Hollars v. Gilreath Dairy Co.

Court of Appeals of Kentucky

Hollars v. Gilreath Dairy Co.

253 S.W.2d 620, 1952 Ky. LEXIS 1116

DecidedDecember 19, 1952

StatusPublished

This text of 253 S.W.2d 620 (Hollars v. Gilreath Dairy Co.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Kentucky primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Hollars v. Gilreath Dairy Co., 253 S.W.2d 620, 1952 Ky. LEXIS 1116 (Ky. Ct. App. 1952).

Pincite

Opinion

CAMMACK, Chief Justice.

This action was instituted by the ad-ministratrix of the estate of Johnny Hol-lars to collect damages for his alleged wrongful death. Hollars met his death as he attempted to jump from a truck which was being operated by Roland Lewis along a highway under construction by Talbott and Meyers. Hollars was a guest in the dairy truck being driven by Lewis. This appeal is from a judgment on a directed verdict given in favor of Talbott and Meyers and against Lewis. The only question in the case concerns the correctness of the judgment as to Talbott and Meyers.

Lewis was driving his truck along the highway which Talbott and Meyers were constructing. The Highway Department had accepted the highway as complete for traffic, though it had not been surfaced. The accident took place on an eight per cent grade where the road sloped away from a cliff over to an embankment of some 100 feet. No guard rails had been installed, but these rails are constructed by the Highway Department and not by the contractor. The road was built in compliance with all the plans and specifications of the Highway Department and was said by a State Highway Engineer to be no more hazardous than other roads in that mountainous vicinity.

Hollars was killed when -he attempted to jump from the truck as it went over the bank. The only testimony concerning the manner in which the accident happened was given by Lewis, the truck driver. He said that, when he was about halfway up the [621]*621hill, he dropped a cigarette and reached down to pick it up and another passenger in the truck hollered, “Look out,” and that he jerked the wheel over but could not straighten up the truck. Lewis said he was driving in the center of the road, and when asked if he took his eyes off the road he said, “I surely did.”

We think the trial court properly gave a peremptory instruction in favor of Tal-bott and Meyers. There was no evidence of negligence concerning the manner in which the highway had been constructed. The facts in the case of Codell Construction Co. v. Steele, 247 Ky. 173, 56 S.W.2d 955, clearly distinguish it from the one under consideration.

Judgment affirmed.

DUNCAN, J., not sitting.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

CAMMACK, Chief Justice.

This action was instituted by the ad-ministratrix of the estate of Johnny Hol-lars to collect damages for his alleged wrongful death. Hollars met his death as he attempted to jump from a truck which was being operated by Roland Lewis along a highway under construction by Talbott and Meyers. Hollars was a guest in the dairy truck being driven by Lewis. This appeal is from a judgment on a directed verdict given in favor of Talbott and Meyers and against Lewis. The only question in the case concerns the correctness of the judgment as to Talbott and Meyers.

Lewis was driving his truck along the highway which Talbott and Meyers were constructing. The Highway Department had accepted the highway as complete for traffic, though it had not been surfaced. The accident took place on an eight per cent grade where the road sloped away from a cliff over to an embankment of some 100 feet. No guard rails had been installed, but these rails are constructed by the Highway Department and not by the contractor. The road was built in compliance with all the plans and specifications of the Highway Department and was said by a State Highway Engineer to be no more hazardous than other roads in that mountainous vicinity.

Hollars was killed when -he attempted to jump from the truck as it went over the bank. The only testimony concerning the manner in which the accident happened was given by Lewis, the truck driver. He said that, when he was about halfway up the [621]*621hill, he dropped a cigarette and reached down to pick it up and another passenger in the truck hollered, “Look out,” and that he jerked the wheel over but could not straighten up the truck. Lewis said he was driving in the center of the road, and when asked if he took his eyes off the road he said, “I surely did.”

We think the trial court properly gave a peremptory instruction in favor of Tal-bott and Meyers. There was no evidence of negligence concerning the manner in which the highway had been constructed. The facts in the case of Codell Construction Co. v. Steele, 247 Ky. 173, 56 S.W.2d 955, clearly distinguish it from the one under consideration.

Judgment affirmed.

DUNCAN, J., not sitting.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

253 S.W.2d 620, 1952 Ky. LEXIS 1116, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/hollars-v-gilreath-dairy-co-kyctapp-1952.

Opinion

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack