1-tc?w C.ofi1C.S 1 osw;M..n <;,ecttq: Ufc 1 rt-1 me Al'10vc N~&J;'TJ ANO sTYt.£0 64.SC N<JW ()..e'Ft;IR.JU;'f) TlJ As ~rt:A-rvtt I , · •
- ]:, <;rA~tnO<II OF jl)(lC..sDU(W({,
11-e""<.•\-toa. :Sa;.~ i?1M04tnvs ~ FdPm n-~e oocJi!J &F c.ft..Un:U-ttK Al'l7e.u.s ,ro Pt<oel2... ~ Jet:JT11 J>.Ei;.'fllJZT UNifl f~QJ<... .JcA)4e ~ ~1112CCT Tlfe.UZ-IrW/lS 'iJeFEZTW&" c.&i:J:::r:I;LI·ffTlJt·J ()F 17-fe f2.;f4 Hf W Af'J16fL DOC 7V ~N !HVAltO -~ ~F TlfC 12.f:4HT TO Ar'i1t'lt-l /??,I,Dc #C?r la.t;wJ::il4LY J:(.(~cftl (l/!.. .1/PCINft'/l..Y. . il-l£ ACr S.CriQIIII'S t41riii5ret.rAL (.1;.10£ TCKi Afll£ AI'P, Ptu'C· i.fl-/,4i srA¢ CJc_IU'l. W46e' .nAYSj VS, f;6q s,w, 1J G'l3 (me, eo., AI'P, f/Bq).
n-it5 U/cJt'l oF dJJ:tf1rf.S<C APPe"Af...-5 -H-AS JtJIJI~iJrC('[;(}J-J tJVIm. .Tff£5 Ulr:trT.INAL J#A~ {ll{oel. .nlt::-(1;;.-)C, CCI-lSI.; AUf,Jl;., 5fE 5, -~ f.fftA'ItJil ··JII¥i 111i:;'"f me rwtJ· Pt1tli4S re:>~-esrrtJC:t:.Sl!cD CN .JJIZ..'t.£1-15 liS UXJ!lJ CJF .lf)ff't"/.fL-S J ~ 1:1! SOP, .;ltJD, VIS~, j 'J~ ~. WJ :U 64 ~ 6c:-;r; C.ft,A{JP, lti8;1J.
FPl6T 1 f1K(J.t:JATe>£ HilS 1<10 AOEQUATC' tJ..EtneOV Al~rHCil.EZ:S NO fttinC'OV ~y flt;;7:J::!W" RJ~.
DrSC-tltTIONAfLY IUVIt:w RUJ/11 AU ADI£~5f ~-u..n«; .g.{ .4/J l7flLZjrUAL /11ANDA~ l>f2a::Ecoi}ly, >e'C .~col!>s ~ smr£;69:2 ~w, ~d rJ.lf (r~ C1l, Jq£35), · .
. St:'lOH-0 1 mee.otJt2T tJFAPtJe'~th CL~ILLY )fl3oseo ffi agaerr:o/J WlteiJ. 'CIFArcro 7eJ OllfJCd.. nfe TiJIIfL ~T .W04c tJF'rue lf3o7J1 Dt<rM aunl w f8!RJR.rn m f'MfiL6Tt71A~ /JVtY AU'O UlflJl£C-T rffl!' O~Ftz.:rr:v6 CCi..fl:FI:Cttrr.tJN- ':1 fiCI(;C(.(Ci rue- 12£l.4rotl.. Hi6 A J1:t4 liT ro Af'J1elfl, Tflc CCuA:r() F" A-F'Ilt:A(..$1
J
{J-!I CiJCJttT Of ltflPcAl-5 Q..u.£o Ct'~~AI!Y TO frAi7JILY L..Aw1 fE>c. R.UL, APJ! pnj)C l/4, '{, T~e ~ 1-fU. 5.4-r:P.:)~ 71-IE /!£t2(/./:ll£1/7t!JB t:Jf/r~ Z::/4 PAOI4A vs:. nfc D~El, lal S.~ 3d tJoscrex, ~ll, AP~ ~3), I)Y Silf!,JnT~ 1-1 cs !1P~t.:~at1"WtJ Fee! wttr:r (JF 11'/Ai.l DUirll.-5 -ltfttf:F" ftd.~ 70 rnt CbVILf ~f:APK4,L~ (£VJ;Sf11J;c-;. 0 p ~. . . wJ+£1( A- TtU:AL CfJcnrr ;J7,IJ>4c OE"Nr:t=S Af.llrf'l'az:.;,l(r TFfe /tU;HT :ro AflN:"-AL F{!()P/1 ;fG e:~~Tll>!-1 (JI-IJ~ti., ~ IJ.VL,t~(}p,p~• .iS.~X.:/) 1 we.tJRdetJ. A.emEUY r$ .6V A wt2J:riJF Jn4~D~ !tf'P~~Ai::. ~:':, 6y .A \Vftr:l ~ IIAaeM (()tlPD;s 1 )tttri 1/,tJ7-.. S'111]:.ff-/ t'.5,, 5TJ.'tTE,13r ~W, 5 ~({Ex;
rnfJ Cf.TXI/4 A~GTv~,CVn.QY,S9-15-,Wr~d '/'-lO, - ·
RECEIVED IN
COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
. SEP 23 2015
Abet Acosta, Clerk ;.
_; f.·: :". ~ I\,.
. STA'[§I11t!l[ oECASE
, .,lie R:ll?r ucMr or ,t~l1cA<.S Pr.Ji/6~0 d~ v~· WflfN rr POIIED .fJt7J't"WfL's. i-~ cr /JMrYrmv .s tti.Pff I~ J'..fMaJ Fa nte Ot;'1JTAL l#t41 ~ ~~ R£tATtJt WA-5 Pf31~0 OF A f'IZEttmn-lAiiY Jff:i<~4 CN JfLS ~TJAL f'lll:CCDr-""t#f.p f'ILrOJ!'. TV IUVACA'Tk1J, A.eLATCIL W4S AL.50 DEPt1.:C:t£0 t?FA ~4J"tJ'i~ ~ A Ff'tlt.t/WUttt ATrOtl t'FP/Jtl&4~ .. AmlffJ.. ro 7E'YM; c;ov'T c.e;oE/}:J..(}(Jt0"3f3,"J:FC?fiE Sf<fOW~ AFf.l:fttnAJrVE AU-lOY ~£#CY 10 Af'A..y ~~S /t()Lf To ttrm Af.lo Tf/.4r API't.rcA~ CF~ /tVI:E wvvLD Al?vBl.Sc't:-V AFFCCr 11~5 l£4AL R.u:,l-lr:5 Olt PIJ:1.4IL£4e; If£ {lit$ 5(}{~DT~ lfJ <:JtAL-L~t A-PI'trC41!£a:rY tJJI"I!.tt£ r~ ptL.l.ARATO~Y ~ttta'-41 <Jvrt; IJIUJtfJ.§fi OFT~S Atf/UJIL AND :r:s /ior Rt""Qvrt!.t-o TV t+?(JT UHTU_ Q.v(£ ri A'rrttn"rco To /!£ ENFoQ.CEO A<-,4r:t4s/ fCW1 .~ HE t11tfY IU$0/tl W {)f:Z_L4TlltlY 12..aLEF. . . iltl4TOJt .Fl£.£il PtliT!C'I</ S~<14 .DKlAitAWti.Y JVD~~~· Oti.3._ 0/.rY of Jo~ 20I!t_ ., ~!fUn( f<.t'Uq;:f) t.tortlk or: COvll.T St'TfiN~ 1 ~ntrt:l) :n/f' Rtc.AWil~. (Jt:7nr£7H t«VLD ()t: DJ:-5ff!Z:55E() RJtL uAflfT f)FP/1Uc:J;Ji;JI./, "Jt£ £Kifii!Jr oi.IE, REL-ArotL cctt~t'tYeD k!1'ra A-LL rusmrcrwt:.Js, oUJ~CD rli C:Ht\~ B. -sa 81fVJtTTWt?., Ac..-$0 sec tXA:ttSI:r_s 31 AtiD tiJ nttto~H J.lO f1WL..T o,:: t-tt3 0(.4.4.1 12EtAWI'lS PtT.riJ(;!fJ wA-S ;.wT t~.f'D}:ClU::1) At..'\tl VI:Si11I5SeD fC~ ~Fj; Ill= iek.o~ffi?N l.vlf£K rr ~S JJor rt4 rtf?' f'IJPI/e7l W J!.fl.Arr;rl TO St7ft UJcJ/lT 0/H£:.
t, It~{( WIIS fJff'tlitlt:D OF A IM.Et:J:tn:IIJN2..JI ~dP-14} f.£cAU;;JL !VAS J:JCr C;t;v£"# 4 'P~If/JAIJ.'Y f(Gftlf:l./t;. Wf.lrul V"""L.OCATfl> IU::6 b oe tJ Jt.«.i=~ /tr4J.tr I JUU.tTOtl. wA-.!) Of(f:/(£0 TO A ffE4r2rH(j OeRJilf .ltEWCA filJ A/ ~r fllo~fl/~i..:(1(o04H ()A.Of!AT~tJtJ ~r.rPN, Lr:~ PAfWL€ ftrU?CAT:Wr.f, wA5 IJlll 4 ~17f4E (IF ~111.n<IIU.. P~s{il)r;w£.< 1 rriE avtlT moull rtft(r :cr ~$t..JICD P( AUf$ cr t.:r1tD.TV, TfiE/Jf' Rltlf A Pll.llt!Arr:tJIIe-t., ULE A M~Wut:,w~ BJn:TLt=:D TO A Ph.B..:n-nrN/.fty Heftt1J;1.t; 1V Dt:TttlmC4e-.wHernell. {{{(12£ wPs fJM6- Iri!,Le C'MJ5f 1t7 !!JELreVt THAT '(l(etU W~ f!J(£j{J. A M.brJA'fJWIJ vUJlAfWIII fiHI) A fi'JPILE (f;ntPUII£~SZ:IIF pr#J.M- ~(Va::"A TU7U f/tAflJ:fl~. CV4f.lo1J VS. S'CA~I)EUA1 4 II lJ, S. 118;' . a, ·Jl? rue 5A~ EF!t.:(..i ltt"l-Aft?ll. W~ 4'-SO ~ A 5~ilctl(~ WEfLQJ AUJO \ITcll-ATl:'""$ DE{) PlloCEsS, i#(J/2.- t.:r"!iseY ~~ 6ttewt1t, l/CJe o,S.Lf11, 3s nFt rrt!Ac covp:r AND ifl£~ Ca!ILT ()C rll.AviS cDuJJrY filnl AW~cD mag_ o.tY.::JLtcATU1JJ fSY Nor . FouPw-c;.it, PA.&PE/1. fJIWC£/)1)/J.£5 mAN'DAre:o rrlY 5vtJI.ell~ Ct:vlfT PllEC£0f.f.IC5 1 wlftC# ~LE"iULY DtcLAtleS rtf4"1 AvPtiU:fiiJTS ARE ~NT.rTL£.0 W A fVU. A;.JO FAI~ (JPIOPJV HlTY ft; LXTr41fft' Ci.APY75 W-~P Afyrn.J1T THCtn rfl AD01Tftlf..l THe Cc()n.T~ f)Tu t«lr R7LLCttJ E~TilllAsfJ£D 5vPP-011£ Cbv~r P~RE/J8-1Le1 wHr:LH Ctt1JALY OtOA'Lt!J/rt-JAI I f (H[ Ar'lllr--Utf..{( 010 N(IT I<Elu:vC A (\IU.. AfJD FArR ~J.JA;.Jtf TO a::rrz,Art! !IJ THe t:.ot-/VLcrr:tJ(i Cc>tJD.I AND ~N COU.Art:(AL ~bln:uj l(, ,f::Jv ~~~iVIIJ4! NtJr C{;IA5Lvt:!fLf.D IiLtLJAL AT Tl-fe Rf!Lf TitAI wAS n:J11{;; C'f R.fL4'tt:~ll5 -~NVOLITc:A.Y lUI} ~[/11t:I.JT, vvti-U.H ~Ufl66' ef /b51 f.4(JV LA"'
tHl.c; liJ Mftirs ANu AVr ll@[rt$
Tf>l · (,/Wvl~ 0 01-le P-ELATCYJ... M.\5 Ct'JltUVED (Jf A l>ll/;U:WII/J4fJY 11£/VZII.JC; WHJXN t/.UJLAW f1F5 ~ ~IJ.t:r£SS /U4111 1 (JJ;l4T()IJ... WAS EUTUtED 10 A Ht:MU/1/y t!J[(Oit ;tEWtATCON Or PRtJ&fTTiJN. . _.. 'll~llfOl.t:Jfl f'tl£f14ts:ot.t P.l:V()(ATftJI.J ,triLl? fJAiJIJLC fl.EU:JCArw1~, wM 401 A 5rtr;,ePFCJ!..Pl!.IIIA<- Pwst::cvrwt< Tilt Cou/lJ .ffV/JO TlfAI rr !USULrtD p.J 4 t-.t/~'5 CJF t.:J:I!J::l(fy1 7116tUf~iltt£ 4 fJil/7t!J4TWNM. UK.C"A f'J/lt?C.EC U1\6 ef.Jfin.ev IO A fJ()£Lr:m"£(j!rf2_y 1iE4t<.-rr.f~ rtJ /Jt!rEtN11.CNE Wl-\E11-U.1( r7ft:/U( .·WI'S PtlOJ!A<J;e Otv5r ro tx:cc~~ Of41 nftl)f IVAS 6ecfJ 11 fJRo64(1{;1N · vrturw ANo A mCitf Codll'~ell-eN:szve F:c~t.- d.MotTJlHI Htl.~nu;:!J .4t5o ov~ flfl.ccES5 Rff!xJICII..Co t?I4(.Y lfl cu !Wm~tL HOtJUI'f4 ww (l£UX4TC:Of,l. rrte CPV'Ar FoullO lfi-A-T {H-e lff$CLTTY 0~ rfiAI ffl:AJ!U~ To 1'/l.orecr Pl2o/!AC(£luCoJ;· /Jo;Hr:'' D~PifuOEO ~1.1 Tilt! tiS£' o~ 5Ka.L k/ifUil J1fe fJ/l.C(/4 (]:()~11(31..5 _IM\5 Viii O::keLV It? Jt;.;s e51'1 T11v:5 Tff~t:S tl!Cflf: :CtJSDitK£'5 Wiltlle' CbVJISfC.. wA-s lltl12i/t¥Lt:D.{[Il:J;') ~ ilvw f~£LATr;Jt5 (O()fl6f{ wM Itl£ffE4TVf),-
A Pllo~ATJ:oAe-IJ. .UIL£ ,4 fJ.ff1/)(_ftE1 r5 £-1-Jr:!TLeD 1b 4 /3fJ.£LunL!JAil.Y AND ·-
Pfloflltno.~ (_!IV. ~E Yl.J:W~EO. 44<}No~ 1 V-5, 5c4P.fl~Ur1 t(/1 V,'5. J?-8.' F.t11.4-L. FfEI(Ial<f(j bEto.Rf 1 Her: ~vn.r Ht--co : '
IJ Dflt;. f'na.ei:. ~I'LDJ\-tB !Ji,ELfi'11INAI!Y At.ID ~.J:/'IIfL. R./;1-t?U..T.ral llt::Rr~U/kj .Z:}..) ntC eAse OF A- tJI/.!)6A-T'IPJJeR. ut<JDE"R. me- 5A-ffltf &IJJ)rf;£~/.JS' 4-flr 'Sf1ECEF!::£b :a.r /?¥1/A:rss EY v.5- fJr<~wCR.1 L£(:!.f3 u,s.q;'J _ ._ wtE; ~vrew
·me- oecrswN T/) P..EvtJfE A Tli2..fll1 (lP sttflB.Vl:S£0 R.EL:EAsE1 A Ct7vi2T tnf/51 F~D 6Y A I'~EflONDft<AJJ(f llF TtJt t.VJ;/X~CE THAT 11ft DEJtNOA-fir tfi(J(AIGD -4 ct;#OCT../tl M OP',Ik5 l£L£:5E;(/Le-tAr~ 0055 C4t..l£lJ At.:!O TCJUJ H13 PllPIJA® ( (JFFJZER. il-¥fl ~tlAf0/2 WAS riJ l=£c( WOt2.kri:IC, oiJ 11-fc bAY EIJ QUJ3(JV'.J , fl<f5Vt11/lli::rA ~C«fla:::f:NCE NO P1fSi~tr- :WIJ « CiuiJ...-r MUTS"t:S FYI..cm ril£ 117€0£ FACI Tf-IAT A Cttnn:c#l!{. A<LVS~TWN. Hft~ I!:Ec 11'1. (JCFot2£ A. CotrlfJCT:FNr Atr(i.foi(J:(f., u.s. vs, sP~A~uN,t.llfJ,§)_c:Lv't-?'f.:n_~- .fC"r 8£ fi:J~D P~IJA"'J(JH mr aK.£ M@l£ ltAS me sAm£ DIJ£ pWc.ESS r~Vll..c ltrl'l /YtV-7• ...
1
·lfit r.~asr 7TlkiE or_c..ptJ..5 WffEt.f T'lle fJAP.Ot.« fliWI!>AUtJI.Iff. 15 Afltt.STED At-\o O.f17Jrt4EDI p5l/IIAL~~:...A• TNf D.f41C7.Wf.l OF /t:CS PAil.CGe t?Ff;rdQ •. 111c: .sl::Ca)J oault.S wfk;H P4Mt£ rs f(J~JJ1AlLY I!EJtJKE/J, tur:::5 I5 ul'lJtR l&J A{l.fl£5f ~F I'A~<il.ii£ ANI) n . tLM1Jr:;J..fJ\(LY ffE~ttr"t¥;, wfl:a::H !lclA(7Jd.. v.45' Dtf.l/2Ct/e-O t7F,
JA ·me DilLE PF c~--nt:j.(AL p/)j)aivtAtr1 Jt.U:e g~.(b).
(b) ~V£XAfW'-{,
(I) P11£trrtT£!WLY »e:A~«lf• .. . .
(A) !ll ~fflAL u~ A .fJ£./):{p( t:"51A ~TODIJ ~ VJ.O<A~ A Cof.iOfZJJOIJ UF PN:J_~r:ttJH-
0 ll svPfM~A br: n.t<:E"Se. A t17A<;1=STDAI£ J~'}€ tnV51 P~YI]PTLY ct'fiDtX.I A ~~ ftJ Cc.1Eb...it1~J./t ~ 7flf:o.t J:-5 P/li:l}A ~ CM£ fo 6£[r81~ T1fA\ A VUJL.I~;il.( O«.v~ED, .
. (g} Ttl£ lftJPrr.J:; 111V5r (!£ a~o IJ. COO/if IJ.ffJ()T~fJ... o/J... 6.V A SO(f{)Lt /.tl'al.D :Jf.f(> Dnal£ • ~oc C!JJ:.Y11, Plltc, i1(A£ 3'J.(b), T'iK COD( ()y Ci1JfllLri4(.. jJIJI;a.lJI/1!.111 JJJ(T, 42. (5}(bj, t/t.J /IJ:CJLA Tl¢;Ai. tJF (/7I..J Drrrt;JiJ 0 F CVmi FJI7'l Q/flf!..
VT6U'K rrJIP05ED Ui40£tt. 5V{jS£Crfti..:J (a.J oF Tftr3E. SEc:Tit/14 -rn:: D~F£APANr wAY 6£ ARilc-sTt'D Af;\1) Dr!AtNt:O A6 -pQt()tJrD~P ~N SlC::r.LOtJ ~I IJr (NCi. Arn.ICAL,.
iH£:' t>tr~N.Q.ttl.lr ~ G'iliTTttD JfJ A /4EP.t1INC, (P12£LCfi1Ci'41riJ.ff!A!F~ Ctmf.tt:D ro ffl€" 01:-Tt-tlm:CI'{ "~-
.,-r.ou fJ.I '(ff(3 c.wtt.r Qr IV~tl ·rv fJMa;I:D wr-111 iHJ. ADJVL}JZAr.wN oF ~1/J:LT t'?,q 11t':?" &/1.I:4;J:IJAC.
C::i-fAttt::£ .<!. No 4t'I'CAL. 111AV 6€ rfli<EM RJ..t;;Wt ~5 D~~»DJA rtOioJ, tiFr82. At{ I~Ol:~'VOJZArJllJ.( PFALL MoCt'tJJ:J:'~S Tf.CLLVVillf4 A55€SSAI#e-N\ ~F PvNLSI-lmBJT (5e-11Cf.lJPJ4 HOfa.Ji;J(j ('.f~.PJ'}0011J<C:E/htr1T OF Senre«, t:;~lfi:CI¥;. of' CbmmtJJJrr'-1 ~fiPl::Jl..V.£SwJJ, AH-V vEFB!t>A~ Af1116\L <e~r:t:iJVE AS IF rifE AOJll... 01Lit:CT;o ll 6( 4vt:U IfAj} J.J(J( Oft N D[f£J2R.£D I
I~ ()QPu..tD J, ~bL Sell~ ~ 1 ~L6C ·17EA~D Q.EulfW.l, OV€' (JJ2tt:E$ .R.:Ct4/.lr AJ.ID l_f
Uv.Q. P~u v~w~ Tf.J;: ~ ~wtroll. crrE.s,~~sA vs, srnre,s~" $.. J.Ahtld 15q_~ IJPLDX~Cif. _ . TH€ ..WD4c WHC I'R.eSED~O- AI ~.lr1lrrt~ ~li f11(!/I<?N TtJ fJ1tODlK£Eo rt' AOi/VD~_ - #- ~o.-r£)t((;l:?l!£
· P~,A~w"e~€D'
1
tHf 40JVOC,~HC,, D(~f>A14r 4()1l.JY A~O r::it1eDX4-reLY ~61rE:IJtri:J4#X:m !fb (/()) TE:1J V&t(LS tll#r'Cfif:/IIWT w.mltK/f i;t:"v'~ PEFaJDAMr .4Hr 6fr'Bl f(JIJn-y ~ ~€' tlf'"AAD DN TUe' r-sSoc p~ POMI6Urne'cJI At'D S£:ille"HCf:1 ~1'1 VIct.lrTiCN ()F D~ Pfl1X:E:SS PF LAu1 €pAfV*{n:--eD T(f(3' lJJ~.Mrr UNOER J1le' ~ Amt:JJDntffW t'F Tflc lll€r6) 5TAte5 ~IJST:rrolWN hiJO Tf.le' DV~ {.t)Vfl$e cr: t./J47 Ptovrswu lir:: AflficAL 11 scc,f /t) ~F ~~ CDf.lSTXrc.JJ:Ia.J e>F ffl£ ~TAr€'CP ~-
IU:l-4rct At-~o ~ ov~Rr VS1 n-NE, ''-8 s.~ ').d 38Lf1 3S¥, i/tJWr:,KJ:
10I>AY WE" HfLD Tff.ftr U'Ji£U .4 TlliM- at;ttT ~IJOS Tff-41 Ali J1.t£()5c0 I./A~ ebl/1/11~0 ~ 14:f:J£Attb/q AS At.Lt;4to ~y 'f1le ~ilrtt ;tAO AOVUP~ A P/l£110/JSLY DEF€/U.EO FrUIJ:r-A(j tJt: 41)l:{..T T((e: «Nttr Itt£-~ "{ltOJ C<JiiDtN:T A SelbliD PHASE 'tel Otr£R.MN(j P(,JifiL$H#'I~IfT, A~.41,fl~5"(b) aot t>FC#rtYt.(J~ e.LliiHUll $rA-TES 111£ R'lt.a71VI/J(j:
't~F ~Sartell I'FA \lt'C'£.4Wi1 f''F ~dtH7tJ#.rrY $VI'EIJ.V£'S~N~IF rFIH:J/(.H?AL:U-71.1 CiS fJMn-veo 'eJt.AUYt
1fle' "'VfXE #1V~T ~cod-v At40 m~~ me .;v~ E'S -· SIAffll1to1tr DCiaDA-~ rH€ FAJW~ t:F A
n; nH?
DUI)(,e- to U~ A Dati!DAflf t~F ~_tgL£ Cc?JSSeQoE'~ t'~Dt'A. ${)[}SfU'fl:'i:IIJ(b)~"'
RUA!ct HAS ~ 1-k1w1J Tft!"j 1-fe'JlOillr~t£ mAT H£ ~ OEiftefJ tJU; ,~SS PF ~ flY. tt+r'
~ aJollf IJ9CD~rl'{~ Hr:S ~OJV.otrAnlht i'F ~mM()Jf[;rY ~V,_W:~~ ANo~.~tfsJ cJAHfCE:N :YOflt ~eR(!~r.~ ,. ' :· .-·
:rn c.; ll.Oc;ll~ 3, At>vs E cF P.rsCJt£-rwu, -me TU:A-c CCcJttr An,os EO .ITs D.I5CIJ..£nt:?N w
~AL~wiN4 IJ.ELATotL'S _£P"PLoy€A.._ :ro n:sr:rr:y OrJ bEiJALF oF h:f.AroP.. 1 119 TC5{'1:Ff Tf'{Ar liECAral.. WAS AI kblt~ cor OF {l+c Aflli\ tlf{l:S ~$ Tff£ (l.f;ASON A.ElAIO(. !11r5'5£0 0/r.l£: CU-$5 vrcurrf./9 m:s t:oNsrrrvr.wu4L a.:rztllf 7'0 A FArR. AflD rf11tJ~r:r;« TftDfL' THE 771IAc Cc:x:Jtt:r AtW>ED m D:J:sa£0XC~ ·By Tl11/iOSitJ<; Col-lPOI'IaJrs WHTCH Wii'll£ AfiP~m CoN OIT:ti?NS PF HJ:s /}£Ffit(£0 AO.:WDJZ4T:Lof.l P{J.t)6!\Cror...c. rFff 'SEJC (;lffl3l0BJ5 TJ.G«N?eW AND -rf-1£ oti..DEtJ... TO OISPLV AH IS".)( 1 -- te ' 5'1lil-l OIJ A(L ~R Dt.:lt/!IS t1r ~s /J.£5EIJDE/4C£ r11Jil(J5@ 6Y Tr-f£ t1ttE.s:rnr-r-l<; :/O~E tJF nte IS()r:d. JviJrCIAL QISTIUcr (OcJA.:r c.oll::J(Tron:o AH #{llrCifO:.of.( "F TNVI}c.ID ~ AS SCJc~ com- Pb~B<Jr5 ~ TiiDrY'c:-T LAW~tX..lY PIWi11VL4AlE) _Z:f.{ 4lie>WA~CE ~ 1ff(?' AD~/;lrsrrurr:ve/PilOC~- DVIl£ (A p A) I • . .
Rt14fol1. wA-S k.lll.e>M~RiU.Y ACLVSEO OP rA££.t#i [O ~(. lf.J:S THfl:QAPi.V Mf~LE k-Cll41lG wr bf If(( A-SLfA 1 ltturtOtS {jOSS AI 71fJfl fTH1C CA<.LaJ~ j:#FOI1/J1 HEll ff<AT P.Et..A:c~- WAS .Cf{FACf u-~Jii.K.r~ Cof' P( f1K AI£A 1 ~€. . tlS· ···~ . ._,._,-~HtD mJtr rr LDCILQ H4V£ l'>ffJ.l Ai-\ '<1/Jf' _ G4i.£Hl Rn't YiEtAfo( ,.rf.lS'f-tAO C>F l!PCAT'Ii ' . · . p · NT- ' VII1Q- __ fl..E1.ATC?~ E6.WV. Y Aw fiNO (oNfTRfmNt Tile C4Lt •
rF Q.EU-tl~ll. W02E ro 114'-E 6££N Af!<:'il.Del) A PQ.tli•t;_-l'f.fA!-Y J.I~Mt.r~ 6Y 11£l?.~6 .0 F LAw .rtfiS ~o~A~ covto /U~ &i::-N Av.wOEO, lWr we. lrlf.,A(. C/cv/J_T or rHE te?I1I JPDJ:CAC DUntiLT a;vltr Al!t>S£0 ·m Or:9::1LtTJ;f:JiJt A~D VIOLAr6> R£i.Af(;f[S OUE !VJ.tOC.E$5 R:J4111.
