Linyi Chengen Imp. and Exp. Co. v. United States

Court of International Trade

Linyi Chengen Imp. and Exp. Co. v. United States

658 F. Supp. 3d 1347, 2023 CIT 147

United States Court of International Trade·Decided October 10, 2023·No. Consol. 18-00002·Published

Opinion

.,22

$ # .%,05,)) %0' ()13( (00,)(3+1(317(46'*( 1041.,'%5('.%,05,))4 1041.16351 7 ()(0'%05 %0' "$" ()(0'%0505(37(013

1)HFG4<A<A:G;89<9G;E8@4A7E878G8E@<A4G<BAB9G;8+ ) 8C4EG@8AGB9B@@8E68 9B??BJ<A:G;89<A4?78G8E@<A4G<BA<AG;84AG<7H@C<A:7HGL<AI8FG<:4G<BAB968EG4<A ;4E7JBB7C?LJBB7CEB7H6GF9EB@G;8&8BC?8TF(8CH5?<6B9;<A4 2 4G87%6GB58E

E8:BEL) #8A8:4M !8I<ABE:4A4A7?8K4A7E4 )4?M@4A78!<8998E BE:4A&""B9s4F;<A:GBA 9BE&?4<AG<99"<AL<;8A:8A@CBEG4A7 KCBEGB "G7 BAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F4E4FG@8E<64AA6 4A7);4A7BA: BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 BA:94A:4L?8LsBB7B "G7 4A7BAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F4A7&?4<AG<99 AG8EI8ABEF8?G<6B "G7 <4K<A:FHA@CBEGKCBEGB "G7 A;H<B74 sBB7B "G7 <4K<A:8A:GBA:sBB7B "G7 "<AL<I8E:E88AsBB7B "G7 "<AL<?4EL&?LJBB7B "G7 "<AL<8A:F;8A:sBB7A7HFGELB "G7 "<AL<H4F;8A:/BA:5<AsBB7B "G7 "<AL< <4;8sBB7A7HFGELB "G7 "<AL<"<A;4<sBB7B "G7 "<AL<#<A:M;HsBB7B "G7 "<AL<)4A9BEGHA8 sBB7B "G7 '<A:74BBB74<G;@CBEG4A7KCBEGB "G7 );4A7BA: '<F;4AAG8EA4G<BA4?*E47<A:B "G7 );4A:;4<HGHJBB7*E47<A:B "G7 )H<A<A:&8A:K<4A:sBB7B "G7 )HD<4ABC8J4LAG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B "G7 )HM;BH%E<8AG4?E4:BA@CBEG4A7KCBEGB "G7 .HM;BHA789HsBB7 B "G7 .HM;BH <4A:L4A:sBB7A7HFGE<8FB "G7 .HM;BH"BA:LH4AsBB7 A7HFGELB "G7 .HM;BH&<A?<AAG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B "G7 .HM;BH);8A:C<A: @CBEG4A7KCBEGB "G7 4A7.HM;BH*<@58EAG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B "G7 899E8L) $88?8L4A7)G8C;8As EBC;LHF6;?46>J8??""&B9s4F;<A:GBA 9BEBAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F0;8=<4A:8;H4*@CBEGKCBEGB "G7 <:;?4A7A7HFGE<8FA6 <4F;4A4?<AsBB7A7HFGELB "G7 4CCLsBB7 A7HFGE<4?EBHCB "G7 <4A:FH<:;BC8EF8EB "G7 )HD<4A/4BEHA *E478B "G7 /4A:M;BH4ABIAG8EA4G<BA4?B "G7 AG8ECE<F8"<@<G87 8D<A:;<A49E<64BE8<:A*E478&BEGB "G7 &<M;BH <A);8A:/H4A AG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B "G7 .HM;BH);H<J4A:K<A:*E47<A:B "G7 BF6B)G4E AG8EA4G<BA4?B "G7 "<AL<<GLBA:94A: <AK<A6BAB@<6*E478B "G7 "<AL<<GL);8AEH<AG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B "G7 <4A:FH'<4A=<HE8AAG8EA4G<BA4? *E47<A:B "G7 4A7'<A:74B*BC&'AG8EA4G<BA4?BEC 899E8L) E<@FBA4A7 <?? E4@8E#BJELE<@FBA&""B9s4F;<A:GBA 9BEBAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F*4E464&46<9<6A6 4AHF4sBB7&EB7H6GF"G7 BA64AABABECBE4G<BA7 5 4BA64AABA"H@58EB@C4AL45HJBB745<A8GEL BECBE4G<BAB??4A7)BHG;J8FGAG8EA4G<BA4?A6 "<58EGLsBB7FAG8EA4G<BA4? A6 $BEG;J8FG4E7JBB7FA6 (<6;@BA7AG8EA4G<BA4?BE8FG&EB7H6GF"" 4A7+)&"/"" *4E4! B:4AFF<FG4AG<E86GBE4A7)BFHA48)8A<BE*E<4?BHAF8? B@@8E6<4?"<G<:4G<BAE4A6;<I<?<I<F<BA+ ) 8C4EG@8AGB9 HFG<68B9 s4F;<A:GBA 9BE898A74AG+A<G87)G4G8F s<G;G;8@BAG;85E<89J8E8 E<4A# BLAGBA&E<A6<C4?8CHGLFF<FG4AGGGBEA8L8A8E4?4A7&4GE<6<4# #64EG;L<E86GBE %96BHAF8?J4F)4I4AA4;( #4KJ8??GGBEA8L%99<68B9 G;8;<89BHAF8?9BE*E478A9BE68@8AG4A7B@C?<4A68+ ) 8C4EG@8AGB9 B@@8E68 BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 *<@BG;L E<:;G5<?? 899E8L% E4A>)G8C;4A<8# 8??4A7?<M458G;) "88 s<?8L(8<A""&B9s4F;<A:GBA 9BE898A74AGAG8EI8ABEB4?<G<BA9BE4<E *E478<A4E7JBB7&?LJBB7 ;B8EBI8F H7:8AG;8BHEGTFF<KG;BC<A<BA<AG;<F?<G<:4G<BAG;4G;4F

FC4AA87A84E?LF<KL84EFG;8BHEG9<A4??LFHFG4<AFB@@8E68TF78G8E@<A4G<BAF 6BA68EA<A:G;8<@CBEGB9;4E7JBB74A7786BE4G<I8C?LJBB74A768EG4<AI8A88E87 C4A8?F<AGBG;8+A<G87)G4G8F9EB@G;8&8BC?8TF(8CH5?<6B9;<A4Q;<A4R FH5=86GGBG;89<A4?499<E@4G<I878G8E@<A4G<BA<A4A4AG<7H@C<A:7HGL<AI8FG<:4G<BA 5LG;8+ ) 8C4EG@8AGB9B@@8E68QB@@8E68R<A6?H7<A:4A<FFH8B99<EFG <@CE8FF<BAE8:4E7<A:G;8<A6?HF<BAB968EG4<AIB?HAG4ELE8I<8J9<E@F<A4A4AG< 7H@C<A:7HGLBE78E )888EG4<A4E7JBB7&?LJBB7&EB7H6GF9EB@G;8&8BC?8TF (8CH5?<6B9;<A4 87 (8: 8CTGB9B@@8E68$BI 9<A4? 78G8E@<A4G<BAB9F4?8F4G?8FFG;4A94<EI4?H84A79<A4?499<E@4G<I878G8E@<A4G<BAB9 6E<G<64?6<E6H@FG4A68F<AC4EG4F4@8A78787 (8: 8CTGB9B@@8E68 4A 4@8A7879<A4?78G8E@<A4G<BAB9F4?8F4G?8FFG;4A94<EI4?H84A7 4AG<7H@C<A:BE78EQ%E78ER6B??86G<I8?LQ<A4?8G8E@<A4G<BARF884?FBFFH8F 4A786<F<BA#8@ 9BEG;8<A4?8G8E@<A4G<BAB9G;8AG<7H@C<A:HGL AI8FG<:4G<BAB98EG4<A4E7JBB7&?LJBB7&EB7H6GF9EB@&8BC?8TF(8CH5?<6B9 ;<A4Q<A4?#R$B 89BE8G;8BHEG4E8G;8<A4?(8FH?GFB9(878G8E@<A4G<BA&HEFH4AGGBBHEG BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 (8@4A7Q<9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BAR$B J;<6;G;8BHEG

BE78E87<A"<AL<;8A:8A@C KC B I +A<G87)G4G8FQ"<AL<;8A:8A,R *33 )HCC 7 &?4<AG<99"<AL<;8A:8A@CBEGKCBEG B Q"<AL<;8A:8AR7<7ABG9<?86B@@8AGF<AE8FCBAF8GBG;8<9G;(8@4A7 (878G8E@<A4G<BA BAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F0;8=<4A:8;H4*@CBEGKCBEG B Q8;H4*R*4E464&46<9<6A6 Q*4E464R4A78?G<6B Q8?G<6R9<?87 G;8<E6B@@8AGF<AFHCCBEGB9G;8<9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA 8;H4*9<?876B@@8AGF6B??86G<I8?LBA58;4?9B9<GF8?94A7<:;?4A7 A7HFGE<8FA6 <4F;4A4?<AsBB7A7HFGELB 4CCLsBB7A7HFGE<4?EBHC B <4A:FH<:;BC8EF8EB )HD<4A/4BEHA*E478B /4A:M;BH4ABI AG8EA4G<BA4?B AG8ECE<F8"G7 8D<A:;<A49E<64BE8<:A*E478&BEG B &<M;BH <A);8A:/H4AAG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B .HM;BH);H<J4A:K<A: *E47<A:B BF6B)G4EAG8EA4G<BA4?B "<AL<<GLBA:94A: <AK<A6BAB@<6 *E478B "<AL<<GL);8AEH<AG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B <4A:FH'<4A=<HE8A AG8EA4G<BA4?*E47<A:B 4A7'<A:74B*BC&'AG8EA4G<BA4?BEC @GF )HCC (8@4A78G8E@<A4G<BA8;4?9BAFB? &?F 18;H4*8G4? 2QG;88;H4* B@@8AGFRBEQ8;H4*TF@GF R$B *4E4649<?876B@@8AGF6B??86G<I8?LBA58;4?9B9<GF8?94A74AHF4sBB7 &EB7H6GF"G7 BA64AABABEC 7 5 4BA64AABA"H@58EB 45HJBB7 45<A8GELBEC B??4A7)BHG;J8FGAG8EA4G<BA4?A6 "<58EGLsBB7F BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 AG8EA4G<BA4?A6 $BEG;J8FG4E7JBB7FA6 (<6;@BA7AG8EA4G<BA4?BE8FG

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

.,22

$ # .%,05,)) %0' ()13( (00,)(3+1(317(46'*( 1041.,'%5('.%,05,))4 1041.16351 7 ()(0'%05 %0' "$" ()(0'%0505(37(013

1)HFG4<A<A:G;89<9G;E8@4A7E878G8E@<A4G<BAB9G;8+ ) 8C4EG@8AGB9B@@8E68 9B??BJ<A:G;89<A4?78G8E@<A4G<BA<AG;84AG<7H@C<A:7HGL<AI8FG<:4G<BAB968EG4<A ;4E7JBB7C?LJBB7CEB7H6GF9EB@G;8&8BC?8TF(8CH5?<6B9;<A4 2 4G87%6GB58E

