John E. Rodarte v. Beneficial Texas, Inc.

Procedural entryThis page is a short order in John E. Rodarte v. Beneficial Texas, Inc.. Read the opinion of the Court — 2015 Tex. App. LEXIS 12448
Court of Appeals of Texas·Decided November 6, 2015·No. 04-15-00647-CV·Published

Opinion

Aept:^/, ' DDL 7 - 6i/ ~Ti^Ul,Nc>. 2.0to- /^iy> ,~fc>r}s ,/ _F^CtlC-l^_ A' RO^A^Tl Ct^CCl,i£c^ e. -40HN c. /^oo>^€7"€ Arru/^r/Tx. us ^ 0£A/£A/a4}^yZjr^^ Z>v^v 7rs Aa/O /i^stc.A/Sr /4rf€f/££s^ fnoK. y^t -Zluotci«L A^ict/uct Ahurrr/SSicxsfL ^uturyTTrk^ 7/^MC^(YieT A2>' zoiv-cx' /^s'^y HonvmUl J^Iic-h^lc. /^l£/?yy ^tc/fAA^o /^/s/c£ 0^S£i»/CiiAiC

Arrmj\Nr*^

^)^^AiftC'Am^trr F^c/mrTicX)

-=7bfiNi 'f^rf^somrTti>r/^ seu^ I2ic3£7z> U^rr H^( sra/t s^l AM»e.H/o/T&M 7f/P7-96'OL.

V v/ V ' ^ \ - -1 > - •• V.-• . I• li -t •.••'I •

•i \ •\ . > \.C "v -•»i\'s '>; V-

. c ^ • * ,. • * ^*.-(7 7 • S

A O . \'/V>v r-. Wi •-

'. -V .'V' -V

:>' .r.\ j.v\v , v;i v •- c^; .-b''^v r •v ,' \ <.b-\

; — v \'V •, \ '> > •>» • ' , i ^• .• \ , . • Vv '. . -•'• "• \ \ '^N- \ - -.. •: - f ^ . ^,r . ,J ^ - \ \ • , U . • < . . . e-v 'V. ., ', :.\ \ ../ur

^ i- '.-'v ' • V •- \ -S ' \ \

• ..-•• - V •\ '•'i \

•5.C ^ v-\V; '"\.x3.'^ XVvC i;,j \ \->/\ r.V » 's \ i Ti . N \

N • »• . r . *. ' - >

W",-. \

^'O ^ \ ~^OZ.HTiliu C>F f^^-TfcS AA/O ^UAt^^C— tml^m'rr to T^-khs ^uUs Of /^fiPcmr^ /^a^oggvu^,r<^ 3Ty/Ai, ApPCrlAAiTo % Prpi.iiit£S, t -^VtiN n. ^fci£vlie72 5£.cm^t!^ hs^c A4ofsr^i(^c SAn/J^j J5>At(/c. T^u^t N'A., A^ TAu^^e f=t)R. L%fr2 TpA c. ano APPclAy^ ^ms£ TP^it ippj/t?v T/^u ST •^om i. RottAQTiSp.^ -Tn^ -^e Nm% As Of Mapch ^ Hizo)^ t o c t a /zo^zro tAs. TTzosr f,'c£k? a/clo 4i ^£ce?/ Sam Autv^/w/Tfm 7S'z^2^ Yzjo\ Mfo -//F AS?AiZls Af^o STAu^Z/iASFi/P^C. . YHoftf 3>Fm JYousrpp/ rAfiFu^AV £t{£T,< a In. a^sv tpu^toj^/Yyo(oo Tz^O fzs'-'sz/o

Tl&M.i Hm. 7>jftT oM -TuG/ Ih zoor W/v<; August zp, zoij ^ -TucFc RictHifioY'^fct OzMiiO fAAiMTFp^J AAfipHjjse^ tpzteppocxztop/ t:a/ A ^ Jk £ * A ^ M lA ^ ^ iCyV ^ Mt jF \F ^ ^ M

I ££\iwnri J — / y c _ ^ C>7- / ict: ^ i^/i.ht!:ili2Cs.A-'(3YA)h^/£\

Tz> AP/tz^fazT^OA^tsSk^H/zo P^Z^FA-rnniv/J.^iCH 2=bi>^ /js sPmf^z^ IjUt JO TFt PPF^i^LB d:>F /1 fnZ S'Mce OY/iv Z0J3 O9'/z&/Z0}3 F^^H2/iF^FF'ZoMn Aso^uflfUMTYjocr/HiUfj T^ziAy F'ims "SO TOFT rZu,iX FOF C2PZ-OF-7tQf.yC2J^Z^cOjZ0ocTP^(i/FL Of / t^T/yfTtSyt/' ^,^/yy7Fei.^P FsroppeiMZZssuc mjy z. J1> '.i. v;i.\;v O" V:-N ••. r-^^^WxS., --i^y JIjA* • ',, T% ..