Rf:LAif/1Ls emJ~muHUY 'SuPtP. v£SLON srallftl) TFl JvtiF a4Ii1, d.oo:l i QEUATOr<. ~s nt~rusEo CiJ#I ro~fNrs (Jr:: ~PECIAL Ct?JdDJc.'T~~ X Wiin"£ WEEil.E Ncr Yt.T LAwru.Ly PwmvL~A-n=D u#JTIL JVL:--! tSC 'J.QO$, VL~L.At:r~ ttEX POST fACTO LAW)1: « .
CONSTl:?LiTIO~AL LAWA STAIVTE' l'ffAT C/1.:CIJ1:Li4/H£Z£ AN .4c~ _AfJD 5:0rtU(ANCOU$LY Pt2.c 1/rv£5 FO~ fJO#r'-?fftrlffq1 oF TH(/)C Wi-1() WOK rnE 4Ci10A.\ 6EFot2.£ Tr fiAO C..l:~iiY 6CcAmE A Cfl:fi11£j ~PECiF. J A_ ~4w !tfAI+f11PEJ2.~>5T(jl.Y AfJfll.I£S A.EIIJ..oAc.trv£L'0 csP, 1"1-l A wAY THAI Nt4AiTVLLY AfftlT.S.· A Acrl={;IM TifAr wA-S- L€4AL wAft#-! :rr U14$"" CPd?1?1UTEO Pfi. r::#CI.f:A'SIM'q '/f/C:(Jpfolr:J'·- Hr'1Er4r Fe;a P-4-sT C:Orfi)()cr;' J
p rtAY£"12.
Cc.~l-is'LDCQJ'l'lC) ALL rll.Ji-nJSc.$ 1 12.CLAW~ P/l_I.V.S THAI T11T'5 f..fOIJOilJ.V~l.£ Ccvn..l <>ll.AiJ($ l)l..lfO P1Ifl1 flilrt:::F", AS TitZ::S H?I-IOOA6Lt COCJI~T CA~ t:!..LEA'O..L'-1 SEE ME J:5 0~) Of ltflfEF.
I oSwi\LD ~E0/24£ LEC Dt> Ht::ILE: C..£.tLafY TI+Ar A rtt.vt: Aufl UJtl../2./:.Cr c.'CJPY OF 1"1+£ /-?;J!L£<:fpZ14 1-fAS ~EtfJ 50-IT bY V. S , 0.£4VLAi2 MArL A DDIUsSEO To;
rtlt q.oua:r i?F Clttrt1IJ.JAL .4t1J'EALS, Cl.ii!t::. {PfJISE PEAIJSoN SVPR.e.me CO<J!ll 13LD(i. i C(, ; 1. 0 ' I t4SI:. l',iJtt!>o}t 0309 cAr-.n·..tLJ srA. t\()Sf11.1JY, 7-fNIJ
)
. VE~IFICAitcN CJFUN.5WORN. DecLARATION
I L,~ {A .
DefeNdaAJ+ pro se }N fAi 5 Cause .5-fCJtfe -fh<- -FotloLUiNg urude.': pe.Nal.fy a.P pe.rJuryr I QW\ a priJoNer Tl::>c :r fiJO, _tt75:CJ9fl. . Curre~-rlly . iN6ar;~era+ecl iN 7l::JC :r- I b lv n Bt)6fl · · UN if lA/ Far+
Sfoc.NoN leY. aS. / am duly 1ual//;'ed t:INd at.rfhoi'JZ.ed IN· . a II ·re..spec.-f $ -fo Mai:e -lht'~ clec.laral/oN, I Aav-c. /'t:!ad -fh-e. +ort::.g~;~g Doc.umeNI- WQ tT o'f'WA(]OAMU$" aNd de.tt'.lare. -1--Aa-f
r
I have per 5;N(A /::.Now ledge 0 -f -fAe Facfs CoN-It:~,Ned fhe,..e..IN aNd Sa,'d . .f4c..l.s are .frue_ ~:uvd C,orrec-f ...
/7-- -7 .
. £X c. cuTEt:J IN I 'rS/od<";o n TexRs pur.fuerN+ .fo /lrf.
.5ef•• Texas ~ P. R;C~aNJ 13],..oo I ef .
· CJt-~ +h/s ~Q dayof')ep~ 'L .;1.!? U.5C fl'!<t/.1
. ( ..S/gNif ur~) pro 5-t...
UNder' law (J..t?. USC:..f1'7'1b) a1vd Sf(};IL· law bo-1-J.. federAl
(Ar-1-. /32, OQ ( Te.>£aS (P.f,c.,)),'NmQtfS /Nc.tJrCer~kd /N tG'¥aS "'"'Y usi. QN UNSworN de.t:...lara·haN UNder peNal+y 0 -f per.Jury lN . pia c. e o .f a wrt'ffe!V de~:..lo.r-a..floN 5 warN he -h,rc a NofCtr'l ~LAb I.'G.
CERTIFICATE OF SE~VICE
I A>.s i5 fo Cer.f/.f'y .fhaf aN Sep[fUn/!eR,2o-2ot5 a -frue aNd C.arrce-4 C.opy o I -fhe above. aNd . .f/,regol"J.B doc.ume~ul wa,s ma/lu1 fo +It e. C /{!rk o I' -ff, e CoualoL(R'M'nA\ A ppe!+/5 . . , .._~/.1. £u_____
pro .se.
