Hornbeke v. White

20 Colo. App. 13
CourtColorado Court of Appeals
DecidedApril 15, 1904
DocketNo. 2921
StatusPublished
Cited by7 cases

This text of 20 Colo. App. 13 (Hornbeke v. White) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Colorado Court of Appeals primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Hornbeke v. White, 20 Colo. App. 13 (Colo. Ct. App. 1904).

Opinion

Maxwell, J.

This was an action of replevin involving 300 deer hides.

The amended complaint upon which this case was tried averred that, prior to January 28, 1901, plaintiff was the owner and entitled to the possession of, and is now the owner and entitled to the immediate possession of, 300 deer hides of the value of $300.00; that about December 10, 1901, the defendant, representing himself to he a deputy game warden, wrongfully, unlawfully and forcibly took said deer hides from plaintiff’s possession; that on said date “the defendant, as such deputy game warden, in consideration of the sum of $30.00 to him in hand paid by this plaintiff, retransferred and delivered the said deer [15]*15hides to this plaintiff, stating to said plaintiff at such time that as such deputy state game warden he had the right to transfer the same to this plaintiff and receive the consideration therefor”; that thereafter, and before the commencement of this suit, the defendant again took possession of said hides, and upon demand refused to deliver the same to plaintiff, to his damage in the sum of $300.00.

An answer and replication presented the issues, upon which the ease was tried.

A determination of the questions involved in this case involves a consideration of several sections of chapter 98 of the Session Laws of 1899, entitled, “An act to protect game and fish,” Session Laws of 1899, page 184, as follows:

Section 16, Div. A, page 188: “All game and fish now or hereafter within this state not held by private ownership, legally acquired, and which for the purposes of this act shall include all the quadrupeds, birds and fish mentioned in this act, are hereby declared to be the property of the state, and no right, title, interest or property therein can be acquired or transferred, or possession thereof had or maintained, -except as herein expressly provided.”

Section 18, Div. A, page 189: “As used in this act, unless otherwise specifically restricted or enlarged, the words herein and hereof refer to the whole act; * * * and whenever the possession, use, importation, transportation, storage, taxidermy, sale, offering or exposing for sale of game or fish is prohibited or restricted, the prohibition and restriction shall, where not specifically otherwise provided, extend to and include every part of such game or fish, and a violation as to each individual animal or part thereof shall be a separate offense. ’ ’

Section 19, Div. A, page 189: ‘ ‘ The possession at any time of game or fish unaccompanied by a [16]*16proper and valid license, certificate, permit or invoice, as herein provided, shall be prima facie evidence that such game or fish was unlawfully taken and is unlawfully held in possession. ”

Section 1, Div. B, page 191: “No person shall at any time of the year, or in any manner, pursue, take, wound or kill any bison, buffalo, elk, deer, antelope * * * or have the same in possession, except as permitted by this act.’.’

Subdiv. 1, Section 7, Div. B, page 192: “The open season for deer having horns and antelope having horns, shall begin August 15, and end November 5 next ensuing.”

Subdiv. 7, Section 7, Div. B, page 192: “The right given by this section to take or kill game and fish is limited to food purposes * * * and no person shall take, kill or have in possession in any one season more than one elk, and one deer and one antelope; or, instead of one deer and one antelope, he may have either two deer or two antelope.”

Subdiv. 8, Section 7, Div. B, page 193: “No game or fish shall be held in possession by any person for more than five days after the close of the season for killing the same, except as in this act otherwise provided. ’ ’

Section 11, Div. D, page 207: “When any person lawfully in possession of game or fish shall desire to transport the same within this state, the transportation of which is not herein otherwise provided for, or out of this state, the commissioner may, upon being-satisfied that the possession and transportation is not in violation of the spirit of this act, grant a permit therefor, and thereafter, during the period of ten days after its date, such transportation shall be lawful between the points therein named. Such permit shall be substantially in the following form:

[17]*17Form 11.
State of Colorado.
Department of Game and Fish. Transportation Permit.
Denver,.......................189. ..
No............
This certifies that Mr...............is entitled to transport from.....................Colorado, to ....................the following game and fish, to wit:............................................. This authorizes possession and transportation between the points named herein only, but not sale or storage. Void after ten days from date.
Commissioner. ’ ’

Section 13, Div. D, page 209: “Game or fish may be transported out of this state only when accompanied by a permit from the commissioner authorizing the same, as provided in section 11 of this division. ’ ’

Section 11, Div. A, page 187: ‘ ‘ The commissioner and every warden throughout the state, and every sheriff and constable in his respective county, is authorized and required to enforce this act and seize any game or fish taken or held in violation of this act. ’ ’

Section 9, Div. D, page 206: “All game and fish seized under this act shall, without unnecessary delay, be sold by the officer seizing the same, or by the commissioner, except when a sale is impracticable or is likely to incur expenses exceeding the proceeds, in which case the same shall be donated to any needy person not concerned in the unlawful killing or possession thereof. Possession by virtue of such sale or donation shall not be unlawful. The proceeds thereof, after deducting the costs of seizure and sale, shall, if made by the commissioner or any warden, be paid [18]*18into the state treasury, but if made by a sheriff or constable, shall be paid, one-half to the commissioner and one-half into the treasury of the county where the seizure was made.”

Section 10, Div. D, page 207: “In case of such seizure and disposition, the officer making the same shall sign and give to each purchaser or donee an invoice stating the time and place of disposition, the kind, quantity and weight, as near as may be, of the game or fish disposed of, and the name of the purchaser or donee.' Such invoice shall authorize possession, transportation within this state, storage and sale for thirty days after date, and shall be substantially in the following form:

Form 10.
State of Colorado.
Department of Game and Fish.
Officer’s Invoice.
• .............................189...
Disposed of by me this day to................ the following game and fish, to wit: Kind.........; number................; weight.............; the same having been seized and disposed of by me under the provisions of the game law. This authorizes possession, storage, transportation within this state, and sale. Void after thirty days from date.
(Title of Officer) ”

Section 16, Div.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Woodrow v. Wildlife Commission
206 P.3d 835 (Colorado Court of Appeals, 2009)
Maitland v. People
23 P.2d 116 (Supreme Court of Colorado, 1933)
Rosenfeld v. Jakways
216 P. 776 (Montana Supreme Court, 1923)
People v. Williams
61 Colo. 11 (Supreme Court of Colorado, 1916)
Cawsey v. Brickey
144 P. 938 (Washington Supreme Court, 1914)
State v. Tice
125 P. 168 (Washington Supreme Court, 1912)
People v. Johnson
38 Colo. 76 (Supreme Court of Colorado, 1906)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
20 Colo. App. 13, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/hornbeke-v-white-coloctapp-1904.