Leavens v. Butler

8 Port. 380
Supreme Court of Alabama·Decided January 15, 1839·Published·Cited by 15 cases

Opinion

To recapitulate, we are of opinion—

First — That the County court cannot decree distribution of'an estate against the executor where by so doing the testator’s intentions would be defeated.

Second — That in the present case, the decree of the County court, if sustained, would most probably defeat the testator’s intent

[403]*403Third — That a legatee cannot, in all cases, immediately after the expiration of eighteen months from the grant of letters testamentary, coerce a payment of his legacy.

Fourth — That the decree of the County court is erroneous, in assuming jurisdiction over- the lands of the tes tator, without the limits of this State.

Fifth — That a court of chancery,has ample power over the subject of legacies, and in such cases can administer complete justice — and in the present case, that tribunal is peculiarly appropriate for the adjustment of the rights of all interested under the will.

It remains but to add, that the decree of the County court must be reversed, and the cause remanded,

GOLDTI-IWAITE, J., not sitting.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Leavens v. Butler, 8 Port. 380 (Ala. 1839).

8 Port. 380 (Leavens v. Butler) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Kirkbride v. Kelly
52 So. 660 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1910)
Hinson v. Williamson
74 Ala. 180 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1883)
Foxworth v. White
72 Ala. 224 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1882)
Whorton v. Moragne
62 Ala. 201 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1878)
Mitchell v. Nelson
49 Ala. 88 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1873)
Clark v. Hornthal
47 Miss. 434 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1872)
Humes v. Fariss
48 Ala. 615 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1872)
Anderson's Adm'r v. McGowan
45 Ala. 462 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1871)
Griffin v. Bland
43 Ala. 542 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1869)
Crusoe v. Butler
36 Miss. 150 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1858)
Smith's Distributees v. King
22 Ala. 558 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1853)
Watts v. Gayle
20 Ala. 817 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1852)
Reynolds' Adm'rs v. Reynolds' Distributees
11 Ala. 1023 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1847)
Harrison v. Harrison
9 Ala. 470 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1846)
Stallsworth v. Stallsworth
5 Ala. 143 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1843)