E8:BEL) #8A8:4M !8I<ABE:4A4A7?8K4A7E4 )4?M@4A78!<8998E BE:4A&""B9s4F;<A:GBA 9BE&?4<AG<99"<AL<;8A:8A@CBEG4A7 KCBEGB "G7 BAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F4E4FG@8E<64AA6 4A7);4A7BA: BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 BA:94A:4L?8LsBB7B "G7 4A7BAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F4A7&?4<AG<99 AG8EI8ABEF8?G<6B "G7 <4K<A:FHA@CBEGKCBEGB "G7 A;H<B74 sBB7B "G7 <4K<A:8A:GBA:sBB7B "G7 "<AL<I8E:E88AsBB7B "G7 "<AL<?4EL&?LJBB7B "G7 "<AL<8A:F;8A:sBB7A7HFGELB "G7 "<AL<H4F;8A:/BA:5<AsBB7B "G7 "<AL< <4;8sBB7A7HFGELB "G7 "<AL<"<A;4<sBB7B "G7 "<AL<#<A:M;HsBB7B "G7 "<AL<)4A9BEGHA8 sBB7B "G7 '<A:74BBB74<G;@CBEG4A7KCBEGB "G7 );4A7BA: '<F;4AAG8EA4G<BA4?*E47<A:B "G7 );4A:;4<HGHJBB7*E47<A:B "G7 )H<A<A:&8A:K<4A:sBB7B "G7 )HD<4ABC8J4LAG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B "G7 )HM;BH%E<8AG4?E4:BA@CBEG4A7KCBEGB "G7 .HM;BHA789HsBB7 B "G7 .HM;BH <4A:L4A:sBB7A7HFGE<8FB "G7 .HM;BH"BA:LH4AsBB7 A7HFGELB "G7 .HM;BH&<A?<AAG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B "G7 .HM;BH);8A:C<A: @CBEG4A7KCBEGB "G7 4A7.HM;BH*<@58EAG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B "G7 899E8L) $88?8L4A7)G8C;8As EBC;LHF6;?46>J8??""&B9s4F;<A:GBA 9BEBAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F0;8=<4A:8;H4*@CBEGKCBEGB "G7 <:;?4A7A7HFGE<8FA6 <4F;4A4?<AsBB7A7HFGELB "G7 4CCLsBB7 A7HFGE<4?EBHCB "G7 <4A:FH<:;BC8EF8EB "G7 )HD<4A/4BEHA *E478B "G7 /4A:M;BH4ABIAG8EA4G<BA4?B "G7 AG8ECE<F8"<@<G87 8D<A:;<A49E<64BE8<:A*E478&BEGB "G7 &<M;BH <A);8A:/H4A AG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B "G7 .HM;BH);H<J4A:K<A:*E47<A:B "G7 BF6B)G4E AG8EA4G<BA4?B "G7 "<AL<<GLBA:94A: <AK<A6BAB@<6*E478B "G7 "<AL<<GL);8AEH<AG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B "G7 <4A:FH'<4A=<HE8AAG8EA4G<BA4? *E47<A:B "G7 4A7'<A:74B*BC&'AG8EA4G<BA4?BEC 899E8L) E<@FBA4A7 <?? E4@8E#BJELE<@FBA&""B9s4F;<A:GBA 9BEBAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F*4E464&46<9<6A6 4AHF4sBB7&EB7H6GF"G7 BA64AABABECBE4G<BA7 5 4BA64AABA"H@58EB@C4AL45HJBB745<A8GEL BECBE4G<BAB??4A7)BHG;J8FGAG8EA4G<BA4?A6 "<58EGLsBB7FAG8EA4G<BA4? A6 $BEG;J8FG4E7JBB7FA6 (<6;@BA7AG8EA4G<BA4?BE8FG&EB7H6GF"" 4A7+)&"/"" *4E4! B:4AFF<FG4AG<E86GBE4A7)BFHA48)8A<BE*E<4?BHAF8? B@@8E6<4?"<G<:4G<BAE4A6;<I<?<I<F<BA+ ) 8C4EG@8AGB9 HFG<68B9 s4F;<A:GBA 9BE898A74AG+A<G87)G4G8F s<G;G;8@BAG;85E<89J8E8 E<4A# BLAGBA&E<A6<C4?8CHGLFF<FG4AGGGBEA8L8A8E4?4A7&4GE<6<4# #64EG;L<E86GBE %96BHAF8?J4F)4I4AA4;( #4KJ8??GGBEA8L%99<68B9 G;8;<89BHAF8?9BE*E478A9BE68@8AG4A7B@C?<4A68+ ) 8C4EG@8AGB9 B@@8E68 BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 *<@BG;L E<:;G5<?? 899E8L% E4A>)G8C;4A<8# 8??4A7?<M458G;) "88 s<?8L(8<A""&B9s4F;<A:GBA 9BE898A74AGAG8EI8ABEB4?<G<BA9BE4<E *E478<A4E7JBB7&?LJBB7 ;B8EBI8F H7:8AG;8BHEGTFF<KG;BC<A<BA<AG;<F?<G<:4G<BAG;4G;4F

FC4AA87A84E?LF<KL84EFG;8BHEG9<A4??LFHFG4<AFB@@8E68TF78G8E@<A4G<BAF 6BA68EA<A:G;8<@CBEGB9;4E7JBB74A7786BE4G<I8C?LJBB74A768EG4<AI8A88E87 C4A8?F<AGBG;8+A<G87)G4G8F9EB@G;8&8BC?8TF(8CH5?<6B9;<A4Q;<A4R FH5=86GGBG;89<A4?499<E@4G<I878G8E@<A4G<BA<A4A4AG<7H@C<A:7HGL<AI8FG<:4G<BA 5LG;8+ ) 8C4EG@8AGB9B@@8E68QB@@8E68R<A6?H7<A:4A<FFH8B99<EFG <@CE8FF<BAE8:4E7<A:G;8<A6?HF<BAB968EG4<AIB?HAG4ELE8I<8J9<E@F<A4A4AG< 7H@C<A:7HGLBE78E )888EG4<A4E7JBB7&?LJBB7&EB7H6GF9EB@G;8&8BC?8TF (8CH5?<6B9;<A4 87 (8: 8CTGB9B@@8E68$BI 9<A4? 78G8E@<A4G<BAB9F4?8F4G?8FFG;4A94<EI4?H84A79<A4?499<E@4G<I878G8E@<A4G<BAB9 6E<G<64?6<E6H@FG4A68F<AC4EG4F4@8A78787 (8: 8CTGB9B@@8E68 4A 4@8A7879<A4?78G8E@<A4G<BAB9F4?8F4G?8FFG;4A94<EI4?H84A7 4AG<7H@C<A:BE78EQ%E78ER6B??86G<I8?LQ<A4?8G8E@<A4G<BARF884?FBFFH8F 4A786<F<BA#8@ 9BEG;8<A4?8G8E@<A4G<BAB9G;8AG<7H@C<A:HGL AI8FG<:4G<BAB98EG4<A4E7JBB7&?LJBB7&EB7H6GF9EB@&8BC?8TF(8CH5?<6B9 ;<A4Q<A4?#R$B 89BE8G;8BHEG4E8G;8<A4?(8FH?GFB9(878G8E@<A4G<BA&HEFH4AGGBBHEG BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 (8@4A7Q<9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BAR$B J;<6;G;8BHEG

BE78E87<A"<AL<;8A:8A@C KC B I +A<G87)G4G8FQ"<AL<;8A:8A,R *33 )HCC 7 &?4<AG<99"<AL<;8A:8A@CBEGKCBEG B Q"<AL<;8A:8AR7<7ABG9<?86B@@8AGF<AE8FCBAF8GBG;8<9G;(8@4A7 (878G8E@<A4G<BA BAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F0;8=<4A:8;H4*@CBEGKCBEG B Q8;H4*R*4E464&46<9<6A6 Q*4E464R4A78?G<6B Q8?G<6R9<?87 G;8<E6B@@8AGF<AFHCCBEGB9G;8<9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA 8;H4*9<?876B@@8AGF6B??86G<I8?LBA58;4?9B9<GF8?94A7<:;?4A7 A7HFGE<8FA6 <4F;4A4?<AsBB7A7HFGELB 4CCLsBB7A7HFGE<4?EBHC B <4A:FH<:;BC8EF8EB )HD<4A/4BEHA*E478B /4A:M;BH4ABI AG8EA4G<BA4?B AG8ECE<F8"G7 8D<A:;<A49E<64BE8<:A*E478&BEG B &<M;BH <A);8A:/H4AAG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B .HM;BH);H<J4A:K<A: *E47<A:B BF6B)G4EAG8EA4G<BA4?B "<AL<<GLBA:94A: <AK<A6BAB@<6 *E478B "<AL<<GL);8AEH<AG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B <4A:FH'<4A=<HE8A AG8EA4G<BA4?*E47<A:B 4A7'<A:74B*BC&'AG8EA4G<BA4?BEC @GF )HCC (8@4A78G8E@<A4G<BA8;4?9BAFB? &?F 18;H4*8G4? 2QG;88;H4* B@@8AGFRBEQ8;H4*TF@GF R$B *4E4649<?876B@@8AGF6B??86G<I8?LBA58;4?9B9<GF8?94A74AHF4sBB7 &EB7H6GF"G7 BA64AABABEC 7 5 4BA64AABA"H@58EB 45HJBB7 45<A8GELBEC B??4A7)BHG;J8FGAG8EA4G<BA4?A6 "<58EGLsBB7F BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 AG8EA4G<BA4?A6 $BEG;J8FG4E7JBB7FA6 (<6;@BA7AG8EA4G<BA4?BE8FG

&EB7H6GF""4A7+)&"/"" BAFB? &?F T1*4E4648G4? 2@GF )HCC <9G; (8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BAQG;8*4E464B@@8AGFRBEQ*4E464TF@GF R$B 8?G<69<?876B@@8AGF6B??86G<I8?LBA58;4?9B9<GF8?94A7A;H<B74sBB7 B 4E4FG@8E<64AA6 <4K<A:FHA@CBEGKCBEGB <4K<A:8A:GBA: sBB7B "<AL<I8E:E88AsBB7B "<AL<?4EL&?LJBB7B "<AL< <4;8 sBB7A7HFGELB "<AL<"<A;4<sBB7B "<AL<8A:F;8A:sBB7A7HFGELB "<AL<H4F;8A:/BA:5<AsBB7B "<AL<#<A:M;HsBB7B "<AL<)4A9BEGHA8 sBB7B '<A:74BBB74<G;@CBEGKCBEGB );4A:;4<HGHJBB7*E47<A: B );4A7BA:'<F;4AAG8EA4G<BA4?*E47<A:B )H<A<A:&8A:K<4A:sBB7B )HD<4ABC8J4LAG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B )HM;BH%E<8AG4?E4:BA@CBEG KCBEGB .HM;BHA789HsBB7B .HM;BH <4A:L4A:sBB7A7HFGE<8FB .HM;BH"BA:LH4AsBB7A7HFGELB .HM;BH&<A?<AAG8EA4G<BA4?*E478B .HM;BH);8A:C<A:@CBEGKCBEGB 4A7.HM;BH*<@58EAG8EA4G<BA4?*E478 B BAFB? )8C4E4G8(4G8&?F T(8C?L@GF )HCC <9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA QG;88?G<6B@@8AGFRBEQ8?G<6TF@GF R$BF *;8BHEGE898EF6B??86G<I8?LGBG;8ABA8K4@<A87C4EG<8FG;4G9<?87G;8 8;H4*B@@8AGFG;8*4E464B@@8AGF4A7G;88?G<6B@@8AGF4FG;8 Q)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99F R BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 BAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F"<AL<)4A9BEGHA8sBB7B "G7 Q)4A9BEGHA8

sBB7R4A7.HM;BH"BA:LH4AsBB7A7HFGELB "G7 Q"BA:LH4AsBB7R9<?87 F8C4E4G86B@@8AGF<ABCCBF<G<BAGBG;8<9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA 1)4A9BEGHA8sBB7TF4A7"BA:LH4AsBB7TF2@GF %CCTA<9G;(8@4A7 (878G8E@<A4G<BAQ)4A9BEGHA8sBB7TF4A7"BA:LH4AsBB7TF@GF R$B 898A74AG+A<G87)G4G8FQ898A74AGR9<?87<GF6B@@8AGF<AFHCCBEGB9G;8 <9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA 89 TF@GF )HCC (8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA Q89 TF@GF R$B 898A74AGAG8EI8ABEB4?<G<BA9BE4<E*E478<A4E7JBB7&?LJBB7 Q898A74AGAG8EI8ABERBEQG;8B4?<G<BAR9<?876B@@8AGF<ABCCBF<G<BAGB4A7<A FHCCBEGB9G;8<9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA 189 AG8EI TF2@GF %CCTA B@@8E68TF<9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BAQ89 AG8EI TF%CCTA@GF R $B 189 AG8EI TF2@GF )HCC B@@8E68TF<9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA Q89 AG8EI TF)HCC @GF R$B 9G8EBE4?4E:H@8AGJ4F;8?7BA H?L G;8BHEG<AI<G87G;8&4EG<8F GB9<?8CBFGBE4?4E:H@8AG?8GG8EF477E8FF<A:G;8<FFH8B9E8BC8A<A:G;8E86BE7 %E4? E:H@8AG H?L $B %E78E H?L $B &?4<AG<99898A74AGAG8EI8ABE4A7BAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F8;H4**4E4644A7 8?G<69<?87G;8<ECBFGBE4?4E:H@8AG?8GG8EF 1BAFB? &?F 8;H4*TF2(8FC BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 BHEGTFAI<G4G<BA)H5@<G&BFGE:H@8AG"8GG8EQ8;H4*TF)HCC? "8GG8ER

