Hall v. Perry

3 Greene 579

• Court: Supreme Court of Iowa
• Decided: November 15, 1852
• Status: Published

Opinion

Opinion by

Greene, J.

This suit was commenced by E. Hall, in the Polk county court, against J. M. Perry, as administrator of the estate of John Norley, on a book account. Plaintiff having recovered judgment for less than be claimed, took an appeal to tbe district court, where judgment was rendered in favor of defendant.

W. W. Williamson and J. E. Jewett, for appellant. C. Bates and J. M. Perry, for appellee.

On the trial it appeared that the plaintiff had, among other items, sued for the purchase money of two tracts of land, and introduced the deeds to show the sale. The deeds recited that the purchase money had been paid, and plaintiff called witnesses to prove that it had not been paid, and was different from that set out in the deed. To this proof defendant’s counsel objected, and the objection was sustained by the court.

The principle is now well established that the true consideration for which a deed was given may be shown by parole proof, although it should vary the consideration named in the deed. But in such case the proof should be strong and positive. Such proof may, with equal propriety, be admitted to show that the purchase money or price agreed upon for the land had not been paid, or was not paid at the time the deed was executed and delivered. As this rule has been entertained by this court in former decisions, it is not necessary to enlarge upon it here. We conclude in the present case, that the court erred in refusing the testimony proposed.

Judgment reversed.