Jones v. Shrigley

33 N.W.2d 510, 150 Neb. 137, 1948 Neb. LEXIS 115
CourtNebraska Supreme Court
DecidedAugust 6, 1948
DocketNo. 32385
StatusPublished
Cited by8 cases

This text of 33 N.W.2d 510 (Jones v. Shrigley) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Nebraska Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Jones v. Shrigley, 33 N.W.2d 510, 150 Neb. 137, 1948 Neb. LEXIS 115 (Neb. 1948).

Opinion

Yeager, J.

In order that the matters in controversy and the issues involved herein may be comprehended a detailed history [139]*139of the incidents and events leading up to them becomes necessary.-

Emily J. W. Spencer^ at the time of her death was a resident of Boston, Massachusetts. She died testate and at the time of her death she was the owner of certain lands in York County, Nebraska. Her will was probated in Massachusetts and later in York County, Nebraska. With regard to the York County land the will contained the following provision:

“I give any and all real estate in York County, Nebraska, to which I may be entitled at the time of my death or which I may have power to dispose of by will to my sister Clara I. Jones and her son Edson T. Jones in equal shares as joint tenants and not as tenants in common, but in trust, nevertheless, to permit said Clara I. Jones and Edson T. Jones each to use and occupy during their respective lives one undivided half of said real estate. Upon the death of either beneficiary, the surviving trustee shall permit the half theretofore used and occupied by that beneficiary to be used and occupied until the termination of the trust as hereinafter provided by such person or persons as he or she may by will appoint, or in default of such appointment to be used and occupied by the heirs of the deceased beneficiary. Upon the death of the survivor of said Clara I. Jones and Edson T. Jones, the trust shall terminate and the legal title as to one undivided half - interest in the premises shall vest in such person or persons as said Clara I. Jones shall by will appoint and as to the other undivided half interest in such person or persons as said Edson T. Jones shall by will appoint, or, if the power of appointment as to either half interest be not exercised, that half interest shall vest in the heirs of the person failing to appoint that interest. I direct that so long as the trust shall continue no part of the premises shall be sold without the consent of said Clara I. Jones and Edson T. Jones or the survivor of them.”

The defendant J. E. Shrigley was duly appointed ad[140]*140ministrator with the will annexed by the county court of York County, Nebraska. On June 21, 1944, a final decree was entered. On the same day the county court by decree upon the petition of Clara I. Jones and Edson T. Jones appointed the said J. E. Shrigley trustee of the York County lands and of the crops and income which had come into being and had accumulated after the death of Emily J. W. Spencer.

Shrigley under this appointment continued in charge of the lands and made his accounting in accordance with the terms of the appointment without interference until the commencement of this action. The regularity of his acts under the terms of the appointment- is not brought into question.

The action here as originally commenced was by Clara I. Jones and Edson T. Jones, plaintiffs,, against J. E. Shrigley, Trustee under the Last Will and Testament of Emily J. W. Spencer, deceased, defendant, and the prayer was for a decree constrúing the last will and testament of Emily J. W. Spencer, deceased, as to the York County real estate and in construing it to declare and confirm in Clara I. Jones and Edson T. Jones a vested fee simple title thereto either as tenants in common or as joint tenants with right of alienation and to thus quiet title in them; for a declaration that the appointment of J. E. Shrigley as trustee was ultra vires and void; and for an injunction enjoining J. E. Shrigley from further interference with the rights of plaintiffs with regard to the land. The case was not finally tried alone on the issues thus tendered.

A contract was entered into for the sale of the lands to one Helen Krenz by Clara I. Jones and Edson T. Jones.

By amended petition Mildred Wade Jones, wife of Edson T. Jones, was made additional party plaintiff and Helen Krenz and Marcia Ann Jones, a minor daughter of Edson T. Jones, were made additional parties defendant.

[141]*141The prayer of the original petition was substantially renewed in the amended petition. In addition the plaintiff prayed that Helen Krenz be required to specifically perform her contract to purchase the real estate. Also plaintiffs prayed for an accounting of the rents, profits, and income of the real estate by J. E. Shrigley.

By appropriate pleadings there was a joinder of the issues tendered by the plaintiffs.

Following trial a decree was rendered by the court declaring a fee simple title absolute in Clara I. Jones and Edson T. Jones and title was quieted in them with full right to sell and convey the said land subject only to the rights of Helen Krenz, the holder of the contract of purchase. Specific performance of the contract of purchase by Helen Krenz was décreed. It was further decreed that J. E. Shrigley, as trustee of the last will and testament of Emily J. W. Spencer, deceased, and individually, forthwith make an account of the rents, profits, and income of the real estate involved. It was decreed in this connection that if an accounting could not be amicably agreed upon that supplemental issues involving that question be framed and that the question be reserved for future hearing and determination. The defendant Shrigley was also enjoined and restrained from interference with the use of the land and from any effort to prevent a sale thereof.

From this decree the defendant J. E. Shrigley has appealed.

The assignments of error urged as grounds for reversal are: (1) The trial court, erred in finding that it was not the intent of testatrix Emily J. W. Spencer, by paragraph 1 of her last will and testament, to create a trust in and to the real estate involved herein; (2) the trial court erred in finding that the testatrix intended that the plaintiffs Clara I. Jones and Edson T. Jones should be vested with absolute fee simple title in and to the real estate; (3) the trial court erred in finding that no remainder estate in the heirs of Clara I. Jones and [142]*142Edson T. Jones was created by the last will and testament of the deceased; (4) the trial court erred in finding that the proceedings in the county court of York County, Nebraska, were not res judicata of the issues in this case; and (5) the court erred in ordering specific performance of the contract of sale between plaintiffs and Helen Krenz.

A determination of the first, second, .third, and fifth assignments of error is dependent upon the kind, character, and quality of estate or estates devised by the quoted provision of the will of Emily J. W. Spencer, hence it shall not be necessary hereinafter to refer to or to treat of these assignments separately.

The fourth assignment deals with the question of whether or not the decree of the county court of York County, Nebraska, appointing J. E. Shrigley trustee of these lands was such an adjudication as would bar the district court from considering and determining the question of whether or not Emily J. W. Spencer by her will declared a valid trust and whether or not these lands were the subject of the trust so declared.

The legal questions involved in this assignment have by the previous decisions of this court been resolved against the contention of the appellant herein. We think those decisions are fundamentally sound and that there should be no departure from them in this case.

In Merrill v. Pardun, 125 Neb. 701, 251 N. W.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

McDonald v. Shaughnessy
231 N.W.2d 332 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1975)
Cahill v. Armatys
177 N.W.2d 277 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1970)
Applegate v. Brown
95 N.W.2d 341 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1959)
In Re Crane's Estate
89 N.W.2d 44 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1958)
Turner v. Mitchell
297 S.W.2d 458 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1956)
De Witt v. Sampson
64 N.W.2d 352 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1954)
Omaha National Bank v. Dennis
37 N.W.2d 228 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1949)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
33 N.W.2d 510, 150 Neb. 137, 1948 Neb. LEXIS 115, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/jones-v-shrigley-neb-1948.