp tt t l / . tr t l l t 2 20) D . B e Eh At ) D. B ea1 (seigh “Mc en’ o nt re 7 01( e’ r f x a2 e’ r ft 7a r nta ac ny w a ony , fs i , . ; fs i st t l s t av e Cs mta K’ p cs. hd en eoa daa m ln h” nta“]n e s d sd u o sh B r e.. a be ng i e ‘ r ’ eg , adh [ e ya i t t si tt t s t’ tt r l e t st e e ws of md y h p sn r m i rsos l fr eigK’ p cs a r h st mn a cnr e b te e o p al epn b ost t, i a t i r i ry ie t n B r e” si ) (t gi e a a LoyDpsint 6-3 D . Rp B e a 67s m ;e a o e’ ci , n r l , ob eot a 126) e’ e y r ft - (a e se l D. in t i io ; fs l i ) s fs B ea9a eigh, a cnr e b [M Loy tern e p c b wete aisws r ft (s r nta “s of md y r ob] ht s r r e e enh p t i st t i . , af i t re a d ie aa m ln h ;D . Sp B ea 4. (a e e vdtr ’ eg ” e’ up r ft n s m. r s t ) fs . i 3 )
Te ais u r ao te o e adma n oteee se rneo a m ln h h p t qa e bu h cn x n en g fhlt ’r e ct “ s eg re r l t tt i tr f e r ’ t ng iin ”SelsSp B ea89 P’ Sp Rp B ea4 D. Sp Rp B e eoa os e P’ up r ft - ls up e y r ft; e’ up e y r f tt . . . i ;. . l i fs . l i a5 B tast mni teeei “oc sr ” n i n croo td i fc i aga y t. u h t e e n hlt s cn uoy ads o o br e – na,srub t ta t tr l , t r a t l cn a c d–b o ercr e dne Ud tee i u s ne tet e e m i lt o rdt t ie y t r eod v ec h i . ne hs c c m acs h st mn et il r r t , a t rs te w g ,p t u r a tes m ay ug e s g Segnr l Cs m G dneo e h ai l l t h u m jd mn t e e eeay u o s u ac n i t rc a y r t a. l t i Acp bi o T nain V u i R a dP t T nain a 1 (d s g h Cs m ce a l y f r sc o a e n et a y r sc os t 0 avi ta u o s t it a t l le r a t in t t “f ne c c c m acsfa ci s eastel gina cn uoy n n spo e o er e si u s ne os el m bcueh aea osr oc sr ad o upr d t jt r t l a l t e l t t b e dne ; d st gh c c m acsfa ci swl ee c dwe p t “lgsh y v ec” i ( a nta i u s ne os el m i br e e hn a y aeeta i ) . ti tr t l a l jt r l t tern e p c [ a ng i e a a m ln h b de n sb i aye dnesc a h t s r r e ws eoa d t r ’ eg , u os o u m n v ec uh s af i ] tt s t t t t i , cr sodne ewe te ais h r lc sc ng iin. o epnec b en h p t , a e e s uh eoa o” r t re t t f t tt )
Ao e m o p n o cn n o b we tep t ss h s niac ote a ta n h a r o t f o e in e en h ai itei i cne f h fc h tr j i tt t re gf t t p csw env oet ng iin ewe K ad Mc en B Gnrw e r e eete r e e ee pno eoa o b en B n ac ny C; o e p cs v h i r r tt t l / r i r Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 0
sb coay f r on ro e poe . e, g D. Sp B ea8cne nta“r e u e f n o e cu e f r rcs See. e’ up r ft (ocd gh p cs jt f/ t - f s . , fs . i i t i w en f e ng i e”b we Mc en B Gad K) D. Sp Rp B e a 7 e o r l eoa d e en ac ny C n B e’ up e y r f t r t ey tt t l / ; fs . l i (d iigh “ e ws o c abc ado h eoa o b we K ad Mc en B G ; a mt ta t r a n a u ak nfr ng iin e en B n ac ny C ” tn t h e tl t tt t l / ) [ e’ Rsost Cu’ Lt Rqe o Nv me 2 21 a2 akold nta“ e D. ] epneo ors ee eus f oe b 2 03t (cn w g gh t fs t tr t r , ei t h p c ws of e ng i e b we Mc en B G n K ” LoyAia tt ¶ 22 r e a n r l eoa d e en ac ny C ad B ; ob f dv a¶ 2-3 i t e y tt t l / ) f i (ts ntap csw e u e t ng iin ewe Mc en B G n g mna e b aeigh r e e sb c o eoa o b en ac ny C ad a e s m y tt ti r jt tt t l / r t s l cn a o i D m ia Rpbc B g i adPci R m P’ B e a 5 cn aigte o rc r n o i cn eu i u a a n a f i ) ls r ft (o rs n “ t ts n l, l r, ic ;. i t t h o e adcu eo e adng iin”b we Mc en B Gadt cn a o i te f r n on rf r n eoa os e en ac ny C n i o rc r n h fs t fs tt t l / s t ts D m ia Rpbc B g i adh Pci R mw h Mc en B G p cc v-- s K) o i cn eu i u a a nte a f i i ac ny C ’ r t e i a i B n l, l r, ic t l / s ai s v ; i a2 (a e i a2 (a e i a3 (a e P’ Rp B ea2a eigh K’ p cs d t 1s m ;d t 8s m ;d t 2s m ; ls e y r ft (s r nta B r e . ) . ) . ) . l i st t si “ e n d e m e a a eu o a m ln h eoa o b we te ue ad h sl i a w e o e r i d s rs t f r ’ eg ng iin e en h by n te ee n r t t n l s t tt t r lr mne nr a y odc d n ht d” i a3s m ;da 34ag n ta K p csw e an o ml cnu e i ter e ; d t (a e i t - ( u g h B r e e r l t a ) . ) . ri t i r n “o n r y eoa d n are uo ad ce e b b hh by adh sl ” i a o v u al ng i e ad g d pn n acp d y o te ue nte ee ) d t t l ti tt e , t t r lr; . 7a eigh,nh cs s e d n “ s tr m nr ’ln h g e e b wete ue (s r ntait s ae a si o r u fo a a m eg ar mn e enh by st t i , l d t el s t e tt r ad h sl , ad h K ws of e o acp or e tee m o a o e o cu eo e n te ee ” n ta B a n r t “ce r e c ht s f n f r r on rf r lr t te t jt r f t f .. ot] nae n c vis h r lcte rsu s f h m k p c” i a 9st g h . [r o eggi ai t ta e e h p sr ote a e l e ;d t ( a n ta t ie t f t e e rta ) . ti t “M Loy e dd K’ p cs n i o nw huay eoa osw hK p sne” n r ob dc e [ B ] r e o h w i o n ng iin i B e on, ad . i s i s t t tt t r l ta K’ p csw e e“i n ng iintl ) da1 ( g nta “] a a m ln h h B r e e s w h o eoa o aa” i t 0a u gh,[ n nr ’ eg t si r t t tt l; . ri t i s t t nain w p t sec aigni o h o nn rsad ea, eoa [t aiet n r sc o t o ai , ah c ni h r e wi e t n bh fng i e or v aa a t , re t s r te l tt ] r are uo p c ” u“]a d n hpe h e ; da 1 ( a n i e a ata K p cs g d pn r e b [ h i o apn e ” i t 7st g n r l , h B r e e i, t t t d t r) . ti , t i t i “ e n s b a are e b wete ueadhsl adi n rs tr mr ’ln h w e o e y n g mn e enh by nteee n d o eu fo a m eg r tt e t t r lr d t l s t ng iin b wete uead ee ) P’ Sp B ea4a eigh “ Bi n mk eoa os e enh by n sl ” ls up r ft (s r nta K d o ae tt t r lr; . . i st t d t i o nrig e s n o t o n e s n we e o ce or e ” Mc en B Gre ) t w p c dci sr s w dci s h h t acp re c ac ny C od s s i n io i io tr t jt l / r; i a5ag nta“r e b we K ad Mc en”w eev yi e n yr mr eta d t ( u gh p cs e en B n ac ny e s e df e lfo p csh . ri t i t l r t r fr t i t Mc en p d o“n l e sp i s ;P’ Sp Rp B e a 4 e pa z g h “ e ac ny a t ur a d upe ” ls up e y r f t ( mhsi ta t l i et lr ) . . l i in t h gv n e akoldeta nh cs‘ er e w e o re ng i e b wete ue oe mn cn w gsh it s ae h p cs e n f l eoa d e enh by r t e t i t i r t e y tt t r ad e e ” n sl ’ . lr )
Mc en p n teakf eoa os ewe K ad Mc en B Gadhasne ac ny a t hlc ong iin b en B n ac ny C, nte bec l is tt t l / oay xhne o o e ad on ro e, s a n g v ec aa s h Gv n e . Te f n ecags f f r n cu e f r a d m n e dne g n te oe mn h fs t- f s i i it r t Gv n e cu e ta h p csh Mc en B G a t o e(n l e) o rc r w e oe mn on r h ter eta ac ny C p dot rur a dcn a o e r t ts t i t l / i h et t ts r n awy sb ct ng iin n ig h Mc en B Gocs nl “ ctd p cs o o l as u e o eoa o o n ta ac ny C ca oa y dt e” r et t jt tt , t t l / i l ia i cn a o o eta K.Se e. D. B e a 5st g h “ ]t ms Mc en B G o rc r t r hn B e, g e’ r ft ( a n ta [ ti e ac ny C t ts h . , fs i ti t a , l / wu tl XClte D m ia g mn a e b cn a o tep c i ws wl g opy o de - e [ l l l h o i cn a e s m y o rc r h r et a ii t a n r t s l t t] i ln , uulfresn i m ” nta Mc en B Gwu “o e msei mnfc r si. sa yosaoat s adh ac ny C o ds mi etl s au t e [ e l le , t l / l t lt a u r ., cn a o ]watwu pyoaie pou ” i a1(a e D. Rp B ea7cig o rc r h i o d afr g nrdc ) d t 6s m ; e’ e y r ft (t t ts t l v t; . ) fs l i in LoyDpsint 1 ad seig h Mc en B G i n ng i e r e w h te ob eot a 15 n a r n ta ac ny C d o eoa p cs i o r io , st t l / d t tt i t h g mna e b cn a o ) se lo e’ B e a 2 (seig h “ i n uuu fr a e s m y o rc r; e a D. r ft 0 a r n ta i s o nsa o a r t s l t ts s fs i st tt t l by t dt e p ct a eefr aiu r e s ;f D. Sp Rp B ea7ag n ue oi a a r eo sl o p t l i m” c e’ up e y r ft ( u g r ct i lr rc a t ) . fs . l i ri, i e a ata –a huh“ e wsn a u bc ad o hng iinb we K ad n r l, h t i t l og t r a o c a ak n fr eoa o e en B n t he tl t tt t Mc en B G – ng iin a n a pcirq r mn oI ep t eN e ” ac ny C ” “eoa osr o se f eu e e f n rri o 2. l / tt e t ic i t t ev t ) Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 1
Cs mi e hs a ind h apcin f h c c m acs f h s ee rq rs u o st l a cu oe ta p ia o otei u s ne ote a ts eu e t sf t t l t r t l t i
cn d a o o“ h h te i s fine dne o s bstel gdi u s ne ote os e t n f we e h es ui e v ec t e a ihh aee c c m acs fh i ri tr r fc t i tl l r t
s e e Wa Eey M me oteT d C m u t So dKo Ao : D e m ig h a. e h v l ”S t r e b f h r e o mn y hu n w bu e r i n te r a i l t t n
Acp bi o T nain V u fr R a dP t T nain (.. Dp o H m ad ce a l y f r sc o a e o et a y r sc os US e’ f o e n t it a t l le r a t t l
Scr yAr 20)“ u o sG dne nAcp bi o T nainV ui R a d a y eut pl 07( Cs m u ac o ce a l y f r sc o a en et P t i i t i t it a t l le r
T nain” a 9 apne t P’ Sp Rp B e ( mhs add sea o d a 1 r sc os t (pedd o ls up e y r f e pa s de) e l i. t 0 a t ) . . l i) i ; s
( mhsigeu e e o“toog ep n infh c c m acs u on nte a, e pa z rq r mn f a hruh x aa ootei u s nesr ud gh s e in i t l t r t r i l”
ic d gspoig v ec”( mhs add i (x a igh c c m acsfa ci s n u n “upr n e dne e pa s de) d epi nta i u s ne os el m li t i ) i ;. ln tr t l a
a r e e we a ein ofc“ e. n spo e b e dne. S ma y Cs m hs r e c d hn s r os fa a .. o upr d y v ec” i i r , u o s a e jt st t r t t i ) ll t
e pa zdh –we ,s e , p t sesorvta rnain a es ce a e eas mhs eta h ea h ea a yekt poeh t sc o v uiacp b bcue i t r r r ta t l tl
I sh wv , n su dh –we e o n Mc en B G eoa d r e w h s t , o ee ud p eta h h r o ac ny C ng i e p cs i i i r i t t tr t l / tt i tt g mna e b cn a o o eta K – Mc en B G o e cn a o w ere o a e s m y o rc r t r hn B ac ny C ’ t r o rc r e f t r t s l t ts h l / s h t ts r e r e od sr mh c may ffr x m e h p c “ ctd b Mc en B Gws o e c re fo te o pn i o ea p, e r e dt e” y ac ny C ato jt r ,, lt i ia l / l wSee. D . B ea5st gh,we Mc en B G og t “ ct” p ct o. e, g e’ r ft ( a nta hn ac ny C suh o dt e a r e o . , fs i ti t l / t ia i teD m ia g mna e b cn a o XCl“ - e wu dc e. we et poue h o i cn a e s m y o rc r - e, XCl o d e d.. h h o rdc n r t s l t t l l l i tr te od ate i a d r e ; da 2 (seig h “ wh h [ sl aret a i a d h gost h dt e p c” i t 0 a r n ta [ ]e e a ee g s o dt e ct i ) . st t t r ] lr e ct p c o g e u [ s es fnin fwe ei bivs h icn rdcte rdcate r e r i s p a a i a uc o o h h t eeeta t a poue h pou t h i v ]l t tr l t t [ ctd p c adtl xe t mk s m pot ;P’ Sp B e a 5 n ig h “ hn dt e] r e n slepc o ae o e rf” ls up r ft (o n ta we ia i i t i) . . i t t Mc en md o e t ur a d ee,te ee dc e we e “ acp or e te ac ny ae f r o n l e sl s h sl s e dd h h t ce r e c h l fs et l r ” lr i tr o t jt o e ) Ii s ma y n su d h – n kte te cn a o –K hd o o et tr f r. tsi i r ud p e ta u ie h o r o rc r f” ll i t t l h t t s B a n p w o un r d w ay refo Mc en B G Q ttte o r y K wseu et f fllod s o n n od r m ac ny C. ueoh cn a , B arq rdo ui a re r l / i tr i ll l r fo Mc en B G n t d s a h p c s b M LoySe D. ]Rsost Cu’ r m ac ny C ad o o ot e r e e y r ob e [ e’ epneo ors l / t i t . . fs t Lt Rqe o Nv me 2 21 (cn w d nta“ eeod v ec..n c eta ee eus f oe b 2 03akol g gh t rcr e dne.id a sh tr t r , ei t h i it t K ws o rei e oet o nr eroeueordc m cad eth p cse f d B a n f e h t s i w p c o r st poue e hn s a er e pci ” t e t r ts i t f r i t i ie b Mc en B G P’ Sp B ea4st gh K cu n “ ae.i o n e s n y ac ny C ) ls up r ft ( a nta B o d o mk.. s w dci s l / ;. . i ti t l t t io we et acpor e ” Mc en B G od s Lt t Cu fo Cus frPi i h h o ce re c ac ny C ’ re ) ee o or r m one o l nf tr t jt l / s r; t r t l a tf ( o 2 21) st g h “ B wso ia d odiet Mc en B G l m cad e Nv 6 03( a n ta K a b g e t e v o ac ny C a e hn s . , ti t l t l r l / l r i od e atep c se f db Mc en B Gad K wsn f e o eue opoue re d t h r e pci y ac ny C n B a o r t r s t rdc r i ie l / t e f m cad e o Mc en B Gt h p c se f d y Mc en B G. TeGv n e e hn s fr ac ny C ate r e pci b ac ny C ” h oe mn r i l / i ie l / ) r t nv d el ad se we e t sp t u rapc o ter a os pb we K ad ee i c y dr ss h h h ai l se f h et nh e en B n r rt e t r i rc a t li i t Mc en B Gwsi tewrsoI ep tieN e2“ostn w h h nr a p c g ac ny C a n h od f n rr a v o , cn s t i te o m ri l / , t et t ie t l in p ccs ote a mna e b ids y r t e” f h g e s m y nur ai r t s l t. Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 2
p csw e eld n codnew h o m ids y rig rccs “v ectate . r e e st i acrac i nr a nur p c p t e – e dne h h. . i r te t l t i n ai i t
p c ws eld n codne w h . ids yp ccs i rq rd Se d a 89 O te r e a st i acrac i . . nur r t e”s eu e e i. t - i te t t ai i . . nh
e s n rcr tee dne sn sf c n ysb a i t a o araoa ep sn o xt g eod h v ec i o ui e l us na o l w esnb e o t ii , i t fi t t tl l l r
ud s n aa aportlv o d a te mne i w c M Loy e K’ p cs Nr net dt n prp a ee f ei h anr n h h r ob s B r e o ra ie l tl i . t si .
ite v ec sf c n y us naad ei d o e m c masn f h mnei w c s h e dne ui e l sb a i n d ae t p i o p io ote an n h h i fi t t tl tl rt r r i
K’ p csw ee oh nr ap c grccsfh g mna e b ids y Te v ec B r e e s tte o m ri p t e o e a e s m ynur h e dne si r t l i n ai t r ts l t. i
o K’ p cssi p isf c nt spo s m ay ug e . n B r ei s m y nui e o upr u m jd mn si l fi t t r t
TeGv n e ’ cs otetes e fh euin “ e o m p c g rccs f h oe mns ae nh o ri ote qa o –t nr a ri p t e o r t h d t h l i n ai
te g mna e b ] nur” i ee waeta teGv n e ’ cs o te mnei h [a e s m yids y –s vn ek hn h oe mns ae n h an n r t s l t r r t r
w c K’ p csw e e 3 TeGv n e p n t r a v yil e dne oc n gh h h B r e e s. 8 h oe mn o t oet e lt v ec cne i te i si r t r t i s li l te i rn
p c g rccs f nt steta K. Adh qa u oe dnes y omash o y ri p t e oe ie o rhn B nte un m f v eci b n ente n i n ai ti h t i l
so c m g n h Gv n e ’ cs Te v ec tate Gv n e ce a osoe y hr o i i te oe mns ae h e dne h h oe mn i s l i v l t n r t . i t r tt s r
gn a Mri pr n ynn o h e dnei d yh Gv n e se f a y drsete ee l o mo a l oef e v ec ce bte oe mn pci l ad ssh r. e t t, t i t r t i cl e
g mna e b ids y Msct a y h Gv n e flt d mnr eh M Loy a e s m ynur r t s l t . o ri l , e oe mn aso e os a ta r ob’ t icl t r ti tt t . s
38 N we ii b e deteGv n e d c t y n sc nl o l eh e dne o h en s r f osh oe mn i r e ad uc c y ui te v ec r t is r t s el i t tn i w cicn ns ost e poffh nr ap c grccsfh g mna e b ids y h h o edcni tsroo e o m ri p t e o e a e s m ynur i t t tu t l i n ai t r ts l t. A aeu,h cu ws o et c mteGv n e ’ pp sn nfo tie iy oi e s rs t e or afr do o bh oe mns ae i a e r odnf fr s f lt t c r t r ft t tl ay uhp e i e dne T a o e h lse e e , h cu hd oud tk ai i r n sc o na v ec o s m wa e r x n te or a t ne ae s ma t tl i . t s tt t r l ee ie o dnf ay v ectateGv n e m haga y os et b e dne f x c t ie iy n e dne h h oe mn i t rub cn d o e v ec o rs t i t r t g l ir i K’ p c g rccsIte u r tte x n h te ais o iut fcs nh “o m B ri p t e nhf u ,oh e e ta h p t cn neo ou ote nr a s i n ai . te tt t re t l ids y rig rccsts te wu b wl d sdotu u te p snt ns at nur p c p t e”e,hy o d e e av et s c r h r r e a os o so t i n ai t l l i r t e i e ti c a ydnf ad drs M Loy p c g rccsi a i K, nt sp alie iy l r ie iy n ad s r ob’ ri p t e v-- s Bado ea t ydnf el t e . s i n ai s v re t ad drste o m p c g rccs f h g mna e b ids y adi adint n ad s h nr a ri p t e ote a e s m y nur – n n d t , o e l i n ai r t s l t , io aa z ad x a te x n ow ctoe w p ae(ri efo ) n ao e Fr e t n ye n epi h e e t h hhst o a ll o df r m oe n h. u h ,o l ln tt i rl fr tr tr te x n h e h o b h fh p t slc t aa mvfr u m yug e ,h p t s h e e ta i e r o ote ai e t o g n oe os m a jd mn te ai tt ttr t re e s i r t re so dg ec eu cn d a o t tese f a oa o o tebreso pouinad hu i a f os e t n o h pci l cin f h udn f rdc o n l v r l i ri ic l t t p sa o o sc m in Se eeaye. 1 Mo ’ Fd aP cc § 6 05 4 p 5- e us n n uh o os e gnr l, g 1 or s ee l r t e 5 4-6 2 p 6 r i t . l ., e r ai . ., . 115-1 (n y n “ udn o Pouin n P sa o”t u m y ug e s g. 0-619aa z g Bres f rdc o ad e us n as m a jd mn t e li t r i r t a) Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 3
p ccsn eig r efrK p ae h p c g rccs fh g mna e b ids y s r t ei st p cs o B a ll e ri p t e ote a e s m ynur a ai tn i rl t i n ai r t s l t
awo. h e9 l3
A n e aoeteGv n e ’ cn ate s s oK’ p c gs h M Loy e s o d bv h oe mns e r hs at B ri ita r ob s t , r t tl i s in t . t
39 Av iu p n ii b e,h Gv n e ge byn p c grccsnh g mn t a os o t n sr f te oe mn os eodri p t eite a e r is t is r t i n ai r t a e b ids y w cite pciids ytsu h eC maeD. Rp B ea1 s m y nur h hsh se f nur ai e e. o pr e’ e y r ft 0 s l t, i ic t s r fs l i ( f r g or e s “ tenr a mne oa a mna e b r) e pa s de)i a r ei tp cs e i h‘o m ’an ern i tn l rfr gr e s m e”( mhs add d t t s l i ; . 1 ( f r g o nr a p c g rccs ote a mnids y) e pa s de) I s m 2r ei t “o m ri p t efr h gr e nu r”( mhs add n o e ern l i n ai t t i . is ne fr x m e h Gv n e a uet p c g rccsntesc r oteah n n acs oea p, e oe mn l dso ri p t ei o r e o fhfs o t , lt r tl i n ai h ts i ap e bs e , uh s h mnei w c Mc en B G ei p cs os et i o n pa l u ns sc ate an n h h ac ny C s t r efr a s ot w r i s r i l / ts i l s cs m s i. h p cso Mc en B G s e o m cad eoei rsc a Sa ad u o e –., er efr ac ny C ’ a sf e hn str ae uhs e s n t r et i l / sl r i tl s r J Pne Se e. D . B e a 56 st g h “ C ’ cs m si.r ae ] wu Ceny e,. , e’ r f t - ( a n ta B G u o e [e ei r o d . g fs i ti t s t r ., tl s l s mi etlB Gwap cte w ewl go a” i a1 ( a nta“ C cs m s o e mse C h r ehy e ii t py ; d t 6st gh B G u o e t l ti r ln ) . ti t t r s mi e dt e te r ete w ewl g o a” o e ms i a d h p cs hy e ii t py. t ct i r ln )
A o e p n, h Gv n e mks we n rp snt n ao p c g rccs t t r o t te oe mn ae s ep g er e a os bu ri p t e h is r t i e ti t i n ai w c a n se f t ay nur aa – n w c a n spo e b ca os o eod h h r o pci o n ids ytl ad h h r o upr d yit nt rcr i e t ic t l i e t t ti e dnet bo e,. ,D . B e a 2 (seig n ra ata“ i n uuu fr v ec o o .Se e. e’ r ft 0 a r n i e l , h i s o nsa o a i , t g fs i st , t i tt t l by t dt e p ct a eefr aiu rt m ” n ta“ wh h te ee aret a ue o i a a r e o sl o p t l i s ad h [ ]e e h sl g s o r ct i lr rc a e , t tr lr e dt e p c..s fnin fwe eibivsh icnrdcte rdca h[ ctd i a d r e.i a uc o o h h t eeeta t a poueh pou t e dt e] ct i t tr l t t t ia p c adtl xe t mk s m pot st gh “ ] c p cs o gosh hv n be r e n slepc o ae o e rf” ti ta [i e r efr odta ae o en i i t i; a n t s n i t t poue a s bsd pn nc a d xessii awy ps b tate xesswl e rdcd r e ae uo a i p e epne tsl as o i e h h epne i b et ti t , sl t l h h ad h epc dpot wln m e az” ci ig h “un azdpot i n i e n te xe e rf i o a rl e l m ta []r l e rf” s o gr t i l t t ii ; a n t ei i t “nsa r m bs e s np n;ru gh “p o c os a b wog n n w u nse uuu fo a u ns t do t ag nta [] j t ncn e rn ad e bs e s l i s a i” i t r ei i s myhv mr ‘r w gp n ta a i p e ” n ta “rfs r n ga n e ee i a ae o goi a s hn nc a d ad h pot a o u a ed vn n e n i’ ti t , t i e t rt , t nain b we ur a d ais ;D. Rp B ea91 (seigh “no u ns r sc os e en n l e p t ” e’ e y r ft -0a r nta [] bs e , a t t et re ) fs l i st t i s n ee oeeigo n l e cs m s s urn et e n pot adh “i n uuu o vn nsl t ur a d u o e, gaa edo a arf” nta i s o nsa t ln et t ri t r i tt t l frn wc ma e n t e napot–o ee t fla oe e – n h fsf wya o o e o pn s o o a i t r rfi r vn o a l g h i teit e e s f i t tr r r e s ne ; da1(seigh “ ]ee sakfrfa l ys oncsal a osqec xt c” i t 0a r nta [ sl ’lc opotbi i n ee r y cneune ie ) . st t a lr i it t si o p cs e g eto o, r f o u o b we by ad ee” uis a “ a js b a f r e b n s o l wo o c ls n e en ue n sl, b n ed my u e i i t l i t r lr t t t cneune f nnc a da o, uh sao cs tatr o t b h h tatoeh osqec o ua i p e fc r sc albr o sh un u o ei e hnhsta ti t ts t t t gr t w e n ue i tepo c dbde uo w c tep cs w ebsd ;i a 1 n (t g e ic dd n h r e e ug pn h h h r e e ae” d t 0 . ci r l jt t i i r ) . 4 in ai enH v dBs e Shopbcin otelnepoot nh “ ea u r e o rc i a a u ns co u ia o frh b k rpsi ta t flr a fr tl rr i s l l t a t io t h i e t n w u ns e i 3-0 e e , w h on cin oc n ghstt soc ma eite e bs e [s s 04 p cn” i nid a o cne i tetii fr o pn snh i s ] r t t it rn asc i se f ids ytsu h e pci nur ai e e ) ic t s r.
A sc e dnewu apat bi e vn Nte p t hsrudh tee vn l uh v ec o d pe o er l a . e h a y a ageta hr ea l i l r re t i r r t l t p c g rccs r o eta toe fK ad h g mna e b ids y fw c K ws ri p t e a t r hn hs o B n te a e s m y nur o h h B a i n ai e h r t s l t i a a. pt r Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 4
p cs ae o “ei d bde “ apo c dh epr r ic m ad xess n aaee r e bsd n d ae” ug st tr e ete xo e sno e n epneadt lv i tl t h jt t’ l
ta ws xe e t ra apotoc te xo e st tu cs w e u y mrzd Se h a epc d o ep rf ne h epr r s r p o s e f l a oie ” e t t i t ’ a- t r l t .
D. B ea6 D. Rp B ea23 A d cse aoeh wv,h Gv n e hs o e’ r ft; e’ e y r ft - s i u d bv o ee te oe mn a n fs i fs l i . s s , r r t t
adcd ui e e dneo upradls o iteeui d a temnei w c M due sf c n v ect spo n f h u nhrq se ei h an n h h r fi t i t e t it tl r i .
Loy e vdK’ p csr mh anabde. Mroe eei h Gv n e hd pld ob d ie B r efo te nu ug s o v, vn te oe mn a see r si l t e r f r t l
o i d a h w M Loy sd ug s o e p csteGv n e p n t n e dne o u n ei o r ob ue bde t s r e h oe mn o t o o v ect t tl . t ti , r t is i
d mnr eh te o m p c g rccs fh g mna e b ids yr cn s n w h e os a ta h nr a ri p t e ote a e s m ynur a ost t i tt t l i n ai r t s l t e ie t
wa M Loyi h e h r ob d e. t . d r
Ii rp b e teGv n e de a e ta M Loyei eta“o m p c g n se y r f h oe mn os s r h r obtsf dh nr a ri t l i, r t st t . ti t l in
p ccs ote a mn nuriv vte rp a o ad os e t n f ug sh po c r t efrh g e ids yno eh p a t n n cn d a o o bde ta r e ai r t t l e ri i ri t t jt
cs ad u ufr g e t m p id w h o e mu o pot ut n ne h c mays o s n o p o a i ni e e o i s m a on f rf b li octe o pn i t tt v r , t t i i
am u fci . D . Rp B ea1 Tte a ef cteGv n e e e h el m a r al y e’ e y r ft 2 oh s m e e,h oe mn l we ci s t e it ” fs l i . ft r ts r a
ta M Loyei etats o m idsyrcct s p cs bsd pn ei d ug s h r obtsf dh i nr a nurp t eoe r e“ae uo d ae bde t . ti ti l t ai ti tl t
. .w h h epct n f pot ne a al y m u [ byn tet tu pae D . . i te xe a o o a rf oc [ fci ] a r s eod h s r p hs ” e’ t ti i it t e] a- . fs
Sp Rp B ea7I seigh wv,h teGv n e po e n ca osohrcr up e y r ft.t tl , o ee ta h oe mn rf r oit ntteeod . l i i ln r t r t f s ti
t spo toe sein S u n o b h M Loy aia t n h dpsinee sh o upr hs a r os c t y f o r ob’ f dv adi eot rva ta t st . ri t . sf i s io l t
h nv md ay uht e e s 0 I ay vn ts mnt sc bodf c–e r n fr e ee ae n sc st mn. n n ee ,ei oyo uh ra e e r eig o r a t4 t t f t fr ,
40 Te n ee aga y upr n e dne h i ce i teGv n e ’ b e i a h o y vn rub spoig v ecta si d n h oe mns r f s l l t i t t r t is r e ne o M Loy ts mn ta “rigb a al y uha XClte D m ia e r c t r ob’ ei oy h p c fe . s t t i n y fci sc s - e [ it l h o i cn n g mna e b cn a o i a p fc wr ’wu b bsd pn bde h cn d sh a e s m y o rc r n ‘e e o d o d e ae uo a ug ta os e te r t s l t t] r t l l t t ir fc r’ p e i o p adepne ( g te uprs f nee fr h epc do p , a oy o na u u n xesse. h spo t f edd ote xe e u u t s t tl t t ., t a t tt oeha epne e cit d e lbre.”Se e’ B ea5cig n ca c rig v ed xess l t c y i c ao t) e D. r ft (t ad h a e z r , e ri , r t , c. fs i in r ti n Loy Dpsina 143) H wv,p t u r we ra i cn x tea u ce ob eot t 3-5 io . o ee ai l l hn ed n o e , h c a i d r rc a y tt tl t ts mn de n ee po st ds ie rig rccs n h g mna e b ids y s ei oy os o vn rf s o ec b p c p t ei te a e s m y nur a t t e r i n ai r t s l t a wo. Mroe te ei oys mc tobs ad ak g n pcit t s v ate h e o v , h ts mn i uh o a c n lc n i se fi o e e s h l e r t i i icy r Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 5
ea p, o a r i ot “o e mu o pot a wl s o h (nunf dt m nee x m e “ pot r o s m a on f rf, s e at te uqa i e)i e edd lt f” t i” l ti
t a o aln o eo e aa r fci ” wu b mctoi psc nlc ni d a ol w p t bc m “m ue al y – o d e uho s m ii adak gn ei l at t it l lt i tl
t cni tteeui pof f o m p c g rccs n hids y o ost e hrq se ro o nr a ri p t ei te nur tu it l i n ai t.
A sc js ate Gv n e hs ae t c m l te v ec nee t poe y s uh u s h oe mn a fld o o pe h e dne edd o rp l , t r t i i i r
sb a i e s ot nh M Loye K’ p cs ae o bde tapo c d o em g us na i psi ta r ob s B r e bsd n ug sh r e e s m a i t tt t i o t . t si t t jt rn
o pot h Gv n e hsi i r fldoliteeui e dneo s bstasc f rf, e oe mn as ma yaet ec hrq se v ect e a ihh uh it r t ll i it it i tl t
a rcdri cn s n w h o m p c g rccs n h g mna e b ids y poeu s ost t i nr a ri p t ei te a e s m y nur e ie t l i n ai r t s l t.
TeGv n e ce s m o e e dne h r a s o h p c g rccs f nt s h oe mn i s o e t r v ecta et t te ri p t e o e ie r tt h i t le i n ai ti
o eta K. B tae dneloas o a y h dy t rhn B u h v ec a flt c r te a h t t i s i r .
Frea p, nsv a p cs h Gv n e r e t M Loy ts mn ta o x m ei ee l l e te oe mn e r o r ob’ ei oy h l r a r t fs . s t t
“v yn [e h s ee wre w h hs“se e te ‘o p s nada o e m u ee oe h a ] v okd i ” a a s d h r cs e t d l wd i t r ] [ r t ss i t r a r l ne
[ AM’ n[oea aa s ote aiu rrdc o o e pw h t g p c ” e D. S ] addn n n y s nh p t l pou t c m u i aa e r e Se e’ , ] li rc a t t r t i. fs
B e a 4 cigadqo n Loy Dpsina 121) sea o e’ Rp B e a 1 r f t (t i i n n u ig ob eot t 1-4 e l D. e y r f t 1 t io ; s fs l i
(seigh “M Loyei eta eeyoyh hs v wre w h a bsdh rr e a r nta r obtsf dh ‘v bd’ e aee okd i hs aete p cs st t . ti t r r t i i
rq rd v ec oids y rcc Is a teei oysmrite e oa r m fr eu e e dne fnur p t e n ed hts mni o nh v n f p e oa i i t ai . t , t e i i r lye o –a i rdc o t s m v ye mn r p c gp n p ss fr i s m wa ap sn n n ouin o o e e l e ay ri r c l , e o h n o e h r t t r e t in iie t t t as a ad ho t at m (s e fre b M Loy ueoteqaf r i [ p fc brc n teri l e s a r no d y r ob’ s f h ui e “ a e e t t ec r i c . s li n ] r t wr ” Fr e n w h ad g h Gv n e ’ r e ne o a al y sc a XCl a o d. u h , o i s n n te oe mns e r c t “ fci uh s - e, l) t r t tt i r t fe it l” rv w f ht nc prva tatei dei oy e r d pcia y ad n ) oXCl e e oter s i ee s h h ce ts mn r e e se f l (n o yt - e. i a rt l t t t fr i cl l l Se ob Dpsint 3 (of m gh Loyst k g bu XCli p t u r Ad e Loy eot a13cnr i ta obi “l n ao - e”n ai l ) n io i n t ai t l rc a. ee at XCl M Loy ad l cneetah hs oi c p sn kolde fh vn so - e, r ob cn d ocddh e a n d e, e oa n w g ota l . iy t rt r l e t c may p c g rccs Se da 14st g h XCl nv t d h m h w hys o pn’ ri p t e e i t 1 ( a n ta - e “ee o [ ] o te [e s i n ai . . ti t l rl i t p cs ) re” i ].
S nia l ite ore fi dpsin h Gv n e suh o rs M Loy s i i cn y nh cu o h eot , e oe mn og t p s r ob a g f t, s s io t r t t e . t we etep c gp ccs h h ds ie w e tnad n h ids y M Loy o h h h ri r t e ta e ec bd e s d i te nur tr i n ai t r r a r t . r ob . d mr d “ ma h wwu I n w”Se ob Dpsint 7 e u e I en o o d ko ? e Loy eot a14 r: , l io . Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 6
o a i p e cs, cigLoyDpsint 1) 1 Oc aa , o ee sc ts mn i n nc a d o s i n ob eot a 14 4 ne g nh wv, uhei oys ti t t” t io . i r t
mc to ee l o ev a pof f o m p c g rccs n h g mna e b ids y uh o gn at s e s ro o nr a ri p t ei te a e s m y nur r r l i n ai r t s l t.
I adin hts mn il me o i fct “v yn [.Loy] a ee wre w h n d t , eei oysi i d nt ae o ee oeM ob hs v okd i . io t t t s r r r t”
Teei oyhs os oee pro t b a os e dt st n oc n grigrccs hts mntu de n vn upr o e cn d e ae a o cne i p c p t e t t t i r t ti r n i n ai
i teg mna e b ids y s wo. Fr e teei oy e rt st g “ re n h a e s m y nur a a h e2 u h , hts mn r e o ei at g r t s l t l4 tr t fs tn a t
p c”oecid iu “aiu rrdc”B n we deteGv n e epi h wh r efr ahn v a p t l pou. u o h e osh oe mn x a o ta i i d l rc a t t r r t ln t
41 “tnad A o e M u ”(S ” i au to mau mn ue i idsi S d a r l wd i t “ AM s n f esr e sd n nurl l ne ) i e t ta eg e igo unfteaoe o ee ei c m e n a pcits Gn a y pa n n ne nt qa iyhlbrf r x tdn o pt g se f ak ee l sek g i r t ft r li ic . rl i, ten me o s nad l wd m u ss h a on ot m taitks n v ae wre h u b ft d a o e i t ite mu fi e h t ae a ae g ok , r a r l ne t t r r epn n ae g e o ad s g v ae kl t c m e a aiu r p a o (r e , o xed g v ae f r n u n ae g s l, o o pt p t l oe t n o h efr i r ft i r is l e rc a ri r ea p,ose b s m p t u r a mn.Se eeay ob Dpsint 4-0 Loy x m e a m e o e ai l g e ) e gnr l Loy eot a195 ob lt s l rc a r t l io ; Aia t 3 M he A mrn AHnbo o Mng mn Tcn us 2 (d d20) f dv ¶ 1 i a r s og f i ; c l t , adok f aae e eh qe 75 3 e 01 t i . . 42 Mr gn a y tsafo c ata M Loys o p e ad ui ettsft o ee l , if r ml rh r obi c me n n qaf doeiyo e rl i r e t . tt li t nr a p c gp ccs n h g mn a e b ids y A n e aoe h p snl o m ri r t e i te a e s m y nur l i n ai r t s l t . s o d bv e e oa y t , r l d ci e te ee ay n w de Se.0spa i l md h ncs r kol g e n , ur. sa s e . 4
A aersnt e f Mc en B G w ci it s o e , by ) M Loys y s rp e a v o ac ny C ( h hs nh cn x a ue, r obi b e ti l / i , i tt r . n mas ee al p vtte ei oh w n p t u r a mna e b f m( e sl s o en ncs r yr yoh d asf o ay ai l g e s m y r si. ee ) si i tl rc a r t s l i ., l r s te p cs mclste o m p c grccsfh g mna e b ids ys wo. e h rr e uhe h nr a ri p t e o e a e s m ynur aa h e t i i , s l i n ai t r t s l t l See. LoyDpsint 1(cn w d ntahlcs n p sn, r-ad n w de e, g ob eot a14akol g gh eakay e oafs hn kol g ., io ei t r l it e a t h w XCl– h D m ia g mn a e b cn a o – ei p cs Mroe s o o - e te o i cn a e s m y o rc r s t r e. o v , l n r t s l t t ts i ) e r acr nt h dpsin M Loy a “n wretrelcsn h]i,ic d g n cod goi eot , r ob hs o y okdh p ei [ sl e n u n oe i s io . l e a i f” l i f m r roi e p y e a B Gad s rdcso adhf mwe h ws m oe a i p ot h m o mn t C (ni p ee r ntei r i s l t t e s) r h e e a e p ydt r l tei e f i dpsin Se da 18 LoyAia t ¶ - Te i n id a o i te ht m o h eot . e i t 3 ob f dv ¶ 14 h es o n cin n h s io . ; f i . r it rcr tae h M Loy fse p y o h e p y atei eo h dpsinw e eod h i e r ob’ it m oe r i m oe t ht m f i eot ttr . sr l r s l r s io e r g mna e b c ma e Ide te v ec sge sh te w e o See. Loy a e s m y o pn s ned h e dne ugs ta hy e n . e, g ob r t s l i. , i t t r t ., Dpsint 3 ( a n ta“]e o pn ta[M Loy wsw h o[ sfs 2 ya eot a 16st g h [ h c may h io ti tt t r ob] a i fr h]it 1 e s . t i r r ra ymd eey igh me e” i a1 2(ec b gh bs e e o Loy e p y s el ae v t nte s vs ;d t 6 1ds i nte u ns sf ob’ m oe ) l rh l ) . , ri i s s l r; LoyAia t ¶ , (a e B ee a u igaged ta b hw e a mna e b ob f dv ¶ 2 4s m. u vn s m f i ) t s n runo h o e g e s m y t t r r t s l c ma e ad su igh M Loy a kolde fh r rig rccs h kolde o pn s n a m ta r ob hd n w g ote p c p t e ta n w g i, s n t . e i i n ai , t e wu e h s nia l p -a o ps d eh d e ote nistsu h eadhs o d o di e i i cn y r d e r o-a te a s fh e r a se e, ntu cu l t r gf t e t t t t te i r l h d b de e cn mo nos Se d¶ 134id a n ta Loywre fr ifs a l e e md o e pr eu e i ¶, - ( i t g h ob okd o h it ry t a . . n ci t sr e p y fo 19-91adh h ps B G m o mnbgnn 07 Ee mrtte m oe r m 9019 nta i o- C e p y e eai 20) vn o oh l r , t s t l t . e p n ii du f tae dne oc n g h p c g rccs f n t o a mna e b o t ts ob u h v ec cne i te ri p t e o o y w g e s m y i, tl t i rn i n ai l r t s l c ma e cu sf ct poe nur-ie rcc o pn s o d uie o rvids y w p t e i l f t d ai . Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 7
cne r a s o h Gv n e ’ cn ate s– h p csa bsdo ana bde, ocp et t te oe mns e r hs ta r e r ae n nu ug s t le r t tl i t i e l t
d cse aoe 3 i u d bv 4 s s .
F a yteGv n e a o pns pg os s m a z g e a ts mn b M i l , h oe mn l sed a ae r o u m i n c t nei oy y r nl r t s ri ri t .
Loy oc n gh p c grccsfXCl Mc en B G D m ia g mna e b ob cne i teri p t e o - e, ac ny C ’ o i cn a e s m y rn i n ai l l / s n r ts l
cn a o e gnr l D . B e a 45 a eig i e a ata“ ep csta XCl o rc r e eeay e’ r ft - (s r n n r l , h t r e[ t - e] t t .S l fs i st , t i t h i h l
cagd o Mc en [ e ] e r ie b teao cs ad eedd pn h cnrc o h e t ac ny w e d e m d y hlbr o s n dpne uo te os uin r l r t n t t t
rq r mn, cig n ca c rig ob Dpsint 1-4a oi n LoyDpsin eu e e s i n ad h a e z Loy eot a121 l cig ob eot i t” t r ti n io ;s t io
a162 103)4 B , y e nin h ts mn cnen XCln te a mna e b t 1-3 3-54 u b d i t , a ei oy oc s - e, o h g e s m y , . t fio t t t r l t r t s l
ids yn ee l5 Fr e teei oysmcto ocp aadsak gn pcit ad nuri gn a4 u h ,hts mni uho cne u nilc ni se fi n t r. tr t tl i icy
d a.S nia l a ogted i ec s hts mn o i ayics o opotm g s ei i i cn y mn o r e c n e teei oy ms n d u infrf a i . tl g f t, h fi i , t t s s i rn
Acr n y ie h o e e dne uie aoe M Loy ts mn cnen gXCl cod g , kte t r v ec o l d bv r ob’ ei oy oc i - e’ ill h i tn , . s t rn ls
p c gp ccs o cno cni t tepofotenr a p c gp ccsoteg mn ri r t eto an ost e h ro f h o m ri r t e f h a e i n ai t tu l i n ai r t
a e b ids y h irq rd omkteGv n e ’ cs s m y nur ta seu e t ae h oe mns ae s l t t i r t .
