In Re Estate of Armstrong

859 S.W.2d 323
CourtCourt of Appeals of Tennessee
DecidedFebruary 25, 1993
StatusPublished
Cited by49 cases

This text of 859 S.W.2d 323 (In Re Estate of Armstrong) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Tennessee primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
In Re Estate of Armstrong, 859 S.W.2d 323 (Tenn. Ct. App. 1993).

Opinion

859 S.W.2d 323 (1993)

In re ESTATE OF Anna Mae ARMSTRONG.
C. Ray ADAMS, Administrator, Plaintiff-Appellee,
v.
Velma MANIS, et al., Defendants-Appellants.

Court of Appeals of Tennessee, Eastern Section.

February 25, 1993.
Permission to Appeal Denied June 1, 1993.

*324 Thomas F. Bloom, Nashville, for appellants.

Gary E. Brewer and Steven W. Terry, Morristown, Jack H. Burkhard and Judy S. Robinson, Greeneville, for appellee Ella Mae Norton.

Permission to Appeal Denied by Supreme Court June 1, 1993.

OPINION

SANDERS, Presiding Judge, Eastern Section.

Some 29 collateral kinsmen and kinswomen have appealed from a declaratory judgment declaring Defendant-Appellee Ella Mae Boyd Norton to be the half sister and heir at law of Anna Mae Armstrong, deceased.

Anna Mae Armstrong died intestate in Greene County in October, 1989, at the age of 80 years. Mrs. Armstrong had no children and her husband predeceased her. It was originally thought by Plaintiff C. Ray Adams, administrator of the estate, that the 29 distant relatives named in the complaint were the heirs at law of Mrs. Armstrong. Prior to making distribution of the assets of the estate, however, the administrator learned the Defendant-Appellee, Ella Mae Boyd Norton, who was a resident of Greene County, was reputed to be the half sister of Mrs. Armstrong. The administrator filed a declaratory judgment action in the chancery court, naming the 29 distant relatives of Mrs. Armstrong and Ella Mae Boyd Norton, together with unknown relatives of Anna Mae Armstrong, as defendants. He asked the court to make a determination of the interest, if any, of the named defendants and any unknown persons in the estate of Anna Mae Armstrong.

Upon the trial of the case, the court determined that Clyde Wells, the natural father of Anna Mae Armstrong, deceased, was also the natural father of Ella Mae Boyd Norton and Ella Mae Boyd Norton and Anna Mae Armstrong were half sisters. Accordingly, Ella Mae Boyd Norton was the lawful heir of the estate of Anna Mae Armstrong.

The other Defendants have appealed, presenting the following issue for review: "Whether the alleged half sister of the intestate rebutted the presumption of legitimacy and whether she established her paternity by clear and convincing evidence." We find the answer to both questions in the affirmative and affirm for the reasons hereinafter stated.

Mrs. Armstrong's father, Mr. Clyde Wells, was reputed to also be the father of Ella Mae Boyd Norton (Ella Mae). At the time Ella Mae was conceived, her mother, Alice Boyd, was married to and living with Ella Mae's supposed father, Elmer Boyd, in a tenant house on Clyde Wells's property. Elmer Boyd was an alcoholic and when he had alcohol available he would drink until he passed out. When he woke up, if he still had alcohol available he would drink until he passed out again. Clyde Wells was a frequent visitor at the Boyds' home and frequently furnished Elmer Boyd with moonshine liquor to drink. The relationship between Mr. Wells and Mrs. Boyd was very suspect in the community.

Gladys Wilkerson, who was a neighbor of the Boyds' when Ella Mae was born, testified her husband's mother, Maggie Jane Wilkerson (Grandma), acted in the capacity of a midwife and delivered Ella Mae when she was born. Mrs. Wilkerson was asked, and testified, as follows:

*325 "Q. Did you have a conversation with Grandma, after she had come from delivering Ella Mae?
"A. Well, yes, there was some more there and when they left, later, down in the evening, she just sat down there and said ... she never did talk too much, but she said, `Well, there's a "nigger" in the wood pile.' I never will forget that, and I said, `What are you talking about?' and she said, `Ella Mae don't belong to Elmer.' Now, one of them had to tell her that."

Mrs. Wilkerson further testified she and her husband were neighbors of the Boyds' while Ella Mae was growing up and Elmer was mean to Ella Mae and didn't treat her like his other children. Other neighbors also testified as to Elmer's being mean to Ella Mae and that when he was drinking he would curse her and call her a "bastard."

Ella Mae's youngest sister testified that as she was growing up she slept at the foot of the bed with her father and mother and she would wake up at night when her mother would be crying and her father raping her mother and calling her a whore.

Mrs. Frank Cogdill, who lived near the Boyds for several years during the 1940's and '50's, saw Elmer Boyd rather frequently. He worked with Mr. Boyd some and Mr. Boyd did work for him. He apparently was a rather close friend with Mr. Boyd and, particularly when Mr. Boyd was drinking, he apparently talked quite frankly with Mr. Cogdill. Mr. Cogdill testified that on several occasions Mr. Boyd told him Ella Mae was not his child. He testified Mr. Boyd said Ella Mae was Clyde Wells's child. The following are some pertinent excerpts from Mr. Cogdill's testimony:

"Q. Did you see Elmer Boyd on a regular basis? I believe you told us about once a week or so?
"A. Oh, I'd see Elmer once a week or twice or three times a week, when I lived down there next to him. Maybe every day or so."
* * * * * *
"Q. And you say you've seen Mr. Clyde Wells bring liquor over there to Elmer?
"A. Yes, sir, I have.
"Q. How did they get along?
"A. Oh, they'd argue and fuss a little.
"Q. Do you know what they were arguing and fussing about?
"A. Well, I heard them arguing one time and I heard Clyde tell him that Ella Mae wasn't his young'un, it was his young'un. They got in a little argument one time. I heard them saying something about that. I heard Clyde say that.
"Q. You heard Clyde Wells say what, now? I didn't. .. .
"A. Clyde said that Ella Mae was his young'un. That's what I heard him say."
* * * * * *
"Q. Did you overhear ... or were you ever told by Elmer, when he was talking about Ella Mae not being his child, about what John [sic] [Clyde] Wells was doing? You used an expression that's sort of typical of East Tennessee, about shucking corn?
"A. Yeah, well, now, I'll tell you, Elmer wasn't no fool. He knew his corn was getting shucked. Elmer knew that.
"Q. Tell us about the conversation where he said that Clyde Wells was shucking his corn?
"A. Yeah, he said ... he knowed Ella Mae was ... he knowed Ella Mae belonged to Clyde. He knew that all along. That's the reason why Elmer didn't like Ella Mae all that good."

It was also testified that on one occasion when Elmer Boyd stated Ella Mae was Clyde Wells's daughter, Alice Boyd, Ella Mae's mother, was present but she remained silent and did not dispute what Elmer said.

Ella Mae's oldest brother testified that when he was about 11 years old Clyde Wells and his son-in-law, Clyde Armstrong, came to their home and offered them money if his parents would let them take Ella Mae with them.

Anna Mae Armstrong, who was apparently some 25 to 30 years older than Ella Mae, openly proclaimed Ella Mae to be her half sister from the time Ella Mae was a *326 young child until Anna Mae's death in 1989.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

James F. Logan, Jr. v. The Estate of Mildred Cannon
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2019
In Re Estate of Rickie Charles Vaughn
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2019
In Re Estate of Virginia Spears
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2017
In Re: Samuel D.
536 S.W.3d 447 (Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2016)
Charlotte Pickel Wilson v. Jeremiah Pickel
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2016
In Re: Conservatorship Of Bill Bartlett
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2015
In re The Estate of Ola Irene Tucker
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2015
James Ray Mynatt v. Charlene Mynatt Lemarr
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2014
In Re Jaycee W.
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2013
Kimberly Shea (Matheny) Coyle v. Gregory E. Erickson
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2011
In the Matter of David J.B.
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2010
In Re Keisheal N.E.
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2010
In the Matter of R. R. B.
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2008
In Re: A. R. and J. R.
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2007
In re S.L.A.
223 S.W.3d 295 (Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2006)
Estate of Alfred O. Wooden v. Evelyn Hunnicutt
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2005
In re: A.L.B., N.W.B. and C.B.B.
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2005

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
859 S.W.2d 323, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/in-re-estate-of-armstrong-tennctapp-1993.