Kara McCulloch DMD MSD PLLC v. Valley Forge Insurance Company

W.D. Washington

Kara McCulloch DMD MSD PLLC v. Valley Forge Insurance Company

District Court, W.D. Washington·Decided November 10, 2020·No. 2:20-cv-00809·Unknown

Opinion

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF WASHINGTON ) KARA MCCULLOCH DMD MSD PLLC, ) et al, ) CASE NO. 2:20-cv-00809-BJR ) Plaintiffs, ) ORDER ON CONSOLIDATION ) v. ) ) COMPANY, et al, ) ) Defendants. ) On November 11, 2020, the Court conducted a case management conference to discuss possible consolidation of this and other like matters involving claims for business insurance coverage resulting from the COVID 19 pandemic. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 42(a) permits courts to consolidate “[i]f actions before the court involve a common question of law or fact.” FED. R. CIV. P. 42(a). This rule affords “broad discretion” to consolidate cases pending in the same district, either upon motion by a party or sua sponte. In re Adams Apple, Inc., 829 F.2d 1484, 1487 (9th Cir. 1987). Courts consider a number of factors in analyzing the appropriateness of consolidation, including judicial economy, whether consolidation would expedite resolution of the case, whether separate cases may yield inconsistent results, and the potential prejudice to a party 1 opposing consolidation. See 8 Moore’s Federal Practice—Civil § 42.10[4-5] (2020). Based on the case management conference and the agreement of the parties, the Court concludes that consolidation according to insurance group will best serve judicial economy in resolving the common issues presented by these cases. As such, the Court hereby ORDERS that the cases involving the insurance groups under CNA Financial Corporation be consolidated. These cases include Kara McCulloch DMD MSD PLLC vy. Valley Forge Insurance Co. (20-cv-809); Noskenda Inc vy. Valley Forge Insurance Company (20-cv-854); Jae Y. Hong DDS PS v. Valley

Forge Insurance Company (20-cv-891); and Jae Y Hong PLLC et al v. Transportation Insurance

Company (20-cv-5556), which shall be consolidated under case number 20-cv-809 as the first filed case. The Clerk of the Court is hereby notified of this consolidation. DATED this 10th day of November, 2020. fitue dr Aten, BARBARA J. ROTHSTEIN UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF WASHINGTON ) KARA MCCULLOCH DMD MSD PLLC, ) et al, ) CASE NO. 2:20-cv-00809-BJR ) Plaintiffs, ) ORDER ON CONSOLIDATION ) v. ) ) COMPANY, et al, ) ) Defendants. ) On November 11, 2020, the Court conducted a case management conference to discuss possible consolidation of this and other like matters involving claims for business insurance coverage resulting from the COVID 19 pandemic. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 42(a) permits courts to consolidate “[i]f actions before the court involve a common question of law or fact.” FED. R. CIV. P. 42(a). This rule affords “broad discretion” to consolidate cases pending in the same district, either upon motion by a party or sua sponte. In re Adams Apple, Inc., 829 F.2d 1484, 1487 (9th Cir. 1987). Courts consider a number of factors in analyzing the appropriateness of consolidation, including judicial economy, whether consolidation would expedite resolution of the case, whether separate cases may yield inconsistent results, and the potential prejudice to a party 1 opposing consolidation. See 8 Moore’s Federal Practice—Civil § 42.10[4-5] (2020). Based on the case management conference and the agreement of the parties, the Court concludes that consolidation according to insurance group will best serve judicial economy in resolving the common issues presented by these cases. As such, the Court hereby ORDERS that the cases involving the insurance groups under CNA Financial Corporation be consolidated. These cases include Kara McCulloch DMD MSD PLLC vy. Valley Forge Insurance Co. (20-cv-809); Noskenda Inc vy. Valley Forge Insurance Company (20-cv-854); Jae Y. Hong DDS PS v. Valley

Forge Insurance Company (20-cv-891); and Jae Y Hong PLLC et al v. Transportation Insurance

Company (20-cv-5556), which shall be consolidated under case number 20-cv-809 as the first filed case. The Clerk of the Court is hereby notified of this consolidation. DATED this 10th day of November, 2020. fitue dr Aten, BARBARA J. ROTHSTEIN UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

Kara McCulloch DMD MSD PLLC v. Valley Forge Insurance Company, (W.D. Wash. 2020).

Pincite

Kara McCulloch DMD MSD PLLC v. Valley Forge Insurance Company (Kara McCulloch DMD MSD PLLC v. Valley Forge Insurance Company) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

In Re Adams Apple, Inc., Debtor. Robert C. Burchinal, Donald G. Ott, Meton G. Raine, Karen O. Raine, John Ruud, Richard H. Mason, Phyllis Mason, Richard Floren, Rachel Floren, Kenneth R. Irwin, Sharon Irwin, Richard J. Willsey and Cheri Ann Willsey, Plaintiffs v. Central Washington Bank, Bank of California v. Central Washington Bank

829 F.2d 1484 (Ninth Circuit, 1987)

Opinion

Related