Cs m hs pknla y n h mt : T poe h t nain a es ce a e u o s a soe c r o t s ae o rvta r sc o v ui acp b t el i tr ta t l tl
43 S ma y M Loy ei e tai ws n uc m o” o XClte D m ia i i r , r ob tsf d h t a “o no mn fr - e, h o i cn ll . ti t t l n g mna e b cn a o t b cld pno ea r e oa aiu r e dr gh cu e a e s m y o rc r o e ae uot s p cfr p t l i m u nte or r t s l t t, l t i rc a t i s o a esn e LoyDpsint 3-2 TeGv n e mks ot m t su e h f sao .Se ob eot a 113 h oe mn ae n ae p o qa ta io . r t t t r t ts mn w h s ot nh,nur-ieg mna e b f ms p cs ae o ana ei oy i i psi ta ids y w , a e s m yi s e r e bsd n nu t t t io t t d r t s l r ti l bde. ug s t 44 Seloe. D. B ea1(seigh Mc en B Gs mi e dt e p cs e a , g e’ r ft 6a r nta ac ny C “o e msi a dr e s . , fs i st t l / t ct i t XCl ;da2 (seigh XCl p csw e bsd pn n xe a ota h sl o - e” i t 0a r nta - e’ r e e “ae uo a epct nh te ee l) . st t ls i r ti t lr wu cv i epne ad eie o eee o pot ;i a 2 ( f r g o h mnei o d oe t xess n raz s mlv f rf” d t 6r ei t te an n l rs l l i) . ern r w c “r e[ e ] e . b we XCl n Mc en” D. Rp B e a 7 a eig h h p cs w es .. e en - e ad ac ny ; e’ e y r ft (s r n i i r t t l l ) fs l i st ta“ e r e cagd y. XCl dpne uo cnrc o rq r mn ” h t p cs h e b.. - e[ eedd pn os uineu e e s. t h i r l] t t i t) 45 A n e aoe M Loy ad l akoldetah hs o e oakolde f s o d bv r ob cn d cn w gdh e a n p sn n w g o t , . iy e t r l e XCl p c g rccs See. LoyDpsint 1 - e’ ri p t e e, g ob eot a14 ls i n ai . ., io . Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 8
bcuep cs w est d nacrac w hnr aids yp c gp ccs “b cv eas r e e el i codne i o m nur ri r t e o eie i r te t l t i n ai , j t
e dne f h nr a p c g rccs f hids y n us o irq rd tg h w h a v ec ote o m ri p t e ote nur i qeins eu e ” oe e i “ i l i n ai t t i , tr t
toog ep n inf h c c m acs u on n te a ” n “n x aa o o wy . hruh x aa o otei u s ne sr ud g h s e ad a ep nin f h. . l t r t r i l l t
sc c c m acse a ih h te et nh d n if ec tep c ” SeCs m uh i u s ne s bs ta h r a os p i o n une h r e e u o s r t tl t li i d t l i. t
G dne nAcp bi o T nainV ui R a d a y rnaina781( mhss u ac o ce a l yf r sc o a en et P t T sc ost- 0e pae i t it a t l le r a t ,
add sea o d a 1 (x a ig h c c m acso s e l m a r e e we “ e de) e l i. t 0 epi n ta i u s ne f a ci s r e c d hn t ; s ln t r t l a e jt h
aea osr cn uoy n n spo e b e dne. l gin a oc sr ad o upr d y v ec” l t e l t t i )
Mc ateeod e ic dsolt e dne ou e ig o K’ p csw ee uhshrcr h en uetote v ec dc mn n h w B r e e s, r l il i t si r t
stohrcric dsse il n e dne“b c v”rte w e6 adte x aa o ooteeodn uee na y o v ec(o eie oo ri ) nlt ep nin l s tl i jt h s4 il l t
46 Mc en z os n n hlnugi teCs m pbcintig h “o eie ac ny e ei o teagae n h u o s u ia o st ta b cv l r t l t an t j t e dne f h nr a p c gp ccsote nur i qeins eu e”we ap t’ v ec ote o m ri r t e f hids y n us o irq rd h e a y i l i n ai t t i r r s ci tat nainv u i acp b i bsdo cn s ny w hnr aids yp c g l m h r sc o a es ce a es ae n ost c i o m nur ri a ta t l tl ie t l t in p ccs SeCs m G dneo Acp bi o T nain V u i R a d P t rte ai . e u o s u ac n ce a l y f r sc o a e n et a y t i t it a t l le r T naina78e pa s de)P’ Sp Rp B ea23 Cti nteGv n e ’ r sc ost-( mhs add ls up e y r ft- ri z gh oe mns a t i ;. . l i . ici r t e dne e a “u eie Mc en p n d os vs h – [ s h o yl s a o o v ec h e s sb c v ” ac ny o t l be eta “ ]te n i urin f i r jt , l iey r t a l l tt o eie v ec”– h Cs m pbcin i s Haqa e R igLt i w c te b c v e dne te u o s u ia o ce a edu t s u n ee n h h h jt i t l t t rr l tr i aec acp dshrq se o eie v ec”f o m ids yrigrccsro h gny ce e ateeui “b c v e dne onr a nur p c p t e pof a t it j t i l t i n ai tt te r en us o “ a d ie w he rneo r e pbsei ardjun ( e o e h p ci qein ws e nd i r e ct p cs u ihdn t eora t ps d i t f t fe i l a lh t p c adte by s n sl s o mn uete o e p c ate a s f o rcp cs r e n o r ue ad ee c m o y sdh ps d r e sh bs ocn a r e ” i) h r lr l t i i t ti . Se u o sG dne nAcp bi o T nainV ui R a dP t T nain a 8 e Cs m u ac o ce a l y f r sc o a e n et a y r sc ost t i t it a t l le r a t ( su igH 526 (M c 1 18) P’ Sp Rp B ea2selols up B e d cs n Q 421 a h 1 91; ls up e y r ft; e a P’ Sp r f i s r , ) . . l i s . . i a3 d cs n H 526 sgeigh te nr a nur p c g rccsts“o d e t ( su ig Q 421 ugs nta h “o m ids y ri p t e”e cu b i s , t t l t i n ai t l siidfr x m eite i a ids yo c mayp cc o st g o rc p csb as e o ea p,f h es n nur r o pn r t e f ei cn a r e y tf , l r t ai tn t t i r e neo ‘o e p c r lc ntervl gm k p cfr c m o t ac m ld n e r ct aps dr e e eigh p ai a e r eoa o md y s o pe ad fe t i’f t e in r t i i, i pbse b ard [ru] adi n UCC § -0() ) 21)r eig o cn a s n u ihd y t e gop ” n cig ... 2351 c(03( f r t “o rc i l a , t ( ern t t w c ‘ e r es.f eit m os m are m k o o es nad s eorcre b h ht p ci..i dne s f o e g d a e rt rt d as reodd y i h i x r e rt h a r t ah d e o oaec..’ ) t r p sn r gny.. ) i r ”.
Mc en cn ns h teGv n e cno ps b p vl nt “o m ids y ac ny o edta h oe mn an o i y r a o i nr a nur l t t r t t sl e i s l t p c grccster bcueter e ewe K ad Mc en ws os it m oay ri p t e”hoy eas “ p c b en B n ac ny a n e ne sf n i n ai h i t l tt r are m k p c ps d r eo o eidpne s nad h cu o eie so ta g d a e r e o e p c r t r needn t d ta o d b c v y h w h e r t i, t i, h t a r t l jt l t [ er a os p b wete ueadh sl ] [ ] o n uneh p c ” e P’ Sp t ]et nh [e enh by nte ee d d n if ecte r e Sels up h li i t r lr i t l i. . . B ea5 selo e’ Sp Rp B ea7cne ntae dne os oso ta K’ r ft; e a D . up e y r ft (ocd gh v ec de n h wh B i s fs . l i i t i t t s Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 4 ae 9
( hruh o n ) fh “o m p c g rccs ote a mna e b ids y C t n “ oog” r o ote nr a ri p t e” fh g e s m ynur e a l t t l i n ai r t s l t . ri y
te Gv n e hsn e a ihd h K’ p cs w e ei acrac w h h ids y h oe mn a o s bse ta B r e e s n codne i te nur’ r t t tl t s i r t t t s
nr ap c g rccsaI ep tieN e wu rq r Se 9CFR§ 5 13)1i. o m ri p t e s n rr a v o 2 o deu e e 1 ... 12 0(()i l i n ai , t et t l i. . l ()
Cs m hs ne crd h ap ie e bsd nrnain a es o p mtd n u o s a ud so ta pr s mn ae o t sc o v ui n e ie i t r e t a t a t l t rt
aetd a yrnain be “ui e ifr a o”o e os a si ain fi ete r a p tt sc o asn sf c n no mint d mnr e as c o oe h h le r a t t fi t t t t tf t tr
c c m acsote a ts ote e v us SeCs m G dneo Acp bi o i u s ne f h s e e r h ts a e e u o s u ac n ce a l y f r t l t t l . t i t it
T nain V u i R a dP t T nain a 1 Te v ec tate Gv n e hs r sc o a e n et a y r sc os t 7 h e dne h h oe mn a a t l le r a t . i t r t
m sa do a i dc e ynui e t spo te s ot nain a e e. O b hh a h et d es e dd isf c n o upr h ue fr sc o v u h e n o te r l t i l fi t t a t l r t
fc ad h l wte Gv n e ’ m in o s m ay ug e ssi n Cs m ueo a s n te a, h oe mns o o fr u m jd mn u a ig u o s s f t r t t r t tn t ’
t nain a e h eo ms b dn d7 r sc o v ute fr u e e e4 a t l r e t i.
p csr a do n‘g e m k p c o‘o e p c ” TeGv n e “o sn d p e r e“ l et ayar d a e r e rps dr e ) h oe mn d[ ] o i u i et e rti’ t i ’. r t e tst ta te‘o e’ m k p c ds ie i [ Q526]po dda acp b maso h h ps d a e r e ec bd n H 421 rv e n ce a e en f t t rt i r i tl d e m ig h te r e a ws ostn w h o m p c g rccs n hids y Se e r i n ta h p c p d a cn s t i nr a ri p t ei te nur ” e t n t i i ie t l i n ai t. i a6 B , nh o ehn teGv n e m nish sc “ps dr e a n te n d t. u otet r ad h oe mn a t nta uh‘o e p cs r o h o y . t h , r t ia t t i ’e t l mas yw c [n rr a v N e ’‘o m ids y rig rccsts cn e as e ” en b h hI ep tie o 2 nr a nur p c p t e e] a b siid i t et t s l t i n ai ’ t tf . I Ad h Gv n e fr e age ta K’ p cs n a w e“e b a idpne d n te oe mn u h rus h B r e i fc e s y n needn . r t tr t s i t r t t s nad i a mne “ostn w h o m p c g rccsi te nur d Te e a t d , n an cn s t i nr a ri p t e” n hids y . h dnl a r” r ie t l i n ai t .I i oteGv n e ’ m in os m ay ug e o te rud s fr aoe b a s n f h oe mns o o fr u m jd mn n h gons e o h bv ovt ay r t t r t t t ie net g e u h cn d a o t te aisag mn o t s o tt h t m edoi fr e os e t n oh p t ’ru e s n h p nat si e v t r i ri re t i i i . 47 Bs e se n s m ay ug e ssi n Cs m ueo t nainv u t e ds ek g u m jd mn u a ig u o s s f r sc o a e o i i r t tn t ’ a t l ap ie h m cad ete Gv n e a o eus te n yo s m ay ug e o i pr s te e hn s h oe mn l rqe s h e r f u m jd mn nt a r i, r t s t t r t s cu e l m o adin d is e eig e a cs ta w en ic dd t h t m te on r a fr d t a ue r lc n c t n o s h e o n ue atei e h t ci io l t f t ri t t r t l e r stsu w e q d e e D. B ea92-62 D . Rp B ea1-52-1 ni a se e l u a d e e’ r ft, 02 9 e’ e y r ft 21 02 te i r i i t .S fs i , ; fs l i , ; D. Sp B ea1 Bcueh Gv n e ’ cu e l ms o igno a e r ia o e’ up r ft 0 easte oe mns on r a i cn ne n d e m t n fs . i . r t t ci t t t ni ssi n teueot nainv u s m ay ug e at te on r a m lo ms b u a ig h s fr sc o a e u m jd mn s o h cu e l a tn a t l, r t t ci s u e t dn d eei. Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 5 ae 0
B Mc en’ M in o S m ay ug e . ac ny o o fr u m Jd mn l s t r t
Mc en’ m in os m ayug e is ma yak gnm i Mc en ses ac ny o o fr u m jd mn si i r lc ni et ac ny ek l s t r t ll i r. l
s m ay ug e o i ci ta a e r sai u so dhv be ap ie bsdo u m jd mn nt l m h l ni t s e hu ae en pr sd ae n r t s a t l te s l a
ddc v v u w h h ecp o ote h e nisw c a e ie t d yrera mn euie a e i te xe in f htr e r t l, t t e t e h h r nt d o u - et t e i e tl tf e t
ud teC T A e gnr l P’ B ea21-51-52-13 P’ Rp B ea11 ne h B P.Se eeayls r ft, 31 72 83 2 ls e y r ft-1 r l . i , , , ;. l i ,
1-8 P’ Sp B e a 11 P’ Sp Rp B e a 14sc o I.. cspa g n n 71 ls up r ft -0 ls up e y r ft - einI A. ur (r t g ;. . i ;. . l i ; t I 1, ai
Gv n e ’ m inos m ayug e attre nis nt do u - et a mnud oe mns o ofr u m jd mn soh e r e iet d yre e e ne r t t r t e t e tl tf rt t r
teC T A h B P).
H wv ,h v uint u p msCs mt ap iem cad e ae o ddc v o eete a a o st e e i u o so pr s e hn s bsd n euie r lt at r t t a r i t
v u o yfrnain a e an b ue Se 9USC § 41 a sc o I spa Te a e n it sc o v u cno e sd e 1 ... 10a ) ein, ur. h l l a t l t . (; t
st e hs eu ete s ot nain a e vnwe (s e ) h by ad h sl a t u turq rs h ue fr sc o v u ee h e a h ete ue n te ee r at i a t l r r r lr e
r a dpo ddh “ ei u s ne ote a ..n c e tateet nh ..i n et , rv eta t c c m acs fh s e.id a [ h hr a os p. d o le i t h r t l i t] t li i d t
if ecter e o aenie ,h ternain a e c s y prx m e”i eote n uneh p c”r l ra v y a ht sc o v u “ oe apo a s e h fh l i ,t t ltt a t l l l i t tr
t oe v use o hnhst e ta s h te asc o v u c s y prx m ee h wts a es fr itet u –h i ta ht nain a el e apo a si e t l t t at t, t r t l ol i t tr
( ternain a e fdnc os ma m cad en a so n l e by snh US i ht sc o v u oie ia ri i r e hn si s et ur a d ue ite .. ) a t l t l l r i l et r
o()h ddc v v u o h c mu d a eo dnc os ma m cad e Se 9... r i e euie a er e o p e v ufr e ia ri i r e hn s e 1 USC it t l t t l i t l l r i.
§ 41 b 2 Bi() 8 ( ( ( (-i 4 10a ) ) ))i.
A d ae aoe h Gv n e tuf hsaetjsfte s ot nain a e s ei d bv te oe mn hsa afldouiyh ue fr sc o v u tl , r t r i t a t l
bsd nh “ ru s ne ote a. We e o n i s o i e oteGv n e t d s ae ote c c m acs fh s e i t l ” h h r o t ps b frh oe mn o o o tr t i sl r t
48 Tet u fr erq rsh tee v u uefr o p io “ l e t m cad e hst eu h eu eta hts a e sdoc masnr a [ o e hn s at t r i t tl r et ] r i ta ws xo etteU td t e aoao te a e m” sh m cad etsu Se h a epr doh ne Stst r bu h s mt e ate e hn s a se e t t i a t i r i i . 1 USC§ 41 b 2 B 9 ... 10a ) ) ) ((( . Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 5 ae 1
r m n a oe qein e einI A, ur. B , nayee ,q t aa fo te e a s n pn us o i t .Sesc o I.. spa u i n vn ue p tr m h t I 2 t t i r
“ ru s ne otea ”e, e h p t hs esuh omk a h w gsowe eon c c m acsfhs ets nte a y a y og t ae soi at h h r o i t l t i r r t t n tr t
ternain a els y prx m ete euie a e rh c mu d a e oie ia ht sc o v u c e apo a sh ddc v v u ote o p e v ufrdnc a t l ol i t t l t l t l
os ma m cad e te eod fht otsv us s fr itet u.Se 9... ri i r e hn s –h scn ote w “ t a e” e o hnh st e e 1 USC l r i e l t t at
§ 41 b 2 Bi; e gnr l D . B ea2-7e pa z gh, vnf c c m acs 10a ) ) )i se eeay e’ r ft 62 ( mhsi ta eei“ ru s ne ( ( ( () l fs i in t i t
ote a ”e i n siidst oye v us ms b cn d e b o d e m a o cn f h s ets s o as e t u r ts a e u e os e d e r e r i t n a l t t tf , a t t l t i r f e t ni
b md cnen g pr s mn u n t nain a e D. Rp B ea 1-7s m. e ae oc i ap ie e s gr sc o v u ; e’ e y r ft 61 (a e 4 rn a t i a t l ) fs l i )9
Mc en ae p t age h,b se n s m ay ug e bsds e o te ac ny t m s o ru ta y ek g u m jd mn ae ol n h l t t t i r t ly
c c m acs f h s ee, h Gv n e hsw vd h opr n y o ek o mk a ae i u s ne ote a ts te oe mn a a e te po u t t se t ae cs r t l t r t i ti
frh ue frnain a e ae otet u rtsv usSelsB ea2 (o nta ote s ot sc o v u bsd nh st oye a e e P’ r ft 9 n igh a t l at t l . . i t t
Gv n e “a n o e d n pof o s bs ae v u acp b a ddc v v u o oe mn hs o f r ay rot e a ih ts a e ce a e s euie a e r r t t fe tl t l tl t l
ud c mu d a e ad seigh “]te Gv n e ] ekt so te ce abi ] ne o p e v u ” n a r nta [fh[ oe mn seso h wh acp [ l y r t l, st ti r t t it
oarnain a e easte pr sd a e c s y prx m ee v us.,hn ws f t sc o v u bcueh ap ie v usl e apo a ts a e..tei a a t l a l ol i t t l t
[ eGv n e ’ bret o ee dne cod g ” H wv, Mc en ce n a hr y t oe mns udnof r v ec acr n y. o ee ac nyi s o u ot h r t] f i il) r l t t i
49 A epie aoea hr ea t m K wsh o y eei N a ga fhtp s x a d bv t ee vn i e B ate n sl n i r u oteye ln , t l t , l lr ca o m cad etsu h eadK d n slo n l e by s e sc o Ispa Tu f e hn s ai e e , n B i o e t ur a d ue.Se ein, ur. hs r i s r d tl et r t , te a n s e o “ e ia os ma m cad et “n l e by s n h U tdSts h e r o a s fi nc ri i r e hn s” o ur a d ue i te ne t e” r e l dt l l r i et r i a t s v a a a s oc masn o proe oteite v u s fr itet u. e 1 o e e s bs fr o p io fr upss fhfs s a e e o hnh st eSe 9 r i r r tt l t t at USC 10ab 2 Bi Te aish eo areh te n r ea tsv u h esh ...§ 41 ) ) )) h p t te fr g ta h o ye vn e a e e ite ( ( ( (. re r e e t l l t t l r scn oe–i.we e ht naina ec s y prx m e teeuie a eo h eod n ., h h e t rter sc o v u l e apo a s hddc v v u rte a t l ol i t t l c mu d a e oie iao s mam rhn s e 1 USC 10ab 2 Bi; e’ o p e v u fr dnc r i i r e cad e e 9...§ 41 ) ) )i D. t l t l l i .S ( ( ( () fs B e t2 epi n ta i l ho a s ft s ae tetss fr i ‘) cno b r fa 7(x a ig h, ni tffc o h cs h e e o h n(’ an e i ln t g t i ,“ tt t i t ape” P’ B ea2 n 1 n igh fsst oye v ui n apcb, bcueh p id ; ls r ft 3. (o nta itt u rts a es o p ia e“easte l ) . i 1 t t r at t l t l l rcr so sh K wsh o yrdc o mn tlrdl h gnN a ga. a o w c eod h wta B ate n poue f e’ a o c t ni i r u..l f h h t l r s i e oi ca l i ws h pd o Mc en” P’ Rp B e a 1-4 epi n ta“ e w e o a s f a s pe t ac ny ; ls e y r ft 31 (x a ig h t r e n s e o i l ) . l i ln t he r l ie iaos ma m cad emdt ur a dUSby s pnw c arnain a e f dnc ri i r e hn s aeo n l e .. ue uo h h t sc o v u o t l l r i et r i a t l ie iaos ma m cad emy e rd a d. dnc ri i r e hn s a b p i t ” t l l r i e ce ) Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 5 ae 2
t spo t snv apcinotedcieo w v. Nrcn Mc en d s Te o upr h oe p ia o f h o r f a e t i l l t tn i r o a ac ny o o h l .
Gv n e ws ne n o ia ot ad s b hh c c m acs fh s ee adhts oe mn a ud o b gino dr s o tei u s ne ote a ts ntee r t r l t e t r t l t t
v us nt m in o s m ay ug e . Segnr l,. ,1 Mo ’ Fd a P cc § a ei i o o fr u m jd mn e eeay e. 1 or s ee l r t e l s t r t l g e r ai
5 12p 5-0-630 d cs n “ai S m ay ug e s ad x a igi e a a 6 2 p 6375-1 ( su ig P tl u m Jd mn, n epi n n r l , . , . i s ra r t” ln , t i
ta“u m yug e my eeus d oo y s o n nr cs oat a o pt ci h s m a jd mn a brqe e n n at a e i ae r so c m e l m t r t t t l te , le a
o d es b a oa t p t o ci so d ess ;i §5 111 a p 5-9-630 r e ne u l s o as f l m r e ne” d f , t s r a f ) . 6 2[] ] p 6295-0 . [, .
(a ind“M t l [ u m yJd mn M in o Df e Gons So d N B cp oe t ui e S m a ug e ] o os n i e n rud hu lp r t t fr t l o e t
Dfvrd .0 i ao ” 5 s e)
Te o o l esh – n s ad nl hs en e r ieta h ue frnain h b t m nita u e n u i t a be d e m dh te s ot sc o t i t ls ti t n t a t
v ui n mna d yi etei u s ne ote a ts otet u r ts v us te a es o ad e b e h h c c m acs f h s ee r h st oye a e – h l t t tr r t l t at t l
st ei p de n p m ap ie e bsdo ddc v v u w c ite eu ta t u s m y os o e i pr s mn ae n euie a e h hs h rs t h at l t rt a t t l, i l t
Mc en avc e Mc en’ m in os m ay ug e te fr ms b dn d ac ny doa s ac ny o o fr u m jd mn h eo u e e e l t. l s t r t r e t i.
I. C n u o V oc s n li
Frhraos efr aoeteoen e ’ o o o s i frakf us c o oteesns o h bv hGv mnsm intd m s olco jr dt n t t , r t t i s i ii
Mc en’ l m ne tene t e C iba Bs rd a n s p c “ B P ”a ac ny l sci ud hU tdSts a ben a nT eP te h A a r i a - r i a r r i t( C T A s)
t a niso e hn hs cv e yPo s o 10-4105 u b rn d Te ol t e t rta toe oe db r e . 830-006ms eg t . h le r h r t tN t ae
Gv n e ’ o o ek gi m s odnlf ac ny B P l mi epc oh oe mnsm inse n d i a r e aoMc en’ r t t i s sl i l sC T Aci w hrse tte a t t
50 Mc en dv e ms oi iko te e v ussu t ag n ta a e ad o ac ny eo s o ft n n h ts a ei e o ru g h r mn t l t t s t l s i t Cs mi n aport See. P’ B ea1-41 1 n, 22 3 P’ Rp B e u o ss o prp a. e, g ls r ft 31 5 8. 2-5 2 ls e y r f t t ie ., . i , , 8 , ;. l i a 1-4 Mc en tufcss n n r w us o o poeu, n t et g s oete t 21 . ac ny hs oue o a a o qein f rcdr adr s o l s v h l r t e i o r ct aud l n p nosb a iea – pcia y Cs m st oy b gino pr s ri l ne y g o tf us n vl w se f l , u o s t u r o ia ot ap ie ic ri i tt i cl t ’ at l t a m cad e ae oi t nain a eee we te ueadhsl a r a d fi e e hn s bsd n sr sc o v u vn h eh by nteee r et , e h r i t a t l, r r lr e l e i t r ote wts s fr i 1 USC§ 41 b 2 Bi siid fht oe s e o hn 9 ... 10a ) ) )s as e t t t ((( tf . Cu N 0-08 or o 5044 t . Pg 5 ae 3
fue r s oe d yPo s o 830-006w c e ae b o c b ,20 or ni cv e b r e .10-4105 h hw emd e r t e te r t tN i r f eO o r2 00
s ma y u e rn d At te h e pcid nis h a sb ct teC T A E r i i r ms l l tb g t . s o htr se f e r ta r u e o h B P ( n y ae e ie te t e j t t
Ns WP00408 WP00422 adWP-020-) te Gv n e ’ m infr o J-027- . , J-029-, n J 00577 h oe mns o o o , r t t
s m ayug e msb g n d Otetehn b hh Gv n e ’ m inos m ay u m jd mn u er t . nh o r ad o te oe mns o ofr u m r t t ae h , t r t t r
jd mncnen gh poe m hd f pr s mnoa r m n g nis n Mc en’ ug e oc i te rp e o oap ie e fl e a i e r ad ac ny t rn r t a t l i n te l s
co - o o fr u m y ug e o te a esu ms b dn d rs m in os m a jd mn n h s mi e u e e e s t r t s t i.
A od wl n r cod g . n re i e eacr n y r l t il
/ Di aR g a s es i wy / ls d Di aA R g a es . i wy ls d Jde ug
D e Jnay 204 a d au 221 t: r , N wYr N wYr e ok e ok , E RT R AA
Mc en Pou s.U td t e Cu N 0-08 S pO 1- d e Jnay 221 ac ny rdc v ne Sts, or o 5044 l p 45 a d au 2 04 l t i a t . ,i . , t r , .
Pg 6 ae: Ite eui a l efhfsp arp ofo o 9d e te x a pcta nh pn t m e n o e r a g hfo n e, et h e rsae h l t i t it r a tt le t t apa i mdt y eo “v le pe s m e al b r [] u” r ie f e a .
Pg 9 ae: I teie m e al f l w g h b c qo, e ae 1 CFR§ w h 1 n hl i mdt y o oi te l k u erp c “9 ... ” i “9 n ie l n o t l t CFR§” ... § .
Pg 1 ae 0: I l eie f h fsf l a g p rp c “ ateK wu ”w hta K ni f oteit u p ar h e aet t h B o d i “ t B n v r l r a, l h l t h wu ” od l.
Pg 1 ae 5: I teial e f h m ne , ette pc b we “a e ad). n hf li ote a tx d e h sae e en s m” n “ ” n n i t le t ;
Pg 1 ae 6: I l ei rp c “ 2”w h F d ni s ,e ae Fd i “. ” n x l t 2.
Pg 2 ae 7: I l e ih oteit u p arp rp c “3 2” w h 1-0 (n te ni e t f h fsf l a g h e ae 1 -0 i “32” I o r n g r l r a, l t . h wrsd e te pctaapa i mdt yf r 1” n b o “2” od et h sae h pe s m e al a e“3 ad e r -0) , le t r ie t fe .
Pg 2 ae 8: I l e w ofo o 2 is t sae ewe “1 ad(t g. ni t o f o n e 8 ne a pc b en 1” n “ i n ” n tt , r t ci ,
Pg 3 ae 0: Il e 1t 1 otei h a g p ofo o 2 rp c “o d d mnr e n ns 3o 4 fh s t p ar h f o n e 8 e ae cu “e os a i x r a tt , l l tt tate r e. ”w h cu “e os a etate r e. ” h h p c.. i “o d d mnr [ h h p c... t i t l tt ] t i
Pg 4 ae 2: I tepn t m eieofo oe3 rp c “ 5 4-6 2 w h § 5 4- n h eui a l f o n t 8 e ae § 6 05 4 ” i “§ 6 0 l t n t , l . ., t . 54” 6 2. .,
Pg 5 ae 0: Itea l e fh scn f l a g p rp c “ 10ab 2 Bi() w h nhls i ote eod u p ar h e ae § 41 ) ) ))i. i tn l r a, l ( ( ( (-i ” t “§ 41 b 2 Bi(). § 10a ) ) ))i. ( ( ( (-i”
Fbu y 121 era 2 04 r , S P L E T LE R T U P EM N A R A A
Mc en Pou s.U td t e Cu N 0-08 S pO 1- d e Jnay 221 ac ny rdc v ne Sts, or o 5044 l p 45 a d au 2 04 l t i a t . ,i . , t r , .
Pg 1 ae: I teiigo cus frPi i, e ae J r P S k ,S mn &S k , n h lt f one o l nf rp c “e y . i i i os i i ” sn l a tf l r sn sn w h J r P W k ,S mn & W k , i “e y . i i i os i i ” t r sn s n.
Fbu y 521 era 2 04 r ,
Related
Cite This Page — Counsel Stack
2014 CIT 5, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/macclenny-prods-v-united-states-cit-2014.