In the Matter of the Civil Commitment of J.R.

New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division·Decided November 12, 2025·No. A-3211-23·Unpublished

Opinion

RECORD IMPOUNDED

NOT FOR PUBLICATION WITHOUT THE APPROVAL OF THE APPELLATE DIVISION This opinion shall not "constitute precedent or be binding upon any court ." Although it is posted on the internet, this opinion is binding only on the parties in the case and its use in other cases is limited . R. 1:36-3.

SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY APPELLATE DIVISION

DOCKET NO. A-3211-23

IN THE MATTER OF THE CIVIL COMMITMENT OF J.R., SVP-785-15.

Argued October 7, 2025 – Decided November 12, 2025 Before Judges Gooden Brown and DeAlmeida.

On appeal from the Superior Court of New Jersey, Law Division, Somerset County, Docket No. SVP-785-15.

Michael Mangels, Deputy Public Defender, argued the cause for appellant J.R. (Jennifer N. Sellitti, Public Defender, attorney; Michael Mangels, on the brief).

Stephen Slocum, Deputy Attorney General, argued the cause for respondent State of New Jersey (Matthew J.

Platkin, Attorney General, attorney; Janet Greenberg Cohen, Assistant Attorney General, of counsel; Stephen Slocum, on the brief).

PER CURIAM J.R. appeals from the May 8, 2024 Law Division judgment continuing his commitment to the Special Treatment Unit (STU), the secure facility designated for the custody, care, and treatment of sexually violent predators (SVP) pursuant

to the Sexually Violent Predator Act (SVPA), N.J.S.A. 30:4-27.24 to -27.38. We affirm.

I.

J.R. is a sixty-seven-year-old man who in 1985 violently raped and repeatedly stabbed D.W. after breaking into her home at approximately 1:00 a.m. while armed with a handgun. D.W. was awakened by J.R.'s weight after he climbed on top of her while she slept. J.R. choked D.W. into unconsciousness. When she awoke, he digitally penetrated her vagina against her will, forced her to perform fellatio on him, and vaginally raped her repeatedly, despite her begging him not to. J.R. held D.W. captive in her home for the entire night. During that time, J.R. threatened D.W. and her three- and five-year-old children, who were present and sometimes awake. Before the vaginal rapes, J.R. forced D.W. to make him alcoholic drinks and demanded she put on a dress. J.R. placed his handgun on the counter at one point, making D.W. aware of the weapon.

After J.R. raped D.W., he stabbed her with a knife seventeen times. J.R.

lodged the weapon in D.W.'s sternum so deeply he had to put his foot on her chest to pull it out. J.R. told D.W. he was going to watch her die, then left, with $100 he stole from D.W. During the assault, D.W. recognized J.R. as the husband of a woman who had recently babysat her children. She stated his name

A-3211-23

during the assault. D.W. reported J.R., apparently concerned she had identified him, told her he would come back and kill her and her family even if it took thirty years. J.R. denied making that threat.

After J.R. left her home, D.W. managed to crawl to a telephone and dial 9-1-1. She underwent four hours of emergency surgery at a trauma center.

Police apprehended J.R. walking on a street approximately one mile from the home shortly after the attack. He was in possession of a gun matching the description given by D.W., a bloody knife, a bloody mask, and the stolen $100. He said to an officer, "I know what I did."

A jury convicted J.R. of three counts of aggravated sexual assault, attempted murder, kidnaping, burglary, aggravated assault, and weapons offenses. The court initially sentenced J.R. to a 120-year term of imprisonment, with a sixty-year period of parole ineligibility. The sentence was later reduced to a sixty-year term of imprisonment, with a thirty-year period of parole ineligibility.1

1 In 1981, J.R. was charged with following a woman home and raping her at gunpoint. The record does not contain further details about this alleged offense or the reasons the charges were ultimately dismissed. J.R. denies the offense, alternatively asserting the victim was a consensual sexual partner and he was out of state at the time the rape took place.

A-3211-23

J.R. also has a non-sexual criminal history. As a juvenile, he was adjudicated delinquent for stealing a motorcycle, driving without a license, and attempting to elude police. He was also charged with being a runaway and possessing a firearm. As an adult, J.R. was charged in 1984 with carrying a prohibited weapon. That charge was dismissed after J.R. completed pre-trial intervention.

In 2015, as J.R. was approaching release from his custodial sentence, the State filed a petition to civilly commit him under the SVPA. The court granted the petition. J.R. has remained at the STU after regularly scheduled annual review hearings through 2024 when the hearing in this matter took place.

In May 2024, the court held a two-day hearing on the State's petition to continue J.R.'s commitment. The State presented two expert witnesses: psychiatrist Dr. Roxanne Lewin and psychologist Dr. Nafisa Mandani. Both experts were qualified in the subspeciality of risk assessment for SVPs and prepared a written report admitted into evidence. J.R. called as an expert witness psychologist Dr. Dorota Novitskie, who has a subspecialty of risk assessment for SVPs. The court admitted Novitskie's report into evidence.

As part of her evaluation, Lewin met with J.R. for eighty minutes. She also reviewed J.R.'s treatment notes from the STU, which included reports of

A-3211-23

other professionals who evaluated J.R. during his commitment. Lewin examined J.R.'s criminal history, both sexual and non-sexual, and the details of his assault of D.W.

Lewin gave J.R. a provisional diagnosis of sexual sadism based, in large part, on the significantly violent nature of his sexual assault of D.W. Lewin explained the diagnosis was provisional because J.R. had only one offense but noted J.R. had disclosed during treatment he was aroused by D.W. being helpless during the assault. J.R. also previously described, but later partially retracted, being aroused by the smell of blood during the assault and by being the cause of D.W.'s extreme distress during the attack.

Lewin also diagnosed J.R. with antisocial personality disorder and opined he has "significant criminogenic tendencies," which have existed since his youth. J.R.'s violent tendencies were evidenced by statements he made during therapy about his frustration with another STU resident who made noise outside his cell. J.R. stated he fantasized about stabbing the resident and dropping him in a hole, pouring gasoline on him, and setting him on fire. Lewin found the remarks concerning given J.R.'s offense history.

Lewin also opined J.R. has a significant substance abuse history involving alcohol, which caused him to lose his job and may have caused marital problems.

A-3211-23

J.R. admitted to Lewin he drank alcohol and smoked marijuana before assaulting D.W. and, as noted above, forced D.W. to make him alcoholic drinks prior to vaginally raping her. The expert opined J.R.'s substance abuse disorder, if not controlled, can contribute to him reoffending sexually. Since 2017, J.R. has facilitated an Alcoholics Anonymous group at the STU. He has a sponsor and has sponsored other residents over the years. Lewin testified that while J.R.'s efforts at ameliorating his substance abuse are laudable, he must also address his sexual offending cycle to mitigate his serious risk of sexually reoffending if released.

Lewin testified J.R. was improving in his efforts at sex offender treatment, has not been on refusal status, and incurred no disciplinary charges during his incarceration and subsequent commitment. However, Lewin opined that despite many years of sex offender treatment, J.R. continues to avoid addressing his assault of D.W. because doing so, in J.R.'s words, "brings him to a dark place." In addition, when J.R. is compelled to discuss his index offense, he continues to minimize some aspects of his assault of D.W.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

In the Matter of the Civil Commitment of J.R., (N.J. Ct. App. 2025).

In the Matter of the Civil Commitment of J.R. (In the Matter of the Civil Commitment of J.R.) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

In Re Commitment of PC
794 A.2d 211 (New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2002)
In Re Civil Commitment of E.D.
874 A.2d 1075 (Supreme Court of New Jersey, 2005)
In Re Civil Commitment of MLV
909 A.2d 286 (New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2006)
State v. Johnson
199 A.2d 809 (Supreme Court of New Jersey, 1964)
In Re Civil Commitment of TJN
915 A.2d 53 (New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2007)
In Re the Commitment of W.Z.
801 A.2d 205 (Supreme Court of New Jersey, 2002)
In Re the Commitment of R.S.
801 A.2d 219 (Supreme Court of New Jersey, 2002)
In Re Civil Commitment of ED
803 A.2d 166 (New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2002)
In the Matter of the Civil Commitment of R.F. Svp 490-08
85 A.3d 979 (Supreme Court of New Jersey, 2014)
In re the Commitment of J.P.
772 A.2d 54 (New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2001)
In re D.C.
679 A.2d 634 (Supreme Court of New Jersey, 1996)