Luis S. Lagaite v. Gregory C. Boland

Texas Supreme Court

Luis S. Lagaite v. Gregory C. Boland

Texas Supreme Court·Decided July 20, 2015·No. 07-15-00232-CV·Published

Opinion

~ ~UL~02~ ~ SEVENTH COURT OF APPEALS

VIVIAN LONG, CLERK

Rt.',. ~S-t- r\lD·H-el-l.S-CO.)~c\J---{f\11\L(~S~ rvow 97-0ht-c..:.iLul~ s, ~ 6~) \\(" ~ - - V-- &l \2_6 (jl i r, 5o lt:11\J D c..r- ~ L D~ ()... .('j Ett,l L

I

Pltl\5'<- hNn bJC\O)e. o; A 111i HoNollA~\~ Cwr( i~MG LJv(I.(&'IJ\W\.llli d-

1Y\t:: ~f)Jtur vV\L) OefL. .UtH')BIL rlu ((c LJ; :J 3 Oh As ·Jltu~o -v-- ..s ~, Al

J

37~ l VS ~~~)[ ',Lt3) ACCOMP/JtJ) ~~ UA()1 ., ObU.LM~Afl AAn &tl~:J\::Li V\1\DITb--n. ifhD'LiiA~~ IUS biH!(),~ 11 fut ~ i ~ 1A.l Uhs PatJ(tr 1D 'iw~ :Ju l-1 ~, ;)_Q \ ~y Ltsr1'e tV C) r 1'rit: Ciwl 0 Di 1 tU) u A) f 0 hJ c; LJJJ--J DoWM "WI-S. D (U

ft.\/Qllblv CvAIS1De-ttrtn MsU_~S)/Jfl'-/ 1&1 t1Vtt- CaM 11'o ~ 1~ tO JI?P~IkJr~ c1un~.>{j0no.~

Pit~~h:o-&11N& <flie /Jf3w.5" lb~iJ<tJ ro \\tt: A\\bNc)urJ of- ~ ~l A( \[WI) ti\AILb-S\GloAJvtui-ctJC€: .

Cb~e(?Ofl~ Ct &0 \t;)"--' D e:J' AL AD 06l t:e:~.

~kts HfHJO~~lt. eourL'\ H~;vl~ Ju&tSOlci\oJ 0r lli~ 6u&JEc\ M~\Th.Q_ 0f\JD~r.z fLu L£ iL a~ 3 D(p AS l~N.St.f\/o -V-- 3,QfN 3 7J.. u.s .J95[ )·gtp3_)

dU~\I(A:!-~

1o 1'\tt:.- I~OfJOO...tJ~\G: or .s~) 0 ColA,;,,

1\)DVJ C'vMES tu lo 0 " L~ 6.A i ~ J rv l~ PP~IIAI\.If ~N D l-le.Cffi'-4 ~ IE..s 1Yt I 5 R€) -fu~"f. ·FV 11\e:. tlB1)\f'B AaoMPt:ltJIE..O W\rvt OOtuMe.tJrs. Su~Pco:\lAJb. rfs APP~\1~~ J\J!\t.S.D)L'f\OrJ :Ji m,,:,{)\£ :0 r'2 t.l CJ f: 1\i I"':;,U &:J:ec( W.. GY.R. , fr·\\6 Gout,( ~~~vr; l9.8UA sm ifS fowe-[L/ or JW\1.5.01 Cfl orJ oven> 1\-\lo SllM~ c:'ASE fu IL &> 'I (::}:)flS uNO tJt... roo If ~n-o 8- o'-1 "' ~'l t-v .

Old.-\ 0~ o /V'oV't:J N\ ts~a... \ to , JoD<)

Uf\J D£~ tvv .Jt Eil=. 1,:;!.: 0 J?.J. 19 ·- ~ :t> tU D~ 0 tuO\J'e)M ~"'€-~ i o\ ).O \ Y , cy . .

urvo\::..(\) No~ ~1_r~_g8,t611 -rv. o~c(o~a- Afll\L GL-·~1 s .. . L( 1s ThE: Pd)\JVtcv of 1'\hS. utllNil 1'0 DtCH)~ .<\ ~\\ldl. IN fON'\rtoJa:sy fbn ~o lo"'t.. '1)(6( f\-'\e; i rw~ \ Ulv\ ( NAS f ~ 1~ t. rJ {0 Out~..l f)Q \N b '\MtS MA s\efl-. 1b 'Ill.\ tl L; .. Wk \.t.H G~\IBS ilhS C&.v~ r APPEll~~~ Co~-.~cuur~r-, CoAJnf\)q\rJ~,c.O.t..IDINt<l·\"b; 8clvtS\VcH Pt:;l00EJS\) Pl ~~ll.-'4 I pf)\!VW(V.-\ i J.Hl\S fUILno rJ CJ t n{~ D'VbJeef IV$)~ i 1$ ~LS CA\.S ~t X\.ttc, JIJ./)1~ D1 cf\tJf'J~G f~ c:f t.X.l3 (s ~fo~t& M~ U:lurr H~ Pl\o P8!..-juf)\&D)L no tJ of- 1V\t) f~~~;{)W\~1\Cn&~ A.S 1)1o(1)t([ Otfbi\J~tJr..S i~~s bttrJ PtWP&a.J-13&\MD Wdl--1 · Pl\oLt:5S ..~rJC 1Y1h{ f)1E. CaN1nC\VffiS-J ts APPkll.0Jf I.S JNDibt.NIIJNIJ u AJar l!D/1£.

