Low v. Pardee

48 Ill. 466

• Court: Illinois Supreme Court
• Decided: September 15, 1868
• Status: Published

Opinion

Mr. Chief Justice Breese

delivered the opinion of the Court:

This was a case on appeal from a justice of the peace to the circuit court of Mercer county, in which William Pardee recovered a judgment against Cyrus Low for twenty-eight dollars and seventy-five cents, for a corn planter sold and delivered by Pardee to Low. It appears the contract was, if Low did not like the planter he was to return it and nothing was to be paid. The claim was, that he did not return it, and the court instructed the jury for the plaintiff, that if they believed, from the evidence, that the defendant took the machine and agreed to return it if it did not raise more corn than any other planter, it was the duty of the defendant, so soon as he tested it, to return it, and if he retained it an unreasonable time he was liable for the value.

This instruction, and another one of the same import, were doubtless correct law; but it was distinctly proved on the trial, that the plaintiff, by his agent, had dispensed with the return of the machine, he preferring it should remain in the possession of the defendant.

The verdict should have been set aside as contrary to the evidence.' For these reasons the judgment is reversed and the cause remanded.

Judgment reversed.