Jordan v. Merten

Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976)

Jordan v. Merten

216 S.W.2d 906, 309 Ky. 105, 1949 Ky. LEXIS 643

CourtCourt of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976)

DecidedJanuary 11, 1949

StatusPublished

Cited by3 cases

This text of 216 S.W.2d 906 (Jordan v. Merten) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Jordan v. Merten, 216 S.W.2d 906, 309 Ky. 105, 1949 Ky. LEXIS 643 (Ky. 1949).

Pincite

Opinion

Opinion of the Court by

Chief Justice Sims

Dismissing appeal.

*106 William G. Jordan and wife sued William J. Merten, doing business as Merten Realty Company, and I. W. G-erstle to recover $315 paid them as a broker’s fee ■on a sale of real estate, which sale the plaintiffs aver was never consummated. The petition alleges plaintiffs owed defendants a commission of $50 on the deal and asked judgment for $315, credited by the $50, or $265.

The answer denied that the sale was never consummated, and by way of counterclaim defendants averred plaintiffs owed them a commission of $525, to be credited by $315 already paid them, and asked judgment for $210.

By agreement the case was submitted to the court without a jury. After hearing proof he gave judgment in favor of defendants for $525. Plaintiffs excepted to the order overruling their motion for a new trial and prayed an appeal to this court, which was granted by the Jefferson circuit court.

Under KRS 21.060 and 21.080 an appeal from a money judgment for as much as $200, exclusive of interest and costs, but less than $500, can be granted only by this court upon a motion made here. Lower v. Lower, 260 Ky. 729, 86 S. W. 2d 682; Title Insurance & Trust Co. v. Cole, 277 Ky. 512, 126 S. W. 2d 1097. Here, the amount of commission claimed by defendants was $525, but plaintiffs admit they owed defendants $50, hence the amount in controversy was $475; therefore, the trial court was without jurisdiction to grant the appeal. The fact that the trial court gave defendants judgment on their counterolaim of $525 did not make the amount in controversy that sum, since plaintiffs admitted owing defendants $50.

No motion was made to dismiss the appeal nor was the question of the amount involved raised in briefs. However, we are compelled to raise it ourselves as it is one of jurisdiction and cannot be waived. Stephens v. Davis, 286 Ky. 608, 151 S. W. 2d 384.

For the reasons given the appeal is dismissed.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Opinion of the Court by

Chief Justice Sims

Dismissing appeal.

*106 William G. Jordan and wife sued William J. Merten, doing business as Merten Realty Company, and I. W. G-erstle to recover $315 paid them as a broker’s fee ■on a sale of real estate, which sale the plaintiffs aver was never consummated. The petition alleges plaintiffs owed defendants a commission of $50 on the deal and asked judgment for $315, credited by the $50, or $265.

The answer denied that the sale was never consummated, and by way of counterclaim defendants averred plaintiffs owed them a commission of $525, to be credited by $315 already paid them, and asked judgment for $210.

By agreement the case was submitted to the court without a jury. After hearing proof he gave judgment in favor of defendants for $525. Plaintiffs excepted to the order overruling their motion for a new trial and prayed an appeal to this court, which was granted by the Jefferson circuit court.

Under KRS 21.060 and 21.080 an appeal from a money judgment for as much as $200, exclusive of interest and costs, but less than $500, can be granted only by this court upon a motion made here. Lower v. Lower, 260 Ky. 729, 86 S. W. 2d 682; Title Insurance & Trust Co. v. Cole, 277 Ky. 512, 126 S. W. 2d 1097. Here, the amount of commission claimed by defendants was $525, but plaintiffs admit they owed defendants $50, hence the amount in controversy was $475; therefore, the trial court was without jurisdiction to grant the appeal. The fact that the trial court gave defendants judgment on their counterolaim of $525 did not make the amount in controversy that sum, since plaintiffs admitted owing defendants $50.

No motion was made to dismiss the appeal nor was the question of the amount involved raised in briefs. However, we are compelled to raise it ourselves as it is one of jurisdiction and cannot be waived. Stephens v. Davis, 286 Ky. 608, 151 S. W. 2d 384.

For the reasons given the appeal is dismissed.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

216 S.W.2d 906, 309 Ky. 105, 1949 Ky. LEXIS 643, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/jordan-v-merten-kyctapphigh-1949.

Opinion

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack