Haynes, Levi C.

• Court: Court of Appeals of Texas
• Decided: January 14, 2015
• Docket: WR-55,208-03
• Status: Published

Opinion

55,¢;><>€§.<>§

r\/O. ,_'Li’z.?$e -C

?_w\` Cj t+§\{v\es #(zzm;q_ ' EC _ " ‘ Dodre 1 ~ ll ~ F_S_' @omo\= cn\mNAL APPEA&S nw 1 4 2015 n\C§x`cc §§ H/\e U¢r|< - -' ,;\-De\-Aeosta,~e\erk

abel Ac§s\‘§ Clerl<

001/cri OF Cr)mmal /éppe§ls §§ T€ms

PO P)§_)_< _1_13_@3_ C§@¢'+'§| 3§§+10)/\

.l____

A»us+m Tzim$ 787 ll

__(__.

23 aebu++az a ol$;+r»'c+ comm Pmpa@d

§mdma$ 6§ F§LM` CCHC(uSlD)/U§'§ Lau)

ana Ar§ler

D_ew! aler|<.

l;v\<>\ \0$€§) pleas@__ Fw\o§ par }:¢`{ ma fm 1716 `

A/‘n_ove danaher @_ause &@pl\cani"s Re baHal 1’§ D¢$+r)c§

(‘nar+\§ Pr§s)§$ea Fmd\`nq_s §§ Fad', C§nClMs¢m/\s §Fém¢)

and Or§l€r

TLW\\C- \!OM FOF \{OM( /lr$$)`$*¢umce 174 %z`S`MA'I’~{~c/;r.

995 pec+‘§;/Il]\/ gu§)mz'§'|~é§{

?et/l 0 £11¢-(¥1€5’(§¥0 Se>

Sq Dm'rmq§m/\ 291

R§sb\§r§'n" tvzmsv’l$g$

a/c`: me ..i;.c.\~z.

l\lO_._M _“ ,Q.;

E)< Pmm.= * 114 THE c§u_glof_cg:_MLN&L

LEvi c, HAYNES 31< APIZ;=;'§_L_$ §F TE)

A;BP'\C/+NF‘§ Mu:f&;_.;_v:§_ai;j;g§q@;, g § di ' @I_N - ,§OFLF jj "NCLMS»(QM; ,

MOW, COMES,, L'-e\/i C .H§\|me§,, Appl\`caw§» Pro_§.c;,__-F{les ii/,\_i;,,___

1`&5 rebuttal im S%§+c‘s proposed F¢`v\diia§s §§ ¥§c+; Conclu.

${ons §§ \cwu and order 1` v\ H/\e ab§\Lc;Ca{>i‘LQmde_C;¢_;/‘_S_.€..,,:__

¢`v\ §§ 4|>p_o_r_'l'_@f_£cp_pLCQL/\tl;:$_&pp_(_l`m+lo_n__{§lwr`»+ §§ Habeas C§rpu$' '

§>_\Ls_uan‘c to /H+, n . o 7, and Ad-. l.c>_s_,je;

I.

'(|A£ appl\`c_§`v_\'_{:_i§_{>_f_€_s w+\Y_Cow'§\}/\e@g l`>u;n§ \~).cmi‘ 4-0 +he sudg» men\' Q¢v\c\ sen+ence §§ -H/\€ 1_8%\¢\ D\$’{'rl‘c'l' Cow+c‘§ l’{wfi$ COLM?\/.

»(<>.ms.,430_C_§L_ss_¢;_v_\_u_v_v_\_b__e_f__'l_5.$3;1_5_,<;,11 where @?_p_(i cami“ura.LCQn - v{c,+ed b\{ § J\'ur\'/ §§ ~H/\€ ago/lsc §§ §qq_m\f_a_{:c§l fob\oe,r\|/ .

n/\ne +r1`@\_¢0_§;%_ass_cs_s_e_d_ap_p_(_i£_az\+_‘$_@un is h mevd' +o (§_o> \!eafs &0v\¥»`v\eme,¢/\+ {v\ +Me Te)<§s dd_e_pw+w\en+ §§ Crlm{m|

1\

Iu.$l['_l:&.€._“_:_v\_$”§\'§v;'§:»:@ vla| D¢\/[_$_[_QV\ ,

i.»

