Ivanti v. Staylinked Corporation

• Court: District Court, D. Utah
• Decided: August 4, 2021
• Docket: 2:19-cv-00075
• Status: Unknown

Opinion

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

DISTRICT OF UTAH

MEMORANDUM DECISION IVANTI, INC., AND ORDER

Plaintiff, Case No. 2:19-cv-00075-RJS-JCB v.

STAYLINKED CORP., Chief District Judge Robert J. Shelby

Defendant. Magistrate Judge Jared C. Bennett

Before the court is Ivanti, Inc.’s (“Ivanti”) short form motion for a protective order in which it seeks to maintain a “Confidential—Attorney’s Eyes Only” (“CAEO”) designation for 734 documents that it produced in discovery to Staylinked Corp. (“Staylinked”) based on this court’s Standard Protective Order (“SPO”).1 On May 28, 2021, Ivanti submitted an Excel spreadsheet in native file format to the undersigned’s chambers after counsel for Staylinked had the opportunity to review it.2 On the spreadsheet, Ivanti listed the challenged documents and provided the reasons for its designation of CAEO. Staylinked provided counter- annotations on the spreadsheet opposing Ivanti’s proposed designations. Ivanti also submitted the documents to chambers for an in camera review of the CAEO designations.

1 ECF No. 69. 2 ECF No. 69-2. This court reviewed every document in camera and, on July 2, 2021, provided a tentative ruling on each by inserting a note on every line item in the spreadsheet that the parties previously submitted.3 The court’s tentative ruling also ordered simultaneous briefing, which the parties provided.4 The court held oral argument on July 27, 2021.5 After considering the information provided in the parties’ initial briefing, the court’s in camera review, the parties’ supplemental briefing, and oral argument, the court GRANTS IN PART AND DENIES IN PART Ivanti’s motion for protective order. To provide context for the court’s rulings on each document, the court first provides its view of the legal background for protecting documents. Thereafter, the court applies the legal background to the several categories of documents in the materials reviewed in camera. Next, the court explains the

terms that it uses in the spreadsheet to denote its specific rulings as to each document.6 Finally, the court discusses why it declines to award reasonable expenses under Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(a)(5)(C). LEGAL BACKGROUND

Because this dispute arises over a protective order, the court begins with the rule that governs protective orders: Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(c). Rule 26(c)(1) allows a court “for good cause”

3 ECF No. 74. 4 ECF Nos. 81, 82. 5 ECF No. 91. 6 A .pdf version of the spreadsheet will be attached to this document to memorialize the court’s rulings. However, the explanatory notes for each ruling are only available in the native file format for the spreadsheet, which will be distributed to the parties in a separate email since an Excel spreadsheet cannot be filed on CM/ECF. to “issue an order to protect a party or person from annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, or undue burden or expense.”7 As an example of this type of information, Rule 26(c)(1) provides that the court can order that “trade secret or other confidential research, development, or commercial information . . . be revealed only in a specified way.”8 Courts interpreting this provision under Rule 26 require that “[w]hen a party seeks such a protective order, it ‘must first establish that the information sought is a trade secret [or confidential information] and then demonstrate that its disclosure might be harmful.’”9 Based on Rule 26(c) and to make discovery more efficient, this court has adopted the SPO, which applies in every civil case that is filed in this district.10 The SPO requires disclosure of even confidential information in a “specified way.”11 Parties can designate discovery

“Confidential” or Confidential–Attorneys Eyes Only. To be CAEO, the discovery material must be “protected information,” (i.e., confidential or proprietary technical, scientific, financial, business, health, or medical information). Additionally, to warrant a CAEO designation, the “protected information” must be “past, current, or future” that includes five categories: (1) sensitive technical information; (2) sensitive business information; (3) competitive technical information; (4) competitive business information; and (5) “any other protected information the

7 Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(c)(1). 8 Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(c)(1)(G). 9 In re Cooper Tire & Rubber, Co., 568 F.3d 1180, 1190 (10th Cir. 2009) (citation omitted) (alteration added). 10 DUCivR 26-2(a)(1). 11 Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(c)(1)(G). disclosure of which to non-qualified people . . . would likely cause harm.”12 The wording of the

fifth category of CAEO information shows that categories (1)-(4) are also linked to Rule 26’s requirement to show “harm” to protect discovery material. Accordingly, based on Rule 26 and the SPO itself, to properly designate discovery material CAEO, the party seeking protection must establish that: (1) the material is “protected information”; (2) material falls into one of the five CAEO categories; and (3) releasing the protected information without the CAEO designation would cause harm to the releasing party.13 To determine whether discovery material is the type of protected information warranting protection, courts have considered multiple factors. For example, many courts have followed the Southern District of New York’s approach in United States v. International Business Machines,

Corp., 67 F.R.D. 40 (S.D.N.Y. 1975), which considered the following to determine whether a matter in discovery constituted a trade secret: (1) the extent to which the information is known outside of his business; (2) the extent to which it is known by employees and others involved in his business; (3) the extent of measures taken by him to guard the secrecy of the information; (4) the value of the information to him and to his competitors; (5) the amount of effort or money expended by him in developing the information; (6) the ease or difficulty with which the information could be properly acquired or duplicated by others.14

12 SPO, ¶ 2(b) (emphasis added) (capitalization omitted). 13 Id. 14 67 F.R.D. at 47. Courts use these same factors to determine whether material contains confidential business, commercial, financial, or technical information.15 But even if the information qualifies as “protected information” in one of the five CAEO categories, the party resisting discovery “must do more than simply allege that the documents are proprietary and confidential.”16 In addition, the party seeking protection must “set forth specific facts showing good cause, not simply conclusory statements.”17 “‘Competitive disadvantage is a type of harm cognizable under rule 26.’”18 CATEGORIAL DETERMINATIONS

Over the course of the court’s in camera review, the court came across several recurring issues and offers its opinion on each. First, regarding emails—the bulk of the documents at issue—the court notes the SPO’s requirement that parties must “designate only that part of a document or deposition that is confidential information or confidential information — attorney’s eyes only, rather than the entire document or deposition.”19 This requirement is significant because the court has found very few email records in which every email in the chain is CAEO.