$B 1&? TF4A7BAFB? &?F 8?G<6TF2&BFG%E4?E:H@8AG"8GG8E Q8?G<6TF)HCC? "8GG8ER$B 1BAFB? &?F *4E464TF2(8FC BHEGTF AI<G4G<BA)H5@<G&BFGE:H@8AG"8GG8EQ*4E464TF)HCC? "8GG8ER$B 89 AG8EI TF)HCC? @GF Q89 AG8EI TF)HCC? "8GG8ER$B 898A74AG7<7ABG9<?84CBFGBE4?4E:H@8AG?8GG8E )4A9BEGHA8sBB74A7 "BA:LH4AsBB77<7ABG9<?8F8C4E4G8CBFG4E:H@8AG?8GG8EF5HGJ8E8<A6?H787<A 8?G<6TFCBFG4E:H@8AG?8GG8E )888?G<6TF)HCC? "8GG8E 4G A BEG;8E84FBAF7<F6HFF8758?BJG;8BHEGFHFG4<AFB@@8E68TF<9G; (8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA

*;8BHEGE8I<8JFG;89B??BJ<A:<FFH8F s;8G;8EB@@8E68TFF8C4E4G8E4G89BEG;8ABA8K4@<A876B@C4A<8FG;4G J8E8:E4AG87F8C4E4G8E4G8FG4GHF<F<A466BE74A68J<G;?4J4A7 s;8G;8EB@@8E68TF78G8E@<A4G<BAFGB8K6?H788;H4*4A7 <4A:L4A:sBB79EB@G;8%E78E4A7GB<A6?H78)4A9BEGHA8sBB74A7 "BA:LH4AsBB7<AG;8%E78E4E8<A466BE74A68J<G;?4J

*;8BHEGCE8FH@8F94@<?<4E<GLJ<G;G;8HA78E?L<A:946GF4A7CEB687HE4? ;<FGBELB9G;<F64F84A7E86<G8FG;8946GFE8?8I4AGGBG;8BHEGTFE8I<8JB9G;8<9G; BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 (8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA )88"<AL<;8A:8A@C KC B I +A<G87)G4G8F

Q"<AL<;8A:8AR*3333 )HCC 7 O "<AL< ;8A:8A@C KC B I +A<G87)G4G8FQ"<AL<;8A:8AR*3333 )HCC 7 O "<AL<;8A:8A@C KC B I +A<G87 )G4G8FQ"<AL<;8A:8AR*3333 )HCC 7 O "<AL<;8A:8A@C KC B I +A<G87)G4G8FQ"<AL<;8A:8A,R *3333 )HCC 7 O "<AL<;8A:8A,*4G 33 )HCC 74G O B@@8E68<A<G<4G874A4AG<7H@C<A:<AI8FG<:4G<BA49G8EE8I<8J<A:4A 4AG<7H@C<A:7HGLC8G<G<BAFH5@<GG875L898A74AGAG8EI8ABE )888EG4<A 4E7JBB7&?LJBB7&EB7H6GF9EB@G;8&8BC?8TF(8CH5?<6B9;<A4 87 (8: 8CTGB9B@@8E6886 <A<G<4G<BAB9?8FFG;4A94<EI4?H8 <AI8FG<:4G<BA89 AG8EI TF&8GF @CBF<G<BAAG<7H@C<A:BHAG8EI4<?<A:HG<8F Q&8G<G<BAR$BI &( O( *;8&8G<G<BA6BAG4<A87CE<68DHBG8F QGJBB998EF9BEF4?89BE;4E7JBB7C?LJBB7CEB7H687<A1;<A429EB@4 ;<A8F88KCBEG8ER4FG;854F<F9BE<GF8FG<@4G877H@C<A:@4E:<AFE4A:<A:9EB@ GB )88<7 4G O B@@8E684668CG874CC?<64G<BAF 9EB@8KCBEG8EF4A7CEB7H68EFF88><A:GBB5G4<AF8C4E4G8E4G8FG4GHF<AG;8 <AI8FG<:4G<BAQF8C4E4G8E4G84CC?<64G<BAFRGB4IB<7G;86BHAGELJ<787H@C<A: @4E:<A5864HF8G;8<AI8FG<:4G<BA<AIB?I87CEB7H6GF9EB@;<A44ABA@4E>8G BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 86BAB@L )88<7 4G

AG;8&E8?<@<A4EL8G8E@<A4G<BAB@@8E68F8?86G87BAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99 );4A7BA:BA:94A:4L?8LsBB7Q4L?8LR4A7"<AL<;8A:8A4FG;8BA?L @4A74GBELE8FCBA78AGF<AG;8<AI8FG<:4G<BA )888EG4<A4E7JBB7&?LJBB7 &EB7H6GF9EB@G;8&8BC?8TF(8CH5?<6B9;<A4 87 (8: 8CTGB9 B@@8E68 HA8 CE8?<@<A4EL499<E@4G<I878G8E@<A4G<BAB9F4?8F4G?8FF G;4A94<EI4?H8CE8?<@<A4EL499<E@4G<I878G8E@<A4G<BAB96E<G<64?6<E6H@FG4A68F<A C4EG4F4@8A787 87 (8: 8CTGB9B@@8E68 H?L 4@8A787CE8?<@<A4EL78G8E@<A4G<BAB9F4?8F4G?8FFG;4A94<EI4?H86B??86G<I8?L Q&E8?<@<A4EL8G8E@<A4G<BARF884?FB86<F<BA#8@ &E8?<@ 8G8E@<A4G<BA AG<7H@C<A:HGLAI8FG<:4G<BAB98EG4<A4E7JBB7&?LJBB7&EB7H6GF9EB@G;8 &8BC?8TF(8CH5?<6B9;<A4Q&E8?<@ #R4G&( )8I8A6B@C4A<8F9<?87 E8DH8FGF9BEGE84G@8AG4FIB?HAG4ELE8FCBA78AGF5HGB@@8E687<7ABGF8?86G4AL IB?HAG4ELE8FCBA78AGF )88&E8?<@ #4G<A4?#4GO)8?86G<BAB9 ,B?HAG4EL(8FCBA78AG#8@ CE &( AG;8<A4?8G8E@<A4G<BAB@@8E684CC?<87<GF<AG8E@87<4G8<ACHG @8G;B7B?B:LGBI4?H8"<AL<;8A:8ATF?B:<ACHGF49G8E78G8E@<A<A:G;4G"<AL<

<G4G<BAF4E8GBG;8CH5?<6E86BE7Q&(R6BA9<78AG<4?E86BE7Q(RCH5?<69<9G; E8@4A7E86BE7Q&((R4A76BA9<78AG<4?9<9G;E8@4A7E86BE7Q((R7B6H@8AG AH@58EF9<?87<AG;<F64F8 $BF BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 ;8A:8ATF?B:IB?H@8E8CBEG<A:@8G;B7FJ8E8<A;8E8AG?L<@CE86<F8 <A4?

8G8E@<A4G<BA 87 (8: 4G <A4?#4G I4?H<A:I8A88EF <AFG847B9?B:F4FG;8<ACHGHF87GBCEB7H68;4E7JBB7C?LJBB7 B@@8E68 FG4G87G;4G<GJ4FHA45?8GBI8E<9L"<AL<;8A:8ATFE8CBEG87?B:6BAFH@CG<BA 4:4<AFG4ALG;<E7C4EGLFBHE68FFH6;4FFHCC?<8E<AIB<68F <A4?#4G 4F87 BAB@@8E68TF4CC?<64G<BAB9G;8<AG8E@87<4G8<ACHG@8G;B7B?B:LB@@8E68 64?6H?4G8747H@C<A:@4E:<AE4G8B9 9BE"<AL<;8A:8A <A4? 8G8E@<A4G<BA 87 (8: 4G B@@8E684CC?<87"<AL<;8A:8ATF @4E:<AB9 4FG;8F8C4E4G8E4G89BEG;8ABA8K4@<A876B@C4A<8FG;4GJ8E8 :E4AG87F8C4E4G8E4G8FG4GHFQ4??BG;8EFF8C4E4G8E4G8RJ;<6;J4F4FF<:A87GBG;8 )8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99F 7 <A4?#4G A"<AL<;8A:8AG;<FBHEGHC;8?7G;84CC?<64G<BAB947I8EF8946GF 4I4<?45?84:4<AFG4L?8L4A7E8@4A787J<G;E8FC86GGBB@@8E68TF64?6H?4G<BAB9 "<AL<;8A:8ATF7H@C<A:@4E:<AE4G8<AFGEH6G<A:B@@8E68GBE86BAF<78EG;8 466HE46LB9"<AL<;8A:8ATF?B:6BAFH@CG<BA64?6H?4G<BAF4A7G;84??BG;8EF F8C4E4G8E4G84CC?<87GBG;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99F54F87BA4AL6;4A:8FGB"<AL< ;8A:8ATF@4E:<ABAE8@4A7 "<AL<;8A:8A*4G33 )HCC 74G A"<AL<;8A:8AG;<FBHEGE8@4A7879BEB@@8E68GB4668CG 7B6H@8AGFB998E875L"<AL<;8A:8A<ABE78EGBCEBI<784@BE86B@C?8G8E86BE7 BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 BAJ;<6;GB54F8B@@8E68TFE84FBA<A: "<AL<;8A:8A*4G33

)HCC 74G *;8BHEGABG87<A"<AL<;8A:8AG;4GB@@8E68F;BH?7 E86BAF<78E<GF4CC?<64G<BAB9G;8<AG8E@87<4G8<ACHG@8G;B7B?B:L4668CGG;8 CE8I<BHF?LE8=86G877B6H@8AGFG;4G"<AL<;8A:8ACE8F8AG874GI8E<9<64G<BA4A7 @4>84CCEBCE<4G847=HFG@8AGFGBG;8F8C4E4G8E4G8FB9BG;8EC4EG<8F<9B@@8E68 @4786;4A:8FGB"<AL<;8A:8ATF7H@C<A:@4E:<ABAE8@4A7 7 4G33 )HCC 74G AG;8)86BA7(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BAB@@8E684668CG87"<AL< ;8A:8ATFI8E<9<64G<BA7B6H@8AGF78G8E@<A87G;4G"<AL<;8A:8ATFE8CBEG87?B: IB?H@8FJ8E8466HE4G84A77<7ABG4CC?LG;8<AG8E@87<4G8<ACHG@8G;B7B?B:LGB 64?6H?4G8"<AL<;8A:8ATF7H@C<A:@4E:<AF "<AL<;8A:8A*4G33 )HCC 74G F884?FB<A4?(8FH?GFB9(878G8E@<A4G<BA&HEFH4AGGBBHEG (8@4A7%E78E19BE)?<C%C 2Q)86BA7(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BAR $B B@@8E684CC?<87<GFABE@4?@8G;B7B?B:LGBI4?H84??946GBEF B9CEB7H6G<BAHF87<A846;FG4:8B9CEB7H6G<BA7<7ABG4CC?L47I8EF8946GF 4I4<?45?8GB"<AL<;8A:8A4A7E8I<F87"<AL<;8A:8ATF7H@C<A:@4E:<A9EB@ GB *4G33 )HCC 74G B@@8E684CC?<87 47I8EF8946GF4I4<?45?8GB4L?8L49G8E78G8E@<A<A:G;4G<GJ4F4;<A4J<788AG<GL 4A7<@CBF874A47I8EF8946GF4I4<?45?87H@C<A:@4E:<AE4G8Q7H@C<A: @4E:<AE4G8RBEQE4G8RB9 9BE4L?8L 7 B@@8E68E864?6H?4G87 BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 G;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99FT7H@C<A:@4E:<AE4G85L4I8E4:<A:"<AL<;8A:8ATF

E4G84A74L?8LTF E4G8E8FH?G<A:<A4E8I<F877H@C<A:@4E:<AB9 9BEG;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99F 7 4G33 )HCC 74G A"<AL<;8A:8AG;8BHEGFHFG4<A874FE84FBA45?84A7FHCCBEG875L FH5FG4AG<4?8I<78A68B@@8E68TF78G8E@<A4G<BAG;4G"<AL<;8A:8ATF7H@C<A: @4E:<AJ4F 5HGE8@4A7879BEB@@8E68GBE86BAF<78EG;84??BG;8EFF8C4E4G8 E4G8B9 )88<7 4G33 )HCC 74G *;<FBHEGE8?<87BA /4A:M;BH8FGC4><9GFE49GFB I +A<G87)G4G8FQ/4A:M;BH8FGC4>R 7 87 <E ;B?7<A:G;4GB@@8E68TF78G8E@<A4G<BAB9G;84?? BG;8EFF8C4E4G8E4G8B9 9BEG;8IB?HAG4EL9H??L6BBC8E4G<A:)8C4E4G8(4G8 &?4<AG<99F5LHF<A:G;8F<@C?84I8E4:8B9"<AL<;8A:8ATF E4G84A74L?8LTF E4G8B9 J4FHAE84FBA45?84F4CC?<874A7E8@4A7879BEB@@8E68 GBE86BAF<78EBECEBI<78477<G<BA4?8I<78A68 7 4G33 )HCC 74G O *;8BHEGABG87G;4GB@@8E686E84G87<GFBJACEB5?8@J;8A<GF8?86G87BA?L GJB@4A74GBELE8FCBA78AGFJ;<6;E8FH?G87<A@<A<@4?<A9BE@4G<BABAG;8E86BE7 GBFHCCBEG<GF4FF8EG<BAFE8:4E7<A:G;8CBG8AG<4?7H@C<A:@4E:<AFB9G;8)8C4E4G8 (4G8&?4<AG<99F 7 4G33 )HCC 74G *;8BHEG4?FB9BHA7G;4GG;8 @4E:<AFB9 4A7 6BAG4<A87<AG;8&8G<G<BA7<7ABGCEBI<78FHCCBEG 9BEG;84FF8EG<BAG;4GG;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99FT7H@C<A:@4E:<AF4E87<998E8AG G;4A"<AL<;8A:8ATF E4G85864HF8G;8@4E:<AF<AG;8&8G<G<BA4E8QHAG8G;8E87R BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 GBG;846GH4?7H@C<A:@4E:<AFB9G;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99F 7 *;8BHEG

6BA6?H787G;4GB@@8E6894<?87GB6<G84AL6E87<5?886BAB@<68I<78A68BAG;8 E86BE7F;BJ<A:G;4GG;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99FT7H@C<A:@4E:<AF4E87<998E8AG G;4A"<AL<;8A:8ATF E4G8BE6BAA86G<A:G;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99FT7H@C<A: @4E:<AFJ<G;G;8E4G8B9 G;4GJ4F78E<I879EB@G;84I8E4:8B9"<AL< ;8A:8ATF 4A74L?8LTFE4G8B9 7 4G33 )HCC 74G AG;8*;<E7(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BAB@@8E684:4<A4CC?<87Q4AL E84FBA45?8@8G;B7R4A764?6H?4G87G;84??BG;8EFF8C4E4G8E4G8B9 5LHF<A: G;8F<@C?84I8E4:8B9"<AL<;8A:8ATF E4G84A74L?8LTFE4G8B9 "<AL<;8A:8A,*4G33 )HCC 74G F884?FB<A4? (8FH?GFB9(878G8E@<A4G<BAGBBHEG(8@4A7%E78E19BE)?<C%C 2Q*;<E7 (8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BAR$B B@@8E68E8I<8J874F<A:?8 6B@@8E6<4?<AIB<684A778G8E@<A87G;4GG;84CCEBK<@4G8?L 7<998E8A68 58GJ88AG;8CE<68FB9G;8&8G<G<BA)8C4E4G8(4G8CC?<64G<BA4A7"<AL<;8A:8A FHCCBEG87B@@8E68TF4CC?<64G<BAB94 4??BG;8EFF8C4E4G8E4G8GBG;8 )8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99F *4G33 )HCC 74G A"<AL<;8A:8A,G;8BHEG6BA6?H787G;4GB@@8E68E84FBA45?L FHCCBEG87<GF78G8E@<A4G<BAGB78C4EG9EB@G;88KC86G87@8G;B7<A78G8E@<A<A:G;8 4??BG;8EFF8C4E4G8E4G85864HF8"<AL<;8A:8ATF E4G8JBH?7ABG58E89?86G<I8B9 BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 G;8CBG8AG<4?7H@C<A:@4E:<AF5HGE8@4A7879BEB@@8E68GBE86BAF<78EG;84??

BG;8EFF8C4E4G8E4G8B9 7 4G33 )HCC 74G *;8BHEG 4:4<AE8?<87BA/4A:M;BH8FGC4>4A76BA6?H787G;4GG;8 E4G854F87BA G;8F<@C?84I8E4:8B9"<AL<;8A:8ATF 4A74L?8LTFE4G8B9 4CC?<87GBG;8IB?HAG4EL9H??L6BBC8E4G<A:)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99FJ4F HAE84FBA45?84F4CC?<87 7 4G33 )HCC 74G O *;8BHEGABG87 G;4GB@@8E68J4FFG<??E8DH<E87GB4FF<:A7H@C<A:@4E:<AF4F466HE4G8?L4F CBFF<5?84A7G;4GB@@8E686<G874FE86BE78I<78A68BA?LBA86B@@8E6<4?<AIB<68 F;BJ<A:G;8CE<687<998E8A68B9 58GJ88AG;8CE<68FB9G;8&8G<G<BA)8C4E4G8 (4G8CC?<64G<BA4A7"<AL<;8A:8A 7 *;<FBHEGFG4G87G;4GB@@8E68 46>ABJ?87:87G;4GG;8E86BE7CEBI<787ABBCCBEGHA<GL9BEB@@8E68GB>ABJBE GB64?6H?4G8G;846GH4?7H@C<A:@4E:<AFB9G;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99F 7 *;8 BA?LFH5FG4AG<4G874A764?6H?4G8754F<F9BE47H@C<A:@4E:<ABAG;8E86BE7J4F "<AL<;8A:8ATF @4E:<A 7 *;8BHEGE8@4A7874:4<A5864HF8B@@8E68 6<G874FE86BE78I<78A68BA?LBA86B@@8E6<4?<AIB<68F;BJ<A:4A4CCEBK<@4G8?L CE<687<998E8A684A76BA6?H787G;4GB@@8E68TF 4??BG;8EFF8C4E4G8 E4G84FF<:A87GBG;8IB?HAG4EL9H??L6BBC8E4G<A:)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99FJ4FABG E84FBA45?8BEFHCCBEG875LFH5FG4AG<4?8I<78A68 7 AG;8BHEG;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BAB@@8E684CC?<87Q4ALE84FBA45?8 @8G;B7R4A74:4<A64?6H?4G87G;84??BG;8EFF8C4E4G8E4G8B9 5LHF<A:G;8 BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 F<@C?84I8E4:8B9"<AL<;8A:8ATF E4G84A74L?8LTFE4G8B9

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

BE64F8?4JFHCCBEG9BEG;8CEBCBF<G<BAG;4G?<@<G87E8FBHE68FBEFG4GHGBELG<@8 6BAFGE4<AGF64ABI8EE<7894<EA8FF4A7466HE46L 7 4G33 )HCC 74G O *;<FBHEG6BA6?H787G;4GG;8F8C4E4G8E4G84FF<:A87GBG;8IB?HAG4EL9H??L 6BBC8E4G<A:)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99FJ4FHAE84FBA45?84F4CC?<875864HF8<GJ4F BA8;4?9B9G;8E4G8@4><A:<GHA94<E4A7HA7H?LCHA<G<I84A7G;8BHEG <AFGEH6G87B@@8E68GBE86BAF<78EG;84??BG;8EFF8C4E4G8E4G86BAF<FG8AGJ<G;<GF BC<A<BA<A6?H7<A:J;8G;8EBG;8E8I<78A68BAG;8E86BE7FHCCBEG874?BJ8EE4G8 7 4G33 )HCC 74G O *;8BHEG4?FB6BA6?H787G;4G5864HF8 B@@8E68F8?86G<I8?L4A4?LM87G;8<AIB<6874G4J;<?8<:ABE<A:BG;8ECBG8AG<4??L 6BAGE4ELE86BE78I<78A68B@@8E68TF78G8E@<A4G<BAJ4FABGFHCCBEG875L FH5FG4AG<4?8I<78A68 7 4G33 )HCC 74G *;8BHEG47I<F87 B@@8E68GBABGFH5@<GG;8F4@8 4??BG;8EFF8C4E4G8E4G89BEE8I<8J J<G;BHGA8JFH5FG4AG<4?8I<78A68<AFHCCBEG4FG;<FE4G8J4FHAE84FBA45?84F 4CC?<87GB9H??L6BBC8E4G<A:E8FCBA78AGF 7 AG;8<9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BAB@@8E684FF<:A87"<AL<;8A:8ATF 4AG<7H@C<A:7HGL@4E:<AB9 GBG;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99FHA78ECEBG8FG4A7 8KC?4<A87G;4GB@@8E68JBH?78K6?H789EB@G;8%E78EIB?HAG4EL4CC?<64AGFJ;B FH5@<GG874??<A<G<4?E8FCBAF8FJ;<?8<A6?H7<A:<AG;8%E78EIB?HAG4EL4CC?<64AGF J;B94<?87GBFH5@<G4??<A<G<4?E8FCBAF8FBAG<@8 <9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 4G O

!" *;8+ ) BHEGB9AG8EA4G<BA4?*E478;4F=HE<F7<6G<BAHA78E + ) N 44 <4A7 + ) N 6J;<6;:E4AGG;8BHEG4HG;BE<GLGB E8I<8J46G<BAF6BAG8FG<A:G;89<A4?E8FH?GFB94A47@<A<FGE4G<I8E8I<8JB94A 4AG<7H@C<A:7HGLBE78E *;8BHEGF;4??;B?7HA?4J9H?4AL78G8E@<A4G<BA9BHA7GB 58HAFHCCBEG875LFH5FG4AG<4?8I<78A68BAG;8E86BE7BEBG;8EJ<F8ABG<A 466BE74A68J<G;?4J + ) N 45 < *;8BHEGE8I<8JF 78G8E@<A4G<BAF@478BAE8@4A79BE6B@C?<4A68J<G;G;8BHEGTFE8@4A7BE78E 7B6);E<@C*E4786G<BAB@@ I +A<G87)G4G8F* )HCC 7 499T7 7 87 <E