\ ro r~~ 1){~ ~()Jf\( t~Q,u,t,b1) nltuh (tr 5t:ZL>uJ~ Df- 31'Aruffitz."\ B~IL or P11APJe.tl.- Ji~O()L/

I

1\1\.S {f.Ut$ DlD \{/\~ 0$),~{)\U\uJ ()£Q A~P~\\JvJf tbi I~ l'=.bA\. fovJf.(~ m (e()~et'L> ~ ~ettJ vN~\.... aub bMCr-Jf ~~e1tJ IWO ~6~NS\ APPt:\ kiJ 1o 111c tl~0\J'e- AL'f\o/\ 1 1)%( I~AS fbtx-f\1 .R\ott:\mv\Jb fbi\ ~1c- ~AS( lo ie~ct.S~. flAA lYtrlfl MC)!\ (' 1YV6 N 0\\ (A~ ~

~POt~ L, 15 NO { UN \h"()t \1 \f\11{,(; rJ lJMCt.JL, f.u \t L\ I .J. f\Ji) . NO~(£ f) f- ·t (\;\ ~ L-

I

jl,{IJ6MtrJ·1 iN We Cit/0~1--L w4S G'-\BIJ 1D APP~HAi'J\ ~v~.o( \0 CA) (\) 5 . JJv ~c_( 11{~ Jti)bMtf\11 OJi~'GIV iiJ\th.LD {\) Ott ~f\£ ~p~~l ~JJ\ 1\ Vt::XAfiOv\S. l-1'\\&A.N) oI'J fYl~tC,r\ \ .11.0 1s A.s {)n te.Qu) B-4 11\t:: J\JOh~ SI.Mt.S '\)Ab( 1Ht C.luJL t ~ oaoette.,o

1

~ 1? hbe:, ,()1\li OOWN\VJ(.S, Wl1ttf1 flb6.~tv0~ ro AP:>t:IIAtJ1 tJf)f\ L IN~ -P.A)'-LS PtL '$ 1, 500~ ~ luJ b ~·-A\\ t9tl'lk.IV DDWMt'J\1\1 'fbN'O ft%~ 13 o,J EewrG[) !' ~1\ "t\~ to.Mrs D~fu\N')wA nuJ of 1<~ ~~~OIWo.tJ,. Mfll::l~N(S l~t..S t.Nctt.Ut:.p t~f\f · DeowM-tN'\S AND VM\'f£-~ Pe.At~\N\1\JCo -ro 'f}t{£. ChM~ 01H&,N£\L0uM~OlC1lOAl, G~/(Tt).

.Ctrz1\DcJJft o(.; ,SEJI \.hCP:

:L, tlO H8Lffi'\ OOL'\\ f\6. {~{ or A ~w8: 0)\~\lv lft.... 1)\6 HOAJOnA~\e:

~{ .JJ~Vf Ju~O\C<10N 0 r f)t~Su.W"rcf lm\ThiL.. UN/JB'l.; fLu l~ Yt .l. i),Ob AS' 1\JvJ~ D-V- Sll1!'J ·3; d. Us J-q:; c19'113 ·) l~LcoMPtJN\~ w1 rr1 l JJnwM&JQ (\'\IJ))lt't) -~ ttJ1\&\(S .N~ ~ S'eNl fD '\11e JiotJo~{)\(2: \JI\J\AN l.DIJ6. Ctbv\l l!tSt~lL Po.Y\~G~ rn~,PAHJ of\.3-m,s~ie· 1501 0..()'-'}0r(JuL~ 2l0 \5 AS fu (\0 ws ~ '

v I

Crun1 of A.P.f>e..A~ cSt.VEJJn~ D\~' Q.,\ c..jf vt ~ 'NON 0 fZ j\) ~ l~ V\ Vt ~N WN tO lJ Y ·0 · 5o·'i. q5 LfO ~M~QALtO)l~ f79\0S-q$y1)

l

EXH\5tf A .,

'

.I

··: . . f.

···-

BRIAN QUINN PEGGYCULP ChiefJustice · CLERK

JAMES T. CAMPBELL Justice ~.e&.entlf ~~5f:rid of W:.exa:s MAILING ADDRESS:

P. 0. Box 9540

MACKEY K. HANCOCK Justice :Jnfur <UllUll±g <UaurlslfimlDing_ . 79105-9540

sol~. Jlfillnwr.e,~mt.e :Z.-;A ...

PATRICK A. PIRTLE '(806) 342-2650 Justice. J\mmilla, W:.exa:s 7!}101..:'2449 ,• .. ·w~fu.itlr~?a:.c:nurts.m:a:±.e:~~us ·.

. ' . .

July 1.7, 401.4 ~· . .; '· ...

'.

.. \ .··:. ' - -··

Harold J. Liller . · : , .... , Luis S .. Lagaite Jr. · OFFICE' OF ATTORNEY GENE,RAL ·.· TDCJ-.ib# 76'2508 -P.O. Box·12548 John ;JViontford Unit Capital Station 8602 ·Peach st. Austin, TX 78711 Lubbock, TX 79404 *DELIVERED VIA E-MAIL*

REf Case Number: 07-14-00219-CV · Trial Court Case Number: 97,061-C · >·.

Styl,e: Luis'S: Lagaite, Jr. #762508 ......

v: ··}

·Gregory C. Boland, et al ..

Dear Counsel and Mr. Lagaite:

. The fol.lowing ·was filed in. the captioned appeal as of Monday, ·July 14, . 2014: ' . .. . ..

.;

Cl :o.~L-'s·

-1•, I . ··("'I ·''"'I'

r:;)~""oru.-1 I'C\J VV Ulll ;·..,.,e)

· · Ver/ truly y·6~rs,

•.··.g~··>~

PEGGY GULP, C_LERK

xc: Barbara Younger (DELIVERED VIA E-rylA,.IL)

Honorable Ana Estevez (DELIVERED ViA E-MAIL) . Caroline Woodburn (DELIVERED VtA E-MAIL) ··· . .' ·.

~ • < • • .... • • __ ;

. ; ..

. •. i

'"'., ...

-v--

\/~L.

~n~~Oili f. -~ bwl~u!J £' N DR\ N\~ De.(E f 3 -W A i tvfJ\lN \S \-\EA e) tJC ? \)· ~ \JJA i 0 t,'\®{tON 10 HOLO Dt..fe Th ~ 'S ~NN CODE. ftc J~N\ fD CH ~P R: \ t-p. 0 t> * iA 1t1 t. CON ft::.fl.E.tJ t E .lPuDbRs

j

_\O Co ull..r! .

W& t3 -~ u rJ _ . !f_ 0.Q 0 ,oAM€.8 C6U.s~

ira 1H~ r\oNo K~~u; j\ ~ Do\.\-0 /l_

m ~ ~e o" ~ 8N \\t\.E " .4,,J1 lu ts s \LArtE" JR. tl\l

GA -1 5. ~7eQrA J6.

~ON\~s t\\Ow P\A\AnfF Uf\\ 1'0 l\O lO OefkNDAN~S. 1-l'i cf Ac_{! oJ ,ANDWP" "~QE.€:>. . 1 Pt;.\\\101\J ~A~J\ \L? CI-\Ot>te-n. \t{\oo&- ft~ f\JtJN fOfie. rncC· W \S CO

(3'-\ W~'-\ 0~ 3- -\ \\:-\ECoJ\J~QtNCf""

0 t\1~ UlJJL( {1-{~ fOf\M ltJ, 6

ow lJtJ\'

fl\\10 W 't'Ul\) SH :rAC: f~ ..

f G: WAs H€./0 A 1 ;i){G:

·

1( ~) 11 ~: .h ~. (o Nf t. Rt NC A '\HRE\r-WA'- W Oe.C.lArt£ ~1111tf OrJ ft:BillHJtl\{ L d-012. <L OE ffif\J C, /JN \S M O tlo fJ tAW lt &~tlJ-~ (l)N 'tHe f>, \\ it;MetJ\S l)() l'f.S ONO\Nb Clftf)JM&'\AtJCb AND As ~o N o flt.ASDN Q Ve:r.A1G.\S u't:< 'uANf, {HE1LI!- ts NO iMPt:JJ ."rL MotJ\ Fo«.n tow ll&n.AR.l-J WH1t.H DD Jf BE- H~\o A11\'\\t Jor~ COt J'f E.n etJ C~ J..Je:.AfLIN(; B\1 fkotJtt WM--\ -1He. s.t>Mt: CJJNf\lf 10 Ho to A e JhJA\\~~\~ I'AECMMJ\V v'\ ~v~ A\NO Pt\UJi()~ m~- 50-M :a: ArJ~.L-'\ s\S

~t J\ S1 u~ \O ~~ Po Sl t No\otJl'-1 uPotJ· L.06tc... -\1%\ OO:f wc -L-< De.fu£5 ~)) 1-\VM~t~i'J0\Sa n)sO ufor-J Pl41N1"1F<.

.

. FA cd rP ·J ~' f Pf\l2s_ef\Jcg-____gf_ jH~ uPno,.J of tr\t: M hO \ct>L ~H~..Vu~rJt(I<Jd ~1\10 ·n- T A~ rJ L- -f , 1h ll\ 01 ~ 00 JlN~I lAW 8tJWnLeM

e.N

!J NO'\ ~\~u 1H~i5H~r\f f.. 6u Nc-S

1'oft.N _ SU fi.G " l}~ ~t -lf\J'fubt'Lff•J 8t THe Ht.Aftl Pltwnf-t:-- IS 12~U\fttO.s,A{ tt1 HE -Ail\N<b

-"-'1 ON fHE: Bt.KA)f- d nJG:""

Db ME

11AfLq ~t*Aa.,!Jo

JO J\A

.. 1f Nor 1H~: \A(\L o ::x >Jt ()).\CoM~· tS i,uDtt{ou fL EO fb~ ~\i iOE :JJ SeNG6 • j O~li R~U\

lA w )f A

DEft.tJD~N\~, Pl.llvrt\HS ~etl( AtJO \5 f2e.APi ~a.. '(qi.Q(..., W\11(11 l) N0\'1U~ OOE~ FUAM t:ttMOM;'

<'10 ~\~ cj_s~~J\1\10 \\.5 11Le-D ANO %S O~~tl M\:J A- 5 \5 ~P

{l-\E. t:tJLAAbtM!2r·r( t'lr {HVtt ~)'\~'fut & of llM ~\or

b

\'fM ro

t() J!f \;

N

AN

N.t

Ot rlb~C\\h\ a.eN\eDH:!

~COOf~tJD

> Bt.N('"i VJM( bJJ'r" ~HWLl} ~ {0 \He R4le' S\

)J'i\06\ tf\J ~CtOt\O~tJ f1~ Pl, Gbt lot J w~ K~ Plle.M\~~ \5 ,\O Ot eC ~f\OC<:dJift~, ~Ht:Jii ~~t! \N Co tJS

No-t' t~Sl <,

!E OtJlE)S Def-eNDIVN'(

~ \5 ~e.()O ~ fD f:D to {tUAL..

rrr .

f~ r,.,,u,s Dl

ih.1llll:

SA-d of 111( fA'i.

~~~l)fu~\lis T''~'~'"S\~ . DO ~IY( ~~~-~- /J &NG\1 W~f(~N\s tOll A frl\V\ \~ ANn Mo~o . \. .

PMts '\\'\)( '\\\\)

·.

\1U tJO M!!>IG:' (\uq{,

.

~r>~otJ ~f ~~ ~t!: \ -< _B_'{ 'trtt _11H 0\~fa.tc, ~(of AQQeiJL ()tJ ~~IV~aV_\·~:.Nl~N\,}!\~2-l;~3 c\~' ~t)\ 0-.t_ . J •0"0\tf,

t llND W AS '¥0\0E

~~--

-C

. _n -~~v

niM~ :l :J

= , __ 1

E5(H!5Jl

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

~ ~UL~02~ ~ SEVENTH COURT OF APPEALS

VIVIAN LONG, CLERK

Rt.',. ~S-t- r\lD·H-el-l.S-CO.)~c\J---{f\11\L(~S~ rvow 97-0ht-c..:.iLul~ s, ~ 6~) \\(" ~ - - V-- &l \2_6 (jl i r, 5o lt:11\J D c..r- ~ L D~ ()... .('j Ett,l L

I

Pltl\5'<- hNn bJC\O)e. o; A 111i HoNollA~\~ Cwr( i~MG LJv(I.(&'IJ\W\.llli d-

1Y\t:: ~f)Jtur vV\L) OefL. .UtH')BIL rlu ((c LJ; :J 3 Oh As ·Jltu~o -v-- ..s ~, Al

J

37~ l VS ~~~)[ ',Lt3) ACCOMP/JtJ) ~~ UA()1 ., ObU.LM~Afl AAn &tl~:J\::Li V\1\DITb--n. ifhD'LiiA~~ IUS biH!(),~ 11 fut ~ i ~ 1A.l Uhs PatJ(tr 1D 'iw~ :Ju l-1 ~, ;)_Q \ ~y Ltsr1'e tV C) r 1'rit: Ciwl 0 Di 1 tU) u A) f 0 hJ c; LJJJ--J DoWM "WI-S. D (U

ft.\/Qllblv CvAIS1De-ttrtn MsU_~S)/Jfl'-/ 1&1 t1Vtt- CaM 11'o ~ 1~ tO JI?P~IkJr~ c1un~.>{j0no.~

Pit~~h:o-&11N& <flie /Jf3w.5" lb~iJ<tJ ro \\tt: A\\bNc)urJ of- ~ ~l A( \[WI) ti\AILb-S\GloAJvtui-ctJC€: .

Cb~e(?Ofl~ Ct &0 \t;)"--' D e:J' AL AD 06l t:e:~.

~kts HfHJO~~lt. eourL'\ H~;vl~ Ju&tSOlci\oJ 0r lli~ 6u&JEc\ M~\Th.Q_ 0f\JD~r.z fLu L£ iL a~ 3 D(p AS l~N.St.f\/o -V-- 3,QfN 3 7J.. u.s .J95[ )·gtp3_)

dU~\I(A:!-~

1o 1'\tt:.- I~OfJOO...tJ~\G: or .s~) 0 ColA,;,,

1\)DVJ C'vMES tu lo 0 " L~ 6.A i ~ J rv l~ PP~IIAI\.If ~N D l-le.Cffi'-4 ~ IE..s 1Yt I 5 R€) -fu~"f. ·FV 11\e:. tlB1)\f'B AaoMPt:ltJIE..O W\rvt OOtuMe.tJrs. Su~Pco:\lAJb. rfs APP~\1~~ J\J!\t.S.D)L'f\OrJ :Ji m,,:,{)\£ :0 r'2 t.l CJ f: 1\i I"':;,U &:J:ec( W.. GY.R. , fr·\\6 Gout,( ~~~vr; l9.8UA sm ifS fowe-[L/ or JW\1.5.01 Cfl orJ oven> 1\-\lo SllM~ c:'ASE fu IL &> 'I (::}:)flS uNO tJt... roo If ~n-o 8- o'-1 "' ~'l t-v .

Old.-\ 0~ o /V'oV't:J N\ ts~a... \ to , JoD<)

Uf\J D£~ tvv .Jt Eil=. 1,:;!.: 0 J?.J. 19 ·- ~ :t> tU D~ 0 tuO\J'e)M ~"'€-~ i o\ ).O \ Y , cy . .

urvo\::..(\) No~ ~1_r~_g8,t611 -rv. o~c(o~a- Afll\L GL-·~1 s .. . L( 1s ThE: Pd)\JVtcv of 1'\hS. utllNil 1'0 DtCH)~ .<\ ~\\ldl. IN fON'\rtoJa:sy fbn ~o lo"'t.. '1)(6( f\-'\e; i rw~ \ Ulv\ ( NAS f ~ 1~ t. rJ {0 Out~..l f)Q \N b '\MtS MA s\efl-. 1b 'Ill.\ tl L; .. Wk \.t.H G~\IBS ilhS C&.v~ r APPEll~~~ Co~-.~cuur~r-, CoAJnf\)q\rJ~,c.O.t..IDINt<l·\"b; 8clvtS\VcH Pt:;l00EJS\) Pl ~~ll.-'4 I pf)\!VW(V.-\ i J.Hl\S fUILno rJ CJ t n{~ D'VbJeef IV$)~ i 1$ ~LS CA\.S ~t X\.ttc, JIJ./)1~ D1 cf\tJf'J~G f~ c:f t.X.l3 (s ~fo~t& M~ U:lurr H~ Pl\o P8!..-juf)\&D)L no tJ of- 1V\t) f~~~;{)W\~1\Cn&~ A.S 1)1o(1)t([ Otfbi\J~tJr..S i~~s bttrJ PtWP&a.J-13&\MD Wdl--1 · Pl\oLt:5S ..~rJC 1Y1h{ f)1E. CaN1nC\VffiS-J ts APPkll.0Jf I.S JNDibt.NIIJNIJ u AJar l!D/1£.

\ ro r~~ 1){~ ~()Jf\( t~Q,u,t,b1) nltuh (tr 5t:ZL>uJ~ Df- 31'Aruffitz."\ B~IL or P11APJe.tl.- Ji~O()L/

I

1\1\.S {f.Ut$ DlD \{/\~ 0$),~{)\U\uJ ()£Q A~P~\\JvJf tbi I~ l'=.bA\. fovJf.(~ m (e()~et'L> ~ ~ettJ vN~\.... aub bMCr-Jf ~~e1tJ IWO ~6~NS\ APPt:\ kiJ 1o 111c tl~0\J'e- AL'f\o/\ 1 1)%( I~AS fbtx-f\1 .R\ott:\mv\Jb fbi\ ~1c- ~AS( lo ie~ct.S~. flAA lYtrlfl MC)!\ (' 1YV6 N 0\\ (A~ ~

~POt~ L, 15 NO { UN \h"()t \1 \f\11{,(; rJ lJMCt.JL, f.u \t L\ I .J. f\Ji) . NO~(£ f) f- ·t (\;\ ~ L-

I

jl,{IJ6MtrJ·1 iN We Cit/0~1--L w4S G'-\BIJ 1D APP~HAi'J\ ~v~.o( \0 CA) (\) 5 . JJv ~c_( 11{~ Jti)bMtf\11 OJi~'GIV iiJ\th.LD {\) Ott ~f\£ ~p~~l ~JJ\ 1\ Vt::XAfiOv\S. l-1'\\&A.N) oI'J fYl~tC,r\ \ .11.0 1s A.s {)n te.Qu) B-4 11\t:: J\JOh~ SI.Mt.S '\)Ab( 1Ht C.luJL t ~ oaoette.,o

1

~ 1? hbe:, ,()1\li OOWN\VJ(.S, Wl1ttf1 flb6.~tv0~ ro AP:>t:IIAtJ1 tJf)f\ L IN~ -P.A)'-LS PtL '$ 1, 500~ ~ luJ b ~·-A\\ t9tl'lk.IV DDWMt'J\1\1 'fbN'O ft%~ 13 o,J EewrG[) !' ~1\ "t\~ to.Mrs D~fu\N')wA nuJ of 1<~ ~~~OIWo.tJ,. Mfll::l~N(S l~t..S t.Nctt.Ut:.p t~f\f · DeowM-tN'\S AND VM\'f£-~ Pe.At~\N\1\JCo -ro 'f}t{£. ChM~ 01H&,N£\L0uM~OlC1lOAl, G~/(Tt).

.Ctrz1\DcJJft o(.; ,SEJI \.hCP:

:L, tlO H8Lffi'\ OOL'\\ f\6. {~{ or A ~w8: 0)\~\lv lft.... 1)\6 HOAJOnA~\e:

~{ .JJ~Vf Ju~O\C<10N 0 r f)t~Su.W"rcf lm\ThiL.. UN/JB'l.; fLu l~ Yt .l. i),Ob AS' 1\JvJ~ D-V- Sll1!'J ·3; d. Us J-q:; c19'113 ·) l~LcoMPtJN\~ w1 rr1 l JJnwM&JQ (\'\IJ))lt't) -~ ttJ1\&\(S .N~ ~ S'eNl fD '\11e JiotJo~{)\(2: \JI\J\AN l.DIJ6. Ctbv\l l!tSt~lL Po.Y\~G~ rn~,PAHJ of\.3-m,s~ie· 1501 0..()'-'}0r(JuL~ 2l0 \5 AS fu (\0 ws ~ '

v I

Crun1 of A.P.f>e..A~ cSt.VEJJn~ D\~' Q.,\ c..jf vt ~ 'NON 0 fZ j\) ~ l~ V\ Vt ~N WN tO lJ Y ·0 · 5o·'i. q5 LfO ~M~QALtO)l~ f79\0S-q$y1)

l

EXH\5tf A .,

'

.I

··: . . f.

···-

BRIAN QUINN PEGGYCULP ChiefJustice · CLERK

JAMES T. CAMPBELL Justice ~.e&.entlf ~~5f:rid of W:.exa:s MAILING ADDRESS:

P. 0. Box 9540

MACKEY K. HANCOCK Justice :Jnfur <UllUll±g <UaurlslfimlDing_ . 79105-9540

sol~. Jlfillnwr.e,~mt.e :Z.-;A ...

PATRICK A. PIRTLE '(806) 342-2650 Justice. J\mmilla, W:.exa:s 7!}101..:'2449 ,• .. ·w~fu.itlr~?a:.c:nurts.m:a:±.e:~~us ·.

. ' . .

July 1.7, 401.4 ~· . .; '· ...

'.

.. \ .··:. ' - -··

Harold J. Liller . · : , .... , Luis S .. Lagaite Jr. · OFFICE' OF ATTORNEY GENE,RAL ·.· TDCJ-.ib# 76'2508 -P.O. Box·12548 John ;JViontford Unit Capital Station 8602 ·Peach st. Austin, TX 78711 Lubbock, TX 79404 *DELIVERED VIA E-MAIL*

REf Case Number: 07-14-00219-CV · Trial Court Case Number: 97,061-C · >·.

Styl,e: Luis'S: Lagaite, Jr. #762508 ......

v: ··}

·Gregory C. Boland, et al ..

Dear Counsel and Mr. Lagaite:

. The fol.lowing ·was filed in. the captioned appeal as of Monday, ·July 14, . 2014: ' . .. . ..

.;

Cl :o.~L-'s·

-1•, I . ··("'I ·''"'I'

r:;)~""oru.-1 I'C\J VV Ulll ;·..,.,e)

· · Ver/ truly y·6~rs,

•.··.g~··>~

PEGGY GULP, C_LERK

xc: Barbara Younger (DELIVERED VIA E-rylA,.IL)

Honorable Ana Estevez (DELIVERED ViA E-MAIL) . Caroline Woodburn (DELIVERED VtA E-MAIL) ··· . .' ·.

~ • < • • .... • • __ ;

. ; ..

. •. i

'"'., ...

-v--

\/~L.

~n~~Oili f. -~ bwl~u!J £' N DR\ N\~ De.(E f 3 -W A i tvfJ\lN \S \-\EA e) tJC ? \)· ~ \JJA i 0 t,'\®{tON 10 HOLO Dt..fe Th ~ 'S ~NN CODE. ftc J~N\ fD CH ~P R: \ t-p. 0 t> * iA 1t1 t. CON ft::.fl.E.tJ t E .lPuDbRs

j

_\O Co ull..r! .

W& t3 -~ u rJ _ . !f_ 0.Q 0 ,oAM€.8 C6U.s~

ira 1H~ r\oNo K~~u; j\ ~ Do\.\-0 /l_

m ~ ~e o" ~ 8N \\t\.E " .4,,J1 lu ts s \LArtE" JR. tl\l

GA -1 5. ~7eQrA J6.

~ON\~s t\\Ow P\A\AnfF Uf\\ 1'0 l\O lO OefkNDAN~S. 1-l'i cf Ac_{! oJ ,ANDWP" "~QE.€:>. . 1 Pt;.\\\101\J ~A~J\ \L? CI-\Ot>te-n. \t{\oo&- ft~ f\JtJN fOfie. rncC· W \S CO

(3'-\ W~'-\ 0~ 3- -\ \\:-\ECoJ\J~QtNCf""

0 t\1~ UlJJL( {1-{~ fOf\M ltJ, 6

ow lJtJ\'

fl\\10 W 't'Ul\) SH :rAC: f~ ..

f G: WAs H€./0 A 1 ;i){G:

·

1( ~) 11 ~: .h ~. (o Nf t. Rt NC A '\HRE\r-WA'- W Oe.C.lArt£ ~1111tf OrJ ft:BillHJtl\{ L d-012. <L OE ffif\J C, /JN \S M O tlo fJ tAW lt &~tlJ-~ (l)N 'tHe f>, \\ it;MetJ\S l)() l'f.S ONO\Nb Clftf)JM&'\AtJCb AND As ~o N o flt.ASDN Q Ve:r.A1G.\S u't:< 'uANf, {HE1LI!- ts NO iMPt:JJ ."rL MotJ\ Fo«.n tow ll&n.AR.l-J WH1t.H DD Jf BE- H~\o A11\'\\t Jor~ COt J'f E.n etJ C~ J..Je:.AfLIN(; B\1 fkotJtt WM--\ -1He. s.t>Mt: CJJNf\lf 10 Ho to A e JhJA\\~~\~ I'AECMMJ\V v'\ ~v~ A\NO Pt\UJi()~ m~- 50-M :a: ArJ~.L-'\ s\S

~t J\ S1 u~ \O ~~ Po Sl t No\otJl'-1 uPotJ· L.06tc... -\1%\ OO:f wc -L-< De.fu£5 ~)) 1-\VM~t~i'J0\Sa n)sO ufor-J Pl41N1"1F<.

.

. FA cd rP ·J ~' f Pf\l2s_ef\Jcg-____gf_ jH~ uPno,.J of tr\t: M hO \ct>L ~H~..Vu~rJt(I<Jd ~1\10 ·n- T A~ rJ L- -f , 1h ll\ 01 ~ 00 JlN~I lAW 8tJWnLeM

e.N

!J NO'\ ~\~u 1H~i5H~r\f f.. 6u Nc-S

1'oft.N _ SU fi.G " l}~ ~t -lf\J'fubt'Lff•J 8t THe Ht.Aftl Pltwnf-t:-- IS 12~U\fttO.s,A{ tt1 HE -Ail\N<b

-"-'1 ON fHE: Bt.KA)f- d nJG:""

Db ME

11AfLq ~t*Aa.,!Jo

JO J\A

.. 1f Nor 1H~: \A(\L o ::x >Jt ()).\CoM~· tS i,uDtt{ou fL EO fb~ ~\i iOE :JJ SeNG6 • j O~li R~U\

lA w )f A

DEft.tJD~N\~, Pl.llvrt\HS ~etl( AtJO \5 f2e.APi ~a.. '(qi.Q(..., W\11(11 l) N0\'1U~ OOE~ FUAM t:ttMOM;'

<'10 ~\~ cj_s~~J\1\10 \\.5 11Le-D ANO %S O~~tl M\:J A- 5 \5 ~P

{l-\E. t:tJLAAbtM!2r·r( t'lr {HVtt ~)'\~'fut & of llM ~\or

b

\'fM ro

t() J!f \;

N

AN

N.t

Ot rlb~C\\h\ a.eN\eDH:!

~COOf~tJD

> Bt.N('"i VJM( bJJ'r" ~HWLl} ~ {0 \He R4le' S\

)J'i\06\ tf\J ~CtOt\O~tJ f1~ Pl, Gbt lot J w~ K~ Plle.M\~~ \5 ,\O Ot eC ~f\OC<:dJift~, ~Ht:Jii ~~t! \N Co tJS

No-t' t~Sl <,

!E OtJlE)S Def-eNDIVN'(

~ \5 ~e.()O ~ fD f:D to {tUAL..

rrr .

f~ r,.,,u,s Dl

ih.1llll:

SA-d of 111( fA'i.

~~~l)fu~\lis T''~'~'"S\~ . DO ~IY( ~~~-~- /J &NG\1 W~f(~N\s tOll A frl\V\ \~ ANn Mo~o . \. .

PMts '\\'\)( '\\\\)

·.

\1U tJO M!!>IG:' (\uq{,

.

~r>~otJ ~f ~~ ~t!: \ -< _B_'{ 'trtt _11H 0\~fa.tc, ~(of AQQeiJL ()tJ ~~IV~aV_\·~:.Nl~N\,}!\~2-l;~3 c\~' ~t)\ 0-.t_ . J •0"0\tf,

t llND W AS '¥0\0E

~~--

-C

. _n -~~v

niM~ :l :J

= , __ 1

E5(H!5Jl

CAUSE NO. 97,061-C . ~ LUIS LAGAITE # 762508, § IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF Plaintiff, § §

v. § POTTER COUNTY, TEXAS §

GREGORY BOLAND, et al., § '· ' ,•' .~ Defendants.

;f .. . -·' . :.

~j : ' ' . {

§ 251ST JUDICIAL DISTRICT .....:

NOTICE OF HEARING . . .

Defendant hereby provides notice· that an on:tl hearing has be~n scheduled for Wednesday, '"· ·" . !. ' " : .

. ,. . •,

January 14, 2015, at 9:30 a.m. concerning Defendant's Motion to Enlarge Time and Declare

Plaintiff a Vexatious Litigant filed on September 9, 2011. Copies of this notice are being placed

in the U.S. mail on this date to the Plaintiff ~d ·,,filed'

. ' .

electronically with the District Clerk.

' ·~ ,". '

Respectfully: submitted,

GREG ABBOTT Attorney General of Texas

DANIEL T. HODGE First Assistant Attorney Gen.eral ·, . .;._.·

-:bAVID C>MA1T:AX Deputy Attorney General for Defense Litigation

KAREN D. MATLOCK Assistant Attorney General Chief, Law Enforcement Defense Division

BRIAN QUINN VIVIAN LONG Chief Justice Clerk

JAMES T. CAMPBELL Justice J&c&cnflr ~istricl of Wcxaz MAILING ADDRESS:

MACKEY K. HANCOCK J.ottcr illount~ illourlzl@uil.Oins P. 0. Box 9540 79105-9540

Justice sotJ&. Jllillmorc,Jl§uitc 2-!'--

PATRICK A. PIRTLE Justice !'--mm-illo, Wcxaz 79101-2449 (806) 342-2650

fufuudx.courlz.so&/ 7±q.coa.azpx

May 14, 2015

Luis S. Lagaite Jr. TDCJ-ID# 762508 Byrd Unit 21 FM 247 Huntsville, TX 77320

RE: Case Number: 07-15-00111-CV Trial Court Case Number: 97,061-C

Style: Luis S. Lagaite v. Gregory C. Boland, et al.

Dear Mr. Lagaite:

By Order of the Court, the motion to stay filed by appellant is denied as moot.

Very truly yours,

~~ VIVIAN LONG, CLERK

xc: Harold J. Liller (DELIVERED VIA E-MAIL)

·. tXniDtf

0 .~ I

BR)AN QUINN Chief Ju>ticO

<n.nurt nf ~ --.ea:Is

C~~·

..f,.J- PEGGY CULP

CLERK

JAMES T. CAMPBELL

MAILING ADDRESS:

Justice

~e&enfiT ~istrid of Wexa:s P. 0. Box 9540 MACKEY K. HANCOCK Jlrtter @nuntlJ @nurts ~uilmng . 79105-9540 Justice

501~. Jlj'illmnre,~uite Z-~ PATRICK A. PIRTLE (806) 342-2650 Justice_ . ' l,mtmilln, ~£X&5 ?9101:-2449 .

: \ fufufu~7tfttnn.t:nurt;:~ctk.tX.;.u:s:

. .

September 8; 2014 .. :·

.. .. ,: ~ ..

Christin Gobe Vasquez Asst. Attorney- General .. ',,

LawEnforcement Division P.O. Box 12S48 MC 003 . Austin, TX 78711 *DELIVERED VIA E-MAIL*

RE.: Case Number: 07~14-00219-cv·· -~-: .:

Trial Court Case· Number: 97;06.1-C . ·

Style: L1,1is S. ~agaite, Jr. #762508 · v: Gregory C. 'Boli:md, et al . ···<

Dear Counsel:

By Order of the Court, th~ hl'otio~ 'for an extension 'of tirne to file Appellee's brief is this· day granted and th~ brief was filed on Friday, 9eptember 05, .2014 .

·'·· '

Very ~rul}lyours,

g~~·· PEGGY CULP, CLERK·

xc: Luis S. Lagaite Jr.

. · .. ~

. .:

. i . .

.. '

·.:··· ::tf\i ~Mt. ~5\sf uuo,c,AL fJ\&'\R\t{ tou£LT Q /('"

0>F

\4J{\eR5 e<:uM'('( {EtAs ElH )u l l

-\1-

\?1~~ e~ ~O{~~jD t__f;AL , Defr-JJD() N"\ S

~ M\ ~ ~)t fE: .N -15 h~ ~ 9-.vJ s fo&~l:J:i - t s ,CcJNCe..lL_ ~iS){\ ON 1u D' Df\\tJ DX£.\~fL6 -~\!l'\1tt A .

!\ ) EN LA K( )t: ~' Mf f\lf\JD ~NGz Qt.~Q~f' f\1\l}{:\ON '\0 << ~}

16 .~ , t\ ~- -'t· I\ (AND AP PhC~\ON foJLMH 'N~ \L~'A~{IQ\.6 l\ \ lED ON

~t t~ ~O J1 rw ~& JJ '~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0A ~~ ~M~N~ill~~~ tfAcfuN

Af.JO Wthl \ D &!0\il \J~ n-t~ Uul\'\' 1\-

tt fo\ltlJ.ll-.) b :

A1\10 25\.\\)i\\\«s 1\{e:. f.J()O~~ f'OOnoJ :L races 0 D~:(Jtee.O \1-\ i\\e '1111 : .

Offit:DJ ~aJUDbit

JI\\ f\Jt)\ltM~EJ\., \3~ )0 \ Y 1{ UJ~ 1Ollt~.

AtJQ

~ ~' \" 'M e cru :>~ ns tf \\' \~ilttA~ Cfucc\ tJJC\u oit J 6 C.tl.lA( ~f A~Qe~\.s .~~~ UJ \:r 01 -\ -eo S~D ~NO fieMbtJO~O .'\0·. \\1~ '\rtt t!LQ.OtUL\

~ ~ (Je. Jlt .\l eR.

. (~L)( Of' q-q ·ft , j:}f\]1) -\ ""\

q ~ 'CV

£Nc,-v- \10\\~tJCY No. OS.. to-~rs ~t( ott OOf \lL b' 10 'J\ C;( ~\ t2J J\8 l),, ARe.. V9tD IN SC~ >\ A~e -.:n.o\\tt~Y9ql No \.U\1t)

~~t , ctr l.. J-.

'}()t'? wt.3Yo3'·L lwl~. f£x ArP , L'« \S \b,Qtsr

OI' l ~lA a6t :: '\\ M~ AN D O~: !J~Ilt: PIA,f)\\ff A \/Bttlil<A.f'& b'\'

~H~ &!eY(\Vf'l \~d.J\D\\ 10 bM\ ~Af \or .JS f$l~\(A~ ~ r:.s.·t}\~ o~~IVAAI$f S'\M U% :'

nl tO q--q~ \\, O\JtJL,3'\ tA1 \.S Q\\ hL -"l" 'll 0'tfDfl e ~\5 c.oul\1 Af(E(L ""'~ ~'NI orJ FW

O

\~c DA ft! vf 9 H~lt,,:;f:, t.tJ'tll(l.~D l(o e.,tt,tJ G. {\-\'.5 \, 1.~ \'{ " u ~\~ ~~-A ~Olli)'-ltfo HO\ o juc l-\ cl AP~ t-~ \..J. 'OO ut\L,

PtC\..)\ON O\ tt\~ 1\t \ Ctu A' \ ~-- \,\ 9-. ·\s A \IIOlA1'lON 0 \=- ~~t:.~ r" ~N q~< i"' \\ ·f:>lt "\'\V~( \\AS A\ti::.AC'\ ~tt. \-\t: .lC __ ~Jt.9\Gf WA.) AGA\AJ~J_ '\t\lt· f)~fe.

NOAI\JTS

fhOI:t{.\)(}r-1 AND -S~ ~~N >Al "\ ~JA\ .\.~ S-1- .:L t ~-\\£ . .\l t~t.J6 w~ 'rh{:.HI(ft: eoJ.r\ r~~~t(J/J 6{L rltifi.U~:sY-~HEAl f'M'-\ iHei 0\.1\:Jl'f.>'<.: ~f O'<.C\>\oN ot \rJG. B~~ Zr< :~o ~~ tv\~ (ho\'\t~ "\'\orJ '~A.\N5f 5t: io4 n \-\e.Aa

-\1-\t>< \-\~ {)et(i.r-.J \10 \01 orv \.S A .:rn:. · · toJ\:>\~ 'J~neo~c'\ ~.

t\\hJAl'\ S\5 ~ \NO K~t t.o 110< S\t ttc. r 3-n u,~ t·S ·l stic-u\'() .ib~ use..o, \J.){,cl-\ MG {\'\e 0v('nt.ME ~I\( -1~

1'

t~S \~ <, Jl 2l l. ~ ~'\ \'1\C N\t'J'- '\1 ~( 1rs ~l~OtJ \S ,{;\)a,'rteS.SAIL'-J {~( Dcit:ND~r-r0 1\tus'\ d\l&\\f'- 1 \\A A~$ G', ~s~ ~t> ')' (u. ?rJ J)~ ~\o""~~.t- ~~A{uN,OAMB~<L t-. \'\

il) ~lHH::\lf ..~~ CUMP0\vJC, ~~~ M~I\. .\'\. S of .Q\k >v~ ~~ -AO.b.J:b«\t<- ~AS\-!> \N LAw .

\, ~& 0~-J \{\S {l\b H( iU A f\tf)Po~\:.~L ~\ \l\0\A%,5. ~\31\JA~ ~ctel\loN \\\Q_ If i.J J'\ \o~ ~~( ,~' ( ~~" t'\ €' ~\-\ f(t- \ l l.N )~p of ~~f\\CM\utl Of ~~ \/b J{ 5\-\tUL'D r-Ja( ,b~'-'G;\ B~~ ~< -t o ~}{" \ f\f ~ho GoN o.1 ~c\ -\' \tJ ~tr tlt /;)N,\) .)-J,Qhtrt-.E. C-\~~s :1NO ~t4 ,C?~~?l·\f ~~uo~\..s ,s g~c~ -bli~t'AL -

(u.tl\\.:)'\\fl\t RND '\Y\~ {A)-. P~'-\E.t .> Mc»J~ '"l;~N~~

e.t~IAS1 ~'s --~ / . ,,( . \· ;~-- .. . .. ' .

-."

' < , ~

.

N; ~u J \ ~

.

i~

.·

M~k •'

.

~

.

l~

.

/ ~bWbM ~~~1\0I{ ~ ~~ ~ CtlM\ ld r;<; 2.1J oy · . I.

BRIAN QUINN PEGGYCULP Chief Justice CLERK

JAMES t. CAMPBELL Justice' ~i&£ntly J:El.istrid of W£X<t~ . MAILING ADDRESS:· P. 0. Box 9540

Jnfur <!.tnunf\1" <!.tnurh>_tJimlm~s .· ... ~ . ' 79105-9540 MACKEY K. HANCOCj( Justice 5lll.~~JlfiJlmnr£,_:~ttit£ 4.-:-6\ (806) 342-2650 PATRICK. A. PIRTLE .

J\imirillo, 'C!J£xaz ~9l.i.ll-Z449

f

Justice

, fufufu~?.tfr.cna•.coitrlz.si:nt£. .J:x.uJi · .

• ,· r , ~ · 1 '• •

. )

.:

. ··-·- \; '":"' --.. -::-~--~ •• . ..... -1:.... ;- . :;--·. :-·>--.,-+-_;,_ ~- --.-. ··~ - :_. .

~uis s: Lagaite Jr.. Harold·J. Liller TDCJ-ID# 762508 OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL John Montford Unit P.O. Box 12548. -: 8602 Peach St. · · · . Cp.pital Station Lubbock, TX 79404 Austin, TX 78711 .... * DELIVERED

VIA E-MAIL *

RE: Case Number: 07-14-00219-CY Trial Court Case Number: 97,,061-C .< ~

Style: Luis S... Lagaite, Jr. #762508 VJGregory C. Boland, ·-

et al

·: . '

Dear Mr. Lagaiteand-Counsel_:.,..

·.· By Order of tlie Court, app~llant's ~otio~- to amend the ~lerk's record volume one of one the reporters record contain in@ a hearing heHd on ·Feb.1·; 2:01.2 ir:J trial court case num.ber 97-06tC i~· granted: The folloWirig was filetL+uesday;·S eptember 02, 2014 in the captioned 'appea'l:' ~---. · · . . , ·-n. , _? _. · .-'·

. Reporter:scR.ecord (1 vol~me) • ~ ;- •( • , '·. ·.' .•. • • < ' ~-:. •

Very truly yours,

9~~ PEGGY CULP, CLERK

xc: BarbaraYoungf?,r (DELIVERED VIA E-MAIL)

l

I

/

l

·• · Cuc~1hcMt. or ~~'l'C£. Ex'Y' \6 t)£A 1

r

\1ea..~ ~'f (~'\\{ ~ ~ 1tU.AI;: OlUbltvA l -

.::( ..... lU\S s. L~&~r\t J"a., ~,~,{)~( . · \V\0\\0N- '\\) D\SM\SS DS~PJJD~N\S t\€AlL\Nb (~ \~ \'-\- \ (Ut.J(Eilf()\N 6 s ' De..fB"lD~rJt.SvM()\\l1/'\ '\0 Sr-JLA2GE: 1\\MG:' AND O'e.C\~e£ P\~'"~{f- A \/6iA'\\ouS l~{)GtiN\ t\\~t)· otJ .C\-9- ll ~N·o ~P()\$~\\oN t:>~t.JL\-\ w~<C~N\ MGno tJ too I 10 \-'tCLD aetit-.~.D~N\S '\1E:AR\N~ ~"' WA'-\ o~ 3-wA'}i\:i~CbNffiawC£" 9\Al\S\J~N\ 10 CJ\r.>~·lt-n., \'-\'.Oo~ ~ ~r-1 tor>'€' e_,v,\ PAoLe.DuLe..s.~, I {b((e.G\ tU~l\:S ~A& {bt,5.N S~ \0 (Hth&$1'1 ·coat; V~S(QU~2 ~\StAt-!\ A\ft;(2JJ6~\ &N&AL. uls' £M,l. Po~'\()(;G' Att~:PA\0 ON i\.\ts J\Si Dt()'-\ Ot Dl:L.6M~8t.. ~0\~ AS .tol \OL\1 S ', ;

- QJtfL\'stl c\1 .Cb&'t. \JA1 lVUEL-

~~\&'\~rJ\ A\\DaMb~} Gt-tJEA2.AL CA~\'\D\. S~A\\0 rJ ~.o, ~CA< \15 Lffr

AU&{\('}; MS·12'7JJ-JS- yg

/

S· A\'\t · -

J'D\irJ ~, MoN\fOIL() \..)(),\ ~lo 0 l. fbl~k\ 0\ . lU~~OL'Ct ~ IC(\.fO~ . PR~S\£

-- l\01..)0~

I

\

Luis S. Lagaite v. Gregory C. Boland, (Tex. 2015).

Pincite

Luis S. Lagaite v. Gregory C. Boland (Luis S. Lagaite v. Gregory C. Boland) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.