James Gregory Troutman v. Kentucky Bar Association

• Court: Kentucky Supreme Court
• Decided: December 18, 2008
• Docket: 2008 SC 000833
• Status: Unknown

Opinion

TO BE PUBLISHED

,C~Vurf of ~6 I

sUFrrxrrt ic

2008-SC-00083 -KB

JAMES GREGORY TROUTMAN MOVANT

V. IN SUPREME COURT

KENTUCKY BAR ASSOCIATION RESPONDENT

OPINION .A,NU ORDER

Movant James Gregory Troutman over this Court to enter an order

suspending his license to practice law in Kentucky for a period of two years,

effective January 25, 2007 . The Kentucky Bar Association (KBA) states that it

has no objection to Troutman's motion. This Court therefore grants the motion

for a two-year suspension. Troutman was admitted to the practice of law in

Kentucky on October 16, 1992 . His bar roster address is 4000 Abbeywood

Village Drive, Louisville, KY 40241 . His KBA number is 84473 .

On January 25, 2007, Troutman entered an Alford plea in the Jefferson

Circuit Court to two counts of wanton endangerment in the first degree (a

Class D felony), one count of criminal mischief in the first degree (a Class D

felony), and one count of criminal littering (a Class A misdemeanor) . Upon entry of Troutman's Alford plea, pursuant to SCR. 3 .166, this Court entered a

order temporarily suspending him from the practic of law.'

Troutman entered the Alford plea as cult of a pretrial diversion

agreement with the Commonwealth . Pursuant to that agreement, the Circuit

Court ordered that Troutman undergo a two-year supervised probationary

period, at the conclusion of which the indictment would be dismissed.

The charges against Troutman arose from damage to property and other

conduct in and around Troutman's neighborhood late at night. Troutman

asserts that his conduct was the result of taking a large amount of over-the

counter allergy medication to control his severe allergies . Following his Alford

plea, Troutman moved the Circuit Court to shorten the term of his probation

and pretrial diversion. He presented the Circuit Court with medical

evaluations explaining that his behavior was the result of an antihistamine

overdose . The physicians who evaluated Troutman were of the opinion that he

was no longer impaired . On June 10, 2008, the Circuit Court entered an order

shortening the term of Troutman's probation and pretrial diversion . The court

ordered that the charges against Troutman be dismissed-diverted, pursuant to

KRS 533.258, with prejudice .

Although all criminal charges have been dismissed, Troutman concedes

that his entry of an Alford plea is proof that he engaged in conduct that

violated SCR 3 .130-8.3(b) ("It is professional misconduct for a lawyer to . . .

See Kentucky Bar Assn v. Troutman, 216 S.W.3d 652 (Ky. 2007). [c]ommit a cri final act that reflects adversely on the lawyer's honesty,

trustworthiness or fitness as a lawyer in other respects .") . Troutman believes

that two years, the original length of his probationary period, is an appropriate his length of time for suspension of license to practice law . The KBA agrees

that a suspension co ensurate with the length of the probationary period is

appropriate.2

This Court agrees with both parties that suspension for a period

commensurate with the length of the original probationary period is

appropriate. Therefore, it is hereby ORDERED that:

1 . James Gregory Troutman is suspended from the practice of law in the

Commonwealth of Kentucky for a period of two (2) years, retroactive to

January 25, 2007 .

2 . Troutman shall, in accordance with SCR 3 .390, notify all Courts in

which he has matters pending and all clients for whom he is actively

involved in litigation and similar matters of his inability to continue

representation . He shall provide copies of all letters to the Director of

the Kentucky Bar Association.

3 . Troutman shall, to the extent possible, immediately cancel and cease

any advertising activities in which he is engaged in accordance with

SCR 3.390 .

2 See Bertram v . Kentucky Bar Assn, 126 S.W.3d 358 (Ky. 2005) ; Kentucla Bar Assn v. Dunn, 90 S.W.3d 461 (Ky. 2002) ; Richendollar y. Kentucky Bar Assn, 60 S-W-3d 551 (Ky. 2001) (suspending attorneys form the practice of law until expiration of their probationary periods) . 4 . Purse nt CR 3.45 Trout ordered to pay all costs

associated with these disciplinary proceedings, certified in the amount

of $ 110 . 00, for which execution may issue from this Court upon

finality of this order.

All sitting. All concur.

ENTERED : December 18, 2008.