HMS Holdings Corp., Health Management Systems, Inc., and HMS Business Services, Inc. v. Public Consulting Group, Inc., James Gambino, and Jason Ramos

Court of Appeals of Texas·Decided September 25, 2015·No. 05-15-00925-CV·Published

Opinion

ACCEPTED

05-15-00925-CV

FIFTH COURT OF APPEALS

DALLAS, TEXAS

9/24/2015 4:35:19 PM

LISA MATZ

CLERK

No. 05-15-00925-CV

FILED IN

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS 5th COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIFTH DISTRICT OF TEXAS DALLAS, TEXAS AT DALLAS 9/24/2015 4:35:19 PM LISA MATZ

Clerk

HMS Holdings Corp., Health Management Systems, Inc., and Business Services, Inc., Appellants and Cross-Appellees, v.

Public Consulting Group, Inc., James Gambino, and Jason Ramos, Appellees and Cross-Appellants.

Appeal from the 44th District Court of Dallas County, Texas Cause No. DC-14-9047

Honorable Bonnie L. Goldstein, Judge Presiding

APPELLEE PUBLIC CONSULTING GROUP, INC’S UNOPPSED MOTION TO SUPPLEMENT CLERK’S RECORD

Appellee and Cross-Appellant Public Consulting Group, Inc. (“PCG”) files

this Unopposed Motion to Supplement the Clerk’s Record and respectfully shows

as follows:

PCG seeks leave to supplement the record with following documents.

1. All exhibits to PCG’s January 15, 2015 Opposition to HMS's Application for Preliminary Injunction;

2. The February 27, 2015 Order Regarding Protocol for Removal of HMS Information from Defendants’ Possession;

3. PCG’s June 29, 2015 Correspondence to the Court and Attached Proposed Agreed-Upon Temporary Injunction.

Counsel for Appellants and Cross-Appellees HMS Holdings Corp., Health

Management Systems, Inc., and Business Services, Inc., and counsel for Appellees

and Cross-Appellants James Gambino and Jason Ramos are unopposed to the relief

requested herein.

Respectfully submitted,

/s/ David S. Coale John T. Cox III State Bar No. 24003722 E-Mail: tcox@lynnllp.com David S. Coale State Bar No. 00787255 E-Mail: dcoale@lynnllp.com Lynn Tillotson Pinker & Cox, LLP 2100 Ross Avenue, Suite 2700 Dallas, Texas 75201 Telephone: (214) 981-3800 Facsimile: (214) 981-3839

Attorneys for Appellee and Cross-Appellant Public Consulting Group, Inc.

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

The undersigned hereby certifies that a true and correct copy of the above and foregoing document has been served Via Electronic Mail by agreement of counsel of record on September 24, 2015:

Defendant Public Trey Cox tcox@lynnllp.com Consulting Chris Patton cpatton@lynnllp.com Group Inc. Samuel B. Hardy, IV shardy@lynnllp.com Joshua Krumholz joshua.krumholz@hklaw.com Brian G. Leary brian.leary@hklaw.com Benjamin Stern benjamin.stern@hklaw.com Robert M. Shaw robert.shaw@hklaw.com Jessica Ragosta Early jessica.early@hklaw.com Daniel I. Small dan.small@hklaw.com

Plaintiffs T. Ray Guy ray.guy@weil.com Olivia Zimmerman Miller olivia.miller@wei1.com Chris Cox chris.cox@weil.com Jessie Mishkin Jessie.mishkin@weil.com David Fertig david.fertig@weil.com Salvatore Romanello salvatore.romanello@weil.com Aryeh Zuber aryeh.zuber@weil.com Cheri Besselieu cheri.bessellieu@weil.com Nathan White nathan .wh ite@ weil .co m David Singh dav id.s ingh@we il .co m Pete Marketos pete.marketos@rgmfirm.com Joel Reese joel.reese@rgmfirm.com Adam Sanderson adam.sanderson@rgmfirm.com Leslie Chaggaris leslie.chaggaris@rgmfirm.com

Individual Sara Hollan Chelette schelette@jw.com Defendants John Jackson jjackson@jw.com (Texas David Schlottman dschlottman@jw.com Action)

Individual Christopher Buckey cbuckey@woh.com Defendants Nicholas Faso nfaso@woh.com (New York Emily Perks Quinlan equinlan@woh.com Action)

/s/ David S. Coale David S. Coale

4850-6319-9785, v. 1

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

ACCEPTED

05-15-00925-CV

FIFTH COURT OF APPEALS

DALLAS, TEXAS

9/24/2015 4:35:19 PM

LISA MATZ

CLERK

No. 05-15-00925-CV

FILED IN

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS 5th COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIFTH DISTRICT OF TEXAS DALLAS, TEXAS AT DALLAS 9/24/2015 4:35:19 PM LISA MATZ

Clerk

HMS Holdings Corp., Health Management Systems, Inc., and Business Services, Inc., Appellants and Cross-Appellees, v.

Public Consulting Group, Inc., James Gambino, and Jason Ramos, Appellees and Cross-Appellants.

Appeal from the 44th District Court of Dallas County, Texas Cause No. DC-14-9047

Honorable Bonnie L. Goldstein, Judge Presiding

APPELLEE PUBLIC CONSULTING GROUP, INC’S UNOPPSED MOTION TO SUPPLEMENT CLERK’S RECORD

Appellee and Cross-Appellant Public Consulting Group, Inc. (“PCG”) files

this Unopposed Motion to Supplement the Clerk’s Record and respectfully shows

as follows:

PCG seeks leave to supplement the record with following documents.

1. All exhibits to PCG’s January 15, 2015 Opposition to HMS's Application for Preliminary Injunction;

2. The February 27, 2015 Order Regarding Protocol for Removal of HMS Information from Defendants’ Possession;

3. PCG’s June 29, 2015 Correspondence to the Court and Attached Proposed Agreed-Upon Temporary Injunction.

Counsel for Appellants and Cross-Appellees HMS Holdings Corp., Health

Management Systems, Inc., and Business Services, Inc., and counsel for Appellees

and Cross-Appellants James Gambino and Jason Ramos are unopposed to the relief

requested herein.

Respectfully submitted,

/s/ David S. Coale John T. Cox III State Bar No. 24003722 E-Mail: tcox@lynnllp.com David S. Coale State Bar No. 00787255 E-Mail: dcoale@lynnllp.com Lynn Tillotson Pinker & Cox, LLP 2100 Ross Avenue, Suite 2700 Dallas, Texas 75201 Telephone: (214) 981-3800 Facsimile: (214) 981-3839

Attorneys for Appellee and Cross-Appellant Public Consulting Group, Inc.

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

The undersigned hereby certifies that a true and correct copy of the above and foregoing document has been served Via Electronic Mail by agreement of counsel of record on September 24, 2015:

Individual Sara Hollan Chelette schelette@jw.com Defendants John Jackson jjackson@jw.com (Texas David Schlottman dschlottman@jw.com Action)

Individual Christopher Buckey cbuckey@woh.com Defendants Nicholas Faso nfaso@woh.com (New York Emily Perks Quinlan equinlan@woh.com Action)

/s/ David S. Coale David S. Coale

4850-6319-9785, v. 1

HMS Holdings Corp., Health Management Systems, Inc., and HMS Business Services, Inc. v. Public Consulting Group, Inc., James Gambino, and Jason Ramos, (Tex. Ct. App. 2015).

Pincite

HMS Holdings Corp., Health Management Systems, Inc., and HMS Business Services, Inc. v. Public Consulting Group, Inc., James Gambino, and Jason Ramos (HMS Holdings Corp., Health Management Systems, Inc., and HMS Business Services, Inc. v. Public Consulting Group, Inc., James Gambino, and Jason Ramos) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.