Hunt v. Farmers' Insurance

Supreme Court of Iowa

Hunt v. Farmers' Insurance

37 N.W. 173, 74 Iowa 231, 1887 Iowa Sup. LEXIS 493

CourtSupreme Court of Iowa

DecidedMarch 12, 1888

StatusPublished

Cited by1 cases

This text of 37 N.W. 173 (Hunt v. Farmers' Insurance) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Iowa primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Hunt v. Farmers' Insurance, 37 N.W. 173, 74 Iowa 231, 1887 Iowa Sup. LEXIS 493 (iowa 1888).

Pincite

Opinion

Seevers, C. J.

The amount in controversy being less than one hundred dollars, we are required to answer the following question propounded by the district court: “ In an action before a justice of the peace, brought upon a policy of insurance, there being a clause in said policy that no action can be maintained thereon unless brought within six months from the time of said loss, after the evidence is all introduced by the parties before a jury, and it appearing therefrom that more than six months had elapsed from the time of said loss to the commencement of said action,- has a justice a light to take the case from the jury and dismiss plaintiff’s action?” It has been held that a justice of the peace has no power to instruct a jury, and that he possesses only such powers as are conferred by. statute. St. Joseph Manf. Co. v. Harrington, 53 Iowa, 380. A justice has the power to set aside a default, or the dismissal of a cause. Code, sec. 3543. But he cannot arrest a judgment or set aside the verdict of a jury. Code, sec. 3550 ; Rhodes v. De Bow, 5 Iowa, 260 ; Dupont v. Downing, 6 Iowa, 172. The question implies that evidence was introduced before the jury showing that more -than six months had elapsed after the loss .before the action was commenced, and we are asked whether, in such case, the justice has the power to take the case from the jury and dismiss the action. We are clearly of the opinion that he cannot, for the reason that no such power is conferred by statute. We cannot imagine a case in which a justice would have such power. When a jury is called before a justice in a case, and duly impaneled, the justice cannot take the case from the jury, his only power being to discharge the jury if they fail to agree. The foregoing question must be answered in the negative, and the judffment of the district court

Reversed.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Seevers, C. J.

The amount in controversy being less than one hundred dollars, we are required to answer the following question propounded by the district court: “ In an action before a justice of the peace, brought upon a policy of insurance, there being a clause in said policy that no action can be maintained thereon unless brought within six months from the time of said loss, after the evidence is all introduced by the parties before a jury, and it appearing therefrom that more than six months had elapsed from the time of said loss to the commencement of said action,- has a justice a light to take the case from the jury and dismiss plaintiff’s action?” It has been held that a justice of the peace has no power to instruct a jury, and that he possesses only such powers as are conferred by. statute. St. Joseph Manf. Co. v. Harrington, 53 Iowa, 380. A justice has the power to set aside a default, or the dismissal of a cause. Code, sec. 3543. But he cannot arrest a judgment or set aside the verdict of a jury. Code, sec. 3550 ; Rhodes v. De Bow, 5 Iowa, 260 ; Dupont v. Downing, 6 Iowa, 172. The question implies that evidence was introduced before the jury showing that more -than six months had elapsed after the loss .before the action was commenced, and we are asked whether, in such case, the justice has the power to take the case from the jury and dismiss the action. We are clearly of the opinion that he cannot, for the reason that no such power is conferred by statute. We cannot imagine a case in which a justice would have such power. When a jury is called before a justice in a case, and duly impaneled, the justice cannot take the case from the jury, his only power being to discharge the jury if they fail to agree. The foregoing question must be answered in the negative, and the judffment of the district court

Reversed.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

37 N.W. 173, 74 Iowa 231, 1887 Iowa Sup. LEXIS 493, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/hunt-v-farmers-insurance-iowa-1888.

Opinion

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack