In Re Clayton's Estate

259 P.2d 617, 127 Colo. 592
CourtSupreme Court of Colorado
DecidedJune 29, 1953
Docket16912
StatusPublished
Cited by1 cases

This text of 259 P.2d 617 (In Re Clayton's Estate) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Colorado primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
In Re Clayton's Estate, 259 P.2d 617, 127 Colo. 592 (Colo. 1953).

Opinion

259 P.2d 617 (1953)

In re CLAYTON'S ESTATE.
CITY & COUNTY OF DENVER
v.
PARK HILL GOLF CLUB, Inc.

No. 16912.

Supreme Court of Colorado, en Banc.

June 29, 1953.

Leonard M. Campbell, Horace N. Hawkins, Jr., Denver, for plaintiff in error.

Max P. Zall, Denver, for defendant in error.

CLARK, Justice.

The parties are here in the same order as they appeared in the trial court. In the interest of clarity, as well as brevity, we will herein designate plaintiff in error as trustee, and defendant in error as golf club or defendant.

This action was commenced by the filing of a complaint in the original proceedings, In the Matter of the Estate of George W. Clayton, deceased, being No. 5702 of the county court in and for the City and County of Denver. Its object is to have declared null and void the lease pursuant to which the golf club claims the right to possession of certain premises the property of the Clayton estate. At a pre-trial conference all exhibits offered in evidence by the parties, respectively, were identified and introduced, *618 and these, together with an agreed statement of facts, were submitted to the court; trial immediately following the pretrial conference and without the taking of additional evidence. Objections on behalf of trustee to some of the exhibits tendered by defendant on the grounds of competency and materiality were ruled upon by the court in defendant's favor, to which rulings objection is not here made. Judgment of the trial court was favorable to defendant.

On August 15, 1899, George W. Clayton died, leaving his last will and testament dated March 2, 1892, which was admitted to probate in the county court of Arapahoe county October 3, 1899. After the making of certain devises and bequests, by the fourteenth clause of his will the testator directed that all of the residue and remaining portions of his estate should go to "the Corporation of the City of Denver, in trust," for the establishment and permanent maintenance of an institution for the care and education of poor white male orphan children, said institution to be known as the George W. Clayton College. The testator went into considerable detail in directing the exact way and manner in which the college should be organized, financed, maintained and operated, and as the fourteenth clause of said will, in which all of this appears, is set forth in detail in the case of Clayton v. Hallett, 30 Colo. 231, 234, 70 P. 429, 59 L.R.A. 407, we prefer to adopt that reference rather than to repeat it here. The executor named in the will was directed to see to it that a proper site for the college be obtained, and that it be established as a going concern within ten years from the date of his appointment. After these things were accomplished, the testator directed, that all of the remainder of his estate should be set apart, held and kept inviolate forever "and the income, rents and revenues thereof, shall be used solely and exclusively for the maintenance of said institution and of the Orphans admitted therein." Under the heading of "express conditions" the testator further directed:

"Second: That none of the moneys, principal, interest, dividends, income, or rents, arising, or accruing from the said residuary devise and bequest, shall at any time, be applied to any other purpose or purposes whatever, than those herein mentioned and appointed."

He directed that said funds shall not be commingled with any other funds of the city of Denver; that said trustee shall annually account therefor by proper report to the county court; and shall submit all the records pertaining thereto to said court for examination.

Through the course of years, since the will of George W. Clayton was admitted to probate, great changes have occurred in many respects. Shortly thereafter the City and County of Denver was organized, separating in part the county of Arapahoe. Legislation was required to implement this transfer. At first it seems that there was doubt as to whether or not the City and County of Denver might legally accept the trust and act as trustee, as requested by the testator, and to the end that this might no longer be questionable, legislation was enacted specifically authorizing the city to so act. After the executor had succeeded in establishing the college and it became time for the trustee to take over its operation, certain ordinances were enacted to accomplish that end. Many of these events are interesting here only because of their historical value and further reference will hereinafter be had only to such legislation as seems pertinent to the questions involved.

In 1931 the trustee leased to the golf club the lands here involved, and said club from and ever since that time has held possession and occupancy thereof pursuant to one or the other of several lease agreements, the last of which bears date of January 1, 1946. As did its predecessor, this document recites that it is "by and between the City and County of Denver as Trustee of the Estate of George W. Clayton, Deceased, acting by and through the George W. Clayton Trust Commission" and the golf club, and it is signed on behalf of lessor in manner following: "City and County of Denver as Trustee of the Estate of George W. Clayton, Deceased, by Ben F. Stapleton, James Fresques, F. S. Wilson, Members of and Constituting the George W. Clayton Trust Commission. Attest: Dan D. Diamond, Assistant Secretary." Its term is for ten *619 years from its date, with an option for an additional five years. It is admitted that the golf club has paid its rent, and that it has kept and performed each and all of the covenants and conditions of said lease obligatory upon it. It is not asserted that the lease was procured by or through misrepresentation or fraud, and the good faith of the gulf club at all times remains unchallenged. It is admitted that the signatures appearing on said lease on behalf of lessor were, at that time, the officials of the city properly comprising the George W. Clayton Trust Commission. The sole claim and contention of the trustee is that the lease is void from its beginning for the reasons: (1) That the trust commission had no power to execute it; and (2) that it was not made under the direction, and did not have the approval, of the county court.

The county court found that it had jurisdiction in the premises; that by virtue of authority implied from the terms of the will the trustee had power to lease; that said lease is signed by the proper authority representing said trustee; that said lease is valid, effective and binding upon the trustee; whereupon judgment was entered dismissing trustee's complaint.

Although the specification of points filed by counsel on behalf of the trustee contains eight separate items wherein it is alleged the judgment of the trial court is erroneous, most of them are of a general nature and the entire controversy may here be summarized under two general propositions:

(1) That the lease of January 1, 1946, was, and is, void from the beginning because it was not executed in the manner and form required by the charter of the City and County of Denver; and

(2) That said lease was void from the beginning for the reason that the terms, conditions and length of time thereof were not directed or approved by the county court.

I.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

First National Bank of Tribune v. Lohman
827 P.2d 583 (Colorado Court of Appeals, 1992)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
259 P.2d 617, 127 Colo. 592, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/in-re-claytons-estate-colo-1953.