Louisiana Commercial Bank v. GEORGIA INTERNATIONAL LIFE INS. CO.

618 So. 2d 1091, 1993 La. App. LEXIS 1824, 1993 WL 146218
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedApril 23, 1993
Docket91 CA 1618
StatusPublished
Cited by3 cases

This text of 618 So. 2d 1091 (Louisiana Commercial Bank v. GEORGIA INTERNATIONAL LIFE INS. CO.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Louisiana Commercial Bank v. GEORGIA INTERNATIONAL LIFE INS. CO., 618 So. 2d 1091, 1993 La. App. LEXIS 1824, 1993 WL 146218 (La. Ct. App. 1993).

Opinion

618 So.2d 1091 (1993)

LOUISIANA COMMERCIAL BANK, et al., Plaintiffs,
v.
GEORGIA INTERNATIONAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, et al., Defendants.

No. 91 CA 1618.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, First Circuit.

April 23, 1993.
Writ Denied July 1, 1993.

*1092 Martin A. Stern, New Orleans, for defendant Georgia Life.

Edward J. Levert, Jr., New Orleans, for plaintiff Rathe.

Mitchell J. Hoffman and Michael R. Allweiss, New Orleans, for plaintiffs Greenwald, Pontchartrain, Roux & Hoffman.

Paul J. Mirabile, Middleberg Riddle & Gianna, New Orleans.

Before CARTER, LeBLANC and PITCHER, JJ.

PITCHER, Judge.

Defendant, Georgia International Life Insurance Company (Georgia International), appeals from an adverse judgement in the trial court in a suit to recover benefits *1093 under a life insurance policy. The trial judge held that Georgia International was at fault in issuing a policy of insurance to its insured, Noel "Butch" Baum (Baum), with an aviation exclusion without notification, in contravention of its own, and industry standards. Plaintiff, Louisiana Commercial Bank, answered and then cross-appealed assigning as error to the trial court's finding that Georgia International did not breach the provisions of LSA-R.S. 22:617 and that the amount of damages awarded to the plaintiff should be reduced by the amount of negligence ascribed to Baum. We reverse.

FACTS

Baum and nine business associates purchased Louisiana Commercial Bank in early 1986. After their purchase, and at the urging of Baum, the members of the investment group agreed to individually buy life insurance in the amount of one million eight hundred thousand ($1,800,000.00) dollars, the amount equal to their individual investments. Baum, a career life insurance agent and owner of Butch Baum & Associates, undertook the responsibility of acquiring the insurance policies for the investment group. He first contacted State Mutual Life Assurance Company of America, the company through which he wrote the majority of his insurance. State Mutual agreed to write the insurance on Baum's co-investors, but refused to underwrite coverage on him. Baum had over $19,000,000.00 in life insurance coverage, almost $13,000,000.00 of which was with State Mutual.

After Baum was unable to secure insurance on himself through State Mutual, he contacted Milton Pullen, an acquaintance who lived in North Carolina and who was also involved in the life insurance business. Milton Pullen, unable to help Baum personally, referred Baum's insurance request to his brother, John, who attempted to help Baum secure a policy through Integrated Resources Life Insurance Company. This effort was unsuccessful because of the amount of insurance Baum had in force at the time, and because of the tremendous amount of time he spent piloting his own plane.

John Pullen then referred Baum to Edward Johnson, another North Carolina independent life insurance agent. Johnson submitted Baum's application to Georgia International Life Insurance Company seeking $1,800,000.00 in insurance coverage. In his deposition, Neil Crawford, Georgia International's chief underwriter, testified he reviewed Baum's application and agreed to issue the policy, but only upon two conditions. First, the policy would only be written for $1,000,000.00 of coverage; and second, the policy would contain an aviation exclusion. Edward Johnson, in his deposition testified that he contacted Baum and informed him of Georgia International's conditions of coverage. Baum accepted the reduced coverage in writing and paid the initial premium of $13,920.00. Baum's acceptance however, made no reference to an aviation exclusion.

Georgia International issued policy number 00394995B to Baum on April 7, 1986, for $1,000,000.00. The policy contained an aviation exclusion. Neither the declaration page, nor delivery voucher made reference to the aviation exclusion. However, the policy cover sheet admonished Baum to read the policy carefully, and it also advised him that he had a right to return the policy within twenty days of receipt and receive a full refund of the premium if he was dissatisfied for any reason.

On June 4, 1987, Baum died from injuries sustained in the crash of an airplane he was piloting. Subsequently, Georgia International denied coverage to the named beneficiary, Louisiana Commercial Bank, on the basis of the aviation exclusion and refunded the premiums paid pursuant to the terms of the policy.

PROCEDURAL HISTORY

On September 11, 1987, Louisiana Commercial Bank filed this suit against Georgia International and Butch Baum & Associates, Inc., seeking the full recovery of the death benefits under the policy. The petition was amended to include a claim for a penalty in the form of interest at the rate *1094 of 8% per annum. Pontchartrain State Bank, as successor in interest to Louisiana Commercial Bank, filed a motion to substitute counsel, but it did not move to be substituted as plaintiff. A petition for intervention was filed by E. Lance Greenwald and Roland B. Juneau, as Trustees of the Louisiana Commercial Bank Voting Trust, and E. Lance Greenwald, Kermit Roux and Mitchell J. Hoffman. The intervenors adopted the allegations of the original petition, but additionally alleged that the policy should be reformed to reflect that they are the owners and beneficiaries.

Pontchartrain State Bank and intervenors filed a motion for summary judgment against Georgia International, who in turn filed a cross-motion for summary judgment. One of the issues before the trial court on Summary Judgment was whether the aviation exclusion constituted an alteration. While these matters were under advisement by the trial judge, a second intervention was filed by Robert and Joan Rathe, who claimed they were entitled to recover because as shareholders of the voting trust in Louisiana Commercial Bank. The trial judge denied both motions, and specifically found that Baum's application was not altered within the meaning of LSA-R.S. 22:617. Butch Baum & Associates filed for bankruptcy and an automatic stay was in effect. Georgia International then filed a motion to sever the claims against them and Butch Baum & Associates, which was granted by the trial judge. A second motion for summary judgment and cross-motion were filed by Georgia International and Louisiana Commercial Bank. The motions were taken under advisement and denied by the trial judge.

During the trial, Louisiana Commercial Bank offered the testimony of Frank Friedler, Jr. as an expert in the life insurance industry. Mr. Friedler was questioned extensively regarding industry standards for notifying insureds of the insertion of exclusions into insurance policies. He testified it is the standard practice within the industry to highlight aviation exclusions on the delivery voucher or on the declaration page of a policy.

After trial on the merits, the trial court found no applicability of LSA-R.S. 22:617, but did find that Georgia International was at fault in issuing the policy with an aviation exclusion to Baum without notification in contravention of its own and industry standards. The trial court further found that Baum was also negligent for having accepted the policy with the aviation exclusion and, as such, was fifty percent at fault. Furthermore, the Court found that Louisiana Commercial Bank had been damaged in an amount equal to the amount they were denied in benefits under the policy, minus the percentage of fault ascribed to Baum. Judgment was therefore awarded in the amount of $535,432.61.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Fielding v. MTL Insurance
261 F. Supp. 2d 619 (E.D. Louisiana, 2003)
Jackson v. Rogers
665 So. 2d 440 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1995)
Opinion Number
Louisiana Attorney General Reports, 1994

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
618 So. 2d 1091, 1993 La. App. LEXIS 1824, 1993 WL 146218, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/louisiana-commercial-bank-v-georgia-international-life-ins-co-lactapp-1993.