Irish v. Profitt

330 N.E.2d 861, 28 Ill. App. 3d 607, 1975 Ill. App. LEXIS 2301
CourtAppellate Court of Illinois
DecidedMay 22, 1975
Docket12642
StatusPublished
Cited by5 cases

This text of 330 N.E.2d 861 (Irish v. Profitt) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Appellate Court of Illinois primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Irish v. Profitt, 330 N.E.2d 861, 28 Ill. App. 3d 607, 1975 Ill. App. LEXIS 2301 (Ill. Ct. App. 1975).

Opinion

Mr. PRESIDING JUSTICE SIMKINS

delivered the opinion, of the court:

Defendants appeal from an order of the circuit court of Logan County granting partition of 400 acres of farmland' devised by Article III of the will of John Wilson Robinson, who died on September 8, 1907, and whose will was admitted to probate on October 21,1907. The issue before this court .is whether the trial court erred in its interpretation of Article III and in its disposition of the farmland.

In Article;III, John Wilson Robinson (hereafter referred to as testator) devised life estates in the farmland in question to his nephew, Cincinnatus McLean, and to Benjamin and William McLean, children of the said Cincinnatus McLean. The testator further provided , as follows:

“* * * at the death of the last surviving of said children [Benjamin and William McLean] and nephew [Cincinnatus McLean] said lands shall be divided among the descendants of -the children * « * and if no such descendants are then living said lands shall be equally divided among the other beneficiaries of this will * * (Emphasis added.)

It is established that the date of distribution of the Article III property was August 5, 1969, the date of death of the last surviving life tenant, William McLean. It is also established that all the named devisees in Article III have died with no descendants surviving them. Therefore, it is agreed by all parties that said property “shall be divided equally among the other beneficiaries of this will * # It is the interpretation of this clause and the interests created thereby that is in dispute here.

It is first necessary to summarize the other relevant provisions of the will. Article II and Articles IV through VIII are similar to Article III in that they devise life estates in farmland to certain named legatees, usually a niece or nephew and his or her children or, at least, some of them. It is then provided that at the death of the last surviving named life estate legatee the land shall be divided among the descendants of certain named legatees, usually the descendants of certain children of ■the named niece or nephew. The life estate beneficiaries in Articles II through VIII of the will and their relationship to the testator are as follows:

1. James McLean, nephew

2. Frederick McLean, grandnephew

3. Lida C. McLean, grandniece

4. Mary Snyder, grandniece

5. Cincinnatus McLean, nephew

6. Benjamin McLean, grandnephew

7. William McLean, grandnephew

8. Maggie Stitt, niece

9. Wilse Stitt, grandniece

10. Don Stitt, grandnephew

11. Andrew P. Robinson, nephew

12. Elwynn P. Robinson, grandniece

13. Clark Robinson, grandnephew
14. Drew Robinson, grandnephew

15. John R. Bostwick, nephew

16. John W. Bryant, grandnephew

17. Lida Meyer, grandniece

18. lone Bryant, niece

19. Annie S. Irish, grandniece

20. John W. Irish, great-grandnephew

21. Harold R. Irish, great-grandnephew

Article IX grants timber rights to 18 of the above named devisees in Articles II, III, and V through VIII for 5 years on the tract of farmland devised by Article IV to Maggie, Wilse and Don Stitt. Article XI bequeaths household furniture and various personal effects to lone Bryant, a niece and life estate devisee under Article VII, and Annie S. Irish, a grandniece and life estate devisee under Article VIII. Article XIV is a residuary clause which states that, “I hereby wish and direct that all the stock agricultural implements and grain together with all other property owned by me at the time of my death and not otherwise disposed of in this instrument shall be equally divided among the following # There are 19 residuary legatees, all of whom were life estate devisees under Articles II through VIII, with the exception that John Bostwick is not a residuary legatee and Wilson Irish is added as a residuary legatee, and only Wilse Stitt and not her mother, Maggie Stitt, or her brother, Don Stitt, is named a residuary legatee. Article XVII devises any tract of land not disposed of to the owner of the land adjoining it (the life estate devisees under Articles II through VIII) upon the same terms as the adjoining land is given.

Article X makes specific bequests to named individuals none of whom were life estate devisees under Articles II through VIII or residuary legatees under Article XIV. These legatees, their relation to the testator, and the amount of their bequest is as follows:

1. Mary Milligan, sister, $50
2. Sarah McCoy, sister, $1000
3. Joseph McCoy, nephew, $300
4. Frederick Bostwick, nephew, $150
5. Darius Hicks, nephew, $200
6. Minnie Irish, grandniece, $200
7. Hannah Robinson, sister, $5
8. Heirs of Frank Hicks, nephew, $25
9. Mary Prather, niece, $50
10. Bell Eggleston, niece, $500
11. Mary Bostwick, grandniece, $50
12. Grace Bostwick, grandniece, $100

.13. Nettie James, grandniece, $50

14. Charley McLean, grandnephew, $50
15. Nellie McLean, grandniece, $280

The instant action was initiated on January 6, 1971, when plaintiffsappellees Harold Irish, John Irish, Clark Robinson, and Wilse Stitt filed a complaint for partition of the 400 acres of farmland devised by Article IH of the will. An order for partition was entered by the Logan County Circuit Court on February 1, 1974. It is from this order that various defendants-appellants have perfected the instant appeal.

The trial court in its final partition order stated that since Benjamin and William McLean died leaving no descendants surviving, title to the land in question passed to “the other beneficiaries” of the will of John Wilson Robinson. The court also affirmed its previous ruling that:

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

In Re Estate of Laas
480 N.E.2d 1183 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 1985)
Brown v. Leadley
401 N.E.2d 599 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 1980)
Evans v. Giles
399 N.E.2d 664 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 1980)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
330 N.E.2d 861, 28 Ill. App. 3d 607, 1975 Ill. App. LEXIS 2301, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/irish-v-profitt-illappct-1975.