.". ',
., . 5 U:·' NOTICE OF COURT SETTING IN THE DISTRICT COURTS OF TRAVIS COUNTY, TEXAS
FOR CAUSE NO. D-1-GN-13-002287
OSWALD GEORGE LEE
VS.
180TH DISTRICT COURT
- - - ..... -- ·- -· ---·-·-··-- -----···--·--- -·-
THE ABOVE CAUSE WILL BE DISMISSED FOR WANT OF PROSECUTION ON THE COURT'S MOTION ON THE 19th day of December, 2014 AT 1:45 PM IN SAID COURT, UNLESS A MOTION TO RETAIN IS FILED PRIOR TO THAT DATE.
PLEASE READ THE TRAVIS COUNTY LOCAL RULES CHAPTER 8 -- PROCEDURES FOR DISMISSAL FOR WANT OF PROSECUTION
AMALIA RODRIGUEZ-MENDOZA DISTRICT CLERK TRAVIS COUNTY, TEXAS
DATED: 11/4/2014
·, I i t.. . ·. ~ -
CHAPTERS
DISMISSAL FOR WANT OF PROSECUTION BY THE COURT
8.1 Case Selection The following cases are eligible for dismissal for want of prosecution sua sponte by the court (a) cases on file for more than 180 days in which no answer has been filed; (b) cases that have been on file for more than 18 months that are not set for trial and have had no filings or settings within 180 days; (c) any other case designated by the Court.
8.2 Copies to Court Administrator A COPY OF NOTICES, MOTIONS, AND PLEADINGS REQUIRED TO BE FILED BY THIS CHAPTER MUST BE DELIVERED. TO THE COURT ADMINISTRATOR FOR THE CIVIL DISTRICT COURTS.
8.3 Notice & Summary Dismissal if No Motion to Retain The Court Administrator will give notice that certain cases will be dismissed for want of proseeution. Such matters will be dismissed summarily without further proceedings on the dismissal date indicated in the notice of dismissal or thereafter unless at least one party files a motion to retain that complies with the requireme!lts of this chapter.
8.4 pocket Settings No Central Docket settings may be obtained in cases set for dismissal until the dismissal docket process is complete, except with leave of Court.
8.5 Motions to Retain and Objections to Motions to Retain (a) Motions to retain must set forth the factual and legal basis for retaining the case and must be filed at least 14 days prior to the dismissal date specified in the notice of dismissal.
. Page 18
(b) Any objection to a motion to retain must be filed at least 7 days prior to the dismissal date specified in the notice of dismissal.
(c) lf a timely motion to retain is filed and no timely objection is filed, the court may grant the motion or may set it for hearing.
(d)· lf a timely motion to retain and a timely objection are both filed, the court will set the motion to retain for hearing.
8.6 Objection to ADR (a) Parties filing motions to retain must file any objection to ADR simultaneously with a motion to retain.
(b) Parties receiving notice of a moti~n to retain must file any objection to ADR at •.
least 7 days prior to the dismissal date specified in the notice of dismissal.
(c) Objections to referral to ADR, will be taken on submission without hearing.
8.7 No Discovery No further discovery may be conducted in cases retained by the Court and ordered to complete an ADR procedure unless permitted by Court order. Further discovery will not extend the deadlines prescribed in this chapter unless ordered by the Court.
Page 19
.1-Jow c.ome5 05 W!..\LO Gt:oll.G f lE£ HEIUTI-!A Ff£/e fi..EFuMED tO AS fJu.mtr.J:Ffi PL.f\"S:f.lrt:f-'F (JII..E5t'""UI!. 'IHIS l?lCJTI()!-l TO /{E7A:X:A 1 TO nu:::S i-lt>l-f/?fl./4l1.(£ (,OU/2..1 l="N A(WI2..1Jcf..\~t (l _ 1/ M:T(.} o~ <HAPLEI1S fF n-IC rMV.C:S C.OVIJTY LOCAL f{UL£5 OF Crt/a. ·PD!G Af.\0 12..UU;-s OF OECoRo/11,
, .IN n_t.-sf'of<lC.E IO Covr<l o12.d'EQ. PUFE"Ntr FF 5 ifOWS /H:tS HtJIJCI)_ArJL6. (/)Uil.l lftE PoU.Owt:NC':j :
:r. .
.,......, L( ON on.. AtJOVf _3_ DAY oF J U/ '/ ao //.j . PLAr::~n:~F TU-EP A Pet:fr:t:OlJ
m
'5 e-e,,.q,l4 o Ec LA M To 11. v :rv 04 e-r.JT '~ 11-'lf.lxi H ;Jo FAVl.T OF J:s OWN PU~IN.U:t:"F AWATED ivtJ/!.f)
fjWtn n-J+S 1-Joi[0/2.4 f;(£. C.CU'lJ,
:n:.,
8Y THf TIMC T<J mi-CH n:mt. HAIJ B ..ltt>ticl) PLArt-.lri"f:F t=-J:L.EI> A N OF morro OI}Jtct:Lb~ FOG. THE Coutl.TS Net fl1 Oi...II~ ON <;IUD Pt:r:rr:z=o~, Nor UNTU.. P-£L£NILV (tfE HOf.JpfJ. .... _ A~L£ (O#TPCfEO PLArN I..LFF NOTrFIJJC, PLAJJ.J1IFF 1 ntA\ (1-l£" Ar!Jo\J£ CAVSE w.:r:(..L t; E DIStn139::t) FOR. wl%1\ or: PIUJ->t:C.UI:CON t>N TI-t£ 11m DAV o~ D&:.ttf/OCR.,;AOILI,
PLA~t.rrrFF PO..Of11]T( Y FCL-1:1) 111t'TUJ 1<1 rc UJCIIL I ;5rt.\T'C/J() THA~ Tll.AVI5 Covr-tTY LC<:AL R.ULE.s.,·cH~Pit$, wea_e 1-Jt>l ru UfJII L-AW Lr!JIVM. y) LtJC:AL IZGlf..£5 wertE NOr Ofl HOLOC»CiS Lr-5-r SO T.O.C. J" 1-Ai/J L.IIJ(J..AtJ..Y CAf-.\NOISUPPLY ro :t:;.!WATESJ pLAI~IiF A'SK <our:zr IO SvPPLif LOCAL fWl£~ CHA Prt=:P.. 8 41
. li"""., ON JA~vAe.V 5Ld :J.0/5 PLA:rl-ffTFF ({Ea;JZVED .S.A-rD R.LJLt=t!. Ffk;t11 t#E "C..tlvti.f, (J/lrOR.
