In re: B.D-1

• Court: West Virginia Supreme Court
• Decided: November 4, 2020
• Docket: 20-0107
• Status: Published

Opinion

Fall 2020 Opinion List - Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia

• Skip to main menu
• Skip to main content

Opinion List Quick Tip

• AEach column of the list can be sorted by clicking the header of that column.
• BThe list-wide active text search or "List Search" allows the viewer to quickly search for specific information by typing a single word or multiple words, seperated by a space.
• CA drop down menu allows the user to change the humber of list items currently showing on the page.

For more detailed help on the new features of the Opinion List, download the overview by clicking here.

Open Help

West Virginia Judiciary

Home | Contact | Employment | Sitemap

Opinions and Memo Decisions of the Supreme Court of Appeals

• Information & Search
• About the Decision List
• Spring 2020 Term

Search

Search the site

Main Menu

• Public Resources
  • Court Information by County
  • Court Forms
  • News & Publications
  • Jury Information
  • Law Library
  • Student Resources
  • Domestic Violence
  • Mental Hygiene & Guardians
  • Child Abuse and Neglect
  • Accessibility Information
• Supreme Court
  • Supreme Court of Appeals
  • Justices & Staff
  • Clerk's Office
  • Office of Counsel
  • Workers' Compensation Counsel
  • Calendar & Docket
  • Opinions
• Lower Courts
  • Circuit Courts
  • Family Courts
  • Magistrate Courts
  • Treatment Courts
  • Mass Litigation Panel
  • Business Court Division
  • Statistics
• Legal Community
  • Court Rules
  • WV E-File
  • Bar Admissions
  • Lawyer Disciplinary Board
  • Judicial Investigation
  • West Virginia State Bar
  • Judicial & Lawyer Assistance Program
• Court Administration
  • Administrative Office
  • Judiciary Policies
  • Court Security and Closures
  • Probation Services
  • Access to Justice
  • Juvenile Justice Commission
• Viewing PDF Files

Fall 2020 Opinion List

Links to all decisions filed in the current term of court are listed in the table below. Are you looking for an opinion list from a prior term of court? If so, please visit the Information & Search page. Opinions from the September 1991 term of court to the present day are available online.

The new integrated decision list combines all of the decisions issued during a court term, identified using case type and decision type codes. To re-sort the list quickly, click any of the column headers (except case number). For more information about using the decision list and for an explanation of the codes, review the page: About the Decision List.

QUICK TIP: For more help on using the opinion table, click the to the right on the page. When the page loads, the Date Filed column is sorted descending.

Current Term of Court Opinions and Memorandum Decisions

Current Term of Court Opinions and Memorandum Decisions

Decision Type
Date Filed	Case No.	Case Name	Case Type	Decision Type
11/04/2020	20-0179	In re: T.M., X.M. and A.M.	JUV	MD
11/04/2020	20-0178	In re: H.B., L.M., K.C. and L.C.	JUV	MD
11/04/2020	20-0168	In re: J.L-1 and E.L.	JUV	MD
11/04/2020	20-0167	In re: F.W. and J.W-1	JUV	MD
11/04/2020	20-0115	In re: E.F-1, C.F-1 and E.F-2	JUV	MD
11/04/2020	20-0107	In re: B.D-1	JUV	MD
11/04/2020	20-0093	In Petition of B.J.B for Expungement of Record	CIV-O	MD
11/04/2020	20-0089	In re: D.M. and R.P.	JUV	MD
11/04/2020	20-0073	In re: W.W., J.W., and B.W.	JUV	MD
11/04/2020	20-0071	In re: W.W., J.W., and B.W.	JUV	MD
11/04/2020	20-0019	In re: M.B-1 and M.B-2	JUV	MD
11/04/2020	19-1100	In re: B.M., C.C., and E.B.	JUV	MD
11/04/2020	19-1009	Jeffrey Humphrey vs. Richard Deal	CIV-O	MD
11/04/2020	19-0974	Raymond Richardson vs. Donnie Ames	POST	MD
11/04/2020	19-0958	State of West Virginia vs. Shawn B.	CR-F	MD
11/04/2020	19-0941	Lawrence K. Hinkle vs. Charles Williams	POST	MD
11/04/2020	19-0932	State of West Virginia vs. Timothy Lambert	CR-F	MD
11/04/2020	19-0908	Michael Ellis vs. West Virginia Human Rights Commission	CIV-O	MD
11/04/2020	19-0898	State of West Virginia vs. Jeffrey Dumire	CR-F	MD
11/04/2020	19-0884	Joyce Pumphrey vs. Mackenzie R. Thorne	TCR	MD
11/04/2020	19-0870	State of West Virginia vs. Barbara D. Brellahan	CR-F	MD
11/04/2020	19-0868	In re: J.J.C. for Expungement of Records	CIV-O	MD
11/04/2020	19-0860	State of West Virginia vs. Raymond M.	CR-F	MD
11/04/2020	19-0810	State of West Virginia vs. William S. Padgett	CR-F	MD
11/04/2020	19-0778	State of West Virginia vs. David T.	CR-F	MD
11/04/2020	19-0740	State of West Virginia vs. Ercel N.	CR-F	MD
11/04/2020	19-0693	Eugene Bowerman et al. vs. Debra Rombis	TCR	MD
11/04/2020	19-0673	State of West Virginia vs. Joshua Settle	CR-F	MD
11/04/2020	19-0538	Andrew Perry vs. Donnie Ames	POST	MD
11/04/2020	18-0732	In re: B.S.	JUV	MD
11/04/2020	19-0103	West Virginia Counties Group vs. Great Cacapon Volunteer Fire Department, Inc.	TCR	OP
11/02/2020	19-0361	Richard Otto and Patricia Otto vs. Catrow Law, PLLC (dissenting opinion by Workman J.)	TCR	SEP
11/02/2020	19-0361	Richard Otto and Patricia Otto vs. Catrow Law, PLLC.	TCR	OP
11/02/2020	19-0267	SWN Production Company, LLC. vs. Corey Conley	TCR	OP
11/02/2020	20-0142	State ex rel. Everett Frazier vs. Warren R. McGraw and Dalton Watts	OJ-P	OP
11/02/2020	19-0228	Monongahela Power Company vs. Michael A. Buzminsky and Vickie Buzminsky	TCR	OP
11/02/2020	19-0830	Ethan B., vs. Tracy W.,	FAM	MD
10/30/2020	18-0927 &18-1045	Estate of Wayne A. Jones vs. The City of Martinsburg	TCR	MD
10/30/2020	18-0139,18-0160&18-0161	State of West Virginia vs. John R. Skidmore, Gordon W. Swiger and Nickolas L. Velez	CR-F	MD
10/30/2020	19-0926	In re M.M., H.M., and W.M	JUV	SO
10/20/2020	18-0608	State of West Virginia vs. Joshua S. Deem	CR-F	SO
10/19/2020	19-0841	Soaring Eagle Development Company, LLC vs. The Travelers Indemnity Company of America	TCR	MD
10/19/2020	19-0978	SER National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburg, PA. vs. David W. Hummel, Jr. and Axiall Corporation and Westlake Chemical Corporation	OJ-P	SO
10/16/2020	19-0369 & 19-0394	J.F. Allen Corporation vs. The Sanitary Board of the City of Charleston and Burgess and Niple vs. J.F. Allen Corporation	TCR	MD
10/16/2020	19-0018	Cynthia McCoy, Anna Eschelmeyer and William Fowler vs. Steven Dragisich	TCR	MD
10/16/2020	19-0447	State of West Virginia vs. Steven Tewalt	CR-F	SO
10/16/2020	18-1104	McClure Management, LLC and Cindy Kay Adams vs. Erik Taylor and James Turner	TCR	SO
10/16/2020	19-0636	Lawyer Disciplinary Board vs. Scott A. Curnutte	L-DISC	SO
10/16/2020	19-0879	Lawyer Disciplinary Board vs. E. Lavoyd Morgan, Jr.	L-DISC	SO
10/14/2020	19-0412	The City of Charles Town vs. The Jefferson County Commission	TCR	MD
10/14/2020	20-0113	In re P.F.	JUV	SO
10/13/2020	18-0339	State of West Virginia vs. Robert I. Brown Jr.	CR-F	MD
10/13/2020	19-0007	Christopher L.L., vs. Donnie Ames	POST	MD
10/13/2020	19-0831	State of West Virginia vs. Edward C.,	CR-F	MD
10/13/2020	19-0988	State of West Virginia vs. Erik K.,	CR-F	MD
10/13/2020	18-1141	B.R. vs. West Virginia DHHR	TCR	MD
10/13/2020	19-0305	Marissa Shaffer and Timothy Shaffer vs. William Bragg, M.D.	TCR	MD
10/09/2020	19-0718	In re A.B.-1 and A.B.-2	JUV	MD
10/09/2020	19-1184	In re: L.C.	JUV	MD
10/09/2020	19-1042	In re A.D., G.D., and E.D.	JUV	MD
10/09/2020	20-0052	In re H.L. AND M.L.	JUV	SO
09/29/2020	20-0202 & 20-0204	In re N.R., A.R-1 and A.W	JUV	MD
09/29/2020	18-1134	City of Morgantown vs. Calvary Baptist Church	TCR	SO
09/29/2020	18-0654	State of West Virginia vs. Dean E. Gamble, Sr.	CR-F	MD
09/28/2020	19-0638	David W. Miller vs. Rogers Petroleum, Inc.	WC	MD
09/25/2020	20-0015	In re S.L.	JUV	SO
09/23/2020	20-0245	In re A.R., H.R. Jr., and Z.B.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0239	In re A.R. and H.R. Jr.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0228	In re T.G. and M.G.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0220	In re C.C.-1, L.C., T.C., and C.C.-2	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0218	In re B.H., A.H., and R.H.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0214	In re M.C.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0211	In re C.C.-1, L.C.-1, T.C., and C.C.-2	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0203	In re L.B.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0193	In re H.M., L.M., J.M., and B.M.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0182	In re M.B., R.B.-1, and R.B.-2	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0180	In re A.M.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0165	In re S.C. and N.D.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0164	In re H.W.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0153	In re A.W., S.R., A.H., B.H., I.H., and E.C.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0150	In re E.K.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0118	In re E.C. and R.C.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0053	In re S.M.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	20-0022	In re A.Y.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	19-0846	In re L.L.	JUV	MD
09/23/2020	19-0739	Julia Surbaugh v. J.D. Sallaz, Superintendent, Lakin Correctional Center	POST	MD
09/23/2020	19-0737	State of West Virginia vs. Donna Elizabeth Weed	CR-F	MD
09/23/2020	19-0683	Brian K. Markley v. WV Division of Corrections & Rehabilitation and WV Parole Board	CIV-O	MD
09/23/2020	19-0570	Jack Sheffler vs. Concord University	ADM	MD
09/18/2020	20-0111	Charles E. Jacobs vs. Shawn Straughn, Superintendent, Northern Correctional Facility	POST	MD
09/18/2020	19-1079	Joseph Todd Hutchinson and Jennifer Lynn Hutchinson v. Mark Forest Underwood, Patricia Jennings and Underwood Law Office	TCR	MD
09/18/2020	19-1070	Thomas H. vs. Karen Pszczolkowski, Superintendent, Northern Correctional Facility	POST	MD
09/18/2020	19-0851	Jeffery Wright vs. Shelby Searls, Superintendent, Huttonsville Correctional Center	POST	MD
09/18/2020	19-0491	Antonio Collins vs. Shelby Searls, Superintendent, Huttonsville Correctional Center	POST	MD
09/15/2020	19-0639	Gary Tobias vs. Kanawha Eagle Mining, LLC	WC	MD
09/15/2020	19-0625	Timothy Milligan vs. Blue Creek Mining, LLC	WC	MD
09/15/2020	19-0613	Alfred Alexander vs. Murray American Energy, Inc.	WC	MD
09/15/2020	19-0600	Joan Estep vs. Greenbrier Valley Medical Center	WC	MD
09/15/2020	19-0589	Gregory W. Wright vs. West Virginia Military Authority	WC	MD
