Love v. Miller

316 S.W.2d 269, 1958 Tex. App. LEXIS 2214
CourtCourt of Appeals of Texas
DecidedSeptember 24, 1958
DocketNo. 13381
StatusPublished
Cited by1 cases

This text of 316 S.W.2d 269 (Love v. Miller) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Texas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Love v. Miller, 316 S.W.2d 269, 1958 Tex. App. LEXIS 2214 (Tex. Ct. App. 1958).

Opinion

PER CURIAM.

This action, upon leave being granted, was instituted as an original proceeding on September 16, 1958, by Miron A. Love under the provisions of Art. 1735-a, Vernon’s Ann.Texas St., seeking the issuance of a writ of mandamus ordering the respondents, W. D. Miller, Bob Casey, and C. V. (Buster) Kern, the County Clerk, County Judge, and Sheriff, respectively, of Harris County, Texas, in their capacities as the Election Board of the county, and as party officials, to publish and post the name of the relator, Miron A. Love, as the Democratic nominee of the Democratic Party for the unexpired term of the office of Judge of the Criminal District Court No. 3 of Harris County, Texas, and to print his name on the [271]*271General Election ballot as such nominee, and futher seeking to enjoin the respondents in their aforesaid capacities from posting and publishing the name of the respondent, Arnold H. Krichamer, as the Democratic nominee for said office and from printing his name on the General Election ballot as the nominee for that office.

Upon the hearing of this cause, relator’s counsel, with the consent of counsel for the respondents, tendered to this Court a signed carbon copy of an instrument styled: “Minutes of the Meeting of District Committee of Democratic Party.”

Inasmuch as this cause involves the efficacy of the action which this exhibit purports to reflect and because it states much of the factual background which occasioned the lack of a candidate for the office of Judge of the Criminal District Court No. 3 of Harris County, Texas, appearing on the ballot in the Harris County Democratic Primary, the exhibit is being here set forth in its entirety. It reads as follows:

“Minutes of Meeting of District Committee of Democratic Party.
“A meeting of the District Committee of the Democratic Party for the District comprising the Criminal District Court No. 3 of Harris County, Texas, was duly held August 27, 1958 at the offices of Cyril J. Smith, 751 San Jacinto Building, Houston, Texas.
“Present was Cyril J. Smith, Chairman of the Harris County Democratic Executive Committee, the only member of said District Committee.
“Mr. Smith called the meeting to order and declared it open for such business as might regularly come before it.
“It appeared that Mr. Smith had previously qualified as a member of said District Committee by taking the oath of office and had accepted and assumed the duties of such office.
“Any call, notice or other formal requirements of the meeting were waived.
“Mr. Smith was selected as Chairman and as Secretary of the meeting.
“It duly appeared as follows: The Honorable A. C. Winborn, Judge of the Criminal District Court No. 3 of Harris County, died June 1, 1958. The territory comprising this district on said date was and still is the one county of Harris County, Texas. Upon the vacancy in said Court becoming known, certain attorneys desiring the Democratic nomination for Judge Winborn’s unexpired term filed applications with Cyril J. Smith in his capacity as Chairman of the Harris County Democratic Executive Committee requesting that their respective names be placed on the official ballots for the Democratic general primary of July 26, 1958. They did this, and said Chairman accepted such applications, so as not to prejudice their rights in case Subd. 2 of Art. 13.12 of the Election Code of Texas [V.A.T.S.] was applicable, which provides for the filing of such applications in certain vacancies. However, Mr. Smith informed applicants and other interested parties and publicly announced through the local newspapers, that there was doubt as to the applicability of Art. 13.12, and if it was not applicable and if it was the duty of this District Committee, of which Mr. Smith was the sole member, to select such nominee, that in so doing he would act on the recommendation of the Harris County Democratic Executive Committee, which Committee he represented on said District Committee. Thereafter the Courts held that the names of candidates for said nomination could not legally be placed on the official ballots of said general primary election of July 26, 1958. See Meyers v. Smith, [Tex.Civ.App.] 314 S.W.2d 631. It is the exclusive duty of this District Committee to select such nominee. See second paragraph of Art. 6.04, Election Code of Texas. Upon Mr. Smith’s request to the Harris County Democratic Executive Committee to recommend a nominee for the unexpired term of the office of Judge of the Criminal District Court No. 3 of Harris County, that Committee recommended by a substantial [272]*272majority vote that this District Committee nominate Miron A. Love, a licensed and practicing attorney of Houston, Harris County, Texas, as the Democratic nominee for said office.
“Therefore, pursuant to said recommendation, and upon his own motion, Mr. Smith, or said District Committee, named, selected and appointed said Miron A. Love as the Democratic nominee for the unexpired term of Judge of Criminal District Court No. 3 of Harris County, Mr. Love’s name as said nominee to be placed on the official ballots in the general elections of November 4, 1958 in Harris County, Texas, and further directed that such nomination be certified to the proper authorities.
“There being no further business to come before the meeting, it was adjourned.”
/s/ Cyril J. Smith Sole Member, Chairman and Secretary of the District Committee of the Democratic Party for the District Comprising the Criminal District Court No. 3 of Harris County

In this connection it should be stated that Judge A. C. Winborn, by virtue of his election in the General Election in 1956, was elected for a full term of four years as Judge of the Criminal District Court No. 3 of Harris County, Texas.1 Having assumed the duties of that office on January 1, 1957, his term would not have expired until December 31, 1960, and consequently he would not have been required to run again until the primary election in 1960.

It also appears that Cyril J. Smith on August 27, 1958, over his signature, purporting to act as “Sole Member, Chairman and Secretary of the District Committee of the Democratic Party for the District Comprising the Criminal District Court No. 3 of Harris County, Texas”, in an instrument addressed to “Hon. W. D. Miller, as County Clerk of Harris County, Texas, and to Hon. Harris County Election Board of Harris County, Texas” stated that he, Cyril J. Smith, “The duly qualified and acting District Committee of the Democratic Party for the District comprising the Criminal District Court No. 3 of Harris County, Texas, (which District is composed only of Harris County, Texas) and the Chairman and Secretary of said District Committee” certified that “Miron A. Love, a licensed and practicing attorney of Houston, Harris County, Texas, was duly named, elected and appointed by said District Committee as the Democratic nominee for the unexpired term of the office of Judge of Criminal District Court ,No. 3 of Harris County, Texas” and that his name as such nominee be placed on the official ballots in the General Election of November 4, 1958, in Harris County, Texas.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion
Texas Attorney General Reports, 1962

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
316 S.W.2d 269, 1958 Tex. App. LEXIS 2214, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/love-v-miller-texapp-1958.