In re Morgan Stanley Data Security Litigation
Opinion
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
20 Civ. 5914 (PAE) In re Morgan Stanley Data Security Litigation ORDER
PAUL A. ENGELMAYER, District Judge: On August 5, 2022, in a lengthy bench decision, the Court approved (1) the proposed class action settlement; and (2) attorneys’ fees, costs, and service awards. See Dkts. 156-58. At that hearing, the Court denied class member Melissa Linden’s motion for joinder, Dkt. 123, and motion to stay, Dkt. 130, recognizing that the motions “appear to be premised on her assertion that the settlement does not provide adequate relief and concern with her future ability to bring claims against Morgan Stanley for issues relating to her deceased father’s account.” Dkt. 160 at 5. The Court noted that, to the extent that Linden believed she had claims against Morgan Stanley based on issues related to her father’s account, her recourse would have been to opt out of the class action. /d. at 5-6, Because Linden had not opted out of the class action, the Court respectfully denied her motions. Jd. at 6. Separately, the Court noted Linden’s objections to the settlement, see Dkt, 122, and at the hearing directed questions to plaintiffs’ counsel about those objections, Dkt. 160 at 75-77. This order addresses three pending motions by Linden: (1) a letter-motion to vacate the final judgment in this action, see Dkt. 192; (2) her objection to the deadline to request redactions to the transcript of the August 5, 2022 hearing, see Dkt. 193; and (3) a letter-motion to impose sanctions for alleged misconduct by counsel for defendant Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC
(“Morgan Stanley”), see Dkt. 194. The Court commissioned responses from plaintiffs, as to the motion to vacate, and from defendant’s counsel, as to the motion for sanctions. See Dkt. 195,! For the following reasons, the Court denies the relief sought. First, Linden moves to vacate the final judgment under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b)(1), claiming that she was “erroneous[ly]” labeled as a “non-party” and “non-party joiner” on the docket. See Dkt. 192. She seeks relief including damages and the production of certain records. See id. Plaintiffs oppose her motion, noting that she was properly classified as a non- party because she was not a named plaintiff and that her motions were duly considered by the Court. See Dkt. 198, Plaintiffs are correct. Rule 60(b) allows a court to “relieve a party or its legal representative from a final judgment” based on, infer alia, “mistake, inadvertence, surprise, or excusable neglect.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 60(b)(1). Linden has not made any such showing here. She has failed to demonstrate that her classification on the docket and the Court’s rulings as to her motions were erroneous, let alone that any error justifies relief under Rule 60(b). Her allegations appear to relate to matters beyond the scope of this class action. The Court denies her motion, Second, Linden “object[s] to the termination of transcript deadline . . , and ask[s] for the transcript to be made available immediately,” asserting that “the people should be given access to the record of the Fairness hearing.” See Dkt. 193. This request appears to derive from the Court’s statement at the August 5, 2022 hearing that it would not issue a written decision, but instead would resolve the motions for settlement approval, and for fees and costs, in a bench
1 In a November 25, 2022 letter addressed to the Court, Linden took issue with various aspects of the Court’s order directing responses to her motions. See Dkt. 197. Her letter, although challenging to comprehend, appears to argue that, inter alia, the Court improperly characterized her as “disgruntle[d] about settlement monies.” See id. (attaching various filings), The Court does not find any allegations in the letter meritorious and denies the relief sought therein.
ruling. The Court added that, “ifthe content of what I say is important to you, you will need to order the transcript of this conference.” Dkt. 160 at 98. Under the August 18, 2022 notice of the filing of the official transcript of the fairness hearing, the parties had seven days to file any notice of intent to request redaction of the transcript; absent such notice, the transcript would become remotely electronically available to the public without redaction after 90 days. See Dkt. 161. Linden does not explain any deficiency in this process, or why she objects to the docket entry she references.” The Court declines to take any action with respect to this objection. Third, Linden seeks sanctions against counsel for Morgan Stanley based largely on a November 11, 2022 email to her from its outside counsel. The email, which responds to an email from Linden, stated that the counsel’s law firm does not represent Linden or Morgan Stanley in connection with the issues she had raised and that the firm would not respond to further correspondence from her. See Dkt. 194. Morgan Stanley opposes her motion. It defends counsel’s email to Linden as accurate and appropriate, see Dkt, 199, and attaches a fuller set of emails between Linden and various counsel assigned to this matter, see Dkt. 200. Upon review, the Court does not find any impropriety or basis for sanctions. Counsel’s responses to Linden’s inquiries, including the email that she challenges, were appropriate. As counsel explained, Linden’s requests related to matters outside the scope of this litigation and/or were subject to direct rulings by this Court. The Court denies Linden’s motion for sanctions.
* To the extent Linden may mean to contend that the Court set a deadline for seeking a copy of the transcript of the hearing, the Court did not set any such deadline.
Plaintiffs’ counsel shall furnish a copy of this order to Linden forthwith and file proof of service on the docket within one week of this order. The Court respectfully directs the Clerk of Court to terminate all pending motions.? The case remains closed.
SO ORDERED. Pragf / Ly Paul A. Engelmayer United States District Judge
Dated: August 8, 2023 New York, New York
3 The Court attaches to this order various unsolicited letters sent by Linden after plaintiffs and defendant’s counsel filed their respective responses. Whether construed as replies or independent motions, these letters appear to reprise arguments raised herein by Linden. The letters do not make any of Linden’s claims meritorious. 4
Via Pro Se Emaif Portal oF Judge Paul A. Engelmayer United States District Court Southern District of New York Thurgood Marshall United States Courthouse 40 Foley Square New York, NY 10007 In re Morgan Stanley Data Security Litigation Case No. 1:20-cv-05914-PAE
Re: Letter Motion to Compel Proof of Morgan Stanley June 2020 Notice and March 2022 Notice, All Notice of Hearings and Notice of Orders, on all Melisssa A Linden filing before the court be placed on the public docket, attached brief in support of and request for oral argument to be granted. 12-02-2022 Dear Judge Paul A. Engelmayer, Scriber, melissa linden, respectfully submits this correspondence in order to expedite the truth, and asks the court to participate in rendering the truth to its public docket. Hense why, scribers, ask the court to grant this letter motion for proof thereof, described in the Specific Facts Relied Upon section, for the following reasons:
Memorandum of Law Specific Facts Relied Upon Plaintiffs’ Attorney asserted under penalty of perjury “The Court also considered Ms. Linden’s motion for joinder (ECF No. 123) and motion for stay (ECF No. 130) and denied both motions. See ECF No.
Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
20 Civ. 5914 (PAE) In re Morgan Stanley Data Security Litigation ORDER
PAUL A. ENGELMAYER, District Judge: On August 5, 2022, in a lengthy bench decision, the Court approved (1) the proposed class action settlement; and (2) attorneys’ fees, costs, and service awards. See Dkts. 156-58. At that hearing, the Court denied class member Melissa Linden’s motion for joinder, Dkt. 123, and motion to stay, Dkt. 130, recognizing that the motions “appear to be premised on her assertion that the settlement does not provide adequate relief and concern with her future ability to bring claims against Morgan Stanley for issues relating to her deceased father’s account.” Dkt. 160 at 5. The Court noted that, to the extent that Linden believed she had claims against Morgan Stanley based on issues related to her father’s account, her recourse would have been to opt out of the class action. /d. at 5-6, Because Linden had not opted out of the class action, the Court respectfully denied her motions. Jd. at 6. Separately, the Court noted Linden’s objections to the settlement, see Dkt, 122, and at the hearing directed questions to plaintiffs’ counsel about those objections, Dkt. 160 at 75-77. This order addresses three pending motions by Linden: (1) a letter-motion to vacate the final judgment in this action, see Dkt. 192; (2) her objection to the deadline to request redactions to the transcript of the August 5, 2022 hearing, see Dkt. 193; and (3) a letter-motion to impose sanctions for alleged misconduct by counsel for defendant Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC
(“Morgan Stanley”), see Dkt. 194. The Court commissioned responses from plaintiffs, as to the motion to vacate, and from defendant’s counsel, as to the motion for sanctions. See Dkt. 195,! For the following reasons, the Court denies the relief sought. First, Linden moves to vacate the final judgment under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b)(1), claiming that she was “erroneous[ly]” labeled as a “non-party” and “non-party joiner” on the docket. See Dkt. 192. She seeks relief including damages and the production of certain records. See id. Plaintiffs oppose her motion, noting that she was properly classified as a non- party because she was not a named plaintiff and that her motions were duly considered by the Court. See Dkt. 198, Plaintiffs are correct. Rule 60(b) allows a court to “relieve a party or its legal representative from a final judgment” based on, infer alia, “mistake, inadvertence, surprise, or excusable neglect.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 60(b)(1). Linden has not made any such showing here. She has failed to demonstrate that her classification on the docket and the Court’s rulings as to her motions were erroneous, let alone that any error justifies relief under Rule 60(b). Her allegations appear to relate to matters beyond the scope of this class action. The Court denies her motion, Second, Linden “object[s] to the termination of transcript deadline . . , and ask[s] for the transcript to be made available immediately,” asserting that “the people should be given access to the record of the Fairness hearing.” See Dkt. 193. This request appears to derive from the Court’s statement at the August 5, 2022 hearing that it would not issue a written decision, but instead would resolve the motions for settlement approval, and for fees and costs, in a bench
1 In a November 25, 2022 letter addressed to the Court, Linden took issue with various aspects of the Court’s order directing responses to her motions. See Dkt. 197. Her letter, although challenging to comprehend, appears to argue that, inter alia, the Court improperly characterized her as “disgruntle[d] about settlement monies.” See id. (attaching various filings), The Court does not find any allegations in the letter meritorious and denies the relief sought therein.
ruling. The Court added that, “ifthe content of what I say is important to you, you will need to order the transcript of this conference.” Dkt. 160 at 98. Under the August 18, 2022 notice of the filing of the official transcript of the fairness hearing, the parties had seven days to file any notice of intent to request redaction of the transcript; absent such notice, the transcript would become remotely electronically available to the public without redaction after 90 days. See Dkt. 161. Linden does not explain any deficiency in this process, or why she objects to the docket entry she references.” The Court declines to take any action with respect to this objection. Third, Linden seeks sanctions against counsel for Morgan Stanley based largely on a November 11, 2022 email to her from its outside counsel. The email, which responds to an email from Linden, stated that the counsel’s law firm does not represent Linden or Morgan Stanley in connection with the issues she had raised and that the firm would not respond to further correspondence from her. See Dkt. 194. Morgan Stanley opposes her motion. It defends counsel’s email to Linden as accurate and appropriate, see Dkt, 199, and attaches a fuller set of emails between Linden and various counsel assigned to this matter, see Dkt. 200. Upon review, the Court does not find any impropriety or basis for sanctions. Counsel’s responses to Linden’s inquiries, including the email that she challenges, were appropriate. As counsel explained, Linden’s requests related to matters outside the scope of this litigation and/or were subject to direct rulings by this Court. The Court denies Linden’s motion for sanctions.
* To the extent Linden may mean to contend that the Court set a deadline for seeking a copy of the transcript of the hearing, the Court did not set any such deadline.
Plaintiffs’ counsel shall furnish a copy of this order to Linden forthwith and file proof of service on the docket within one week of this order. The Court respectfully directs the Clerk of Court to terminate all pending motions.? The case remains closed.
SO ORDERED. Pragf / Ly Paul A. Engelmayer United States District Judge
Dated: August 8, 2023 New York, New York
3 The Court attaches to this order various unsolicited letters sent by Linden after plaintiffs and defendant’s counsel filed their respective responses. Whether construed as replies or independent motions, these letters appear to reprise arguments raised herein by Linden. The letters do not make any of Linden’s claims meritorious. 4
Via Pro Se Emaif Portal oF Judge Paul A. Engelmayer United States District Court Southern District of New York Thurgood Marshall United States Courthouse 40 Foley Square New York, NY 10007 In re Morgan Stanley Data Security Litigation Case No. 1:20-cv-05914-PAE
Re: Letter Motion to Compel Proof of Morgan Stanley June 2020 Notice and March 2022 Notice, All Notice of Hearings and Notice of Orders, on all Melisssa A Linden filing before the court be placed on the public docket, attached brief in support of and request for oral argument to be granted. 12-02-2022 Dear Judge Paul A. Engelmayer, Scriber, melissa linden, respectfully submits this correspondence in order to expedite the truth, and asks the court to participate in rendering the truth to its public docket. Hense why, scribers, ask the court to grant this letter motion for proof thereof, described in the Specific Facts Relied Upon section, for the following reasons:
Memorandum of Law Specific Facts Relied Upon Plaintiffs’ Attorney asserted under penalty of perjury “The Court also considered Ms. Linden’s motion for joinder (ECF No. 123) and motion for stay (ECF No. 130) and denied both motions. See ECF No. 160 at 5-6; :’, Scriber doesn’t no agree with this statement and ask for tangible proof thereof in the format described bellow
1. Proof of Morgan Stanley June 2020 Notice, March 2022 Notice be piace to the docket by Plaintiff, 2. All Notices of Hearing that were issued in connection with melissa linden appearance, request for filing electronically, dkt123, dkt 130 ect placed to the docket. 3. All Notices of Orders on all issued in connection with melissa linden appearance, request filing electronically, dkt123, dkt 130 place to the docket. 4. Plaintiff Attorney continues to establish Melissa Lindens filings are confusing and hookwkin, these filings as if they are ignorant. This is notice to all parties, iam pro se filler and am happy to provide verbal disclosure to any matters that arises out of my filings. |am a phone call away, so if your confused, i believe a this more constructive form of communication and remedy for your confusion.
