In re Greek Catholic Union

Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas

In re Greek Catholic Union

19 Pa. D. & C. 78

CourtPennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Luzerne County

DecidedAugust 15, 1932

DocketNo. 1367

StatusPublished

This text of 19 Pa. D. & C. 78 (In re Greek Catholic Union) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Luzerne County primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

In re Greek Catholic Union, 19 Pa. D. & C. 78 (Pa. Super. Ct. 1932).

Pincite

Opinion

Valentine, J.,

This is a petition of the general counsel or “Supreme Legal Adviser” of the Greek Catholic Union of the Russian Brotherhoods of the U. S. A., a fraternal beneficial society, asking that the court determine the validity of a bylaw of said society which provides: “The supreme legal adviser shall visit the main office at least once each day.”

The society is incorporated under the laws of this State. Its main office is located at Homestead, Pa. It has various branches which are located in different States. The bylaw in. question was adopted at the convention held at Gary, Ind., in 1929, and is printed in the Russian language but, unlike the other bylaws, does not appear in the English translation.

The bylaw in question serves no useful purpose but on the contrary makes it difficult if not impossible for the general solicitor to fulfill the duties of his office.

Suits to which the society is a party are pending in different States. It is the duty of the general counsel to represent the society in all legal matters. He cannot properly do so if he is obliged “to visit the main office” at a time when his presence is required in court, nor is it a reasonable requirement that the solicitor visit the office on Sundays and holidays, which literal compliance with the bylaw would require. To be valid, a bylaw must be reasonable: 7 C. J. 1075; Marshall v. Pilots’ Ass’n, 18 Pa. Superior Ct. 644.

The bylaw in question is unreasonable, arbitrary, oppressive, and of no benefit of the society, and hence we conclude that the same is invalid and not binding upon the petitioner.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Valentine, J.,

This is a petition of the general counsel or “Supreme Legal Adviser” of the Greek Catholic Union of the Russian Brotherhoods of the U. S. A., a fraternal beneficial society, asking that the court determine the validity of a bylaw of said society which provides: “The supreme legal adviser shall visit the main office at least once each day.”

The society is incorporated under the laws of this State. Its main office is located at Homestead, Pa. It has various branches which are located in different States. The bylaw in. question was adopted at the convention held at Gary, Ind., in 1929, and is printed in the Russian language but, unlike the other bylaws, does not appear in the English translation.

The bylaw in question serves no useful purpose but on the contrary makes it difficult if not impossible for the general solicitor to fulfill the duties of his office.

Suits to which the society is a party are pending in different States. It is the duty of the general counsel to represent the society in all legal matters. He cannot properly do so if he is obliged “to visit the main office” at a time when his presence is required in court, nor is it a reasonable requirement that the solicitor visit the office on Sundays and holidays, which literal compliance with the bylaw would require. To be valid, a bylaw must be reasonable: 7 C. J. 1075; Marshall v. Pilots’ Ass’n, 18 Pa. Superior Ct. 644.

The bylaw in question is unreasonable, arbitrary, oppressive, and of no benefit of the society, and hence we conclude that the same is invalid and not binding upon the petitioner.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

19 Pa. D. & C. 78, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/in-re-greek-catholic-union-pactcomplluzern-1932.

Opinion

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack