Lowry v. M'Burney

Supreme Court of South Carolina

Lowry v. M'Burney

8 S.C.L. 237

Supreme Court of South Carolina·Decided June 15, 1817·Published

Opinion

Bay, J.

delivered the opinion of the Court.

As this was a case which turned entirely upon evidence, and as there was evidence on both sides, I left the case to the Jury, as being a case very proper for their consideration; and they found for the plaintiff the full amount of his bond and interest. After hearing the arguments' on this motion for a new trial, I can see no grounds for impeaching the verdict of the Jury, and am therefore clearly of opinion the motion should be refused ; in which opinion all my brethren coincide.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Bay, J.

delivered the opinion of the Court.

As this was a case which turned entirely upon evidence, and as there was evidence on both sides, I left the case to the Jury, as being a case very proper for their consideration; and they found for the plaintiff the full amount of his bond and interest. After hearing the arguments' on this motion for a new trial, I can see no grounds for impeaching the verdict of the Jury, and am therefore clearly of opinion the motion should be refused ; in which opinion all my brethren coincide.

Lowry v. M'Burney, 8 S.C.L. 237 (S.C. 1817).

Pincite

8 S.C.L. 237 (Lowry v. M'Burney) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.