W t1..eC£'[:Ve:LiJ4 TI-l~£: RDL£G PLMI--IJTFF1 FrL.Ef> tnoT:Wt-l FoR.. EYTcNTLON Or rnne (IJEf{lll.- THE OcAOLif.Jc.,
poAYca.
O()Jr;CWON iO(AO g) A Q;11:ft-tr;5nt4&S.
n·r::~m~:sSAL 12F<OtnEf..f 0 Al'ION.
:rn Tf.JE o:r:~nzrcr OJur1.:rs tJ~17J.AiJIS C.(JVIJ~ /l::Jt'A~
~Ow (J;rtt£5 OS~<,tAl..D C,Eo«;E LGE HfREDJ AFTElL (tt;"'F0i2./1.£p PO As (.:JLAif-lr.IFF, PLArN7TFF Pl1£sEf<iT.:.S 1/f:.J:S mon:c~ oF Olfo~~ -to(ADR.) ~EF£11AAL lo or~m"S"'i rM Acc.oa..v~c w.tTJ-1- (CHAPTEil. e oF ri/£ rllAv.l="S cov~iY LocAl t<.vl£5 oFail.r:L: Prwc.. t:\IJO l!..uL£'5 or: owtJ.om;~ ·-· IJ.J ILE~Po11JC£" TO CHAPTFfJ.. 8; OF TMiiiS CovNrV loCAL IUJL£5 1 (JLAii-ITrFr IJ..E5PE<:..FVLY-
$f.JOW5 UJJTO mt.S' f/b~tl6LE CCJU~T Til£ RJ£{_(}U./lldC, /
I,.
PUt:!.SU/.HS\ TC rtY.4S Gov;r. cof>E lf ~00/d'J8 ;Crl(JC~ 5HOU-6 AFF.:Tf~WZAP:V£ AcT IJY ~ENCf'-.71? A(.>f1Ly rr~ ILULt ro uun A~!J rHtr AflflLJLt!r.r:.o£1 oF?"C.X:t-1 rlvl-£ Wt?C/L-D D!2AmlttlZLY Ar::F-ecrJ' f'LMI<J.lTFF.~ Lt-"ZJA-L /l.L:if..IIS Ai-\0 fJJ2II/r{E~£5; PUU:j;.ffT/¥ H~ mul7.n.\Ci TV cifAtLct4<i~ AfJPLI<A Lr ()rTY oF R..Ut.E :I:IJ DEL.LArt 4TOP..y:.TV!Xjd1CMr 7v~r Llf.WE#tf iJ. or rHt:5 Al[r.L<:..l..e. ~cPeALED 1-1 ow.$. :lt:Jo l , 6 3 8) , \ ]I.,
AS srATEO r:i-1 fJU.rrr!FF~ ffl(lrri:Jf./ ro p_aArtJ n-uwCK;J-1 NO rAV'-' oF nr~ bwfl PLAJ:H'r:ifr HAD /ll.i;i ri)(:A. ~.J,~IJAT wAS Rf&vriLED bi= IIJ:M IN TJ-Il:"6 (ASt PtlOSti:.OTt;IJ,
'·~
PLAnlT~Fr ~-Jevct1.. I!.EC..ffVED A;..iY €:J(Loea.. lo AiJst.-c.l6t wt'ii-J-rf.l 18? DA'·IS.
()(_AJ:;.rf!'f"F Ht1D Nb w4Y To :>ET ct.\<SE RJo_ T~AL Af'TEra. l)ai:J4 FOil.. tJv£/t IB /?ICJIITfiS or< HAD .41-iY r-Wf1X.£ TV F.U.£ A~Y rJJF0/2/JJArro;.j vATI-1-:n.J lBo DAYS. 'f
txAr:.iJT.rFF ~AD NQ rDEA THf C.ovltT Por-l'lrED-ovr T1-ll:5 CASt 1:oll rn:si11C5SAL R
PLA"tl-srrrF tJIILY LEAQ..J..J£0 Of=' t~5 C.AS e wA ~ ai'y:I:'lKE"' FO~ DIS it1£~5.4L FOil. WAU"r oF P~O)t([)T.l'"ON SUA$1l0fJ1T 8Y rf/~ C..O(J{l./,
-~----~·---
Fotl mf" Al30ll€ P1MOt.15 PIANT!:FF ')i1WIJYELV tJ/J.TccTT TO TJ.IE. &;\:0~) ADJ!tiJ:Ii;Tf1Artt2-5'
.orsm:rssA L reo Jlt:w111111 r f. I DA fJ.,.
lo ~-'1\J/-\-MTE Tl-f~H NO F4Vt.r Ot=' HrS t?W.tJ PLA.TAlTIFr -t..vAs· Vt</Ai&£ ro C.OtnfJ(.Y lV.LlJ4 (!1) v ~· {) /1_0£;~ ..
/1 DAY OF ·TitnulfRY ) J f).Of5
{W1L