Kraaz v. La Quinta Motor Inns, Inc.

396 So. 2d 455, 1981 La. App. LEXIS 3669
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedMarch 10, 1981
Docket11693
StatusPublished
Cited by4 cases

This text of 396 So. 2d 455 (Kraaz v. La Quinta Motor Inns, Inc.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Kraaz v. La Quinta Motor Inns, Inc., 396 So. 2d 455, 1981 La. App. LEXIS 3669 (La. Ct. App. 1981).

Opinion

396 So.2d 455 (1981)

Larry KRAAZ and Joyce Kraaz
v.
LA QUINTA MOTOR INNS, INC.

No. 11693.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Fourth Circuit.

March 10, 1981.

*456 Barnett & Vedros, Ralph L. Barnett and George P. Vedros, Gretna, for plaintiffs-appellees.

Phelps, Dunbar, Marks, Claverie & Sims, Jesse R. Adams, Jr. and John C. L. Guyer, New Orleans, for defendant-appellant.

Before SAMUEL, CHEHARDY and KLIEBERT, JJ.

CHEHARDY, Judge.

Defendant, La Quinta Motor Inns, Inc. (La Quinta), appeals a district court judgment in favor of the plaintiff Mrs. Joyce Kraaz in the following sums: $3,500 for physical pain and suffering, $13,000 for future psychological and psychiatric treatment, and $30,000 for past and future mental pain and suffering; and in favor of plaintiff Larry Kraaz for physical and mental pain and suffering in the amount of $2,500. The district court order further granted judgment in favor of Mr. and Mrs. Kraaz for property loss in the amount of $23,000, including legal interest from the date of judicial demand and for all costs of the proceedings.

The record reveals that on or about December 31, 1978 the plaintiffs, who were registered guests at the La Quinta motel in Metairie, Louisiana, were robbed of approximately $23,000 in cash by two robbers who broke into their motel room during the early hours of the morning while they were asleep.

Mr. and Mrs. Kraaz both testified they heard a close catching sound which was followed by their door opening and the chain breaking away. Mr. Kraaz testified that one of the intruders jumped on him and forced his head down into the carpet with a gun, while shouting obscenities, causing a laceration to the back of his neck, and severely obstructing his ability to breathe. He testified the gunman drew back the hammer of the gun and released it, while demanding the money and threatening to kill him. The other assailant took Mrs. Kraaz into the bathroom, put her into the bathtub and gagged her. The plaintiffs were then bound hand and foot, and after the robbers ascertained the location of Mrs. Kraaz's purse and abstracted the money, they fled the room. Mr. Kraaz then got free of his ties and gave chase, but could not locate the assailants, who escaped. As a result of the incident, Mrs. Kraaz suffered a laceration of her lip and an extensive bruise on her hip.

*457 The Kraazes testified that earlier the preceding day Mr. Kraaz picked up his wife at the airport in New Orleans where she had flown for the purpose of bringing him $25,000 in cash for the possible purchase of a racehorse. They then, after stopping for a cup of coffee, proceeded to the Fair Grounds where they had lunch, watched the races, and engaged in betting. At one point during the luncheon Mrs. Kraaz extracted approximately $1,500 from the roll of $25,000 in cash (which she was carrying in a brown paper bag in her purse) in order to pay Thomas Tomillo, a horse trainer for the plaintiffs. Both Tomillo and Mr. Kraaz testified that racehorses frequently are bought and sold through cash transactions rather than by check or by means of the racetrack registry.

Several days after the robbery and assault, Mrs. Kraaz consulted Dr. Terry Passman, a psychiatrist, regarding her emotional upset and sleeplessness, who administered a tranquilizer and then sent her to East Jefferson General Hospital for stronger medication. After seeing her on a number of subsequent occasions his diagnosis was acute traumatic neurosis, evidenced by problems with sleeping (requiring the use of sleeping pills), inability to enjoy sexual relations with her husband, and fear of staying in motel or hotel rooms, in which plaintiffs had previously resided for the greater part of the year due to their travels as racehorse owners. Dr. Passman recommended at the time of trial that Mrs. Kraaz get future psychiatric treatment and estimated the length of time necessary for carrying out the therapy to be at least two years, at the rate of two or three sessions per week. He estimated costs, based on his own fees, at approximately $65 per session.

W. L. Quattlebaum, Jr., a resident of Pine Bluff, Arkansas, and also an owner of racehorses, testified that he knew both Mr. and Mrs. Kraaz and that he, himself, was a registered guest at the La Quinta in December of 1978. He described an unsuccessful attempt by someone using a ski mask to gain entrance to his room by identifying himself as the manager of the motel. Although he called the front desk, where an individual volunteered to call the police for him, no law enforcement authorities ever came to his room. Quattlebaum further stated that several days later he was called to the office of the manager, Mr. Croucher, to discuss the attempted robbery and at that time learned of the assault of the Kraazes; Croucher, however, denied having ever spoken to Quattlebaum, but said he had only heard rumors of another incident through the desk clerks.

Articles 2964 through 2971 of the Louisiana Civil Code address themselves to the responsibility of the innkeeper. We should particularly note the following provisions, applicable to the present case:

"He is responsible if any of the effects be stolen or damaged, either by his servants or agents, or by strangers going and coming in the inn." Art. 2967.
"Every landlord or keeper of a public inn or hotel, shall be required to provide with an iron chest or other safe deposit for valuable articles belonging to his guests or customers, and each landlord or hotel keeper shall keep posted upon his doors and other public places in his house of entertainment, written or printed notices to his guests and customers that they must leave their valuables with the landlord, his agent or clerk, for safe keeping, that he may make safe deposit of the same in the place provided for that purpose." Art. 2968.
"Every landlord, hotel or inn keeper who shall comply with the requirements of the preceding articles [article], shall not be liable for any money, jewelry, watches, plate, or other things made of gold or silver, or of rare and precious stones, or for other valuable articles of such description as may be contained in small compass, which may be abstracted or lost from any such public inn or hotel, if the same shall not be left with the landlord, his clerk or agent, for deposit, unless such loss shall occur through the fraud or negligence of the landlord, or some clerk or servant employed by him in such inn or hotel; provided, however, that the provisions of this article shall not *458 apply to a wearing watch, or such other articles of jewelry as are ordinarily worn about the person." Art. 2969.
"He is not responsible for what is stolen by force and arms, or with exterior breaking open of doors, or by any other extra-ordinary violence." Art. 2970.
"No landlord or innkeeper shall be liable under the provisions of the foregoing six articles to any guests or party of guests occupying the same apartments for any loss sustained by such guests or party of guests by theft or otherwise, in any sum exceeding one hundred dollars, unless by special agreement in writing with the proprietor, manager or lessee of the hotel or inn a greater liability has been has been contracted for.
"Provided that no guest shall be held bound by the limitation of value established in this Article unless this Article is conspicuously posted in the guest room." Art. 2971.

Nordmann v. National Hotel Company,

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Kling v. Collins
407 So. 2d 478 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1981)
Durandy v. Fairmont Roosevelt Hotel, Inc.
523 F. Supp. 1382 (E.D. Louisiana, 1981)
Kraaz v. La Quinta Motor Inns, Inc.
401 So. 2d 992 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1981)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
396 So. 2d 455, 1981 La. App. LEXIS 3669, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/kraaz-v-la-quinta-motor-inns-inc-lactapp-1981.