The F{rs+ C§u.r'§ §§ A=P§)ea.\s a§§{rmed appl\'can+;s Con\/\'c'l'fon

11/\ an unpubl¢;$ bed memorandum 0,|2_'_1_1<11`0__1/_1,.__1;{;§\_/1/1€3 V. S+a§€.

111-as 003~14~ ca acqch '1§__~19_'1__3(_1”¢:>< Ap§>_:Hnu.s+vnED__i_-s+]_

mao,_v_\_c_)_p__ei _.>__/31._ pl\é;§v\_+_-$§i_\.ed_a_mr__i____+ 0‘__§__ Hab§a__s_ @orpu,S_________ al- \eg_l_n,q_th_a_‘r_be was Polemed cm oooor+umh +o 51`111>,_§_{>_¢1*1`{:101/1___

J¢`-o( a\$(‘,{_€_{;\_ov)af_Y__ f_g\hew because _____c¢.p_p_l_\Qw/\'§K §1+4-§1'{1€\_/ 0\1`<|

m>`\' movinch (>_§>\ LQ§m+ ~\:\/1§:|' +(/1€ _Qon\!_l____(‘ilom_ba§l b_e_e_n_cc?fdme<_:\_.__ m’ wb§c\' apphcav\'l' mueeol.;c;_d_:l_"§_d_© §1_1_€_5§11_0\_(>1-;11’€1011+:__1?113______

&ou,se jesus B all eq_mq v1'o\c1+101/1 o§ §.5>,1)_11_`€§_111'5_0114_¢__

Df 0 (’,€.SS_CL 3_(/£§3._._._’[\0`_€__3(>_?_\\_C.QL_Y\.');S__¢»:)_$_+_AL\_{‘_A()_()_[LC§:Ho n er Wn'?'

o‘F Hubeas C§rp_u_$_&%§i:es_ a.»'“>_ -Qol(ou_u:

"l:pMS arleae '§l/wd'_a Pp[lc§u:d"$ Ac+ua/ Imn§Cel/d' Q(§umm,

§houlc@ loc denied becaus€.(l) Hae apvc)abayl'§ §§ W1[l1`e,

' @mes’(homas Ls` no‘§ frecb_b{e CZ)‘!/ba+/ fhomas wa$

1/\0+ C_f_e€l_Lb_[ (§_du_cfma +§1€ m'[’£¥\/l €u) wt”h'¢\ '§L\e 5+§€§€.

l/ka_j'l/ ha_w\a$_ was _lvlaccum+€ reqarJ1 na +§1€ §ac.n“s

f +(/\e Oase

2.

fLD. fha b1>+r`11~.4' 601111’ Con'l'enc_@_s_ ~H/\a+' cyphan 0101$_1510_1§_{)11011_€1_1

~!-f/\od' \/1_<;__ 15 _01_6'{'11101(\1{ mnocen'l'

/{\/16 \/16_01>1>_1__________1<:011/1‘_|' asser+ 101011' *Q)f H/\e 01§"1`1 1101\/11' o~F W1'.fl1e,(`_301me.$ '1/15101/1/\015 13 creob` lo\e, fha 00011€01111'._6_0_11_{'€1\0{ had +hLS N.€u)ly

1111 "__"

-___0_1.1F_Y`_1,1c_1;r1/16: 6001\11 have cfea+ed doub+ dmwm +he 1/1110{1`¢,+ mt +L\e 1’111\/. {111€ 0101)11110111‘1' 011/101 W1ll1e 1/15J10W1015

[,\M\ 01 10101' +Y1011. 4116 0100110_011/\'1' +c.sh¥cec/ 41+-{-1:101[ bui,______

W1\l\e JAM€$ T\aow\as d1 d noT

fha 011>1>111‘0151'1_’01_Sser+ +15101'{' dam/141 +be 810+¢\_5111+€11/1€11)

1111"H/1 W1|l1e jumc$ Uowm$ +L\c 3'{-01‘\'1: cl011m +Lwd' Wil}¢'e

WPJ'€ 110‘1' (‘,Y”Edzb[e 411€ abol\€anf' Com+end +l/m'(' 1/1/1111€,

\/1101$ Ver\) 1’,1€0(11>1<>, because 1191-old +be 1111€1\/111116:$' .

b1 'Hd€ S+v~{'€-~ Hne real +m+(/\ Der{~cumna ~l-o'H/\€,Cas€.

011/101 no‘{‘ 'H/\€> D(e-Fabncg§l'€d pab/15 w(n 161/1 bo'H'l 'H/\€ avpl( -‘

/‘01111_1' 011/101 W1ll1e 3”01111¢$ Tl/\oma_s were +Y1e01 on

1116 011>1>11c011/1'l' dsserl' dunn/11 +|ne 5+0+1':3 111+er\f1e111 1111'?{/1

v\hlhe, \11/11{1¢ 1013 +1/1€ 310+€$ 111+€1\/1€1,1)€1;5 H/wrb H’

\15€¥€ 1Y1\/e$+161¢€l'o1’ C `T'. 5011/10{€1’5{0€+60:('1\(€) v\/VIO

1>_1,1‘{’ "H/\€ 0.010[1€41.1’1"' an »H/\c SCewe_o'F'H/HS Cnme, ._(_§ee » 1

\AM[\€ jan/165 mon/las 61:{";\0'01\/1`|"11'1 SuDPOV+) _j>_*\_(`__an+

C.ev\i*ev\cj +1/1011' W1H1e, 111 his “ 10101\/1'1 41r101 durina 'Hae,

A\SZD \N1ll1€ aAmrl’ ~(v M,SH’\G 6101\>(1€/&|'\+1$ name 5111¢€,

|/16 w€f€ 61 111_\1€11116 +o 01\/01¢1 bemo lo_ck_e_d 110/gee

&>aAQ, 2 OS; W1_l_l165__ Y_€_C_o(d€d of udnH~€A/l m'{'CI\/|€U) S‘}Ztlr¢m€n+)

5.

Mso. gee ane, 14 o'F W`»ll1el$ Wer~en mkr\/\eu) Q>y

-H/\€ Bi~cd’e. '{'o gee how 'H/l€, de%~echv€/ C."l" SanolefS

pu+ or Consp{r€c@ +D __p(a<>e 1112 appl{can'i' an Hhe scene

¢<)‘F H\MS Cflm€. 1`F W1/ll€ didn t"f'€,l{ {'H/\€ HJLM£_S A’F'H'\C.

0+@1€1 1311/3 H/La+ wave 111\!0{1/@61 111 +11e rabber\g

'1\/1€_ mij;can{’as$e({' -Hrwc\' fne never Hneud how 1115

mma managed +o 41>_1' mvolv»eci 111 a crim;__g, 3110/has

11115 --11111+'11 1115 rece\mf* dwcoverv ap v\hlh'e:> 4¥1313111/1'1

ofF mmors¢ suhmif'¥¢o? -\-o cmr ammlma cam?e.ssmq

`\11)\»1¢1+ 1112 had done FurH/\ermor_€,_@p

+1101‘1' Sfm%e__‘.s 1111€1\)1@,11)@1 wi+l/\ 1/\[1111@ [1<¢11~1 Allen KA)

‘ raid W1H1e dumna 1416 111+erv1e1,d +1111+ 3116 was going +o

311 611/101 111`+~31\/1€115 mr Q T 331101@1$ 1011+31\€ neverdfd because ~Hnex€ 3 no €,\rwlwc_e mahcod'eo? m 1116 record

+$/\011’ Sl/\€ dwi {31:€ paqe 13 01(" 51%1{'1€‘3 wn`H-ev\ 1`114611111€115>

611/mucva 1100\1<:01111’ 3110113! ~1 6133€1'+$ +11¢11' 1112 13 one

0'\: 01(‘.+1,101\ 111110¢@11+ MsO bas<, 011 +{/1@_ New[v dl$€o\/ered

\)1cl€)/\Qe (A~P~P\@la\!c+ @`P \,151[11€ JZ»M€$ ‘I/hovvla£> app)man'l"

' l/\A§ been demd 'Hfl€ -Du.& Pm(l€$$ D`F La.u.) /Equal ibm --

+ec‘/+bon UF Hae. haw b@+L\ +|/1¢1+0'1_`+11€ Uf S 0011341+1.1+1011

--)-_ ._

1‘-1+|4 A'mevwlmen+ SeC. l 141/wl +1101'1'0‘?+}/1@_ iam Cam-

311+1,1+101/1_»11+ 1_3¢¢ 1¢1.111 +0115 1115+01111’€¢1.1»13€.‘

‘lll.

F1'na\\\§ 'HV\€ A§>\_O\-\.CQH+ ASSef+ 'H'¢Od' 'H/\IS hand-melt Cour'i’ k

‘4.

§a$ r_cM€/feal m blMK/w§¢+€» 114(1=“)< /Pa({'€ §ltzomlo~

q»n sw 1a zm_ Tex cr /11>11 1¢1%)[4)[7)(8')(¢1)

/6) Persav\ 131 m£lv Cbn\f¢c,+cd 111 §1r+r1al is 120')' perml“r+ed 4-0

110an Cotla{'e,m{ xH‘Ac‘/K an 'H)m:|' llonmc:l“mn 1011%01¢1*'

111/malina mcneaqu l\1 persuasi_v€ case +Lwc?' he 13 admllv

lv\v\oéer\'t' Av\o\, ‘f~'§us abol\€an'l" §30{ habeas rehej€ based

01/\ C,(Am/\ 010 AC,+\AQ\ cnnoc_€/n'\*' mms+clemons’+m't'c 'H/m+‘

mewt\l dl$&ov'e(éd CV\C{£VILL€ 1`F +1*1,1€, Crea+€$ doubt as

+o e¥~F1c:a1Q~/ o`F veroh ci 5115¥1'0,1¢111' +a undermme Cs)m§`denc¢

1`1/\ V~erdm,+ amd 'H/wd’ 11" 13 probable -H/wd' vefohcj’woul@l bap

@\(~F¥ere/mf on 9611101\.1&9@[1¢0111’( assev+ H/\od' +ke abde

would §e me‘i' ip +§€ wu\l \/w\cl |

Jow/\C.S ¢an\/Y\O.~S us eat aDOhCm/\')"\S name m 'H\€ ms'l'ah'l"

cause wi{~haui‘ +Lw. lénowledq~e @‘F mpphcav\'\' A-l§_o, `1‘1`

+§e 1111\1 bowl been mparmed §1/ Willhe, Cov\cerv\mq

~{~\/1€ st+emen‘l' +(,1@1+ aided-we 30111@)@,1"5 made +;;1

\A)1(l\~€ ¢~.§01/\+ 11/`1<‘,r1mma‘i'mq 6~01>)1€011/1‘1'4~0+§1$ Ca.s< 1?

\Anlh€ M)ou(obr\\+ +'€l( him wf)o 'H/le o+e\et‘ qu\_($ L,J¢L.S.

@>_1§¢.\>_11§_€0.~.\;1+ asser’f' 'Hm$ Cow'(' 19141'[11/1€01 /E§< Dar`l'e g 1201/1010),___ L\/l ofol€r par (',Ov\~pw{ey_\c,e m xfexJ.m.+'é-o be unal€f'rmned bv ~

v\eu)lv d\sco\/erec} emo\wce as reqmr_eol ¥or §AL> eng

1&\1€¥ baseJ 011 d 1`1v1 op aQ{-ual 1111/111;1»,11¢¢, 1+`15 1101

necessm\! H/wd~ new evi_<_l_em;€ render s'§+e\s ease

\e¢mllq or 101/\${’1'[-1).{~101/\01{1\1 11151,1¥{-\&1€1/1'\'-1-`0{ Cor\\m;'l'fovl

f$:> /(L\A+ 'H/\e l§Fo §o\C Cour+' mc Cmm\ 1141 APQ@JS_,Z

€X€(`C,\_$€. O`F +`»S QDS+COYWLC.+LOVK hab€dj 11).(`\§0{1¢+\0',\,|/1,

' 16 1101 -1<) 101/lew 101\’\1 5 \f100011c1* 1301 +v decide w110+110r

11011)1\1 0115 covered evidence 10011101 1101/0 0_0111/1110€01 J’un/

011" 0101>110011/1'1'5 11111000110€ \/ermon's /1»1111 7`;»~)<01$ C. C 17

Ac`1'$ 11 .0"1, 11 0'11.&-?01\<:01,101`1' C,on+€r\d ‘1‘1/10\,`1 1'1'1/11011€101,- 10€€01\)1§~@ 10€ 113111 1101110+1/10 0ppor'1w11'1~\/ 111 Con~Fron+

100‘1'1\ \/\11111€ 611/101 '1'1\0\'1' 013 c1€‘1~ec_`1"1\1€. 3011/101€1$

1193 1101>1\001111 013301"1' »1’11€ C0011'1' 5101'1~€01:.1.”11 order-10 011'01111“

1/\011)€.0.$ \”19__110'1: 010 C1011w\ '1'11101'1’ 11121,1>1\1 d\SCo\/€fcd €\1101€.11€€»

wou101 1101~1£ 00111111/10001 1`111111 01` 011>1>1.120111'1‘"3 111110€@110€_,

Qew+ mu.S'l' 1010 Co»\\/mcec1 +11011` mem 1001¢`1'3 unques'honamy

051'011>1131/1 011')1)11001111' s 11100¢0,11¢€ "1/111011<:0'1~10110.1011] 031-0110113111 11100111$ 1-0 001011011311 by 0110011» 011101€01\\01`1101110

ev101w¢e 1/11£11 +110 011>011001111' assexf '1'11011 11~0 00111

231#11111311 1101\1011 '1'1/1€ 011par~1~u111'1-11 '1-<1 010 58

\/-.

(’_11_11 10111_01= _

1 1_”1110 011>___1)11`001111'_01$301_1~_+_101011'__11_¢ 16 0101-1,10111\/_1111/100011€.€

2. 151/10 001)11<:0111'1' 015$€1_'1_‘11101011‘_1’_101£_01;¢_11)_1>[_011$covered

e\nalev\c¢ week 1110 3101/1010111015 301 1501 111 E)< 1_>011¢.

E11"L01/m10 91‘~1'1 S\M 201 zoz.. 1014 dr 111?1>..)

._ _,_. __

. 3 1.11_-6_1_1_1__'111/1__11_15_3 1110 _Q_p_.pl\canT 1/101$ 01€110101131'1011~001 +1»101'1` 1118 0011\110,1`101/1 1,15015 1_1111)1019_0_€>_(_1_1_0_1;_1`_0_1_1.\0_12_®_€_________9 fl 1

1110 1/1€11111( discovered ev10101/100` 111'11112 111$10111'1’ 0011,130.

(¢_1 `

v 146601'011`11¢11\1. 1116 090110011/11‘ mm +11¢._1' +11€ 601/161 1512 61`1¥¥11¥\41 A:DD~€A\S 01"01¥\`1' O.PO1\Can'1` fe\\e§ m "wnS 11/1$1~51»/11' Cau56 -

CE@n Ezcmz_ol= ssav\cE

jew/106 1103__1)€_6_1:1 ac____c;¢_m_p{c_sb_e_bd_ b__a__ezd_incj__e_n_+___li,ih . . . 010»\| op §Yom‘ uaw 2015_ 01, (‘,op\/ 0`131‘111$ ms+mmen_i_ '1:_@________

1:11_6'___ /4¢§_51510.1/11* D1_s1r1<*.i‘ /H‘lome\l 01 +1/1€ 1301101,011/1¢1 nddf¢;s$'.

('_01{01\/\/\ /’1'116\/1

,v ____________

|1011113 001,11/\1\{ ,T€XA$ 1101 Fmv\\

l_

12;§_11§6+15111\\( 5_11,1)111111_661 _

_'_C.__W 1’<\: admsz Dq<'f`\~n€($®(\ \L.’n\1 ` l S°`\ "1)¢1((1~\€1'1`0\/\

_ ' ~ 5 . 5 \chl\_w>n jim '1'>393