Complaining to a judge on a public docket seemly is a waste of time and appears to me, a regular person, to be exhibiting snitty behavior for an Attorney. Legal Argument . As plaintiffs' attorney have asserted under penalty of perjury “The Courtalso considered Ms. Linden’s motion for joinder (ECF No. 123) and motion for stay (ECF No. 130) and denied both motions. See ECF No. 160 at 5-6; The dacket reflects this statement, by the plaintiff, to appear as if itis not the truth and is why Scriber is asking for the court to relive her and remedy this matter. In the action of grant an order to compel the Plaintiff to place tangible proof to the docket of their assertion of, “The Court also considered Ms. Linden’s motion for joinder (ECF No. 123) and motion for stay (ECF No. 130) and denied both motions. See ECF No. 160 at 5-6; □□ Noting, to the court, the above matter, is the reason for this request, for an order to compel. Noting scriber, believes this submission meets the Criteria to grant her request. As the court be provided proof of scribers assertion in their own records. Scribers believes the courts records will evidence the piaintiff's argument and statements, to be bald on their face. In addition to pointing out, to the court, the court itself, doesn't have subject matter jurisdiction to grant or extend an argument the plaintiff that doesn’t exit. Concluding, the Plaintiff can't say Melissa Linden filings were consider, when the case records appears, she has never been notified of this, or in even in front of this court. Seemingly this type of argument and defenses appears unlawful. Which is why the scriber is asking the court for remedy of this matter by making plaintiffs provide proof of their assertions. Wherefore, scribers, asks the court for immediately relief and remedy of the matter by granting scribers request for an order to Compel Proof, in the form of, Morgan Stanley June 2020 Notice and March 2022 Notice, Ali Notice of Hearing and Notice of Orders, on all Melisssa A Linden filing before the court to be placed to the public docket, and request for oral argument to be granted, in addition to any cost and expenses associated with the filing and what the court sees fair and just
Respectfully Submitted
Melissa Linden Order for Letter Motion to Compel Proof Notice of, Proof of Morgan Stanley June 2020 Notice, March 2022 Notice, All Notice of Hearings and Notice of Orders, on all Melisssa A Linden filing before the court, brief in support of and request for oral argument.
Entered in support of, on 12/2/2022 and Is so ordered
Pursuant to the terms required by Law. The below parties have been served this matter on 12-2-2022. Respectively
Melissa linden
John A. Yanchunis Jonathan M. Sedgh Linda P. Nussbaum Heather H Jones Morgan & Morgan, P.A. Morgan and Morgan Nussbaum Law Group, P.C. The Consumer Protection Firm 201 N, Franklin Street 7th Floor | 850 3rd Avenue 12£E Avenue of the Americas | Florida Tampa, Fl 33602 Ste 402 New York, NY 10036 401 E. Jackson Street (813)-275-5272 Brooklyn, N¥ 11232 917-438-9 £02 SunTrust Financial Center (853) 222-4736 (fax) 212-738-6839 lnussbaum@inussbaumpc.com | Ste 2346 ivanchunis@forthepeople.com | jsedeh@forthepeople.com Assigned: 11/04/2020 Tampa, FL 33602 Assigned: 08/18/2020 Assigned: 09/30/2021 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED | 813-500-1506 LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED 813-435-2369 (fax) heather@theconsumerprotectionf irm.com Assigned: 08/3 1/2020
Lestie Guilion Michael Anderson Berry James £. Ceechi Lori Gwen Feldman Armold Law Firm Arnold Law Firm Carella, Byrne, Cechi, Olstein, | George Gesten McDonald PLLC 865 Howe Avenue 865 Howe Avenue Brody & Agnello, P.C. 102 Half Moon Bay Drive Sacramento Sacramento, CA 95825 5 Becker Farm Road Croton on Hudson, NY 10520 Sacramento, CA 95825 916-777-7777 Roseland, NJ 07068 517-983-9321 916-239-4787 □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ 973 994-1700 888-421-4173 (fax) 916-924-1829 (fax) Assigned: 08/20/2020 973 994-1744 (fax} Lfeldman@4-justice com iguillon@justiced4 you.com LEAD ATTORNEY jcecchi@carellabyrne.com Assigned: 09/17/2020 Assigned: 08/20/2020 Assigned: 09/17/2026 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED Jane Baek O'Brien Daniel H, Levi Brad Scott Karp Anna St. John Pau, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & | Paul Weiss (NY) Paul Weiss (NY} Hamilton Lincoln Law Institute Garrison, LLP (DC) 1285 Avenue of the Americas | [285 Avenue of the Americas | 1629 K St. NW Suite 300 2601 K Street, N.W. New York, N¥ 10019 New York, NY 10019 Washington, DC 20006 Washington, DC 20006 212-373-3497 212-373-2384 917-327-2392 (262) 223-7300 212-492-0497 (fax) 212-373-2384 (fax} anna stiohn@hiliorg (202) 223-7420 (fax) dleviq@paulweiss.com bkarpempaulweiss.com Assigned: 07/12/2022 jobrien@paulweiss.com Assigned: 10/11/2021 Assigned: 09/292020 LEAD ATTORNEY Assigned: 09/29/2020 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED | LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
LEAD ATTORNEY FEE PT Kyle Alan Shamberg ie Wehington, STE | Jonathan M. Jagher Erich Paul Schork Michael L Roberts Chicago TL, 60602 , Freed Kanner London & Millen | Roberts Law Firm US, PC Roberts Law Firm 312-750-1265 923 Fayette Street PO Box 31909 20 Rahling Circle kyle@lellp. com Conshohocken, PA 19428 Chicago, If, 60631 Little Rock, AR 72223 Acsigned: 00/17 09/17/2020 610-234-6487 342-810-5824 (5013-821-5575 ATTORNEY TO BENOTICED 224-632-4521 (fax) □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ | (301)-821-4474 (fax) jiagher@ikimlaw.com Assipned: 09/17/2020 aprilburton@robertslawfirm us Assigned: 09/17/2020 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED | Assigned: 03/18/2021 PRO HAC VICE ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Michael Milton Liskow Janine Lee Pollack Se ot viens Karen Halbert Melissa Robin Emert Caleaterra Pollack LLP Ste 9th Floor Roberts Law Firm, P.A, Stull, Stull & Brody 1146 Avenue of the Americas New York, NY 10036-5803 20 Rahling Circle 6 East 45th Street Sth Floor 212-899-1761 Little Rock, AR 72223 NY, NY 10017 New York, NY 10036 inliskow@iealea terrapollack 501-821-5575 Assigned: 09/17/2020 212-899-1760 □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ □ (fax) ATTORNEY TO BE 332-206-2075 (fax) sTackco ‘Assigned: 09/17/2020 □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ NOTICED abrody@ssbny.com m Noten TO BE Assigned: 09/23/2020 Assigned: 69/17/2020 LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED NOTICED
Via Pro Se Email Portal Judge Paul A. Engelmayer United States District Court Southern District of New York Thurgood Marshall United States Courthouse 40 Foley Square New York, NY 10007
12-02-2022 In re Morgan Stanley Data Security Litigation Case No. 1:20-cv-05914-PAE Re: Letter Motion for Clarification and requested argument to insure fundamental fairness to the matter Dear Judge Engelmayer and the Court Melissa Linden, Scriber, respectfully submits this motion for clarification and Brief, in support of, the Plaintiffs, rendering an emergency clarification, in the form of an affidavit, clarifying the Plaintiff statement under penalty of perjury that states the following, "Ms. Linden was a class member for purposes of the Morgan Stanley Data Security Incidents, she was nota party to the litigation as she was nota named plaintiff in any related matter consolidated before this Court.” Memorandum of Law Specific Facts Relied Upon This statement above is based in ambiguity thus in need of clarification. In that, scriber asks the court, how can one be a class member in the incident but not able to become a part of the litigation. When applying this statement to the law it simply makes no sense. Highlighting, aren't class actions formed in the first place to be all inclusive. This is why scriber is asking for clarification of plaintiffs' determination, of scriber, and define how she cannot participate in this litigation. From scribers point of view, this determination, doesn’t seem consistent with US Law. Therefore, is the reason, scriber, is asking Plaintiff to clarify their statements below: 1, Whatis the definition of a class member for purposes of Morgan Stenly Data Security Incident, 2 what is the definition of, a party which a named plaintiff in any related consulted matter before this courtis 3 who made this determination alleged classification and choose which parties can be heard.
