Hoogovens Stahl Groep BV v. United States

1999 CIT 87

Opinion

5.+212

70+6'&56#6'5%17461(+06'40#6+10#.64#&'

,#/'5.9#65105'0+14,7&)' :

*11)18'0556##.)41'2$8'6#.%1051.%174601  

2NCKPVKHHU

 X 

70+6'&56#6'5 

 &GHGPFCPV  :

/'/14#0&7/CPF14&'4

9#65105'0+14,7&)'

6JKUKUQPGQHCPWODGTQHCPVKFWORKPIFWV[ECUGUVJCVTGEGPVN[YGTG

TGCUUKIPGFVQVJGYTKVGTHTQOVJGNCVG*QPQTCDNG&QOKPKEM.&K%CTNQ 7RQP

TGEGKRVQHCEQR[QHVJG%NGTM UFQEMGVUJGGVKVCRRGCTUVJCVQP,CPWCT[

1 These consolidated actions were reassigned to the writer by order of July 9, 1999 and the papers were delivered to me by the Clerk on August 19, 1999. COURT NO. 93-09-00573 PAGE 2

CPQTFGTYCUGPVGTGFGUVCDNKUJKPICDTKGHKPIUEJGFWNGDWVVJGTGCHVGTQP

(GDTWCT[VJGEQWTVITCPVGFRNCKPVKHH*QQIQXGPU OQVKQPVQUVC[

RTQEGGFKPIURGPFKPITGUQNWVKQPQHTGNCVGFCEVKQPU#UKFGHTQOUQOGOQVKQPUVQ

COGPFC,WFKEKCNRTQVGEVKXGQTFGTPQCEVKQPYJCVGXGTYCUVCMGPD[RNCKPVKHHQT

D[CP[QVJGTRCTV[VQVJGUGEQPUQNKFCVGFCEVKQPUUKPEG5GRVGODGTC

RGTKQFQHPGCTN[HKXG[GCTUGZEGRVQHEQWTUGVJGTGEGPVTGCUUKIPOGPVQHVJGECUG

+PXKGYQHVJGHKXG[GCTFQTOCPE[QHVJKUCEVKQPCNNRCTVKGUKPENWFKPI

KPVGTXGPQTUCTGJGTGD[FKTGEVGFVQHKNGYKVJVJKUEQWTVYKVJKPVJKTV[FC[UQHVJG

FCVGQHVJKUQTFGTCPCOGPFGF,QKPV5VCVWU4GRQTV RCTVKEWNCTN[YKVJTGICTFVQ

75%+64WNG C  CPFKHCRRTQRTKCVGCPCOGPFGF2TQRQUGF$TKGHKPI

5EJGFWNGCPFQT2TQRQUGF5EJGFWNKPI1TFGT

#NVGTPCVKXGN[KHRNCKPVKHHUPQYFGUKTGVQXQNWPVCT[FKUOKUUVJKUCEVKQP

RNCKPVKHHUOC[FKURQUGQHVJKUECUGKPCEEQTFCPEGYKVJ75%+6 I

5114&'4'&

&CVGF0GY;QTM0GY;QTM #WIWUV ,COGU.9CVUQP5GPKQT,WFIG