(*%.3%/(813s B@@8E68<F4HG;BE<M875LFG4GHG8GB64?6H?4G84A7<@CBF847H@C<A: @4E:<ABA<@CBEG87FH5=86G@8E6;4A7<F849G8E78G8E@<A<A:G;4G<G<FFB?7<AG;8 +A<G87)G4G8F4G?8FFG;4A94<EI4?H8 + ) N B@@8E6878G8E@<A8F4A 8FG<@4G87J8<:;G874I8E4:87H@C<A:@4E:<A9BE846;<A7<I<7H4??L8K4@<A87 8KCBEG8E4A7CEB7H68E4A7BA84??BG;8EFF8C4E4G8E4G89BEABA8K4@<A87 6B@C4A<8F + ) N 76 *;8;4FHC;8?7B@@8E68TF E8?<4A68BAG;<F@8G;B79BE78G8E@<A<A:G;88FG<@4G874??BG;8EFF8C4E4G8E4G8<A BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 N 76J;8AQ78G8E@<A<A:G;8F8C4E4G8E4G89BE8KCBEG8EF4A7CEB7H68EF

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

)G4G8@8AGB97@<A<FGE4G<I86G<BAQ)R ( B6 $B IB? 4G E8CE<AG87<A + ) $ B@@8E68@4L78C4EG9EB@G;8Q8KC86G87@8G;B7R4A7HF8Q4ALE84FBA45?8 @8G;B7R<9<GE84FBA45?L6BA6?H78FG;4GG;88KC86G87@8G;B7<FABG984F<5?8BE E8FH?GF<A4A4I8E4:8G;4GJBH?7ABG58E84FBA45?LE89?86G<I8B9CBG8AG<4?7H@C<A: @4E:<AF9BEABA<AI8FG<:4G878KCBEG8EFBECEB7H68EF )88 + ) N 76$4IA88G&H5?TAFA7<4"G7 I +A<G87)G4G8F*3333 )HCC 7 Q1*2;89B??BJ<A:;<8E4E6;L1<F4CC?<872J;8A 64?6H?4G<A:4??BG;8EFE4G8FP G;8S1:28A8E4?EH?8TF8G9BEG;<A1 + ) 2 N 76 G;84?G8EA4G<I8S8KC86G87@8G;B7THA78E1 + ) 2 N 764A74ALBG;8EE84FBA45?8@8G;B7J;8AG;8S8KC86G87 @8G;B7T<FABG984F<5?8BE7B8FABGE84FBA45?LE89?86GCBG8AG<4?7H@C<A: @4E:<AF RF884?FB)4GE8CE<AG87<A + ) $ 4G ?58@4E?8BEC 74G O DHBG<A:)4GE8CE<AG87<A + ) $ 4G ALE84FBA45?8@8G;B7@4L<A6?H784I8E4:<A:G;8 8FG<@4G87J8<:;G874I8E4:87H@C<A:@4E:<AF78G8E@<A879BEG;88KCBEG8EF4A7 CEB7H68EF<A7<I<7H4??L<AI8FG<:4G87 + ) N 76 s;<?8B@@8E68<FC8E@<GG87GBHF8I4E<BHF@8G;B7B?B:<8FQ<G<FCBFF<5?8 9BEG;84CC?<64G<BAB94C4EG<6H?4E@8G;B7B?B:LGB58HAE84FBA45?8<A4:<I8A64F8 R BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 /4A:M;BH8FGC4> 74G DHBG<A:*;4<&<A84CC?84AA<A:A7HF

BEC I +A<G87)G4G8F 7 87 <E )8C4E4G8E4G8 64?6H?4G<BAF9BEABA@4A74GBEL6BBC8E4G<A:F8C4E4G8E4G8E8FCBA78AGF@HFG584E FB@8E8?4G<BAF;<CGBG;8E8FCBA78AGFT46GH4?7H@C<A:@4E:<AF78FC<G84G;<A E86BE7 )88:8A8E4??L<7 4G O F884?FB ??<8866B<<?<CCB4E4) #4EG<AB) C I +A<G87)G4G8F 7 87 <E Q1*2;8 CHECBF8B91 + ) N 82<FGBCEBI<78E8FCBA78AGFJ<G;4A<A68AG<I8GB 6BBC8E4G8ABGGB<@CBF8CHA<G<I8458EE4G<BA4?BEHA6BEEB5BE4G87@4E:<AF R FC86H?4G<I87H@C<A:@4E:<AHF<A:G;84I8E4:8B94 E4G84A74A E4G864AABG58HC;8?754F87BAJ84>E86BE78I<78A68C4EG<6H?4E?LJ;8A B@@8E68<GF8?96E84G87G;8F64E6<GLB98I<78A68 )88BFHA*BB?FB I +A<G87 )G4G8FQBFHA*BB?FR$B s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

%CCTA@GF 4GO 89 AG8EI TF)HCC? "8GG8E4G BAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F4FF8EGG;4GB@@8E68TF78G8E@<A4G<BAGB4FF<:AG;8 )8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99F4 @4E:<AE4G8<FE84FBA45?84A7G;4GG;8BHEGF;BH?7 ABGBE78EB@@8E68GBE8BC8AG;8E86BE7BAE8@4A7GB6B??86G477<G<BA4? <A9BE@4G<BAGBE864?6H?4G84F8C4E4G8E4G845BI8M8EB )888;H4*TF@GF 4G O *4E464TF@GF 4G O8?G<6TF@GF 4G O8;H4*TF)HCC? "8GG8E *4E464TF)HCC? "8GG8E8?G<6TF)HCC? "8GG8E 898A74AG6BAG8A7FG;4GB@@8E68TF64?6H?4G<BAB9G;8F8C4E4G8E4G8<F<A 466BE74A68J<G;G;8BHEGTFE8@4A7BE78E 89 TF@GF 4GO 898A74AG7<7 ABG9<?84CBFG4E:H@8AG?8GG8EE8:4E7<A:G;8<FFH8B9E8BC8A<A:G;8E86BE7 .5(30%5,7(%3*,0%.&6.%5,1025,104 B@@8E68;474G?84FGF<K4?G8EA4G<I8FGB6BAF<78E<A78G8E@<A<A:G;8 7H@C<A:@4E:<A9BEG;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99F 4A79BHE477<G<BA4? BCG<BAFCEBCBF875L898A74AGAG8EI8ABE7HE<A:G;89<9G;E8@4A7 B@@8E68

BAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F8;H4*4A7*4E4644?FB<A6BECBE4G85LE898E8A68G;8 4E:H@8AGFB9G;8BG;8E&4EG<8F<AFHCCBEGB9B@@8E68TF78G8E@<A4G<BAGB4FF<:A4 M8EB@4E:<AGB)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99F )888;H4*TF@GF 4G QBAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F=B<A<A4A7<A6BECBE4G85LE898E8A68G;84E:H@8AGFB9G;8 BG;8EC4EG<8F<AFHCCBEGB9B@@8E68TF1<9G;2(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA R *4E464TF@GF 4GQ*4E4648G4?4?FB;8E85L47BCG4A7<A6BECBE4G85LE898E8A68 G;86B@@8AGF58<A:9<?87BAG;8<9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BAE8:4E7<A:G;8 E864?6H?4G<BAB9G;8F8C4E4G8E4G8 R BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 6BAF<78E874??B9G;8F8BCG<BAF4A7H?G<@4G8?LF8?86G87 <AG;8<9G;(8@4A7

(878G8E@<A4G<BA8KC?4<A<A:G;4GQ1429G8EJ8<:;<A:4??BCG<BAF4A76BAF<78E<A:G;8 I<8JFB9G;8BHEGJ89<A7HA78ECEBG8FGG;4G4FF<:A<A:G;8E4G864?6H?4G879BE 1"<AL<;8A:8A2 M8EBC8E68AG<FG;8BA?LE8@4<A<A:4?G8EA4G<I8BAG;8 E86BE7 R<9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA4G 898A74AGAG8EI8ABE6BAG8A7FG;4GB@@8E68<:ABE87BG;8EI<45?8 4?G8EA4G<I8F4E:H<A:G;4GB@@8E6894<?87GB8I4?H4G8G;84?G8EA4G<I8BCG<BAF 5864HF8G;8E8<FQABE4G<BA4?6BAA86G<BA58GJ88AG;8946GF9BHA7 G;8 B4?<G<BATF@8G;B7B?B:<8F4E8?8FFCE898E45?8G;4AG;8 124A7G;86;B<68F @478 4FF<:A<A:1"<AL<2;8A:8ATF1 2@4E:<A R89 AG8EI TF%CCTA @GF 4GO F884?FB&8G<G<BA8E@GF E49G(8FH?GF(878G8E@<A4G<BA#4E QB4?<G<BATFB@@8AGFBAE49G(8FH?GFR4GO &(((( 898A74AGAG8EI8ABE6?4<@FG;4GB@@8E687<7ABG477E8FFJ;8G;8EG;8F8 @8G;B7B?B:<8F6BAFG<GHG87QE84FBA45?8@8G;B7FR5HGBA?L8KC?4<A87J;LG;8F8 4?G8EA4G<I8F4E8?8FFCE898E45?8G;4AG;8 @4E:<A 89 AG8EI TF%CCTA @GF 4GO 898A74AGAG8EI8ABE6;4??8A:8FB@@8E68TFE8=86G<BAB9G;8 9BHEG;4?G8EA4G<I8BCG<BA4F4Q94??46LR4E:H<A:G;4GB@@8E68E8?<87<AC4EGBA &?4<AG<99TF74G4<AE8=86G<A:G;<FBCG<BAL8G<GH?G<@4G8?LE8?<87BA&?4<AG<99TF74G4GB 4CC?L4@4E:<A 7 4GO BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 B@@8E686BAF<78E87G;89BHE4?G8EA4G<I8FCEBCBF875L898A74AG

AG8EI8ABE<AG;8B4?<G<BATFB@@8AGFBAE49G(8FH?GF5HG78G8E@<A87G;4GG;8 E4G864?6H?4G879BE"<AL<;8A:8AJ4FG;8BA?LE8@4<A<A:4?G8EA4G<I8BAG;8 E86BE7 <9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA4G O *;<FBHEGCE8I<BHF?L6BA6?H787 G;4G464?6H?4G<BAB9G;84??BG;8EFF8C4E4G8E4G8B9 4FF<:A87GBG;8 IB?HAG4EL9H??L6BBC8E4G<A:)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99FJ4FHAE84FBA45?84F4CC?<87 CHEFH4AGGB/4A:M;BH8FGC4> 898A74AGAG8EI8ABETFCEBCBF874?G8EA4G<I8FE8FH?G<A@4E:<AFG;4G4E8 A8<G;8E ABE *;89<EFGBCG<BACEBCBF875L898A74AGAG8EI8ABE FH::8FGFG;4GB@@8E68F;BH?764?6H?4G8ABE@4?I4?H8J<G;4F<@C?84I8E4:8B9 G;8&8G<G<BAABE@4?I4?H84A7"<AL<;8A:8ATFABE@4?I4?H84A7+ ) CE<68J<G; QJ8<:;G4I8E4:8HA<GI4?H8FRQ+,FRE8CBEG87<ADH4AG<GL4A7I4?H8Q',R FH5@<FF<BAF9EB@4??F8C4E4G84CC?<64AGF47=HFG875LG;8J8<:;G87F8??<A:8KC8AF8 47=HFG@8AGFE8CBEG875L"<AL<;8A:8A9BE4@4E:<AB9 B4?<G<BATF B@@8AGFBAE49G(8FH?GF4GO *;8F86BA7BCG<BACEBCBF875L898A74AGAG8EI8ABEFH::8FGFG;4G B@@8E68F;BH?764?6H?4G8ABE@4?I4?H854F87BAG;8&8G<G<BAABE@4?I4?H8BA?L 4A7+ ) CE<6854F87BA',+,FJ<G;BHGF8??<A:8KC8AF847=HFG@8AGF9BE4 @4E:<AB9 7 4G BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 *;8G;<E7BCG<BACEBCBF875L898A74AGAG8EI8ABEFH::8FGFG;4GB@@8E68

F;BH?7J8<:;G4I8E4:8G;8Q5BB>8A7@4E:<AFR5L4FF<:A<A:4 E4G8GBF8C4E4G8 E4G84CC?<64AGFJ<G;4',+,45BI8"<AL<;8A:8ATFJ8<:;G874I8E4:8F4?8 CE<684A7G;8&8G<G<BA@4E:<AB9 GBF8C4E4G8E4G84CC?<64AGFJ<G;', +,F58?BJ"<AL<;8A:8ATFJ8<:;G874I8E4:8F4?8CE<689BE4@4E:<AB9 7 4G O *;89BHEG;BCG<BACEBCBF875L898A74AGAG8EI8ABEFH::8FGFG;4G B@@8E68F;BH?764?6H?4G8ABE@4?I4?H854F87BACEB7H6GFC86<9<6ABE@4?I4?H8F 9BE"<AL<;8A:8A4A79EB@G;8&8G<G<BA4A7+ ) CE<6854F87BAF4?8F 7B6H@8AG4G<BACEBI<7875L4??F8C4E4G8E4G84CC?<64AGFJ<G;GJBFH5BCG<BAF B@@8E68F;BH?7@4G6;FC86<9<6CEB7H6GFJ<G;CEB7H6GFC86<9<6ABE@4?I4?H8F9BE "<AL<;8A:8A4A7G;8&8G<G<BAJ;8AG;8E84E8FC86<9<6CEB7H6GF4A7 B@@8E68F;BH?7HF84A4I8E4:8B9G;8@4G6;<A:@B78?F9BEABE@4?I4?H89EB@ "<AL<;8A:8A4A7G;8&8G<G<BA9BEJ;8AG;8E84E8CEB7H6GFG;4G<A6?H78FB@85HG ABG4??@4G6;<A:78G4<?F9BE4@4E:<AB9 7 B@@8E688KC?4<A87G;4GQ142?G;BH:;J84CCE86<4G8G;81B4?<G<BATF2 6E84G<I84GG8@CGFGB78G8E@<A8BG;8E@8G;B7B?B:<8FGB64?6H?4G84F8C4E4G8E4G8J8 7<F4:E88G;4GG;8F8@8G;B7B?B:<8F4E8@BE84CCEBCE<4G8G;4AG;8 @4E:<A J;<6;J8@4<AG4<A<FG;84CCEBCE<4G84?G8EA4G<I8GBG;8466HE4G8@4E:<A64?6H?4G87 <AG;8HA78E?L<A:<AI8FG<:4G<BA R<9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA4G B@@8E68 BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 FG4G87G;4G4@8G;B7B?B:LE8?L<A:BA',+,F4FG;854F<F9BE+ ) CE<68<FABG

FHC8E<BEGBG;8@8G;B7B?B:<8FG;4G<G4CC?<87<AG;8*;<E7(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA 4A7G;8BHEG;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA 7 F88*;<E7(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA BHEG;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA B@@8E6846>ABJ?87:87G;4G',74G4 CEBI<784:?B54?4I8E4:8I<8JB946B@C4ALTFF8??<A:58;4I<BE5HGE8=86G87FH6; @8G;B7B?B:L5864HF8FH6;74G47BABG6BAF<78ECEB7H6G@<KJ;<6;64A58 F<:A<9<64AG<AFB@864F8F <9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA4G B@@8E68FG4G87 G;4G<ACE<BEE8@4A778G8E@<A4G<BAF<G6B@C4E87G;8&8G<G<BA74G44A7G;8F8C4E4G8 E4G84CC?<64AGFT46GH4?F8??<A:58;4I<BE7HE<A:G;8C8E<B7B9<AI8FG<:4G<BA4A7 <AG8AG<BA4??L6B@C4E87CE<68F4A76BFGF9BECEB7H6GFG;4G6BH?758<78AG<9<874F <78AG<64?CEB7H6GF7H8GBF<:A<9<64AG7<998E8A68F<ACE<6<A:58;4I<BEFJ<G;FH6; CEB7H6GF 7 F88*;<E7(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BABHEG;(8@4A7 (878G8E@<A4G<BA I8AG;BH:;G;89BHEG;BCG<BA477E8FF87G;8FC86<9<6<GL<FFH8@4G6;<A: F<@<?4ECEB7H6GFGBG;86BEE8FCBA7<A:ABE@4?I4?H8FB@@8E68E8=86G87G;8 9BHEG;BCG<BA5864HF8G;8CEBCBF87@8G;B7B?B:L7<7ABG6BAF<78EG;87<998E8A68F 58GJ88A&?4<AG<99TF4A7G;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99FT6B@C4A<8F <9G;(8@4A7 (878G8E@<A4G<BA4G O B@@8E688KC?4<A87G;4G7H8GB7<998E8A68F58GJ88A G;8F8GJBGLC8FB96B@C4A<8FFH6;4F47<998E8A68<A6BFGFGEH6GHE8G;8 6B@C4E<FBAF58GJ88AG;8F8??<A:CE<68B9G;8F86B@C4A<8F4A7ABE@4?I4?H854F87 BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 BA&?4<AG<99TF74G4JBH?758HAE8?<45?84A7?<>8?LHAE8CE8F8AG4G<I8B9G;8)8C4E4G8

(4G8&?4<AG<99FTCBG8AG<4?7H@C<A: 7 B@@8E68FG4G87G;4G&?4<AG<99TFF8??<A: 58;4I<BEJBH?7ABG58E89?86G<I8B9G;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99FT4A7<AGHEAABG E89?86G<I8B9G;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99FT8FG<@4G877H@C<A:@4E:<A7HE<A:G;8 C8E<B7B9<AI8FG<:4G<BA 7 *;8BHEG6BA6?H78FG;4GB@@8E68CEBC8E?L6BAF<78E874A7E8=86G87 898A74AGAG8EI8ABETFCEBCBF874?G8EA4G<I8F5864HF8B@@8E684EG<6H?4G87<GF E84FBAF9BEE8=86G<A:G;8@8G;B7B?B:<8F54F87BA',74G44A7<GFE8I<8JB9 E86BE78I<78A68 *;8BHEGJ<??HC;B?7G;84:8A6LTF78G8E@<A4G<BA<9G;84:8A6L ;4F8K4@<A87G;8E8?8I4AG74G44EG<6H?4G874F4G<F946GBEL8KC?4A4G<BA4A7 466BHAG879BE78GE46G<A:8I<78A68 #BGBE,8;<6?8#9EF FFTAI )G4G84E@#HG HGB AF + ) +A<I8EF4?4@8E4BEC I $"( + ) AG;89<9G;E8@4A7B@@8E688KC?4<A87G;4G<G6BAF<78E87F<K CBFF<5<?<G<8F9BEG;84??BG;8EFF8C4E4G8E4G8G;8 E4G8G;8 E4G84A7G;8 9BHE4?G8EA4G<I8E4G8FCEBCBF875L898A74AGAG8EI8ABE B@@8E684EG<6H?4G87<GF E84FBAF9BEE8=86G<A:G;89BHEBCG<BAFCEBCBF875L898A74AGAG8EI8ABE54F87BA B@@8E68TF4A4?LF<FB986BAB@<68I<78A68BAG;8E86BE7F;BJ<A:7<998E8A68F 58GJ88A"<AL<;8A:8A4A7G;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99FFH6;4FG;8<EF8??<A:6BFG FGEH6GHE84A7CE<6<A:G;4G6BH?7ABG58478DH4G8?L477E8FF875L898A74AG AG8EI8ABETFCEBCBF87@8G;B7B?B:<8F *;<FBHEG<A"<AL<,<AFGEH6G87B@@8E68 BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 GBABGE8FH5@<GG;8HAE84FBA45?84F4CC?<87 E4G8J<G;BHGA8J8I<78A68<A

B@@8E68TF<9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA "<AL<,*4G33 )HCC 74G B@@8E686BH?7ABG6<G8A8J8I<78A68<AFHCCBEGB9<GF E4G8 4A7G;HF78G8E@<A87G;4GG;8 E4G8J4FG;8BA?LE8@4<A<A:BCG<BA4I4<?45?8GB B@@8E68 66BE7<A:?L5864HF8B@@8E684EG<6H?4G87<GFE84FBA<A:FH99<6<8AG?LG;8 BHEGFHFG4<AFB@@8E68TF78G8E@<A4G<BAGB4FF<:A4A4AG<7H@C<A:7HGL@4E:<A E4G8B9 GBG;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99F (12(0,0*5+((&13' 898A74AGAG8EI8ABEE8DH8FGFG;4GG;8BHEG7<E86GB@@8E68GB8<G;8E 64?6H?4G84@4E:<ABG;8EG;4A BE BEGBE8@4A7J<G;4E8DH8FGG;4G B@@8E68E8BC8AG;847@<A<FGE4G<I8E86BE7GB64?6H?4G84@4E:<ABG;8EG;4A BE 89 AG8EI TF)HCC? "8GG8E4G O 898A74AGAG8EI8ABE6BAG8A7FG;4G E8@4A7<F4CCEBCE<4G89BEB@@8E68GBE8BC8AG;8E86BE7GB6B??86G477<G<BA4? <A9BE@4G<BAGB64?6H?4G847<998E8AGF8C4E4G8E4G8 7 4G &?4<AG<994A7BAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F4FF8EGG;4GG;8BHEGF;BH?7ABGE8DH<E8 B@@8E68GBE8BC8AG;8E86BE7 )888;H4*TF)HCC? "8GG8E8?G<6TF)HCC? "8GG8E*4E464TF)HCC? "8GG8E BAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99F8;H4*4A78?G<64?FB E4<F8G;8<FFH8FB994<EA8FF9<A4?<GL4A7=H7<6<4?86BAB@L<9B@@8E68J8E8GB BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 E8BC8AG;8E86BE79BE4F<KG;E8@4A7E878G8E@<A4G<BA 8;H4*TF)HCC? "8GG8E4G

8?G<6TF)HCC? "8GG8E4GO H7<6<4?6B@CH?F<BAGBE8BC8AG;8E86BE7<F?<@<G87GBHAHFH4?6<E6H@FG4A68F FH6;4F9E4H7BEE86BE7<A466HE46<8F FF4E)G88?"G7 , +A<G87)G4G8F 7 O87 <E F88B@8&EB7F AGT?A6 I +A<G87)G4G8F 7 87 <E B?74FG&4C8E <4A:FHB I +A<G87 )G4G8F*3333 )HCC 7 O ;4A:M;BHsH=<A <A8;8@ 46GBELB I +A<G87)G4G8F 7 87 <E *;<F64F87B8FABGCE8F8AG946GFFH6;4F9E4H7BE<A466HE46<8F<AG;8E86BE7G;4G94?? HA78EG;8?<@<G878K68CG<BAFGB=HFG<9LG;8BHEGE8@4A7<A:9BEB@@8E68GB E8BC8AG;8E86BE7 ?G;BH:;G;8BHEG;4FABG87F8I8E4?G<@8FG;4GG;8C4H6<GLB9 G;8E86BE7<FB@@8E68TFBJA@4><A:7H8GB<GFF8?86G<BAB9BA?LGJB@4A74GBEL E8FCBA78AGFF<@<?4EGBG;8946GF<A/4A:M;BH8FGC4>G;8BHEG6BA6?H78FG;4G B@@8E68TF786<F<BAGBABGE8BC8AG;8E86BE74GG;<FG<@849G8EA84E?LF<KL84EFB9 ?<G<:4G<BA<FABG4E5<GE4EL4A764CE<6<BHF *;8BHEGJ<??ABGE8@4A7GBE8DH8FG B@@8E68GBE8BC8ABEFHCC?8@8AGG;8E86BE7