4 when were class members, for purposes of Morgan Stenly Date Security Incident notified, they could not take part to In re Morgan Stanley Data Security Litigation Case No. 1:20-cv-05914-PAE 5,1 want to Notify the court that, all my request to seek remedy of the matter were given to the prospective parties, well before judgment came to be in this matter. All parties failed to act. Legal Facts Relied Upon In order to rectify the confusion surrounding the matter of scribers class determination, clarification would be needed and precedence relied form this Court, stated that any non-party that requires clarification regarding the scope of the facts may make an application and “[s]uch clarification will be promptly provided.” As the court can determiner themselves, the plaintiff statements are based in confusion and clearly in need of definition and is why scriber, has asked the court to relive her of this matter, and remedy the situation immediately by granting this motion and ordering a clarification from the Plaintiff pertaining fo the above statements. Highlighting, similarly, the Second Circuit instructed that “when questions arise ...., district courts will not ‘withhold a clarification in the light of a concrete situation’ .. . [and] [t]he doors of the district court obviously remain open for such applications.” NML Capital Ltd. v. Republic of Argentina, 727 F.3d 230, 243 (2d Cir. 2013) (“NML II’).2 Conclusion Wherefore, scriber asks the court to grant this submission as a remedy and relief to the chaotic matter. In that it would be nearly impossible for scriber to form an argument when facts are simply not clearly defined. Especially when the assertions made by Plaintiff, seemly are with no merit and is why scriber has asked the court fo grant her this remedy, by ordering the plaintiff to clarify their ambulant statements, in addition to the cost and expenses associated with this filing and what the court see fair and just
Respectively Submitted,
Melissa Linden Order Order for Letter Motion for Clarification and requested argument to insure fundamental fairness to the matter
Is ordered
Pursuant to the terms required by Law. The below parties have been served this matter on 12-2-2022. Respectively
John A. Yanchunis Jonathan M, Sedgh Linda P. Nussbaum Heather H Jones Morgan & Morgan, P.A. Morgan and Morgan Nussbaum Law Group, P.C. The Consumer Protection Firm 2061 N. Franklin Street 7th Floor | 850 3rd Avenue 1211 Avenue of the Americas | Florida Tampa, FI 33602 Ste 402 New York, NY 10036 401 E. Jackson Street (813}-275-5272 Brooklyn, NY 11232 917-438-9102 SunTrust Financial Center 222-4736 (fax) 212-738-6839 lnussbaum@nussbaumpe.com | Ste 2340 ivanchunis@forthepeople.com | isedeh@forthepeaple.com Assigned: 114)4/2020 Tampa, FL 33602 Assigned: 08/18/2020 Assigned: 09/30/2021 ATTORNEY TOBE NOTICED | 8£3-500-1500 LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED 813-435-2369 (fax) heather@theconsumerprotectionf incom Assigned: 08/3 1/2020
Leslie Guillon Michael Anderson Berry James E. Cecchi Lori Gwen Feldman Amold Law Firm Amold Law Firm Carella, Byrne, Cechi, Olstein, | George Gesten McDonald PLLC 865 Howe Avenue 865 Howe Avenue Brody & Agnello, P.C. 102 Half Moon Bay Drive Sacramento Sacramento, CA 95825 § Becker Farm Road Croton on Hudson, NY 105206 Sacramento, CA 95825 916-777-7777 Roseland, NJ 07068 917-983-9321 916-239-4787 aberry(@ijusticedyou.com 973 994-1700 888-421-4173 (fax) 916-924-1829 (fax) Assigned: 08/20/2020 -973 994-1744 (fax) feldman@4-justice.com leviton@diustived you.com LEAD ATTORNEY jcecchi@earellabyrne.com Assigned: 09/17/2020 Assigned: 08/20/2020 Assigned; 09/17/2020 ATTORNEY FO BE NOTICED ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED Jane Baek O'Brien Brad Scott Karp Anna St. John Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & | Paul Weiss (NY Paul Weiss (NY Hamilton Lincoln Law Institute
Garrison, LLP (BC) 1285 Avenue of the Americas | 1285 Avenue of the Americas | 1629 K St. NW Suite 300 2001 K Street, N.W. New York, NY 10019 New York, NY 10019 Washington, DC 20006 Washington, DC 20006 212-373-3497 212-373-2384 917-327-2392 (202) 223-7300 212-492-0497 (fax} 212-373-2384 (fax) anna stighn@hlliore (202) 223-7420 (fax) dlevig@paulweiss.com bkarp@paulweigs.com Assigned: 07/12/2022 □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ Assigned: 10/11/2025 Assigned: 09/29/2020 LEAD ATTORNEY Assigned: 09/29/2020 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED | LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TOBE NOTICED Kyle Alan Shamberg we “Wonington, STE 1240 Jonathan M. Jagher Erich Paul Schork Michael L Roberts Chicago iL 60602 ae Freed KannerLondon & Millen | Roberts Law Firm US, PC Reberts Law Firm 3 1275661265 923 Fayette Street PO Box 31909 20 Rahling Circle kvlealell m Conshohocken, PA 19428 Chicago, IL 60631 Little Rock, AR 72223 OoT7 09/17/2020 oe aaa, ' 312-810-5824 (501)-821-5575 ' ATTORNEY TO BENOTICED | 27747632~ (fax} erichschork@robertslawfirm US, (501)-821-4474 ( ax) agher@tklmlaw.com Assigned: 09/17/2020 aprilburton@probertslawfirm.us Assigned: 09/17/2020 ATTORNEY TOBE NOTICED | Assigned: 03/18/2021 PRO HAC VICE ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Michael Milton Liskow Janine Lee Pollack Caleaterra Pollack LLP : Kareo Halbert Melissa Robin Emert Caleaterra Pollack LLP woot ante of the Americas Roberts Law Firm, P.A. Stuil, Stull & Brody 1140 Avenue of the Americas 20 Rahling Circle 6 East 45th Street 9th Floor New York, NY 10036-5803 1 4 ittte Rock, AR 72223 NY, NY 10017 212-899-1761 , : New York, NY 10036 . 501-821-5575 Assigned: 09/17/2020 212-899-1760 uliskow@ealeatervapollack.ce | +, .) ATTORNEY TO BE - - } no karenhathertgor: I . " cD abr ssbny. □□□ 2078 Oa) stlack.co Assigned: 09/17/2020 wa arenhathert@robertslawfinm, | NOTICED abrody@sshny.com ipallack(@ealeaterrapoliack.co ATTORNEY TO BE . m NOTICED Assigned: 09/23/2020 Assigned; 69/17/2020 LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED NOTICED
Via Pro Se Email Portal Judge Paul A. Engelmayer United States District Court Southern District of New York Thurgood Marshall United States Courthouse 40 Foley Square New York, NY 40007 In re Morgan Stanley Data Security Litigation Case No. 1:20-cv-05914-PAE
Re: Amended Letter Motion for Order to Compel (Original Summited 12-02-2022). Both Plaintiff and Defendants Council Susanna M. Buergel Jane B. O’Brien , the Firm of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP ,Defendant Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC to, Provided Proof thereof, Notice of, Claims Admirations Notice, approximately mailed in June 2020, March 2022, Proof of Melissa Linden Notice of Hearings and Orders, and attached brief in support of this request, a request for oral argument and request for the court to stay its decision on Plaintiff and Defendants responses until ail motion involving disclosure and scribers appearance have addressed
12-04-2022 Amended version, Note: First Version date12-02-2022,
Dear Judge Paul A. Engelmayer, Scriber, melissa linden, respectfully submits this correspondence to amended earlier version in order to expedite the truth, information, has arisen, after scriber summited 2- 2-2022's original version of the above mention filling and is why she is asking the court to participate in rendering the truth, to its public docket, by accepting this submission as the current version. Hense why, scribers, ask the court to grant this letter motion for proof thereof, described in the Specific Facts Relied Upon section, for the following reasons:
Memorandum of Law Specific Facts Relied Upon Plaintiffs' Attorney asserted under penalty of perjury “The Court also considered Ms. Linden’s motion for joinder (ECF No. 123) and motion for stay (ECF No. 130) and denied both motions. See ECF No. 160 at 5-6; :’, Scriber doesn’t no agree with this statement and ask for tangibie proof thereof in the format described bellow
1. Proof of Morgan Stanley June 2020 Notice, March 2022 Notice be place to the docket by Plaintiff, 2. All Notices of Hearing that were issued in connection with melissa linden appearance, request for filing electronically, dkt123, dkt 130 ect placed to the docket. 3. All Notices of Orders on all issued in connection with melissa linden appearance, request filing electronically, dkt123, dkt 130 place to the docket. 4. Plaintiff Attorney continues to establish Melissa Lindens filings are confusing and hoodwink, these filings as if they are ignorant. This is notice to all parties, | am pro se filler and am happy to provide verbal disclosure to any matters that arises out of my filings. |}am a phone call away, so if your confused, i believe a this more constructive form of communication and remedy for your confusion. Complaining to a judge on‘a public docket seemly is a waste of time and appears to me, a regular person, to be exhibiting snitty behavior for an Attorney. 5. Defendant Attorneys has never communicated to scriber that they were not getting herfiling. Scriber data is severely breech; she is a phone call away to sort this communication matter out. Bring this before a judge is seemingly a waste of time and should be consider irreverent. 6. Attorney for Plaintiff response they didn’t not want to help me attain my and fathers' information form the defendant that was breeched by the actions of the defendant in this matter. Scriber has a right to her family's information and to be heard in the matter, 7. Order Compelling Susanna M. Buergel Jane B. O’Brien, the Firm of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP, Defendant Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC to individually submit an affidavit under penalty of perjury affirm these assertions made before the court by the named parties, “Nor has Paul, Weiss ever been retained at any time by Morgan Stanley to represent itin connection with Ms. Linden’s demands for paperwork and files concerning those accounts, or for any issues related to any matters pending in the Connecticut Court of Probate, While there is no dispute that Paul, Weiss represents Morgan Stanley in the Class Action, involving a settlement class of........ at Paul, Weiss; we are not confident that we received every communication Ms. Linden intended to direct to our firm. Case 1:20-cv-05914-PAE Document 199 Filed 12/02/22 Page 3 of 4 4 which Ms. Linden is a member, Ms. Linden’s repeated communications to Paul, Weiss do not concern that matter. Paul, Weiss’s November 11 email was therefore accurate and appropriate in all respects.” Legal Argument As plaintiffs’ attorney have asserted under penalty of perjury “The Courtalso considered Ms. Linden’s motion for joinder (ECF No. 123) and motion for stay (ECF No. 130) and denied both motions. See ECF No. 160 at 5-6; and the Defendant Attorney's represent under penalty of perjury “Nor has Paul, Weiss ever been retained at any time by Morgan Stanley to represent it in connection with Ms. Linden’s demands for paperwork and files
conceming those accounts, or for any issues related to any matters pending in the Connecticut Court of Probate.” The docket reflects the above statements, by the plaintiffs and defendants, to appear as if, these statements above are not the truth and is why Scriber is asking for the court to relive her and remedy this matter. In the action of grant an order to compel the Plaintiff to place tangible proof to the docket of their assertion of, “The Court also considered Ms. Linden’s motion for joinder (ECF No. 123) and motion for stay (ECF No. 130) and denied both motions. See ECF No. 160 at 5-6:’ and the Defendant to place tangible proof, in the requested affidavits on the public docket. Furthermore, ask the court to consider these requested submissions as evidence, to be use in the decision rendered, surrounding these matters. Much more to the point moves, the court, to stay their decision making, until all disclosure is furnished. Noting, to the court, the discrepancy discussed above are the reason for this request, an order te compel. Noting scriber, believes this submission meets the Criteria to grant her request. As the court can be provided proof of allindividuals assertion on the public record instead of opinion on their hearsay. Further noting to the court, scribers, believes the courts records evidences both the plaintiffs and defendants' argument and statements, to be bald on their face. In addition to pointing out, to the court, the court itself, doesn't have subject matter jurisdiction to grant or even so much as extend an argument to the plaintiff or defendant, that doesn’t existin when applying the law. Concluding, the Plaintiff, can't say Melissa Linden filings were consider, when the case records appears,1. she has never been notified of this,2. or even so much as in front of this court. The Defendant, simply, can't restrict scribers access to the information and deceit family members information associated to breeches involving this decommissioning matter and certainly can't restrict access after, a Justice orders record production the breeched information pertaining to this decommissioning maiter. Seemingly, these type of arguments and defenses appears unlawful. Which is why the scriber, is asking the court for remedy of this matter, by making plaintiffs and defendant, provide proof of their assertions to the public docket. Highlighting to the court, most often, the court declines to prosecute or take up matters involving fraud on the Court. Because of past, very public position, on behalf of this court, scriber feels, the court, has fo be diligent, in nothearing or participating in actions involving potential fraud on this court. Thus why, scriber prays, the court, remedies this matter, potently, involving fraud on the court, to the apocopate venue, to address these potential issues, in the appropriate manor governed by the law. Scriber's time is as equally valuable as everyone is. Scriber is a, self-employed, widower, with 8-year-old and 16-year-old. . Wherefore, scribers, asks the court for immediately relief and remedy of the matter by ordering, scribers, Amended Letter Motion for Order Compel Summited (12-02- 2022). Both Plaintiff and(added) Defendants Council Susanna M. Buerge!l Jane B.
O’Brien , the Firm of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP ,Defendant Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC to, Provided Proof thereof, Notice of, Claims Admirations Notice, approximately mailed in June 2020, March 2022, Proof of Melissa Linden Notice Hearings and Orders, and attached brief in support of, request for oral argument and request for the court to stay its decision on Plaintiff and Defendants responses until all motion involving disclosure are addressed, in addition to a penalty of 3 times the value of award monies, cost and expenses associated with the filing and what the court sees fair and just granted , for display consistence vexatious behavior before the court.
Melissa Linden Order For: Amended Letter Motion for Order Compel Summited (12-02-2022). Both Plaintiff and(added) Defendants Council Susanna M. Buergel Jane B. O’Brien , the Firm of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP ,Defendant Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC to, Provided Proof thereof, Notice of, Claims Admirations Notice, approximately mailed in June 2020, March 2022, Proof of Melissa Linden Notice Hearings and Orders, and attached brief in support of, request for oral argument and request for the court to stay its decision on Plaintiff and Defendants responses until all motion involving disclosure are addressed, in addition to a penalty of 3 times the value of award monies, cost and expenses associated with the filing and what the court sees fair and just ,granted , for display consistence vexatious behavior before the court. Is so Ordered
Entered in support of
Pursuant to the terms required by Law. The below parties have been served this matter on 12-4-2022. Respectively
John A. Yanchunis Jonathan M. Sedgh Linda P, Nussbaum Heather H Jones Morgan & Morgan, P.A. Morgan and Morgan Nussbaum Law Group, P.C. The Consumer Protection Firm 201 N. Franklin Street 7th Floor | 850 3rd Avenue 1211 Avenue of the Americas | Florida Tampa, F! 33602 Ste 402 New Yark, NY 10036 401 E. Jackson Street (8135)-275-5272 Brookiyn, NY 11232 917-438-9102 SunTrust Financial Center (813) 222-4736 (fax) 212-738-6839 inussbaum@nussbaumpe.com | Ste 2340 ivanchunis@forthepeople.com | jsedgh@forthepeople.com Assigned: 1144/2020 Tampa, FL 33602 Assigned: 08/18/2020 Assigned: 09/30/2021 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED | 813-500-1500 LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED 813-435-2369 (fax) □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ irm.com Assigned: 08/31/2020
Leslie Guillon Michael Anderson Berry James E. Cecchi Lori Gwen Feldman Arnold Law Firm Arnold Law Firm Carella, Byrne, Cechi, Olstein, | George Gesten McDonald PLLC 865 Howe Avenue 865 Howe Avenue Brody & Agnelic, P.C. 162 Half Moon Bay Drive Sacramento Sacramento, CA 95825 5 Becker Farm Road Croton on Hudson, NY 10520 Sacramento, CA 95825 916-777-7797 Roseland, NJ 07068 917-983-9321 916-239-4787 aberry(@iusticedyou.com 973 994-1700 888-421-4173 (fax) 916-924-1829 (fax) Assigned: 08/20/2020 973 994.5744 (fax) lteldman(@4-justice. com leuiflon@justicedyou.com LEAD ATTORNEY □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ Assigned: 09/17/2020 Assipned: 08/20/2020 Assigned: 09/17/2020 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED Jane Back O'Brien Daniel H. Levi Brad Scott Karp Anna St. John Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & | Paul Weiss (NY) Paul Weiss (NY) Hamilton Lincoln Law Institute Garrison, LLP (DC) 1285 Avenue of the Americas | 1285 Avenue of the Americas | 1629 K St. NW Suite 300 2001 K Street, N.W. New York, NY 10019 New York, NY 10019 Washington, DC 20006 Washington, DC 20006 212-373-3497 212-373-2384 917-327-2392 (202) 223-7300 212-492-0497 (fax) 212-373-2384 (fax) anna stiohm@mhiliorg (202) 223-7420 (fax) dlevi@paulweiss com bkarp@paulweiss. com Assigned: 07/52/2022 jobrien@paulweiss com Assigned: 10/11/2021 Assigned: 09/29/2020 LEAD ATTORNEY Assipned: 09/29/2020 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED | LEAD ATFORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED LEAD ATTORNEY : ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Kyle Alan Shamberg Weekinaton, STE 1249 Jonathan M. Jagher Erich Paul Schork Michael L Roberts Chicago, IL 60602 > Freed Kanner London & Millen | Roberts Law Firm US, PC Roberts Law Firm 3 12-750-1265 923 Fayette Street PO Box 31909 20 Rahling Circle kvle@lelln cam Conshohocken, PA 19428 Chicago, IL 60635 Little Rock, AR 72223 ee 09/17/2020 650-234-6487 312-810-5824 (501)-821-5575 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED 224-632-4521 (fax) erichschork @robertslawfirm.us (501 )-821-4474 (fax) . ijagher(otkimlaw.com Assigned: 09/17/2020 aprilburton@robertslawlirm.us Assigned: 09/57/2020 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED | Assigned: 03/18/2021 PRO HAC VICE ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Michael Milton Liskow Janine Lee Pollack . Calcaterra Fora □□ ions Karen Halbert Melissa Robin Emert Calcaterra Pollack LLP Ste 9th Floor Roberts Law Firm, P,A, Stull, Stull & Brody 1140 Avenue of the Americas New York, N¥ 10036-8803 20 Rabling Circle 6 East 45th Street Sth Floor 212-899-1761 Little Rock, AR 72223 NY, N¥ 10017 New York, NY 10036 mltskow@catcaterrapoltack.co 501-821-5575 Assigned: 69/17/2020 212-899-1760 in * (fax) ATTORNEY TO BE 2078 ta) stack-co Assigned: 09/17/2020 Kerenalber t@rabertslantim. NOTICED abrody@ssbny.com ‘onan Assigned: 09/23/2020 Assigned: 09/17/2020 LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED NOTICED
Via Pro Se Email Portal Judge Paul A. Engelmayer United States District Court Southern District of New York Thurgood Marshall United States Courthouse 40 Foley Square New York, NY 10007 12-4-2022 In re Morgan Stanley Data Security Litigation Case No. 1:20-cv-05914-PAE Re: Letter Motion for the Order of Acknowledgement of Dkt 125, Dkt 126, Dkt 127, pursuant to law, accept Scribers Appearance and issue an additional order Granting Electronic Filing Request Dear Judge Paul A. Engelmayer and corporation,
Melissa A Linden, scriber, ask the court to grant her requests in this Letter Motion for the Order of Acknowledgement of, Dkt 125, Dkt 126, Dkt 127, pursuant law and accept, Scribers, Appearance and issue additional order Granting her Electronic Filing Request. As the above request ed action will instant terminate the confusion surrounding the above mention matter. Much more to the point assures, scriber, the court, is aware of who she is. In addition, scriber, asks the court to review exhibitA, this is a snap shotof the courts public docket, showing the parties that appeared or flied in the above mention matter, currently, Melissa Lindens name appears to be void. Because Melissa Lindens is a named class member, and submitted fillings, her name should be present. As it appears void from being listed as either, a party who made filings or a party who made an appearance in the above mention matter, is why scriber is asking for the above-named relief and remedy, Highlighting to the court, to the best of scribers knowledge, these are the basic requirements to litigate in southern district. With scribers name being void, the record appears as if she doesn’t exist, when applying court process and the law. Thus, why scriber is asking the court to confirm her filings met the courts criteria and require to appear in the above mention matter, and is why scriber is asking for this confirmation, to be remedy in the form of an order. Noting, by rendering the requested order, scriber is under the belief that this will alleviate future appeal issues, that might arise if left un remedy. As before the courtis, scribers, appearance, motion to file electrically and assurance she is capable of filing electronically. Wherefore, scribers, request the court provide remedy to the ambiguity surrounding scribers appearance and ability to file electorally. Both of these issues and their status
in court, seemingly,are not defined and is why scriber is asking the court to grant this Letter Motion for the Order of Acknowledgement of Dkt 125, Dkt 126, Dkt 127, pursuant to jaw, accept Scribers Appearance and issue an additional Order Granting Electronic Filing Request, in addition to grant any cost or expenses associated with this filing.
Respectively Summited
Melissa Linden . Order for Letter Motion for the Order of Acknowledgement of Dkt 125, Dkt 126, Dkt 127, pursuant to law, accept Scribers Appearance and issue an additional order Granting Electronic Filing Request Is entered on
and is so ordered
Siite Se ae EES ero oe reineao oa TESST Recerca eam acer □□ eae ey GES GRAS OR ES ee PieU ORGS is nin Org AE ea CORES GGUS ee eC aa CeO ee Ee nies OI ces SDE Se BE pee es Be ee ES oreo □□ ERE OSes preted Dor □□ ae peace Soe □□ eG ee ees wegen ARC Se rere BS Oe eae EES COS GS a eo On Cat CSE Ak ele as EAS hea Rona tree oN Soe ECE SERCR Ore RIS ES eine ee □□□ Oe omnes eon mana meses re OA NR Sena RR SO Seis Pate Sapam ae TEE Oa GCE SEU Ee ee es GE ake EAS tiaret asa we Peis FR SESE eee ONES LE RE EN aie tPA een Lee Reranch Sie eaten LA A Semorina Ave ES SS cies ee SO SC ESTE ae oe ae eT LS Rie Oe panes Genera cS □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ Oe Oe eee SESS SHOES Ls SORE hse aie □□ OES SEO OE eR See Be SEAS SES ESS Se coerce rian ernie Nene ger aM ene SESE Sse seen aC OE ee □□□ re cs cabana esi PO a Se Re staat oo ee ra ee ee RECs □□ eae nabis moni Setter pcome ars nl enon mame SOS □□□ Es ES ee Wibod rer RENE □□□ pen rae SE dae EUeb sain Ruetcemmar § Cras a Sherine, Noose eae anu ets □□□ OO ee or LD Ee He SES SNES a a A) ESRD SORE Ce RRR a a IRC RARER: en Cees ne RU Eee SR ESI Cee □□□ near aioe aa SUS ee ane Siena ees □□□ Gl nena etter □□□ ESOS ES □□□ eS eS eee Src Ua ar eo Be Se eee Ree Se OES Un ae a ESSER SUN Ca RE Se rr OS ES a ie □ oe ROS EOE □□ SO OR ee Sora CRUING (Rene aeRO a ae SURE SSSA ioe aie iia elena DO Ga eee SUE as (Une Caen ne □□ es Oh UGTA OSS ee He SE ee Pe oe USGS eS oobi arena ee ei ees □□ eee □□□ a ae GC nese GOs 2 oe upasertn a □ ae rrr Gari nae Pioeer Serer SSP Oa Sy PER or at Borg GE OSS aE a REpe tee Sevueene (Cae Cr ued Ne ae Pee □□□ eee: oone: Senora arden CO SESE Ee ees Shae EO □□□ □□ ae □□ SIS Rosin io Secon acid be i PEASE □□ □□ □□□ es a a Oe a een ie HI Sees ee DA □□ oot ara cee Nera Onan ners ee ee ae Samana GG eee ae Pe eevee cee Be COME eee Raat □□ auee er EE OE ORE EGS es Ce Sg Braces tae eee, SSS eat nape cere une” RO ties eran ae ee Uo SU Gast geeteas Ce ee ee ee eee □ ee A SI ie ee □□ EG US OG ee ree an BORIS Riagiste eine meen Guin Satinmn enter Baer rig