Vi V\ -y y ; N ^V^ . -W

\ . • >' • ' . ^W ' ., ""•: - •• •- \\yi '• - ! V- 'V.'.* " •'" s •;' •. \ ^V - iTvv V- '. ^•>- - \ ^-• r- -VV -r * >, v'.,^.-.'\ A .X,AA ;Aky • .X v-v. A • — *•% VV :^\_\. ^\-i'';• \'^'. .. r^ •. "- , '•y\ . .• •, SsH • a •> . ^ •;\ .:: v\V V \ Xh ^ • ' ••-• • •. .-.y -''t C>\ .' : .;j=. •- ; .-X i . A ^ • • X ••••.v.>-..:< j,^ %•; •• y i' j-v Xi A - X.A V' ijii'. yy '"S. "i

• I , /. _X'. ' i. \ CiS: "-= v A . .1vn3s^ Vs^. : \ "= v ", . (-v-- \x\ •••: •.. .^Avsix^-Vs^ .'A L-> \ .%c\ — \ \ XS-\\ „S5"a:X'^ • •:• A.j;• ;-S V- -A • - 'usva'AA .>a'\ '•• A.:. -i^A • AA?5v',(\\i\Ks*X: ^ ;• r ••••'. •/• '•' A V»'•'• Av AV Avi vX rXA ••. V i> k X .vV.» 0-:^QKA. /i'AXA'Av.- ' • "« '. r \..-::. -• :.\'

••-.VyjxXci\,^ s X/A-2/-A''••roV.,"..'i: ;^ ,'^X .^- v-/'' '.^I'.v •.•'V-;v. .\ \>V!~ \v:. Arr VsZv. A^A^-'-^ •* ' v ..v v \ '/ v- A3^A \ ,;\ AC; .Y^v--Vi-.:\ ,VV r;<^ \'>s. CY: • :A Vi n -V'""-; Y'- • ••^.• .. 'xA vV''--AJ\ 3A-;A\ ".V"aA> AAaa >v.^ >. y.A: ; A'aA VA/'X 'yA-H HX ^. V -y • ' y , v • v-'T :.'. ,y. '.N 'Xy f ' ArXA ArA-V v;.AX'' •r'-ti A>.. •r-. \ -X'. •: f./. -A;.. A- . ;\.•XaA- \ Tv-cVA-yv^ AxX-A'vAAX'Y '••••, AjY vAy:. -y . .a a y . v".'y. ...v-. ; y'A* X;;-vy'X".:. v\ ~n '.<§-A yv^x; • • •--iiV. y -Y A\ r- yAv). . ^'Ay-\ c;A''';Y:Y;y^^yA;<,?y tA'cX."-aYVX^ -Y. AiA vx • Yfyyv \ yy •. ;i '• X'x; Y'aAX v;-A"y\ r. -T ... :A(;wy,-""x ; A^.> !v - , A."i X. "y"^ "•. X" A A - - i i ; > ' NA' 'i A AaU Ar-xAAiA iA-Ax ^ y< ; Xy-yA-r- YA5LI Of ^Qjrrij^ 'XtDZArrtTiLS C>t^ fHeTtcS /^/VO ^^Ufii^£/ 2. y^^ic e>t= /oA/rcAju _ ^ Appbji^U ^ V. t lifi :it/aE\ Of AuTrio^htks - -f-zy 57^£/HUrr ?>F '7HLC4S£ . 0 ST-^TZMeA/r RG£i^F^iA/6, OA/)c. /4/?£ilFt€.f^ , /? - JSSUSJ fA^SA/-7£Q 9 SlFTZ^lSfiff- OF Tm. , . iO SiitAKhAARy OF - - j^/3-y^ ApUitHEtTf . f t! . 3.V.5;^ AficHALU FtLP>/ yAeUicL^ H'S okciteroA/, HE dRAtrrsA S^crvt^s^OZ 'Zois-' fZAtHT\PA^J s^ro/y^ TH HIDTiOH fO^o S,UfmAi^Tc{tO£:F A^NT^ CEeAidy yH /l?A/r^ny TO Ttst}ttTOiji//^Fcse^/Tsfj ysy ^ocaateSp,^ ejn t^/hN££- /^%£FlF)i^y/^4^^^/^.fEy^^y^j'9ji//i^/y-^tZ3i . ,>.. H9, i9/S'0,ShS2^/r/^PEfy looI y^}r4Ah '/•/'OOJ _ „ -//. Hl.OD] / ^z>00/ ifROhATi. E^Ocj / ^ / , UaI t/omi FjED' /I'OR.y 7/^AyiC^ Cou^ Xa^Hoc>Fe:ii, ^/yiFl'S'PSi M ^A/EA€t/L UJAftR/\Any 3]pT EOEqn / fHOpsecy 7/csOj Aa/o H X^rr U/^c^ AHO y6STAM£Afr/7iUf:i SXa/ TrJ/s £f^lASc OF y^esriOj*/ yTO AOH^V/UMMFi TEmS y/li-J.THE /L(:>-<^-EE •HoH^CFO TXEmFr y^AoTsET/oyy ^F/zEO to 00 st>/ /SE THXT RDJty\iniS*i..xs A X/Vz/X 07 y/^'s McnHe'^^XF/o Eyxs £EQiiArrHza yp^ Nome ?A Ecy£Tc.j ta^ftsla/ /i FfuJO/cy/F y > ^F)o^t^ ^uA4nVjyfFtASc/Eo^ /ffS^~CX-C?S393 AfciOEE E^EoC-Z/^^^HFiA/yyiFF^/^EFO s<^b TFOTFrT/ TO/^OiYiyrESA. PZ, /99'y /Shpulc. Th^ y^77?ry T^ TTXnsZHc, dZAitfS^