9&.64,10%0'0&.64,101)!1.605%3: 22.,&%05,3/4 B@@8E6878G8E@<A87G;4GIB?HAG4EL4CC?<64AG9<E@FBEIB?HAG4ELE8I<8J

9<E@FJ;BFH5@<GG87G<@8?L6B@C?8G8E8FCBAF8FJBH?7588K6?H7879EB@G;8 %E78E5HG9<E@FJ;BFH5@<GG87BA?L<A6B@C?8G8IB?HAG4EL4CC?<64AGE8DH8FGF BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 J<G;BHG9H??E8FCBAF8FJBH?76BAG<AH8GB58<A6?H787<AG;8%E78E )88<9G;

(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA4G O 898A74AGAG8EI8ABE6;4??8A:8FB@@8E68TF78G8E@<A4G<BAGB8K6?H78 <4A:L4A:sBB74A78;H4*IB?HAG4EL4CC?<64AG9<E@FJ;BFH5@<GG879H?? E8FCBAF8F9EB@G;8%E78E5HGFHCCBEGFB@@8E68TF78G8E@<A4G<BAGB<A6?H78 )4A9BEGHA8sBB74A7"BA:LH4AsBB7IB?HAG4EL4CC?<64AG9<E@FJ;BFH5@<GG87 F;BEG8EGJBC4:8E8DH8FGF<AG;8%E78E 89 AG8EI TF%CCTA@GF 4G O 89 AG8EI TF)HCC @GF 4G O 898A74AGAG8EI8ABE6BAG8A7FG;4G <4A:L4A: sBB78;H4*)4A9BEGHA8sBB74A7"BA:LH4AsBB7F;BH?74??58<A6?H787 <AG;8%E78E54F87BAG;8TF;B?7<A:<A;4A:M;BH4J7?BBE<A:B I +A<G87)G4G8FQ;4A:M;BH4J7,R 7 87 <E 4A7 B@@8E68TF47@<A<FGE4G<I878G8E@<A4G<BA<A&4FF8A:8E,8;<6?84A7"<:;G*EH6> *<E8F9EB@G;8)B6<4?<FG(8CH5?<6B9,<8GA4@87 (8: 8CTGB9 B@@8E68#4L 9<A4?499<E@4G<I878G8E@<A4G<BAB9F4?8F4G?8FFG;4A94<E I4?H84A7466B@C4AL<A:FFH8F4A786<F<BA#8@BE4A7H@ 7 )4A9BEGHA8 sBB74A7"BA:LH4AsBB74E:H8G;4GG;8LF;BH?7588K6?H7879EB@G;8%E78E5HG 7BABG6;4??8A:8B@@8E68TF8K6?HF<BAB9 <4A:L4A:sBB74A78;H4*9EB@ G;8%E78E )4A9BEGHA8sBB7TF4A7"BA:LH4AsBB7TF@GF 4G 898A74AG 4FF8EGFG;4GB@@8E686BEE86G?LCEBCBF87GB8K6?H7868EG4<A6B@C4A<8F9EB@G;8 %E78E 89 TF@GF 4G O BAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<99FA8<G;8E6;4??8A:8 BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 B@@8E68TF8K6?HF<BAB9 <4A:L4A:sBB74A78;H4*9EB@G;8%E78EABE

6B@@8AGBAG;8<A6?HF<BAB9)4A9BEGHA8sBB74A7"BA:LH4AsBB7<AG;8%E78E )888;H4*TF@GF 4G8?G<6TF@GF 4GO *4E464TF@GF 4GO BAFB?<74G87&?4<AG<998;H4*<A6BECBE4G8F5LE898E8A68G;84E:H@8AGFB9G;8 BG;8E&4EG<8F<AFHCCBEGB9B@@8E68TF78G8E@<A4G<BAGB8K6?H788;H4*4A7 <4A:L4A:sBB7 )888;H4*TF@GF 4G 1//(3&(;49&.64,10(*6.%5,10 B@@8E68;4FCEBI<787G;4G<GJ<??8K6?H789EB@4A499<E@4G<I89<A4? 78G8E@<A4G<BAQ4AL8KCBEG8EBECEB7H68E9BEJ;<6;1B@@8E68278G8E@<A8F4A <A7<I<7H4?J8<:;G874I8E4:87H@C<A:@4E:<A B9M8EBBE R ( N 8 F884?FB + ) N 74QA@4><A:4 78G8E@<A4G<BAHA78EG;<FFH5F86G<BAG;847@<A<FG8E<A:4HG;BE<GLF;4??7<FE8:4E74AL J8<:;G874I8E4:87H@C<A:@4E:<AG;4G<F 4F789<A87<AF86G<BA 55B9G;<FG<G?8R *;8;4FFG4G87G;4GQ<G<F6?84EG;4G<A7<I<7H4??L E8I<8J879<E@FJ<G; 7H@C<A:@4E:<AF@HFG588K6?H7879EB@4?? B5?<:4G<BAFHA78E4A4AG<7H@C<A:7HGLBE78E15HG2G;8FG4GHG87B8FABGFC84>J<G; 4AL6?4E<GLGB6BA98EE<A:G;8F4@858A89<GBAABA<A7<I<7H4??LE8I<8J879<E@F 4FF<:A874 7H@C<A:@4E:<ABEM8EBE4G8 R;4A:M;BH4J7, 74G F884?FB;4A:M;BH4J7?BBE<A:B I +A<G87)G4G8FQ;4A:M;BH 4J7,R *3333 )HCC 7 O 499T7 7 BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 87 <E 9<A7<A:G;8FG4GHGBEL?4A:H4:84@5<:HBHFJ;8A7<F6HFF<A:

QJ;8G;8EG;4G1 2S4??BG;8EFE4G8T + ) NN 76 < 766BAFG<GHG8FS4ALT J8<:;G874I8E4:87H@C<A:@4E:<AG;4G B@@8E68@HFGS7<FE8:4E7TCHEFH4AGGB + ) N 74R *;8BHEG9<A7F:H<74A68<A;4A:M;BH4J7,J;<6;8KC?4<A87

s;4G7B8F:<I8G;86BHEGC4HF8;BJ8I8E<FB@@8E68TF4CC?<64G<BA B9 G;8 8K6?HF<BA E8:H?4G<BA GB G;8 ,B?HAG4EL CC?<64AGF <I8A G;8 ;<FGBEL B9 G;8 8K6?HF<BA E8:H?4G<BA <A J;<6; 6BA68EAF 45BHG ?<@<G<A: 8K6?HF<BA GB F8?86G87 @4A74GBEL E8FCBA78AGF J8E8 @<G<:4G87 G;EBH:; G;8 4I4<?45<?<GL B9 IB?HAG4EL 8K4@<A4G<BA G;8E8 <F 4A <A;8E8AG 4E5<GE4E<A8FF <A B@@8E68 <FFH<A: 4 5?4A>8G E89HF4? GB 8AG8EG4<A IB?HAG4EL 8K4@<A4G<BA E8DH8FGF 4A7 FH5F8DH8AG?L 78AL<A: 8K6?HF<BA GB G;8 ,B?HAG4EL CC?<64AGF G;4G J8E8 4FF<:A87 4 QE8CE8F8AG4G<I8RF8C4E4G8E4G8B9M8EBJ;<6;4:4<A<F=HFG4CEBKL9BE G;8<A7<I<7H4?J8<:;G874I8E4:87H@C<A:@4E:<AFB@@8E68F;BH?7 G;8BE8G<64??L64?6H?4G89BE4??E8FCBA78AGF ;4A:M;BH4J7, *4G33 )HCC 74G O *;86BHEG

E84FBA87G;4G

B@@8E68TF 4CC?<64G<BA B9 <GF 8K6?HF<BA E8:H?4G<BA GB G;8 ,B?HAG4EL CC?<64AGF <G 4FF<:A87 QE8CE8F8AG4G<I8R 1 2 @4E:<AF ;4F GJB <AFHE@BHAG45?8CEB5?8@F *;89<EFG<FB@@8E68TFE89HF4?GB6BA7H6G 4ALIB?HAG4EL8K4@<A4G<BAFCE8I8AG<A:G;8,B?HAG4ELCC?<64AGF9EB@ 78@BAFGE4G<A:7<E86G?LG;8<EBJA8I<78A68B994<EGE47<A: *;8F86BA7 <F B@@8E68TF 6BAG<AH<A: 4FFH@CG<BA BE <A98E8A68 G;4G ,B?HAG4EL CC?<64AGF 78A<87 <A7<I<7H4? 8K4@<A4G<BA 4A7 H?G<@4G8?L 4FF<:A87 4 QE8CE8F8AG4G<I8R 1 2 @4E:<A J8E8 A8I8EG;8?8FF HA94<E?L GE47<A: CE86?H7<A: 8K6?HF<BA *;8 6BHEG DH8FG<BAF ;BJ 4 E84FBA45?8 @<A7 6BH?7@4<AG4<AFH6;4A4FFH@CG<BABE<A98E8A684:4<AFGG;8,B?HAG4EL CC?<64AGF 7 4G33 )HCC 74G BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 *;8499<E@87G;86BA6?HF<BAG;4GB@@8E687<7ABG478DH4G8?L

FHCCBEG<GF78G8E@<A4G<BAGB<A6?H78IB?HAG4EL4CC?<64AGF<AG;8%E78E5HGCEBI<787 GJB64I84GFGB<GFEH?<A:

1<EFG2J8F4LABG;<A:45BHG1G;8+ ) BHEGB9AG8EA4G<BA4?*E478TF2 E8I8EF4?B9B@@8E68E4G;8EG;4AE8@4A79BE9HEG;8E8KC?4A4G<BA 14A7F86BA72J8HA78EFG4A71G;86BHEGTF786<F<BAGB8K6?H78IB?HAG4EL E8I<8J 9<E@F 9EB@ G;8 4AG<7H@C<A: 7HGL BE78E2 4F ABG :B<A: 58LBA7 ;B?7<A:G;4GB@@8E68;4FABG<AG;<FCEB6887<A:CEBI<7874FH99<6<8AG E4G<BA4?8 9BE 6BAG<AH<A: GB <A6?H78 G;8 IB?HAG4ELE8I<8J 9<E@F <A G;8 14AG<7H@C<A: 7HGL BE78E2 4A7 J8 E8?L BA G;4G HA78EFG4A7<A: <A 499<E@<A:G;816BHEGTF2=H7:@8AG GE8@4<AFBC8AGBB@@8E68<AG;8 9HGHE8F;BH?7G;8<FFH84E<F8GB477E8FFG;<F<FFH8@BE89H??LG;4A<G;4F 7BA8<AG;<F<AI8FG<:4G<BA s87BABGCE8=H7:8G;8E84FBA45?8A8FFB9 4AL=HFG<9<64G<BAB@@8E68@<:;GL8G4EG<6H?4G89BE786<7<A:GB<A6?H78 IB?HAG4ELE8I<8J9<E@F<A4A4AG<7H@C<A:7HGLBE78E ;4A:M;BH4J7, 74G B@@8E68<AG8ECE8G87G;8;4A:M;BH

4J7,;B?7<A:GB4??BJB@@8E68GB78G8E@<A8<GFCBF<G<BABAJ;8AGB:E4AG 8K6?HF<BAFGBIB?HAG4ELE8I<8J9<E@F )88<9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA4G O Q1;4A:M;BH4J7,27B8FABG6B@C8?B@@8E68GB8K6?H784??6B@C4A<8FG;4G E8DH8FG87IB?HAG4ELFG4GHF5HGG;4G<GJBH?7E8I<8J4AL9HEG;8E8KC?4A4G<BA CEBI<7875LB@@8E684GG;4GG<@8 R 0%.:4,4

B@@8E687<FG<A:H<F;8758GJ88AG;8GJBGLC8FB9IB?HAG4EL4CC?<64AGF<A G;89<9G;E8@4A7P8;H4*4A7 <4A:L4A:sBB7J;BFH5@<GG87E8DH8FGF9BE IB?HAG4ELE8FCBA78AGGE84G@8AGJ<G;;HA7E87FB9C4:8FB9DH8FG<BAA4<E8E8FCBAF8F BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 4A7FHCCBEG<A:7B6H@8AG4G<BA4A7)4A9BEGHA8sBB74A7"BA:LH4AsBB7J;B

FH5@<GG87GJBC4:8E8DH8FGFJ<G;ABDH8FG<BAA4<E8E8FCBAF8FBEFHCCBEG<A: 7B6H@8AG4G<BA <9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA4G F88 <4A:L4A:sBB7TF)86 (8FC 85 &( O ( O <4A:L4A:sBB7TF)86 (8FC 85 &( ( O <4A:L4A:sBB7TF)86 (8FC 85 &( ( O "BA:LH4AsBB7"8GG8EQ(8DH8FG9BE*E84G@8AG4F #4A74GBEL(8FCBA78AGBE(8DH8FG9BE,B?HAG4EL(8FCBA78AG*E84G@8AG4F4A ?G8EA4G<I8R86 &()4A9BEGHA8sBB7"8GG8EQ(8DH8FG9BE *E84G@8AG4F#4A74GBEL(8FCBA78AGBE(8DH8FG9BE,B?HAG4EL(8FCBA78AG *E84G@8AG4F4A?G8EA4G<I8R86 &( B@@8E688KC?4<A87G;4G <4A:L4A:sBB74A78;H4*F;BH?7588K6?H7879EB@G;8%E78E5864HF8G;8L @8GG;89<EFGE8DH<E8@8AGGB586BAF<78E879BEIB?HAG4ELE8FCBA78AGFG4GHFHA78E + ) N @49<?<A:G;8F4@8<A9BE@4G<BA8KC86G879EB@@4A74GBEL E8FCBA78AGF5LG;8F4@87847?<A8 <9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA4G O A 6BAGE4FGB@@8E68ABG87G;4G)4A9BEGHA8sBB7TF4A7"BA:LH4AsBB7TFGJB C4:8E8DH8FGFJ8E8QI<EGH4??L<78AG<64?<A6BAG8AG4A7E8DH<E87AB6B@@<G@8AGBE 899BEGBA58;4?9B9G;8F86B@C4A<8FR4A7J8E8ABG68EG<9<876B@C4E87GBG;8 Q;HA7E87FB9C4:8FB9DH8FG<BAA4<E8E8FCBAF8F4A7FHCCBEG<A:7B6H@8AG4G<BA4F

8;H4*TFE8FCBAF8FGB)86G<BAF4A7J8E8ABG<A6?H787<AG;8 47@<A<FGE4G<I8E86BE7 BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 J8??4FF4?8F4A7946GBEB9CEB7H6G<BA74G454F8FR9EB@ <4A:L4A:sBB74A78;H4

* 7 4G B@@8E68E84FBA87G;4G

1*2;8E8<F4F<:A<9<64AG7<998E8A6858GJ88AG;BF86B@C4A<8FG;4G@8E8?L FH5@<G 4 5E<89 FG4G8@8AG E8DH8FG<A: GB 58 F8?86G87 4F 4 IB?HAG4EL E8FCBA78AG 4A7 G;BF8 6B@C4A<8F G;4G CEBI<78 6B@C?8G8 DH8FG<BAA4<E8 E8FCBAF8F5LG;87847?<A8F8FG45?<F;879BEG;8@4A74GBELE8FCBA78AGF FH6;G;4GB@@8E68;4FG;8<A9BE@4G<BA589BE8<GGBCBG8AG<4??LF8?86G G;8@ 4F IB?HAG4EL E8FCBA78AGF 4A7 FG<?? 6B@C?8G8 G;8 <AI8FG<:4G<BA J<G;BHGHA7H878?4L 7 4G O

&HEFH4AGGB + ) N @4HCBA?<@<G<A:G;8AH@58EB9E8FCBA78AGF HA78E + ) N 9 6B@@8E68QF;4??8FG45?<F;4A <A7<I<7H4? J8<:;G874I8E4:87H@C<A:@4E:<A9BE146B@C4AL2ABG<A<G<4??LF8?86G879BE <A7<I<7H4?8K4@<A4G<BAR<9 G;86B@C4ALF88><A:<A7<I<7H4?8K4@<A4G<BA FH5@<GFQ R5LG;8F4@87847?<A8FG;4G4CC?LGBG;8F8?86G87E8FCBA78AGF4A7 G;8AH@58EB9FH6;6B@C4A<8F<FABGFB?4E:8GB5HE78ABE78?4L<AI8FG<:4G<BAB9 G;8<A7<I<7H4??L8K4@<A876B@C4A<8F )88 + ) N @48@C;4F<F 47787 IB?HAG4ELE8FCBA78AG4668CG879BE<A7<I<7H4?8K4@<A4G<BA<FFH5=86GGB G;8F4@8E8DH<E8@8AGF4F46B@C4AL<A<G<4??LF8?86G875LB@@8E689BE<A7<I<7H4? 8K4@<A4G<BAHA78E + ) N 9 6 BE + ) N 9 8 <A6?H7<A:G;8E8DH<E8@8AGFB9 + ) N @4 )88 ( N 7 BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 *;8BHEG4:E88FJ<G;898A74AGTF4E:H@8AGG;4GQ162EH6<4??LG;8E8?8I4AG

CBEG<BAB9G;8FG4GHG8BA?L4CC?<8FGB4C4EGLSJ;BFH5@<GFGBG;847@<A<FG8E<A: 4HG;BE<GLG;8<A9BE@4G<BAE8DH8FG879EB@8KCBEG8EFBECEB7H68EFF8?86G879BE 8K4@<A4G<BA TR89 TF@GF 4G 6<G<A: + ) N @4 *;8BHEG4?FB 9<A7FG;8B4?<G<BATF4E:H@8AGC8EFH4F<I8J;8A<GFG4G8FG;4G

A7887 8I8A <9 B@@8E68 ;47 F8?86G87 IB?HAG4EL E8FCBA78AGF 1)4A9BEGHA8sBB74A7"BA:LH4AsBB72JBH?7ABG;4I8588A8?<:<5?8 GB58F8?86G874FG;8L7<7ABGF4G<F9LG;8E8DH<E8@8AGFGB58GE84G874F4 IB?HAG4EL E8FCBA78AG A BG;8E JBE7F 8I8A <9 B@@8E68 ;47 4668CG876B@C4A<8F4FIB?HAG4ELE8FCBA78AGF4A764?6H?4G87<A7<I<7H4? @4E:<AF 9BE G;8F8 6B@C4A<8F AB FH6; @4E:<AF JBH?7 ;4I8 588A 64?6H?4G879BE1)4A9BEGHA8sBB74A7"BA:LH4AsBB72 89 AG8EI TF)HCC @GF 4G6<G<A:<9G;(8@4A7(878G8E@<A4G<BA4G O

8KC?4<A<A:G;4G46B@C4AL@HFGFH5@<GE8FCBAF8FGBG;8DH8FG<BAA4<E8F5LG;8 7847?<A88FG45?<F;879BEG;8@4A74GBELE8FCBA78AGFGB586BAF<78E879BEIB?HAG4EL E8FCBA78AGFG4GHF *;<F64F8<AIB?I8FG;8F<GH4G<BA6BAG8@C?4G875LG;8<A;4A:M;BH 4J7,J;8AG;86BHEGFG4G87G;4G

GE8@4<AFBC8AGBB@@8E68<AG;89HGHE8F;BH?7G;8<FFH84E<F8GB 477E8FFG;<F<FFH8@BE89H??LG;4A<G;4F7BA8<AG;<F<AI8FG<:4G<BA s8 7B ABG CE8=H7:8 G;8 E84FBA45?8A8FF B9 4AL =HFG<9<64G<BA B@@8E68 @<:;GL8G4EG<6H?4G89BE786<7<A:GB<A6?H78IB?HAG4ELE8I<8J9<E@F<A 4A4AG<7H@C<A:7HGLBE78E ;4A:M;BH4J7, 74G BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 *;8BHEG6BA6?H78FG;4GB@@8E68TF7<FG<A6G<BA58GJ88AG;8IB?HAG4EL

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

IB?HAG4ELE8FCBA78AGF )4A9BEGHA8sBB74A7"BA:LH4AsBB74E:H8G;4GG;8L J8E8ABG:<I8A46;4A68GB7<E86G?L78@BAFGE4G8G;8<EBJA8I<78A68B994<EGE47<A: 5864HF8B@@8E68E89HF87GB6BA7H6GIB?HAG4EL8K4@<A4G<BAF5HGG;8L7<7ABG F4G<F9LG;8FG4GHGBEL6E<G8E<45L9<?<A:G<@8?L<A9BE@4G<BAE8DH<E87B9@4A74GBEL E8FCBA78AGFG;4GJBH?78A45?8G;8@GBCEBI8G;8<E94<EGE47<A:<9F8?86G874F IB?HAG4ELE8FCBA78AGF )88)4A9BEGHA8sBB7TF4A7"BA:LH4AsBB7TF@GF 4G *;8BHEG6BA6?H78FG;4GB@@8E68CEBI<7874E84FBA45?88KC?4A4G<BAGB =HFG<9L<GF8K6?HF<BA9EB@G;8%E78EG;8IB?HAG4EL4CC?<64AGFJ;BFH5@<GG87G<@8?L E8DH8FGF9BEIB?HAG4ELE8FCBA78AGGE84G@8AGJ<G;;HA7E87FB9C4:8FB9 DH8FG<BAA4<E8E8FCBAF8F4A7FHCCBEG<A:7B6H@8AG4G<BACEBI<7<A:G;8F4@8 <A9BE@4G<BAG;4G@4A74GBELE8FCBA78AGFFH5@<GG875LG;8F4@87847?<A8<A 466BE74A68J<G; + ) N @4 *;8BHEG4?FB;B?7FG;4GB@@8E68J4F E84FBA45?8<A6BAG<AH<A:GB<A6?H78G;BF8IB?HAG4EL4CC?<64AGF<AG;8%E78EJ;B7<7 ABGFH5@<GG<@8?L<A9BE@4G<BACEBI<7<A:G;8F4@8<A9BE@4G<BAG;4G@4A74GBEL E8FCBA78AGFFH5@<GG875LG;8F4@87847?<A8<A466BE74A68J<G; + ) N @4

BEG;89BE8:B<A:E84FBAF<G<F;8E85L G;4GG;8BHEGFHFG4<AFB@@8E68TF4??BG;8EFF8C4E4G8E4G8 BAFB? BHEG$B &4:8 4FF<:A87GBG;8)8C4E4G8(4G8&?4<AG<99F4A7<G<F9HEG;8E

G;4GG;8BHEGFHFG4<AFB@@8E68TF78G8E@<A4G<BAGB8K6?H78 8;H4*4A7 <4A:L4A:sBB79EB@G;8%E78E4A7<G<F9HEG;8E G;4GG;8BHEGFHFG4<AFB@@8E68TF78G8E@<A4G<BAGB<A6?H78 )4A9BEGHA8sBB74A7"BA:LH4AsBB7<AG;8%E78E4A7<G<F9HEG;8E G;4GG;8BHEGFHFG4<AFB@@8E68TF<9G;(8@4A7 (878G8E@<A4G<BA H7:@8AGF;4??<FFH8466BE7<A:?L

F 8AA<98E;B8EBI8F 8AA<98E;B8EBI8F H7:8 4G87%6GB58E $8J/BE>$8J/BE>

Linyi Chengen Imp. and Exp. Co. v. United States, 658 F. Supp. 3d 1347, 2023 CIT 147 (cit 2023).

Pincite

658 F. Supp. 3d 1347 (Linyi Chengen Imp. and Exp. Co. v. United States) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.