09/15/2020	19-0552	Robert L. Wildman vs. Ball Metal Food Container Corporation	WC	MD
09/15/2020	19-0517	Randy Shamblin vs. Nursing Care Management of America, Inc.	WC	MD
09/15/2020	19-0425	Brian Collins vs. Alpha Natural Resources, Inc.	WC	MD
09/15/2020	19-0373	Hampden Coal, LLC vs. Casey Colley	WC	MD
09/15/2020	18-1087	Victor Cameron vs. Murray American Energy, Inc.	WC	MD
09/04/2020	19-0909	William James Bumpus vs. R.S. Mutter, Superintendent, McDowell County Correctional Facility	POST	MD
09/04/2020	19-0892	State of West Virginia vs. Mitchell H.	CR-F	MD
09/04/2020	19-0749	State of West Virginia vs. David B.	CR-F	MD
09/04/2020	19-0680	Donald Moore vs. Chip Franklin Buzzo and Vanda Dawn Buzzo	TCR	MD
09/04/2020	19-0633	State of West Virginia vs. Devin Michael Collins	CR-F	MD
09/04/2020	19-0605	Lester Yost, Lewis Yost, and Rosalie Yost vs. Mary Ann Yost	PR	MD
09/04/2020	19-0584	State of West Virginia vs. Joseph C.	CR-F	MD
09/04/2020	19-0578	State of West Virginia vs. Jeremy Fountain	CR-F	MD
09/04/2020	19-0523	State of West Virginia vs. Joseph P. Hawkins	CR-F	MD
09/04/2020	19-0498	State of West Virginia vs. Elbyheine Bond	CR-F	MD
09/04/2020	19-0381	State of West Virginia vs. Michael Kandis	CR-O	MD
09/04/2020	19-0327	State of West Virginia vs. Brice Anthony Braxton	CR-F	MD
09/04/2020	18-0713	Tony J. Walker vs. Michael Martin, Superintendent, Huttonsville Correctional Center	POST	MD
09/03/2020	20-0229	In re E.W.	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0187	In re M.M., W.M., T.M., and J.T.	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0152	In re N.C., A.S., and K.S.	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0151	In re J.T. and C.H.	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0147	In re R.M.-1 and R.M.-2	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0119	In re A.R. and J.M.	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0114	In re D.P., G.P., and S.P.	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0100	In re W.D.	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0098	In re W.D.	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0097	In re J.T.-1	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0085	In re J.S., Z.S., K.S., A.S., and R.S.	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0084	In re K.D.-1, K.D.-2, J.J.-1, J.J.-2, and L.J.	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0072	In re J.H., A.H.-1, and A.H.-2	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0070	In re L.W.	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0061	In re H.H.	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0060	In re D.C.II	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	20-0023	In re K.G.	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	19-0920	In re D.H. and H.H.	JUV	MD
09/03/2020	19-0551	State of West Virginia vs. Robert Anthony Chester	CR-F	MD
09/03/2020	19-0531	Tonya R. Lee vs. Lonnie V. Lee	FAM	MD
09/03/2020	19-0524	Harold B. vs. Donnie Ames, Superintendent, Mt. Olive Correctional Complex	POST	MD
09/03/2020	19-0513	Benjamin Rogers vs. Jessica L. Williamson	TCR	MD
09/03/2020	19-0504	State of West Virginia vs. Darian R.	CR-F	MD
09/03/2020	19-0500	State of West Virginia vs. Darrell Lee Williams	CR-F	MD
09/03/2020	19-0328	Stephen Upton vs. Caren Jenkins	TCR	MD
09/03/2020	18-1130	State of West Virginia vs. Joseph Arnold Farrell	CR-F	MD
09/03/2020	18-0749	State of West Virginia vs. Robert Francis Rumble	CR-F	MD

• About this Redesign
• Twitter

• Contact Information
• Terms of Use
• State of WV Main Page

The West Virginia Judicial System is an Equal Opportunity Employer committed to providing equal access and unbiased, non-discriminatory treatment to all.
2020 West Virginia Court System - Supreme Court of Appeals. All Rights Reserved.