cums tune ESL SISO er Cone ae ORES OOS □□□ SE CCC Te ee SSE OSE Os SEE eee ama OSES BEES ek URES ORG RSs RG A pomeuettae Ee aici Be ee PEO SCS SOE CC eee en Ce eee ores eC ae ee □□ eee een lbs Orie Seen Sie ee Se OE OO SIE ee ND Ri ain Coie oe Seana Sag ES ee Gee Se ee CG USSR SAGE aan ere See Sein ana arte re ewnen cei Ree □□□ Sek ae Nee pare ba SESE SG US ah MOAR SRG Reece ee nooo ae SE CO ete Race ay Cucina ERE aD heel □□□ Serie mie ent ac mene SS SS tae Ciera i Raise HERS Scie heyh cists tee i DEG SR ARN a TR oe AC □□□ Ea Sr a eens Cage omunete Lees ER Cae We ee es Se □□ ee Bo RS aE a De ees RE ES Se ee Coos ae Gi aoe eases simone we een Rao Sree Seon Re Cea Nn Wet ae san □□ AE Rea □□□ SUR Sushi ers ian san lebanon) aeantinl magi na ER Sr hae eis etic tbe Mtns □□ ne atta oreati EERS Sirviae □□□ Sarsa ARSE Sie RS eh fos See RUE ia Snr ae wineLc Oe ge ARICA TOote ersinatead Sots OER ar ga Bepraie Sr etre Re earn RSS CaN SERS oS □□ CO ea eet eet Se a CRE LEIS coe RN Sh St ee Ee oe I TEAS COS ES SieiE an re ng is emia Or Ee Sans ae pated ticwaaie setae HE eet ea rece ESSE Catt SOO EGE RO ne seta Ee Oe SE es oe a ee maid SUhNe aun pete Cin UREA □□ NE dager MES ee cope are REE ERS aaa tet ipa oa creek DERN eo oe ee ce oe ee co eee Se TSO A eee Ue □□ ee Ge Eee ee Se oe Heinesen oe Oe none □□□ □□□ ear Ses Si sie eres EO RS □□□ eae RGR Ur a Se Sera GEER EOS RSS Peco te eatin □□ cereal palsgalicren Gain □□ nucsars iy Ree oui Fran Se SUSUR ergata RS SULS Coen ES ee □□□ nica dah seep earn oe oer an aera mrtar nS □□□ ere ries re Geers eR eee Tere Les □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ eh PEC TSI patentee □□□ CEOS EL a eH ere ae aaa DEES et Sareea ic Pacer re nce He PESTS See ga eas ee oe □□ eiab USE RorR ia ee Ge □□ OS eke OST CG ee i Ue ee ee SR ERS RG io Sn Se ae ee OS Oe cs : □□ ee ea creme mae tin eee ae Boe ee ee oe BES ESS Se) ESSN OF a Aes una Stier Roca files pie ea eemone ec ama Nes Se ea SS cS Soa ere es SPH Make seer ai aan ta ESE UE SIE Cos he CORE Ree SEE ESE ARSE OO SESS ee SG eC Cec Se FES RAT ee enti ee ee ee eee eae = us Lr EE re Ue □□ a Brae Ra ee ob ee UNIS eens eae □ eee Nae ea Dray aes SO a Se EELS UC ac IRC Nn Catena □□ Be REA GUA intte □□□ uaergici SEER NSS Cs Sie ES EE a SOREN SESS le Be ae ACG rr Peer oe SAC SC Tp ES We RET ONL a UE Oni UR UR pA
spa tl ainda selena SUIS este cat seater □□□ □□□ Sopp sho ec econ Re □□□ cen ea nena nmten ee Oe □□ spgupiitamintn nreeeneatt nate cation, emits aa ie eae earth Oe ee eee □□□□ a a sen te enue ear eater ana pebba gt ea Nee uaa □□ SURO COS RUS RSC SASS SC Scere tare gin □□ er □□□ □□ Ur Se a ee ORR HR EE Be RSS ee Oe See guns ES SESS Re seat Rees OS SEG Seater ae asin Se SIRE pane UG EG NS AS □□ epee iy a CES SS eee re sbeelett ey SEES CE SOUS ee TOUS SEU OE MER ei oar ESE □□ □□ PS SOEs Sa tem amen ices a eo meaner an OS □□ er Rea eS eS Os SE eo □□ □□ he = pienae aaa as EGER □□ Oe eee ear Nona ate oan tage peat ean □□ ecm PASE SEG I □□□ OE aes ER OSES GER Pipes Can or ea ee acisame anne cminoet RD EI RUSDCI AG NLantoiiiu cca ain dem ee CURIE, CONSE Puen Oe cana Hosier Uy ee ROE aE Ce Beta rtanines Contour □□ □□ ee eee rr ee PS er) Us ee □□□ □□ □□□□□ SS ES Ue eee RR ee Ee Se □ ee eee erent rec ES OO Sones US HO Ra OO ae rie Ree PONSTEL ea oe SS GA Seca ee ey □ Be Se ee OTR CON □□ SURE □□ □□□□ (Oe oe eee eres EG GL ees eee eee □□ es ROE Se aeons ere a ee Ge □□□ —r—— Sele Rh rear emma rate Sees at oan Scan RE Ss Sod iene Era ee eubete ried TENE Sn See RE detect aie entaeuin REE CHE SORE RUC SSRN □□ □□□ i‘ iS ro □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ SE Oe cee EUS SNE ARG □□□ □□ POS Ee eS eS sae ms aR a a ce Srmeeeat my ke Se OE CRON SRS □□□ ouwng sien neeereaue cepa cea Steere ae SOR ROM SENG Wile □□ □□□ □□□□ Ramee ene eces DOSS UAE Se SSS es Se CO RSS a tee aC met er ce ee ae Se ae □□ Se ee ee RSs ne ee a Sisters MERON CD ness gre namics ener Lene Nnraee wntee me ys pC Gn red woes □□ seca GcGRe aR Ee Sa are ee □□□ oa OC alo □□□ □□ □ Ce eet toaenny eS Re nega □□ □□□ RES CUS Case bay ae ute OS ea cle □ Ce coe Ease — □□□ Ces ies a ZS SCS Ga : Lee ee ES es ee Eee a CN □□ pe ne □□□□ □□ eS oe EOS OSS GO □□ ee ee ae reaertee Ree ee 2 Be AO es hearer Fat Meme see Bg eg eS ee ay □□□ ee ES GG Us Ee □□□ mS Lee LE ea □□□ □□ es CRIS □□ eu RNG ad ec A ene arin cet EA Bs ESE es □□ Se ee (eo COU ee BES eae — □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ oo SURE bee (SUS a sul oe aint pee Ur cert ee □□□ UE □□ □□ nee SO A es eae SNE □□ pea as Fe OO □□ Se SE □□ Sees a □□□ NE Rete Be a saath ae ee SES □□ □□ Ee Ree oS SESS Geese UR SSeS □□□ a Leng Sa SR ae SE Or eg CR a acns ae PERS Rea a Wie sero oreeten Men □□□ Aa Serene □□□ □□ □□□ □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ cacy — Re OSE OE □□ ER ee a SO eR SRE sree 9 Ra Perea we ec SAUD cee See MASSES unl Soe tame Guten para meant □□□□□□ □□□□□□□ Sirs a et an ne ne eas Shs Ee Suet eect cets Son Ninn Sean SURG Seas mcr te oa SORE rtaee tata Let ah oanah □□ at aya Smee PORE eek PELE ee SR ERE Sus UM Fayrig nic tas oe iaeacusang aes aree es SRS SSESHI Soest ane! of Guckerine aoe tiraa hoch aed, coat ar eragucets acer ente □□□ SEN ner ate oe □□ CESS SS Ns en ee BER repens mouae or ar Cir rauginte Swett ge eS
noo
a SU ma ne doa tne SOAS aE es — ecistectat ae eee Tice a eee 2 Si ee se SIR RE ee nes Bs ban Pat ee 2 os oe reat bree Bees san Bae eee CeCe ene pe aces EN □□ ete ads Rahat Op ROR pore oo a acetate OSS eee: Seat SASHES RARE SE Sa pater earn tee See oe □□ REL oe ee eee BG See ee, = oe OE emp Eee Pope ee sere ee aay ee ce USE CRE ee CE Salada a 0 fie ee et raeade RSE SEs EEE Secs pia □□ oo ee ee eae ee se See oe on eae ee ee Garcieae SCRE sree HJ le sete ee Ss ee oh Mc □□ Se sees IESE ME et Rameuomans SN OEE □□□ Mee pase: SESE □□□ □□□ Ee ec ee ee
« —se PU pe seecers ee ee aaah it eA NO □□ eee Ue Pa Nancie Ouse Oe es a □□ prattcaett SOS Sse Se fi eee CRS ee see SS oe ee os □□ ee seie Ll Oe Nr □□ Seen a) ei ad SA ee ee ee □□□ a Scheie eneeNcch emneeenace Ee Se ee Seo ig Cae i □□□ isa ee SS rrsi—CsS eee — oe SESE SEE a SUE oe ntl CC □□ ec ek ee SESS SS sO SE RRR Oe ce es | ESOC SOLE □□□ a nee sass Sia er wee ee ESS SAU ERT □□ SE REGUS Seas a □ ets ee □□ Sse ea SRE OED, REECE Se eo SRG Head Oe □□□ a rt—™—C—“R ee a □□□ A □□ ES es eo ES SEES oh cae So ae ete Sees Se Se ee Ee ee cai Es fae eee Soe ee Se SECU ER Che ie SEC ake th —=“E te Ear ee Poe GU inete ae. es Sle Be ee ee eee sé □ BER Shee □□□ □□ OE Ei ibybame sence ee □□
Ee as Rice ne enone oe Kee sun ae ates Le Ea a CREE SCP □□□ Sea HOSES Ce Bassler □□ ere □□ okt ree A Nan ieoaenarne □□ rook Ce ee oa □□□ AS (ea Ab ee oe kk oy □ He ee SS rrr 2 ee RUS Ua ROS Sievan Se Ie NRE SEE oP RB oo Re ERs Oe ans ee Sack ee nore ie "er"? ee fo Fee OU = eee aE eee ee enue Ses Sen Sea SI Butoh Scania te Spe □□ Reena a NO ERE Rr ine ago POEs ea so een satao es Beate pres pee ea Ue as oe ey □□ □□ rr Se Aare ee are Ae wae Beret et ene AERC Se cee SI Ss RES Nile 2 ee □□□ ee SER UC EOS eee ce ERR SSR UR SS Seis AGE a oe as SO AMER Se chs Pati oe SOE Ae na nasties Renee ae De ae A okisteen 5 eh □□ SoU De eens and BE CS Se ee ee Leer en Cees ee Se eee Specie ae □□ —rr— eshte ro EESanCED ee
es oo Be □□ ae SURG OR EE vigrina RIES ad ta epee Rae Sioa Ness □□ □□ [Pesos pea ee i esses Lr i □□ eo es i a aa bie, cen ues penis Gee ee SEES Se Sule ee SC ORI tek a ee Sa AE RS ORGS Ee sagt ce NaS ES oe eee Saas Sa at Songer Cane RSIS nae ape CesT ete et ands Dineen tenia Seon et ea AS RS Ea oer iy ee ees □□□ Stn EEN rae SEES Re es asi arene estore SeGh ee en □□□ □□ ee Sey Set eS eS SE □□
Ss fasta a ean Ta OR a eR a A Gea at rea GER A RA RAS EE eo os ienindtey wade oo ale aes ee SECU SECS Fl hae SUEUR Nees rnaete nett Ceo ates Ghia caet he RM Oa GREECE GSES ES et ce eae Eee SE □□ Se cee Seer Peis es SoS TEST SESS RUG SRE A are etn borane Ca Catia este ea hee and ON ROU en had Oe leno NIM PRL Siac Von ete ne PSOE □□□ St Peers catty Munna Senta □□□ etry Los Ra ream Bata ost aaa Ce SS RAG □□□ □□□ eta aero GE oe Geka RI uiseectin Grea tn □□□ Come cuca (eaiceTU SESS Oca nena ee oR LN Gun arte aa Rs ino manera eT Be Oe CIR RIL SUN a ean, Rc evap EO ne □□□ segs SONA ECE Saad cee ats erature Me unar go oe □□□ NRE Ca □□□ PS on Gn on edna Nees Cie PSS eeGtpel eens Serer Vue uae meat SENG SUS AS □ Rae EEO Ee GCE Be Co eat ME ant el uest Gur page pean a pe eee Ocean nae eemetea ROR oie OU Raa ata □□□ eines ete Ae 7 SEIN as Cras SN Nine earns MERON Be RE Nig etiite aS Re ERNE A Pee ee RE Gea SCE anne □□□ eC een Coe Oe ee ge RIN Og NE SS Coed GR BOA Gea EER aa BC oe Seen a rmaeer eas toner encite tine es ie ane ent ES □□ vais Sia UN nent) Uinaaner ORO I CR USN Hn inet ORNL □□ Nan REBEODN Sin ea nCIG a Gans Se Site ae a ESE EG ee OS TOS RUNNION Soe i CO Sena IOS GR HES ene EY TO SY SECEDE 00S a □□□ A ces oar eeacresey pel Cacia SE OU GN GSE SN ral cine sree ete cera eget Se teeena ec CRS Ges RE □□□ ESS EE ASSO OU Ea EEE LACES a cating acts gruneeaun Ge CORE pti ict ON US SPRUE eS BSE GE ENE GaSe CS SS SE age □□ Rabi eS ES asa eee a eee eset RSET SRO US a Roars nyo bora gr iene Sener eS area ua □□ ees COR ERR RAs a2 cee Arr Oa renee se □ ee ESS SSS ESSE SSSR CORSE CEA SO OG CHa Be ee er Cn Un ae SISO a aE aut Daas ee ee ee es ENE es eoria Riana Ogee eee ee EUS SCO ieee cue uae gees ot etch MATAR 2S □□□ OU RGR Es a Bc Un ern nn SE RES Goa □□□ Ry Re A TEES eR Ae AS □□□ co SER □□ EE AEG oe SENET Oe a NU aE EL NcoI RU A geet uaa nen ena awa i erin mentee seh Geert Ayu Ries canoe Cont nln rs ie meee Gade eM NY SENSIS EUS ER ESSE FOS OS AEC See eal a FS CSE SS RRR Oe Oe EE CRP □□ CSE EAS SE BO ES Ge CS Oe Oe rumen aes □□ ae eater ese ES ce SESE aN eae nae tke eR nee SE SCS OSS EGS re □□□ Ree A coed ZR ee re eaten ee ie ae res Peekes torreon ink Orden cepataepin cece astm Nara be ieee aN Ce ROR ee Se) ee ae Sis a a cr ead Bins A Sea ee ees Tepe ena te Roe cm nen Naga COG Si tea ebiere rs uci teres ce ged etna Tennis mm ed een an eae OS □□□ SG UE TMobile Minnie Ce Oa SUI eo in DS Rca as Savage SN Us Ue ee pasa eo PGE Se Rue a CON □□ Dea NU riee ETN Sem urea Re Be eee ee Ho ee etee □□ □□□ cl STOIC Utara Gro Ucateo ceacieet ger eh Noe NMG ERUsoe Cs Heh aren Real Urvashi Roan A eee Ce □□□ ES EGGS □□□ eect EO iad BE □□ RES PSU rte ie Ce CEOS DSc SOS SUS Tae □ SS Cee EE, Dai areeg eo ee ENE, EOS oe eer eS ER teeta anh Da ce ntiran oon Cn amar hie vice ceset retin CON ca a □□ LOE catia ciaue Giana atic ob setae in an eesee oe GRICE Ea tire puter ra a cess Lr ans is pyres Sian ea Re ROSE LOE, Ru RTCHE ST KSC amen ene EOS oie ee □□ SL RSS ABS Ser een ak □□□ che Mabe rig CL RS ee Sa RR Cee □□□ Saul BO SS Sa a aE Sg OR IO Sep ce ert Ee OR IRS CE SOS CO te eR Ge RSS ats SR SS ES CS A GR Se COR a reefer mean aT SS SE RS US EGE oR RES ee ee Ns ase ats wea aie Oc Ca ARTA Garten CECE Cap ee Cate □□□ MM ERO Sa a hata Sic □□ eema mr eS ieee cee Sr epee UE SEE SO OS SI a hy opisatas □□□ OOS ee Ue SS SR ge SU Aer □□□ □□ ee eee Go Senet UG ee or SAIS eet □ ie Oe eH a Ma ees EGG evoke Mcior Geer □□ NOS Ue ea ee me ee rae ieee el GS ISS SS GS aa a A ee eee PE ISRO AER AGS el oa Ona A ERS GR Oy ei ea Ra SiS Scatias shash UN geting. ibn haha) Sonate Saeed en ee aE NR OAS ae ASS ah eS Fen Cag Sete NSE PN □□ SE OAR Bee eset AS RE UAE ote reese Co ee SSS ESO SESS US Tas SUSE A RA Se See Cha Raat aRierbrat ac tac nestor se antes aos eee eee een TT zabo Nip tig Gig OC, Bi cre ean Cee corms Sacein bread Parent cite cern male na imino aacre REE □□ ae esata Se ereat ere □□□ ua gor □□□ oe eee) | eat ceca eee ea GSE AC AS RSC rr Seach echt ea esac a ROPER AMG SUES CE UE CaS te Gln cay IV cn BAA UE A CRY niin enue een eee ee eared coe Capa pega ear rer eens EAs ihe Urns ets Sa ENS RS NEE VC SU eG a ee nee ee ee ACES Sar CAN eee Siete ae cet ere Ale weaide FREES) SERENE RCT CS □□□ Sores aoe Douce eee aS OE as OUR SSO hE OS eR EEE SOS ON Ee Os ca Be Cenc Cees Seta sent ene en UT ra SES A ace a ea agence Cones ee tn bags vark ao WE Cue oan Wot neeey ear SOs ee □□□ BGP ee ea □□ USES SS Ss SS Re rascal Nea Bae OS DEE OR Aro eevee at aot oe mc a eae ero □□ Nae tact mica eke oe OMe ee ee eee [2 eae SMG ce a ee eo Giana □□□ □□ RUNS CRIN A ECE COE, Bare ie | RES Tae Gear es Hier REUSE RU CES Urs Gi SAS, ES □□ Cs Ga a ESRC end Aeraiisin or tuurne un onan Ria soe udm o/ttin MeO ONC. Se es Her bay ani netie Gale cee ee UG ree suc ae ieee SS BSE a oer eae □□ ea plat Ger ene ae Ba □□□ Pe Sek Fa Sa ees cosa ese ion ea Siege Ga eC Tere REAL CARS Pte SOL rR at ne Sah a BONG □□□ □□ RECs □□□ ae ua eT eer a □□□ Dlr OC ee SUE eae EES SR ONE COS eS a ANU Sgn CAG pane □□ SGaGa in tu emmamereuiaia sie eater Umer nes ee ORelnGr ESAS CEU Seas ac Sait Coe Oumar Ra Sue acres NO rs Ce a Rov aries rape dacees uch uecmuenmegaus movertesia ensures dumbantonagusr cope ee ee ee PALME IR □□□ Se re CRS CCE SS ar Pa osu a Deas AGES es ae eaiatita erin au See ee PELE Oe ene Se Ee Us NS BSCR GZ ee OES aS SO ik iE Aa pie er heat CS arcs ak ume meer eee er Lo meio PASSER EA □□ ES SSS IE EA GSES Cc Ss A De aca EE URE OG ead gS a ES EE SS Ce □□ Re reg ce sc cS □ A Ee CS SES □□□ □□□ ane aig a aah Reece Te aE PAU AADAE Season oeoea cecee ete ee eae abemtecn nl irate Un pu urd □□□ ie amet ie tite a on aes SNR CU a □□□ PE RO BE GOAN Ieee aN tora lacia Aaa man ate Aer hue SCRE Sa EEG □□ SEAS SSS SSeS GRE ee GREASE SSA SS OS ag SOUR et ee ce ga entra cen Se SUE Ea □□□ SE □□ □□□ ee ene Co Gale noe RTT Lath ea SL
ny .
LEONE ERO EEO Eee ee HERA na a Be SS ee a hee oes ie SG neuen eS □□ ne ER ee ee ee ee HOSES SE CSUR i Cs UP □□ an cou ec mere aime Comin on aeeur se ete a eee A ee Rae Mam UT eee SAT SEA Se AUN Se RIS □□ ee caer aud ea Se CNS Eee en ees EERE vette suneee es Re Pence eit bets HE MALU ALS ee gee OS aac RON eer ape A SSRSGR eA A erga rae lr lO aretha estan ao Gen ey SHES Ca UA 2 ESS EAA MR oa OE □□ □□ SE RS RSS ESE Le □□ eee doer Hie SS SOE SS Oe 2 eS pe ee ee Geese ohh SOON ep get cesmicloractRiemai sora ae Se Sos Se a ee ee ae Be Reese Cee es gu □□□ Sia ee ES □□ SU OES SES es ore Se De Se ee OE SES one seein Nore ur ee renl ieee en aRIseN UNIS BE Be UP ST RC coe US St EOS Fe Bhan Mea □□□ SCS ASUS UGA SEE Sie ae SOE CG Sa AES CRU Sanaa se ec Rune arta emma □□ AR ae Ria erna cron Naina □□ cuss CANE en Rea eine genie eR □ eS ee ee ie ee ee ee RS es a ee Rego a Buse aoe ee a it ie SES ae eG cae OO ciara ste ne la eer aie emma ae ERE OS □□□ DCS SSS SE er ea Be ie a Gait See UN a ioe Re ANU Nu iN DIN Aen OT BIG PR eaten aes aU LC aT ESTES OS OE SUES CR □□ □□ OS □□ Oe Serer ge eee ROSIE SS SOS CS AR RR Sar RE SSS Oe Gt Oa RR Se eee (acura get Ba ER SRS So HA URS ESS SC oe Soe arena ttl a ncpg Ronhige aeia in oes Ueno pAiane eB Nae Pe ee cc ae? ESD CR RCS Sin carts ahaa USE □□ Re See, ee ISIE SRST OS SE Rip AIRC eS La ES ce an ian: MET ote Oat EES ESE ROS Sac EN Caer earn Ua ners ee ee ee Rue □□ ee ee OS SS SS Siotigiacr □□□ peer □□□ SOU ee □□ ees □ ee ieee = Pe SG ae PEGS Fa eee a ee eer ee oe Co eS BO SCE Cs DOs ee eine SSS eS elena □□□ USE eee and ce □□ a ae Des □□□ Pe tg eT ar ees GUNG SEA ea en □□□ SG eee I Ee ss ge Be □□□ SSeS OS GEE GR aati Gee seem ee BER Be Se ee ES SNARE □□ ee aang ele ots LETS CST TEE ORIN Ae ea eaten cere ui sais Lec io tea Sy oe Mince SOUS i Bee oe ee GU Se eee a ee SOS Ee OS EG sec ce Se Gs Ee hee re SU 2s BERGE CSE SSIS ADHESION □□ Ue Gers ened! ee ee ee ee □□ EOE ESE A □□□ Ge a Re □□□ eee eae eee te FURS As oa aa ee aN BE □□ Ge SS ei ss De ge EGE US CENA SE Os Re aoe aoe oem ee Heri Maid aiioe Save pega re Sees See tn eee oe at Grtinay at ercubiats Ant rongmmenl mneemin aa menos MeN Sle Fegir Gots Law ieee cnin GENE Ea Ea aetna RSP TS ECA cee DEE RS OEE ean oo Pe as GI Re ie GEO Goh CE Uae caceerid nS Cn te eam TES RSME een eee et a esbbecbidl atuuea sire sparsity peice CON SU SS BL FS Se CO Ue Cap aaa BEES SIR UE SIS NERA BLU Sr SRS Geo ettea ssi ee es ee OU SR SS ETERS Sa ae EEN CS ciopo anton ger Tan gtea in GRE une MU NESS SAGA! anno TORSO ee aa ane Pe ee Oe □ ces oe I ESSE GRESSION ae □□ er Oo REAR ee a ee Ca eee (oo rrr ET ed □□ ee ee ae pe EO ee ee ee Ee ee ee pone ee ee Oa ee parti ee a Ente es EE NS | CE ae BANE Nicltrpi ote cs cg ee nua ea □□ SOEs ae ee si ee □□□ Sos eee rahe See Sel ae UNSER SEE □□□ Sales Co es se □□□ ae ea a eae te Oe aie ee ee ESS ee Cea rue ee □□□ a ee SOLE Ser □□ eenty Seeing SS □□□ ee ecient Fay BAUR es eee coreg nee ere Pes cease ese OS Sees □□ Cae atatieeds teen nemee nee SORE OCU □□ CA EG RADE Se ee Be ee Ce ee Se ae CE sO a ne See ee aber ees CU ES eae ond Gee bh Sic Res ce Seer ae a ESN LS Seppe a RO espa arene genaetec nde NUTS eae Ce Rene ee ee ee
cee ORES Se RS os ee ORS Se ee es ee es ah □□ eoruanaortessine Oe ae eae inter: Fe 2 tie earn ce und pee Nc ee shea Mapecet aie peers neice □□ horse nore en Baio or oe ee Bee ee □□□ EOS ences eras ae ea IOSGUAE OST Set es OSes porenaiagehaete ee Bene ie SONI Sic ee eee □□□ nes eae ae □□ — tl antl RENO So =. Be Sees ee ee Peer oa □ a a eee ESS SEUSS SERRA RS) SLOT ras ne ae Ee Kimo Peres 202 oe □□ SS SONS SU es ee (oe ee SE EO eet ee Ero RU NaS □□□ a stations aes ee OBO ria eee Sens Cs ae a a HS Rance PE nists rr Es rr
ces ean ae earn es ee ieee rr ees Ieee tiie ES Ss aulrouennaen paleo sann aR SESE OO a gee eg Tne a RSUnE oe Ree (ES Hey OS cane a SRL aS □□ cea ee A OR ces SES ee SS PARSE NORCO A ines Se ee SG lL bead be oer See Spier LR Sanne. eee Se □□□ □□ CANN ee eS parece ee eo BSS es ee Gren UAC a eines OS Be Ese Set ee ee Cee Sa Ty hse ee SRST 0 EERIE AE EE oo sie ee ES ran ORE □□ Ue ea Sn) ee a ‘ieee soe □□□ reer □□□ eee Lanne oy eee rae CH MR Se □□ ea Se Cg Ea eas OS Oe =. rr Se ae es oe ee : Sees Oe ee Ee Lemire visti Pas: ES Stee Sree ee Recs NU CRE SEER TSE SOE ee Beers ees eee Sa Aeon Grea Dee Cs ee es Hs maar □□ CROSS Cg Ue A eens □□ Leste fats a eee ERE □□ Ss ee gents canara Sys □□□ RCE ipaRnN screen isnarors ceed nce reas OES SES eee ane iy Ute SEA SSS a ON SUES □□□ Tosa Sees 2 ae 5 SEER OU SUSE OE Se oe Ne Coe SO SSeS Te eS ss iste leet Se eo eS ee eee ie Cee ue pos A ee oe ee □□ es mn So Ce ce RACE lero se ee pes bo ee aaa 2 ee eR es soma OBS SE eee Oe i SSS tee □□ SOURS aces page ie ee x BU Os CSE SS Bee Ea to eee en Sone eo eee Lee: ene ba Ghat Sota Eater aca a a Een eae EE de CRE Siioasnionnrds ee eee ee eas
SE Seedirers aes (Gane connec re Eyota seein PIECES Se icuensnteatcon: eases one □□ eee Sore a tane ea ee ee See TESST ee eae we a OR Boa ONES Hever einine oe eee □□□ EG □ SO ree aS EO Sate es Rs oe HG ser Bal: el bee SECA ae cal ESOS Ge Ss Pg es a Ee ee ee rr So □□ SER OS EC DER aay Sanayi ce breads ee feet SSE eS poe EE eS STS rl shih [apa OE SEES lc lenis FR Se SS ERR EAE □□□ tetarte ee ee See eos eee — ee
Ce eee eae cous Se OE Oa SOS As oo 8 CS Se
Oe ea Ee ge SOR Gee: Se — a Cs
ee □□ eee Se ee
ee ahs ee poe cee □□ SS Seer an DO [ante jhen are eis SEE Se eee Foes maps ansratnt a PORES ah ori tat versed fies oe eee eee eee a Ce
ee RE oe = ————— LLL
— ~~~. senteee seit ee . es SUS, Ces Se ae □□ Bie Talla So eerie erece □ = □□ See 8 ee — ee ee One eee . re eG a Oui i epee EUS TR Bee a
BOSS ee med ee ue ee □□□ □□□ SORE SENS Be Sao a ee
US □□□ OG eee OR Es eee EO □ ee Beene
Se Sees ee me SERGE finite) ee ee es ee Sue □□ □□□ □□ ee Re We Hae ache TARE Sek See SaaS Te ae
ee SUES es aia A BS Se Saas ne eet mnie eget RRO ae Ee eane — ee eats Ree Se, Pee SE nee
bee EE SN eS Os See ee Re ee □□ SR es es
oe □□□ as a □□□
oe ee soo . ee oe
| 2 SE □□□ ae sini el er So
□□ □□□ EL baa es eR 2 ae ee SO Gy □□ ena eee ee ‘aie a ewan
SEE cpees □□□ Oe Sine ae a dactacees bas A wee UE SUeeS SE eee SAREE
ee Bevis Soar et URE □□□ ciaae ia subst: ce Se SPEER Sea oon saree ae SNe ESR
=n a eee ae — 2 □□□ ee Oe Spore SORES Roos SU Ug Se eat aptpe pat tran Ee RON Ben sues Bove SEP re Ce Neos Ceiee foresees rr . Regents Sorat Sarees RCE Pade Ue Seen Sete ee seis: —rr—”—CS Se. ee Se eer □□□ □□ Heres Bo □□□ SRE Ce ES
Se ar cL Ss eas ee □□□ ae a Dees SL OSes oe es ss oa Ee eee ee oe □□□ ae Bi 1g. See a □□□ Lee ESE Se
(ee Pee Le RE □□ es □□ PEE eae FES Se OS Aaa ast oe See spies or Deo oe aaa skigeiae ue ae eS GM TEP REEL - eg ee es ee Gotu -— oe aa SS BS RUS CR a SOLO ashes, RCT □□□ ea ee Reuse glete alone eee
□□ DD oe es asta Sanita BSE SE Ss □□□ EES
eo Sa iets ce EE SS Co ae LL SEES ee
ee) EES os ee Se eee one eee See) uma et □□□ ees oS
TES BS esa esa OS ee CR OSE a Glee ea eee eee SES ee ee is — aha — heater Ska ee spe Cumene Rae ea pee ara □□□ eyes ad oS WRENS OR ae SSeS UCN oh Sas De eS
EOE Ee Seen ee a eee BESS SS □□ aaa
es eer ee nes sat tet Aa, des as ae SU eae ane Rey Ease vena Bae SEES ees UE SSE aoe ees
Su 2 eS st SE □□□ □ a
Er SG □□ ee rT SE es es ater akc □□□ ad les, BC oT □□ ae Ce eee eee ee rere ee este □□□ □□□ GSTS □ ieee ee ee ne ee ee RC SEE mt PRRs eee Svea oe se eas ee ae ee me ater, LE Se tele Be SOE ah Ee ee Merete renee sae Saves Tingant se eee ets See PES Boece ae ee eS SUES ie aCe a □□□ ee SS SOG BN a Oe GEN OE SS See = □ □ ah BA Eo UGS □□ a ea coe ee es ES Peas ee aK mere ee pene ae a ee See Sea SS meee scape Sa □□ ce □□ PEs es EE agit SOS □□□ See es Bo Ges Sees eR □□ Sa ee Se eh ae (Oo eee cr ee Seige SS eC □□□ SSC RUS Se ee Hae □□ ea ee eo Sees Soe Se CE Sheua yaiimsuesen one SEL eee aoe Fe es ee ROUSE ee ee SU nea Bus eae Si Bae Se Sees cee ee es ee nbstieas ee Se dees es Sige UE ARIA manele crac LC pelea Soc ee lr shousmabcreses ab RS at POSE Seen a COURSE ee So i ag □□ rr Jere ee IS ee ee EEOC ess Sk SEES emer area: oer ee oe ee rr aso Coe eee mea {OSUNOE Cua oe human ee Sa Soe IN OLLI □□ ners antennae Acacias Se ee = a RS □ Ee es nese een GUTS Aenea eh sri EAE ae RT ESSN ERR Sn BPs NS ig RHEE re eee Se ee a ee ie □□ Aiomitea 5 ee ee ee oe eee SE eee eet Se □□ □□□ - = ee ciecen ine erion □□ ECS a Umass eee Sie aioese cae Ros □□ aT Sc ae Se SC ese Sees — rrr—“——“=*RCEOOC RaKG Steen EEC Stee crn Beane sheerenaes Ghee So ashes ah eat: Seg are RS Re ee ea oe Utes eet SU ee ae a ee alin Sars ONGGe: Somoahuc engniy te mente Ce eS Ca but ine ee ee eee eee i Hate AEE ee Cae encase COE □□□ TRS □□□ □□□ Svea ee Soe □□ eee ee RSE ees □□□ Seis eancanian armpenete Te Oe mean ee Se SEs es ee ee cee eG ee Sees eas) ee eee ee EC ee mee ee ee pe Oe ee ere Ge Ss ce earce PR Ce CER GORE a ganar ae Sciacca ee PIO Ge ES ee ua oo eee ee ee Soe A ee eae □□ EO eRe ee seit Se oe rr □□ Ueto MS NE ACHES! See ae cre Se ee on ee r—“—O—O—O—O—O—S—S—SS Se SEONG Rat SG Ue eee SUSE SHG Soria oe eae SCENE UR See ee aeace SE sede ee ed |= ee #-». = mec ee □□ = ates □□ foe □□□ □□ Sas REP Cae iment fe a ea ieee i ee TE Sus eastie es SS ee See se es OS See Es as GS er
sunt trensie erat nesting □□□ unr ol eos cotupara eine sca seesenan sccm □□ Sm et Se Ss eG PERG IS Se eS renee ee Shr eS es □□□ SS ati menue eunccoy rohan ence eee □□ Sa Pe reset eats caked Sen SONS Geter eine dso ioe eG Se Ce 8 oa COUN Be one ee eaten Se ee ea ee goer a ne EO SE nea RUA ee Soa Pe EUG □□□ OR ERS Se SES areas OS OR re a NS eS ein eas Uninc ese SE econo gee ee ae ee ee Se SUSE AS a oe Moet Caer: eee TR A ee = SUSE Vere ec rR Ran a Rea 2 SESS Go 8 aera a ea nee ce Sao org OS ee Soe eG Rte eee oe eo eee Sr Ne ee cen: coo oe ee es ma rrr □□ oe ee are se Bocas Teaco ee ee □□□ □□ ome cnet GS eee Res CRI eer OSES nes ESD AOE SO Sg eee ee EG Oe heater Se oe RUT TE en ay ses UO SE RE LUCE ORAS NCES EST □□□ ag ce oe mun □□ SE ees a Gas ROS □□ eee COE oe es nn the ES ae ee Se ES eee eel aSeoRe Snes Bo Se ESO Se erent oahu Sears pies nase nes aE ee oo Dr ee EEE ESIC Ne ease oe es Be Oe eee cenen a cea SO ee ee ee Be Oe 3 ee a ee Stee Le SRE ESE ee ae Siete Sree aares aati NERC □□ RE OS See □□□ Bees ee ee ll oe CO ee eae De) are ee See eRe Pe BESOIN eee ee OSS Tae □□ SECs PO SRE cio □□ ee Big ees Eee Sine SR EN PERLE UR) ee Eee sept ee SO ee Pein eee eet ecennames □□□ □□ □□ PERSIE Eaainn □□ eeeuecaal aetee nut SE □□□ Ceci enti GUE See □□ ee ie es Ogee □□□ sae Ces es □□□ ns oe ON See bee eal me ee a eee aa ORE ECGs BME OULENCe sos TENT UR EE □□□ ea UE Rene ees oS a Oe IS oe LOOM ER GNIS aa aN USSG ene Belmar raz SUS A eae Rca re Sean Se oS Obagi CoS Reyer peugeot Beane HES GSES SO CESS □□ bee □□□ Resp ee SOE Se es ROR occa EU ERA Ue □□□ oP ina tae near □□ Oo pe ssa ee ee ate einaca aeaaa Deaton SRine ee ORIN aN aaa ati Sreearacee ee SE Se oe ec SSE Fesoe nei So SECA SSE eS eae cu nares Sineiane ei ee Ur Rr SRP ee Pee ee ee Be □□□ □□□ pan ceece: RTS □□ a eae ee OS SS Pee SURE CU □□□ i Suara Cen OSE ea EA □□ ho RGA EER Ons oS RGR RU Ee Go Ga □□ eeie ae ie mee Ss 2s Pe ees Sram ah gt □□ Mes Ba gs ee eee eee unl Gennytee NET Aa Poet al Sane SUR Saba tims Mabie ween ort as Soe aT eee ee SRE Ee Re SCRA ain, ee eres □□ ee ar Recs tahun SUR ale Rae itrnese caree ai omer ars oe So moessea serial ear menu poe mean LCS RS EAR TE SON at OES □□ ESE Se □□ Sa eee CEE SEU ener reais
ee i
Goniohateg ines | 0011772000. ee ee creer □□□ □ | ee ee ehevidenes | Pein oe [even ee oe Se Se ee Goyohantes Pain| ES CI Ls cir Prominin error eaten [gam ence on | Sa BER Pre ee Le ee ee oe Aubhite co [Puig | [ope ee eatvolidatod Faatasir | 09117-2000 lee ot ee [nein Comueeg tain ao) io Gm Gans amet oe mtn ne Monn crm oe ne me ey ana | gars unr Te | Ome Soe cutee ig | Manan gant em Cae, CC RG ome terre iron ett re P pe ee cen Pre gmp □□ omnia nae enue Gite iC Neon = eommalidaed Place OWIEION Ma eerste tara po onsoldated Paiatll| 09/17 2020. a = Sh [Copledned Mate 001172000 bos Sean Pam = 0728 100 ee SIS SR SIE re Liem reese ee TT ME SGU Ca Cr LE a PACER Service Center : 8
Pursuant to the terms required by Law. The below pa served this matter on 12-04-2022 Respectively
John A. Yanchunis Jonathan M, Sedgh Linda P. Nussbaum Heather H Jones Morgan & Morgan, P_A. Morgan and Morgan Nussbaum Law Group, P.C, The Consumer Protection Firm 261 Franklin Street 7th Floor | 850 3rd Avenue 1211 Avenue of the Americas | Florida 401 E. Jackson Street Tampa, Fl 33602 Ste 402 New York, NY 10036 (813)-275-5272 Brooklyn, NY E1232 917-438-9102 SunTrust Financial Center (813) 222-4736 (fax) 242-738-6839 inusshaum@nussbaumpc,com | Ste 2340 ivanchunis@forthepeopic.com | isedgh@forthencaple.com Tampa, FL 33602
voy
Assigned: 08/18/2020 Assigned: 09/30/2021 Assigned: 11/04/2020 813-500-1500 LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED | ATTORNEY TOBE NOTICED | 813-435-2369 (fax) heather@theconsumerprotectionf irm,com Assigned: 08/3 1/2020
LesHe Guillon Michael Anderson Berry James E. Cecchi Lori Gwen Feldman Arnold Law Firm Arnold Law Firm Carella, Byrne, Cechi, Olstein, | George Gesten McDonald PLLC 865 Howe Avenue 865 Howe Avenue Brody & Agnello, P.C, 162 Half Moon Bay Drive Sacramento Sacramento, CA 95825 5 Becker Farm Road Croton on Hudson, NY 10520 Sacramento, CA 95825 7TTT-TTT7 Roseland, NJ 07068 917-983-9321 916-239-4787 aberry @ijusticed¢you.com 973 994-1700 888-421-4173 (fax) 916-924-1829 (fax) Assigned: 08/20/2020 973 994-1744 (fax) lfeldman@4-justice.com lguilion@justicedyou,com LEAD ATTORNEY jcecchi@carellabyrne.com Assigned: 09/17/2020 Assigned: 08/20/2020 Assigned: 09/17/2020 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED tj Jane Baek O'Brien Daniel H. Levi Brad Scott Karp Anna St. John Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & | Paul Weiss (NY) Paul Weiss (NY) Hamilton Lincoln Law Institute Garrison, LLP (DC} 1285 Avenue of the Americas | 1285 Avenue of the Americas | £629 K St. NW Suite 300 2001 K Street, N.W. New York, NY 10019 New York, NY 10019 Washington, DC 20006 Washington, DC 20006 212-373-3497 212-373-2384 917-327-2392 (202) 223-7300 212-492-0497 (fax) 212-373-2384 (fax) anna. stiohn@hlliorg (202) 223-7420 (fax) dlevi@paulweiss,com bkarp@paulweiss.com Assipned: 07/12/2022 jobrien@paulweiss.com Assigned: [0/11/2021 Assigned: 09/29/2020 LEAD ATTORNEY Assigned: 09/29/2020 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED | LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED Kyle Alan Shamberg Lynch Carpenter LLP Jonathan M. Jagher Erich Pau! Schork Michael L Roberts Chiceeo I 60602" STE 1240 Freed KannerLondon & Millen | Roberts Law Firm US, PC Roberts Law Firm 3 192-750-1265 923 Fayette Street PO Box 31909 20 Rahling Circle kvle@tctlp com Conshohocken, PA 19428 Chicago, IL 6063] Little Rack, AR 72223 aay 09/17/2020 610-234-6487 312-810-5824 (501)-821-5575 ATTORNEY TO NOTICED 224-632-4521 (fax) erichschorké@robertslawfirm.us | (501)-821-4474 (fax) iiagher@fkimlaw.com Assigned: 09/57/2020 aprilburton@robertsiawfirm.us Assigned: 09/17/2020 ATTORNEY TOBE NOTICED } Assigned: 03/18/2021 PRO BAC VICE ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Michael Milton Liskow Janine Lee Pollack raeaterra Po "hav aaieas ‘Karen Halbert Melissa Robin Emert Calcaterra Pollack LLP Ste 9th Floor Reberts Law Firm, P.A. Stull, Stall & Brody 1140 Avenue of the Americas 20 Rahting Circle 6 East 45th Street 5th Floor oe soot 18036-5803 | Tittle Rock, AR 72223 NY, NY 10017 New York, N¥ 10036 mliskow@icateaterrapallack.ce 501-821-5575 Assigned: 09/17/2020 212-899-1760 □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ - (fax) ATTORNEY TO BE 332-206-2073 (fax karenhatbert@rohertslawflim, | NOTICED abrody@ssbny.com jpolla cldea leaterrpoliaeksco ee Oy IO OR. us Assigned: 69/23/2020 Assigned: 09/17/2020 LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE ATFORNEY TO BE NOTICED NOTICED
roy
Via Pro Se Email Portal 7 Judge Paul A. Engelmayer United States District Court Southern District of New York Thurgood Marshall United States Courthouse 40 Foley Square New York, NY 10007
12-02-2022 In re Morgan Stanley Data Security Litigation Case No. 1:20-cv-05914-PAE Re: Amended Letter Motion for Clarification, Stay of Judgement of Plaintiff and Defendants Response until parties Disclose, and requested argument to ensure fundamental fairness to the matter Dear Judge Engelmayer and the Court: Melissa Linden, Scriber, respectfully submits this motion for clarification and Brief, in support of, the Plaintiffs, rendering an emergency clarification, Defendants Attorney in the form of an affidavit, clarifying the Plaintiff statement under penalty of perjury that states the following, “Ms. Linden was a class member for purposes of the Morgan Stanley Data Security Incidents, she was not a party to the litigation as she was nota named plaintiff in any related matter consolidated before this Court.” and supporta Stay of judgement of Plaintiff and Defendants Response until parties Disclose for the following reason: Memorandum of Law Specific Facts Relied Upon This statement above made by the plaintiff and defendant clearly seem to be based in ambiguity thus in need of clarification. In that, scriber asks the court, how can one be a class member in the incident but not able to become a part of the litigation. Scriber also asks court how it could consider defendants determinations, when scribers families information is clearly breeched within the confines of this suit. As my understanding, when applying the law to these actions it simply makes no sense. Highlighting, aren't class actions formed in the first place to be all inclusive. This is why scriber is asking for clarification of plaintiffs' and defendants’ determination, of scriber, and define how she cannot participate in this litigation. From scribers point of view, this determination, doesn’t seem consistent with US Law. Therefore, is the reason, scriber, is asking Plaintiff and Defendant to clarify their statements below: Below is what scriber is asking Plaintiff Ciarify: 1. What is the definition of a class member for purposes of Morgan Stenly Data Security Incident,
2 whatis the definition of, a party which a named plaintiff in any related consulted matter before this courtis 3 who made this determination alleged classification and choose which parties can be heard. 4 when were class members, for purposes of Morgan Stenly Date Security Incident notified, they could not take part fo In re Morgan Stanley Data Security Litigation Case No. 1:20-cv-05914-PAE 5, | want to Notify the court that, all my request to seek remedy of the matter were given to the prospective parties, well before judgment came to be in this matter. All parties failed to act. Below is what scriber is asking Defendant to clarify: 6.In this comment “1 These communications, which are attached as Exhibit 1 to the accompanying declaration of Susanna Buergel dated December 2, 2022, were directed to several lawyers Case 1:20-cv-05914-PAE Document 199 Filed 12/02/22 Page 2 of 4 3 entities not involved in the Class Action, including Charles Schwab) provide her with documentation and other information related to her deceased father’s former accounts.” Scriber is asking for clarity if, who the Defendant has given access to her deceased fathers accounts. Advising the court, my dad, was afforce intelligence, had firm understanding of how data breeches can ruin your life. Making it very clear to the court, my dad, would not be cool with how his legacy is being handle at the moment. 7.Scriber asks, Defendant to, 1. Name what entities not involved in the class action or matter did scriber direct Justices Peoples publicly dockets order, that defendant was a party to and please provide proof to the public docket. Advising the court, Charles Schwab, happens to be co- named in the decree by the court and also advising the court, defendant, failed to execute on the order. Also advising both of these companies are tied to identity theft matters involving my family. Making it clear to the court, Morgan Stanley failed to execute ,Richard F Lindens, examiners request. 8. Has the law firm of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison, LLP. Or Pau] Weiss (NY), or any attorney in this matter, representing Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison, LLP. Or Paul Weiss (NY), have represented Charels Schwab and co, in US courts or worked on any of their legal matters representing Charels Schwab and Co. Legal Facts Relied Upon in order to rectify the confusion surrounding the matter of scribers class determination, clarification would be needed and precedence relied form this Court, stated that any non-party that requires clarification regarding the scope of the facts may make an application and “[s]uch clarification will be promptly provided.” As the court can determiner themselves, the plaintiff statements are based in confusion and clearly in need of definition and is why scriber, has asked the court to relive her of
this matter, and remedy the situation immediately by granting this motion and ordering a clarification from the Plaintiff pertaining to the above statements. Highlighting, similarly, the Second Circuit instructed that “when questions arise ...., district courts will not ‘withhold a clarification in the light of a concrete situation’... fand] [t]he doors of the district court obviously remain open for such applications.” NML Capital Ltd. v. Republic of Argentina, 727 F.3d 230, 243 (2d Cir. 2013) (“NML IP).2 Conclusion Wherefore, scriber asks the court to grant this submission as a remedy and relief to the chaotic matter. In that it would be nearly impossible for scriber to form an argument when facts are simply not clearly defined. Especially when the assertions made by Plaintiff and Defendant, seemingly are, represented with no merit and, is why scriber have asked the court to grant her this remedy, by ordering the plaintiff and defendant to clarify their ambulant statements, as well as grant a Stay of judgment, of Plaintiff and Defendants Response until parties Disclose, in addition to the cost and expenses associated with this filing and what the court see fair and just.
Melissa Linden . Order Order for Amended Letter Motion for Clarification and requested argument to insure fundamental fairness to the matter ls Entered
Isordered
Pursuant to the terms required by Law. The below parties have been served this matter on 12-4-2022. Respectively
John A. Yanchunis Jonathan M, Sedgh Linda P. Nussbaum Heather H Jones Morgan & Morgan, P.A. Morgan and Morgan Nussbaum Law Group, P.C. The Consumer Protection Firm 201 N. Franklin Street 7th Floor 850 3rd Avenue 1211 Avenue of the Americas | Florida Tampa, Fi 33602 Ste 402 New York, NY 10036 401 E. Jackson Street (813)-275-5272 Brooklyn, NY £1232 917-438-9102 SunTrust Financial Center (813) 222-4736 (fax) 212-738-6839 inussbaum(@nussbaumpe.com | Ste 2340 ivanchunis@forthepeople.com | jsedah@forthepeople.com Assigned: 11/04/2020 Tampa, FL 33602 Assigned: 08/18/2020 Assigned: 09/30/2021 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED | 813-500-1500 LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED 813-435-2369 (fax) irm.com Assigned: 08/3 1/2020
Leslie Guillon Michael Anderson Berry James E. Cecchi Lori Gwen Feldman Arnold Law Firm Arnold Law Firm Carella, Byrne, Cechi, Olstein, | George Gesten McDonald PLLC 865 Howe Avenue 865 Howe Avenue Brody & Agnello, P.C. 102 Half Moon Bay Drive Sacramento Sacramento, CA 95825 § Becker Farm Road Croton on Hudson, NY 10520 Sacramento, CA 95825 916-777-7777 Roseland, N} 07068 947-983-9321 916-239-4787 aberry(@justicedyou.com 973 994-1700 888-421-4173 (fax) 916-924-1829 (fax) Assigned: 08/20/2020 973 994-1744 (fax) lfeldmani@4-justice. com teuillon@iusticed you.com LEAD ATTORNEY jcecchif@carellabyrne.com Assigned: 09/17/2020 Assigned: 08/20/2020 Assigned: 09/17/2020 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED Jane Baek O'Brien Daniel H. Levi Brad Scott Karp Anna St. John Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & | Paul Weiss (N'Y} Paul Weiss (NY} Hamilton Lincoln Law Institute Garrison, LLP (DC) 1285 Avenue of the Americas | 1285 Avenue of the Americas | 5629 K St. NW Suite 300 2001 K Street, N.W. New York, NY 10019 New York, NY 10019 Washingion, DC 26606 Washington, DC 20006 212-373-3497 212-373-2384 917-327-2392 (202) 223-7300 212-492-0497 (fax} 212-373-2384 (fax) anna siiohn@bilore (202) 223-7420 (fax) dlevi@paulweiss.com bkarp@paulweiss.com Assigned: 07/12/2022 □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ Assigned: 10/11/2021 Assigned: 09/29/2020 LEAD ATTORNEY Assigned: 09/29/2020 ATTORNEY TOBE NOTICED | LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
jartomireronvone| □□ APFFORNEY TO BE NOTICED Kyte Alan Shamberg Weehington, STE 1240 Jonathan M. Jagher Erich Paul Schork Michael L Roberts Chicago IL, 60602 , Freed Kanuer London & Millen | Roberts Law Firm US, PC Roberts Law Firm 312-750-1265 923 Fayette Street PO Box 31909 20 Rahling Circle kvle@ilclin cam Conshohocken, PA 19428 Chicago, IL 60631 Little Rock, AR 72223 ‘Assigned: 09/17 09/17/2020 610-234-6487 312-810-5824 (501)-821-5575 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED 224-632-4521 (fax) erichschork(@robertstawfirm.us | (501)-821-4474 (fax} jiagher@ifilmlaw.com Assigned: 09/17/2020 aprilburton@robertslawfirm.us Assigned: 09/17/2020 ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED | Assigned: 03/18/2021 PRO HAC VICE ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Michael Miiton Liskow Janine Lee Pollack jcterra Pollak ae ricas Karen Halbert Melissa Robin Emert Caleaterra Pollack LLP Ste 9th Floor Roberts Law Firm, P.A. Stull, Stull & Brody 1140 Avenue of the Americas New York, NY 10036-5803 20 Rahling Cirele 6 Kast 45th Street 9th Floor 312-899-1761 : Little Rock, AR 72223 NY, N¥ 10017 New York, NY 10636 liskow tea terrapollack.co 501-821-5575 Assigned: 09/17/2020 212-899-1760 mliskow@eateaterrapottacsco sho wien ea terns 200) (fax) ATTORNEY TO BE 332-206-2073 (fax) Assigned: 09/17/2020 karenhalbert@robertslawlinn, | NOTICED abrody@ssbny.com jpollack@calcaterrapollack.co Ws m coin TO BE Assigned: 09/23/2020 Assigned: 09/17/2020 LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED NOTICED
In re Morgan Stanley Data Security Litigation (In re Morgan Stanley Data Security Litigation) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.