Jobe, William Walter

Opinion

, j " ~ ‘ ,ZUZ'N W R~QQ>, mag-w 56

g CAU;E /vo. /D~/;z’/$MQ~C BgEEfLWMFILE

TMA\COu

' \/\!;Hi.»am W/al+eg U'éBE § IA/ THE W_")’E‘Z/// Vc_ _ _ » § 1015 meier co L,L£T TH@ jam/ri DF 72¥`/’5 MOA/'/"L"»»v¢m££`)' C¢w,u?'/ R-EFORMA‘TIo/\/ OF L) _'MDc¢m EMTRE@EB VEDUN , UURTOF chM\NAL APPEALS ' OCT 23 2015 A§@@v&©@§@@,©@@v@< 1

De_‘¢'e_/~/JAA/+ moves A$ TITLEL) mud gram //,/

SuPFO€T .',J /,-""- _ v n D;'s‘ra.'J /~zrro/e/ve:/ Ecr/o Cwemm/ ' w.eo/’E /)/vd su@'m;++@d _A/vd ’5","5'/¢!£1) ”_§7'/)77:§ '/%rfw 70/400@' _pI_EA_M-'l€:§_" lTMOG-E HA/m;L/'¢)A/ 黀/w/”EO' ’|;L~l\~JOID lA) THE money z IZZ_

. WHP_,QMME, PRemi'_\. as CO/»I$'IDEREO, Th¢>, §+./J+e, ,O.e@vs +lmi' fla/b mo'l’iow +D Adopl' be QFMN%M £A/Q{ £[[;M cH mv+/'Ms AA/Q_/ PleAdi'A:Gs ./wd wli`/\)é>$ +he_f:e¢w w Ad¢/>i'€/) _/wd _`I`_N»C'DRPDMTEQ w' b@.)/m!-P 010 'Hq.@, 5+/,>+¢ /,v 7%,.3 025;, CASE A!D 0%~08»072&;;£&

I/uco/

TRLH\ DATE 1~3*41011 éRAA/rio A_/z/o _Adm;*fjfed _AUD/af /0/§/90//'/1/6'_“

IA/To El/.Lole~ce _"jT/»)TE_§ moT/"on/ 7'0 mo+{ou `]I' S'MCH- mo'h'o/\).s _A/'vd p/eAdi?l/£»S, 714

'Léaourvo\s _S+Meal ~)"h¢c),£e,-po,e,e, 411/01 »Qgh'/\/és ~Hae_ao/v Aee E_SSEN'TIAL h> +lw, j'T/)+e, I/u_ O&»DE»€ +D_ Feo$e(:u+a r/Hq

` CA$E

"/"LJO 44/`¢;)£;'5 I/:/ 77/£ I/i/£zc'/"/)z€/z/ `/"3 `_§;4/1/ 374¢;/_»./ n CWA/ 77 441 ['45€ /z/z), XZ»MJ Di`sch,q;¢c»e,,l dam/ned "`(C£/;m'A/A/ ALEbM" F££ .'27.../4‘?/ c@<:'m:»/,,,l 467/kw mma/5 ca4 _A,er, 27,¢9/ ~I)ud,zmw;' 04 _zA/»FDMA +,;u/@ _s'@ mem 115 w Iw/.zmw)’ de I/v f@em +501/ /1/0 Cf/Aec,£. /1//2 %/¢»:’4, A/z:? z"@/¢/Wz/“,m/,

C C 4 447’ 322 Dw wider

‘QI )'€.4£5 a/d (` 1455 C'_ /%sz/e,»zm.¢/¢)..»: . [2>.,¢£7'5 ('//466£@/ E/_`SBE Fa.»z [‘L/)s$ 6 //7/3'¢!€/)7¢/.)4/0£ L'/'Z,Jé€ 544/d (’//4£4€ Vof@l “ 544/s 05 wm 4,1/// €L/;.s) 6 44/3¢/£4¢,44/44 ,

C'///')£é€ 00 aj /M)T CA.<’/ :/"_/4// Tme,

/?Z?‘l L/Z$eeT/ (a¢w/f/ 15 4/5.:) ,4 /Z,ess _(” %3¢/2»1¢’4£ [`k/4£6€0 Fo,e CLAS< 8 M/'SJ/Memuw»_ /4/;¢> '%.2/"/4,1/¢/ 4/4 444 7 043'/)¢/3;@¢/ .4/1/@’ 445 _r@/M LW¢ ames /TQ/M€ 444/71

me _ 0.4. 444 7'0 444 '7'415 541/r1 4/€,,4.

I \,J.'nmm wm»fe.e ;704€ was 447 444/4 421de CHAQ(`:E d 1

Tex/L<. Ru|'e,s of 444@LLAT£ P£oceduea 4%;1 Fe/ees','l)le. 54404 (a] `\)\)"a\ilc"_am LJM+£/¢ ;`YBBE 6‘4$£ 4 (0/4/7£467£0‘ A)€£A/`i/é£wm/r amc w, 04-02~078&.2 »ce 4// 444%/¢; _.45-4££»/ +o m Te_nm<. 04 +ha, CO~,TQA¢T:"F when 7`4/'41 314 L:-€ 46¢£4/“22¢:/ me Pch A@Qezm£A/T TL@, CoA/TR/)¢;T of 7%@ /"/e/) A@R;£me~r is b;»@l;/\)& w 4//' /’M'+ie§.

