Hernandez, Oscar v. State

Texas Supreme Court

Hernandez, Oscar v. State

Texas Supreme Court·Decided September 16, 2015·No. PD-0736-15·Published

Opinion

a/0. i i - t i - a n a L o - c t i T3C/5 X.N THE

.CJDUrt _<?_/= ..C..AX M1A/AL APPEALS ORIGINAt ._ Op TB.X A £

RECFiVPnj

APPELLa_a/T SER-1-6-2-015 VS.

ThLE_J TATBJ) F TEXA S Abel Aeosfa. Cterk APPELLEE

-Pj^titLQ_n_ lh c ^M.S^_ilA^O^ro/^_Tk^_X^° jOJA.tricf_ Cou ft of chereHe€. c?#/? fy^ l~e)<roi,S Ci_tLcL_

Xh^_CoJAr±_±i_AJA^^±S_±o_Yi^he T-vse.l-fi-h nls+r/cr ._-_.. .of1 Tc.K&-.Cj svo,_ \$--ll~DO^6>0~-C(l

Perjtxoa/ ink nxscRetzoma ry HE. \SX£ \A/ JiO^±J^i±O^j3JLA_BlE___C0^ri' of Appeal£ c^neL TUSJ-lC-e. JlkeJLCjdEj .JD.$Cj^rLJd^IJlCkh oiez^_A Pp ^ilc^n fs hy *,n£ Th rough */5 <su t°P- e- // ^<? 1~$..__ Aip/o&U et^te pr~0 -£ e. OZCCur Her^/»^Z. tern/ pursuit .Tv_.ttJk-.f9 CfV.isi&n $„.oJLy Vetin0h^_AJ^JT_z&U'S_^o_hjj-. ^rt,J4_£tlA^)_yy&rKj_h\ A/W, T*jr»^s <^C >_p^.rA i7,0J2j.A^t(_<L.)._ .OjF.Ti.-e-. 77-e.va^S ;Co_etje._ orF. cr,'"i 1nt^l p ro£*-dJJ-?'«• tf-jfr^ X«*3»r.$-. -

kMJ^^S^Xh/3.^^itfiJk.U..£!i:fi.tk.. Pj-TlTiojn i_vrjDjH:&£TJL0/V_4 Aj_ RbJ^TEJ^j.

iOURT-OFeRMINAL-APRlAUS _ osccor H^rh a-n rte?^

•" SEP r6 2015~ '""

-Abel-Acosta-i-Clerk- /niCho^-ij u^'iT A44tf_£>*i._Jk>_£V Ten n Z_(.$j^^elaM^jJitoU>S^JEB&b

"P ~ro~Je~

jjXEMTxt^rL.0b. Fartibs aa/o cou/v^bl

A-PMjLL^AMTJ OJC^rrternan^ez : T_D_CT^4* OJlUX XX AAiChCLel .Uft i.T.

.Tewi eSS et .Colo r\y, T* 7tr.rrU..

APPELLATE Cou/v£E L'* S l~-en L(xngsjo^n P,o. to* 531 TyJj^r^.jOL.Zi'7-LQ

TRXAL COU/I/SZLS Jcctfr she^rieioun PjOJftox £3 7

_ . . ... RiASKjTy 7S7P5-

STATE oF TEXAS : Za.chM-Lt„Pa.?f on cJzue.-£-o-ti-C£—C.e<Lk.nty o)Strict a -H-ornty P>6, Vox it so HuSkj T* 7r7tr- • ___

TAR LP nP tnh/TEA/TS ;

. £.4j>B, .A/a-yTl&.SL_Pjj___coll _pAr+l_£S__ _ i

Ta*bJjz.-QJLut&n.-tents . .. ii_

XttjCzx.. af Auth arjfijzf .... ili

Sta-Te/^&nt 7f e-Cf^udridJn^ A/0. oTtuJ _/+jr.g.U-#\jtLKt_t_.

S-hc*ste/*€.h,t of f-hsL.._/&_-.______.

.5-Hutc/nt-nT ot pro C^dutr(A__l_Hi$tpjry_

~.6dC0MjbjcL for Kzis/e ^

AKgU./nctJt . J -//

-^pjrcvyvl<L^ijy-ir_JLjL.±L££_ i_X_

Certificate at s-er\s/ce,_ M.

Ha/OBX oF Au + UnfiTTTfi*;

Stcut-e. LAvw

BXpcurtt Feltokij Y\<r. s,j^.^X./?C7SB.j 72.L LT*tx, cri/y.lAfi^'iffl} .Htr.ncLhfft.cjL. v> &***+£>j___7_&<».$t.\*r,_j3LclJ5:i Cr^,_c&s^,_A-/?/LfJtJjO ..LUQUh j 4*/7 S,W. jid CAsfl+M Lf LUfUlbj^, st-osi-n. 7X s.iA,, j./ 3S~S"j 3(,3 CT^r.cri^, ^/s>.9^o^)_ .Ro.ti-0&i?—te-f±&££-jJJt-S-*-.i'r' -let.- forj ?iiAT^X^crir^,^^_^cto_t_) "RaSe- V. S+*she,j 7<T± . <, Us. ±d 5~X*9, <T3 f~ LT**-> Crjyy.. A-*p. it 77) FBDERA L \_Aus

.cuyier v, siAiil\/CL.hj hhg u,s. 35Cj sw.cinro)•_..__ .^L„C_&n*^J3_iJ_J^,3_,_£&M_J_^^ ih^-Ce^MJi—S^JltiJ^h^ocUse*-,-.3* 7_ iA__5, 7S~M'y.77J-.CJHJ-0-)- $fKi-£M-L*d&.iC ¥,. W.JHeJjk-JjBLf'tv*, HUt; U*.5.*..(,.tt-j--(^Z-j-.tffJLJL\311£\\-

til

*TATEMe.*/T 11 Efi, AlQ[) Ja/& a*> f> fi A L ARGUMe.HT -ALQ—joxj^J. <*<r<jfjj>/h.ent Li r&au &ftecl j, &cc^mSCj glS .-^/U~b^e.. s.k.0 <#:n ~ -» i ^ b Vi/j Th e fC/_a?( -r^Cord CI ec^r/y C5tc^bt <$h € f Theut .Ths. , j^Jv^lct€j^Ci2,__a£_.i^ei^e^T} of cetuunSeJ ~-)t( b-e- es-rcuhihkef.

STATEA\EAH- o-F THB CASE.

J3Jt-J£B^JUJ^JLy-^J4JO.yln...tkse Jaconet Tudidc^l OlStriCt Ceu.r't of...- Ch^TLhr-e coL^nTyjTexa^; The 0<fe.nc£-&nt *se<^S I* dieted for Th-e off-en*^ af conT'lu 0US s&rucuf Ah uuS-e- of «_ young th-tel 0f.__... ^Ck/ltlr&H-tn Cu-US-e A/wr\b-^r I7j6?40, Aji^.ry.wtct $*,(ec-tecl ort .. -Tjj.LyiTjjXcJ^) a-nd tr'ie^i to^^enCed ph Jvtly lOjtelS*.oti~Tu(y:$(,J.oj%_ ^^^i^ry^r^TJ^rnyrdla'jy^^eCiCt of g uUtyj cuhd art*-?' ^\/rtLeyic&_ O.K.. pMft",±kM-*-nT Sentenced. Arff &ii&kf To 6£ y&&r$ \v\Th-e. T^XCoS -b^H&rt/n-enf_. jf or;,*lhaJ T^S r/ceJ c^noi c^iiOj 00ofj nc..

'. StQJte./neht ,^ pro r.F quip AL HzsTO RY €jci^.jy\ cLy_^_fj^ojrz.^t.h€.- TwMffh court - of--Apf_^eUs;__^tfir/yi£d Th.-c. t-r.rAsCf hu<dLgy^&*T of Iht^f^cTl^c.of.cou^^^^f.ib.se^^.^olht'^ Of., terror* Th« Texcc-5 Cptlrt of trt/n In e^l App e^l* granted The, fir$T. frO-S* yy\oTiOh -for frh € *rT-en$<'on §>f+',/ne j^i^A/c/i tCfUt, Th-e. pcfittoh for P.scr-CTtoncory H^i/I e\v,Thv ri/n* rtfiU th-e pe,tiT>oh hc^s ^b^^n^€_<t€ji dztl TV A-U&U^t- ^y £?/t~t

, O-Pourm ton -Qfvjzew DiD THB tl Th court of: Apf>-e&-L $ fe»- son a^b ly cupply c Ie<*r\ y ^estc^hj./shed ^^d^rc^l \_o.\as , a*d#r Strt'ch lct**d v, Wccffi In^tPP^OO. .,. w,s, 4>4rv Iftf s,ct. ^otXj yo L,£d,<Xd (, 714 Cil^HJ. hy ou. prtfond-zro/hcv of The. _ ^jtyjd^hCt tkust hi's coatf<&/s M-trforsviu/rtc* fell b&iow cctctpttc/ professional/ nor^ia. Thtrttef-tj th* consftuTt&n cohct $truPur<, . jyj,fnotfKi' -Ahjn .- r-e-V-cuS coh st, A-rt, fy sf' i( is*.) • V-tmt?"'* a-^a/, T^Td^ CCp, ... j&dr.*. 17.07,_ f y Cn,),

A ff &UAAE A/T

- A~De-fe.hda.yit in (m CrIyy\inccl TriQui h^5 The right T&. effect,'ise ^X3JJ.£i^JbJjyL—OjfL^-0JUL.k!LS-&Jl Vf.S Const'.* A/netttff, KX unci XlMj'T.e-X, . ^-Cattft^u-rt. TjSec io) roW^H v, Atcobfr^cj *-*? U6= ^iS~jik CifJXj.. ..-Trl.Cul CrOtAtoS'cf >v\UL$t cc-CT vyithlri Th-e. ra^nd-*- &f coyyipet-exc*.--

aCe~/yia^td'&dl o~f e^tf ot *-eyJ '* cr lattice/ CC^^ti, TyiC/Ku-hH \7, Wchu-ird$Q)\ . 3.f7 UstJ7r% 77/ ClfSO)* Th* Scu/n-e $T<^n elc^rdS c^/o/oly In woJua,+fhsj -jffidsUfep^-^±a*±Lo_n $f_...fetsulh eoL cobd ouyyo Int&d. ceutiS-H. cayferv^ . 5MJl.lkeo.hj M. *fA... US* 33S~j 3ff C19tO ) , Th* tff-e. Cti^£rt*S5 of CouM$-et . 1$ 0r<tlfact,rLly jy-ccuy-cet by th-e. Totality of th-* T^r^s-enti^tUJij db.uiLj^k.-eii.jit^^in.^/^. error c&n coyi^ttfctt*- I* effect! i/<_ cl.ssfSt^tic-e- *jvfLJLo.(A.H i.-e-l, EX fa-rt-c F*.ltoh; ri<Tp Sjtw^ct 731j 73 G CT<-K, Cr>>?. yttpf, iff/) «Xtl.-ecrdd.i.tlcMj cu dtf-e* da,^T in a- cr^fntut trivul does sis&T n€.^jiL to . ^o.b^€ct..c<jt- Th'asl to cet^ns^s \n^ff-^ttiv^ reyr-es-entitsthh TO. ,-pr*5*>lr\r< .Th* \S$U-c -for o^ff^^l< Kob'>n5oft V, Stc^T-c^lb StW> 3d rd^S-H-. ..-XJ.S2L. Criffle AfPiJ^OJDQ^.Xn orfar in he-r-t «jc ca-nv/cfitm r-cVtrs-eU. on ._. ..^/'jiff.^ij.^ c*~rf*riliL<nT sr\u,5t shoi*/ tkeuT Tr^l cou^n$*Ps •?-crfor>ne^nc-«- ^-cC&fUj-tnf'.-tt-t+d Th-uT th* U^flc\eh.t f*rfor/>*&<*icc re $n( •+<£*? in , pr-e-JjUClU-t TO The d.tf-endfr'it by *t*-f>ril/jh<y him of Cc t&-/r Tn^f- ^Mrfrh. r-cliu-blx, results* STticKl^hd v. \/*,iki*.gTvnJt(M,/ U-$> t,WJ.-bp7jo*i.- ...Cit$'€)f Thji c^ff^l/tutc- Cffuo^T syiocst j>^e triV/ coum&-tixs Conduct: .JoJLSj€jL-jjip0&- T-he^fCt^rtlcUl^r Fc^otS ot €.CL>ck cct,5<- >Zot. uXT.ty.lCL..- —. .T.h-Cr--Urpf'efl.0>'HT.-'n-ufi~ sho*" TWcoT Thiecl CooonSvft ir-tpr*Ser\-tc^T>oh -f~<,(l _ - bclon/ cuti 0bj-e. CT! \rc sTundturdl #~f rJeeut0*icubled9-e£S—<Zd...erf-b%7* . ?h, U&tt,-irialnfnj 1* €-pf*.ct.iif< ecsstST&sh c-c of c& uns&l +_h-e> cL,ppell&n± .jnjJST id&.nTiiy.-.XLjLfS OT OynlS$Jotl S by Trifl COUnS-C thccJt i*,«/>e_rf<L,£__~__. -Jt}\^Jf~eS>_U,.i_t5^- of r-cO^Soneubi-C -frs -fvision ets( J uda,yn fit Cunt/ vr-e^e e>.&JtrsS'ttiLjrh *~rc<sA^-t_QjF^fro~F#$SiOhc*/liy Co/np^hznt cufsjsTttn c*e ,Zc£ ojC (e^a, ,MlTLA^ootiL.[\j_jjth t.c^fp^Ut^nt /hdsiT Sh&h^ cc re^fc/iQtbi-i probability thccJt) .buTfor^c.cLU-jistV* ur\profes.fiena^l -^rrotfj fh* r-e§uit of The _prt\c*l^gl'<%£. .woMd hcLV<- b*~en- differed t.,.X^C. ^t b<fH% Kcccionubi* -probability ._. .-SiAstfLiCf#nt-Tvu<nd-4r.*itri-e the, cphfid^nc-^ }nth~e o^Lf-co^-^> Zd. M.e...ftt^-dcL_r:d.S—asJ9.ti.0Mrtj£&fC. It) ftrick l^nd uJSe u-ffly rv c^;^ ina^f. .. cou5^eS_ Jib. Ttk^ccS ,..£«.. Htrn.tut\A.£i-. V> ff<Lt^/ 7& k /". i-^J- d £2 CTt^tCt^, A-pfJ^ f^

. Xh Thh - CcoS*; D-e-f^rtSe. Cei^n $ e-/'s n&/n -er oct-S ^rro rs co/tn bitmtZ . to jr-vSu-lt im th-e. o^jt>y-&//&-nT r-z C-eIis i#z~ in ff-& ctiVe u^SiSto^tit-e , ...jp.t- Co\u,.n£*£,(.. ...... J .-Tho5-fL ^rrvr^ IhC/iCd.^l TtSKZ XI) Afp^lf&vT vtscu$ U'tffiritrvti (?-f his . .. Ki^ht To.€.-Ff-&Ctil/<- U^SfSt&snte of cjc^KS-d.y^b&n.tricol CVUsrtS-el . fulled .to UlSclcS~*e a^pi *J<rp-crt witness r&s lAit-* n* }ji_rfi&jf_M^ltr?es£ -t^Sti.sxo:rty_t0jh<-iz.xcllLd&d1, _..,

.j^SSpce =#)_ Afp-&/fectit \aa-cl4 Uey?r/t/-e^ ot hi, f )pftt. To € fF&cfrt (^•^ . a/55l$tcoKC-e- of- CCu^nSerf \^h^h Tr/cof CouohS-t-f fu~l(•e.vC' TO snt^fr-c ^b2ii„_tf_GJrjL^.r*+,tcrn. r-e-^rct*t\^ Tfr^ ufpect-^cdfesfl/noriy of* th ..-•€Jef>.-€K±J&JiTttiSL§S« .... . ... .

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

a/0. i i - t i - a n a L o - c t i T3C/5 X.N THE

.CJDUrt _<?_/= ..C..AX M1A/AL APPEALS ORIGINAt ._ Op TB.X A £

RECFiVPnj

APPELLa_a/T SER-1-6-2-015 VS.

ThLE_J TATBJ) F TEXA S Abel Aeosfa. Cterk APPELLEE

-Pj^titLQ_n_ lh c ^M.S^_ilA^O^ro/^_Tk^_X^° jOJA.tricf_ Cou ft of chereHe€. c?#/? fy^ l~e)<roi,S Ci_tLcL_

Xh^_CoJAr±_±i_AJA^^±S_±o_Yi^he T-vse.l-fi-h nls+r/cr ._-_.. .of1 Tc.K&-.Cj svo,_ \$--ll~DO^6>0~-C(l

Perjtxoa/ ink nxscRetzoma ry HE. \SX£ \A/ JiO^±J^i±O^j3JLA_BlE___C0^ri' of Appeal£ c^neL TUSJ-lC-e. JlkeJLCjdEj .JD.$Cj^rLJd^IJlCkh oiez^_A Pp ^ilc^n fs hy *,n£ Th rough */5 <su t°P- e- // ^<? 1~$..__ Aip/o&U et^te pr~0 -£ e. OZCCur Her^/»^Z. tern/ pursuit .Tv_.ttJk-.f9 CfV.isi&n $„.oJLy Vetin0h^_AJ^JT_z&U'S_^o_hjj-. ^rt,J4_£tlA^)_yy&rKj_h\ A/W, T*jr»^s <^C >_p^.rA i7,0J2j.A^t(_<L.)._ .OjF.Ti.-e-. 77-e.va^S ;Co_etje._ orF. cr,'"i 1nt^l p ro£*-dJJ-?'«• tf-jfr^ X«*3»r.$-. -

kMJ^^S^Xh/3.^^itfiJk.U..£!i:fi.tk.. Pj-TlTiojn i_vrjDjH:&£TJL0/V_4 Aj_ RbJ^TEJ^j.

iOURT-OFeRMINAL-APRlAUS _ osccor H^rh a-n rte?^

•" SEP r6 2015~ '""

-Abel-Acosta-i-Clerk- /niCho^-ij u^'iT A44tf_£>*i._Jk>_£V Ten n Z_(.$j^^elaM^jJitoU>S^JEB&b

"P ~ro~Je~

jjXEMTxt^rL.0b. Fartibs aa/o cou/v^bl

A-PMjLL^AMTJ OJC^rrternan^ez : T_D_CT^4* OJlUX XX AAiChCLel .Uft i.T.

.Tewi eSS et .Colo r\y, T* 7tr.rrU..

APPELLATE Cou/v£E L'* S l~-en L(xngsjo^n P,o. to* 531 TyJj^r^.jOL.Zi'7-LQ

TRXAL COU/I/SZLS Jcctfr she^rieioun PjOJftox £3 7

_ . . ... RiASKjTy 7S7P5-

STATE oF TEXAS : Za.chM-Lt„Pa.?f on cJzue.-£-o-ti-C£—C.e<Lk.nty o)Strict a -H-ornty P>6, Vox it so HuSkj T* 7r7tr- • ___

TAR LP nP tnh/TEA/TS ;

. £.4j>B, .A/a-yTl&.SL_Pjj___coll _pAr+l_£S__ _ i

Ta*bJjz.-QJLut&n.-tents . .. ii_

XttjCzx.. af Auth arjfijzf .... ili

Sta-Te/^&nt 7f e-Cf^udridJn^ A/0. oTtuJ _/+jr.g.U-#\jtLKt_t_.

S-hc*ste/*€.h,t of f-hsL.._/&_-.______.

.5-Hutc/nt-nT ot pro C^dutr(A__l_Hi$tpjry_

~.6dC0MjbjcL for Kzis/e ^

AKgU./nctJt . J -//

-^pjrcvyvl<L^ijy-ir_JLjL.±L££_ i_X_

Certificate at s-er\s/ce,_ M.

Ha/OBX oF Au + UnfiTTTfi*;

Stcut-e. LAvw

BXpcurtt Feltokij Y\<r. s,j^.^X./?C7SB.j 72.L LT*tx, cri/y.lAfi^'iffl} .Htr.ncLhfft.cjL. v> &***+£>j___7_&<».$t.\*r,_j3LclJ5:i Cr^,_c&s^,_A-/?/LfJtJjO ..LUQUh j 4*/7 S,W. jid CAsfl+M Lf LUfUlbj^, st-osi-n. 7X s.iA,, j./ 3S~S"j 3(,3 CT^r.cri^, ^/s>.9^o^)_ .Ro.ti-0&i?—te-f±&££-jJJt-S-*-.i'r' -let.- forj ?iiAT^X^crir^,^^_^cto_t_) "RaSe- V. S+*she,j 7<T± . <, Us. ±d 5~X*9, <T3 f~ LT**-> Crjyy.. A-*p. it 77) FBDERA L \_Aus

.cuyier v, siAiil\/CL.hj hhg u,s. 35Cj sw.cinro)•_..__ .^L„C_&n*^J3_iJ_J^,3_,_£&M_J_^^ ih^-Ce^MJi—S^JltiJ^h^ocUse*-,-.3* 7_ iA__5, 7S~M'y.77J-.CJHJ-0-)- $fKi-£M-L*d&.iC ¥,. W.JHeJjk-JjBLf'tv*, HUt; U*.5.*..(,.tt-j--(^Z-j-.tffJLJL\311£\\-

til

*TATEMe.*/T 11 Efi, AlQ[) Ja/& a*> f> fi A L ARGUMe.HT -ALQ—joxj^J. <*<r<jfjj>/h.ent Li r&au &ftecl j, &cc^mSCj glS .-^/U~b^e.. s.k.0 <#:n ~ -» i ^ b Vi/j Th e fC/_a?( -r^Cord CI ec^r/y C5tc^bt <$h € f Theut .Ths. , j^Jv^lct€j^Ci2,__a£_.i^ei^e^T} of cetuunSeJ ~-)t( b-e- es-rcuhihkef.

STATEA\EAH- o-F THB CASE.

J3Jt-J£B^JUJ^JLy-^J4JO.yln...tkse Jaconet Tudidc^l OlStriCt Ceu.r't of...- Ch^TLhr-e coL^nTyjTexa^; The 0<fe.nc£-&nt *se<^S I* dieted for Th-e off-en*^ af conT'lu 0US s&rucuf Ah uuS-e- of «_ young th-tel 0f.__... ^Ck/ltlr&H-tn Cu-US-e A/wr\b-^r I7j6?40, Aji^.ry.wtct $*,(ec-tecl ort .. -Tjj.LyiTjjXcJ^) a-nd tr'ie^i to^^enCed ph Jvtly lOjtelS*.oti~Tu(y:$(,J.oj%_ ^^^i^ry^r^TJ^rnyrdla'jy^^eCiCt of g uUtyj cuhd art*-?' ^\/rtLeyic&_ O.K.. pMft",±kM-*-nT Sentenced. Arff &ii&kf To 6£ y&&r$ \v\Th-e. T^XCoS -b^H&rt/n-enf_. jf or;,*lhaJ T^S r/ceJ c^noi c^iiOj 00ofj nc..

'. StQJte./neht ,^ pro r.F quip AL HzsTO RY €jci^.jy\ cLy_^_fj^ojrz.^t.h€.- TwMffh court - of--Apf_^eUs;__^tfir/yi£d Th.-c. t-r.rAsCf hu<dLgy^&*T of Iht^f^cTl^c.of.cou^^^^f.ib.se^^.^olht'^ Of., terror* Th« Texcc-5 Cptlrt of trt/n In e^l App e^l* granted The, fir$T. frO-S* yy\oTiOh -for frh € *rT-en$<'on §>f+',/ne j^i^A/c/i tCfUt, Th-e. pcfittoh for P.scr-CTtoncory H^i/I e\v,Thv ri/n* rtfiU th-e pe,tiT>oh hc^s ^b^^n^€_<t€ji dztl TV A-U&U^t- ^y £?/t~t

, O-Pourm ton -Qfvjzew DiD THB tl Th court of: Apf>-e&-L $ fe»- son a^b ly cupply c Ie<*r\ y ^estc^hj./shed ^^d^rc^l \_o.\as , a*d#r Strt'ch lct**d v, Wccffi In^tPP^OO. .,. w,s, 4>4rv Iftf s,ct. ^otXj yo L,£d,<Xd (, 714 Cil^HJ. hy ou. prtfond-zro/hcv of The. _ ^jtyjd^hCt tkust hi's coatf<&/s M-trforsviu/rtc* fell b&iow cctctpttc/ professional/ nor^ia. Thtrttef-tj th* consftuTt&n cohct $truPur<, . jyj,fnotfKi' -Ahjn .- r-e-V-cuS coh st, A-rt, fy sf' i( is*.) • V-tmt?"'* a-^a/, T^Td^ CCp, ... j&dr.*. 17.07,_ f y Cn,),

A ff &UAAE A/T

- A~De-fe.hda.yit in (m CrIyy\inccl TriQui h^5 The right T&. effect,'ise ^X3JJ.£i^JbJjyL—OjfL^-0JUL.k!LS-&Jl Vf.S Const'.* A/netttff, KX unci XlMj'T.e-X, . ^-Cattft^u-rt. TjSec io) roW^H v, Atcobfr^cj *-*? U6= ^iS~jik CifJXj.. ..-Trl.Cul CrOtAtoS'cf >v\UL$t cc-CT vyithlri Th-e. ra^nd-*- &f coyyipet-exc*.--

aCe~/yia^td'&dl o~f e^tf ot *-eyJ '* cr lattice/ CC^^ti, TyiC/Ku-hH \7, Wchu-ird$Q)\ . 3.f7 UstJ7r% 77/ ClfSO)* Th* Scu/n-e $T<^n elc^rdS c^/o/oly In woJua,+fhsj -jffidsUfep^-^±a*±Lo_n $f_...fetsulh eoL cobd ouyyo Int&d. ceutiS-H. cayferv^ . 5MJl.lkeo.hj M. *fA... US* 33S~j 3ff C19tO ) , Th* tff-e. Cti^£rt*S5 of CouM$-et . 1$ 0r<tlfact,rLly jy-ccuy-cet by th-e. Totality of th-* T^r^s-enti^tUJij db.uiLj^k.-eii.jit^^in.^/^. error c&n coyi^ttfctt*- I* effect! i/<_ cl.ssfSt^tic-e- *jvfLJLo.(A.H i.-e-l, EX fa-rt-c F*.ltoh; ri<Tp Sjtw^ct 731j 73 G CT<-K, Cr>>?. yttpf, iff/) «Xtl.-ecrdd.i.tlcMj cu dtf-e* da,^T in a- cr^fntut trivul does sis&T n€.^jiL to . ^o.b^€ct..c<jt- Th'asl to cet^ns^s \n^ff-^ttiv^ reyr-es-entitsthh TO. ,-pr*5*>lr\r< .Th* \S$U-c -for o^ff^^l< Kob'>n5oft V, Stc^T-c^lb StW> 3d rd^S-H-. ..-XJ.S2L. Criffle AfPiJ^OJDQ^.Xn orfar in he-r-t «jc ca-nv/cfitm r-cVtrs-eU. on ._. ..^/'jiff.^ij.^ c*~rf*riliL<nT sr\u,5t shoi*/ tkeuT Tr^l cou^n$*Ps •?-crfor>ne^nc-«- ^-cC&fUj-tnf'.-tt-t+d Th-uT th* U^flc\eh.t f*rfor/>*&<*icc re $n( •+<£*? in , pr-e-JjUClU-t TO The d.tf-endfr'it by *t*-f>ril/jh<y him of Cc t&-/r Tn^f- ^Mrfrh. r-cliu-blx, results* STticKl^hd v. \/*,iki*.gTvnJt(M,/ U-$> t,WJ.-bp7jo*i.- ...Cit$'€)f Thji c^ff^l/tutc- Cffuo^T syiocst j>^e triV/ coum&-tixs Conduct: .JoJLSj€jL-jjip0&- T-he^fCt^rtlcUl^r Fc^otS ot €.CL>ck cct,5<- >Zot. uXT.ty.lCL..- —. .T.h-Cr--Urpf'efl.0>'HT.-'n-ufi~ sho*" TWcoT Thiecl CooonSvft ir-tpr*Ser\-tc^T>oh -f~<,(l _ - bclon/ cuti 0bj-e. CT! \rc sTundturdl #~f rJeeut0*icubled9-e£S—<Zd...erf-b%7* . ?h, U&tt,-irialnfnj 1* €-pf*.ct.iif< ecsstST&sh c-c of c& uns&l +_h-e> cL,ppell&n± .jnjJST id&.nTiiy.-.XLjLfS OT OynlS$Jotl S by Trifl COUnS-C thccJt i*,«/>e_rf<L,£__~__. -Jt}\^Jf~eS>_U,.i_t5^- of r-cO^Soneubi-C -frs -fvision ets( J uda,yn fit Cunt/ vr-e^e e>.&JtrsS'ttiLjrh *~rc<sA^-t_QjF^fro~F#$SiOhc*/liy Co/np^hznt cufsjsTttn c*e ,Zc£ ojC (e^a, ,MlTLA^ootiL.[\j_jjth t.c^fp^Ut^nt /hdsiT Sh&h^ cc re^fc/iQtbi-i probability thccJt) .buTfor^c.cLU-jistV* ur\profes.fiena^l -^rrotfj fh* r-e§uit of The _prt\c*l^gl'<%£. .woMd hcLV<- b*~en- differed t.,.X^C. ^t b<fH% Kcccionubi* -probability ._. .-SiAstfLiCf#nt-Tvu<nd-4r.*itri-e the, cphfid^nc-^ }nth~e o^Lf-co^-^> Zd. M.e...ftt^-dcL_r:d.S—asJ9.ti.0Mrtj£&fC. It) ftrick l^nd uJSe u-ffly rv c^;^ ina^f. .. cou5^eS_ Jib. Ttk^ccS ,..£«.. Htrn.tut\A.£i-. V> ff<Lt^/ 7& k /". i-^J- d £2 CTt^tCt^, A-pfJ^ f^

. Xh Thh - CcoS*; D-e-f^rtSe. Cei^n $ e-/'s n&/n -er oct-S ^rro rs co/tn bitmtZ . to jr-vSu-lt im th-e. o^jt>y-&//&-nT r-z C-eIis i#z~ in ff-& ctiVe u^SiSto^tit-e , ...jp.t- Co\u,.n£*£,(.. ...... J .-Tho5-fL ^rrvr^ IhC/iCd.^l TtSKZ XI) Afp^lf&vT vtscu$ U'tffiritrvti (?-f his . .. Ki^ht To.€.-Ff-&Ctil/<- U^SfSt&snte of cjc^KS-d.y^b&n.tricol CVUsrtS-el . fulled .to UlSclcS~*e a^pi *J<rp-crt witness r&s lAit-* n* }ji_rfi&jf_M^ltr?es£ -t^Sti.sxo:rty_t0jh<-iz.xcllLd&d1, _..,

.j^SSpce =#)_ Afp-&/fectit \aa-cl4 Uey?r/t/-e^ ot hi, f )pftt. To € fF&cfrt (^•^ . a/55l$tcoKC-e- of- CCu^nSerf \^h^h Tr/cof CouohS-t-f fu~l(•e.vC' TO snt^fr-c ^b2ii„_tf_GJrjL^.r*+,tcrn. r-e-^rct*t\^ Tfr^ ufpect-^cdfesfl/noriy of* th ..-•€Jef>.-€K±J&JiTttiSL§S« .... . ... .

.-ZSJue- 31) A-ppvl/u-nt. -*^*^ d^prfir*** ot hh rip/iT to <fY*cf,V* . u£sf$T#'rtce^ o-f cauvnt-e,! «stiryn TY~i^ Cetonf-et titled To a^^H^ <*<•__ . dill-.of •e.^rt e.p tion f-e, ^ytcrvC inr The- r-e,cordl i nj- i ot Th-e fonen sJc ..inferviiksS*

.XSSJ<k£.M).-Arpp<eK.&etT wu*> d^p riir-cd o-f.hh. ris-ht -TV- *-ff<ec.fiis-t. ~^A$A$tV't«£--^--o~f~Ci?UsW-£€( to"/?*n TTicU coccn^-el feci led To object To fh--£- .Chour^^c <rn ftA,ni$h/n&nT Bu-f&d' on tln-e, u-bS-enc-t of- l&n<y u^^-e. .ct/d)r'iS\n'y the,.Jury Tfut/f Appelant vovcld. KPT fc-e ••eJi*'jbLe~..*f0JC. .. pc^roie,,. ......

..x-ssu* f!) a pp-^K^^t ^^ d-oprtt/ec/ of hh -vip^T f-o ^ectiVe. ._ .u-fsisTco^c-e _ot cou^9-e( v^hen TritU c^u^$-eJ Fc<JI-ed fD r-tauest . iftC/ilSiOfl in rh< CAc^/y^-e on Pu-nHh^e-nT /<wifit^y-e ^W5/iy **«• jury thust A~pp-oi(c^fvi- v^oiAjd not t*. ^lip-lbl-c Fc>r pourol^e.^ :Z5svL-e- C>) App--ellounir v^c^S deprived of his rip^hf to *ff-ec+iyiL .OsSS^tQshCt of oouhSet ^h-en Trjcuf CouiSel fcull-cU. to. obj^ctLTjo_tk.e .tricol courts ? rofoftd r~cspo*c-e r-ce,u^rd) nj Th -t -t Ff^ct of f> curoL-e.^ . OKI Ayp^U.fl'ft'fs S-ent&HC-i. «. ._.....

.._ £JSci<, 71) Apfvifo/ht wet* cd^pri r-edl of hi-b riyhr To •cff^cTi^-e .. c^.fSistco-r\C& ot coutn5^1 */he*\ Tria^l Counsel faulted To object- ~t0 in.a, d /*isslbl& h&^r^u.y recjurd,>r\q u decuTk rhr^c^t.-/y\£o.d~e—by A-pp-zll-Qs*it» - .. .. _

Xn 1h<- -F-lirff- is5Uej rfppef'fcc+T e^r<f.U€i> Tfo**T. Uic'z> COUn£*tl K^*-£ //•? e.&PeCi~it/£. .h-€.Cu.US€ .h-P-f.^JLed^Jv d/S-U&S-e.. child fo^&mtc, thTer\/le.i*'&y f)e&,she/ JLe4JLjt£-Ac-*o.t&tjh'Aj..&k-.p~CK±j*rJr*.<eS.s., .nzhSCh-JrjcSjkrlijed. i.K-Tk^c <^c/ux/c^i. _. .of. h^r_tiJBTiJ*Jil^iy-* .. Trifci Cou/nf^i ..u/.eui._rriA-eFFe£f_/f-4 by f-^l/i^r-t To ^/.V-e notice, of Testify lyiff . •tjcp.-trt.- wtfAeJS,. h^dfrfu-l ~£&tc*t$:ct prop *rLy.. yiv^*x^M0tl<J e &fS-e.lt a,s ajn •zxp-t-rt wifn ess, h-c-r~Tf>sf^yi^Vy U<ot^/d. hccyx.~~c&//<4_l_Pti-0 o/occbf ._ IJh<'.tr lCfj-^y 'S_ T^yt»./nC-tJ.il^...c^.^d. Th<~ CLldTCO^-^CP^f Th-<- -£*<~S-e?._i4^£LiA,/d htuT*.^. h^,-OK diff-ef-onT. t-cCc^Ui^ The r~e.c&^d reflects fh*T~ £^5, tx~djt*lr~r>ed i-c _ hnJ^lny UjC.dL.jri 1~h*~ yet&t Ccmctfrtietp, fJti^—-C,iAt^<^T. c*^.f&&4., SpeeJft'caJ.ly^ &*5> T-eS*-'fi-td.*=Z follows \ -...'. . __

Q,b0.y0U t-cnt'rvb-tr' fcolffhg ft? c^jpoiic-e oftiCre.r.ThcoT #i}/yft'Tf_ A.^y.es_i . . __

Q.* A*s<£ *&**t'did\y.0jULjt&4t'-Th-e, ptPh'C-e, offj C-*rA A, Ufaid i^lyux 4cm*, of Th-e, 6TiAffv

J%.:OJ\?-yt Mo**' c.a/n~t. y?u. didnt telf 1^',/n c^il thti. StaffI'lisTh-e>ce. cu reasonj!'. j£.»-T-EUSt..,-£. .do-nt-r£fik:j.ly-l:Lk£,-J'b.^--p^ #r.i T.-$uSTde&*-\ ,_.X. did/ft.

Thi nk iT.HAJ^J. u/so necessary to .te//.. th<j*t •^^•erythinp^,

-Q.f.-h.O:<S--JiO-kkL-siAoc0.h-y(>.u-_tc// u^bo uT -Lis-cryrhinp r^tcst kc^^P^^-^^ o/xfestd9 oj^^yt<d^^y.o..u~c^.K^-TokJhfn<pLt^~> - —- - .

.Am—y~€S-4-

JX,J^h.C^-JLS^y It d*sptH(£s on who yoc-t, c^rc tuJklnpTOfhltf^lrrozct.y T.b,.^^jJt^.depend'i on hojf smUcA y0i>t Tri^ft th*f- p^/-^1"1 *

..Q t.-Wh&n you •foufd' t*oJP T# otbir p-e*p/e- <*->*Vyo u urait.ld.flf .Telf.Thati ^yxjryThtnp^? vwcr-cvou. T&Mlh.jp- Th-#*n Th-e, .tr.t^Th ore*-, lie, J\a X gu€f>s yo*~ oeultt Secy oc lie » if

Qt.Q.ha./.,J4^e.uM tkn^t h*. Jbeta,uZ€. yai^ dI(Lift tr,ll then* Th* tmtt'r-c +ij(jHj ?_ A* yef» ...

-.^AJtot-eoiSjtf-j f>p>, Jlyyi'ilc^r/y c^dy^/tte,c£—±hiiiA__hjer_l_n^ ,-.!J4-C0rt_5_;sTe*'t -w/Tk- her p r-esflous shzfts-^t&nTs conc^r^tnytjhj^c^le^c^Hi- _<,U*TTS, speo;flCcUjy_jB±SrT.e9.tifi-cc/ c^i falh^.^4,

#, SP Thfe-e^orfotcs ygtcr* \a,ter^ yffu.T-cli. Th-& Iflftrict- 4~Hn>rfle.yJ u^A*,1 y<ju *,r+_ _ £ct-yltr\ty not>r is Th*. truth r At.y-es*.

-$••*-» kt*y.tS.t. fbr^ Pvj^r.ye/^rij you ccntinucd to lie, c^bouit if, A» -"fit Tvtuily,

..SI aJ^Jvi>T^jde. yoiL.sn ett,*i r\ pt _. Ta:fii,lly,>_L_der^ 'f.. und<jz£tiLsid.

&< He,£u.u$><- X u*_us&n-t .Susyl.rip. fhewfai-t entire truth..JL Mrej^Jd f lc ct'..$ay_pArfS/ - _.irJ^JoLulil. h-e t*,' ii-e thouvdi* -

, Thu.5, 5-elf\ T^ST,sntwj,• The, ^-K.ry ut^ej^ld b.-C. cz,b/' e- ~iO_Con Sid-e.d' th<. . \r_icjhisn'*$ .. ih~ Co u,rt T^J>tl<<?. ota t-^s v/th th e k/^nn^l-e-d^-^. jrA&jf. -e^-^h __„. . i*rltm £<,s pr-av />sly kc^d ^,/ i^^n l.€SS.^Th.t^n .ce-**-/> lAfe- iA-e.r~sj.ajd of Htefr .~.$.£*ri-es_+_UJt/sr* Grfe.fy^.T-h.-e-.fcotry reCu$onco4>ly• „tould facuif-t- found Th-e. &,S-, O.W.. . E,5jl icock-tU cr-eUiblliTy^b^T it d^..CT,hed^fodo jo.T.b^r^jfo.r<^ Appel/^^t - Canelcede, tria,( csun$*el<r fcuilur-e to p rapierIy no:ffc^^^t a^ c^n ex-pert wlthefy -^SO-Jrh<, autocue, ofTh-t r<t-/-e wot>t,ld hMAr-e, b^~ett cl/fFer-ent,... .^ekfrT Zo~m-pLy/h.p- .uzj*zf\- -Te-V%^ 'JtU.lej cF B\rjeL-e-hC-e. lo*X<^JJ&).-J^h-l-C-h~r<.4Ulr:es.__ a-pu/rty Cpmplcu'ihjnty pp- th-e ^Jr.c/t4^-i-/OA df^LVjd-t^A^, to ^tcchjc The, jth -c $t*<b$Tc*:i.c=e,_of_th &—€JA-L(L^n,C£,.-. Known to. Th e, Tr i'u-( _CourTj App-t//<i,n fS ^O^r^J/um^y^T ThUfT hj$ trincl CfiUA9j€ii ta^i/u-t-e, to tl^te^iy de $icyria,t*_ ___ ...S'-eJjf. .as ec^i -£->rp~irt vrltfietS d<-pTtu*d hia* of etf-ectiiT-e, a,ssi£tc^sic-e. _ ^.ofccu-nS-tli Coufife,/ eJf'd nat fll-e cuny /n afig *.£„<*? _

_Xn th-e 5-e_c<;e,d c^^djT.hl.rd. i$su^/ Aff-e/twf centemdj th^T~ hi$ counsel , MAius . IK^ff e,&flIJ£ h.^ec^c *,* .•€ _A-e, f^f*c£__tv..«n^/r-&-.M^..b.ll(. ct jZ^rCtptio.n Tey-nrdfrty. th-*. Test/^ip-^y he, e^p-ecf-fd to e.//c/r- jfn?s*i_._ S.^Lf_OL^jxjd usnd pf th-c r-ccojrdsii, _o.fi—fhdt-f<Zr^n.sJ.cs~_ Ij-rter tr.>-e^. of Th-€. ,\d^iCf/<n9 hor 'te-$ +•/ <r>os?y ^oi^jd. hu/rc $f>onj:#/**{'* The coitrT h a.s r&Co-tyniz-eeL

Hernandez, Oscar v. State, (Tex. 2015).

Pincite

Hernandez, Oscar v. State (Hernandez, Oscar v. State) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.