Intercon Solutions, Inc. v. James Puckett

• Court: Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit
• Decided: June 29, 2015
• Docket: 13-3148
• Status: Published

Opinion

In the

United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIP

%=P24M4259P P >P =>P  %.
"">P ',P


P
 PP$P
P>P   %$.
"" %$=P IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIP

&&"P(%#P*P$*P**)P)*(*P%+(*P%(P*P %(*($P)*(*P%P ""$%)>P)*($P,)%$=P %=P23PP7925POP  
  >/ &=P IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIP

P
 P29>P3125POP P P3:>P3126P IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIP

%(P 
>P 
>P $P 
>/ #&%/

&$=P 
>/ #&%/ &=P $*(%$P %"+*%$)>P -P &(%,)P (/"$P )(,)P %(P "*(%$P ,)>P $P )"P
*%$P*-%(!PA
BP*%P,"+*P*)P+)$))=P $*(M %$P )!P 
P *%P (*/P *P )P $P $,(%$#$*""/P ($"/P %&(*%$=P 
P %$"+>P %-,(>P **P $*(%$P )&)P 0(%+)P-)*P*%P$>P*%P(#)P**P+)P#*%)P%P)M &%)"P **P ,%"*P *P &%"/P %P ""$%)>P -(P $*(%$P )P 3P %=P24M4259P

)>P$P(P$%$))*$*P-*P $*(%$F)P&+"P(&()$M **%$)P %+*P *)P &(*)=P 
P %##+$*P *)P %$"+M )%$P *%P *-%P $)P A%$P )**P $P %$P ("BP $P *%P *P &+"=P $*(%$P ()&%$P -*P *)P #*%$P *%$P +$M (P *P ,()*/P +()*%$=P P %#&"$*>P )P %$P ""M $%)P "->P "")P **P 
F)P )**#$*)P (P ")>P $P **P 
P!$%-)P*#P*%PP")=P P
P )P P )$*%$P %(&%(*%$P -*P *)P &($&"P &"P %P +)$))P $P **"=P P &(*)P (P **P 
F)P )**#$*)P -(P #P $P )$*%$P +*P -(P (+"*P -"/P $P ""$%)P A$P *%$P *%P $P )$*P (*"/P *%P *-%P $)BP$P**P ""$%)P"-P*(%(P%,($)P*P#M *%$P "#=P +*P $P $)-(P *%P *P %#&"$*P 
P ))(*P P $)P )P %$P )$*%$F)P $*M
P )**+*>P P KKP5=35=621>P5=35=636=P*%$P5=35=621P)P*P$*%$F)P()*P$*M 
P "->P $*P $P 2:9:@P K5=35=636P -)P P $P 3121=P 
P %$*$>P $P *P )*(*P %+(*P ">P **P ""$%)P A-%)P "-P %,($)P %M%M"-P ))+)BP -%+"P ,P 
P *P $*P %P *)P $)P +$(P )$*%$P "-P +)P 
P)P)P$P)$*%$P$P#P*)P)**#$*)P*(=P :7:P=P+&&=P3P2137>P2145N47PA==P ""=P3124B=P 
P)*$)P%(PG)*(*P"-)+*P$)*P&+"P&(*M &*%$=HP $/P )**)P ,P %$"+P **P )%#P *%$)P %(P #*%$P A$P P -P %*(P *%(*)BP (P ">P $%*P *%P &(,">P +*P*%P#&%)P%$P*P)&!(P*P%)*)P%P$)>P-P$P P )+)*$*"=P P %#)P =P +(!>P
%.
/ %%! P =P9PA3125BPA%""*$P)**P")"*%$B=P
$P$*M
P)**M +*P )P P )&"0P ,()%$P %P *P *%(*P %P +)P %P &(%))>P )$P*%P(+P$)P%)*)P/P(*$P$P)%"+*P%(P '+"P##+$*/>P$PA$P),("P)**)BP/P('+($P("/P )&%)*%$P%PP#%*%$P*%P)#))=P
P$$*P**P&(,")P %=P24M4259P 4P

%$P)+PP#%*%$P+)+""/P)P$**"P*%P(%,(P*)P%)*)P%P"*M *%$P$P#/PP$**"P*%P#)P)P-""=P P )$*%$P $*M
P )**+*P &(%,)P %*P $P ##+$*/P$PP('+(#$*P%P("/P)&%)*%$P%$PP&&(P (%(=P*%$P5=35=621P,)P*P$$*P##+$*/P(%#P ""*/P %(P )**#$*)P %##+$*P *%P P %,($#$*"P %/=P P )*(*P %+(*P %)(,P **P *)P %)P $%*P %,(P )**#$*)P**P
P#P(*"/P*%P*P&+"P%(P*%P $*(M %$F)P +)$))P (,")=P :7:P =P +&&=P 3P *P 2147N4:=P *%$P 5=35=636>P/P%$*()*>P&&")P*%PGCD$/P%("P)**#$*P#>P %(P-(**$P)**#$*P%(P%*(P%+#$*P)+#**>P$PP&"P %&$P *%P *P &+"P %(P P &+"P %(+#P $P %$$*%$P -*P $P ))+P %P &+"P %$($H=P P K5=35=636A3BAB=P %M($"/P (/"$P)P$P))+P%P&+"P%$($>P)%PK5=35=636P&&")P*%P ""P%P
F)P&+"P)**#$*)=P *%$P 5=35=636A5BABP &(#*)P P $$*P *%P "P P G)&M "P#%*%$P*%P)*(!HP*P%#&"$*>P%#&$P/PM ,*)P $P %*(P %+#$*)P )%-$P **P *P "#P G)P )P %$P $P *%$P $,%",$P &+"P &(*&*%$P $P &**%$=HP
$/P )**#$*P -*$P *P )%&P %P K5=35=636A3BP #*)P *)P )*$(=P P *P $)P )%-)P *)>P *$P *P +P #+)*P )#))P *P )+*P +$"))P *P &"$*P $P G)*")P /P "(P $P %$,$$P ,$P P &(%"*/P %P &(,"$P %$P *P "#=HP *%$P 5=35=636A6BP ('+()P .&*P *%$?P *P %+(*P #+)*P %"P P ($P -*$P 41P /)P $P ))+P P M )%$P -*$P 8P /)P %P *P ($=P $$P *P ($P $P )%$>P""P)%,(/P)P)*/PAK5=35=636A6BABB=P P*P%+(*P ($*)P *P #%*%$>P *P $$*P (%,()P **%($/)FP )>P %)*)>P$PP&$"*/P)PP)P;21>111PAK5=35=636A7BB=P P )*(*P %+(*P "$P *%P (+"P %$P 
F)P #%*%$>P %"$P **P P )&"P #%*%$P *%P )*(!P )P $%#&*"P -*P 5P %=P24M4259P

*P ("P +")P %P ,"P (%+(=P :7:P =P +&&=P 3P *P 2152N66=P P %+(*P ("P &(*+"("/P %$P +"P 23AB>P -P )/)P**>PPP#%*%$P()&%$$P*%PP%#&"$*P$"+)P$/P ,$>P G*P #%*%$P #+)*P P *(*P )P %$P %(P )+##(/P +#$*P +$(P +"P 67=HP 
F)P #%*%$P $"+P ),("P +$(P&)P%P,*)P$P%*(P%+#$*)=P ("P (+")P &(,"P $P ("P %+(*=P >P ==>P */ #!'/ #%!"/
$$!%$-/,
,/',/
$%%/ $&# /!=>P66:P ==P 4:4P A3121B@P #/ ',/
#!/ %/ !#"=>P 557P ==P 851P A2:91B@P  / ',/ &#>P 491P ==P 571P A2:76B=P %$())P $P "*(P ("P &"$P )*$()P $P %)%$""/P %)P )%>P )P $-/ ,/ ',/ !#/ $$&$/ +/ %$-/ %=>P 662P ==P 419P A3118BPA(,*P+(*)P**%$P%(#P
*P%P2::6B>P+*P )**)P"!PP%#&("P&%-(=P *P%""%-)>P*P)*(*P%+(*P ">P **P K5=35=636P $$%*P P &&"P $P ("P )+*)>P ,$P *%+P )%#P )&*)P %P *P )**+*>P )+P )P *P "(M$M %$,$$M,$P )*$(>P $P &(%,)%$)P %(P M )*$P$P&$"*)>P(P)+)*$*,P$P$*+(=P 
P ##*"/P &&"P (%#P *P )*(*P %+(*F)P %(M (P$/$P*)P#%*%$P*%P)#))P*P%#&"$*=P *P("P$P &(*P%$PK5=35=636A6BAB>P-P)/)P**PGCD,(/P&(*/P)PP (*P%P.&*P&&"P(%#PP*("P%+(*P%((HP()%",$P P)&"P#%*%$P*%P)*(!>P$P$P&(*P%$P*P%""*("M%((P %*($P %P ! / ',/  / &$%#/ ! / !#"=>P 448P ==P 652PA2:5:B=P
*P*P%("P(+#$*P%P*)P&&">P##()P%P *P &$"P .&())P )!&*)#P %+*P &&""*P +()*%$>P $%*$P**P)**P)**+*)P$$%*P.&$PA%(P%$*(*BP("P +()*%$P$P**P*P+&(#P%+(*P)P$P+$-""$P $P ($*P /()P *%P .&$P *P )%&P %P *P %""*("M%((P %*($=P >P ==>P !(/ &$%#$-/ ,/ ',/ #" %#>P 669P ==P211PA311:B=P
F)P#%*%$>P(P(%#P$PG%""*("HP*%P %=P24M4259P 6P

*P #(*)>P )P $P %(*P *%P -$P %+*(*=P
P $)P ()P (%#PP%""*("P#**(=P>P==>P %/%%$/',/! >P 546P==P961PA2:89B=P $)*P%P)#))$P*P&&"P##M *"/>P %-,(>P *P %+(*P ((P *%$P *%P ,P *P &(M *)P *#P *%P )!P %(P (**%$P +$(P 39P ===P K23:3AB=P %$0$P**P*PP*!$P))P%$P$P#&%(*$*P$PM *"P))+P**P)P%&$P$P*P,$*P(+*>P*P)*(*P %+(*P(*P*)P%((P%(P$*("%+*%(/P(,->P$P-PM P*%P&*P*P&&"P%$P**P)**+*F)P+*%(*/=P

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
# /#$$/ >P 677P =4P 275>P 292N93P A6*P (=P 311:BP A""P *(P %"$P **P )**P $*M
P "-)P #/P P &&"P *P *P )+##(/P +#$*P )*P %(P +)$P )**P &(%+("P (+")P (*"/P $P P ("P )B>P -*P
$/ ',/ !# / !*/ #!&"-/ >P 894P =4P2439>P2445N46PA==P(=P3126B@P/',/#&"/ '#. $%*-/ >P847P=4P2291>P2299N:3PA:*P(=P3124BPA*%(>P =>P %$P/P%0$)!>P0PP

=>P))$*$P(%#P*P$M "P%P(($P$P$BPA%$"+$P**P)**P"-)P#+)*PP &&"P )P -(**$>P -P +)+""/P #$)P **P )**+*)P )+P )PK5=35=636P$$%*PP+)P$P("P%+(*B=P 7P %=P24M4259P

)$*%$F)P)*P%+(*P$%-P)P*>P$P%+(P)P )P(/P%(P()%"+*%$=P'$/',/!)>P3126P)=P P679PA=P *=P )=P /P 39>P 3126B>P %")P **P K5=35=636P ,%"*)P *P )**F)P %$)**+*%$P +)P K5=35=636A5BABP ('+()P P +P *%P()%",P*+"P)&+*)P**P&(%&("/P"%$P*%PP +(/=P P%+(*P&(%P$P*(P)*&)=P()*>P*P)!P-*M (PK5=35=636A5BABP$PP+$()*%%P)PP%(#P%P)+##(/M +#$*P &(*=P A,("P ("P %+(*)P %P &&")P ,P *(*P )**P $*M
P )**+*)P **P -/>P $P 
P )P )!P+)P*%P%P)%P*%%=BPP%+(*P"P**PP)&"P#%*%$P *%P )*(!P )P $%*P P ,($*P %P )+##(/P +#$*>P +)P *P ('+()P +)P*%P()%",P#*("P*+"P)&+*)P%$PP&M &(P (%(>P -P *P )+##(/P +#$*P )*$(P &(%M *)=P3126P)=P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
)PP#**(P%P)$*%$P"->P*P+""P)**+*P)P +$$%("=P %=P24M4259P 8P

("P%+(*)P&&"/P*P-%"P%P)**P"->P$"+$P +M "P)%$)P)+P)P'$>P$P,()*/P"**%$=P#/,,/ ',/ !" $>P 415P ==P 75P A2:49B=P
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
P)**+*>P846P P221L2P*%P 221L46>P -P (*)P P '+"P ##+$*/P **P $P P (M )%",P $P ("P %+(*P %$P P #%*%$P %(P )+##(/P +#$*P %(P*P*("=PA846P P221L31P%$*$)PP-P&(%+("P(+")>P +*P */P (P (%#P K5=35=636>P $P 
P )P $%*P $,%!P *#@P$>P*P%)P$%*P#$*%$P*P ""$%)P)**+*P*P""=BP P*(%(P((,P*P*P)#P%+*%#P)P*P)*(*P%+(*>P +*P %$P *P %"$P %P '$P (*(P *$P *P )*(*P %+(*F)P ()%$)=P)P(+*F)P()%"+*%$P%P'+)*%$)P%+*P%-P*P 9P %=P24M4259P

&(%+("P)&*)P%P%*(P)**)FP$*M
P)**+*)P-%(!P $P("P%+(*P-""P,P*%P-*P)%#P%*(P)=P P &&"*%$P %(P ",P *%P &&"P +$(P §23:3ABP )P ($*>P$P*P)%$P)P
  =P