Lacson, B. v. Toll Brothers, Pets.

• Court: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
• Decided: April 18, 2023
• Docket: 305 EAL 2022
• Status: Published

Opinion

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA EASTERN DISTRICT

BRETT ADAMS, TAMRA ADAMS, JILL : No. 300 EAL 2022 O'DONNELL, MATTHEW O'DONNELL, : JASON TEPFENHARDT, JESSICA : TEPFENHARDT, JAMES WIEGERS, ANN : Petition for Allowance of Appeal MARIE WIEGERS, BRIAN BENTRIM, JEFF : from the Order of the Superior Court CAMPAGNA, ELIZABETH CAMPAGNA, : CATHERINE BENTRIM, JAMES COY AND : DENISE COY : : : v. : : : TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A., ANDERSEN : WINDOWS, INC., THOMAS E. MANION T/A : MANION CONTRACTORS AND/OR : THOMAS E. MANION, MICHAEL : ANTOLINO CONSTRUCTION, INC., RSB : CONSTRUCTION CO., MACK DONOHOE : CONTRACTORS, INC., ELK : CONSTRUCTION, PETR JACH T/A BRICK : FRONTS, .L.C., EXTERIOR OPTIONS, INC. : : : PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

JAMES COOKE AND TRACY COOKE : No. 301 EAL 2022 : : v. : Petition for Allowance of Appeal : from the Order of the Superior Court : TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, VI L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. : : : v. : : : ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., NEW : MILLENNIUM CONTRACTING CORP., : MACK DONOHOE CONTRACTORS, INC., : MAR JOHN MASONRY, INC., CONNOLLY : STUCCO AND PLASTERING : : : PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA, VI, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

JAMES COY AND DENISE COY : No. 302 EAL 2022 : : v. : Petition for Allowance of Appeal : from the Order of the Superior Court : TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. : : : v. : : : ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., MICHAEL : ANTOLINO CONSTRUCTION, INC., RSB : CONSTRUCTION, EXTERIOR OPTIONS, : INC D/B/A EXTERIOR WALL, INC., FRANK : BADOLATO, AQUARIUS SIDING : : : PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

THOMAS DEANGELO AND CAGLAYAN : No. 303 EAL 2022 DEANGELO : : : Petition for Allowance of Appeal v. : from the Order of the Superior Court

[300 EAL 2022, 301 EAL 2022, 302 EAL 2022, 303 EAL 2022, 304 EAL 2022, 305 EAL 2022, 306 EAL 2022, 307 EAL 2022 and 308 EAL 2022] - 2 : : TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, II, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. : : : v. : : : ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., MS : BUILDERS, INC., M A CARDY : CONSTRUCTION, INC., DOMINIC C. : DEFRANGESCO, MACK DONOHOE : CONTRACTORS, INC. : : : PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA II, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

TODD ELLIOTT AND JUDITH ELLIOTT : No. 304 EAL 2022 : : v. : Petition for Allowance of Appeal : from the Order of the Superior Court : TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, II, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. : : : v. : : : ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., MACK : DONOHOE CONTRACTORS, INC., M.A. : CARDY CONSTRUCTION, INC. : : : PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA II, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

[300 EAL 2022, 301 EAL 2022, 302 EAL 2022, 303 EAL 2022, 304 EAL 2022, 305 EAL 2022, 306 EAL 2022, 307 EAL 2022 and 308 EAL 2022] - 3 BENJAMIN LACSON AND EVELYN : No. 305 EAL 2022 LACSON : : : Petition for Allowance of Appeal v. : from the Order of the Superior Court : : TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. : : : v. : : : ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., THOMAS E. : MANION T/A MANION CONTRACTORS : AND/OR THOMAS E. MANION A/K/A : MANION, RSB CONSTRUCTION CO., : EXTERIOR WALLS, INC., MACK : DONOHOE CONTRACTORS INC., ELK : CONSTRUCTION, INC. : : : PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

MICHAEL MILEY AND JENNIFER MILEY : No. 306 EAL 2022 : : v. : Petition for Allowance of Appeal : from the Order of the Superior Court : TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA II, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. : : : v. : : : : :

[300 EAL 2022, 301 EAL 2022, 302 EAL 2022, 303 EAL 2022, 304 EAL 2022, 305 EAL 2022, 306 EAL 2022, 307 EAL 2022 and 308 EAL 2022] - 4 ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., NEW : MILLENNIUM CONTRACTORS, MACK : DONOHOE CONTRACTORS, INC. : : : PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA II, L.P. AND TOLL PA GP CORP.

FURRUKH MUNAWAR AND AAIYSHA : No. 307 EAL 2022 MUNAWAR : : : Petition for Allowance of Appeal v. : from the Order of the Superior Court : : TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA II, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. : : : v. : : : ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., MACK- : DONOHOE CONTRACTORS, INC., : MILLENNIUM CONTRACTING : CORPORATION : : : PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA II, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

DANIEL PORTER AND CAROLYN : No. 308 EAL 2022 PORTER : : : Petition for Allowance of Appeal v. : from the Order of the Superior Court : : TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA II, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. :

[300 EAL 2022, 301 EAL 2022, 302 EAL 2022, 303 EAL 2022, 304 EAL 2022, 305 EAL 2022, 306 EAL 2022, 307 EAL 2022 and 308 EAL 2022] - 5 : : v. : : : ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., DOMINIC C. : DEFRANGESCO, MACK DONOHOE : CONTRACTORS, INC. : : : PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA II, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

ORDER

PER CURIAM

AND NOW, this 18th day of April, 2023, the Petition for Allowance of Appeal is

DENIED.

[300 EAL 2022, 301 EAL 2022, 302 EAL 2022, 303 EAL 2022, 304 EAL 2022, 305 EAL 2022, 306 EAL 2022, 307 EAL 2022 and 308 EAL 2022] - 6