15 See, e.g., S. New England Tel. Co. v. Glob. Naps, Inc., No. 04-CV-2075, 2008 WL 11492786, at *3 (D. Conn. June 19, 2008) (relying on six-factor test for determining whether “commercial information” warranted protection under protective order). 16 JTS Choice Enters., Inc. v. E.I. Du Pont De Nemours & Co., No. 11-CV-03143, 2013 WL 791438, at *2 (D. Colo. Mar. 4, 2013). 17 Id. 18 Id. (quoting Zenith Radio Corp. v. Matsushita Elec. Indus. Co., 529 F. Supp. 866, 890 (E.D. Pa. 1981)). 19 SPO, ¶ 4(g) (capitalization omitted). Ivanti has a duty to redact even if the record contains protected information that is CAEO. Withholding the entire document, which may contain parts that are not CAEO, is improper under the SPO. The court is unpersuaded that redacting is “unduly burdensome.” The court itself reviewed all the documents and is aware of how quickly documents can be redacted in Adobe Acrobat. Thus, redacting instead of withholding entire documents is the requirement here, too. Second, except for Zebra, the court believes that customer names must be redacted before sharing those documents with those other than counsel. Providing customer names to a competitor appears likely to cause Ivanti a competitive disadvantage. This is especially true where, as here, the basis for Staylinked’s requesting these documents was to obtain information about the problems with Ivanti’s product as a defense to Ivanti’s claim that Staylinked was

improperly stealing clients from Ivanti. Knowing the specific problems of Ivanti’s product on a specific customer’s system would provide any competitor with a competitive advantage. Redacting customer names should sufficiently alleviate the risk of competitive advantage because knowing the problems with Ivanti’s product without the customer identity makes the prospect of purposefully taking customers unlikely. Third, as mentioned in the preceding paragraph, many emails contain narrative discussions about problems that Ivanti or its customers were experiencing with certain software applications or hardware. In some emails, there are also actual error logs and code to fix the problems discussed in the emails. The court does not believe that discussions about a customer

having problems with the application’s buttons, for example, meets the requirements of “protected information” much less CAEO. In fact, the internet is replete with community fora that discuss troubleshooting of known problems of all sorts of products especially those of an electronic nature.20 Thus, a general awareness of product problems cannot be CAEO. Also, lists

of problems in Ivanti’s resolution queue, repair priority, who was assigned to fix them, or the exchange of pleasantries and jokes between employees, do not appear to the court to meet the definition of “protected information.” However, the computer-generated error logs, resource reports, kernel traces, and resources traces—although not “code” as that term is used among computer scientists21—appear to indicate how Ivanti’s products are running and may provide information as to which system is running them and the specific problems that system is having with Ivanti’s product. This provides a competitive advantage to Staylinked because it would be able to see the specific errors in Ivanti’s system, on specific systems, performing certain functions. That information

would be a helpful competitive marketing tool. Consequently, the logs on the spreadsheet marked as “code” will retain their CAEO status.22

20 For example, those who use Apple products can log on to Apple Support Communities, APPLE, https://discussions.apple.com/welcome (last visited Aug. 4, 2021), input the problem that a user is having with their Apple product, and a community of users will provide suggested remedies to the problem. The same type of forum exists for users of any Microsoft product. MICROSOFT, https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us (last visited Aug. 4, 2021). 21 ECF No. 85 at 5. 22 The court acknowledges and appreciates the declaration of Bryan S. Morse, who holds a doctorate Ph.D. in Computer Science. Dr. Morse makes a compelling case that the materials marked as “code” do not contain the “secret sauce” of Ivanti’s product in terms of its source code. Id. Dr. Morse also helpfully summarizes what the documents marked as “code” on the spreadsheet actually show. Id. at 4-8. The things contained in Dr. Morse’s helpful summary undoubtedly reveal how Ivanti’s product operates. Retail Ventures, Inc. v. Nat’l Union Fire Ins. Co. of Pittsburgh, Pa., 691 F.3d 821, 834 (6th Cir. 2012) (stating that information that shows how a business is operated may be treated as protected information). Although Dr. Morse opines that none of this information, with 14 possible exceptions, would “provide StayLinked with any competitive advantage,” ECF No. 85 at 5, the court is unsure the standard that Dr. Morse applied Fourth, many documents contain charts that also list revenues generated from specific customers. As counsel for Staylinked recognizes, disclosing the revenues to Ivanti’s competitor would place Ivanti at a competitive disadvantage. Therefore, these revenues (and customer names) can also be redacted prior to sharing with non-attorneys to avoid placing Ivanti at a competitive disadvantage. After redaction, these documents will not retain their CAEO designation. Fifth, there are several presentations that appear to have been made to the troubleshooting staff about their efficiency and future workload. Most of these are designated as LANDesk Reports. The court does not see how this generic information is protected or how its disclosure would harm Ivanti by giving Staylinked a competitive advantage. Thus, the CAEO designation

on these documents is denied. Sixth, the documents contain several meeting agendas, which are sometimes called “coreteam notes.” These appear to be invitations to a team meeting that also track who was in attendance and the topics that were or may have been discussed. The meeting topics are generally one or two words. At times there is a productivity chart attached. There are also documents that discuss potential training topics for both staff and external customers. These discussions are general and are usually limited to one or two-word topics. The court does not see

to reach that conclusion, especially where, as here, knowing how the product functions and how it errs when performing specific functions would be of benefit to a competitor. Although Staylinked may not review this information, its Technical Advisor certainly can, which still provides Staylinked with the ability to argue that Ivanti’s errors caused its customers to go to Staylinked. Therefore, the court is unwilling, at this point, to allow Staylinked to see the materials designated as “code.” how meeting agendas and general training topics constitute protected information much less show competitive harm for their disclosure especially given how old some of these meeting agendas are and how generically the training topics are listed. Therefore, these materials are denied CAEO designation. Seventh, the documents also contain several employee workplans that set goals and rate progress for a particular employee. Again, the court does not see how generic goals amount to protected information or meet the requirements of CAEO. The court does not understand how disclosure of a generic workplan would place Ivanti at a competitive disadvantage vis-à-vis its competitor. Accordingly, the CAEO status of these documents is denied. Finally, the documents contain a few manuals that belong to other companies. The court

does not see how these manuals that were shared with Ivanti could be considered Ivanti’s “protected information.” On the other hand, the court does not see how these manuals from other companies could be used in this litigation against Ivanti, but, in any event, they do not appear to meet the requirements for CAEO. Therefore, they are denied CAEO status. GUIDE TO THE COURT’S SPREADSHEET ANNOTATIONS

Given these general categorical observations, the court provides a key to its document- by-document rulings memorialized on the attached spreadsheet. Where the court denies protection for a document, the column labeled “Court Disposition” will include the word “No.” The explanation for that ruling is contained in a note attached to each cell, which is available only in the native file format of Excel, which the parties will receive via separate correspondence. For documents that may contain some CAEO information, the court uses “Partial” and explains that designation in an explanatory note attached to each cell in the native file format of the Excel spreadsheet. As to a document that the court rules is entirely protected, the court uses the word “Protected.” Where a document shares the same resolution as another version of that same document, the court uses “Same as above” or “Same as [specific number].” For such designations, the parties are directed to the designated cell for the court’s more specific explanation of the court’s ruling on that document. DECLINATION OF REASONABLE EXPENSES UNDER FED. R. CIV. P. 37

The court declines to impose reasonable expenses for bringing and defending against Ivanti’s Motion for Protective Order because the arguments are substantially justified. Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(a)(5)(C) provides that “[i]f the motion is granted in part and denied in part, the court may, after giving an opportunity to be heard, apportion the reasonable expenses for the motion.” Rule 37(a)(5)(A) and (B) provide the standards as to when fees should not be awarded. Specifically, both state that fees must be awarded unless the arguments of the losing party are “substantially justified.”23 “Substantially justified” is a familiar term to those who have ever worked with the Equal Access to Justice Act (“EAJA”).24 EAJA allows a “prevailing party” to collect attorney fees against the United States government unless the United States’ litigating position was “substantially justified.”25 The United States Supreme Court held that a position is substantially justified if it is “justified in substance or in the main—that is, justified to a degree that could

23 Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(a)(5)(A)-(B). 24 28 U.S.C. § 2412(d)(1)(A). 25 Id. satisfy a reasonable person.”26 Stated differently, a government position is substantially justified

“if it has a reasonable basis in both law and fact.”27 Where, as here, Rule 37 employs the same term of art as EAJA for the same purpose of awarding costs and attorney’s fees, the court borrows from EAJA jurisprudence to determine substantial justification.28 After a thorough review of the documents, the court observes that there were a few instances of what the court considers to be over designation of CAEO materials and a few instances in which the designation should not have been challenged because it was clearly warranted. However, any over designation and any misplaced opposition to designation are insufficient to convince the court that the arguments on which the parties relied lacked a reasonable basis in law or fact. Therefore, given the additional discretion entrusted to the court

for granting in part and denying in party Ivanti’s motion (i.e., “the court may . . . apportion the reasonable expenses for the motion”),29 the court declines to award reasonable expenses including attorney’s fees.

26 Pierce v. Underwood, 487 U.S. 552, 565 (1988). 27 Hanover Potato Prods., Inc. v. Shalala, 989 F.2d 123, 128 (3d Cir. 1993). 28 Lawson v. FMR LLC, 571 U.S. 429, 459 (2014) (“[P]arallel text and purposes counsel in favor of interpreting . . . provisions consistently.”); Northcross v. Bd. of Educ. of Memphis City Sch., 412 U.S. 427, 428 (1973) (per curiam) (stating that when two provisions of different statutes share similar language, that is a “strong indication” they are to be interpreted consistently); Morissette v. United States, 342 U.S. 246, 263 (1952) (explaining that “where Congress borrows terms of art” it also borrows their meaning). 29 Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(a)(5)(C). ORDER Based on the foregoing, the court orders Ivanti to produce copies of the documents reviewed in camera with redactions as set out above within 60 days of this order. DATED this 4th day of August 2021. BY THE COURT:

JARED C. BENNETT United States Magistrate Judge

Case 2:19-cv-00075-RJS-JCB Document 93 Filed 08/04/21 PageID.1923 Page 13 of 22

BegDoc EndDoc Ivanti Reason Ivanti Subreason StayLinked Challenge Year Court Disposition Category IVANTI009594 IVANTI009594 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer name may be redacted 2014 No Meeting agenda IVANTI010398 IVANTI010398 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2006 No Email IVANTI010995 IVANTI010995 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2006 No Meeting invite IVANTI011475 IVANTI011495 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2014 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI011496 IVANTI011543 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2014 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI011544 IVANTI011592 Sensitive Business Information Confidential Financial and Marketing Presentation Outdated and routine report 2014 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI011593 IVANTI011600 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2014 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI011601 IVANTI011608 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2014 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI011609 IVANTI011616 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2014 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI011617 IVANTI011663 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2014 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI011664 IVANTI011714 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2014 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI011717 IVANTI011726 Competitive Technical Information Technical Analysis or Comparison of Competitor Products Public "sales@naurtech.com" 2014 No Sales presentation IVANTI011727 IVANTI011736 Competitive Technical Information Technical Analysis or Comparison of Competitor Products Public "sales@naurtech.com" 2014 No Sales presentation IVANTI011737 IVANTI011743 Competitive Technical Information Technical Analysis or Comparison of Competitor Products Public "sales@naurtech.com" 2014 No Sales presentation IVANTI011744 IVANTI011773 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2015 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI011774 IVANTI011803 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2015 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI011867 IVANTI011897 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2015 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI011901 IVANTI011949 Sensitive Business Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2015 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI012006 IVANTI012015 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Product information re public release 2015 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI012016 IVANTI012044 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2015 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI012130 IVANTI012152 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2015 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI012154 IVANTI012159 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Product information re public release 2015 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI012160 IVANTI012187 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2015 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI012190 IVANTI012199 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2015 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI012200 IVANTI012205 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2015 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI012302 IVANTI012307 Competitive Technical Information Technical Analysis or Comparison of Competitor Products StayLinked's product information 2016 No Email IVANTI012358 IVANTI012380 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2016 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI012383 IVANTI012384 Competitive Technical Information Technical Analysis or Comparison of Competitor Products StayLinked's product information 2016 No Email IVANTI012427 IVANTI012428 Competitive Technical Information Technical Analysis or Comparison of Competitor Products StayLinked's product information 2016 No Email IVANTI012429 IVANTI012431 Competitive Technical Information Technical Analysis or Comparison of Competitor Products Customer name may be redacted 2016 No Email IVANTI012432 IVANTI012434 Competitive Technical Information Technical Analysis or Comparison of Competitor Products StayLinked's product information 2016 No Email IVANTI012436 IVANTI012436 Competitive Technical Information Technical Analysis or Comparison of Competitor Products StayLinked's product information 2016 No Email IVANTI012437 IVANTI012437 Competitive Technical Information Technical Analysis or Comparison of Competitor Products StayLinked's product information 2016 No Email IVANTI012438 IVANTI012463 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2016 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI012464 IVANTI012489 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2016 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI012497 IVANTI012499 Sensitive Business Information Confidential Financial and Marketing Information Sensitive information may be redacted 2016 No Performance Appraisal IVANTI012514 IVANTI012516 Sensitive Business Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected 12516 but NO ON REST Email IVANTI012517 IVANTI012519 Sensitive Business Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above (Protected 12519) No on rest Email IVANTI012523 IVANTI012527 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Sensitive information may be redacted 2016 Protected 12523-25 (script) no on rest Performance Appraisal IVANTI012565 IVANTI012566 Sensitive Business Information Confidential Financial and Marketing Information Sensitive information may be redacted 2016 No Performance Appraisal IVANTI012570 IVANTI012571 Sensitive Business Information Confidential Financial and Marketing Information Sensitive information may be redacted 2016 No Performance Appraisal IVANTI012572 IVANTI012576 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Sensitive information may be redacted 2016 Protected 12572-74 (script); no on rest Performance Appraisal IVANTI012585 IVANTI012591 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Product information re public release 2016 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI012601 IVANTI012606 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Outdated and routine report 2016 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI012622 IVANTI012624 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI012625 IVANTI012628 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI012629 IVANTI012632 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI012633 IVANTI012636 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI012637 IVANTI012640 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI012641 IVANTI012645 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI012647 IVANTI012649 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Customer names Protected; rest no Email IVANTI012658 IVANTI012665 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Customer name Protected, rest no Email IVANTI012666 IVANTI012673 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Customer name Protected, rest no Email IVANTI012674 IVANTI012681 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Customer name Protected, rest no Email IVANTI012682 IVANTI012689 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Customer name Protected, rest no Email IVANTI012690 IVANTI012693 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI012696 IVANTI012704 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Customer name Protected, rest no Email IVANTI012705 IVANTI012708 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI012709 IVANTI012717 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Customer name Protected, rest no Email IVANTI012718 IVANTI012725 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Customer name Protected, rest no Email IVANTI012726 IVANTI012734 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Customer name Protected, rest no Email IVANTI012735 IVANTI012743 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Customer name Protected, rest no Email IVANTI012744 IVANTI012746 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Ivanti public information 2016 Protected the script code; rest no Email IVANTI012751 IVANTI012760 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Customer name Protected, rest no Email IVANTI012761 IVANTI012770 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Customer name Protected, rest no Email IVANTI012771 IVANTI012781 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Customer name Protected, rest no Email IVANTI012782 IVANTI012792 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Customer name Protected, rest no Email IVANTI012798 IVANTI012802 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email Case 2:19-cv-00075-RJS-JCB Document 93 Filed 08/04/21 PageID.1924 Page 14 of 22

Protected first email discussing code; rest no for IVANTI012803 IVANTI012807 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 reasons stated above Email Protected first email discussing code; no on rest IVANTI012877 IVANTI012882 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Email IVANTI012886 IVANTI012891 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No for reasons in 12798 Email IVANTI012917 IVANTI012919 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer name may be redacted 2016 Protected first and alst email; rest no Email IVANTI012920 IVANTI012942 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Public "Copyright © 2014 Woolworths Limited" 2016 No Manual IVANTI012943 IVANTI012944 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI012955 IVANTI012960 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Zebra user guide 2016 No Manual IVANTI013117 IVANTI013117 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout "Copyright © 2014 Symbol" 2016 Not sure; is this Ivanti's? Script IVANTI013118 IVANTI013120 Sensitive Business Information Customer License or Contract Information Zebra End User License Agreement (EULA) 2016 No; Not Ivanti's License Agreement Protected sample code at 13124; no on rest IVANTI013121 IVANTI013130 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Email Protected sample code at 13124; no on rest IVANTI013131 IVANTI013140 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Email Protected sample code at 13145; no on rest IVANTI013141 IVANTI013151 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Email Protected sample code at 13156; no on rest IVANTI013152 IVANTI013162 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Email IVANTI013163 IVANTI013165 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013166 IVANTI013169 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email Protected sample code at 13175; no on rest IVANTI013170 IVANTI013180 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Email Protected sample code at 13186; no on rest IVANTI013181 IVANTI013192 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Email IVANTI013194 IVANTI013197 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013202 IVANTI013202 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013211 IVANTI013212 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013213 IVANTI013216 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013217 IVANTI013219 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; same as above Email IVANTI013226 IVANTI013227 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; same as above Email IVANTI013228 IVANTI013229 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; same as above Email IVANTI013230 IVANTI013233 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No: same as above Email IVANTI013234 IVANTI013235 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No: same as above Email IVANTI013236 IVANTI013237 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; same as above Email IVANTI013238 IVANTI013247 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; same as above; Email IVANTI013248 IVANTI013250 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013251 IVANTI013255 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013256 IVANTI013256 Sensitive Business Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013258 IVANTI013261 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; where is the code? Email IVANTI013262 IVANTI013265 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; same email series as above Email IVANTI013266 IVANTI013267 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; what code? Email IVANTI013269 IVANTI013271 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; same string as above Email IVANTI013272 IVANTI013274 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; same string as above Email IVANTI013275 IVANTI013277 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; same string as above Email IVANTI013279 IVANTI013281 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; same string as above Email IVANTI013282 IVANTI013284 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; same as above Email IVANTI013285 IVANTI013287 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; describes problem not code Email IVANTI013288 IVANTI013290 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013291 IVANTI013293 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013294 IVANTI013301 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013308 IVANTI013309 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013310 IVANTI013311 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; same as above Email IVANTI013312 IVANTI013313 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; same as above Email IVANTI013314 IVANTI013315 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No; same as above Email IVANTI013316 IVANTI013319 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013328 IVANTI013330 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email Case 2:19-cv-00075-RJS-JCB Document 93 Filed 08/04/21 PageID.1925 Page 15 of 22

