In re Subpoenas to News Media

593 N.W.2d 558, 459 Mich. 1241
CourtMichigan Supreme Court
DecidedApril 30, 1999
DocketNo. 114570
StatusPublished
Cited by3 cases

This text of 593 N.W.2d 558 (In re Subpoenas to News Media) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Michigan Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
In re Subpoenas to News Media, 593 N.W.2d 558, 459 Mich. 1241 (Mich. 1999).

Opinion

In lieu of granting leave to appeal, the circuit court’s order of April 22, 1999, and the district court’s orders of April 9 and 13, 1999, are vacated. MCR 7.302(F)(1). The district court erred in allowing use of a subpoena -under MCR 2.506 as a discovery procedure in a criminal case. The case is remanded to the 54-B District Court for consideration of the prosecuting attorney’s request for investigative subpoenas under MCL 767A.1 et seq.; MSA 28.1023A(1) et seq. Motion to file a brief amicus curiae is granted. In light of this order, the stay entered by this Court on April 29, 1999, is vacated. Jurisdiction is not retained.

Order Entered May 6, 1999:

Proposed Amendments of MCR 2.113, 5.113, 5.901, 7.210, 8.105, 8.116, 8.203, 8.205, and 8.302 and addition of MCR 2.518 and 8.119. On order of the Court, this is to advise that the Court is considering proposed amendments to Michigan Court Rules 2.113, 5.113, 5.901, 7.210, 8.105, 8.116, 8.203, 8.205, and 8.302 and the addition of 2.518 and 8.119. Before determining whether the proposals should be adopted, changed before adoption, or rejected, this notice is given- to afford any interested person the opportunity to comment on the form or the merits of the proposal, the text of which follows.

In October of 1998, the Michigan Supreme Court established the Michigan Trial Court Case File Management Standards Committee to develop recommended standards for the creation and maintenance of court records. In its final report regarding recommended standards, the Committee also made recommendations for rule changes, which are the source for the rules published for comment in this order. Copies of the [1242]*1242Committee’s final report are available from the State Court Administrative Office.

[The present language would be amended as indicated below:]

Rule 2.113. Form of Pleadings and Other Papers.

(A) [Unchanged.]

(B) Preparation. Every pleading must be legibly typewritten or printed in ink in the English language.

(C) Captions.

(1) The first part of every pleading must contain a caption stating

(a) the name of the court;

(b) the names of the parties or the title of the action, subject to subrule CD);

(c) the file case number, including ar-prcfhe-eontaining the last two dig' its-of the-year of the filing a prefix of the year filed and a two-letter suffix for the case-type code fsee MCR 8.117) according to the principal subject matter of the proceeding;

(d) a ca3c-typc eodc (sec-MCR 8.117) according to the principal subject matter ofrfehc suit;

(e) -(h) [renumbered (d)-(g) but otherwise unchanged.]

(2>(3) [Unchanged.]

(D) -(G) [Unchanged.]

Rule 2.518. Receipt, Storage, and Return of Exhibits. (Option A) (New)

(A) Receipt and Storage of Exhibits. Exhibits for use at trial or other hearing shall be received and stored as provided by records standards. At the conclusion of criminal, traffic, and juvenile offender trials for which there is a conviction, exhibits shall be maintained in a proper storage area in accordance with time frames specified in records retention and disposal schedules.

(B) Return of Exhibits. Except as provided in subrule (A), exhibits shall be returned in the manner provided in this rule.

(1) By Stipulation. At the conclusion of civil and family matter trials, the court shall ask the attorneys or parties whether they will stipulate on the record to the release of all or a portion of the exhibits. If so stipulated, each party shall sign a stipulation and order releasing the exhibits.

(2) By the Clerk.

(a) The clerk shall initiate the return of exhibits as follows:

(i) If an appeal has not been taken, within a reasonable time after acquittal, entry of judgment on the merits, or dismissal of the action.

(ii) If an appeal has been taken, within a reasonable time after the appellate proceedings are concluded, unless the action is remanded for further proceedings in the trial court.

(b) The clerk shall notify the parties who submitted the exhibits and attorneys of record, if any, that the exhibits will be destroyed on a specified date at least 28 days after notice is served unless the parties retrieve them from the court.

[1243]*1243(c) Weapons and drugs shall be returned to the confiscating agency for proper disposition.

(C) Disposal of Exhibits. Any exhibits not returned in accordance with subrule (B) shall be disposed of in accordance with records retention and disposal schedules.

Rule 2.518. Receipt, Storage, and Disposal of Exhibits. (Option B) (New)

(A) Receipt and Storage of Exhibits. Exhibits for use at trial or other hearing shall be received and stored as provided by records standards. Unless otherwise stipulated or ordered by the court, at the conclusion of criminal, traffic, and juvenile offender trials for which there is a conviction, exhibits shall be maintained until the end of the appeal period in a proper storage area.

(B) Release of Exhibits in Civil and Family Matter Trials or Hearings. At the conclusion of civil trials or hearings, the court shall ask the attorneys or parties whether they will stipulate on the record to the release of all or a portion of the exhibits. If so stipulated, each party shall sign a stipulation and order releasing the exhibits.

C) Return and Disposal of Exhibits. At the conclusion of a trial or hearing and appeal period, or at the conclusion of a trial where there is an acquittal, exhibits should be retrieved by the parties submitting them, except that any weapons and drugs shall be returned to the confiscating agency for proper disposition. The court may dispose of all exhibits not retrieved within 56 days after expiration of the time to take an appeal of right or after acquittal.

Rule 5.113. Papers; Form and Filing.

(A) Form of Papers Generally.

(1) A petition, motion, inventory, report, account, or other paper in a proceeding must

(a) be legible and in ink, legibly typewritten or printed in ink in the English language, and

(b) include the

(1) name of the court and title of the proceeding in which it is filed;

(ii) file case number, if-anyj including the case-type-eode a prefix of the year filed and a two-letter suffix for the case-type code (see MCR 8.117) according to the principal subject matter of the proceeding, and if the case is filed under the Juvenile Code, the petition number that also includes a prefix of the year filed and a two-letter suffix for the case-type code;

(iii) -(iv) [Unchanged.]

(c) [Unchanged.]

(2) [Unchanged.]

(B) -(C) [Unchanged.]

[1244]*1244Rule 5.901. Applicability of Rules.

(A) Scope. The rules in this subchapter, and in subchapter 1.100, and in rule 5.113, govern practice and procedure in the family division of the circuit court in all cases filed under the Juvenile Code. Other Michigan Court Rules apply to such juvenile cases in the family division of the circuit court only when this subchapter specifically provides.

(B) [Unchanged.]

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

People v. Pastor
463 Mich. 378 (Michigan Supreme Court, 2000)
In Re Investigation of March 1999 Riots
617 N.W.2d 310 (Michigan Supreme Court, 2000)
In re Subpoenas to News Media
613 N.W.2d 342 (Michigan Court of Appeals, 2000)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
593 N.W.2d 558, 459 Mich. 1241, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/in-re-subpoenas-to-news-media-mich-1999.