Jennifer Kirk v. DOJ

Opinion

In the

United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit

JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJO

'=O49L579<O

 O >O 
>O

O

 O
O
 OO  >O 
=O

JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJO

(($O*'%O, O&!,O,,+O!+,*!,O'-*,O '*O, O'-, *&O!+,*!,O'O $$!&'!+=O '=O48LL8:4L L ONO  
   >!=O JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJO

O O49>O5349ONO O O5>O5349O JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJO

'*O 
>O
>O &O 
>!  ! =O 
>!  ! =O '*%$$1O O !+,*!,O '-*,O %1O *-O O *!%!&$O +&,&O '&$1O /!, !&O 47O 1+O 'O !,+O !%('+!,!'&=O=O=O*!%=O=O68BC=O-,O!OO(*!+'&*O(*'.!+O +-+,&,!$O++!+,&O,'O(*'+-,'*+O,*O!&O+&,&>OO !+,*!,O '-*,O %1O *-O , O +&,&O ,O &1O ,!%O '&O , O (*'+-,'*G+O%',!'&=O=O=O*!%=O=O68BC=O &&!*O!*#O&L "'1O'&O+- O*-,!'&@O, O!+,*!,O"-O-,O *O+&,&O 5O '=O49L579<O

B'*O%!$O&O/!*O*-CO*'%O4;;O,'O443O%'&, +=O!*#O'&L ,&+O , ,O + O (*'.!O !,!'&$O ++!+,&O ,*O , ,O *L -,!'&O &O !+O &,!,$O ,'O O -*, *O */*>O -,O , O &!,O ,,+O
,,'*&1O +O $!&O ,'O !$O O +'&O %',!'&O -&*O -$O68BC=O!*#O, &O!$O, !+O+-!,O-&*O, O
%!&!+,*,!.O *'-*O
,>O 8O ===O K:35>O +#!&O O !+,*!,O "-O ,'O +,O +!O , O (*'+-,'*G+O !+!'&O &',O ,'O !$O , O %',!'&O , ,O /'-$O(*%!,O, O'-*,O,'O*-O *O+&,&O-*, *=O  O !+,*!,O "-O !+%!++O , O '%($!&,>O !.!&O ,/'O *+'&+=O 5349O ==O !+,=O  O 8:656O B==O $$=O
(*=O 5<>O 5349C=O !*+,>O , O "-O , '- ,O , ,O / , *O ,'O %#O O -$O 68BCO %',!'&O !+O '%%!,,O ,'O &1O !+*,!'&O 1O $/>O *!&!&O !*#G+O$!%O/!, !&O, O+'(O'O, O0$-+!'&O,'O

O*.!/O !&O 8O ===O K:34BCB5C=O '&>O , O "-O $!.O , ,O , O *! ,O/1O'*OO(*!+'&*O,'O',!&O*.!/O'O, O(*'+-,'*G+O !+!'&O!+O1OO'$$,*$O,,#O-&*O5;O===OK5588N&O , O

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

,&O /!, O ', *O (*'+-,!'&+=O O +,,O , ,O , O (*%!+L +!$O*'-&+O'O*.!/O*O, '+O, ,O(($1O,'O$$O0*!++O 'O (*'+-,'*!$O !+*,!'&N+O O (*,!$O %,,*>O *O !+L *!%!&,!'&O'*O', *O'&+,!,-,!'&$O,*&+*++!'&+=O837O==O,O 4;8M;9=OO$+'>O==>O !!!
>O84:O==O789>O 796O B4<<9C@O ! ! ! >O :<6O =6O :45>O :4<M56O B:, O !*=O 5348CO B&O &C=O -+O , O !+!'&O / , *O ,'O !$O O -$O68BCO%',!'&O!+O*.!/$O'&O, '+O*'-&+>O!,O +O&',O &O'%%!,,O,'O&1O!+*,!'&O1O$/>O&OK:34BCB5CO , *'*O'+O&',O'*$'+O*.!/O-&*O, O

=O 0,O-(?O'+OK5588O(*'.!O&O)-,O*%1O&O+'O $'#O

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

'*O%'+,O+!,-,!'&+N'O/ ! O!*#G+O!+OO''O0%($N K5588O'+O&',O(*'.!O&O)-,O/1O,'O'&,+,O, O(*'+L -,'*G+O!+!'&O&',O,'O!$OO-$O68BCO%',!'&=O O!$$-+L ,*,+O , O (*'$%=O
'*!&O ,'O K5588BC>O %',!'&+O %-+,O O !$O/!, !&OO1*O'O, O"-%&,G+O!&$!,1=O,!'&O5588BCO +O +'%O 0(,!'&+>O +- O +O &/O &O *,*',!.O *-$+O 'O $/>O -,O &'&O (($!+O / &O O (*!+'&*O '&,&+O , ,O +-L +,&,!$O ++!+,&O "-+,!!+O O $'/*O +&,&=O ,O -$O 68BCB5CO -, '*!2+O +&,&O *-,!'&+O $'&O ,*O O 1*O *'%O, O'&.!,!'&G+O!&$!,1?O ('&O , O '.*&%&,G+O %',!'&O %O %'*O , &O '&O 1*O ,*O +&,&!&>O , O '-*,O %1O *-O O +&,&O !O , O &&,G+O +-+,&,!$O++!+,&O!&.'$.?O B
CO !&'*%,!'&O &',O #&'/&O ,'O , O &&,O -&,!$O '&O 1*O '*O%'*O,*O+&,&!&@O BCO !&'*%,!'&O (*'.!O 1O , O &&,O ,'O , O '.*&L %&,O /!, !&O '&O 1*O 'O +&,&!&>O -,O / ! O !O &',O L '%O-+-$O,'O, O'.*&%&,O-&,!$O%'*O, &O'&O1*OL ,*O+&,&!&@O'*O BCO !&'*%,!'&O , O -+-$&++O 'O / ! O '-$O &',O *+'&L $1O .O&O&,!!(,O1O, O&&,O-&,!$O%'*O, &O '&O1*O,*O+&,&!&O&O/ ! O/+O(*'%(,$1O(*'.!O ,'O , O '.*&%&,O ,*O !,+O -+-$&++O /+O *+'&$1O (L (*&,O,'O, O&&,=O

O %',!'&O -&*O -$O 68BCB5C>O %'*O , &O O 1*O ,*O *O +&,&!&>O!+O0,$1O/ ,O!*#O/&,+O, O(*'+-,'*O,'O!$=O ,!'&O 5588BCO &!  O + '/O , ,O K5588O '+O &',O '*O *O&O)-,O%&+O'O*.!/=O &>O /!, O **O 0(,!'&+O 'O , O +'*,O !$$-+,*,O 1!

 >O K5588O '+O &',O *++O , O (*'(*!,1O 'O /!, L '$!&OO%',!'&O-&*O-$O68BC=O,!'&O5588BCO(*'.!+?O '=O49L579<O 8O

O (*!+'&*O !&O -+,'1O -&*O +&,&O 'O O '-*,O +,$!+ O 1O
,O 'O '&*++O $!%!&O , O *! ,O ,'O O *$+O -('&O , O *'-&O, ,O, O+&,&O/+O!%('+O!&O.!'$,!'&O'O, O'&+,!L ,-,!'&O'*O$/+O'O, O&!,O,,+>O'*O, ,O, O'-*,O/+O/!, '-,O "-*!+!,!'&O,'O!%('+O+- O+&,&>O'*O, ,O, O+&,&O/+O!&O 0++O 'O , O %0!%-%O -, '*!2O 1O $/>O '*O !+O ', */!+O +-L ",O,'O'$$,*$O,,#>O%1O%'.O, O'-*,O/ ! O!%('+O, O +&,&O,'O.,>O+,O+!O'*O'**,O, O+&,&=O

!*#O '+O &',O .&O &1O 'O , +O *'-&+=O  O '+O &',O +1O, ,O *O+&,&O/+O!%('+O!&O.!'$,!'&O'O, O'&+,!L ,-,!'&O'*O$/+>O, ,O, O!+,*!,O'-*,O$#O"-*!+!,!'&>O, ,O , O+&,&O0+O, O$/-$O%0!%-%>O'*O, ,O!,O!+OH', L */!+O+-",O,'O'$$,*$O,,#I=O*O*-%&,>O*, *>O!+O , ,O ('+,L+&,&O .$'(%&,+O &,!,$O *O ,'O O */*O '*O ++!+,&=O -+,O +O ('+,L+&,&O *,*',!.O  &+O !&O , O &,&!&O -!$!&+O *O !%($%&,O -&*O 4;O ===O K68;5BCB5CO*, *O, &OK5588>O('+,L+&,&O++!+,&O,'O, O (*'+-,'*O (+++O '-,+!O , O +'(O 'O K5588=O
+! ! !! >O493O=6O463<>O4646O&=9OB44, O!*=O4<<;C>O'L +*.>O-$O68BCO(*'.!+OO%&+O,'O*-OO$$$1O!%L ('+O +&,&@O / &O , O '&.!,!'&O !+O (*'(*O &O , O +&L ,&O$/-$>OK5588O!+O-&.!$$=O -,O !,O *$1O '$$'/+O , ,O *.!/O -&*O , O

O !+O (L (*'(*!,N*.!/O , ,>O !.&O , O .&-O (*'.!+!'&+O !&O 5;O ===O K46<4BCB4C>O '-$O '-*O !&O %-$,!($O !+,*!,+>O !&$-L !&O , O !+,*!,O / *O , O (*!+'&*O !+O '&!&O &O , O !+L ,*!,O 'O '$-%!=O 'O %,,*O / ,O /O %#O 'O K5588O +O &O )-,O *%1O '*O , O (-*('+O 'O K:37>O !,O /'-$O O &O -& ((1O.$'(%&,O,'O+($!,OO*!%!&$O+O!&,'O*%&,+O &O .O!++-+O+- O+O-$O68BCO%',!'&+O$!,!,O !&O!+L ,*!,+O, ,O!O&',O '+,O, O*!%!&$O(*'+-,!'&=O 9O '=O49L579<O

$, '- O K5588O -+-$$1O !+O O (''*O /1O ,'O (*'>O !*#O '-$O .O!$O&O'*!&*1O%',!'&O!&O, O*!%!&$O+O+#L !&O , O "-O ,'O '%($O , O (*'+-,'*O ,'O !$O O -$O 68BCO %',!'&=O O ! ! ! >O 6<3O =6O 4336O B:, O !*=O 5337COB-+!&O, !+O(*'-*O,'O'&,+,O, O(*'+-,'*G+O!L +!'&O &',O ,'O !$O O %',!'&C=O !.&O -$O 68BCO , O "-O $#+O -, '*!,1O,'O*-O!*#G+O+&,&!O, O(*'+-,'*O!$+O O %',!'&>O -,O O + '/+O , ,O , O '-*,O +O , O ('/*O ,'O '%($O, O!$!&O'O+- OO%',!'&O!O, O*!,*!O'*O*.!/O'O (*'+-,'*!$O!+*,!'&O .O&O+,!+!=O -+O, *O&L &',OO&1O'-,O'-,O, O!+,*!,O'-*,G+O('/*O,'O&,*,!&O O %',!'&O +#!&O , O "-O '*O , ,O *$!=O
&O -+O , !+O #!&O'O%',!'&O!+OO'%($,O*%1O'*O+'%'&O!&O!*#G+O ('+!,!'&>O 8O ===O K:37O '*$'++O *+'*,O ,'O , O

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

O!+O&',O, O*! ,O/1O,'O+#O&O'**O'%L ($$!&O, O(*'+-,'*O,'O!$OO-$O68BCO%',!'&=O
 

O