IVANTI013331 IVANTI013332 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names and revenue may be redacted 2016 No Email IVANTI013333 IVANTI013336 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names and revenue may be redacted 2016 No Email IVANTI013337 IVANTI013340 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names and revenue may be redacted 2016 No; same as above Email IVANTI013341 IVANTI013342 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Not sure Email IVANTI013343 IVANTI013343 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Not sure Email IVANTI013344 IVANTI013344 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI013364 IVANTI013371 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013372 IVANTI013379 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI013380 IVANTI013387 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI013391 IVANTI013393 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names and revenue may be redacted 2016 No; same as 13331 et al. Email IVANTI013417 IVANTI013417 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013432 IVANTI013435 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013438 IVANTI013438 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013439 IVANTI013442 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013443 IVANTI013444 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 No Email IVANTI013509 IVANTI013510 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013512 IVANTI013518 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013519 IVANTI013519 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013520 IVANTI013520 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI013521 IVANTI013522 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI013523 IVANTI013523 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI013549 IVANTI013550 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI013551 IVANTI013552 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI013572 IVANTI013575 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names and revenue may be redacted 2016 No; (revenue yes) Email IVANTI013591 IVANTI013593 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013594 IVANTI013596 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI013597 IVANTI013599 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names and revenue may be redacted 2016 Same as 13572 Email IVANTI013663 IVANTI013665 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 No Email IVANTI013675 IVANTI013681 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Product information re public release 2016 No LanDesk Report IVANTI013692 IVANTI013693 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer name may be redacted 2016 No Email IVANTI013694 IVANTI013708 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Product information re public release 2016 No LanDesk Report IVANTI013710 IVANTI013724 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Product information re public release 2016 No LanDesk Report IVANTI013726 IVANTI013740 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Product information re public release 2016 Same as above LanDesk Report IVANTI013802 IVANTI013805 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013806 IVANTI013809 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI013810 IVANTI013813 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI013814 IVANTI013818 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013822 IVANTI013836 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected the code and the hierarchy; rest no Email IVANTI013837 IVANTI013851 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI013852 IVANTI013853 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names and revenue may be redacted 2016 Same as 13572 Email IVANTI013855 IVANTI013858 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 No Email IVANTI013954 IVANTI013961 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013962 IVANTI013964 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013965 IVANTI013973 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 13954 Email IVANTI013974 IVANTI013975 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI013976 IVANTI013984 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 13954 Email IVANTI013985 IVANTI013986 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer name may be redacted 2016 Same as 13974 Email IVANTI013990 IVANTI013999 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 13954 Email IVANTI014003 IVANTI014005 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer name may be redacted 2016 No Email IVANTI014006 IVANTI014009 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer name may be redacted 2016 No Email IVANTI014010 IVANTI014014 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI014015 IVANTI014020 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 14010 Email IVANTI014021 IVANTI014023 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI014024 IVANTI014024 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI014025 IVANTI014097 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI014098 IVANTI014285 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI014286 IVANTI014347 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI014348 IVANTI014566 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI014567 IVANTI014704 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI014705 IVANTI014885 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI014886 IVANTI014915 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI014916 IVANTI014916 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI014917 IVANTI014917 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI014918 IVANTI015079 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI015080 IVANTI015241 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI015242 IVANTI015403 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI015404 IVANTI015565 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI015566 IVANTI015727 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI015728 IVANTI015889 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code Case 2:19-cv-00075-RJS-JCB Document 93 Filed 08/04/21 PageID.1926 Page 16 of 22

IVANTI015890 IVANTI016051 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI016052 IVANTI016213 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI016214 IVANTI016375 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI016376 IVANTI016537 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI016538 IVANTI016699 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI016700 IVANTI016862 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI016863 IVANTI017025 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI017026 IVANTI017187 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI017188 IVANTI017350 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI017351 IVANTI017513 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI017514 IVANTI017676 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI017677 IVANTI017840 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI017841 IVANTI018004 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI018005 IVANTI018168 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI018169 IVANTI018332 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI018333 IVANTI018496 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI018497 IVANTI018659 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI018660 IVANTI018823 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI018824 IVANTI018987 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI018988 IVANTI019151 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI019152 IVANTI019315 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI019316 IVANTI019480 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI019481 IVANTI019644 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI019645 IVANTI019808 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI019809 IVANTI019972 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI019973 IVANTI020136 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI020137 IVANTI020301 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI020302 IVANTI020466 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI020467 IVANTI020630 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI020631 IVANTI020795 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI020796 IVANTI020959 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI020960 IVANTI021124 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI021125 IVANTI021289 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI021290 IVANTI021454 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI021455 IVANTI021619 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI021620 IVANTI021784 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI021785 IVANTI021950 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI021951 IVANTI022115 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI022116 IVANTI022280 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI022281 IVANTI022446 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI022447 IVANTI022612 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI022613 IVANTI022778 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI022779 IVANTI022944 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI022945 IVANTI023111 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI023112 IVANTI023228 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI023229 IVANTI023394 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI023395 IVANTI023560 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI023561 IVANTI023726 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI023727 IVANTI023892 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI023893 IVANTI024058 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI024059 IVANTI024225 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI024226 IVANTI024391 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI024392 IVANTI024558 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI024559 IVANTI024724 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI024725 IVANTI024891 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI024892 IVANTI025058 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI025059 IVANTI025225 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI025226 IVANTI025392 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI025393 IVANTI025559 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI025560 IVANTI025726 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI025727 IVANTI025893 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI025894 IVANTI026060 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI026061 IVANTI026227 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI026228 IVANTI026394 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI026395 IVANTI026561 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI026562 IVANTI026729 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI026730 IVANTI026896 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI026897 IVANTI027064 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI027065 IVANTI027232 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code Case 2:19-cv-00075-RJS-JCB Document 93 Filed 08/04/21 PageID.1927 Page 17 of 22

