In Re Estate of Elkins

888 A.2d 815, 2005 Pa. Super. 375, 2005 Pa. Super. LEXIS 4000
CourtSuperior Court of Pennsylvania
DecidedNovember 7, 2005
StatusPublished
Cited by5 cases

This text of 888 A.2d 815 (In Re Estate of Elkins) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Superior Court of Pennsylvania primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
In Re Estate of Elkins, 888 A.2d 815, 2005 Pa. Super. 375, 2005 Pa. Super. LEXIS 4000 (Pa. Ct. App. 2005).

Opinion

BENDER, J.:

¶ 1 Philadelphia Health and Education Corporation (PHEC) appeals from the or *818 der entered on December 30, 2004, that confirmed the Fifth Account of the Testamentary Trust (Trust) established by George W. Elkins for the benefit of Hah-nemann Hospital and ordered that PNC Bank, N.A. (PNC), the surviving trustee, pay to Abington Memorial Hospital (Ab-ington) the income from the Trust. We vacate in part and remand for further proceedings.

¶ 2 Pursuant to a petition filed by PNC requesting an adjudication of the Trust for the benefit of Hahnemann Hospital, the orphans’ court scheduled a hearing and “directed the trustee to provide notice of the hearing to any interested parties, Ab-ington Memorial Hospital ... and the Attorney General as parens patriae for charitable organizations.” Orphans’ Court Opinion (O.C.O.), 12/30/04, at l. 1 PNC’s initial petition stated that the account was filed due to “the sale of the assets of Allegheny Hahnemann, formerly known as Hahnemann Hospital, a not-for-profit corporation, to Tenet HealthSystems, Inc., a for-profit corporation, causing a failure of the charitable purpose of this Trust.” Petition for Adjudication, ¶ 3. An amended petition was subsequently filed, providing that the account was filed “because of the sale of the assets of Allegheny University Hospitals — East, including Hahnemann University Hospital, formerly known as Hahnemann Hospital, a not-for-profit corporation, to Tenet HealthSystems Inc., a for-profit corporation, as a result of the bankruptcy of Allegheny Health, Education and Research Foundation (“AH-ERF”) and its related entities.” Amended Petition for Adjudication, ¶ 3. Despite the apparent differences for requesting the adjudication, the first invoking the doctrine of cy pres 2 and the second just denoting the changes undergone by Hahnemann Hospital, both petitions suggested that PHEC be designated as the proper recipient of the income of the Trust. After the amended petition was filed, Abington Hospital filed objections and a hearing was held on May 27, 2004. Abington contended that the doctrine of cy pres was applicable and that it should be the entity to receive the distribution of the Trust’s income to carry out Mr. Elkins’ intentions.

¶ 3 Initially, the orphans’ court noted that Mr. Elkins, who died on October 23, 1919, left a will that provided the following pertinent provisions:

(a) I give and bequeath Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000.) unto my Trustees hereinafter named, IN TRUST as is more fully set out hereafter, for the Abington Memorial Hospital, now in Abington, Montgomery County, Pennsylvania.
(b) I give and bequeath Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000.) unto my Trustees hereinafter named IN TRUST, as is more fully set out hereunder, for the Hahnemann Hospital, of the City of Philadelphia.
(f) In the case of the two trusts for the Hospitals aforesaid, I direct that my Trustees shall pay over the income therefrom semi-annually to the Trustees of the said Hospitals to be used by them as their discretion may dic *819 tate to be for the best interests of the charity administered by them, save only that the said moneys shall not be used as a building fund.

O.C.O. at 2-3.

¶ 4 Additionally, the orphans’ court provided the following background information concerning Mr. Elkins’ relationship with Hahnemann Hospital and the hospital’s affiliations:

From 1869 until 1919, the year of the Will’s execution and the decedent’s death, the official name of “Hahnemann Hospital” was “Hahnemann Medical College and Hospital of Philadelphia.” As a hospital and medical school, the primary functions of Hahnemann Medical College and Hospital were the education of new doctors, the employment of physicians for patient care, and the operation of the hospital itself. Mr. El-kins, a lawyer, served as a trustee of Hahnemann Medical College and Hospital of Philadelphia from 1900 until his death in 1919 and served on the Trustee’s College Committee during the 1917-1918 session.
In 1982, the name of Hahnemann Medical College and Hospital of Philadelphia was changed to “Hahnemann University.” Hahnemann University became part of Allegheny Health, Education and Research Foundation (“AH-ERF”), a Pennsylvania not-for-profit corporation, in 1993. AHERF also controlled the Medical College of Pennsylvania (“MCP”), which likewise operated a medical school and hospital (the former Woman’s Medical College of Pennsylvania). Through a series of mergers and divisions in 1994, AHERF combined MCP and Hahnemann Medical College into the MCP Hahnemann School of Medicine. AHERF separated the hospitals and the medical schools into two not-for-profit corporate entities in 1996.
The hospitals became part of Allegheny University Hospitals (“AUH”). The medical schools were collectively renamed Allegheny University of the Health Sciences (“AUHS”).
In 1998, AHERF, the hospitals and medicals schools filed for bankruptcy protection. In August of 1998, Tenet, a for-profit corporation, acquired from the bankruptcy estate all of the assets of the former Hahnemann Hospital and now operates what were the former buildings and operations of Hahnemann Hospital. As a for-profit entity, however, Tenet was not able to receive the various charitable assets of the hospital.
In October of 1998, Philadelphia Health and Education Corporation (“PHEC”) and Philadelphia Health and Research Corporation (“PHRC”), both not-for-profit corporations, were created. PHEC was created in order to own and operate four health-related schools: The School of Medicine, the School of Nursing, the School of Public Health and the School of Health Professions. PHEC received the “medical school endowments” and other funds related to the educational institutions, such as scholarship funds, assets' for endowed chairs and professorships, etc. PHRC was created to receive the charitable assets related to research and patient care, in what was generally referred to as the “hospital endowments.”
The transfer of charitable assets from the AHERF component hospitals, including the former Hahnemann Hospital, to PHEC and PHRC was approved by the Philadelphia Orphans’ Court in separate Decrees dated November 6, 1998. Because of disputes between the corporations, PHRC dissolved and transferred all of its assets to PHEC. The Philadelphia Orphan’s Court approved the transfer of charitable assets *820 to PHEC by Decree dated May 27, 2003. The charitable assets earmarked as “hospital endowments” are used by PHEC to fund and manage community-based health care programs.
From 1998 until July 2002, PHEC operated under affiliation and operation agreements with Drexel University and with Tenet. Prior to 1998, Drexel University did not have a medical school or any other health-related school. The operating agreement between PHEC and Drexel University gave Drexel University the ability to assume control over PHEC, and Drexel University exercised that option in July of 2002.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Macturk, A. v. Trust of T.R. Morris
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2020
In Re:Estate of Pemberton, J. Appeal of:Dunker, J.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2018
In Re Estate of Elkins
32 A.3d 768 (Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2011)
In Re Erie Golf Course
992 A.2d 75 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 2010)
In Re Wilton
921 A.2d 509 (Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2007)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
888 A.2d 815, 2005 Pa. Super. 375, 2005 Pa. Super. LEXIS 4000, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/in-re-estate-of-elkins-pasuperct-2005.