Lovorn v. Hathorn

365 So. 2d 947
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedJanuary 10, 1979
Docket49446
StatusPublished
Cited by16 cases

This text of 365 So. 2d 947 (Lovorn v. Hathorn) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Lovorn v. Hathorn, 365 So. 2d 947 (Mich. 1979).

Opinion

365 So.2d 947 (1978)

Mrs. Bobby LOVORN, Sammy Carter, Joe Goodin, J.D. Eaves and Prentiss Carter
v.
Ralph HATHORN, Mayor of Louisville, et al.

No. 49446.

Supreme Court of Mississippi.

October 4, 1978.
As Corrected On Denial of Rehearing January 10, 1979.

Laurel G. Weir, Philadelphia, for appellants.

Fair & Mayo, James Mayo, Louisville, William A. Allain, Jackson, Frank Deramus, Louisville, for appellees.

Sara E. Gallaspy, Jackson, amicus curiae brief for Mississippi Municipal Association.

En Banc.

LEE, Justice, for the Court:

Mrs. Bobby Lovorn, et al., filed their bill of complaint against Ralph Hathorn, Mayor of Louisville, et al., in the Chancery Court of Winston County, seeking a mandatory injunction to enforce the election of a five-member school board for the Louisville Municipal Separate School District. The chancellor entered a decree dismissing the bill and complainants below appeal and assign the following errors in the trial:

(1) The chancellor erred in holding Mississippi Code Annotated Section 37-7-203 (1972) to be unconstitutional.

(2) The chancellor erred in holding that the constitutional rights of appellant were not being violated under the one-man one-vote principle.

(3) The chancellor erred in amending his decree after an appeal had been perfected to the Mississippi Supreme Court.

Since July 1, 1960, Louisville Municipal Separate School District has covered all of Winston County and has been the only school district in said county. Twenty-six hundred seventy-five (2,675) pupils outside the Louisville city limits and fourteen hundred eighteen (1,418) pupils inside the city limits attend the schools of said district. The population of Winston County is approximately eighteen thousand four hundred six (18,406) of which number approximately seven thousand (7,000) live within the City of Louisville. Taxes in the school district are assessed and collected by the Louisville City Tax Assessor and Collector, and the school district has issued negotiable bonds for the purpose of funding construction and maintenance of the schools. School taxes collected inside the city amount to two hundred ninety-four thousand nine hundred sixty-four dollars three cents ($294,964.03) and said taxes collected outside the city amount to two hundred *948 fifty-five thousand eight hundred twelve dollars twenty-four cents ($255,812.24). There are fifty-two (52) municipal separate school districts in Mississippi and at least forty-eight (48) such districts have territory located outside the municipality which is embraced within the school district.

Since 1960, the Board of Trustees of Louisville Municipal Separate School District has been composed of five (5) members, three (3) of which are appointed by the governing authorities of the City of Louisville, and two (2) of which are elected by the qualified electors of the school district outside the city. That part of Mississippi Code Annotated Section 37-7-203 (1972) as amended, which applies to this suit provides: "... in any county in which a municipal separate school district embraces the entire county in which Highways 14 and 15 intersect, one (1) trustee shall be elected from each supervisors district." (Emphasis added).

It is not disputed that the underscored phrase applies only to Winston County. Appellants' suit was brought to enforce election of one (1) trustee from each supervisor's district. They also contend that the method of selecting trustees for said municipal separate school district violates the one-man one-vote rule and that the right of individuals residing outside the Louisville city limits to vote for trustees was being unconstitutionally diluted in violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution. The chancellor found the quoted part of the statute to be in violation of Section 90, Mississippi Constitution 1890, and unconstitutional. He also held that the one-man one-vote rule was inapplicable to the present case.

I.

Did the chancellor err in holding Mississippi Code Annotated Section 37-7-203 (1972), as amended, to be unconstitutional?

The basis of the chancellor's ruling is that the part of said statute referring to Highways 14 and 15 bears no rational relationship to the means of electing trustees in the school district, that it could not apply to any county except Winston County and that it is a local and private law in violation of Section 90(p), Mississippi Constitution 1890, which follows:

"Section 90. The legislature shall not pass local, private or special laws in any of the following enumerated cases, but such matters shall be provided for only by general law, viz:
* * * * * *
(p) Providing for the management or support of any private or common school, incorporating the same or granting such school any privileges; ..."

We held in Wilson v. Jones County Board of Supervisors, 342 So.2d 1293 (Miss. 1977), where the statute under consideration involved levying an additional two-mill tax in a county having a population in excess of fifty-nine thousand five hundred forty (59,540) and being traversed by U.S. Highway 11 which intersected U.S. Highway 84 (Jones County), that the classification must bear a rational relationship to the purpose of the section. We said:

"It is the Court's duty in passing on the constitutionality of a statute to separate the valid from the invalid part, if this can be done, and to permit the valid part to stand unless the different parts of the statute are so intimately connected with and dependent upon each other as to warrant a belief that the legislature intended them as a whole, and that if all cannot be carried into effect it would not have enacted the residue independently. [Citing cases].
* * * * * *
... We are therefore led to the inescapable conclusion that the legislature would have enacted the valid part of the statute independently of the invalid part because this is precisely what it did. The invalid part of the statute may be separated from the valid part and stricken out leaving a complete and consistent plan whereby counties may levy additional taxes for general county purposes. We therefore hold that the part of section *949 XX-XX-XXX authorizing counties to levy additional taxes for general county purposes, and the part in the last paragraph prescribing the procedure to be followed in making the levy, are constitutional." 342 So.2d at 1296, 1297.

An act providing that a county having two judicial districts and being intersected by U.S. Highway 84 and Interstate 59 was held to be unconstitutional in Smith v. Transcontinental Gas Pipeline Corporation, 310 So.2d 281 (Miss. 1975). It was emphasized that the classification must be germane to the subject matter of the legislation.

In Vardaman v. McBee, 198 Miss. 251, 21 So.2d 661 (1945), the Court stated:

"Class legislation, also often called local or private legislation, is legislation limited in operation to certain persons or classes of persons, natural or artificial, or to certain districts of the territory of the State, and statutes which make unreasonable or arbitrary classifications or discriminations violate provisions of Constitutions prohibiting special laws granting any special or exclusive privileges, immunities, or franchises, or passed for the benefit of individuals inconsistent with the general law of the land. 12 C.J., Sec. 855, p. 1128; 16A C.J.S. Constitutional Law § 489.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Mississippi Department of Revenue v. AT&T Corporation
202 So. 3d 1205 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2016)
In Re Bell
962 So. 2d 537 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2007)
Mauldin v. Branch
866 So. 2d 429 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2003)
Carolyn Mauldin v. Beatrice Branch
Mississippi Supreme Court, 2001
Attorney's Fees of Mohr v. Powers
32 P.3d 647 (Hawaii Supreme Court, 2001)
Secretary of State v. Wiesenberg
633 So. 2d 983 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1994)
Phipps v. Irby Const. Co.
636 So. 2d 353 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1993)
Van Slyke v. Board of Trustees
613 So. 2d 872 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1993)
State Ex Rel. Pair v. Burroughs
487 So. 2d 220 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1986)
Hathorn v. Lovorn
457 U.S. 255 (Supreme Court, 1982)
Quinn v. Branning
404 So. 2d 1018 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1981)
Carter v. Luke
399 So. 2d 1356 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1981)
Tatro v. State
372 So. 2d 283 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1979)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
365 So. 2d 947, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/lovorn-v-hathorn-miss-1979.