Plea~ Co,\/TRACT was Fo£ 5 744/35 P£ob/-)%//)A/ IF RF_vo\

THE CONTMLTEOL P|€4 BAR@H,,\/

\/Uh@/J 4 P)e/a of GW'IH /`_s @A/%¢ecd /`4/4 _<‘/’47¢

C{<¢'m.’/\//al T/a{,ai __S"e./e£/)I Paelea,o| £QA/.S+f#uhb“/A/ QIGIJTs 446 i`n/uolved F.‘H\ 4/42/\/0144+ /)/\/4/ /‘IH) 4meA/d44/f. '

1590/4st 4 pleA»@AQG'A/A/ A(Weee/%e,v// /'3 50/@‘/ L’)Q'Twaed Th¢ JTATQ, mud mg defcudAA/f. 694//7’ 771¢

STATe 44/0[ de-{’e,/\/dAA/% MA‘/ A//¢z. 7'4£415 0¢’ /?é, AC*Q€€MZn/‘f` Thl, 7'£)(/)1 00sz €oM/VI;/'_S €»€,QG’£. /f£

ii umM+em//)’ 441/15 u/z/» /1/@¢'»0)‘/4%@¢/ 744/ns iv 4 //e4 »544_ 6-4/’4/ Aé£eeM&MT, /)700£ 14 5'747€, X‘i§ 5‘,1,.). 34 344, 332, /7?)<`. [4,;4 444 4404)

F{l€d _4~¢1 6£4/\)?'/:’0, /)707'/'2),\/ 444/d 0,<’0£,€ 87 ;7?/._46/@/1'4,»//4>_4/ URDEK TD ADUPT pl€Aol//\//r$‘//'/éa' 57 U.% ff//z? CoLEMA/U ll~ /7 g';RD'[Q

TH.IS MoT/DA)- Co,\/Solidn+ed T%esc T/wo fun/1213 mwT§ To GeThe/L 043€ 4/0 03 OX¢O°pr. ca \A)Th CorJTQa¢Ted P)eA 5 >’4423 P.€oLoAT/an/ 44!4/

4 GM.|?’Y PleA.AA/al 77\¢> A/e_w kewd¢c.T/MMT

ID |3\ |3)\»39. C£,.

_Tki.-S moT/v/Jj DROCR TD ADDFI p/»EHBl//\/&S,

lime/450 4 'CM/m¢r@,d v 4/44 n/m 74,»;4/'/~34?4// DF 5_`/€4£$ )OBOL)A+IDA/ WI'H\ ov\T W/‘///%'m ng¢/

_LA/ 771£ Com&T 200/n

time oF CraimiA/m V£ocwwae_ 44+.¢1& ;zcz 13 mde (_Q\ m .. 0/'\)1\/4£94)0/\/1`5% fha Oe/wdm/T 0¢'5

\.\)FLS D»d Gu,\/\`/ pie/4 /4€££?/'€4[. b\//r§ 77/['57{4£5 )Q€ab/)+M CHSE /UU. DZ 02 072(43.'(£ 4 COA/Te/+c?'ed 4/24.

CC 4 4eT 34 13@)(31)04\/ 04 T£.»’/a/ l“B~Q@// WHe,J jud GE 400;4734 mDT.DA/, oro/24 n 4004f ' p!QAO\I IUB' C 0 p A2T ali 13 (_Oi\ C;\\.¢ a a vEQMP~T

3., 4 ` j \

`Sl'm`ll ;'A/{`o¢;m 'Hw, de.¢’e,/vo¢'A/¢/! wl\m%e£ if L)/'// f'Q//oc.) 04 wier/7 fha 4/@4 .404@¢.4~;47” m 044,\/ €4.,¢47',4,4/4/ 19@}9@@~ /,a,./}/ {`iA/d/.»\/C~ o/v 7_7¢€, F/é/J fhould 771¢. fewer R€jecT §&Q@emeA/vl'j r/~.L UE/En/L?l/H./T 5/1/)// A€,pZ£/M/f/'/'e¢/ h> w 441 alem) M/, defeA/dg)uT; 414/4 44 (m/H’>’ 44 4/4/£1 CoA/I'en/alz,& .

.\/Jz|\\’4m wal+e¢; `_;TDE>E mmi TJBGE was A/euee, fold M¢£e wm 4 G_w»\+\l Pna 154/heed 4/~/04 4cce47ea/

IA) Tm MQ+:D,\) /020€4 To 40047' /’/44¢//;./55` - (~3 &D|[§ OR wm dog€ 400de To w..H\@la/Jw

im MQ. case A)v. 02-02~07$@2';;- __ ~ 14 SeUTw¢/A/e» Pms¢' 15144¢’ 54/[/ 441/¢ fg//ez;

Ir\Heeed 4 Ple¢) I/\/ HL»Q Co,;aT QQDM JE£E 54[¢/ F.»r¢ 5 ‘/444’5 )”/2»1,4+¢"04\/ 27140€ //4/4;/"%¢>.»./ 54/4/ f ACLQPT ‘Hml/ 9124., 71@_1/ .mfd I 4m GaL&/Y)

G-ive "/ou. "ID 7242,5 T.'Q.L.

judge MWM ord 4;)/44,/./4:\ .w.-'¢:,:»MUZAE 54 A pie/4 EA/Teo_ed'Fo./.>_ .77»4_ ‘/0 7442,5 FD,C, DIV"/ CouTQ/>.)c“l'ed plea 697 Al)/HD/l/{.she[/ /;?D£'LJFU

n\z_ 5 `/€AB$ 2 P.Q,o|oa-Hod. _ l

`11»\%#&0)\ 4444441.5 comer .:E/z/r m 4/,‘//,4,» 554¢’= BHCL; To T}\e, Cowvi"/ CouQT'. Becm,¢§a 010 éu.'}T)' Plaa 4401 $cooT PAwGAA} Oid /UvT_ F//e bleez.T 4!/9£4/» jud_£~é )'lnmi)+or)l) B»QAAJTMI :J/¢:>BE /}70+;0_,./ Foe, A/ZL) TM¢>»\ mud CouFl¢'¢T 045 IA)'+€Q@§T Bec/.)¢,¢se, 559@')’ pma G»AA) Ofr,l AJDT 'F{Ie_ IU€£/éc?’f/e{ /LS§FSM/vce, 0¢’, Coumsz\ 0»\)_ W\{<;\¢\Ael, G'Q,f.@£,'ua A/vcl _SLT Mg+,'M/ faa wm Tam\ 411~43~¢1'0)|1 I wulf/m :YQQ,E Comm@/,./ed/A/` \\-3041\ med mo+:.w 44 A/ew mm 44414/4444/44//~/£~//

A‘DO\AT Gu,'i j ‘l"/ plé)¢) .

_’H'&~i;-.'@lo`\\ Ff/vd.‘¢d& OF FACT /wd Coucmsi"ou_s O¢’ Lm.) simms w ‘;TMLC»E HAM:HW/.

wHE/\) 1475 HAM:!+@,,) emma 777 €@,.//‘ZM/’@¢/ plie,A oFP 07 777 backer 577€@/“ ,4,1./7/ A/Aw/_

balder DOQ|L e`l/

Ex §PMT@ ma :r…,k.w> 454 5 w 2439 [m< few /./-’/z lolo\) \/\)\ne»_\) /‘}al£~{’wdA/\JT Su(Ce§Sf)u/// Ch»//AA/z?~£s ,4

C@/Ju\cT{o»J cbi/aimed +h£@uol# A Me&o%/b %e@/ )0/£4 mg _ Gmi \+7J The HPFQoP£/Me Reme@(‘/ 15 gpec/f,c pee/'of€/ YV\AI\)C@., |'5 MoT pos$;\¢)le, 771£ p/Q£} /%LLST be l//?L/')*' O{QAWA) /-Wd ne FAeT/(es mLLsT ha ReTue/d€_¢/ 73 +h@,.(IL DE|`L‘>».H\)M' posi+£o.¢)$ fee A/§o(L/£fé//?'% sma 152 5,1),3,7 579,5 63 » ‘7'#/ [72,<. m ;m/

UACZMTD &005 'P@,T QQPA\

ll~l\~lo\l"j~‘~ F.‘N¢>liA/c. 04" F/)‘¢~,Ts mud C@>A/clusfou; of LAL), was GMN+QO\ SHP_ Pu\\ed T)'w. _'F‘/QAK P(€ob.a+{o»l CMTMJ@J ma team 'CA§E m /0¢13-)3¢@34»€4 PAP.T¢'Q,§ musT L>L QA,T'l/cen/ed 7’0.771&[£ D£_Z`é/))/A/ `po;.+Ea/\)§ S;HE Al$o Pu|led 7712 ‘/D' YQ'AA 750£,

S<),,J+~e~)co_

IF The, pleA 577/l I§ Aa//mff£a' ///e£¢ /5 /7 6u//>‘/ plan m/ william JEBE Feom /Tém/ /-_? -Qou v E/UT&QQJ BY 14 /-7

»FLLA cn~- nm sma dc c.p.`/)/¢T¢¢Qc 13 wm U)

L'o\\ Pkioe +o Accem',"~&'/) P|‘QA o-P Gw:i+/_ 04 okla/94 0~@ Nolo Co,\)+e~de,€., T'h.z Cou§.'f .S\M\| /AdmoA/fsl»\ T;\p,

Do.+`+;md zw+ o+`f

;5,

,.=.._-._.,_ _`_.____ __~

fn `T“M Q/WG=€, owe Tha Vmu{bkmeM/'f A'HAL//»e.d ap ma _ Off€m§a; 4 . l"]) 'Q\OH waile 1335 ~/'£7'7'| I)BE _ LJ/)s lhwca Admo/ui§¥\ed Fo¢: "{O' Ye,/m,s 7.'07€. , DAH‘/ Aolmo/uf.sk 707 771 571/aes 770777+.'7>7/ 075€ 7/7;).-02-0?»07?7 Cou;+{'+u+{w¢)l lateer of +\71 defwd/w+ 7 7 . 117/7 T_L\i~k 777 + TM ll defeudm/+Z G¢M“IH P|w 771757' 194

177/011),4_§+77)7177/1;1|1 777/757 7777@//71'@7/%/7:) v 807|<7‘7) V AIAIM/»A 395 175 523$§ 371 imm

7<7717++ 7 572/g 2017 5:7) 371 757 777/727 1777-77 /7‘7>0_@?001'7)

775/gosa 177 771 55th 07577;17 1777-1 717 7 manson 70 01577153 077 075£ 770.02~02~0"7%;1-1;4 ’l`w:> 0755 770_ 10~171'737_3;1»172 w;‘+A +77@ ”5'1'£[£; ,_YY)oTImJ .7'0 _ADoQT P)eeo|lué'"`l,w§oTE |1>>/ 777/71517£>/717`7721[ 777 `07'51'7;@7 7'7707<77£/ 5010 710/mw &7€77/71'1) by \

5`7777\€7£ 71777:17077, _7;1»7,17-3070 7)717 /)7/777777€77 777/fo '

~ 77.‘71 _7-3~2077 50 77/7/77/_ ‘/771)7177/ 72 01571_<5 /5727/1 »D-f»`<$fmi".s"$ilj -,LA_.SE /1/17. OX'OS 072&»2 64 /)/50 D75m7'.5$51)

CA§E 770. 70~1&'{3¢3;1-£4 Bec¢m.se, TH@§@ '717>1>'17/01¢7/77£7/7§, Plenol.w¢+s \mo)';o~s 7)7/77 £ulhués IMC@€DDRATED 177

’ \ REFERE/du;. 177 771 ,”57771'5 /7777;1_~77/ 7_’071@1)7>'/“/)/;77777775`

7777€& TRI/~)L 37 17771) 775

FH<°_' CO\AQ{' 07€1 /UU]' AU/’/iD/§/’l wi"/'//(Am :/:DBF frOf\ TH& 170 ‘/QAR 7',07€. .7".'7/ 557/7@7/@`7/77 /'/M§@.

07 0717 777 C@MT 77l/777 wallin/77 35177 ./’1>7/,"7777/7€777 777;7 c777m777777 7777. 157/777 777@7 17//'71<@77 777/77 §77~7'\7 777/7 7~3"770\71 7‘/777 777/77 .7177777777 777

ama 771).. OY'DX'D`/'X&);Z»££ 776 5 772,4,<3` 7€7@57777;9,7/ 'OROEQ 70 /}DDP`/* 10/73710{/7/6> /'//[c/ 57 0774_. fC/'/D 501@714/»)7/ /0'1'/7'@20/0 A/z/d Aa/m/)"f'e¢/ 177/72 El//@/emc@ 177 777"77 7-3 -»777//,! 777 /“7»/77777/k 7/777 7777»77 77 7). 77 5;77777/ 777 /7/7“/777777 375 717/7/ h<7~'7~77/777 _5“7'£7/7_ §im 077507/ A/z/o/ 1177/75 //Am/`/#Du 5/”6/1/€7’/ ..47/7/ §1@/7/7/7' 50 /7)17 /0/€77 07’ 5 `/eA£ 87 5"/7¢7//}7/7»70/£74 17 Geé£w£/Mf AA/a’ 7'-£¢?.777@7277 7Z7z /)/e/). 7977)77€7/ 777/7/‘ 777/77 »7777777/ 777 77 77 7. 717/7 (7/77777/ '7,/77',,/ 07777\ 70 ‘01)777 7/777/7>777 77775 elam/777 77_%7/7£ 77777.`!777/ /’;27/7~.20/7 _7’7/73' _ ms 777£57'7 /77/7/ 577/md 71 1)...17. 157/77 1’77/777777/ /2~/7»72777 7777:7~ 7’/77 777/77 1771)7“1;7/77777‘ M_a‘é`/w, 0§-02»0’7§17:1-57<‘ 777/ COM 73Ac7'£0 /’)/£A fA/fE/€EA' /;4/71> 77€/,;4/ 37 0/4

777/77 /’7¢7'77 1727/771 //77777,"/'777/ /~3~7;70/7 1757/777 _ 11--7717/377_31-_€7¢. 737 777 £77777/ /’777. /'777’ 577/~` JA£;/r/\/TD 607/17/7'7' U.M.I.`. @/}56’, /I/O. §72>7°@25.5’ p£)b£ 717/777- c 7777'777777777/77 777 7/7/ "’//772/" 77 5777'/277;7`77 67777777 377771>€ D7`5'c77/77e7157/ 777 "C.Qim;m/ Ac:'f/ém/"

7,

memv:\ C‘CLR A/ei’, ;2.'7.01 Ixm/;¢’fmwr @.e.I/i//@éem¢;-f,;z,\/

C‘C_¢P¢. fmi <;_Z`Z. DL/ ®u;l>..wé`» (’H/L€éc~’ /`/1/ /4 %//3'@/£/)¢£4/¢/0.<_, T'HeY H/)d 7'0 HAue_ 726 /’/.€A 70 /0./€01/@ up /?Z’S n O;(/{.l’.. SH/\/ ':/;)C."/A/ TD Coc,m/r/. UA‘IL /r$ /`/1/ jA/pf€/%Z///

£¢A§E A/,Q. /D~/l-"/.Zl.z_?;z ~£.€ F@.e F£LQ//Y` A.,LJ.I', fill _§`E/l/TE/z/£/'/\/L# //é,ese_ 72»,2£¢1, L//)§ A'/z/d /4¢"&0¢.,"/&1/ `Ac i’/JA/ 0 1’-"` ,4,/ a/¢/A¢/ // ZJ emg/2a /’//,4,€¢>£¢ /72.-

l.>/x/ E/EM

H€DAA J’,;w. €/m' /Jz)¢- OY~L>X'O'?%Q

ACC€,FT€¢/ 7'/4€ 5 Y£A£ /1-5~@?0/1 /749/7;»4/ /°¢5 dismiss

[)i'.$"l/£f¢-T EOWLT' G,€/?a/T[H "'wfa~k L)H$ IA/C'D;R-P[D__RA+£¢/ `/"0€+@#¢£ w.`+'A CA§E A!c>, io~ 12~13¢¢3;1~5.,€ I`/./ morrow oeae,e m AA,:»`<>T //Mé/,QM mv Quz),§T'/’.')A/ i`_s' /!01,) age 'L.)L.@ 5’@10@£A7’£0 fAe. E)@ IMCQK/»?QM+£A nap/xzmwr;. /m»m¢ m mgm/35 @A/ n 4CA§E. /!/1). 035’0?’[573@;)`° CQ Dlsm§ssecl BQTM .l`_'/UD.I.'(.T/v)EW§l €eeme /'¢ f% u,\/,~"/A%ce/)'//>’ ,Aeld§ uA/-A/e.(',o+/"M€.d realm fm /7' p/éA-BA£éA/Z/ A@RE£mea/T Dz'd /u@+ AAmo/\//;s'hed 722 A€FE)MA/@/T Fo§l LIO `/€/%£L$ T¢O.C. pl(£e C`AAJ A'/oT _S'TAA/c/- C,C,P. mar mpg)$ (a) [)\ TL»@ FIEA muir 65 wi+b\de/;w/~) A.\m\ 'T'm VHQT.’QS MusT ha Re_T’WQ/\)eA/€,d. 7”0 7%2[@

O{{I@i/\//-)| Pos,'"+.'.),\)$ 563v L)`f€i'~:(sz‘/" l/. _§`TA`T¢,

TK{F\\ feasz fommf'/'S

C ER m 11 mrs 1115 SE/e 1/1¢: mm 11 111 1111+;#7 wm 1111 OCT= _|Ce 120/5 14 fkue /)11/1/ ['0£122¢+ 6er DF 771e %lc)@ue 1711/d )501€12§011'1/¢;

doeumen/~l LMS jew/ed 0/1/ fha 01;1'151€/`1;1¢ Af/`Z/e/z/e/§

OFF/`L¢, /)’/’1)11//‘¢~0114£1€7 51».111'/"/ 1411/115 011/a 7'0 (’11~1~,11:7' 1>¢’ C£imfnml 11/’/’111/1- b~/ 1115 max/1

F€M pa / 1/’11 /// 1511 b 1111 '/f&/

_M@%&/@

L/x/$L/MM 0551//1€14151”11/ FM/¢M/r m 11?2' a..s.¢.' /7

I h/////¢)M` ida/1523 §/`Z'BE /!%??QV 14/» /7€ ¢/e/eA/é/A/z/f' /M/¢/ haw f)€e§e/z//’// /h/€A£AMANJ /ju fmc 72>

A-f 1111 michael bia/115 decle£v. 1111/dep pen/A/f/ 015 Pe/i <_/1,112/ T\/m+ ACLDRd 1106 lo /Y)`I bahc¢’. 71a 155/1513 15+¢1#'£@/ /}1//7111

Aloove, RE‘FS&-m¢§'T/'AA/.’. DF ;'/'11111;-1»£1/7' /1'1<>11' 72112. 1411/d

CO RR QcT. '\ 1"1‘@-1/1§11 111 r/111 __L___ 1/11/ of 01:1:1?0/5 14 pec/fully 511 1 1»1»1»1/

WL_ @

BHRBARA Gmdd‘em ADHMFCK

l D1cTRic.T C|egk mouTGo/v\££`/ £@11/)'>' .__ 1 `_ ` FD 601 ¢§QZJ Dme\_al ATTo-m/€,/ _ _COAHQDQ_ /y" 77305' 307 w )Ol!i')///aj _$'7_¢2/1/1;///

b ' 601/1201 71 7730\

Coum“ oF ceimwnl APPems P1O1 ibew D\Z\'DZ CHPITDL _Sm)'/DA/

A»L_s\'£u 711 727 ll

CAM_$E /1/0_ /D-/Q»/_M$_;z'c;/<

'THE _57/17'£ of 77EXA5 § 'IA/ THE 0151'£1¢7‘ 501127 \/ ` OF MouT&OmF£Y [011111/7'/

W\'l\mm LJA|+eP~ UBBE 250 711 ';1':11/1:¢;141 015/ncr

ORDER THE CouQT. /’\Al///l/é CQA/é/'c/é/€`€c/ 7%€, £[FD.'€/WA//b/J 01 UT111C~11111/7r /;§ A@.ee,by é£A/z//"Eo/ A£/z/I£a TO BE BEA/CH h/AM/M/f£o E/)c£ 7’0 [1>111//”/011’

Co/\/a/ic;+{o 1/

1731/05 51{>£51¢/1;1/¢

/21'111 /-3»11111

~ 1555 c 69

.1¢:=13NSE; l

_ ‘ l THE STATE OF TEXAS

VS.

‘ . 1 ., f\ , 5g1 ll1r:111/1. wl ;_1£15

MO'I'ION TC DISl\/HSS

TO THE HONORABLE IUDGE OF SAID- COURT:

Y¢OW COMES the State of Texas, by and through her Distn'ct At.ff.ney, abovev entitled and numbered criminal action for the following reason.'

§ Cannot prove beyond a reasonable doubt_

3 The De_i`end:~_nl was convicted in another case.

U In custody elsewhere

0 Old case, no arrest.

Cl In the interest of justice

C| Missing witness.

13 Request of complaining witness_

Cl Th.e,.Ds:f§nda_u_f.ii§_d.¢§§§§¢d~

U Motion to suppress granteai.

Cl Co-Defendant tried, this Defendant testify.

U Ins_uftic_i_ent evidence

E] R 4 "tution made.,

rC`l'/&§ln)efendant convicted, insufficie ev`%ce this Defendant. c.. Case refiled as Cause No. \(\ ’ §§ “ 5 5@`33 C] Clearance Lelter. '

U Other. ~

EXPLANATION:

?.»-‘»:' 53

s ` "( 15 ` 515 ,` / . LlC€&QQ ]NTHE!' m

5/>1'“1;`\)5=' ‘ 53 -5‘ cAUsE No. 5\§”5\1%“5\‘7§5(@

1 DISTRICT COURT

IN COUNTY COURT A'l` LAW N@?;§Ee' is "~~»

OF

:4©5:§§/ MoNTGoMERY 111 rsi\n”Y

and respectfull

. _,11“ t

y requests the Court to dismiss the

RECE|VED AND FlLED FOR RECORD

AT___~O’C|OCK_________M.

WHEREFORE, PREMISES CONSIDERED, it is requested thatۤt_he above entitled and numbered cause be dismissed

fAssistant District Attorney

Montgomery County, Texas

ORDER 'I'he foregoing motion having been presented to me on this the _ day

considered, it is, therefore, ORDERED, AD.TUDGED, and DECREED that said is hereby dismissed »

IUgGE

VO%/\,\

o A.D. 205_5__ and the same having been

above entitled

DISTRICT COURT

COUNI Y COURT AT LAW NO. MONTGOMERY COUNTY, TEXAS

WH`ITE - ORIGlNAL COUNTY GERK 4 GREEN - COPY

//

CANARY -'COPY

and numbered cause be and the same

(_y'(j\__,.`_/ z\/<_;/)/»`_.<_;

PlNK - COPY

cause N@. io-iz-isssz-cn '

THE sTATE_oF_ TEXAS

§ _ ` _ mrni; `DISTRrC_TZ oURro § , v.. § - MoNTGoMERY co § erL'iA-M WALTE-R'JoBE , § . 339"13UDICIAL iiier 455;`

STATE’S MOTIQN TO ADOP-T PLEAD]NGS

Cornes Now the State of Texas ,by and through its Assistant Cnrninal Disnict Attomey, in the above styled and numbered cause and files this motion to adopt certain pleadings and motions heretofore filed and ~` as grounds thereof Would show the Court the following:

_ _ I.

The State has filed motions and pleadings in Cause Number 08108-07862-CR. t

The State requests that all such motions and rulings thereon be adopted by reference and incorporated 5 by reference on behalf of the State in this case. Such motions and pleadings, the grounds stated therefore, and the rulings thereon are essential to the State in order to prosecute this case.

' ‘ _ _ in. . . 1 l l WHEREFORE PREMISES CONSlleRED, the State prays that this Motion to Adopt be granted

5 and that all such motions and pleadings and the rulings thereon be adopted and incorporated in behalfofthe v 5 5 5 5

State in this case.

` ` Respecrruiiy submitted,

Assistant lbistrict Attorney

'Montgomery County, Texas 1 SBN: 24065_0624

CERTUICATEO,F SERVICE

l certify that a true and correct copy of the above- listed motion Was delivered to M. Griffin, attorney for the

Defendant, on this the / ZH3 day of l QQQH bg£ ,.2010 /’ v

' T'HE sTATE o,F` TEXAS .

~`__/'

Wi:LLIAM WALTER JoBE _-

_ cause Np, 10-12’-13632-cR'

.V.

cmw)cmomw`)_

ORDER

.The Court, having considered the State’ s Motion to Adopt Pleadings, said motion is hereb@nie d

1916/tm fcme

J_udge Presiding

/02Ȣ>?~///0"

' /3'

NO.

IN 'I`HE COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE

NINTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT OF TEXAS

' AT BEAUMONT, TEXAS

*************************************************

WILLIAM JOBE Appellant,

V.

THE STATE OF TEXAS Appellee.

FROM THE 359TH DISTRICT COURT OF MONTGOMERY COUNTY CAUSE NUMBER 10-02- l 3632-CR

***********">'c<*_*=¢¥***£o=**************#***************

TO THE HONORABLE JUSTICES OF THE COURT OF APPEALS:

C S NOW William Jobe, Ap ellant, by and through_counsel, and submits this docketing

statement pursuant to `l{ule 32.2 of the Texas Rules of Appellate Procedure, and would show this Court the

following:

10.

ll.

13.

14.

515.

APPELLANT’S NAME:

TRIAL COUNSEL:

APPELLATE COUNSEL:

DATE rRiAL coURT iMPosED

- SENTENCE IN OPEN COURT:

OFFENSE CHARGED:

DATE OF ALLEGED OFFENSE: DEFENDANT’S PLEA:

TRIAL IN GUILT PHASE:

TRIAL IN SENTENCING PHASE:`

DATE NOTICE OF APPEAL FILED lN TRIAL COURT:

PUNISHMENT AssEssED: APPE.A_L FRoM_ PRETRLA.L oRDER?

APPEAL iNvoLviNG_rH_E VALIDITY oF A sTATUTE, RULE oR oRDINANcE?

CHALLENGE TO THIS COURT’S JURISDICTION:

DATE OF MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL:

William Jobe

Michael Griffm

300 W. Davis Suite 540 Conroe,_TX 77301 Telephone: (936) 539-1011 Facsimile: (936) 539-1002 Scott Pawgan

P.O. Box 8930

Huntsville, TX 77340 'I`el'epho`n_e: (936) 435-1380 Facsimile: (936) 435-1652

January_§, 2011 Driving While Intoxicated 3ml or More

April 30, 2008

N/A n '

Guilty Plea

No Juiy

February ll, 2011

Forty Years Institutional .»Division bin

Texas Department of Criminal Justice

Undetermined

Undetermined ` ¥" No

N/A

16. MOTION lN ARREST OF JU_DGMENT FILED? ~ No

17. TRlAL COURT AND RECORD: 359th Judicial District Court of Montgomery County; Cause No.

10~12-13632-CR

18. TRiAL JuDGi~:; ' ` The Honorable Kathleen Hamiiron District Judge l 207 W. Phillips sune305 Conroe, TX 77301

19. DISTRICT CLERK: 4 Barbara Gladden Adamick ’ District Clerk 301 North Main Con`roe, TX 77301

20. cLERK’s REcoRD REQUESTED: Febmaiy.i i, 2011 21. coURT REPoRTER: l ' Darlene Forville Court Reporter ;;" 207 W. Phillips 1 sune305

Conroe, TX 77301

22. REPORTER’S RECORD

REQUESTED: - February ll, 2011 23. APPROXIMATE LENGTH ~ ~OF 'I`RIA`L: 4 2 Days 24. APPELLANT’S INDIGENCE: v ' Appellant was determined by the Court to be

indigent prior to the trial of this case and was represented by Court appointed Counsel. Appellant ` continues to be indigent

cEP.'rmc. -TE or sERvicF..

This is to certify that a copy of the above Docketing Statement was served by certified

United States Mail, first class delivery prepaid, on the Montgomery County District Attomey. Respectfully submitted,

@"`\

Scott Pawgan Attomey for Appellant

TxDPS CCHl\ lame Search Record | Criminal History Search | TxDPS Crime Records Ser... Page l of 17

Texas Department of Pub|ic S_afety Criminal History Search

uSER:dosxes\(16500,15500'1$ERVE1=,:msth onii:?iéim§ 10:10:46 AH LAHG.EHGL!SH (l)NITEn S1ATes)

\7`:\ TxDPS CCH Name Search Record Search Information BATCH # 2867288 seARcH # 12922102 seARcH suMMARY )oee,vvxLLiAM wALreR 11963»4-2] useR NAMe r)Psresr_

DAT7E 2015- 027 6T17 . O: 45. 145418- 6: 00 7

Ir is a crime to disseminate this record to an y person 01 entity not authorized to receive the recordl Nair)e- -based criminal history record information should not be

discussed nor released to a potential subject of the record For further information pertaining to the unauthorized ohtaining, use, or disclosure of crimina.l history ’7 record information please review Governmen_t 77Code 411. 085. ~

JoBe,wILLIAM (er: 03638337)

910 7 . 7 . k 073633337_ oAreLAs'r uPDAreo 7 " 77 2/757/270715_ v 7 SE)_( . :,. . . ` § t MALE ,, . _ ., _ 1 _ w R.ACE . __ 1 . y WH!TE . v , . 7e7r7117NiCITY7 7 7 7 7 77 77 7 7 4 77 Noi\i- HI_sPAl\_iic HeIG7HT 7 ’77 77 7 7 77 54140" 4 . 77 7 ,. q 4 7 We_iGHr 7 7 7 7 771501_99 ; 7 77 ~ e7Y7es7 7 7*‘7'7 7 1731_71_,1157 7 77 \ 1 77 \74 HAiR 7 7 7 77 7 7 7 990va d 7PLAce 01= 517an 7 7 7 77 7 7 A41_1_ orHeRs (ANY 1179717@1\1 cou'\JTRY/DEPENDEN 1 NA7M7e7(s7) 74. _ 4 7 ioe, WiLLiAM v1/1\1_T`er7

7 JOBE, BiLL » »

ioee, BILLY

'Joee, wILLiAM (PR`rMAr`

\.JOBE WluLI_A_M w 4 JOBE,wieLiAM :wAi_TeR NoBLEs,BiLL 7 ' _NoBLes;BiLi_'v NoeLes;MicHAeL` Gn;e_eR'r wALKeR,STeVE 77 7 wALKeR,sTeveN

` wAu

ARREST SU"MARY ' `/"/l€k e* rs A//) /‘7?873 D 1902 oAreoFARResr , sequence cooe_ TRACKIN_G NuMeeR

27_[11_7¢419_89 7 7 A7~7 77 - 4_7¢_2771199_0 7 7 77 7A- idiis[i99o 7 7 47A77 ` 5[4¢1991 77 7 ~'

9127[1992

714[37[19957

4_[3_0[1_995

4`¢_101199_6 91_6¢19_96_ 7 7

7 711571719967

7 79¢4¢1996

9004026229 7 4 4 7 117/101\1100141_91<\_'7 co so co_NRoe_ 9003322805 7 l HARRis c_o consrAeL_es o`F`Fice P'c'r` 4 spRiNG

7007170774719471 977070473173_6721 7 77 7 7 7 7 7 M017\14T77G70M7eiiv7 co 797o4 0017\111704e77 90043379273)<7 7 77 7 7 7 7 7 M0N7T7070Me71z7r7 co 970 7c70N7Ro7e7 797004747257128 77 7 77 7 4 7 7 7 7 MoNrGoi/ienvco 907c407NROe 77 0052086097 c71_7e\7/e71_AN_o Po 90044_3474279 7 7 7 77 MoNTGoMeRY c770 79707 <7:071\17ROE_77 7 9037424797171737)4<77 7 7 7 7 re7x_As7Hv1/7Y PAT 7017 aec 2 70197'_r A H70711_s_roN 005747502462 77 7 7 7 ‘ 7c71_7179v7eL/74No7 71>71) 7903624272)7< 7 77 7 PAsA0eNA Po 9190876717295 7 7 M0N7TG70M77ER7Y 007 90 coN7Roe

shaw

7 52127227001 _57¢1_70(20_01 6¢176[2070717

7 77 7oizsizooi 7

7 2172737[24070727 7 si9iz70075 4[370¢2707078

)>')>4>'>.>‘)> )>,7)>;> > >§>7:>§>')>

/7

http://l70.193.85.54:8080/DpsWebsite/CriminalHistory/Application/Search/Individual.aspx... 2/6/2015

TxDPS CCH Name Search Record | Criminal History Search | TxDPS Crime Records Ser.._. Page 2 of 17

The information contained in this record reflects only information contained in the Computerized Criminal History database maintained by the Texas Department of Pub/ic Safety. Contact the contributing agency for specific or additional information regarding charges or dispositions The contents of this record is confidential and intended for dissemination only to criminal justice agencies or other individuals or agencies authorized by law to receive criminal history record information.DPS cannot guarantee the records you obtain through this site relate to the person about whom you are seeking information. Searches based on names, date of birth and other alphanumeric identifiers are not always accurate Tbe only way to positively linl< someone to a criminal record is through fingerprint identification lt is your responsibility to make sure the records you access through this site pertain to the person about whom you are seeking information Extreme care should be exercised in using any information obtained from this Web site. i\/either the DPS nor the State of Texas shall be responsible for any errors or omissions produced by

ARREST DATE 2/11/1989 (1 CHARGES)

ARREST oeTAIL ARResT DATE seQueNce cooe ARRE79171NG AGeNcY

ARREST DATE 2/1‘1'.,'1989 (CHARGE *001)

OFFENSE RECORD 7I7NTERNAL AGENCY PERSON NU7M7BE7R ARREST7 OFFENSE

\1ARREST OFFEN$7E LITERAL

acoulz'r 9TATus A

,cooRT 071FFe 1912 ?;;couRT 01=FeNs7e LI*reRA1_74 7 ;'§couRT 019P051110N 7 , -couRT 0199091'11_017\1 DATE 7 .'couRT 121101311711701\17

1.

ARREST oAjre 4/27/719790 (2 cHARGEs)

ARREST DETAIL A119199T770A_T4e

seQueNce cooe

ARREST DATE 4/27/1990 (CHARGE *00_1)

"_7'OFFENS_E RECORD 7")1ARREST7 O7FFEN 057ARREST OFFEN7SE7 LITERAL7

1§c0_uR'r sTATus A7

` couRT 071=7F7e1\197e

~, count 07F7Fe1\_19e7 LI_TeRA17.7 §'c70uRT 01971>09111017\177 7' 7 t;couRT c017\1F71NeMeNT

ARREST 0ATe'4/27/1990 (CHARGE ’{002)

11c0uRT sTATus 174 i7co7uRT 707FFeNs7e7 7 7

17 couRT oeFeNse LxT_eRAl__ c7707117RT 70191>0917_17101\1 couRT c0N7F1Ne7147e7NT

ii 7couR717 PR0v19107N

ARREST DATE 10/18/ 1990 (1 CHARGES)

ARREST D_eT_AIL A7R7R79 7 7T7 07 seQueNce 7c0707e 7 112/7101<711\1<7;7 Nu71~44aeR ARRE§TING 1105ch

ARREST DATE 10/18/1990 (CHARGE A001)

§;OFF_ENSE RECORD

1\717T7eRNA7L AGeNCY PER970N N07M4B7ER i;171\1T7e7RNA1_ AGeNc¥ cAse _Nu_MeeR §7A77RRe7sT 01=7FeN79e 7

7A7R7Re7sT QFFeNse cITATION

‘7§_71_EVEL A71\10 0757GREE 041= 0F4F75NSE "' ARREST 0ISP0791T1017\1 DATE

70R1\'1NG LJNDER 11\11=1_1.17e1\1ce 1_

» ARR‘7E7S7T DATA NOT 7R7E_CE7I\1ED7

7 A797917T7-7'(F7Ree 1_e7xT4)7 (717730000004)7

`717>`00110 oaoeR ca1149797-`"(eRe`e 7`Te>4<1) 123990000) 7;___c401\1v1c7re077 _31_07)

7 7’77co1\1c7171RRe1\1T(73673)

secondary dissemination of this da ta.

/L/D ._(7”/[/`7@6/;\/ 70

Equ,\/T/

/€38

C/i$i /1/0. Xz?z,za'$

2/11/1989 A LIBERTY CO 50 LlBERTY (TX1460000)

7 13192

DRIV1N_G uNoeR 1N1=Lue1\1ce 1_101170_13 (54040000)7 owl 7 7 7 7

DW71 MISD C_ON7VI7CTED (310) 3/7167/1797879 .zY .

4/27/71990 A

90 (00020000)

AGG AssAoLT_ coNv1cTe0(`31o) zv _~` ~

CRIMIN7AL M!SCH_IE7F

72Y

ibi .1`/_ . A

7 071727053754087

171/19111797 7co7 790 1100971701\1 (T><10107000)

11_ARR1_9 00 90 1100_91011 _(_T)<1010000) 90409710

192190204_6728

cR11~44 14190711 $200<$790 129000014) 28 03(1737)(3)

7M1907e1~4e17\1\1701z_7- c7_7LAs479 7A (MA_) 10/418_/19970

,/J? '

1109 17540400007)4'_77, 7 7

http://l 7(). l 93.85.54:80SO/DpsWebsite/CriminalHiStory/Application/Search/Individual.aspx...

D, u. I.

2/6/2015

)-"~¥ac.sw;=_o AND F\Leo

, _* _l _ /._£Qrzrr~_cc.e ) ' T'HE sTATE oF TEXAS "~* ---»’ ~~§ ”"`““ '

tith 1 2 2008

t at,-'..¢.Mic`a ll‘~ ' ,' ~

»<~ 359th District Court

William Walter Jobe NO_' 0 8 - o _3 ~ 0 7 8 6 2 ' 'CR _CR

INnr-ovTMENT ~ -

Count l v ` Charge . . DA File # Agency # #1 DR_i_v_rNG w_HlLE rNToXICATED - 3RD on - 08~001829.1 08A007538 'MORLI.Y._ . `

Se`c. 49'.04; Fel..3 °_

IN THE NAME AND BY AUTHORITY OF THE STATE OF 'I`_EXAS:

'I`HE GRAND JURY, for the Connty o_f Montgomery, State of Texas, duly selected,v empaneled, sworn, charged, and organized as such by the 9_t_h Judicial District Court for`said Count);, upon their oaths present in and to said court that William'Wal_ter Johe, hereinafter styled Defendant, on or about April 30, 2008', and before the presentment of this indictment, in the County and State aforesaid, did then and there operate a_ motor vehicle in a public place while the said defendant was intoxicated

And it isfnrt_her presented in and to said Court that; prior to the commission of the foregoing offense, on March 16, 1989, in the County Court at Law of Liberty County, Texas, the defendant was convicted of an offense relating t`o the operating of a motor vehicle while intoxicated; and on September 15,- 1988,~-~in- the County Court at Law. of San -Jacinto»Cc`)unt)/,v Texas, the-defendant was convicted of -an offense relating to the operating of a motor vehicle while intoxicated,

Enhancement Paragl raph A . And the GRAND JURY further presents that said Defendant, William Walter Jobe, was

convicted of a felony, to wit: Possession of a Controlled Suhstance on January 15, 2003 in the 359th District Court of Montgomery County, _Texas in Cause No. 02-07-0463 6-CR under the name of William

Walter Jobe and said conviction became final prior to the commission of the aforesaid offense in Count l of this Indi<:trnent.

Enhancement Paragraph B And the GRAND J'URY further presents that said Defendant, William Wal_ter Jobe, was

convicted of a felony, to wit: Possession of a Controlled Substance on November 22, 2002 in the 75th District Court of Liberty County, Texas in Cause No. 24235 under the name of William Walter Jobe and said conviction became-final prior to the commission of-the aforesaid offense in Count I and Enhancement Paragraph A o`f this lndictment.

Minute

Dote:_AUGlB_ZUllB___ _ n 35

/7'

l _ l THE STATE OF TEXAS 4 359th District Court . o _ v, - gm range _, _ m _".] » 1 ' '_ . o aec e€»‘)' Q/ ' 0 ~ 2 ~ 3 6. 2 - William Walter Jobe ` t FO §(,"\o-C"‘~-/ ’ NO. 3 CR~CR . M ~ . (Re-Indictrnent) Count ’ Charge DA File # Agenc #

#1 DRIVTNG VVHILE INTOXICATED - 3RD OR 08~001829.1 08A007538 MOR_E .~ . ~ Sec. 49.04; Fel. 3 °

' INTHE NAME AND BY AUTHORI'I`Y OF THE STATE_OF TEXAS:l

THE GRAND JURY, for the County of Montgomery, State ofTexa`s, duly selected, empaneled, sworn, Charged, and organized as such by the 2215t Judicial District Court for said County, upon their oaths present in and to said conn that William Walter Jo`be, hereinafter styled Defendant, on or about April 30, 2008, and before the presentment of this indictrnent, in the County and State aforesaidx did then and there operate a motor vehicle in a public place while the said defendant was intoxicated

And it is further presented in and to said Court that, prior to the commission ofthe foregoing offense, on February 12, 1991, in 'Canse No, 41572, i_n the County Court at Law of Liberty County, T__€_Ka§» fh_€_ defendants/§§.99@119§¢§.49§3§.9££€_9§§ relatipg,ts the sustains .Q_f a ta.f.>.tet.¥§hi_¢,l@ ,w_hil@ intoxicated; and on'September 15, 1988, in Cause No. 88-253, in the County Court at Law ofSan. v Jacinto County` 'l`exas, the defendant was convicted of an offense relating to the operating ofa motor vehicle while intoxicated, y - '

l And the Grand Jury further presents that during the commission ofthe primary offense alleged above, the Defendant_ did then and there use or exhibit a deadly weapon, to-wit: a motor vehicle,

-Enhnncement Parag;a`ph A And the GRAN`D JURY further presents that said Defendant, William Wnlter Jobe, was

convicted ofa felony, to witt Possession ofa Controlled Substance on January 15, 2003 in the 359t_h

District Court of'Montgomery. County, 'I`exas in Cause No. 02-07-04636-CR under the name of William Walter Jobe and said conviction became final prior to the commission of the aforesaid offense in Count l ofthis lndictment.

- Enhancem`ent Paragraph B b v And the _GRAND JURY further presents that said De_fendant, .William Walter' Jobe, was .

convicted ofa felony, to witt Possession cfa Controlled Substance on November 22, 2002 in the 75th District Court of Libetty County, Texas in Cause No. 24235 under the name of \/Villiam V\'alter Jobe and said conviction became final prior to the commission ofthe aforesaid`offense in Count l and Enhancement Paragi'aph A of this In_dictment. `

:l\l ne §§O,)\}'i'“£I\lCQ/A,l(,¢ phrase mg TMJ(,,‘_¢` D"d.§ /Uot` FCM' neaglt‘i wes/vw mata

l