IVANTI027233 IVANTI027401 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI027402 IVANTI027569 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI027570 IVANTI027737 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI027738 IVANTI027906 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI027907 IVANTI028074 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI028075 IVANTI028242 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI028243 IVANTI028410 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI028411 IVANTI028579 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI028580 IVANTI028747 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI028748 IVANTI028917 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI028918 IVANTI029086 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI029087 IVANTI029255 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI029256 IVANTI029424 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI029425 IVANTI029593 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI029594 IVANTI029769 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI029770 IVANTI029949 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI029950 IVANTI030108 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI030109 IVANTI030321 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI030322 IVANTI030572 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI030573 IVANTI030851 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI030852 IVANTI031139 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI031140 IVANTI031205 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI031206 IVANTI031355 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI031356 IVANTI031732 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI031733 IVANTI031940 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Code IVANTI031941 IVANTI031941 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI031942 IVANTI031943 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI031944 IVANTI031949 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 14010 Email IVANTI031950 IVANTI031951 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 31942 Email IVANTI031952 IVANTI031957 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI031958 IVANTI031964 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 14010 Email IVANTI031965 IVANTI031967 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 31942 Email IVANTI031968 IVANTI031976 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI031977 IVANTI031984 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI031989 IVANTI031991 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI031993 IVANTI031995 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI031996 IVANTI031999 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI032000 IVANTI032003 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 31993 Email IVANTI032004 IVANTI032006 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 31996 Email IVANTI032007 IVANTI032012 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI032013 IVANTI032017 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI032018 IVANTI032018 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI032019 IVANTI032165 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI032166 IVANTI032297 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI032298 IVANTI032449 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI032450 IVANTI032531 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI032532 IVANTI032708 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI032709 IVANTI032872 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI032873 IVANTI033045 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI033046 IVANTI033272 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI033273 IVANTI033543 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI033544 IVANTI033816 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI033817 IVANTI034089 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI034090 IVANTI034363 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI034364 IVANTI034638 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI034639 IVANTI034914 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI034915 IVANTI035201 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI035202 IVANTI035352 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI035353 IVANTI035595 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI035596 IVANTI036040 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI036041 IVANTI036537 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI036538 IVANTI037088 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI037089 IVANTI037126 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI037127 IVANTI037141 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI037142 IVANTI037342 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI037343 IVANTI037522 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI037523 IVANTI037761 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI037762 IVANTI037766 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI037767 IVANTI037776 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email Case 2:19-cv-00075-RJS-JCB Document 93 Filed 08/04/21 PageID.1928 Page 18 of 22

IVANTI037777 IVANTI037784 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI037785 IVANTI037793 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI037794 IVANTI037960 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI037961 IVANTI038149 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI038150 IVANTI038367 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI038368 IVANTI038476 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI038477 IVANTI038491 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI038492 IVANTI038575 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI038576 IVANTI038576 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI038577 IVANTI038758 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI038759 IVANTI038909 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI038910 IVANTI039060 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI039061 IVANTI039254 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI039255 IVANTI039502 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI039503 IVANTI039792 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI039793 IVANTI040138 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI040139 IVANTI040528 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI040529 IVANTI040922 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI040923 IVANTI041097 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI041098 IVANTI041341 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI041342 IVANTI041637 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI041638 IVANTI041644 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Protected Code IVANTI041827 IVANTI041835 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI041836 IVANTI041837 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI041838 IVANTI041840 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 No Email IVANTI041841 IVANTI041845 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI041849 IVANTI041849 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI041850 IVANTI041851 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI041852 IVANTI041872 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI041876 IVANTI041878 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI041879 IVANTI041883 Sensitive Business Information Email re Customer License, Sales, or Marketing Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI041894 IVANTI041896 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI041901 IVANTI041902 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 No Email IVANTI041903 IVANTI041908 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI041909 IVANTI041909 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Protected customers Email IVANTI041910 IVANTI041910 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI041911 IVANTI041911 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Same as 41909 Email IVANTI041912 IVANTI041918 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI041919 IVANTI041919 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Same as 41909 Email IVANTI041920 IVANTI041920 Sensitive Business Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI041921 IVANTI041922 Sensitive Business Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI041923 IVANTI041924 Sensitive Business Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI041925 IVANTI041926 Sensitive Business Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Same as 41909 Email IVANTI041927 IVANTI041928 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI041929 IVANTI041936 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI041937 IVANTI041938 Sensitive Business Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Protected customers Email IVANTI041939 IVANTI041939 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI041940 IVANTI041943 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI041944 IVANTI041948 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI041949 IVANTI041951 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI041952 IVANTI041954 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI041955 IVANTI041957 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI041958 IVANTI041961 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI041962 IVANTI041965 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI041966 IVANTI041969 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI041970 IVANTI041973 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042003 IVANTI042007 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042008 IVANTI042012 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042013 IVANTI042017 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042018 IVANTI042023 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042033 IVANTI042034 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 41939 Email IVANTI042042 IVANTI042043 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042044 IVANTI042045 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042046 IVANTI042046 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042048 IVANTI042049 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Technical Training Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042050 IVANTI042052 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042053 IVANTI042055 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042056 IVANTI042058 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 42042 Email IVANTI042059 IVANTI042061 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 No Email Case 2:19-cv-00075-RJS-JCB Document 93 Filed 08/04/21 PageID.1929 Page 19 of 22

IVANTI042062 IVANTI042067 Sensitive Business Information Confidential Financial and Marketing Presentation Outdated and routine report 2016 No LAN Desk Report IVANTI042068 IVANTI042070 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042071 IVANTI042073 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same Email IVANTI042079 IVANTI042082 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same Email IVANTI042089 IVANTI042097 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042117 IVANTI042119 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Partial Email IVANTI042124 IVANTI042127 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042128 IVANTI042131 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042133 IVANTI042136 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042137 IVANTI042140 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042141 IVANTI042144 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042149 IVANTI042153 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Sensitive information may be redacted 2016 No Work Plan IVANTI042256 IVANTI042263 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 42089 Email IVANTI042264 IVANTI042271 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042272 IVANTI042279 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042280 IVANTI042289 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI042290 IVANTI042300 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042301 IVANTI042308 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 42089 Email IVANTI042310 IVANTI042314 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Sensitive information may be redacted 2016 Same as 42149 Work Plan IVANTI042315 IVANTI042318 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names and revenue may be redacted 2016 Partial Email IVANTI042319 IVANTI042327 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 42089 Email IVANTI042328 IVANTI042336 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 42089 Email IVANTI042337 IVANTI042345 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 42089 Email IVANTI042346 IVANTI042354 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 42089 Email IVANTI042355 IVANTI042364 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 42089 Email IVANTI042365 IVANTI042374 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 42089 Email IVANTI042375 IVANTI042384 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 42089 Email IVANTI042385 IVANTI042394 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 42089 Email IVANTI042395 IVANTI042403 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 42089 Email IVANTI042404 IVANTI042412 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 42089 Email IVANTI042415 IVANTI042416 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Partial Email IVANTI042441 IVANTI042444 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names and revenue may be redacted 2016 Partial Email IVANTI042445 IVANTI042448 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names and revenue may be redacted 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042449 IVANTI042452 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names and revenue may be redacted 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042453 IVANTI042456 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names and revenue may be redacted 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042457 IVANTI042461 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names and revenue may be redacted 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042462 IVANTI042463 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Partial Email IVANTI042465 IVANTI042469 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI042470 IVANTI042474 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042475 IVANTI042480 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042481 IVANTI042486 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042487 IVANTI042496 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI042497 IVANTI042506 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042513 IVANTI042519 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042520 IVANTI042523 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Technical Training Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042524 IVANTI042527 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Technical Training Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042528 IVANTI042532 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Technical Training Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042535 IVANTI042539 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Technical Training Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042540 IVANTI042544 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Technical Training Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042587 IVANTI042588 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Partial Email IVANTI042655 IVANTI042662 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names and revenue may be redacted 2016 Partial Email IVANTI042663 IVANTI042665 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042666 IVANTI042669 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042676 IVANTI042679 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042686 IVANTI042690 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042770 IVANTI042770 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042771 IVANTI042772 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042774 IVANTI042776 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Partial Email IVANTI042777 IVANTI042779 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042780 IVANTI042783 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042784 IVANTI042787 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042788 IVANTI042791 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI042792 IVANTI042795 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042796 IVANTI042800 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042801 IVANTI042805 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042806 IVANTI042810 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042811 IVANTI042816 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042817 IVANTI042822 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 42663 Email IVANTI042823 IVANTI042824 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email Case 2:19-cv-00075-RJS-JCB Document 93 Filed 08/04/21 PageID.1930 Page 20 of 22

IVANTI042825 IVANTI042830 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042831 IVANTI042836 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042837 IVANTI042838 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042839 IVANTI042844 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI042845 IVANTI042846 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042847 IVANTI042852 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI042867 IVANTI042869 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as 42845 Email IVANTI042873 IVANTI042875 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI042876 IVANTI042878 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI043007 IVANTI043026 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043027 IVANTI043048 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043049 IVANTI043051 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043052 IVANTI043053 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043054 IVANTI043059 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Partial Email IVANTI043060 IVANTI043079 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043080 IVANTI043101 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043102 IVANTI043104 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043105 IVANTI043106 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043107 IVANTI043112 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Partial Email IVANTI043113 IVANTI043118 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043119 IVANTI043125 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043126 IVANTI043132 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043133 IVANTI043139 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043140 IVANTI043146 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043147 IVANTI043151 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043152 IVANTI043171 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043172 IVANTI043193 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043194 IVANTI043196 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043197 IVANTI043198 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043205 IVANTI043211 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as 43107 Email IVANTI043212 IVANTI043219 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043220 IVANTI043227 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043228 IVANTI043235 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043236 IVANTI043243 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043244 IVANTI043251 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043252 IVANTI043260 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043261 IVANTI043269 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043270 IVANTI043278 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043279 IVANTI043287 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043288 IVANTI043296 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043297 IVANTI043305 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043306 IVANTI043315 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043316 IVANTI043325 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043326 IVANTI043335 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043336 IVANTI043345 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043346 IVANTI043356 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043357 IVANTI043367 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI043377 IVANTI043378 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI043379 IVANTI043380 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Same as above Email IVANTI043383 IVANTI043385 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer names may be redacted 2017 Partial Email IVANTI043407 IVANTI043408 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043409 IVANTI043410 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043411 IVANTI043421 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043422 IVANTI043423 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043424 IVANTI043434 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043435 IVANTI043436 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043437 IVANTI043441 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043442 IVANTI043443 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043444 IVANTI043457 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043458 IVANTI043459 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043460 IVANTI043463 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043464 IVANTI043480 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043481 IVANTI043487 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043488 IVANTI043523 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043524 IVANTI043531 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043532 IVANTI043534 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043535 IVANTI043540 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043541 IVANTI043569 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043571 IVANTI043581 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code Case 2:19-cv-00075-RJS-JCB Document 93 Filed 08/04/21 PageID.1931 Page 21 of 22

IVANTI043582 IVANTI043586 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043587 IVANTI043616 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043617 IVANTI043630 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043631 IVANTI043632 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043633 IVANTI043636 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043637 IVANTI043653 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043654 IVANTI043658 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043659 IVANTI043663 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043664 IVANTI043667 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043668 IVANTI043674 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043675 IVANTI043684 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043685 IVANTI043694 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043729 IVANTI043730 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043731 IVANTI043732 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043733 IVANTI043743 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043744 IVANTI043745 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043746 IVANTI043756 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043757 IVANTI043758 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043759 IVANTI043763 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043764 IVANTI043765 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043766 IVANTI043779 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043780 IVANTI043781 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043782 IVANTI043785 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043786 IVANTI043802 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043803 IVANTI043809 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043810 IVANTI043845 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043846 IVANTI043853 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043854 IVANTI043856 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043857 IVANTI043862 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043863 IVANTI043891 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043893 IVANTI043903 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043904 IVANTI043908 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043909 IVANTI043938 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043939 IVANTI043952 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043953 IVANTI043954 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043955 IVANTI043958 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043959 IVANTI043975 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043976 IVANTI043980 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043981 IVANTI043985 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043986 IVANTI043989 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043990 IVANTI043996 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI043997 IVANTI044006 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI044007 IVANTI044016 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Protected Code IVANTI044064 IVANTI044065 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 Partial Email IVANTI044066 IVANTI044069 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2016 No Email IVANTI044232 IVANTI044236 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Partial LAN Desk Report IVANTI044239 IVANTI044239 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 No Email IVANTI044243 IVANTI044243 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044245 IVANTI044246 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044311 IVANTI044315 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy StayLinked public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044316 IVANTI044321 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy Ivanti public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044322 IVANTI044327 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy Third-party public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044328 IVANTI044333 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy Third-party public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044354 IVANTI044359 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy Ivanti/StayLinked public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044360 IVANTI044365 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy Ivanti/StayLinked public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044366 IVANTI044372 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy Ivanti public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044373 IVANTI044373 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy Ivanti public information 2017 No Email IVANTI044374 IVANTI044375 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy Ivanti public information 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044376 IVANTI044377 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy Ivanti public information 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044378 IVANTI044380 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy Ivanti public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044381 IVANTI044383 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy Ivanti public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044384 IVANTI044386 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy Ivanti public information 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044387 IVANTI044390 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy Ivanti public information 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044391 IVANTI044394 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy Ivanti/StayLinked public information 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044395 IVANTI044398 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy Ivanti/StayLinked public information 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044443 IVANTI044444 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Ivanti public information 2017 No Email IVANTI044445 IVANTI044446 Competitive Business Information Comparison of Competitor Product and Strategy StayLinked/third-party public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044501 IVANTI044504 Competitive Technical Information Technical Analysis or Comparison of Competitor Products StayLinked public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044505 IVANTI044508 Competitive Technical Information Technical Analysis or Comparison of Competitor Products StayLinked public information 2017 Same as above Email Case 2:19-cv-00075-RJS-JCB Document 93 Filed 08/04/21 PageID.1932 Page 22 of 22

IVANTI044509 IVANTI044513 Competitive Technical Information Technical Analysis or Comparison of Competitor Products Public domain information 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044514 IVANTI044518 Competitive Technical Information Technical Analysis or Comparison of Competitor Products StayLinked public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044535 IVANTI044537 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 No Email IVANTI044538 IVANTI044540 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044541 IVANTI044544 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044545 IVANTI044547 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044548 IVANTI044551 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044552 IVANTI044555 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044556 IVANTI044560 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044561 IVANTI044567 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Protected Email IVANTI044568 IVANTI044571 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044572 IVANTI044575 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044576 IVANTI044579 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044580 IVANTI044587 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044588 IVANTI044596 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044597 IVANTI044605 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044606 IVANTI044614 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Partial Email IVANTI044615 IVANTI044623 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044624 IVANTI044633 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044634 IVANTI044643 Sensitive Business Information Email re Highly Sensitive Financial or Marketing Information Primarily public information 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044651 IVANTI044657 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 No Email IVANTI044665 IVANTI044668 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044702 IVANTI044706 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044707 IVANTI044711 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044713 IVANTI044717 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044719 IVANTI044748 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Public "Welcome everyone! And thank you for joining us for this Ivanti session." 2017 No Client Presentation IVANTI044749 IVANTI044760 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Client Presentation IVANTI044761 IVANTI044765 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 No Email IVANTI044766 IVANTI044770 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044771 IVANTI044775 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044776 IVANTI044780 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI044781 IVANTI044785 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2017 Same as above Email IVANTI045349 IVANTI045384 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Public "Copyright © 2017 Daniel Eden" 2018 Protected Code IVANTI045626 IVANTI045635 Sensitive Technical Information Presentation re Technical Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2018 No Presentation IVANTI046698 IVANTI046698 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Code Fix/Change for Customers Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2018 Partial Email IVANTI046699 IVANTI046701 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2018 Partial Email IVANTI046702 IVANTI047168 Sensitive Technical Information Code or Log Printout Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2018 Protected Code IVANTI047530 IVANTI047530 Sensitive Technical Information Email re Development Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2019 No Meeting agenda IVANTI048412 IVANTI048888 Sensitive Business Information Customer Pricing Data Public "For more information on our products: www.honeywellaidc.com" 2020 No Customer manual IVANTI048889 IVANTI048890 Sensitive Business Information Customer Pricing Data Public "©2020 Honeywell International, Inc." 2020 Same as above Customer policy IVANTI049019 IVANTI049019 Sensitive Business Information Customer Pricing Data Customer-facing subject matter, oudated, and not secret 2020 Partial Email IVANTI049020 IVANTI049489 Sensitive Business Information Customer Pricing Data Public "For more information on our products: www.honeywellaidc.com" 2020 Same as 48412 Customer manual IVANTI049490 IVANTI049491 Sensitive Business Information Customer Pricing Data Public "©2020 Honeywell International, Inc." 2020 Same as 48889 Customer policy IVANTI049524 IVANTI050013 Sensitive Business Information Customer Pricing Data Public "For more information on our products: www.honeywellaidc.com" 2021 Same as 48412 Customer manual IVANTI050058 IVANTI050521 Sensitive Business Information Customer Pricing Data Public "For more information on our products: www.honeywellaidc.com" 2021 Same as 48412 Customer manual IVANTI050522 IVANTI050522 Sensitive Business Information Financial and Marketing Spreadsheet Public "For more information on our products: www.honeywellaidc.com" 2021 No Spreadsheet IVANTI053517 IVANTI053933 Sensitive Business Information Customer Pricing Data Public "For more information on our products: www.honeywellaidc.com" 2021 Same as 48412 Customer manual IVANTI053934 IVANTI053934 Sensitive Business Information Financial and Marketing Spreadsheet Public "For more information on our products: www.honeywellaidc.com" 2021 Same as 50522 Spreadsheet