3, i s V,)- av.^. •^,. , \ ^ \ I • • - (

:\v- • "v

•r\' V 3-v Vv

l.'\i iV • ' > ^ I • ; • % .

^:5V \ •". _ I* . - .

_ . I V \ \ kI .

•'>\

W I' ' V

- v /••' -v,; ~ :Av:" i/>',i.::>v.A v'v ^ *• V'- . , V'<

v\ --v ... -'. \ " V- / >-. t. •A: -...A-' _ '••••• X •; ^ ^ ,'-v'

-.1 V • ;. H *\ " If X. • '' *y » . <••• >\" V\ \r v,.:. y J '-• •' * ^ :: \"\V.- > i-x. j\ r^'^c -\ \> i"> *.« .\."c *•• .'*' .. A- i"*-:. • ". •• * ^.V^ V^•. X X..U •. y .f'v •) V . \ - -. v-^. ; "x /•. ; S '\ • \ ' \ • S • ^. * V', > \ w ' ^ .1 .:. N .i •

..A ,A, / . t . •• • ;^ vA-.:\ Ax^>,. '^•"i v. \ ^'•^^\ s r: ' - «, "Jj * \ *». '• •i.x\ "\ ' \. - " A. ..•(/.;•• ' \v, •-.r^ 1 . \ -. • \ iAv K'I'A^v ,X V' j\ ' • >,-- i y 'v V. V, .' .. \ C r. c-"- X.^X \' \ \ T* ^ V -••. •. Y ' X V . • . .vX, , V.\i^ \ X .V - ' • V^ \f , I . \;". ".. "v x's ;\' S »- -K ,X;Vi ;xS. X X . • -4 'X. ',Vy^ ^^\"\ (.--%• xA :i^..At.\'V~v-\x ^ *%**• , •.•>» — : . : »: it ..xtb • tt ••, . ••. [ A ^. —. 1 - r- \ • 'A 't .1. •y. -"> , ,-•• V.;v.ji. _ s^ -vr' , x> . -v-.. . i"i A ' \ •^•t 'Vrx-.. h>£tAirrt^''>3^t5£N£/yiOiAiiJ^ Pii.ihic.plU ChF fA/l^O TV ^SLWlJ r/!:eCSOl»/T .- THUc /iiee ot^^ufA/€ Ts.fufs ^P j^/lcTy As 3y Po!:)A'?r£p^yTA)fr/jD^/ir_av^/f^ UiviATcO T^iou Mn-llu s-o //-^ ^tuBS(xriv/USA /^^p/ ^Ppi6i-r A oyAhtt^ &P F^n^iiropy'/CjEpJO/^^^C^AfLpr /jlA/^/U^ A 7C> y^HA- £>Ljy^ JupD AO/iP/s /^cA -ib p,pc/'^y ^ifLOtvr :i:mujtfAic. /vcrsM-^ a ffop^io /^ ^ yAl/rTj U OVO^J piWdP'c.'aC 7a/^. /jsA- tyoiu^r^yy ZT/jouS^ft>v To Usc TPt phocc€^s p/^o/u^ TA^c yU>^ /a/ yyiuAiTii>yiy/yo F^y AP TXiFiikiCAoAfy 5pim^ /j^a/o^^/T/^it ^ 7>a^ P^mn/Ty y£>

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI